Hello and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a podcast about the ancient world and education and stuff My name is Thomas Magby. I'm joined as always by mr. Hannenberg and mr.
Graham Donaldson hi hello gentlemen. We are here you all held the funny puns I was gonna pretend that they were my puns, but I can't do it I just can't lie to the audience anymore guys you want to say all of your funny things you said about this being part four of Plato's Republic oh Hope Star Wars no sir, sir, we start talking about what a shaved we'll keep it like yeah So, you know I was gonna steal all that pretend that I was the witty one. It's not me guys. I think I'm big Dude in the costume right no no no it was just like a real wookie if you shaved it just probably look like a dude Right I guess that would make sense right here guy here guy with a snap with a snap like a rounded mouth Yeah, I don't know what I mean he had a fall.
Oh, okay Like a like a like a like a roundy roundy mouth. You're not out like a roundy mouth. You know like a snout like a snout part I don't entirely understand anyway actually you know I should draw a shape will keep you email us and a more memes Thank you loyalist man who keeps any us memes although those sustain a jay they give him life really they do Whoever's been sending me memes much. I read them and I giggle and I just love it so much And but actually we're not here to talk about Star Wars.
I believe we're here to talk about Plato's Republic Plato's Republic Graham is already on his phone. I'm going off. We are all to a great start Oh, well, don't Google shave. Look why would you why would you do that?
Why would you do that? Blackberry can't on see that it's a blackberry. I do a blackberry. Can you get a real phone please this is Candace finest phone?
You need you need buttons you poor. Yeah, I don't like it all seriously. Okay. Anyway, okay.
This is all you okay We're back for Plato part four and I'm if you're good sick of this you just let me know It's the beginning of everything classical this unless you count the alien the Odyssey, right? Who cares about those book or Gilgamesh? Or if you don't count all those guys and Socrates and some other writers who are also important, but you really think like who's one of the most important Dude's ever well George Washington obviously, but I'm gonna only slightly less feel like we're under cutting argument No, Plato really is a huge deal and so I I've always Strolled like I've stalled out kind of right around book for whenever I do the Republic and I'm excited to finish this monster So if you're into it, we'll finish we'll finish her out and you will be able to you know go back and say like oh We did the whole Republican. I know what's in there and I kind of get the gist of it and so I'm you know if you're in for the journey I'm in for the journey.
I've been wrong. I'm in love it. So boys. Do you remember what's happened so far?
I'm about chapters one two and three. We're trying to figure out what justice is trying to figure out what justice is at some point Yeah, why are we trying to figure out what justice is because I've a drinking party where some guy asked kind of yes There's one cranky guy and he's like it's the justice is this month the right of the strong over the week and everyone's like you're a doofus And then he's like whoa, I mean like it's a huffing walks off and then some of the kids around are like is it? No, really really the guy had a point maybe he argued poorly But your answer wasn't very good Socrates. So you need to do better to figure it out So if it's Socrates it does that if we can see it in the big we can see it in the small now We're building this look for justice in the city.
Yeah, exactly So if you're just if this is your first Plato podcast consider going back and listen to Republic 1 2 and 3 But if not, it's basically a conversation between Socrates who was Plato's mentor and a bunch of other folks and Socrates is a bit of Ham he's a bit of a card. He's kind of cheeky and pretends to be stupid even though it's he's clearly really smart and It's it's fantastic like reading reading the Republic really is a treat. Okay, so he said right if we want to find justice in the person I don't know what really what that is Why don't we look where it's big and kind of get an idea of what it is maybe in a city and everyone's like Oh, that's a good idea Okay, well, let's construct the perfect city So he spends three books doing what does the perfect city look like it actually ends in this book book for and I'll get you there But the last part we ended on last week was talking about the treatment of the guardians and the guardians as far as I understand Is two classes of people we have our ruling guardians who make the laws and we have our warrior guardians right and all together The laws who enforce the laws and all together these people are the guardians of the state right They pretty much run things they're in charge and then you have a populace and their treatment Do you remember anything about the way that they were treated in their lifestyle? This is stuff about you only tell them stories like a rogue stories.
Yeah only rogue stories and only music in the major key That's about marching and victory. I think yeah, no that's sad music. No that's that minor key business. No weird stringed instruments there was Get your phyme special food.
I can't remember. Yeah, you've got them used to die. Yeah, yeah, yeah Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, even the meat that is typical to a soldier on the move You can roast stuff you can roast you know, yeah, no sweet sauces That makes it all gross. So no sweet sauces hardy fair Oh, and they don't like money Yeah, you are not allowed to have money on property And you have to live kind of in barracks and common and they sort of assuage your desire for that sort of thing by telling you You've gotten golden blood our money.
You are you are literally like a million dollars And that's how they sort of you know kind of well They like why would you dirty yourself by touching the fake stuff that everybody else is trading around when you have When you're really deal. I think it's a great idea to found a state upon lies. Yeah, but it's most important people We had a whole debate about the fact that states are just lies everyone greeze. Oh my gosh.
That's this That's conspiracy Graham Why would you even say that? Yeah, you know he's a talking man Doesn't get to talk for the rest of our page. I just for four minutes. Just put him in his place He picked up his blackberry Put that on there when the thing you pick up sassily is a blackberry don't matter that all thing.
It's a sweet way You don't see talking Graham. We just literally just thought about this. He's looking great Okay, so the question It looks very upset being very cheeky. Okay, he's out of time.
I think he's actually gonna not talk to people in four minutes Okay, so the question that this chapter before it starts out with is well What about those poor guardians really like no money no conveniences? They can't even spend money on a mistress like you're That's like no, I'm not getting there. He's like they can't even spend money on luxuries like food and mistresses Mr. Sis just casually thrown in there as a luxury apparently it was a common thing Yeah, they're just having a mistress was a deal and he's like they don't they don't seem like they're going to be happy right there With their fair and his response is like yeah, maybe but our goal isn't to make every individual in the state happy Whole to just like lots of happiness for lots of people right like sure we make everybody happy if we gave them big like purple robes and crowns And this is what it made everybody yeah, you make every common person absolutely ecstatic by just showering money upon him And giving him nothing but sweet meats and mistresses right?
But that's not the point I'm just wondering if actually will they be happy by fulfilling their role I don't know and that's one of the things that I'm not sure that they would be unhappy first of all But second of all, that's not even our goal and then he has got a little bit of analogy a little bit of an analogy working on my That's a really great. Thank you about painting a statue So for those of you who've been in museums You might not know that most of the statues rent equity that are now white marble were traditionally painted right they were all painted Viber colors and then it is only with age With age that they have lost their color entered white right? So he says look if I was painting a statue and some dude came up and he's just pounding it's about two minutes Yeah, he's gonna just barge in It's not like the profound thought yeah, this is wonderful So he's like if I was painting a statue and some some dude came up and he's like just focus in on the eyes And he's like man you should make the eyes purple that'll look really cool Like they'd be so pretty if you made him like mostly purple and then the painter would be like I'm aiming for an overall effect here Like if I try to make every single piece as beautiful as possible. Oh, it wouldn't actually make a good piece of art It wouldn't actually make a good piece of art exactly.
So I think it's okay on that one sure So what about our guardians? Well, they can suck it up as kind of this kind of thing And then he talks into like they're just sort of like naming problems within their state Right, we're finishing up creating the city and one of the things that he talks about is he's like okay I'm seeing another problem besides our unhappy guardians and that's that there are two causes of the corruption of artisans One is wealth. They're like what do you mean? It's as well if Sam a good potter and then I get wicked rich It has a potter.
What do you think is gonna happen to the effort I send towards my pottery much less effort? Oh, yeah, I'm gonna phone it in hard. I'm rich right. I don't have to work so hard So my my artistry is going to suffer right what if I'm wicked poor what it's gonna happen to my art You're gonna try really hard so that you can make money right but if it gets grandma shaking his head But he is not allowed to talk does communication count nonverbal communication now.
I'm just gonna be able to talk 40 more seconds I think I know we'll get there so he says if you're in total abject poverty You literally can't afford the supplies for your tray. You never be able to you can't do it So on both ends you have trouble so the solution is middle way right so he had it way before good old Arthur got on the Buddha wow, you know, no way something in the middle good and then he's like okay I see another problem with our state. It's that you know, we are we're not very money focused We're not focused on luxuries and provide like we have some but we're not a money focused state Right. How are we going to go to war against the rich and powerful?
What's our plan a plan for wait? He's like look at our state right austere. We are we have great warriors I'm sure but what happens if we go up against a huge state with water money. How do we solve this?
We take their wealth we we need to be able to take their wealth is grand back in the mix Grand please get back in the mix I show the sore from carrying the podcast on This is the worst all our listeners like grand please don't we share the michlorian songs and praises We give them something we have our warrior something to fight for okay, maybe and then they might die because it's a huge army Yeah, he says okay What you do is well if you're going against two rich and powerful cities what you do is you go and talk to one of them? I say look why are you on with those guys you can fight us but we have nothing to give you right? Yes, you can beat a poor city and take nothing or you can ally with us because we won't take any of the spoils We will help you beat this other city and you can take everything would not be in attractive proposition That's smart and he says well if you're thinking about a large and rich city as one city You are doing it wrong because a large and rich city is multiple cities within one location Sure, and the truth is he's like you have lots of groups of people You have the incredibly rich and you have the incredibly poor And if what you do is you try to ally with the poor against the rich who are running with the city you all of a sudden Find yourself with many friends indeed because you've taken the wealth from those rich people given to the poor Well, so say I'm going up against the city right the city is usually run by the wealthiest few Yes, and so if I start spreading rumors to the poor that we can overthrow and then we're not gonna take any of the riches Right, just help you in rebellion then they're like oh run like I said yeah Why are we helping these rich dopes like get more rich right when we can get rich if we just help this other city this is There's a security that comes with drifiness. Yeah, yeah I see like exactly I I and because a huge city is subject to that kind of divide of populace, right?
Is it just anything I didn't think about it till you said it inequality exists within this city I mean inside of our ideal city there are rich and poor like I don't know the Socrates even reflect on this to say what's inside of us No, it's just interesting that Our ideal state is not you know, everyone has the exact same skill or ability or wealth or pick your thing I just I didn't think about that until you just said that there are rich and poor people like yeah Why wouldn't our ideal city not have poverty because it's perfect so says Socrates poverty is perfect No, it just doesn't have poverty. He doesn't have poverty. So we don't have poverty Not as far as I know it has not been addressed So right we I think he assumes that if we create the perfect state organizing so far as the state doesn't as people in the state Don't want these riches. Yeah, exactly if we never enough to go around people and the guardians aren't Augling after riches and everyone is sort of doing their own thing and doing it well and not trying to barge in anybody else's thing Right, right.
We have a functioning state. Okay, it's functioning well. Okay. The next question is how big how big is our city?
How big should we allow ourselves to get before splitting off big enough that everybody can hear somebody talking in the town square? It's like shouting really loud. Yeah, so like there's nothing answer. There's a dude who yells it Yeah, if it's and then if the size of the police.
Yeah, what did I miss this? Something different before but that used to be the like size of the city if like you're Polish We know bigger than if when you're in the forum and you yell and do the back can't hear you You're serious too big and there's but there's some like example from antiquity It's like some guy with a really loud voice if you can't hear him. Yeah, your polis is too big scream on The polls are in the police and if you move too far away, I can't hear screaming. I'm sorry.
I'm sorry. I'm sorry I don't know if that's in the republic but that's a thing I've quoted before yeah, yeah I don't remember any speaking of letters though I'm looking at the spot where they talk about the size and I do not see anybody hollering in the polis Maybe did you guys see one of those like fake internet quote things? Yeah, exactly this whole podcast is a scam. Sorry.
They're there. This is true a thorough number of yes Lewis quotes bonk around the interview absolutely never said that's fair point Yeah, so how big should the city be how do we regulate the size of the city as large as is good for unity? Oh great. All right, so super useful So the moment you start getting like crazy dissension among the populace.
You should probably like start a city Yes, start a new city and just split off a little bit right if we can't all get together and agree on things then it's only a problem 25 people You have a bleak outlook on well remember all of these people are perfectly Oh, yeah, that is true for God right. Yeah, definitely listen to happy marching music. Yeah, we're eating I believe we I still think Socrates would be totally jazzed over not sprulex. He thinks relax was the bane of everything Yeah, it's a little yeah a little too screechy.
Yeah, it's sounds like crazy warfare Okay, so that's that I guess my first question you guys was do you think that like do you think that America has gotten too big as of Obvious disunity or I mean the cities. Yeah, I mean Man, I don't know How do you how do you organize 350 million people right like I come from a nation of less people than California, right? So we in Canada we got 30 million people but we've got a huge landmass and in the United States We have a smaller landmass but ten times more people What's our teaser? Or what's the reason why you should split into have more cities just because there's disunity?
Was that that was the rationale? Yeah, he wanted to be only large enough that could maintain unity and he's assuming that cities equal state Yeah, right so if we don't have the unity we should have let's we should split into So we part of our part of the American answer to that is we have states exactly But even the state is larger than a then a polis their laboratories of democracy is larger than any polis Yeah, I think we talked about Athens having I forget the number 50,000 I think men and so I don't know like it The scale is totally off right part of the answer is that there are states that have unique identities to themselves and so that's a part of it Are we too big? I don't know. I want to say no because it feels weird to say yes I want to say no because we can I would say that there are certain ways that we can still communicate with everyone in the polis It's our marketplace is different and it means something to have American values I think and so there's a way other being unity that I think as many people have said we've lost probably since the I don't know 1950s 1960s, but there is something that unifies us and we would call that Usually freedom or democracy or some but something like that.
I didn't have to pass a test to get in I just had to I just had to do the To do the paperwork needed for someone who was getting a green card, but I didn't have it like values test Because yeah, but if you were to become a citizen then there'd be like a that's more a facts history thing Yeah, it is but it is also probably probably yeah, I'd like to announce a queen or something Like rip up a picture ever In front of I don't know an effigy of George Washington. Oh my gosh Yeah, I I want to say that we're not too big because we are capable of agreement through whatever those like shared values are And that's possible. I think a beautiful thing of the American experience experiment is the possibility of unity across many different people groups That when you look at other nations They don't often have the melting pot quality that the United States has it's worked for us for 150 years over so I do not think we are too big because of like unique values that we hold there's yeah states don't have I mean states have cultural differences So like Washington State is very different from Texas, which is very different from New Jersey culturally But they also but I'm sort of unclear as to what if they have many large functional differences Right like I guess there are some states that have more established centralized health care plans in some states that don't I like to get pretty weird. Yeah For different states in Nevada and Florida like if you are more of a libertarian you want less regulation go New Hampshire Right if you're more of a status than you want to have more centralized control go to California Is that true that's sort of in my perception but I've lived in enough states to know if that is in fact true That's just sort of been my outsider's perception.
Yep. Yes There are unique identities by state and you will feel more or less like an insider depending on which of those if you fit with that Yeah, yeah, so the state agree with that. Okay. Yeah, okay I guess I'm hung up on the question of is the United States too big that's a different question than are the states too big Yeah, right and but weirdly enough like there are stereotypes of Texas, right?
And not everyone in Texas is actually a cowboy sure Graham. I don't know if you know this not you guys don't like house I just love a lot of sure that they're easy to ride in very slow. Yeah, good. They do not much object But maybe but again, there's it means something to be Texan, right?
Yeah, it's actually different than a California. Can I say that like sure sure? But then there's also the bigger question about how much have we subsidized populations with using technology or using technology like how much have we been able to feed a population because of the technology that we've had with crop yields and fertilizers and these sorts of things and what happens if We can't do that anymore. I mean, there's there's there's sort of the like That's sort of more fundamental question about like how much people can a landmass actually support?
I think I think it's three percent of Americans that are farmers and we could fit the entire United States and Texas and have a lower population density than New York Like we have lots of land. Yeah, not that we would want to have population density of New York throughout all the Texas Anyway, I think like that don't really scare me, but I hear you that there are like sustainability questions The things that scare me are the like every increasing needs of fertilizer fertilizer for keeping the same amount of yield So we've got this like red-queen fact of running to stay in the same spot. Anyway, that's another podcast conversation all together. That's for the conspiracy Episode one JFK, oh my gosh, I saw there was a student reading that.
What was that like that conspiracy theory JFK book? What was it called like from the 70s on man? It was like this famous book and it's freaking kidding. No, no It's not this like funky title about what really happens JFK.
I can't remember what it is. Anyway, let's keep going Yeah, Jeff gave us a fake. He was a puppet that they walked around to be present. Okay Puppet state, right the next thing is literally puppet state The so we've we figured out our size right and just enough to be harmonious And the next thing we talk about is education like is he's like do we need any more legislation than that?
Like what about the small stuff like what about? You know who's got what and who gets like what about marriage for example? And who gets to like how do they marry and how do they procreate children? Like all of that stuff and he's like well what we got to do is make sure that we we plan for the most important thing the number one most important thing that Will be sufficient for our purpose right which kind of guides everything and this sounds so self-serving But it's education is that nurture if our citizens are and I quote if our citizens are well educated and grow into sensible men They will easily see their way through all these as well as other matters And basically says that all of these things will they'll figure it out and then he kind of drops that Follows the general principle that friends have all things in common Which freaks me out because it sounds like marriage and children like oh, we'll just do it all together I don't what does it mean to do that all together?
What does I mean? Whatever, whoever and everybody and we raise kids all together again I think I said in episode one that about the republic I always thought this is like a super totalitarian state that ends up looking like 1984 Wherein everyone owns everyone else. I'm pretty sure we do end up there, right? He started he's a strong family.
I think he's got this sort of like everybody is Creating kids together kind of yes Well if I remember I think later it actually talks about how they will take the kids and test them out Maybe we did that in previous episode already. I don't remember that but it's terrifying the kids test them out Yeah, yeah, I'm gonna tell them that was all dream Yeah, yeah, I was like that which was the most And this is what I thought it was interesting it's like give them a classical SAT and then they figure out what their blood is Yeah, and then he said like ply them with oh, yeah try to Crazy, yeah, it's crazy. Um no those were the opposite reactions No, so he also says this thing also and I quote also I said the state if once started well moves with the accumulating force like a wheel for good nurture and education implant good Constitutions and these good constitutions taking root in a good education improve more and more and this improvement affects the breed in man As in other animals basically if we make a good crop They'll make a good crop and they'll make a good crop and it's just gonna accumulate and get better and better What do you boys think that not true? Why don't you think it's true because there's there's great man who have crappy kids?
Hmm true. Yeah, I was like you can you cannot expect the education to work perfectly every time and accumulate like a wheel We the breeding doesn't work that way right that people don't I think in this he's probably wrong And then he goes into a really long diatribe about how we should be really freaked out about any new music I'm not kidding. That's a tangent. Let me let me read you the quote Basically that music and gymnastics right which provided the basis for education need to remain intact and unchanged right and he says We'll have we'll have any regard for the newest songs and I quote for any musical innovation is full of danger to the whole state And ought to be prohibited so Damon tells me and I can quite believe him He says that when modes of music change the fundamental laws of the state always change with them Hmm.
I do I wonder about this that music art poetry gets beyond your rational faculty like it gets to some deeper part of yourself Like does it? I don't know there is danger in is there like media you can say that quote about like Let me let me write the songs of a nation and I care not who writes her laws Right like that sort of idea that the music in the art end up playing a much more Large guiding force in in the state then and then and then that sort of laws and culture are downstream from artistic innovations And so we should be real real wary when you know punk rock comes to Athens before whatever He's redark time No, but I think there's something to that where like the the artistic expressions end up becoming embedded in the cultural identity and in the cultural identity gets codified into laws and then Yeah, yeah, and then I thought this was really good. I actually put in my commonplace book He says the lawlessness of what you speak easily steals in yes I replied in the form of amusement and at first sight it appears harmless Yeah, why yes, he said and there is no harm were it not that little by little the spirit of license finding a home Imperceptively penetrates into matters manners and customs when issuing with greater force it invades contracts between man and man And from contracts goes on to laws and constitutions in utter recklessness and the last Socrates by an overthrow of all rights Private as well as public rap music doing us all folks, but he's on something there He maybe it's or it's overblown to say that all laws are thrown over whatever you just said but yeah There's a danger there, but there's it yes that Or the that our minds will be changed without us realizing it. I mean, that's I don't know it's really true.
I think it's true Yeah, that's why yeah, yeah, so you guys are you and as a strive to like banning certain sorts of music I so I have a child that was announced a while ago I will be a cautious of what music this child listens to like I will it will not just be a purely laissez-faire do whatever you want to With the reason being some music is harmful and when he's older I would teach him that principle but at first it will look more like censorship before it looks like teaching him out to make His own decision has to be yeah, but yeah I remember driving home and had this little like through the looking glass moment where I was four five sort of name pop songs after each other and I was for whatever reason was trying to think of could I crystallize the message of this pop song into one phrase and Five in a row and it was the same phrase it boiled down to this I'm amazing. Nobody else realizes this one day they will It's like the message of five songs in a row You will one day see that I am as awesome as I know that I am And I was like at some point that's got to be formative on The listener over and over and over again and at some point if that's formative on every listener over and over and over again That's going to reflect itself in what we think the pursuit of happiness or the good life is and there's yeah I'm sure you can look at current political Instabilities and trace it back to what seems to be a name or jazz I like inoculous or benign sentiments back in the day or whatever the moving from In the tritone yes, we're becoming just grouchy old man We're like I'm like the tritone came in everyone thought that the devil's the devil's interval was gonna hurt everyone's mind and So they're doing a song they're doing a longer time frame right so one way of doing this is to say you know I was born in 1989 so the music of the 90s is perfect, but anything post 2010 is wicked But actually what if this actually started in the 1800s my goodness We're butterflies who landed on a tree and don't think it's growing. Thank you. Wonderful.
What or land on a tree And don't think it's on fire No, I'm saying yeah, so the problem is older and actually go back to older music like maybe all music in the last hundred years We shouldn't move past the liar. I'm saying that those Greek for on to something So anyway, we're in chance man. I feel like we've just undercut ourselves with every audience out there We're talking about stuff about old things so I'm sorry to all but all of our liar players who are listeners will love this episode We've done on them for for the record. I love a lot of modern music and I am completely disolute All right, so the next the next thing he talks about is like since our guys healthy for you Like there's no moral value.
There's no listening to that modern music does nothing to you Oh, man, I actually I've been thinking about this a lot lately especially in it in regards to students And I'm sorry audience if we're a little off track here I'll try to hustle through something we do every episode but you know I have some content I have important content maybe So why would you go that out of coffee over 40 minutes of that thing? I was funny. This is maybe not as important thing we do every night But the honest the honest truth is the world I don't like I don't a lot of that music probably has not been beneficial for me And I think that as a high schooler and I think many of our high schoolers have this exact same thought that like they will be one person for for a time and then they will listen to an evil song and then they will continue to be that same person because the cumulative effect of Evil songs and the consumption of evil art is almost imperceptible and can only be perceived over the course of decades All right, so like as a high school student I was like I listen to Rage Against the Machine That was great for the record rage is still great. I'm great.
Wonderful But but like there's there are some songs and some things and the problem is that when you then later need to think these are the things that are readily at hand Right, I have like maybe maybe setting my table with a single packet of cheese It's among a feast is not necessarily a bad thing But if my table is completely filled with trash then when I have to reach for something on the table I'm going to come back with trash and I think cumulatively in my own life and my own soul It has been a negative effect and so I'm you know like I'm always sort of trying to reevaluate my own entertainment and where that lands and so like if students if you're listening like personally I Scribed to the I think that it is a silly thing to talk about music as having detrimental effects But having lived through that attitude and come out the other side of it I can say that it definitely has a negative ones But that said like I am working at a classical school and like I'm faithful and I encourage kids every day So like there are worse outcomes. It's just it's a struggle for me instead of taking it from us Maybe an experiment is best like I did this with music for a while do a fast We don't listen you try to listen any music at all for a second period of time And then when you get back into listening to music listen into something that you're like man I wish I liked this so what I did most recently this the school year was I did listen to music for a long time And then when I came back I only listen to a certain a couple of composers I wanted to like find I want to see there's like any good contemporary composer Taylor Fifth He's a stony his name is Arvo part a RV O and his last time's part to be a Or can't probably pronouncing it wrong, but I listen to his music sort of exclusively for this the first what are we a week week nine of the school year? I was listening to him exclusively every morning while I come into school in grade before school starts for about nine weeks and And it's just like with any sort of fasting when you haven't listened to something for a while And then you do something completely different your taste sort of changes and I went back and I was listening And then like the radio was on it was listening to some music that was kind of like a name boring and it's just I don't know There was a benefit I don't want to put too fine a point on it But but if you're yeah, don't take our word for it Listener if this is something that you were thinking about and you and you're asking yourself like I wonder if Plato is Honestly about this or if he's a sogrechial dude, well then test it yourself Yeah, I think it's just an accumulated darkness And I think that the same kind of thing happens when you spend too much time on the internet right the internet is a it is a Palpably darker place than the real world right is actually darker and if you spend more time there than you do in the real world It will go into darkness right anyway, so that's a good question And I've got to honestly answer it right so he kind of goes on and compares our state full of well-educated people who are listening to excellent music And just being awesome and how much an easy time they will have legislating themselves right if we got to figure out And his example is like when the young are to be silent before their elders how they are to show their respect for them by standing and making Them sit what honors it appearance what garments or shoes are to be worn the mode of dressing and hair department matters like you they will Invent for themselves all these rules right? We don't need to make little rules for our state about these because once we take care of education They will regulate themselves and he compares it to a state that doesn't regulate himself and I would love it if my students stood up When I walked in the classroom, holy smokes, you make that happen No, but I've been praying you just said it was gonna do it it was gonna take care of itself If I write to you, they're not done the education Oh, this is part of their education, but then I feel like it loses something I feel like I'm a big like tur- I'm making them do it I demand that my students address me appropriately that means not a dude But Lord Hanenburg is fine because that is because I'm a Lord new listeners AJ is in fact a Lord anyway Just so you know that he's just he's not actually anyone He has a bad lord he purchased title he still I'm not from not a type of how many Lord chicks weren't purchased Graham I'm a great point.
Oh, the Lord some of the 80 Lord James. Right? Rumble grumble gel you want to go buy one seriously you want me a Lord spend the $25 I think I'm gonna be a Duke. You would not rank me.
Yeah, and I would I would have to address you as my leash Oh Worth it now or I'm a Lord. I would act I would actually make an effort to do that. Okay. We have to move on So basically once we have everything squared away in education we get it right and the next thing so he's like okay We figured out all the small quibbles about legislation all the small laws We don't really need to worry about that as long as our education is solid What about the spiritual life?
Mm-hmm and he says well, we're gonna leave that to the God right? Whatever the God tells us to do Apollo. He's been our man for a long time. He's in charge We'll do what he says will maintain the oracles rock and roll right?
He's not bringing any big upheaval there and then he's like alright well We did it guys we built the state off and far as we know this baby's perfect right? She's carrying us all the way so just to be clear They built this city but not on rocket roll. Yes, definitely on liar and the major scale or whatever their version of the major So lies and lies and lots of lies about everything to everyone great city. Yeah, and and heavy censorship Okay, so I mean I said look what we're trying to do with the first was figure out where justice was right I'm where we do it and they're like well, we don't know and he says well now We have to look at the qualities in the state and then maybe we can look back in the qualities in the man So what are the good qualities in the state and one of my favorite little sections?
He just says clearly the virtues are for in number He's like there are four things and you're searching for one of them Well, you can do is find the other three and then the one you're the extra one you need is the leftover one right? If I'm looking for like three chips I lost and I found three of those well the fourth one is the fourth one and it's got to be somewhere It's the one that's over right what is happening that was a horrible idea But stick with me and he says do you do use like loose chips all the time Yeah, those chips looks like the words is when you lose a chip and then it gets hit and becomes multiple Just multiply your pains But there's like not a lot of distance traveled from like the chip repository to the chip tell us you're sure That's true. You have long arms, and I don't eat exclusively Pringles like you can just up in the camera your mouth and let the whole string go in Okay, so he says clearly the virtues are for a number he basically says that's our tactic We're gonna if we're searching for a fourth thing We'll find the first three and then it'll be whatever's left over and he says and is not a similar method to be pursued about the virtues Which are also for in number he just says it Yeah, no no Absolutely zero ever to prove that there are four and just that's sure I mean Clearly how could it be otherwise Socrates there are only four Naturals right good okay, so he says all right well wait a minute. Yeah, you're trying to win art Oh is the rational there we go.
I was gonna say tie the virtues to the No, don't tell us the rational one Leonardo's a spirited one. Yeah, no Faiel I For virtues if we have well after we're done Okay, okay, I'm on it. Yeah, we're with it. Okay, so the first virtue He's like okay wisdom where where where's the wisdom of the state and how much time I run with you?
20 minutes 20 minutes top of the heap is wisdom. Okay, so he says wisdom if you said like the wisdom of a state is in its carpenters No, no, that's just wisdom in carpentry. You're just like oh good at carpentry So where would you say it's like where's wisdom found? We're at the right of the guardians the top right the people who can correctly make decisions about the whole stretch Right, so that is wisdom and I quote it is the knowledge of the guardians he replied and is found among those who are just not describing as perfect Guardians, right?
This is about my mind. Sorry. So the virtues are actually located in each of the functions of the city So he's not saying all four virtues are in our leading guardians. No, these are wisdom right now He's looking at the virtues of a state.
So the wisdom of a state is found in the leaders It's cool. Yeah, it does right so the courage is easy to Where's the courage from? Well, they're really like the virtue the courage virtue of a state right looking at a state as a whole right that is found in our The guardians right doesn't go in much into exactly what wisdom is beyond just making like right decisions Right good counsel truly wise making decisions about what to go and what to do temperance knowledge, right? It's like knowledge of good knowledge.
I didn't find it last episode I should have but prudence is usually inserted for wisdom. It's the right action at the right time. Yeah, practical knowledge Right now, and so he says okay courage you've attributed it to our Our art in class of The throne of oh man, that's such a great name for it. We have that as a lecture we have a Throw down class we have a mark we have the mark we have the Yeah, but they're just training to hit non-assay let's I want them to hit each other I'm a boxing class.
That's why you don't teach that like various types of throw down We'll just have like throw a bunch of pipes on the floor and be like throw down go for it. Yeah, good Okay, there'll only be one single lecture every class in one two minutes Email us at class Okay, if you want to teach that class, so courage what is current you guys know this I feel stupid asking the question because you're just gonna give me the Right answer what's courage? Courage is the mean between foolhardiness and cowardice. Yes, but you've told me where it's located between two things What does that mean?
What is what is courage? What's doing the right thing? No, Britain's that's pretty nice. Whoops But I actually do I actually thought I don't know the oh bonus.
I actually give it to you. Okay, so this is let's see Here this is this is the actual quote This is what courage is the city will be courageous in virtue of a portion of herself which preserves under all circumstances That opinion about the nature of things to be feared and not to be feared in which our legislature educated them and this is what you turn Courage so they are taught these things are to be feared and these things are not to be fearing the right thing and maintaining that in every situation that means Mmm in the rest in battle not in wartime. So like if you're not a warning like if you're nothing well, you're not really being truly crazy Yeah, you're being foolhardy. It's like an objective Nature of a thing whether it ought to be feared or not that's interesting.
That is true. That's not true courage is like just blasting in despite danger That's not true courage is maintaining an opinion on what is to be feared and not feared Yeah, right even if they are torturing you and you're like look you can kill me That's the worst you can do you can have a storm just throw my soul I don't fear you right like that that is true courage Yeah, and so that is found in our guardians right if our guardians always have in mind like here's what to be feared Which would be defeat disgrace and the destruction of the state versus what is not to be feared Which is an enemy a sale in the trip, right? Then they are courageous. Okay.
This is interesting. I like this where in the world is temperance That's next. Yeah, that's like the little artisan class. Okay, so what is what is temperance there?
Temperance is not too much not too few you want like is the right is the right amount You might so you're gonna say this is an answer your question But it's the mean between being a bump on the log and doing nothing and excess of like gluttony so it's Consuming or like engaging when one one ought to and not engaging one shouldn't okay, right? Yeah Does that like what part of our city does that that's a great question so our families our I'm gonna hustle up a little bit because we are running out of time And there's still a lot to do but temperance is not located in a single group Temperance is the harmony of the whole that's cool So temperance you have often said like it means not too much not too little obvious pleasures, right? Basically, he says it's a man being his own master It's good But that is a silly way to say it a man being his own master if the master and the man are the same the slave and the master of the same thing I'm not really saying anything so when I say a man being his own master What I truly mean is part of a man ruling over the rest of the man that should be ruled and the and the harmonious agreement between the two Oh, one thing should rule one thing should be ruled and so in a state it is the same it is the statement that it is that Here's the the actual definition most truly then may we deem temperance to be the agreement of a naturally superior and inferior as to the right to rule of either Both in states and individuals so the superior knows they should rule they know it's the right and they stay at top the inferior No, that is not their place and they say you guys rule will stay here bonus, right? That is what we have chosen you for you are in that place sure My biggest question when I read this was how often has this been used to justify slavery totally right?
Yeah, yeah, and that's what's not so charged that people have put against Plato and even their sorrow is that I mean I played with this that that those are grounds for it and also air So is in fact in favor of slavery like right it is not incorrect to say that right the naturally superior in failure right? That's that's troublesome in his state He's actually choosing like he allows for mobility in the classes right if I'm smart and I show aptitude then I'll get bumped up Right if I'm supposed to be in the guardian class and I really suck at my job I'll be bumped down right so he's actually allows for mobility And so there is like a natural recognition that yes These people are made for this job and you're not sure but on the same token like there is like in my class temperance Is the agreement of the students to let me rule and then me agreeing to like rule the students appropriately that is temperance Right and that keeps anything from flying way off the handle and it has it makes more sense in a man Okay, next one is done. We've done the three right what's left just a Artists in class. Yeah, okay, so dudes.
What does it make any sense? I'm going so the underlands where justice lives just in them. Okay, so everywhere so he says basically he's like oh man What's left? I don't know and he's like yeah, we're gonna look and he's like I feel like we've been hunting around she's hiding the bushes so we're gonna find her there's this great little dialogue and He's like what that I could but you should regard you should regard me as a follower who has just eyes enough to see what you Show him this is about as much as I'm good for that's the person listening It says offer up a prayer with me and follow I will but you must show me the way here is no path I said and the wood is dark and perplexing still we must push on what in the world let us push on here I saw something oh my god hello I said I begin to perceive a track and I perceive that the quarry will not escape good news.
He said truly I said oh we are stupid fellows So why so why am I good sir at the beginning? Really silly back and forth and essentially what he says is look we've had justice all along mmm Justice is the quality of doing your own thing and minding your own stinking business Mmm, right not knowing anyone else's affairs Yeah, he's like we said that with from the very first We wanted our people to do one thing and do it well and not mess with anybody else's job And he's like if you do that in a state then you're not trying to take anybody else's business Yeah, you're not trying to try to jump jump into a job that isn't meant for you not like trying to oust people who should be ousted You're not stealing from anyone you're just doing like what you're taking care of what's yours and doing what's good I think that Aristotle eventually will sort of revolutionize the notion of what justice is and Nick McKee and ethics I think his definition is probably better than just like do your own thing and don't be nosy right? But that's essentially what playo says is like I think we shot down air shallows as closer to giving everyone their due And I thought that down in book one as not a good definition right that was the one about the If grand gives me his guns and then comes back and says he wants to shoot someone like I can't I shouldn't give him his guns Yeah, that's fair. Yeah, so I don't know yeah, um basically he says okay, so this is just right I'm taking three distinct classes any meddling of one into the other or the change of one into the other is the greatest harm to the state Right, we're meddling with each other.
It's gonna cause problems. Yeah, right? So that's justice right so they've got the four and he's like bonus We've got justice as far as the state goes does that hold true in man Right, how do we take the notion of justice within the state which is everybody sort of doing their own thing and transfer it to a man? And he's like well, we've got three parts of a state are the three parts of a man And listener you don't know how significant this portion is but this is where the four virtues the four cardinal virtues are established and they Justice courage peppers and they stood for I think that's now we're looking at 20 They still stand they are 400 years from this until now they have stood for the last 2,400 years affirmed and reaffirmed by every philosopher and theologian up until now This is like a play-doh is not screwing around this This is the defining chapter for the four virtues and it is it has stood since then like that is a Christian added three more Yeah, but the cardinal virtues are available to all men the faith of the logical virtues are available supposedly only through interaction with the divine Yeah, so these are the virtues of all men there no matter your station No matter your faith, right?
You can be just and temperate and wise and have all those things even with no faith Then we'll do the three parts of the city then time with our tripartide soul. Yes And so this is also like I'm telling you this is where they figure out like okay What are the different parts of man? He's like okay? Well, do we still have in our body sort of a a like ruling part?
He's like yeah, you know like a rational soul that sort of makes decisions He's like do we have an competitive soul something that wants stuff and he's like the no I'm sure yeah You you got a part like soul that like that wants things and that that super makes sense So he says let's see we can clearly assume that they are too and that they differ from one another the one with which Man reasons we may call the rational principle of the soul and the other which is which he loves and hungers and thirsts and feels The fluttering of any other desire may be termed the irrational or a pennative the allied sundry pleasures and salam's actions It's like great. There's two principles in the soul and he's like what about spirit, right? Okay, so the way he comes up with reason versus appetite is that he says look sometimes you have a desire that you know It's not a good thing to fulfill right. Yeah.
Yeah, if I'm super thirsty But I knew that there are there's like poison in the water I will desire to drink that water like my appetite I will want it so bad or like you've known this if you've been camping like you see a stream You want to just dunk your face in it because you're so thirsty, but if you're in the water you get in the yardy I'm a be a fever. Yeah, and so that's so that's so he's like all that that's thing. I believe you Yeah, he goes through this whole thing establishing that like if two things are opposed to each other They must be different parts right? I can't say that they are one whole when they're trying to do two different things So right so there's this whole section about improving how that's a principle and we don't need to go into it But he says like look if you're trying to do different things with this water You've clearly got two different parts of the soul that are at war one that is reasonable and one that desires Right, and he's like all right.
What about the spirited one? And he's like well I remember this story about this guy named Leon Tius some of a glion and he was coming like up to the north wall of the city And he saw a whole bunch of dead bodies at the place of execution Like just a bunch of dead things and I don't know if you guys are the same as me But when you're watching a horror movie you like crazy stuff is happening like oh, I don't look but I also like So you have the desire to look at the dead bodies and he knew he shouldn't right He's like I won't do it and he held out for as long as he could for time He struggled and covered his eyes, but at length the desire got the better of him and forcing them open He ran to the dead bodies saying look you wretches take your fill of the fair sight He's like talking to his eyeballs. He's like look eyeballs. Oh my gosh take your He's frustrated with himself.
Yeah, so at that point we have anger and anger can go at war with desire So clearly they're not the same thing They're two distinct things right and it is allied with reason so they find out that the spirited soul will often you feel really bad? If you sort of like given to your desires and so there are three parts There's the rational there's the spirit and cuz anger isn't really reason right and it's not really an appetite because it can be a war with Abatite right so you have reason spirit and appetite and spirit is allied with reason trying to establish those things And so here we find the hierarchy of the tripartite soul Which is our very first episode you can go and listen to it on our website, but man in three parts Yeah, reason spirit and appetite and he says okay, so now if we've had our for virtues in the state and we got the three parts of man Where can we find those in man? Well, what is wisdom wisdom of the state within our ruling class? Well, we have a ruling class in man reason rational right seems the line of the reason for good right courage Can we have courage within a man right maintaining?
Something's are to be feared sometimes and sometimes spirited that the will yeah It's in the will right knowing what like being able to maintain even to rest the things that I know are right right? And then we have temperance so as temperance was harmony within the state. How would that look in a person? Is that harmony the harmony that your appetites are following your spirit and your your reason yeah?
Yeah, yeah Yeah, and so basically knowing it like my appetites want a thing But if I have harmony and knowing who is ruling the appetites will stay ruled by my reason And I will not take too much of a thing because I know that there's a point which I need to stop and my spirit will help me maintain that right I will add force to my reason and resist against my appetites So if everything is ruling as it should then we have no problems It's the man gets disordered when those things get out of whack I know we've talked about all this before but like this is where it comes from It's play a book for and I could read there's a section where he basically defines each of the four virtues and then he basically says Justice is maintaining that that that hierarchy right so interesting it's putting reason above will and appetites justice Yes, all these bound together and each one doing his own job and not trying to do the job of something else right? If your appetites are trying to do the job of reasoning that doesn't work right? And so that the harmony of temperance is like maintaining maintaining sort of a unification about a country's It was in charge and it was in charge. Well, that's also justice right so but maintaining like that sort of unity about how to sort of live in the world I guess yeah, um, do they accept this answer?
Yeah, he's like nice great job Yeah, yeah, not to rebel and even to do the work of the others he sets in order his own life Oh, so yeah, and this so justice here I can read you the quote about justice but in reality justice was such as we were describing being concerned However, not with the outward man But with the inward inward which is the true self and conservative man for the just man does not permit the several elements with him In him to interfere with one another or any of them to do the work of the others He sets in order his own inner life and is his own master and his own law and it peace with himself And when he has bound together the three principles within him which may be compared to the higher lower and middle notes of the scale At and the intermediate intervals when he has bound all these together and is no longer many But has become one entirely temperate and perfectly adjusted nature Then he proceeds to act if he has to act what whether in a matter of property or in the treatment of the body or in some Affair of politics or private business always thinking and calling that which preserves and cooperates with his harmonious condition Just and good action basically like sticking with it right everything in harmony perfect And then he like they go a little further like what was vice? Well when things go screwy and then he says okay So now what do you think about just like justice? Are we supposed to come back justly if we go and punish like is that a good thing right? That was the main question the question we started with in book one and the answer is in my judgment Socrates the question has now become Ridiculous because if I am acting unjustly it means that I'm a disordered person living in a disordered state I'm a mess I can't control myself and so acting unjustly is an inward problem that causes lots of pain Wow, and then basically like the end of this chapter says Well, we can look and see that the way of virtue is singular There's one way to be rightly ordered but many ways to vice and injustice are all over the place And so he says before I'm looking there are four ones that deserve note And I'm sure we'll go to that next chapter and he says just like Sorry, there's there are problems.
There are five of the state and five of the soul and he's gonna go over like what states are good So he's like ours is a monarchy and aristocracy right? That's what we like but we're gonna go into which governments are better which ones are worse So to summarize basically they finish up the state saying like what about our poor guardians? Well, they can suck it up and if we educate everybody really well everything will run smoothly Which I highly doubt and also be careful of crazy music and then we figure out the four virtues and establish the four cardinal virtues Which are again wisdom courage temperance and justice in the state and then the man and basically realize that like acting unjustly is the recipe for Having a bummer life. Sure.
Yeah, that's awesome. All right. Thank you. Hey, that was really good So this has been classical stuff You should know you can find us online at classical stuff net if you want to go listen to that episode one with Graham and AJ Where they talk about the three parts of the soul it is up on our website You should go listen to that you can also find us on Twitter at classical stuff CLS Stuff that is on Twitter and you can email us at classical stuff at veritas academy dot net and I think that is all that We have cool.
All right. Thank you all for listening. Thank you. I did for the episode.
Cheers. Cheers. Bye