All right, so you remember a few episodes ago we had this discussion about photography and how it preserves things. Do you remember that? Yes, I do. So the camera I've been using is an SLR not a DSLR But an SLR but it just bought something I want to show you here on this zoom call looks like a little black leather pouch Yeah opening the pouch look at this What does it look was it look like a?
Gray brick that I assume is some sort of camera. Yeah, listen to this That cool ones so this is a film camera camera. I don't know It's called an icon 35 Ti it is like it's a coveted point and shoot camera like it is a camera that Photographers have claimed is one of the best point and shoot film cameras that was ever made that's up for debate I don't really know if that's a thing or not, but check this out on the top It's got this little needle and like if I want to shoot in aperture mode I can do that and I can just roll a little wheel what and it will change the aperture and you read it on these needles It looks like a gas cage way. Does that look cool?
I'm shooting on an SLR as well courtesy of you. Thank you for that. Once again. Yeah, you're welcome I use a Speed booster no I don't have to have a speed booster with it I go straight to a Sigma lens that I really like one that I use with my digital photography I'm gonna take a picture of you while we're doing this.
Thank you. I'd like that. You just like let me move this microphone It took a flash. I don't know if that's gonna flash.
That's just gonna look better It's just gonna flash in the screen that I just failed I wasted an image anyway. I'm sorry go ahead That's like a buck. Yeah, I owe you a buck. I should have warned you I should have thought of it But one of the tricks with that is that I have a really tough time having my hands off the wheel so to speak on all the Little fine tuning stuff that I'm used to doing with my digital cameras So when I'm taking those pictures my eyes is this aperture correct?
I don't know what am I even allowed to adjust how does it work? It's very very confusing and this thing it looks like 1930s or 1940s Little dials and needles there on the top it looks like instrumentation from an old plane or something from the air out of the rock It's here. Yeah, it's called a galvanometer is what it was in physics class It's like the little needle and there's a magnetic field that moves the needle. It's beautiful.
Isn't it? Yeah, it is beautiful So what I've been learning is how film works and what I've learned is it's literally silver Crystals there a little bit a little bit silver halide crystals inside a super new age. I know it's pretty crazy I'm like wear them near your heart and it reveals things. No, not like that No, it's just like little bitty ground up pieces of silver halide which is like silver and like some I don't know I don't know what it is chlorine fluorine bromine I don't know I don't know chemistry very well, but as the light hits it it changes the the the crystal to turn it into a latent image And then the developing process actually amplifies it so when you look at an image on film you're looking at literally silver metal It's really cool.
So anyway, that's that's what I've been researching how film works And I'm working on a video about that But I thought the idea of capturing something in a physical form so that you can have it indefinitely even though it was just a little moment I thought that was really interesting. Yeah, likewise and I've been puzzling over something similar and I appreciate you being willing to come into this conversation effectively blindly I wanted to talk with you about a similar process of grabbing a snapshot of something So part of the beauty of taking a picture like you and I take when we hang out with our families is that even though It's only been six weeks or eight weeks since you were up in my neck of the woods hanging out already You all have changed we've changed and that picture that moment of us in the black Hills that moment about rush more that moment in my backyard Those can never really truly be repeated and we have this little flat two-dimensional paper thin memory Physical expression of memory that we can put hands on and we can put eyes on and it will always be a little bit of a physical connection to that Irreplaceable unrepeatable moment that happened right there. It's almost like an apparition It's like a sample that represents the whole or but it's an ephemeral kind of feel to it Like the moment came and went but we have this little reachback moment of it that we're able to And I don't know extrapolate the entire experience from is that that make I don't know it's almost like you have to interpolate everything Yes Lately I don't know if it's the algorithms that I've created all working against me at once But I keep getting served stuff about another kind of hypothetical snapshot and that being a snapshot of Somebody's brain at death and I don't mean like a death mask have you ever seen one of those? I saw Brady did a video about Isaac Newton's death mask is so when he died they put plaster Paris over his face And that's a that's a death mask I assume it's a snapshot right it's the same concept right?
It's one last remembrance of what that person was well fluids had still been recently pumping and before the decay of death starts to set in and Disfigure and change it's one last shot at recollection. So death masks were something you can make I mean you see some living masks as well where people put straws in the nose So you can breathe when you make that plaster mask like they do when they put it elaborate The rubber masks on actors and things like that for special effects But for the most part the idea there is this is a final memory of this person as close to their last breath as you can get But in that same spirit as technology advances from plaster of Paris to the digital world no doubt Somebody at some point was gonna have it occur to them well if we can save memories What if we can find a way to save brain memories? So I'm thinking about the death mask so you move from a camera snapshot to the death mask which safe thing saves things in three dimensions Yes, it's a three-dimensional representation. You know they have methods nowadays It's like 3d laser scanners.
There's a guy here locally a friend of mine They have a whole company called LiDAR USA and they create LiDAR It's basically radar, but with lasers they use light to bounce it off of objects and they scan a three-dimensional Area and they can reproduce everything in 3d and they'll mount these on drones and they can fly them over anything They can fly them over crops and approximate the yield of oranges in a you know orange grove or they can fly them You know over a field and count the number of sheep, you know They can do all these different things using these but you can also take a snapshot of a three-dimensional time It's called TISPY time space position information And so you can go to a place and it's almost imagine pulling the pin on a grenade and you throw the grenade and it shoots Light out in all directions and then it captures the light and then you can reproduce the three-dimensional world Is that what you mean with this? Yes, except for the brain. What do you mean? We as people?
Believe things are transcendent. It doesn't matter if somebody thinks there's a god not a god whatever Only the most devoted nihilist or naturalist would say there's no pattern and no meaning to anything Humans assign meaning to stuff if there isn't meaning we'll find it we're wired for it or evolved that way depending on how you see the equation And so we like these snapshots they matter to us they preserve something in 1999 when I saw the matrix and I saw them jadting sticks into the back of the characters brains and somehow they could upload kung-fu and Memories and entire environments for a disembodied version of themselves to go on around in I thought what I would think about that now It's absurd fascinating it raises a lot of moral questions Wasn't there a junk cloud van dam movie as well some unreal soldier or something where they'd also upload things to their brain stems with a big needle? Yeah, that kind of sounds right all of those van dam movies from that era including the one where he does the splits in the commercial They all run together for me remember the splits on the song. Oh my goodness.
So download and brain stuff. I'm with you Yeah, yeah, so it's become very trendy in the last two or three years of entertainment to Explore this idea of what it would look like to create a digital afterlife to find a way to map memories and consciousness to digitize that To then create an environment for that version of the self to go and live in into perpetuity Then presumably somehow to monetize all of this again Maybe it's just a fluke of the algorithm by keep getting this stuff serve to me more and more and I'm starting to see people who are trying to make The case that this is not an entirely unrealistic idea. Hold on wait. No stop stop says you said the phrase digital afterlife Yeah, like what does that even mean?
So what does that even mean? So life life implies that you're alive. Yes So after life to me implies life after death. Yes, so digital afterlife implies something digital that happens after the moment when I die Or my physical body is deceased.
Yeah, but the fact that you put that word life in there implies that it's digital life So it's almost like artificial life that happens after you die. Am I tracking everybody wants to live longer people do crazy things to avoid death The human buffer bar of mortality is an intimidating thing and yes, what you just described back is it's what I think people are pursuing Some sort of solution by which your mind your consciousness your memories whatever makes you you in the invisible sense can be mapped Like what you described with the the light are put a flash grenade in a room that sends out lasers in all directions capturing a digital print of that Moment except with your mind and then I think the idea is that we're engaged right now or a few people on the fringes of science are engaged Right now in the pursuit of an entirely technological afterlife So initial question that I would have for you that I would like to workshop is based on where we were at right this minute What are the hurdles to make something like that happen? Okay, so there's there's a lot here There's a lot here. So first of all I thought about these things, but not in the way that you're talking about it So for example, I have an unlisted YouTube channel that I film a lot of stuff around the house with the kids and the fan Like the other day I sat down with the kids and actually this was last year I just found the file I negotiated to buy their teeth.
I know this sounds so stupid, but we don't Yeah, the two fair doesn't visit our house for many many reasons but as a result of the two fair not visiting our house I Negotiate with my children for their teeth. I use it as an opportunity to teach them how to negotiate, okay, and Turns out I had forgotten this happened. I start the camera facing my face and say all right All right kids you wonder why we've brought you here today It's to buy your teeth daddy's gonna buy your teeth and I turn the camera around and all the children are there and I go in one by one negotiating with them to buy a tooth off of them if it's got a cavity It's not worth as much all these things long story short It's is a really precious moment in a young family and you want to keep that and you want to know what that was like So I have uploaded that to email addresses that I've assigned to each of my children And when they become a certain age they'll be given the password to this email address and they'll go in there And they'll see when they started riding a bike. They'll see when their brother was playing baseball that time They'll see when they sold daddy a tooth for him to who I don't know.
It's funny like my youngest daughter She says hey you can have this one and I'll give you five dollars and I was like, okay You can pay me five dollars to take this so cute to disposal fee. Yeah, it's a battery or oil is so cute So in this way my goal is for daddy to be alive in the minds of my children long after I'm gone So I've done that I've also got a fail safe where I have recorded a video Directed to my family and it's in the safe. Have I told you about this? It's in the safety deposit box Mm-hmm.
So that's a thing. So these are the ways that I hope to you know in effect speak to my family after I'm dead Do you screw around in that video or are you all serious like if you're watching this? Oh, yeah, I say You know what it's long before YouTube, so I don't actually remember what's on the video I should probably go I mean was filmed in like 2011. I was going to after you screw it around at least a little bit a little bit I think I think I say something like oh my goodness.
I'm dead, you know, or something like that But I really need to go watch it, you know, we've had additional children since then so I need to make sure everything's relevant But yeah, that's a way to speak beyond the grave But that's not what you're talking about you're talking about a way to interact with the world if I understand correctly like if you could capture an algorithm It's almost like a simulation of the person at a certain moment like if I were to say this how would Matt Whitman respond and then I'm sorry. I'm talking a lot is this no, it's why it's such a ludicrously difficult proposition You took us right there I mean the two sides of the coin are the existential which you intuitively brought up talking about the video You made for your family in case of your in the event not in case we're all gonna die in the event of your passing when that happens You went to the existential to share moments the beauty that is memory We haven't talked about the curse that is memory as well And then you started to shift gears into the technological hurdles is one of the first questions that you had a rest with I mean for the theist who believes from whatever their religious tradition is that there's some sort of afterlife that there's some sort of notion of Heaven you don't have to worry about the environment the deity character handles the environment where The deceased go in this afterlife in every different religion the deity makes it and so it's great streets paved with gold whatever the conception is It's just there in this conception one of the technological hurdles is you have to figure out where this consciousness if it were to be The harvestable or duplicatable where does it even go the slap that thing on a robot and just have these things gradually pop up And maybe a hundred years from now you got people wandering around the streets in their physical avatars That sounds really unappealing to me and where I sit right now Or do you create some Skyrim type environment where everybody's goes and effectively plays a video game except that's their entire Existence and a waste is kind of situation the technical hurdles are really fascinating to me before I even get into the existential hurdles because How would you even begin to map the amount of data? I mean a mind is a world unto itself. I'm too simple a man to understand how you can one and zero the human mind You understand this world better than I do Can you even fathom a method to take that complexity and boil it down to a program or memory?
No, but one thing that I think it would have to be able to do is grow like Let's just say for a second that you are able to map the human mind in some type of program And not just the human mind but a specific human mind I think an important attribute you would want this program to have or this it's not an algorithm It's like this entity to have is you would want it to be able to develop and as it interacts with the world around it It would learn from that. I don't know. I mean I think about the afterlife a bit and me too I think the ability to grow and learn and advance and better yourself I don't think it's going to end at the grave. I think it's an interesting thing like if you were to freeze I don't know There's a running joke about Walt Disney freezing his body cryogenically or something like that I'm Ted Williams Right, and so I wonder if if you could freeze yourself and then reanimate yourself at some point in the future What's the intent is it because I don't know there's so much here?
This is interesting. It's an interesting topic Well, first of all what's your take on the afterlife? Well, I think there is one I understand that that's gonna come off as insane to the purely naturalist thinker But the purely naturalist thinker and I and I am an Unapologetic theist we have a lot more in common than you might figure if we're both operating in logical structures We have a different take on how things happened in the first place for me I don't think existence and matter are eternal. I don't think time is eternal I think non-existence is more likely and makes more sense than existence and yet there is existence That's crazy to me.
That's kind of like the cosmological argument, right? Kind of yeah a little bit of a twist on that Since you and I can agree that existence exists. I'm a hundred percent sure I exist I am almost as sure that you exist I guess you could be an elaborate program and so is everyone else and I'm the point of everything But my experience doesn't reinforce that it says I'm some guy and everybody else is also some person and We're not fake programs that you know serve the NPC role to spice up Destin's world Like I'm an actual person you're an actual person in our Venn diagrams over lab occasionally and that's where the fun happens And that's the cart that said that right I think therefore I am yeah very good and so yeah Yeah, I think that not to get too weird not gonna go down this rabbit trail very far But that has a lot to do with how I built up my belief system as well It's like I know that I exist and I know that there's some kind of moral law and I know that I don't I don't do things That I feel like I should for some reason and I also feel like I do things I feel like I shouldn't for some reason and so that feels like something above me and so moral law feels you know Self-evident to me and then extrapolate and you know keep on going down that road far enough and pretty soon You know you're at a church, so well, it's hard to draw those parallels But that has a lot to do with how I ended up where I did as well that has a ton to do with why I was back in after I was out on the whole faith thing I simply could not find a satisfactory explanation for why there are things instead of not things That's not the whole or some of my faith, but it's a big deal but that that cogito air goes soon. I think I don't know Oh, it's just that's the name of the argument.
Okay, it's It has a ton of far-reaching implications It has far-reaching implications for the individual because we do have a sense of self We can think of things and if I ever want to prove to myself that I'm actually here All I have to do is try to think of something that I wasn't gonna think of and I know that sounds ridiculous But it's even like thinking about fate in general So we got this version of the world that is unfolding before your eyes and my eyes right now And all I have to do to change it from one version of the world that was gonna play all the way out to maybe a different one Is drop this little remote in front of me like I just did if I didn't that's an entirely different version of reality Well, who decided to drop that remote me because I thought of it And so I think therefore I am and I participate in this larger world this larger unfolding of reality Existence is something that gets cheapened with the word existential because we take that and we think of just like I'm angsty and I feel things inside but existence in and of itself is such a Fascinating line of thought to deeply explore both for our notion of self and for how our notion or awareness of self Affects our ability to understand what this whole proposition might be that proposition being existing Hey, this episode of not have questions is brought to you by HelloFresh It's America's number one meal kit delivery service you get fresh pre-measure ingredients and yes I'm reading this because they say it better than I do and mouth-watering seasonal recipes delivered right to your door So you can skip the grocery store and count on HelloFresh to make home cooking easy fun and affordable They have that really dialed that actually is a wonderful summary of the whole thing That's pretty much what they do the deal with HelloFresh is you get to learn how to cook It sounds like a little thing But it's not a little thing like the sauces are amazing the fact that you can take normal Ingredients that you would see like sesame oil or garlic or whatever and then you can do little chappity chop chop and then little sizzle sizzle And all of a sudden boom crazy sauce like it's amazing So I highly recommend it just for that reason alone you get to learn how to make cool things And it's made the not HelloFresh food that we eat at our house that much better because we know how to like do things in the kitchen now Well when you say crazy sauce that sounds like just an expression But I think you actually mean it like it's crazy how good it is and as a not stylish grill guy I mean I make stuff on the grill and it tastes fine I can handle my own business well enough to not starve to death if I'm home alone But prior to HelloFresh I really had no sense of what it would look like to make food taste better to do weird creative things that Dry out all kinds of flavor explosions and make it awesome It's just that wasn't in my realm of thought at all and now what I'm finding is that pretty much every meal I'm getting with HelloFresh and these are the kinds of I really seek out anyway They all have some kind of super unique creative sauce with ingredients and elements I never would have thought of and it's like I'm rediscovering food Yeah, it's crazy. So the way it works is you can well here Let me just do the promo code thing for you. So if you go to hellofresh.com slash in dq12 That's for no dumb questions in dq12 and use the code in dq12 you get 12 free meals including free shipping Yeah, they send you 12 food meal things to your house for free. It's pretty impressive So you do that but the cool part is you get to pick what you get They have over 27 meals that you get to choose from you can do the veggie option you can do the classic stuff All these different low calorie meals if you're interested in that craft burgers, whatever you get to choose the meals So you get to say, you know, I've never made like an Asian dish I'm gonna try that or I've never made whatever this is, you know, I don't even know how to say that But I'm gonna try it they send it to your house and you actually learn how to cook it So you become intimately familiar with like how the flavor comes to be it's amazing So anyway hellofresh.com slash in dq12 use the code in dq12 for 12 free meals including free shipping Yeah, I want to double down on that too If you haven't gone and looked at these recipes for a while and then you go back now the last time I looked Which was only a couple of weeks ago I was blown away by how comprehensive the coverage is Everything that I could think of or that I've ever heard of that is what people eat in terms of a palette or a food style or dietary Style they were all on there they've thought of everything and accommodated everything deliciously that anybody I've ever heard of is doing in terms of Dieter menus.
It's very very comprehensive and seems to be continually expanding And you do the math on it and it's cheaper than shopping at your local grocery store some smart company called Zagat Do you say Zagat or Zagat? How do you say that? I don't know why did you put me on the spot? I don't know these things.
I'm super sorry to embarrass you It's spelled C-A-T and it's one of those words that I see everywhere and it was afraid that one day I'd have to say out loud and now I have and I feel nothing but humiliation But what I know is that they did them out on it and they found hellofresh to be 28% cheaper Then just run into the local grocery store and 72% cheaper than going to a restaurant and the food is as we talked about spectacular So it's an awesome deal. Oh, yeah, absolutely and the cool thing is they send you the right amount of each ingredient So you're not feeling like your waste and stuff. It's a good deal totally recommend it hellofresh.com slash in dq12 use the code In dq12 at checkout 12 free meals including free shipping I just thought of why that is a got word throws me off so much because if I say the Z like an S It sounds like I'm talking about Bob's bag it or the big tie guy that you fight right before and bison and Street Fighter Yep, so got another one. I don't know so the take home here is twofold one I don't know how to say that and to hellofresh is really good and you get 12 free meals including free shipping Which is incredible you can get that by going to hellofresh.com slash ndq12 and then you use the code And dq12 so thanks hellofresh and thank you you for liking hellofresh And there's this big circle of symmetry and synergy that happens when you order this using that promo code absolutely.
Thank you very much But you're you're quickly running up into the whole free will thing and the you know Everything is determined for you already you're quickly running there and and you could say on the other side of that argument You can say yeah, but the chemicals aligned in your brain to you would have always dropped that remote in front of you because of the way the chemicals I mean that's the obvious But I don't know I feel like I have free will that's all I can say you know There's this discussion that goes on about free will or unconditional election in the faith circles and as it pertains to Christian notions of salvation You mean yeah, and you can spend a lot of time there And then there's this one verse in there somewhere that says make your calling an election sure Which seems to include both free will and election in the same verse and I'm like okay cool. I'm out on this discussion This is above me. I don't know anymore. So you know I will say this if Christianity didn't have that tension I would immediately dismiss it as a fraud How can you have even if the whole thing is a fraud still?
How can you have a system of beliefs where you have a supposedly completely unlimited divine character? There's nothing you know that that character doesn't know there's nothing you can think of that that character can't hasn't already thought of every possible outcome every possible past every possible Permutation of events that could move forward this unlimited deity within Christian religious philosophy has already thought of it And has always known it that deity is unlimited has never learned anything that deity has never improved It's a really mind-bending concept But in that particular religion you've got that deity hanging out with people like me and I definitely have problems and have learned things and don't know all the Things and I'm not unlimited in power and so it's kind of a necessary friction If you're gonna have a god character who knows absolutely everything and is unlimited in power and authority Interacting with chumps like me who are just around for a few decades and like read some books one time and tried real hard But don't know that much stuff. Yeah, but I mean if this infinite being can interact with all these people and knows all the outcomes And why did it choose the outcomes that involve pain Matt? I mean like clearly it's evil right?
It's either all powerful It's a cheap question. No, it's not really don't think that I think it's one of the most fair questions that the Odyssey that someone Counting the cost of what to make of religious claims of any type I think it's an Suffering is an incredibly fair question to ask and I think there are incredibly thoughtful responses to that and incredibly glib responses to that But look what's happening here. We start thinking about the afterlife and we cannot help but think about self family life death eternity God Determinism free will it just gets us into everything and I'm more than old enough to remember when that was an entirely spiritual conversation And now literally in the last two maybe three years that is starting to become a technological conversation That doesn't mean that the afterlife has conceived of for all of human history by all different kinds of expressions of religion is now out the window And the solution to human immortality is some sort of upload. I'm not being deterministic in this or being like oh well I guess now that I guess your science will have to handle this one No, but it's fascinating to see this place where it overlaps.
I mean really what is this this is your diagram? This is our Venn diagram Yeah, it's the realm of the spiritual the philosophical and the human overlapping with absolutely the ones and zeros of the digital sciences Well, I think I think the phrase digital afterlife first of all I haven't read any of the things you're talking about so I don't know the context in which you're referring to but I think Digital afterlife could mean how you organize your Digital life for after you're dead. It could have that meaning you know you could have that really close friend That's gonna delete all your search history for you, right? So you can manage all that stuff or you could take it a different way and I think this is what you're implying is some type of digital heaven Yeah, good.
What is that what you're referring to? Yeah, I remember in 1987 I got a clock radio for Christmas from my parents and I was only supposed to listen to the Christian radio station Oh Matt, but I didn't really yeah We're listening stations in Colorado like KVPI which rock to the Rockies really and there's also a little pop station out of Fort Collins And I would tune into that real quietly like under my sheets at night And I would listen I listen to pop and rock music because it was so much better than the Christian stuff and I You got like DC talk just yelling the words heavenbound again and again You can get that from the Christian bookstore in the late 80s or you can get Belinda Carlyle and well other great stuff and so I'm listening to everything I can get on the radio Just soak in this stuff in there's this one song by Belinda Carlyle that I love called heaven is a place on earth I'm like that sounds vaguely Christian my parents would probably be happy with that so I tried it on them It's like awesome bad kids at school told me about this song and I listen to it It sounded like maybe it was sort of Christian because it has heaven in it Yeah, really he's like well first of all I have some problems with your story young man and secondly well He was actually about it secondly heaven is not a place on earth heaven is a place in heaven It's different he tried to explain all of this really complicated abstract philosophy to me And I did not get it and then that was the conversation that caused him to be like hey Maybe we've been a little a little hard on you about the whole music thing like what if we listen music together and then we'll just we'll talk about it We're going straight to free bird and simple man. Absolutely. We did.
Yeah, and then and then that year my dad That was kind of fun Fun wrap drill that year my dad elected to go and teach at the school where I was going to school They needed a part-time music appreciation teacher and that conversation helped to cause him to decide that he would go and do that And as a result my dad was the guy who taught me decades of music including pop and rock and all that stuff But I remember that conversation about heaven is a place on earth and dad being like no That's not what we believe and then I remember working out at the gym in like 2015 the first year black mirror Came out and there's an episode called San Junipero and as the episode unfolds you start to realize oh these characters are their Uploads these are dead people are almost dead people and their uploads their sims whoa living out their afterlife in San Junipero, California I guess in the 80s maybe their vampires for a while I know it was ridiculous and the point is you can be whoever you want whatever gender you want You can have whatever body you want you can live however you want you can't even really actually hurt other people in this world So you can do it. I mean morality is a totally different thing now and the whole time I was like the black mirror the whole theme of all this is this is dark These are not good ideas But that was the one episode that kind of departed from the dark theme and left it a little ambiguous like would this be desirable? Or is this a problem? And then as I'm thinking about I'm like well into Carlisle song then the song that they played as they drove away on the beach at the end Was heaven's place on earth and that's stuck with me fast forward a couple years Amazon releases this show called upload the guy who did the office camera that he's named he put together this show and it's cute it's funny there's only one season I think we watched it and it dealt with some of the logistical problems with an upload society where your dead can be sent to reside in various levels of heaven and hell much like the medieval satirist Dante and Yeah, yeah on your levels of punishment suffering or bliss in the afterlife and it seemed like that middle dent in the conversation And maybe I just talked about that episode or those shows with the wrong person But then it gets into my algorithm and I start seeing stuff about this very famous author who I knew about before Ray Kurtzweil You've heard of him, right?
I've heard the name, but I don't know where you're going with this I don't know anything about him. He's a he was associated with Google for a long time. He's a futurist He wrote a bunch of books at the age of spiritual machines. I think is the most famous one Coincides with the matrix late 90s something like that I haven't read any of these books But I start here more and more people talk about his ideas for this concept of the transcendent human and a lot of the trans humanist movements Thought seems to correspond with Kurtzweil and then I'm like, well, is anybody doing this?
I just want to look so I go and I start looking to see where we actually at in this sci-fi conversation and dude people are actually Starting to try to offer this service What like you could pay money to upload you to a thing? Yes But we can't do it yet. So you're buying spots on a ship that has yet to sail But here's the thing so this one that I'm looking at this is in the MIT journal MIT technology review from a couple years back The headline here is a startup is pitching a mind uploading service that is quote 100% fatal and what they go on to describe is a California company I'm sorry. What did you say?
What 100% what 100% fatal it kills you? Okay, so what they are proposing now what they're apparently able to do I don't know where it's at at this point is some kind of very complex embalming process for the Brain but the brain has to be totally fresh and if they do it it does not upload you to anything But they think this is the preparation a brain would need to be resuscitated Unbricked to use the technology language far later down the road decades down the road a century down the road to take somebody who died Right at the front end of this anticipated technology and make it possible for them to be the earliest uploads to some hypothetical digital afterlife Down the road. Here's where it gets crazy. It looks like according to this MIT journal article The only kind of person you could do it on right now is somebody who's obviously terminally ill because the embalming process of the brain has to Happen while they are alive or in the process of dying So California has some end-of-life option act which this company is supposing would allow enough gray area for them to be able to actually do this on someone Where you out on that ethically?
Well This is complicated. This is very complicated. One thing that's interesting is I recently learned from a neighbor Who handles artificial insemination of different farm animals I learned about some of the things that they do in order to collect the semen from the stud animal And then they freeze it and so they can take that biological live thing They can slowly cool it down over this is this very specific cooling profile And then they can replace the water content in it with glycerol It's either glycerin or glycerol. I don't know the water content in the semen Yeah, I guess I don't know I don't know what I'm talking about dude.
I'm just I'm just going here This is what we were looking at sheep when we had this conversation and You know what I was like man, what's the deal with these? Oh, these are my studs, you know I sell their seed for whatever for stock And so if you do this just right and you freeze it just right these things can stay for an extended period of time What a year five years ten? I don't know. I don't know.
I'm doing such a risky Google right now trying to try to figure this out You better go in cognito there buddy. Why don't you just screen share for accountability? Yeah, I will gladly do that And so I'm sitting here. Oh host disabled police.
Oh, so long-term storage I don't know what long-term storage is but long story short I mean you can store this up for like six years is I'm sitting here looking at one academic paper and it says six years So we know it's at least that long, but I think it's way way way longer than that What's interesting when they revive the semen after a certain amount of time? It just starts wiggling again and starts doing his thing and what's interesting about this is if you think about a seed like a plant seed There are documented cases of plant seeds that have been stored and the pyramids for example And then scientists have been able to plant them and they're viable and just a plant seed to me is fascinating because it has all the genetic information To further the living being and it has the ability to go dormant for a certain amount of time And then if it's correctly stored and then quote I'm doing air quotes now If it's woken up or waken up whatever if it's revived in a certain way Germanation happens and all of a sudden you have a live plant again Yeah, and obviously everybody knows it does not do anything though to bring back the consciousness of the entity that produced the seed in the first place Yeah, and that's why because I love the idea of humanity going forward, but for over to I'd like to be there I mean I like us, but I also like me so I'd like for my mind to move forward to if we have an option to do that I mean I think that's how people think yeah proliferation of the species is very different than proliferation of my unique mind Yeah, I don't know. This is all super interesting to me, but I don't know where we're going with this I'm sitting here like reading things about freezing your pets See now apparently that's a service that the American dog breeders association offers or they're giving you information on how to do that There's a whole lot of information, but I don't know like a home kit for how to freeze your pet. No, you're pet seed I don't think it's a weird.
Yeah. Yeah, that that got weird and hurry, but yeah, it's just not where I'm out with my pet Yeah, I've seen have you seen people that will freeze dry their pets look It's they basically make a mummy out of their pet they're like oh, you know chuckles was so great And then they'll have their pet like curl up like it's taking an app and then they'll freeze dry and they'll just keep it in the corner Room you seen this stuff. I saw that I assume it was just taxiderm'd. Yeah, it is right there pet That's a thing well, that's what tax it's that's like a the ultimate form of taxidermy is free free drying It's a very expensive thing to have an animal freeze dried, but it's a thing people do it so is linen Taxiderm'd what well, I mean isn't lemon lemon's body propped up and on display or wasn't it for a really long time?
Oh, we're talking about like Soviet Union lemon. Yeah, that's the one. I don't know. I have no idea glad Yeah, I hadn't ever really thought about taxiderm'd a pet or taxiderm'd a person Yeah, obviously that's for the benefit of the people who would see it and remember the pet or the person or what the person stands Which brings up a good point like what is the point of this so-called digital afterlife?
It's yeah, is it for the people that persist after your death? I mean or is it the thing that you were just talking about? You know you're saying I want to be there too like is the point some type of self-centered like I want to persist I want it to be me, you know what I mean? Well that hinges on one very key technological question if such technology Okay, in a religious context do you is your understanding of Christianity your religion that upon death when you then encounter heaven and God Are you aware that you were a human and that you lived on earth and?
Aware of the context of earth or do you become a brand new thing with a fresh new consciousness? Well, I think I think your consciousness persists is the way I would say it like you you there is there's a continuation that occurs and In the afterlife you do have the ability to remember things that happened in this life I think the Christian understanding is that yes that the heart will go on Whereas here the bajillion dollar question is if you get uploaded is that you know I can't be you can it? No, it's the and I think it has something to do with where you think you exist Do you think you exist in the network that is your neurons or do you think you exist in this other thing? like the human soul where have you ever read the experiments they did back in the day which aren't crazy they say okay?
This person's on their death bed. I'm going to put their whole death bed on a scale and as they expire I'm going to see if how much the human soul weighs which which sounds silly, but it's not silly because I don't know I mean at some point really it does sound silly to me it doesn't sound silly to me it sounds like that was a person's like hey We got to know we got to know you know if there's some way not saying the results were conclusive You're saying it's a reasonable question for somebody to wonder about I think it's a reasonable thing to test I think it's a reasonable to test and I give you that yeah, and so that's that's interesting so Wherever you think you exist like do you think it's within these three dimensions? Do you think it's within another plane of existence like we only recently started to understand magnetic fields who only recently started to understand electricity? You know we're learning all kinds of stuff in crazy physics now But like I think there are other forces at work that we just don't know yet.
We just don't understand and I think that's okay We don't have all the answers I'm Henry for a minute physics would be more capable of talking about this But like when you start talking about the unified theory of the world in the standard model or whatever they call it these days I mean there's certain forces at work We understand that we have this many things that we know about and then there's these other things We don't know about which is why they expose on with such a big deal and I don't claim to understand any of that I'm a mechanical engineer if I can't put a wrench on top of it and turn it it's hard for me to understand I'm just a simple rocket science. You know what I mean I do know what you mean I mock you but I appreciate your humility and that you do understand the limitations in the narrowness of your field That said you're a real good thing and I like making your brain about this stuff the question Where do you exist? Where does Matt women exist? It's more than the physical.
I'm absolutely sure absolutely sure. I've known people that have lost appendages and It's not like a portion of their soul was gone. They continued to exist You know you've known people that have had portions of their brain removed. I know I know a guy in Atlanta I met him was talking to him.
He had a brain tumor. He had a significant portion of his brain removed I went and talked to him afterwards. I'm convinced is the same person. I'm convinced He had a little trouble with words, but I'm convinced it is the same person I can feel the same heart connection with him that I felt to begin with and I don't know how to explain it other than it's that That knitting of souls that occurs in human conversation I've had I had the full-on feel of that knitting of souls before his surgery and after his surgery and therefore I conclude that you know That's him and so that kind of leads me to think that he doesn't exist in the special arrangement of the neural network of the Synapses firing inside of his brain.
So where where does the person exist? I don't know I say that as if it's conclusive I mean I can't know that right, but that's just that's just where all the evidence is pointing me at the moment people have wondered this forever and One of the philosophical exercises has been around for ages instead of the test of time is the ship of Theseus question Have we talked about that? I'm familiar with concept. Yeah at what point isn't that the ship of Theseus anymore?
Refresh me on what it is just so I make sure I understand it super simple version imagine a ship that keeps on being repaired and fixed and parts were placed and Eventually after 60 years of being on the high seas literally every bit of that ship has been replaced at one point or another Is that still the same ship or is it now something entirely different? Likewise if a band has 15 different lineups over the course of a 30 or 40 year career cut now with them and members come and go Is it still that band eventually you know the only catalog they've learned from the previous iterations They it all fits together with the previous iterations is it still the band likewise if Every bit of my body save like tooth enamel and a couple other things get swapped out every night on middle school Somebody said it was like every seven years. I have no idea on that But let's say we were such a creature and that is how things work Am I still me every seven years and how so how often do brain cells regenerate replenish duplicate? I don't know but surely between the time you're a little little kid and you're an adult Overwhelmingly what is you is something physically different than what was you so the ship of Theseus thing is just an exploration of This question of essence that even goes beyond the self and into what makes anything an identifiable thing over time because as you brought up I think really smartly early on change is constant and so any version of a digital afterlife that didn't involve change would be death I mean that there is no life without change if you're not changing you're in a test tube Yeah, not even that you're it's over when change stops So this is meant to account for that truism that people all the way back millennia ago understood and that we understand now So where do I exist?
Well, I think the ship of Theseus exercise has something to say about that It cannot just be in my physical parts because I am more than that do my old physical parts teach my new physical parts stuff I mean I took my biology classes in high school and college. I understand that information gets replicated and passed along I get it But is that really a satisfactory and complete explanation for what makes a person a person? I don't think it is. I think essence is a real thing.
I think it transcends physicality or chemical things I think abstraction is real and I know lots of people think abstraction is not real It's an other thing But as soon as a thought has been thought that thought is real as soon as a thing has been imagined that thing is not entirely imagination anymore It's been giving some substance in the life of the mind and the abstract and the life of the mind are real The essence of a person is real and that just to take it one quick step further I see you have a question That's why I think people should be treated well And that's why I think slavery is bad and racism is bad and atrocities are bad is because I do think people are more than Bags of cells. I think there's something transcendent about them about us. Yeah, I agree that we're there's something transcendent But the brain is something that's so interesting here because I'm thinking back to the photographs on photography film You have a photograph you wanted me to look at look at this photograph No, I am thinking back to specific photographs and like the the memory is a physical thing So could you say well a memory is a physical arrangement inside the brain and much like the Saturn 5? Flight computer.
I know this took a really weird turn now I'm with you But when you access the memory on a Saturn 5 flight computer you have to read the memory and erase it and then rewrite it That's the way you access memory on that old-school core memory, which is physical ones and zeros So does your brain every time you access a memory? Are you erasing it and then rewriting it inside the mind and the reason? I'm thinking like that is because you know how your memory can distort over time. That's one Yes, interesting another thing that's interesting is I don't know if you've ever have a loved one that's that's had dementia It's a fascinating It's awful first of all, but the way it's heartbreaking it is and so you know There's a very close member of my family that has dementia right now, and it's my granny and when we're talking to granny It's like hey, you know today's a good day today's a bad day, and we'll talk about You know mom will say well, you know today We were talking about stuff that happened way back in the 50s and we're just going with that today You know it's just really weird place where there's an there's a memory that's replaying itself in her mind But how is it how is it happening and what's so interesting is granny can look at me and be like she'll swing her eyes And she's like okay look I know I'm having trouble remembering right now So so that awareness of I'm having a difficult time remembering it's almost like the moral law that was written in my mind back I don't know if that makes any sense at all, but the fact that granny knows her memory is betraying her Tells me that there's some difference between granny's memory and who she is Did that make any sense at all wow?
That's a great observation it takes me back to watching my grandmother walk through the same thing You know same exact language good days bad days My grandpa would go up there to the nursing home in Torrington Wyoming, and he was beloved there because of his philosophical ethical persuasion He'd never put it that way, but he was beloved there because he held an ethical philosophical persuasion that she was still her Absolutely that's still her she doesn't know who most people are she thinks max my grandpa or she did before she died She thought max was a younger version of himself who had a thing for that nurse and she'd get mad and worked up about stuff and Spout some pretty angry language that didn't sound anything like her she forget things But max my grandpa was absolutely convinced convicted that's still her and so he treated her with the dignity and the care and the Oathkeeping of a husband of 60 years at that point who believed that even though something physically broke about you You're still you as crazy man My dad came up to visit this week and my dad lives in Colorado I love up here in South Dakota And so he goes right through our old family stomping grounds of Eastern Wyoming We're dad grew up and he ran into some lady with a familiar name at a restaurant and asked where he knew her from and she quickly connected the dot She's like I was a nurse up there in the early 2000s at the nursing home and your your max Whitman's boy and I was like yep We all adored max Whitman then she went on to explain why and Without using sophisticated philosophy language what my dad relays it she went on to explain They adored him because they worked around people whose brains broke who physically broke and whether they ever discussed or not Their ongoing question is what makes a person a person and max had an answer it ain't hard She's still her full stop discussion over and it moved this lady It affected her and she remembered it and was 20 years after the fact ready to recall that and tell my dad how much she thought of His dad for how he responded to the question you just posed This episode of questions is sponsored by Raycon you go to by Raycon calm slash in DQ That gets you 15% off your order Matt How's your a constrain you phenomenal? I ran into somebody the other day who's like hey You know you do stuff on the internet like the stuff on the internet you say you have Raycon's do you have them? And I was like boom yes, I do because it's part of my everyday carry I was nice back up the claim Oh, they tried to call your bluff. That wasn't a bluff.
I've had that happen too. So my is like hey man Um they texted me they're like my little earbuds that I got on Amazon for like 20 bucks quit working I'm looking for some other stuff. Do you think I should get the and they set a brand? I was like dude, I don't know what to tell you I legitimately like Raycon.
I've been telling you this He's like oh, yeah, you do say that a lot, but do you mean it? I was like yes, I mean it I mean like I've run almost 200 miles this year for the four scum 500 and I've worn my Raycon's every time I've wore earbuds. So anyway, it's real. I don't know how to say it other than like I Legitimately like these they're good.
They say the way Raycon works is you put these little earbuds in this little I don't capsule I guess I would call it the term yes and that charges the earbuds And so they have a small battery on the earbuds themselves and a large battery in the little capsule You charge the capsule and then when you kind of put them back in their holder They charge themselves when you're not using them. So it's it's a great setup. I really like them So I highly recommend it you go to buy Raycon calm slash in the queue and get 15% off your order And that's Raycon spell phonetically as Romeo alpha Yankee Charlie Oscar November Raycon with an in at the end by the way the everyday E25s they now have a USB C connector on the charger, which is awesome. No, it's awesome.
No, it's great So I got dailin some so dailin the other day. He's like man, my earbuds died I was like day long are we okay? I'll do this and so got him some and then they came in and before I gave him to him I opened him up to see what they look like because I'm weird like that and they had the USB C connector And I love it and I'm gonna have to order myself some new ones now because I want that connector But I've a wait a second here. I want to make sure I'm tracking with you I am using those E55s all the time, but I also still have my old E25s, but those have the old what you call it micro USB They don't have the USB C.
Are you saying that the new E25s are also USB C now? Yeah, if you go to the website right now by Raycon calm slash in DQ that new E25 version has the USB C adapter It's exactly what I'm saying. Oh, oh, that's spectacular. That's the last thing.
I'm still holding on to the old adapter for brilliant Yeah, I'm just gonna make that upgrade next time I get those one the thing about earbuds is come on Using this for active stuff. That's part of the point Is it there so small and easy to drag around with you and they stay in your ear when you do active stuff? And as I've told you before I use the Raycons for hitting tennis balls on the tennis ball machine It's like 200 300 balls per bucket and I will hit four five buckets worth of balls That's a long time sitting there sweating profusely and banging away on tennis balls and Raycon does not officially say that they are impervious to my Disgusting ear sweat, but anecdotally I can say they are impervious to my disgusting ear sweat I have not burned through any of these using them as a workout earbud But I know a ton of people who have used lesser earbuds and they go through them left and right because they can't handle the sweat Raycons can Matt We don't stop we can talk about this look dude. I don't think talking about your ear sweat is gonna help sell the product That's supporting the podcast.
Well, I think it will I just don't think it's gonna work Look, I think you're a nice person. I really do mean that I think you're a good dad I think you're a good friend and I think you're dead wrong on this point because Everybody knows that you use earbuds for things that involve you producing disgusting your sweat Well, what the people want to know is will it wreck it if I use this while I do anything active? And what I'm trying to say is if I can't wreck it doing what I'm doing with sweat then you can't wreck it go to town I mean, but like there's so many happy things you could say like the fact that I have a little button on the side to pause things when you're Running I like that you could say all these like the fact that you get like what is it over six hours of play time? No 24 hours.
I don't know I'd have to read that but you can say all these happy things But no you go straight to that your whole sweat Yeah, you're funny thing though because if you if you have this really cool product that has neat buttons and feels nice When it's in the little capsule and it charges and it stays charged for a long time But the second you expose it to any kind of rigorous test like working out with earbuds in and then it gets destroyed then It doesn't matter what kind of features it has I've actually washed mine in the washing machine and they survived see that makes people think about clean Things oh, I like it did there that was good. Yeah, let me see if I can help with that too washing things is good Soap is good. I like fresh smells and also my revolting ear sweat can't break Raycon's great Now repeat the thing that people go to to get the discount and then and then we're out and that's how we do the ad yeah We're gonna buy Raycon calm slash and deque and you get 15% off and seriously I cannot seem to break these things and they sound great and they work great and I love them and I hope you give them a shot I Don't believe in a digital afterlife. That's where I'm at.
Yeah, I just don't I think our brains have the ability to contain memories I don't know how I think that we have the ability to access those memories and I feel like I am Something apart from my body and I feel like there is a level where they connect and I don't understand that But that's that's the sense that I have and that's the best I can do with that So I don't think I can take that part of me that doesn't seem to be in the physical world and put it in a Physical form that could be uploaded to anything. That's where I'm at. Where are you at? I wouldn't even say I'm conflicted about it.
It's just very very hard for me to think about it Because it overlaps into so many other areas of thought and ethics I'd be really interested my friend There was one company that I saw that was talking about well We would do a partial upload so you would be here in this world and there in the digital world and their ambition is to get to a place Technologically years and years from now where they can do this transitional period so that they can answer try to answer this exact question At what point does the bulk of you move over into the digital world to the point where you can vouch for you being you in that digital world? I read that article and I'm sorry. I don't have it in front of me to forward it to you and I thought How could you trust that vouch? How would you know if you weren't you and then of course you have to ask the self-reflexive question after that?
How would I know if I weren't me? Yeah, I would I know if I were an upload like even right now, you know I think therefore I am but am what that's where philosophy reason religion Sociology looking at other people comes in to provide some kind of philosophical ethical framework for thinking about that and for me I feel very defined in my faith and by the deity I believe is the first cause that I think I am made in the image of God flawed touched by the brokenness and frailty and entropy of existence and That the redemptive work of that God is in process and that at some point we will see the redemption that we read about in a really tangible way Yeah, I think it's where Jesus fits into equation I do think there's an afterlife and I would like to participate in it I would like to be a part of the transcendent I'd like to be there to see that I hope along with you that there's growth in that if there isn't I don't really understand why there's an after life I guess but the digital afterlife thing feels It conjures two emotions for me beyond what I just said one is dirty It feels like a cheap down dirty fast way to skip all of the difficult things about existence and hustle right to make me eternal Gross, it's always a bad guy in the movies that wants to harness technology to become eternal as a power unlimited power And that kind of ranting so something about it feels intuitively dirty to me But I understand that could be entirely because of my biases my faith whatever the other thing that I feel when this topic comes up is empathy Dying is scary people don't want to die people don't want people they love to die You have this poisoned well of conversation and disdain that we feel for each other and on the internet It's really easy to get super slap happy about who ought to die well I hope you I spout things off But my goodness is there anything more unifying amongst us as humans then for the most part of things are even going sort of okay We think living is pretty cool and we think it's pretty cool that other people get to be alive too And we think death is scary and feels unnatural and wrong it feels abrupt it feels too soon and it makes life feel bittersweet Everybody is grappling with that it informs so much And so I see this stuff and I understand how somebody could look at these kind of ideas and be like that is blasphemy and evil You're playing with fire Pandora's box. Maybe this is weird scary maybe dangerous stuff But I also look at the people who are throwing their energy at this and who are excited about something like this I'm like you know what we have something in common We understand that death is unnatural that it doesn't feel right that it's something that if we had the option to solve it We would want to solve it death isn't that and no? I don't think death is natural I think death is natural right now, but I don't think that death was part of the natural design for things in the first place I think that humans are transcendent I think that people are made in the image of God and there's something lasting about this that is far greater than the human body And so death is natural based on the ground rules.
We have right now But man there's a reason I think hardwired into our hearts that we kick and scream and fight and that we yearn Though we think we were made for something more than this everybody suspects we were made for something more than this Can I take a swing at that so I think death is natural, but you're advocating that we are supernatural And so like we as beings don't feel like we should be coupled to that natural thing that is death Is that the way to say that I think that's a perfectly fair take yeah, I think that's a good way to put that I think the natural is supernatural. I don't think there should be a natural world The fact that there is one just definitionally by merit of the word transcends the natural if there is a natural world That came from something that is beyond the natural world the natural couldn't make the natural itself So the fact that existence exists is supernatural Does me ever believe in my religion or my understanding of God, but this came from somewhere another thing I think about when people want to upload their consciousness to a hard drive or a server or whatever it is It's the desire to continue as we are now and I feel inhibited by this body Like I feel like I'm hungry sometimes and I feel like I'm angry sometimes when I don't want to be angry I feel like I have sexual desires. I do not want to have at times I feel all these things that are a part of this carnal body that I don't want And it would be really cool to shed that You ever read screw tape letters? Yeah, okay, so I'm I'm re listening to it I'm just in chapter four right now and he's talking about Screw tape letters as you know, it's about how to Tempt a person to send them off the rails so to speak and it's a fascinating book written from the perspective of a demon That's tempting a person a patient he calls the person and one of the most interesting uses of redirecting The the energy and thoughts of the human that he's trying to send off the rails is by making him hungry or making him fall victim To some of his the needs of his body.
I feel that and I think at some point I won't I Don't know what that looks like, but I don't know. It's a lot easier to say. Oh, you know death is like you remember what it was like Before you were born. It's just like that.
It's far easier to say that and just accept that but I don't know I just I feel like it's more than that. That's the problem It is a feeling and feelings are hard to prove I think there's a whole lot of hubris at times when we say well We we understand everything about the human mind and clearly this is a blah blah blah Understanding how something works doesn't mean that we understand how it came to be or all these sorts of things Anyway long story short science has limitations. I feel like I'm more than my body. Yeah well, all of that's really thoughtfully put and I Just try to remind myself as someone who tends to be pretty skeptical of things and as someone who likes data and likes to try to make Decision based on data.
I try to remind myself that we've always thought that whatever we think right now is the best thinking We ever did since the era of the scientific revolution and the enlightenment and it always turns out we were wrong and misunderstood things It's why we keep replacing our science textbooks because we actually have a ton to learn and we're very humble creatures And so we're doing a great job pooling together the resources of all of our minds But we don't know all the things we don't know all the things I have a theological answer for what I think makes a person a person I have an experiential answer for what I think makes a person a person I have a philosophical answer from some of the people I think have the best minds and all the history is what makes a person a person I have a legal answer for what I think makes a person a person and Why we should have laws that protect people and their property from other people and and ill intent they might have I've got all of these different categories I feel like I can repeat a good argument here, but I come back to what you just said, buddy It is also as uncomfortable as it is it comes down to a matter of essence at some level two a sense of hunch of feel and for that reason as alluring as the idea might be of jacking the back of my head into a machine and uploading everything into some idyllic garden of Eden like environment on some server somewhere I don't think that will be me and I don't think that will be other people I think that will be something that we do to feel better about death that ultimately will be unsatisfying I guess I'm open to being wrong, but that's my read on it right now