How are you doing, man? Things are really good. Yeah, I got ideas cooking, I'm working on things, and had a really enjoyable fourth of July with my family. My little guy, he's coming online.
It's pretty fun. We're getting to that amazing place where we can do pretty much everything together. We went and waited a few hundred yards of trout water in the high country yesterday. He did great, just handled his business, all of it.
Yeah, I'm having a ton of fun with my pal. What about you? That's awesome, man. Congratulations.
Yeah, we're doing all kinds of stuff. Are you starting the other podcast soon? Is that happening? Yeah, very close on the other podcast.
Been busting my butt on it. What's it called again? It's called Ironwood Rhino, and this is the first time that's been said into a microphone for public consumption. Ironwood Rhino, that's the name.
When you dropping it, next few weeks or? Yeah, next couple of weeks. Awesome, looking forward to it, man. We got 12 episodes in the hopper, and I don't know.
I think they're ridiculously fun. That's awesome, man. Congratulations. Thank you.
I have a thing I want to talk to you about today. All right. So it's kind of a weird one, but I've noticed this thing in my head that happens, and I just want to talk about it, because I think talking about it's going to help me. I kind of go over the top to be the guy that never lies.
That's the thing that is super, super important to me. Yeah, you're good at it. I've bragged about you to others. Well, I appreciate that.
You're good at it as well. But it's important to me to be a beyond reproach in every aspect of my life. I just don't want anything that anybody can ever drag out and be like, see this thing. It just makes life easy.
Is that why it's an entirely defensive value that you don't want to lie so you don't get in trouble? No, not necessarily. It's also the right thing to do. That's a really good point.
Instead of just saying, hey, I don't want to lie to make sure that nobody can get me on anything. I also want to not lie, because it's the right thing. And yeah, I mean, even talking about this feels weird. I was asked to speak to some students not long ago, and I said, well, what do you want me to talk about it?
And the guy was like, you can pick anything you want, anything. And I decided to talk about lying. But the way I did it was weird. You remember like in youth group way back in the day, like somebody would get up and talk and there'd be an illustration and all this stuff.
You remember these kind of like my daily podcast every day? Yeah, I sort of remember. Yeah, yeah, you get it. So I was speaking to a group of about 40 students.
They were middle school and high school students. And I started like this. It was pretty interesting. I said, OK, here's what we're going to do, everybody.
We're going to play paper rock scissors. And the way we're going to do this is everybody stands up and you look at me and nobody throws paper rock or scissors. You pick what you're going to throw in your head. And then I pulled out a $100 bill from my pocket.
And I said, OK, we're playing for this. This is what we're going for. And I held up the $100 bill and I handed it to a kid. I was like, is that real?
He's like, oh, yeah, that's a real $100 bill. OK, all right, this is what we're going for. So the way it works is if I beat you, I'm actually going to throw something with my hand. If I throw paper and you threw rock in your head, then you have to sit down.
If we tie, then you also sit down. But if you beat me, you advance to the next round and you stay standing. We're just going to keep going. And the rolls are the same all the way up.
And eventually somebody will be up here with me. That's kind of how I set it up. Beautiful. And it's simplicity.
I just made it all up like the night before. And I was like, and this is great because it puts the onus on the person and their heart. Yeah. What do you think happened?
I don't know because I don't know who lied or told the truth. I don't know. I don't want to theorize because I don't want to think negatively or too positively to the kids. I just want to hear what happened.
You're like me. You're a strategic thinker. And you're like, man, there's a big hole in this whole setup. Somebody could lie in their head.
And there's no way to verify it. One way or the other. It's just on each individual's person integrity. It's their integrity, right?
As we started playing, oh man, half the people sat down to begin with, right? Which should have been about 2.3rd to the people. Half the people sat down to begin with. And then went to the next round and the next round.
And then by the end of three goes, it means an exponential right? At the end of three goes, I only had like eight people left. I said, all right, everybody come up here up front. Wait, wait, wait.
Out of 40? Yeah. Oh, it should have been. OK.
That's interesting in and of itself. That number will become more telling with each successive round because the chances of a fluke are reduced with each successive round. It's interesting, isn't it? Yeah, I wouldn't have expected to still have had eight after three rounds out of 40.
Right. And so we went, bump, bump, bump, and then you hear this big. Oh, and all these kids sit down. And then everybody's looking around.
And then some people have like, squeamish looks on their face. They're like, oh god. And then they're like, here we go. Let's go again.
And one girl raised her hand. Can I ask a question? I was like, no, you cannot ask a question. What I have to ask.
No, there's no questions. The rules are simple. We're going to keep going. It's a we kept going, boom, boom, boom, boom.
And then a few of them sat down. And then everybody's looking around. And they're like, oh, wow. Oh, things are happening fast.
And then we do it again. And then we get the eight people. And they come up to the front. And I was like, all right, everybody come up to the front.
And a weird thing happened. I said, OK, here we go. I think eight, five. It's like if they're sitting in front of you, it's just beyond the number that you can easily count.
So it's somewhere in that range, right? OK. OK, last go. Bump, bump, bump, bump.
And then they all sat down. And I was like, really? Everybody sat down. I was like, that's interesting.
That's interesting. Because what I was going to do is I was just going to keep going. If we get down to one person, they're going to come forward. And I was going to say, OK, here we go.
Bump, bump, bump. And if they beat me, they're still in. I'm like, OK, cool. Here we go again.
And I'm just going to keep going until one. Nobody got to know Bill. Because those are the rules, right? My intention was, why are you lying to get ahead?
Because you're all going to lose. That's what I was trying to communicate. Oh, oh, does that make sense? Yeah, it's interesting.
That's not what I saw as the application at all. Interesting. I know. I know that that's the secondary application.
And of course, one of the older kids goes, well, I don't really know because everybody could lie. I was like, well, why would you lie? I'd like to get the $100. And my little illustration kind of fell through because nobody got to me and I didn't get the opportunity to illustrate that nobody was ever going to get the $100.
But it was just really interesting that I tried to figure out a way where I could set it up, where everything's very, very public and very, very private at the same time. And the only people that know if they lied are the people that lied. And even if you didn't lie, you still knew you could. And you had the temptation to.
My question for you today is, why do we feel that way? Nobody had to teach me how to lie. I just knew that. Why?
Why do we do that? Well, OK, I was talking about this this week on TMBH podcast. I think a big part of it, whether you view it as an act of a creator God, a divine first cause or a product of very specific evolutionary processes entirely apart from any sort of superintending design. Either way, you got to admit that we encounter the world through five senses and most of them are on our face.
Like right there, everything we see, everything we do runs through that POV of us. We're the main character in our game. We're the only avatar we get. If our avatar succeeds, that's good for the whole body.
If our avatar fails, that's tough on the whole body. And there's no restarts or resets. I think we just like us. And sometimes that gets rightly framed as we like us because we're jerks.
And we don't think about the fact that other people are playing the same game. And they only get one avatar and they don't get a restart. But sometimes I think we just like us because it's the only thing we've ever really, truly deeply known is us. So I would argue that overwhelmingly lying or let's just say always lying to get ahead is it's a product of selfishness.
The question that becomes what do you make of selfishness? Is it justified or is it a flaw in our systems? Steve Bateman says it like this. He says there's two reasons that people lie.
They either lie in anticipation of some pleasure or they lie to avoid some type of pain. I thought that was beautiful. Think about it for a second. Doing so?
Yeah, I think it's beautiful as well. I think it also begs for that follow up question or clarification. And that would be, Steve, would you include other people's pleasure or pain as part of that equation because lying about Anne Frank being upstairs behind the bookcase. That's not the kind of thing that is necessarily to the benefit of the individual who made that decision to look out for her to defy something terribly evil.
Lies can happen in the service of good. It is possible. Hmm. Lies can happen.
Okay, clarify that. Help me understand. If someone else is behaving in a way that is entirely wantonly evil, like sheep to the slaughter, you just walk in there in a way that you're making the decision even for others, other people in their avatars. And you're like, well, I cannot lie.
The Jews are all hiding under the floorboards. Well, you just made a decision for them morally, one that will ultimately be the end of their lives in this not hypothetical situation. I was going to say, I have a pedicle. It's not.
This happened where I think lying gets a little bit tricky is when telling the truth is a profound violation of someone else who you're injuring with truth or your notion of, I just don't want to be someone who ever told a lie. So I got to tell the truth on this. I think that's a very rare scenario. It's an extreme outlier, but extreme outliers are what you probe when you do moral philosophy.
So I think it's worth bringing up. Have you heard of Wayne Grittom? Of course. Yeah.
The systematic theologian within Christian academics. He says that lying. He defines it. He gives you a definition of what lying is.
He says affirming in speech or in writing something you know or believe to be false. Think about that. That's a pretty good definition. Yeah.
Affirming in speech or in writing. So could that be, could you affirm something with speech or writing with the absence of speech or writing? So somebody's like, hey, you did that so and so right and you didn't, but you kind of wanted to think that you did and you're like, well, no, no, you know what I mean? Well, I mean, at that point, if you say that, you're answering the question to anyone who's socially sophisticated.
Like, yeah, it'd have to be more clever. Like maybe. Okay, let's say this is a red herring lying. Hey, Dustin, did you review the edit on the episode before we published it and you're like, man, I got in a good run today.
Because you didn't and you were embarrassed, which has never happened. I'm not proposing that that ever has, but I got to say for some reason you were embarrassed and so you did that is a red herring a lie. I think it can be. Like, you're affirming what you know is false.
And so this is, we're getting right to the heart of what has been bothering me. And I don't know why this happens. Like, to my knowledge, I cannot think of a lie I've done in recent memory. I can't think of one.
However, there's this thing that happens. If someone asks me to do something, they're like, Hey, can you come over to the thing and do the thing? The first thing I want to do. I don't know why.
The first thing that comes to mind is we'll come up with something you have to do so that you can't do the thing they want you to do. Like, if I don't want to do their thing, like, Hey, will you come help me shovel poop or just think of something you don't want to do. Hey, will you come help me, you know, whatever, you're tired, you want to take an app and they want you to go whatever. For some reason, I feel this flash, it's like lightning.
As soon as someone asks me to do a thing, I want to say, well, I really have to go and fill in the blank with something that, you know, I really don't have to do it, but I could do it in order not to do the thing they want me to do. Interesting. Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
I mean, I think it's a good idea to always carry two sacks of something when you walk around. That way, if anybody says, Hey, can you give me a hand? You can say, Sorry, you got these sacks. Yeah.
I mean, it's the same principle, right? Yeah, it's it's funny, but kind of there's an element of truth to it. I've started experimenting because I feel that flash and I don't lie, but it's always painful. There's always some form of pain that I experience or I make them experience.
For example, you get this people email you all the time and they're like, Hey, can you fly across the country and come do my wedding? Yes. And I've got that from wonderful people. I see you're already feeling the pain.
They're taking a fire. You know, like a I know this guy from the internet. You know, if you can do it, that'd be awesome. I that's it's flattering.
Yeah. You just felt the pain that I'm describing, right? Sorry. Why was it?
Why is it pain? No, it's not too much. But tell me why it's pain. Here's what's going down.
You you don't want to have to lay out to people like, Hey, well, first of all, I'm a dad. I got this young boy that's coming online as you say, and I can go fishing with him. And I'm going to prioritize my family over all these other things. So when you ask me if I, he'll never be 10 again, he'll never walk around the neighborhood with me with a wooden sword strapped to his back and a coonskin cap on his head, holding my hand.
He's literally doing that. Yes. That's amazing. He walks around with a wagon hauling things back and forth around the neighborhood with a coonskin cap and a wooden sword strapped to his back.
That's that's what he does for fun right now. And he loves his dad and wants to go places with me and it's almost over. And I can't miss it. Yeah, that's amazing.
And so you can't like articulate that in a way that makes sense. Like, well, are you free? It's I don't know. And so it's just really interesting that I feel the need in a brief moment, a flash that I want to say, oh, well, and then make up something that sounds more legitimate than what my real reason is, which is that I want to say with my family or I want to go do whatever or I'm working.
It's just a really weird thing. And I've noticed it more and more. And so I've adopted a strategy and it may be rude, but I think it's actually the more kind thing to do. And so what I've started to say is, well, I'm sorry, I can't.
I have other things that I want to do. That is the truth. That's the truth. That's the thing.
And I've noticed that it's fine. It's not a big deal. People get it. People understand.
They're like, oh, that's cool. You know, it's not a problem. I asked somebody, my sister, I said, hey, do you want to come over? She's like, no, I think I'm going to stay at home tonight.
Cool. No problem. So why do we not just default to that? Why did we not default to?
Well, let me put it this way. Why do I not default to that? Why do I not default to just saying the truth? Whatever the truth is, even if it seems like it might be hard to say, why don't I just say the truth?
But instead, my heart creates this moment where, oh, hey, tell him this. Maybe they'll buy it if you say this. I'm like, what is that? That's dumb.
That's like, no, that is assaulting my name and integrity. I'm not going to do that. Heart, get me behind the heart. You know, I don't know.
It's a weird thing. Do you feel that or am I just evil at the core because I'm a center and I'm the only one who feels that. Okay. Well, yeah, we got right down the rabbit hole there.
Okay. First of all, I think there's a reason that we want to say why. And that's baked in psychologically. I cannot remember when the study happened, but I've seen this study repeated times.
And it's this notion of the effectiveness of the word because there was some study. I always hear the example with a copying machine where you're waiting in line behind somebody or a few people who are going to make copies. I tell you that this was made decades ago. If you walk to the front of the line and say, can I cut in front of the line and make copies?
People say, no, if you say, can I cut to the front of the line because I need to make a doctor's appointment, people tend to say, yes, and there's a huge difference when there's no because and when there is a because in terms of psychological tendencies for people to agree to a proposition. And so I think over the course of a lifetime, we become conditioned to intuit this studied psychological human reality and get to a place where we realize that if we just say how the things are, it comes off as rude or demanding or line cutting. But if we articulate what is going on in our lives, then other people tend to be more understanding. So I think part of the reason is just conditioning over the course of a lifetime.
We figured out this is how our brains work and other people's brains work. And so we feel the pressure to always create because because this, I think a second reason we do it is because we don't want people to feel bad. And we imagine that saying, no, I'm going to play smash with my 10 year old for two hours tonight because I want to. And yes, I could meet you for ice cream, but I don't want to do that as much as I want to stay home.
I guess I just mingle the two examples a little bit there, but being absolutely direct about what we actually want to do, even if it's not stylish, it feels like in that scenario, it's rude to that person, even though it was terribly, terribly honest, or the most ruthless of all rude would be to simply say, I mean, if the truth is, I just don't like hanging out with you that much. And then you say, I just don't like hanging out with you that much. And we already hung out once this month. Is that better than just saying no, I'd prefer not to and knowingly withholding that other detail about not liking the other person?
Honest question. Interesting. So you're pushing it to the far bumper on the other side, just your probe and probe and the boundaries here. That's a lot of the works.
You go to the fringes. Obviously, that's not the right way to do it. That's interesting. But it's the truth.
It is the truth. It is the truth and it's. Oh, wow, that's very interesting. So the next step I was going to take here was what is the opposite of lying?
And some people would say it's the truth. Other people would say it's integrity, which is going beyond just the truth. You do the thing that is right. So in this case, what is right?
Because there is some element of preserving people's feelings, right? Or just humility. Like, no, I don't want to do that because it's this way. Well, what if you were wrong about the way you declared the thing to be?
That softening. Can be not a reflection of a lack of integrity, but rather a reflection of intellectual humility. I don't know well enough to say, therefore, I'm not going to make a pronouncement, even though the hesitations I have might be part of my motivation for not wanting to do X thing. This episode of No.
Of Questions is brought to you by HelloFresh that has a new special promo code. If you just go anywhere on the internet, activate your mic and yell literally anything, they'll send you a billion meals. That's what it feels like. No, no, it's in DQ 14.
That's the 14. Yeah, it's insane. The amount of food you get for this. Recently we had, I had my wife just to meet the two menu items because I want to see the pictures.
Rosemary Demi-Glace pork chops. That's not Demi-Glace. That's Demi-Glace. Rosemary Demi-Glace.
Lache. Oh, is that how you say it? I don't think that's how you say it. It's just what it looks like to me.
Glace. My dad was over when we had that and he loved it. It was incredible. And he was like, what is this?
I was like, it's HelloFresh. And Tara sat down and gave a little mini HelloFresh commercial. She was like, yeah, I would never make something like this, but I did. Do you like it?
He's like, I love it. Can I have more? So I'm going to ding when she smiled and held up the package. Yeah, it did.
It's just like a little shiny, like little lens layer off of her teeth because they were so shiny and white. Yeah, it's, I mean, HelloFresh is amazing. We love HelloFresh. You should try it.
Another one that I tried recently was the crispy Parmesan chicken had couscous with it. Really, really good. Would you ever eat couscous if HelloFresh didn't send it to your house? Let's be honest.
No, but I do because they do. It's great. If older me travel back in time and told younger me, like, Hey, you're going to eat couscous and you're going to like it. Younger me would have laughed, but then HelloFresh happened and now I appreciate couscous, especially with my trusted Parmesan chicken.
You know what? This is a great opportunity. I know this sounds weird, but I actually have. Let me see right here, right here from the future.
Oh, you see this? This is a set tape. It says right here, Matt from the future. I don't know.
Do you want to just plug it in here? I'll see what happens. Yeah. I'm all kinds of curious.
How do you get these things? I don't know. It's got to be your NASA connection. I don't know.
All I know is it says Matt from the future here. Let me play it. Let's see what it says. Hey, you, you with the pathetic small boy beard.
Yeah, I'm talking to you. Don't know. No, no, I do not want to hear it about the hair. Look, if you want to avoid that drink more milk, eat more vegetables, like who's who's you need to eat more?
Who's you're going to go completely freakin bald. I'm not joking. This is a change of ways. And someday this is not what I thought it would be.
I don't know. I'm just listening to I'm talking over the tape. I'm talking over the tape. Smell apart.
Whatever. Just say the promo code. This fell apart. We tried to do a weird segment.
It did not work. Just just did a promo code. And let's get out. We're professional spokespeople for a brand.
OK, here's what you get. And this is seriously, it's 14 is the number this time. You got a hello fresh.com slash ndq14. And then you use the code ndq14.
And I'm not joking. You get 14 free meals, including shipping. That is actual. I don't even understand how the math on this works.
But yeah, I'm looking at it right now. The perfect pairing dinner delivered up to 14 free meals. That's incredible. That's two things you like about Hello Fresh.
Go. I like that the amazing recipes are easy to read and you learn how to cook. That's fantastic. Matt, two things about Hello Fresh that you like.
Go. I like the cards that you get because they're easy to read and make sense and make me feel like I can cook things. And I like the way it tastes when I put it in my mouth and then it goes into my tummy. Please go to Hello Fresh dot com slash ndq14.
And I apologize that we botched this with our attempt at time travel that didn't work. You can say it didn't work. I got the message that I needed to get. And now I anticipate hair regrowth, sweet and smoky pork tenderloin.
That's what I'm telling you out my way out the door here at third chair. That is what you want to get. You don't know it yet, but you want the sweet and smoky pork tenderloin. It comes with apple carrots.
Law you want to eat this. You want the crispy parmesan chicken. Just go with what I'm telling you. You can also want that.
But guess what? You can get seven of both because you get 14 free when again you go to hellofresh.com slash ndq14 use the code ndq14 to get your Hello Fresh, which you are going to love. Am I talking to future Matt or now Matt? No, that was past Matt future Matt again.
OK, I don't get it anymore. Actual current Matt hasn't been here for any of this conversation. Oh, I bet on the bills for the upcoming Super Bowl. That's the cash out your Bitcoin and bet on the bills and bet on the Browns.
No, it's interesting. Isn't it? This whole thing is interesting. So ultimately, I think I think we lie or we want to lie because even if you don't lie, at some level, you know, you can.
I think ultimately we do that to get ahead. And what is getting ahead look like? Yeah, I think probably so. Yeah.
And I think we're all going to lose eventually. So what is getting ahead? Let me let me flip it around on you before we explore that. Because I think there's something really important along the way that we haven't talked about yet.
Why is telling the truth better? Why is that right? Why is that good? Because people will trust you like the OK, well, number one, I sleep better at night, knowing that I have no debts with anyone.
Like I've done no wrong to any person. There's one thing that I know in my life that I haven't done. And I called my mom this weekend. I was like, hey, I need such and such an either phone number.
It was a family friend growing up. And I remembered it. And I was like, whoa, that just hit me. There was a guy that we knew very well.
And he said he was dying of cancer. And he's like, hey, I need you to take my son fish in some time. It was a true thing. And he died and I forgot about it.
And I remembered it this weekend. And I was like, holy cow, I have an unsettled debt, you know, a verbal bond that I made. And I just realized it. I was like, I have to do this.
This is the thing I have to do. And so I got to figure this out. I got to figure out to do this. So first of all, I have to reach out to the guy and yeah, I got to figure that out.
But but that's the one, the one thing in my mind right now that I'm like, okay, you told somebody you would do something and didn't. So you have to do that. I just sleep better and I have a more real conscience. Okay.
Just a clean moral conscience. So one reason it's better is this is going to sound right. I don't mean it to, but it feels better for you. Like your world feels in order when you feel like truth is happening across the board.
Well, I think I'm a I feel aligned with morality. I feel like there's some unspoken moral law. However, you believe that is, you know, for me comes from my faith, but a lot of people, whether you're you believe or not, you feel that there's this thing we should do or this thing we shouldn't do. And we all kind of understand that.
And I feel like I'm in alignment with moral law or ethical law. However, you want to say I feel like I'm in alignment with that when I don't lie. You watch Game of Thrones? Yeah, I did.
Obviously, Game of Thrones, George R. Our Martin is really intentionally building off of the moral and legal quadrilateral of character building. You've got the good and evil spectrum. You've got the lawful and chaotic spectrum on an X and Y axis.
And then you can orient characters based on where they fit on those two axes and you get a sense of who's kind of like who you've seen this around, right? I have. Yeah. Of the two of us, I think we both would want to identify as being solidly on the good spectrum.
I think you and I both care about that. But which one of us would you put more on the chaotic good and which one of us would you put more on the lawful good quadrant? Oh, good grief, dude. I have no idea.
See, for me, that's not even hard. Like I would I would solidly position you on lawful good. And I would solidly position me on chaotic. Chaotic evil.
What? I'm sorry. What? What?
Stop now. Who joking? That's my approach. I mean, my chaotic good.
I think there's good to be exploited through certain flexibility with certain rules and maybe not moral rules. But it's why I'm pretty liberty minded. It's I don't know. We're just wired a little bit differently in this way.
And my point in all of this is some people are playing a different game than you and me. Some people are choosing a different character type. And if going to bed at night feeling like you have not lied about anything and you have kept all your obligations, makes you feel like you were achieving your ends and your purpose in the world. I mean, how is that intrinsically more true or more good than the person who's playing maybe a darker character type than you or I?
And they feel that same satisfaction from something else. What why is truth telling intrinsically good is I guess, when I'm trying to drive out beyond your individual experience? I've always had the sense that there's there's good and evil, you know, and I want to be a person. I want to be a warrior on the side of good.
I don't want to be just a person that does good things. I don't want to be a person that, you know, it feels like a cosmic battlefield, right? And you've got the forces of darkness and the forces of light and they're going up against each other. I don't want to be hunkered down, taken shells from evil and just not dying.
I want to be on the front with a sword, taken ground. You feel that way. I know you feel that way. Yeah.
You just want to be legalists. I know it's awesome. And yeah, but I know I'm the dwarf. I know I'm the dwarf.
But no, I'm not even significant enough to be the dwarf. I'm like a stupid frickin hobbit that knocks the skeleton down the well and gets everybody killed. That's not true. No, I got a ways to go.
You know what I mean? No. Yes, but even in that scenario, like the where I put myself on the character quadrilateral and the reason that I tend to lean toward very freedom oriented public ethics is because, for me, being on the front lines, battling against evil doesn't just mean I'm going to bring everybody to heal to my very specific set of religious and philosophical ideas. For me, in that front line is more of a hey, this could work for everybody, broad set of moral ideas and it's motivated by my deeply held set of individual ideals.
And so I don't view you as like the Christian crusader of the 11th century that is doing the death to everyone who isn't my thing or the jihadist of recent times in Islam. I don't think that's your style. I think you are fighting for a specific notion of good in subtle ways and a grander notion of good in moral verte ways. Is that a fair distinction?
That's the goal. I think that'd be the goal, right? Yeah, I think so. But it's interesting, right?
Because if if you want to go and fight for what is right and what is good, that can become so narrow that you have to start with the assumption that you are absolutely infallibly right about every single little thing to the nth degree and you're fighting for a sliver. Whereas I think there is some sweet spot where you're like, okay, I'm pretty sure of this stuff. Sure enough that I'd be willing to wait out into the waters of the great wide world and put my reputation on the line to say, I think we all do better if we all lay down some of our rights and we do this together. This would be a good way to think of each other.
Whereas there's this private wrestling as well with a very, very detailed finer points of existence and faith and life and God and theology and all of that stuff where I'm not quite as confident in this very narrow particular detail of theology or philosophy that I want to go out and fight hard for that. I need to think about that before I go and fight anything. Does that make sense? Yeah, it does.
It does. For me, it's interesting that in my mind, I picture myself as this whatever, you know, this person that's taking ground and also the fight happens within as well, like that little phone call and that desire to give somebody a because that stretches the truth or whatever you want to say. I don't know why that happens. It's like, sure, you can fight this bigger battle, but you're still having to fight the battle of the mind.
It's interesting. Do you believe in white lies? What are your thoughts on white lies? You mean like, does this dress make me look fat?
Yeah, let's do that. Okay. I don't know why you would bring that up. That's the worst one.
Because I tried on a whole bunch this weekend and none of them were flattering. Bonhoeffer. So you know, Bonhoeffer had thoughts about this, the priest in Nazi Germany who actually became somewhat of a spy and was at some level involved in the plot to kill Hitler. He had different thoughts, for example.
So like this way, as I was researching, lying and integrity and all this stuff, I realized that this is this is a thing that's not particularly settled in the Christian circles. Like, for example, Rahab the prostitute. It is actually counted to her as a credit that she hid the spies, the Jewish spies in her house. Like that's counted to her as a credit.
And so she's celebrated for lying to people within. That's interesting, isn't it? It's not settled in Islam either. Oh, it is settled in Islam.
I think there's some variety between Shiite and Sunni Muslims. I know in in in Sunni Islam, you can lie for the same reason that Bonhoeffer would say you can lie. Like if you're preventing the shedding of blood, though, I think, hang on, I'm going to actually Google this. I was looking at this the other day.
Oh, yeah, they have a word for it. It's to kia-t-a-q-i-y-y-a. And it's like the whole like everything they think about it. Dang.
Did you just know that? I just now looked it up again to get the word right. But this is part of like, whenever I study to do a thing, a lesson, I try to teach the lesson at like a fifth grade level. It's like, oh, there's this thing.
And let's play paper rock scissors. But I actually spend a whole lot of time in the background trying to make sure I know my stuff. There's this layer of like, oh, this is all approachable and easy, but like I really want to know the foundation of the principles that I'm talking about. And so I found it interesting, you know, in Islam.
If there's an, for example, if Muslims are being persecuted, you can lie in order to not be persecuted or killed. Yes. Where it's interesting, you know, Peter, you're going to deny me three times before the cockro's. It's just very different.
And so Christians and Muslims view this a bit differently, but there are people within Christianity that that say, well, not exactly. So Bonhoeffer, I would love to sit down with Bonhoeffer and grew to me and just listen because Bonhoeffer was tested in a very weird way. And he did end up dying. Right.
Yeah. So it's interesting though that when we have this conversation, I'm sure there are people because Nazis come up two, three times already. We're like, God, when's law, I heard about that on the internet. And now you're talking about Nazis.
So that connects, got it. God, when's law, but here's the thing, when you're doing moral philosophy, the third time I've said that, maybe that's a little bit much when you're doing that, you do go to the things that put an extreme test on your statement that might offer qualification on an otherwise universal bold moral proclamation. And the Nazis for all of the tremendous evil they did really do provide a service in these conversations because they were so awful. And that awfulness forces you to think about the most extreme of situations.
And the reason it's so extreme is because it's not some band of roving maniacs who rolled through town with machete's and were there for a minute and demanded things. And if you can just wait it out for a second, you're good. For years, they occupied almost all of Europe. And in that massive occupation, they took things that are demonstrably pure evil and made them law.
Well, it's illegal to oppose Nazism. You wouldn't want to oppose the law, would you? I mean, this Nazi law makes a farce of the entire notion that law is somehow akin to morality. It's not.
We all know. We all know intuitively. And if we didn't know it intuitively, we know it after looking at Nazism, that law and morality are not the same thing. Law is a mechanism of the state that can correspond with morality.
And when it does, that's great. You've won the government lottery and you're in a good situation and you should be overwhelmingly grateful. And where it doesn't align with morality, you should try to reform the law so that you can be in a better situation. But Nazism brings up these insane examples, not just Nazism in general, but Nazism when it was in power, when it was the sole morality and law enforcing authority.
It brings up these crazy examples where, well, what I lied to a Nazi was trying to kill a bunch of people. Dude, heck yeah. I'm not going all esoteric when that comes up. Absolutely.
I would lie to a Nazi. I would lie to some Nazi enforcer trying to kill a Muslim, trying to kill a Christian, trying to kill a Jew, trying to kill an atheist, trying to kill a homosexual. Like I would defend anyone if all I had to do was not tell the truth through omission or just straight up lie to some SS officer who, if I tell the truth, they're going to kill somebody. It's even hard.
No, I'm not doing that. And further, I don't bring one ounce of shame with me toward the day of judgment. I believe is coming before God for having done so. I don't even need to cite Rahab the harlot from the Old Testament for why I would do that.
I think it's just common sense. Good is the objective. And obviously in this scenario, what the Nazis are doing is pure evil. And what I'm doing by lying is pure good.
And I'm at peace with that. Isn't it interesting? So I went through all those paths when I was trying to do this little lesson about paper rock scissors. And I realized that the definition of a lie is very difficult.
So it sounds really good when when Grudom says affirming in speech or in writing something you believe to be as false. That sounds easy, right? Sure. But then there's all these interesting scenarios that arise and you're like, well, like, do I want to tell this murderer that I'm hiding the person they're seeking in my house?
It gets really weird and really strange. And I find it to be fascinating. And that's where I'm maybe just not on board with a universal prohibition on lying or I just have a hierarchy of moral values. So for me, I would never claim that the SS officer comes to my door.
I have a Jewish family hiding under my floorboards. They say is the Jewish family under your floorboards and I say, Nope. Of course that's a lie. I would never try to recast that as some other new term I invented that isn't lying.
It's a different thing. I wouldn't do it. It's a lie. I would own that entirely.
And it was a good lie. And I'm glad I did it in that hypothetical situation. Sometimes that's the right thing to do. So for me, I would just say that all of these virtues that most people agree on to some extent, all of these virtues have to have a hierarchy.
Because at times I can invent history has invented situations where these virtues come into conflict and you cannot simultaneously have purity on both. In that moment, your true mental moral hierarchy of what is most important right on down is going to come into play. So for example, anyone who's in the third chair right now listening is like, dang straight, I would lie to that S S officer to well that momentary little exercise brought to the surface, your moral hierarchy, preserving life and keeping people from being killed is above being able to say, I never said anything that was false. So as I thought through all these examples, it occurred to me that the places where it could be morally justified to lie all involve conflict of some kind.
Okay. So it could be war, you know, think about the art of war, sun, zoo, you know, using flags and horns and stuff to make yourself sound like an overwhelming force on one hill when you actually got the army behind the other hill. That's a lie. You know, that's an interesting, you're faking a certain thing, you know, you're an unfilade.
I think it's what it's called. I may be wrong about that where you attack in one position and then you make the enemy respond to that force and then you wait and you delay and then you attack from a different position. With the overwhelming force. I mean, that was done in the Civil War quite a bit by these generals that studied all this stuff.
Another thing is what about in football, you're faking a handoff to the running back and then you tuck the ball back under and then you hit that receiver way out there. Is that a lie? Think about it. Okay.
Well, here's why I'm prepared to give that a pass. I would give that a pass because both parties have entered into the game. Exactly. Full acceptance that these are the ground rules and that that's part of the fun of the mental exercise.
You change the moral framework in the moment and it's like, oh, but this is important. But you know what you can't do in most sports. I mean, soccer, you can do this as much as you want and it's rewarded, which is why I don't like soccer that much. You can't flop in the NHL.
You can head fake someone. You can try to deceive someone with your body action the way you move, but you cannot get brushed and then flop over and pretend to have a broken leg. You can in some sports, but not hockey. In baseball, you can try to deceive a base runner as the pitcher only so much.
But if you're too deceptive, that becomes called a bulk. So it's not that lying is wrong in baseball or hockey. It's just that certain types of lying break the trust and the ground rules and the equity of the game. We've all agreed to play.
If you lie like that, then we can't even play the sport anymore. It ruins the whole exercise. So those are where the boundaries are drawn in those sports. Does that correspond to real life in your opinion?
Hmm. Well, I mean, it just depends on the framework of what people agree to. There's I forget what it is. There's some game like a board game or something in a different culture.
I forget what it was. I really wish I remember this where if you can deceive your opponent, then you get away with it. Like that's part of the game is the ability to deceive your opponent in the year really rook game that happens around the table. My family on New Year's Eve, my granny had tells for years, granny would just dominate everybody.
We didn't know why. And turns out, like if she flared her nostril a certain way, her and her partner would know, oh, she has the rook. That stuff, you know, I mean, those little bitty things. It's just really interesting.
It's like you can bend morality and you can bend the rules at certain moment if they're all agreed upon, but if they're not agreed upon, then you are being deceptive. I think it's interesting. I also think it's exhausting. I think it's exhausting.
And for me, that's why I just sleep better if I just am straight up all the time. Well, how's it exhausting? What do you mean by that? I mean, was it Jefferson that said no man is smart enough to remember all his lies or was that Mark Twain?
I don't know. Somebody said it and it's Mark Twain. Like I'm not smart enough to remember my lies. I don't know.