*11.4 Makkos Daf 08 A (4 lines before spreads)*

*11.4 Makkos Daf 08 A (4 lines before spreads)**Summary*If someone threw a stone into the street and it killed someone, he goes to _galus._*Gemara:**Question:* Someone who throws a stone out on the street is a _shogeig?!_ *He’s being careless!**Rav Shmuel bar Yitzchok:* This is discussing a case where *he was demolishing a wall* - he wasn’t just throwing stones out carelessly.*Question:* He should still watch what he’s doing!*Response:* The demolition is taking place *at night* (when streets are generally deserted).*Question: At night one must also watch* what he’s doing?*Response:* The stones aren’t falling into the street, but *into a dung-hill* (where people go to move their bowels).*Question:* If this is a place *frequented by people;* he is blameworthy! If it *isn’t frequented by people;* he shouldn’t even be considered a shogeig, *he’s an _oneis!_**Rav Papa: It’s a dung-hill that is generally frequented only at night,* and the demolition took place during the day, so he isn’t careless by letting the stones fall there, yet he should have checked if anyone happened to come by because sometimes people come during the day too.*11.4 Makkos Daf 08 A (4 lines before spreads)**Summary*If someone threw a stone into the street and it killed someone, he goes to _galus._*Gemara:**Question:* Someone who throws a stone out on the street is a _shogeig?!_ *He’s being careless!**Rav Shmuel bar Yitzchok:* This is discussing a case where *he was demolishing a wall* - he wasn’t just throwing stones out carelessly.*Question:* He should still watch what he’s doing!*Response:* The demolition is taking place *at night* (when streets are generally deserted).*Question: At night one must also watch* what he’s doing?*Response:* The stones aren’t falling into the street, but *into a dung-hill* (where people go to move their bowels).*Question:* If this is a place *frequented by people;* he is blameworthy! If it *isn’t frequented by people;* he shouldn’t even be considered a shogeig, *he’s an _oneis!_**Rav Papa: It’s a dung-hill that is generally frequented only at night,* and the demolition took place during the day, so he isn’t careless by letting the stones fall there, yet he should have checked if anyone happened to come by because sometimes people come during the day too.s Daf 08 A (4 lines before spreads)**Summary*If someone threw a stone into the street and it killed someone, he goes to _galus._*Gemara:**Question:* Someone who throws a stone out on the street is a _shogeig?!_ *He’s being careless!**Rav Shmuel bar Yitzchok:* This is discussing a case where *he was demolishing a wall* - he wasn’t just throwing stones out carelessly.*Question:* He should still watch what he’s doing!*Response:* The demolition is taking place *at night* (when streets are generally deserted).*Question: At night one must also watch* what he’s doing?*Response:* The stones aren’t falling into the street, but *into a dung-hill* (where people go to move their bowels).*Question:* If this is a place *frequented by people;* he is blameworthy! If it *isn’t frequented by people;* he shouldn’t even be considered a shogeig, *he’s an _oneis!_**Rav Papa: It’s a dung-hill that is generally frequented only at night,* and the demolition took place during the day, so he isn’t careless by letting the stones fall there, yet he should have checked if anyone happened to come by because sometimes people come during the day too. See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate