I've noticed you make a lot of things on the internet. Yes, I've noticed you make a lot of things on the internet. Another thing I've noticed is every time you make something on the internet, people have a tendency to write comments about the things you make. I again, I've noticed the same thing about much of your content.
This idea was your suggestion, this topic, and I think it's genius. And it's it's comments on the internet, like who is making the comments and like, what's the motivation? Like who are the people doing this? And I think it's a genius topic that I'd love to talk about.
Thanks. Yeah. And I'm curious to think about how it affects us and what it says about us. And I want to sociologize it a little bit.
We have a buddy right now that is dealing with this. I would say in a much more powerful way than we are. Yes. Yeah, he is.
So his name is Barnaby Dixon and Barnaby did a really interesting thing. He makes amazing videos involving puppets and we'll talk more about that later. But Barnaby made a video about a controversial topic. I've got to say this about myself.
I try to avoid controversial topics on the internet. There's something that's intentionally divisive. I say intentionally because a lot of people have motivations to make certain topics divisive. If I view a topic like that, I avoid it because I'm like, you know, I just don't I just don't want to divide people.
But Barnaby waited out into it, didn't he? Boy, did he? Yeah, it is a tricky topic that he chose to tackle. And he surely had to know that the comment section was going to be fascinating.
And that the comment section would involve some pretty serious heat and some pretty serious pushback given the topic that he chose to address and the way he chose to address it. Well, what's the question? I'm going to push back on you a little bit because I don't think he actually addresses the topic. He just invites another person to the table that has a differing opinion than what I would call the mainstream opinion.
Yes. You know what? That's a very fair re-characterization. Your description is the superior of the two.
But yeah, I like the idea of him Barnaby jump on because rather than you and me trying to recall comment storms that we've had from years past, we've got a mutual friend here who's going through it right now and it's fresh and it's raw and he'll no doubt have very honest thoughts on the thing. Yeah. Yeah. So should we just get him on?
Let's do it. Barnaby's here, Matt. This is, I mean, you watched this video. Very interesting.
Like, how do we want to do this? Well, first of all, hi Barnaby, it's good to see you again, man. And we said, hey, in person, and an event and shot back and forth a couple of times on the internet sense. And that's right.
Well, first of all, just for people who don't totally know, your talent level is one off the charts and two ridiculously weird. They had, they invented a genre for me. I didn't know that there was hand puppet design and execution, like as an artistic category. And that's been, that's been very eye opening and very fun.
And I've got to see you do that in person. And for people who aren't familiar with your work, it's just going to sound head scratching weird until you go and see it. It what it does though that I think is brilliant. Like when I first met you and we were sitting at the table with a whole bunch of other internet people and you pull out this little bird and you cram your fingers into its legs and its head and you announce it as a name.
Stap check. I'm like, oh, well, that name sticks to me. I like him immediately. And this is going to sound mean, dude.
I'm going to ask for your grace in advance. But I was like, oh, no, this is like when somebody's like, I've got a joke and everybody gets uncomfortable because they're like, I have to act like this is good. And I thought, oh, no, he's doing puppet stuff. This is like my, oh, okay, I need to act like this is good.
And then it was incredible. And no, I was required and I was immediately humbled by how just amazingly inventive the whole thing was. But then I didn't even understand the tip of the iceberg of what you were doing. Dab check takes on a different personality than you and he can say stuff and do stuff that you can't do.
And this happened right in front of my eyes at a table. Like a holiday in a lobby one time. And I just remember thinking, this is genius. It's one dude giving himself multiple voices through this incredibly disarming artistic process that you can't help but marvel at in terms of sheer execution quality.
And then I start watching your videos and then I start watching where your recent videos and you take these beautifully designed, beautifully prepared, just articulating, puppets, I don't know how to describe a Barnaby. I'm so sorry. And you give each of them a different voice that I assume is your voice doing voices and they have a different personality. They have a different character.
They have a different set of gripes. They have a different read on the world. They have different proclivities, different responses to disagreement and engagement. And it lets you tackle things.
It lets you have a conversation with yourself and with other people, but the rest of us haven't figured out how to have yet on the internet. And so I cannot vouch hard enough for you and your brain and your artistry and what you're doing. It is so clever and so different. And if anybody in the third chair is not checked out Barnaby stuff, it turned this garbage off and just go see that real quick and then come back because it is top notch.
That said, the conversation we want to have today is about you taking one of those puppets that you designed a philosophy to see a first name. Yeah, he's fulfilled. Oh, Phil, a philosophy. I see what you're doing there.
It's literally a fish pop and a blue fish pop in a fishbowl. And I'm like, oh, this will probably be some cute jokes. And I start watching and the philosophy wants to have a conversation with a therapist about children transitioning, like transgender children. And I'm going, the juxtaposition is melting my brain.
There's a fish puppet in a fake fishbowl with this goofy chill European accent, having a conversation with this therapist over Zoom talking about something that you can't talk about. And I was blown away by it and I went, my emotions were this. Well, this is amazing. Ooh, that really makes me think.
Oh, poor Barnaby, I bet he gets murdered in these comments. And I think the reason that we wanted to bring along was not to settle once and for all the hot button issues surrounding transgenderism, gender dysphoria, all of the questions that go on there. We don't know what we're talking about. Who am I kidding?
But more so. I wanted to talk about that interesting way that you got into the conversation and what your experiences was like with the commenting public coming out of that. So thank you for indulging me the long gushing introduction. But would you mind speaking to that?
Like, what was the feedback like on that video? It was mixed in truth. At the beginning, I think it was extremely negative in terms of people getting quite upset. I think later on, those comments kind of settled a little bit lower down the comments section.
So I think even if you watch it now, you'll see a lot of reasonable comments at the top. But when you get to a certain level, they are quite angry. Twitter was the place where I think most of the anger happened, which might not be too much of a surprise to a lot of people. But I knew it was going to be a difficult subject, but I felt very well equipped.
I mean, I'm not saying what my opinion is on the subject. And I don't really know, to be honest. But I have the sense that exploring it from a certain direction is seen as taboo. And I think that's a problem, really, because you want to have people who have good intentions, as I believe my guest does, talking about these subjects, because she so clearly in my mind coming from a place of compassion.
And one of the main criticisms that I was getting even, but she was certainly getting was that her position was coming from a place of hate. And that's quite an assumption, really, when you think about it. I mean, on the one hand, you know, the activists or the detractors, whatever you want to call them, feel they have science on their side. Yeah, they can magically know someone's intentions.
It's quite quite the juxtaposition in a lot of ways. But you do get the sense, really, that they just don't like the opinion and throwing whatever they can your way and seeing what's six. Yeah, it's sometimes insults are the last resort of someone who doesn't have an argument. And I saw a lot of insults in your comments section.
And did that stick to you? Like, did those affect you personally? It's hard to say they did nothing, but they probably did nearly nothing, actually, because I knew it was going to happen. I do feel sorry for people who kind of internet hate comes their way, and that not quite sure what they've done wrong, because in the moment they're kind of scrambling.
And I think you get a lot of those kind of knee-jerk apologies in that moment. And then maybe they have a second more to think about it. And I think maybe I should not have apologized for that kind of thing. But I knew I worked on this video for months in advance.
I did a lot of research just so that I could, you know, so that if someone called me ignorant, that wouldn't stick. And I did a lot of, I guess it would be kind of motivational and analysis on myself, because it's one thing to be maybe right about something, although, you know, as I say, I don't take a stance on it. It's another thing to do something for the right reasons. And I think that's important because, as I say, they kind of come after your motivation.
So if you are sure in your own motivations, there's very little they can do to upset you really. So what was the intent of the video? Like, why did you decide you wanted to create it? I think because what I do, as Matt was saying, I have a multitude of characters and they're quite different to the point that no one could say that it is me, really.
They might infer it or they might guess, but they can't prove it. You know, I would say I'm for sure I put a part of myself in the characters, but if they ever say opinion and that actually says such ridiculous stuff, this character, but I might think what I would never say. I might think I obviously have to think of it because I write the thing. But when it comes to Phil, he's very measured for one, but also he's a fictional character.
I voice him, I puppeteer him, but for people to infer my motivations behind it, it's a little bit harder when I'm not even on the video myself. Can you introduce me to Phil? Like, well, I guess if I were to want to say hello, Phil, how are you doing? Well, Phil's voice comes a little, doesn't come so naturally to me because I'm probably thinking, so I'll give it a go though.
So Phil has a kind of Eastern European sounding. At the beginning, I thought he was going to be Polish or something because his second name is Rebaqiyevit. I lived in Poland for a little while and Reba means fish, so Rebaqiyevit is like fishman or something like this. It's amazing.
It's so warm and inviting and calming. Yeah. That was enchanted by the fish voice the whole time. And for me, it was disarming.
I mean, I couldn't be mad. Did you guys ever watch those red letter media reviews of the old Star Wars films? They did reviews of the episodes one, two, and three. They're like 90 minute reviews.
I've never watched the entire reviews, but I know the red letter media hasn't a huge following. Yeah, huge loyal following. I mean, they're good at film. They're good at story.
And one of the things they figured out is that the role of the critic is a it's a lame role. It's one that should be mocked because it takes a lot of energy to make something beautiful and not a lot of energy to crap on it. I mean, it's the the brand-alini BSA symmetry principle in motion. And so what they did is they created a fictional character to do their movie critiquing for them, an old man named Mr.
Plankett, or Josh Complyer to Bob Abert Dang. And I mean, he's murderous and vile and disgusting and unlovable in every imaginable way. But it positions him to be able to make the critique instead of Mike and Jay, the people who actually make the show. It had never occurred to me that this might be a way to do social criticism, literary film criticism, or even just offer difficult opinions or get people into a conversation that might be somewhat off limits at a given time.
Now, they do it in a way that's crass and fumbling and I think very, very funny. But seeing you do it with such elegance, I kind of wondered as I scroll down, maybe this disarmed the whole thing. And maybe it's the kind of thing where like, look, I'm not going to go on the internet and yell at a fake puppet fish with an Eastern European accent. I'm just, I have my lines, I'm not yelling at a puppet fish.
But no, no, those lines did not exist. Some people were cool with yelling at a puppet fish. What was the most clever thing that somebody yelled at you? Oh, there were some really good ones, actually.
One of them said, Barnaby Dixon forgot how puppet's working accidentally got stuck up his own butt. That's pretty good. And another one was, oh, I never knew I needed to know the answers to the question. What if Jim Henson was a bigot?
Pretty mean, but quite funny too. I like the creative ones, actually. But the whole process of using a puppet to, I'm not going to say that you're using the puppet to tackle the topic. You're using the puppet to bring someone else into the conversation as the way I would.
That's what it appears that you're doing. To me, it reminds me of a matador. Like a matador has this red cape and you've got the bull charging at the cape. And then you just kind of move the cape out of the way.
It's almost like the puppet is your cape. And in this metaphor, the bull would be the angry people on the internet. And the thing about a matador is they look so graceful when they're out there doing their craft and that's the impression I get because I saw what you did. Like at the end of the video, you had me have an authentic connection with your guests.
She showed us a dance. I mean, it was amazing the way you did it. And right when the topic got really, really difficult and I was like really thinking hard, the fish would do something silly. I don't even know what it would do.
It would burp a bubble or something. And I was like, whoa, this is elegant and how gracefully you're handling this topic. And so I mean, hats off to you, man. This is incredible what you've done.
What inspired you to do this? Like, where did you come up with the idea in general? Or is it just something that you had this puppet? I'll backtrack ever so slightly because what you mentioned there, yes, I asked her if she would do a dance simply at the end of it and she knows what's the word.
It's called Oriental and Egyptian folklore dance. That's what she does. But she has this type of dance called Saeidhi. And it's very interesting, I think, to lean into the talents of the guests that you have, especially if they're creative or artistic or something like that.
The prior guest we had Martin Mullin, who I met at your place actually in Alabama when we did think of Con. And we had him play his vibraphone too. And I just feel that so much, I mean, not in the case of Martin, but when it comes to a controversial topic, it's very good to remind people that the guest is a human. You know, and something like something that's created, something that's graceful, something that's expressive, I think, especially right at the end of the video, it's sort of a message to say, okay, you're dealing with a person here, please, sort of think of them that way.
Don't forget that's what they are. The last part of your question, would you mind repeating it? Oh, I was just wondering if the whole idea of using the puppet as a tool is something that happened because you had a puppet laying around. Like, if only you only told you have a hammer, everything's a nail.
Like, did you have the puppet and then stumble upon this method? Or was it part of the process from the beginning? I think, I can't remember exactly what came first, the concept or the fish. I think I wanted to, I could, I mean, you guys work online as well, so you have the sense of how divisive the internet can be.
And I'd see, and I've said this before, but I see the divisiveness of it and the shutting down of the conversation be kind of a problem, especially if we want to kind of solve problems, because complexity and nuance are key to those things and the variety of voices are also key. So, you know, I feel in a sense that there are certainly brave people than I who actually will voice their own opinion on the topic, maybe their next bill on a certain subject, and they do get shot down. They do really, you know, every day for those people, it's, it's hate after hate after hate, just coming through that inbox, this kind of thing. And I thought, maybe I have quite a unique way of being able to tackle these subjects.
I feel like I have a tool in a skill set that allows me to be somewhat protected, and it's a privilege that not a lot of people have, so I want to use it in a way that can help, I guess. Yeah, and if the main objective of making things on the internet was not to get yelled at, the solution is simple, just don't make things on the internet. Yeah. But clearly, I mean, success cannot be first and foremost defined by have no one get upset, or the only solution is do nothing.
If you do something, if you think things, if you ask questions, it's going to be provocative to someone, and if you are talented to the level that you are Barnaby, I mean, good stuff rises to the top, it's not a surprise that a gajillion people watch what you make, like the law of averages say people are going to get mad. I don't know, I suppose that begs the question, what is success for you? What do you hope happens when you make a video on the internet that tackles a difficult topic? I don't know, I mean, it's interesting that there are a lot of people that make quite lighthearted videos that don't have an element of what it would be, that just want to simply entertain and I'm content to do that to a degree, because I think there is certainly merit in making fun, creative, pretty, lovely, funny videos that can really help diffuse situations, especially if there is an element of social unrest online.
It's nice to duck out into those places. I don't think people should feel they have to do this, for example. I feel people already are doing a lot of good when they're creating fun, entertaining content. I think because I had the tool and the ability to find a way to do it that could potentially be effective, so part of it, the motivation is curiosity.
It's like how effective could this be and could I get away unscathed, so to speak, if it works and there is very minimal blowback and people have listened, then it's a success. If there's a lot of blowback for an approach that is very measured, then it highlights an issue. So in both instances, I think it can be deemed a success. You see what I'm saying?
Hey everybody, it's Matt from the Distant, Distant Future. There used to be an ad spot here for something or other. All of that seems so long ago now though. Things were so much simpler and more innocent then.
Destin from the future, bring listener from the past up to speed on what's happened. Yeah, so I wouldn't say cataclysm because it was more of an outright battle. What we do know is that we scorched the sky because the thought was that they would no longer be able to produce electricity with solar panels if we darken the sun. Turned out not to be true, and so now we have a dark sky.
I don't know, what else should we say? We became so obsessed as a people with what we could do that we never stopped to ask what we should do. Right. And then the machine struck first, and now here we are, 35 feet underground in our bunker.
Yes. Mibrated long gray beard and my pole with an anti-machine electric mount staff that can keep my enemies a day. Yes. In my right hand, briefly on the microphone, sending this message back across time in the hopes that you previous listener can do something to support the fight we engage in.
Now Destin, what could they do? Yeah, there's really only one thing and we've found this to be true. It battles the forces of marketing executives and all the things and that's support this podcast on Patreon at patreon.com slash no dumb questions. That's really it.
I mean, if you're able to support the Patreon, that would be great. Patreon.com slash no dumb questions. We'll also send you a sticker of our disheveled selves. Actually, it's not the other time travelers in this podcast, but you will get stickers.
And that's that's where we're at. Yeah. So thank you. Thanks everybody who supports the program.
Thanks everybody who's considering sending, sending forward in time the reinforcements we need to win the battle from our bunker today in the distant future. Patreon.com slash no dumb questions. Thank you. Patreon.com slash no dumb questions.
Question here. When you make a piece of content for the internet and you know it might be controversial, like you did know going forward with this video. Yeah. Do you anticipate the comments ahead of time?
And do you try to change the content based on the comments you think that may emerge? I think you have to be sensitive to people's mindset if you want to be receptive to it. I think there's a difference between compromising what you want to put out by being overly sensitive or being overly apologetic when you don't feel that way and doing it to try and meet people halfway, I would say. And there's a balance to be struck there.
And that's what we're certainly trying to do. Let's talk more about the concept of comments in general. I'm sure it's been on your mind a lot over the last few weeks since you published that video. It's interesting to consider how they affect us, the people who put things on the internet.
Most stuff doesn't get through the armor every now and then. Some cleverly worded comment does. I suppose what pushes my buttons most are accusations of intellectual dishonesty instead of just articulating a disagreement. Well, tell me why I'm wrong.
If it's so, if I'm so wrong that you could accuse me of being a liar because it's so obvious, you should have no trouble then just pointing out the flaws in my argument or the lack of data I gathered. So that one, I wouldn't say it hurts, but it makes me want to respond and I have to tell myself not to. It uks you. Yeah.
The other one that gets me is the accusation of laziness or stupidity. You just didn't do your work. Oh, and again, I would just say, well, it's so obvious then it should be no trouble for you to demonstrate the work I should have done. I suppose everybody's got their little thing and it's fun to unpack what might get through the armor for somebody like you or me or Destin here.
But I'm kind of interested right now in your grand take on the whole proposition of comments in general. How do you think that's shaping the world? What kind of feedback loop do you feel like that's creating? Are we better for having them or would we be better off without them?
I don't know to be honest. I mean, in my comment section, I try to think if I have ever deleted comments, I could probably count the instances on one hand maybe when I know someone to be lying, for example, or something like this. It's so minimal. I literally may be less than five times in the whole history of my channel.
Also, I'm being very rude to another comment or something like this. Just like that's like, I'd like hope I deleted before they see it, something like that. I don't know. But I think conversation is important.
And even if you don't agree with someone's opinion, at least you know what they're thinking or at least what they want to express. What else, I'll tell you what, I'll tell you what, I have deleted comments in the video. And it's like, that's exactly the opposite of what I'm trying to do. I know the best way to start conversation is not likely name calling.
So I know some of these comments have merit and some of them are probably going to be dead in the water. But if they're going to be dead in the water, just let them float there for a bit. That's my feeling. Well, so that's an interesting question because I think that comments on the internet make a lot of sense if we know that the comments are real.
But I did this whole misinformation series online. I happen to believe a significant percentage of comments on the internet are not real. Interesting. Yeah.
I don't know what that number is. I mean, let's just say nonzero. And so I find it interesting that you've heard of comment regading. You've heard of this?
Like, if you have a community online, let's say that Barnaby Dixon makes a video about Green Legos being the best Lego. And I'm in a subreddit about Red Legos, right? Dang. And I'm doing that problem.
So I go to my little subreddit and I'm like, hey, Barnaby Dixon's made this. He's got this stupid fish that's talking about how Green Legos should be allowed. And we all know that our Red Legos are superior. Let's go to the comment section and let's blow it up.
Oh, by the way, there's 100,000 followers of the Red Legos subreddit. And so you start comment regading and you just go over there and relentlessly go after it. That's a thing. And so I would call that coordinated behavior.
And so these types of things happen and it's, you know, they're, I don't know what the countermeasures are for certain things like this. And there's other things that happen that are, you know, AI driven. I mean, I've seen it on Smarter Every Day. And so I think that it's very, very difficult.
The more people that assemble and take place, the more power, they're like hills, like in a war, right? And like the more people and money assemble in one place, the more valuable that spot of ground on the internet becomes. It's like the thing that happened on Reddit a while back where you could pay a certain amount of money for a pixel and. Oh, yes.
That was fascinating. Or actually you didn't pay money. You just actually could change the pixel. So you could only do it within like an hour window and then you have to wait like another hour or something like that, right?
Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. And so it became very important to coordinate in groups and it became very important to concentrate your fire on a certain place.
And so as more people gather in a certain place, it becomes more important to concentrate fire in terms of internet, idea, willpower. I don't know how to articulate it, but I think you get what I'm saying. I do. I think, I mean, there's obviously bots and there's people that aren't actual.
Well, I was going to say people that aren't people, robots, algorithms or whatever it is, that aren't actual people commenting. And I can see that could certainly be a problem. Or people, I don't know, they're trying to cause some degree of unrest. So they're saying what they're saying.
I could spot some of these people in the comment section who are, it seems some obvious to me that that wasn't actually their position, but they were just trying to stir things up. So yeah, of course, they're exercising their voice, but they're not really speaking with their own voice in a sense. I mean, but when it comes to people coming from a different site, for example, I would say that a lot of the people who were commenting more critical things on my video probably came from Twitter, and they weren't likely followers of me either. So what would happen is someone would share, well, first of all, it happens I would share a clip of the video.
And if that clip was deemed to be contentious, as most clips in that video was, the person would share it. Ironically, getting it a lot more views and a lot more eyeballs and a lot more, it's very interesting, something. But anyway, so a lot of people would come to my YouTube page and leave a comment and leave a down vote, this kind of thing. In a sense, you get the sense that like, it's more important to some of these people to be seen to be against something than to not, than to accidentally get it some exposure.
You know what I mean? It's the signaling that they are fought or against something. If they truly believed it was harmful, then they wouldn't share it, I would say. Yeah, they do with their own opinion on it.
So like my sense is that, uh, interesting that they're keen for people to know they're against it as opposed for keen for people not to see it. I think that's very well said. That's very insightful. And that what you said right there, that observation comes back to this organic truth of having comments be a primary way in which we engage with each other.
Yeah. Remember, this wasn't how we engaged with each other until half of a young lifetime ago. Yeah. I go back and watch episodes of Community from the mid to late 2000s, and I can tell it was before commenting was how we talked.
The jokes are different. The virtue signals are different. And then something happens about season three or season four on that very show. And you can tell that right there, right between that episode and that episode, is when we hit the inflection point on where most of our communication happens.
Now we're in the commenting world. It happened right there. Yeah. And I would come back to this truth of not just the internet, but of everything.
Whatever you incentivize, that's what people will do. Sometimes we intentionally incentivize things with tax policy or central planning. Sometimes just the medium that we use incentivizes certain behavior. Well, here's the thing.
If we all go to a high school together and we hang out, the most represented part of the distribution of comments and opinions is going to be the big bell in the middle. You can tell with your eyeballs, like, ah, you know, so and so has an opinion. It isn't really working for them. And it doesn't look super healthy.
I want to include that person to be kind, but this isn't the person you want shaping all of the ideas for everybody, probably they're not in that moment in life right now where everything's working great. You can see that when the commenting is happening in humanity and our full physical interaction and being present with each other is on display. But in the comment section, what's rewarded is not the bell in the middle. What's rewarded is the fringiest ends of the distribution.
And the more that gets rewarded, the more that draws engagement, the more that pleases the various algorithms that are built to reward engagement, the more that seems normative. And the more the giant bell in the middle of generally healthy, pretty much middling, ah, live in, live, you got your opinion. I got mine. We could talk about it.
Whatever crowd that crowd gets pushed down and flushed out into the more rewarded ends of the distribution. And so we're seeing something happening here that feels almost unnatural in terms of human interaction as the fringiest stuff is what seems to be rewarded. And the normalist stuff just remains quiet. I think the middle of the bell is wildly underrepresented in the comment section.
The bell is flat, isn't it? Yeah, I'm looking here at the reviews on the No-Dome Questions podcast on Apple Podcasts. And thankfully, there's a lot of positive reviews, the overwhelming majority of positive reviews. Every once in a while, you get some negative ones in there.
And the negative ones are pretty telling about the person that left the comment. This is a person not what was promised. I agree that there are no dumb questions, but these are dumb podcasts. But there are dumb podcasts.
I thought this podcast was going to be intellectually stimulating instead of two guys talked about nothing related to the title and the fact of the substance for all 10 minutes. Yeah, pretty disappointing. That's a word I see quite a bit in negative comments. Oh, it said pretty disappointing at the end of the comment.
It did. It said pretty disappointing. That word, for some reason, I see that word show up in negative comments all the time. I'm disappointed, disappointing.
Interesting. My last guest mentioned in one of the answers that I cut out, not because she didn't want included, but because I had to sort of try and get it to fit within a certain time frame. She mentioned that a lot of the people commenting angry things have quite a lot of trouble advocating for themselves in real life. And do you wonder if they resort to these tactics because in a kind of like a solipsistic way or something, this would be what would work on them?
What do you mean? Well, I guess that if they do have trouble advocating for themselves and someone came at them with a lot of hate, then it would be an effective way of getting them to shut up. Do you see what I mean? So they see that as they're kind of using the poison that they would be used on them that would be effective on me thinking would be effective.
Wow, wow, wow. That's such a good thing. Interesting. It's not mine.
It was from my guest. I'll give you credit or the fish credit. It's a good take. This is telling.
You started to say to comment and I was like, that is so true about other people. And then you kept going one, one thousand two and somewhere around eight, one thousand, I was like, and it's also true for me. When I comment, I got two techniques. Now I got three.
One is just genuinely thankful. Thanks. Glad you like the thing. That's great.
Just very sincere. Thank you. Approach number two is I LOL the dumbest stuff. Like people come in crazy hot flame throwers going.
Their facts aren't even straight. I'll do the LOL. I'm sorry you feel that way. I would encourage you to reconsider how you connect with people on the internet.
I don't think this will achieve the things you want to achieve because they stuff like that because that would burn you the most because that would work on me. Yeah. Work on me is a sheer kind of a wow dude. What are you doing?
Like be self aware because one of my biggest fears is being even less self aware than I am right now. The cringiest, most painful moments for me to look back on are the ones where I went big and I embarrassed myself in front of everyone because I just didn't get the room. I didn't get reality. And so why do I make those comments because I know it would work on me.
The other one that I'll do is a little bit of snark. If somebody hits me with an ill-informed comment, I will come back with a little bit of sarcasm. Somebody yelled at me one time for using an analogy. It's like cars or something to talk about the Bible.
And they're like, what can I idiot bastardize the Bible by likening it to cars? And I came back and I was like, yeah, that's almost as stupid as some idiot likening the word of God to seeds or soil. And the point being like Jesus uses tons of illustration talking about the word of God. And the reason I made the comment, it had nothing to do with that person.
I never even thought about whether that would affect them or move the needle for them or help them or be empathetic to them. The reason I make those comments is because I know they would work on me. This is a very eye-opening moment for me and it will change the way I respond to comments on the internet. So thank you.
Interesting. Well, you know, another of my guests said, and this was Martin. I don't, I'm sure he wouldn't mind me saying this, but he said all criticism is projection as well. And I think that plays into it to a degree as well.
I couldn't say what he meant by that exactly. I mean, I couldn't mean... Did you say he's staring to the corner of the room being like, that sounds profound. That sounds profound.
And I feel like I should understand it. I think I'm an idiot. I should say, I've been thinking about it for a bit too. Sometimes I get glimmers of understanding it and sometimes I'm making them.
But I think in this context, yeah, you're projecting your own sense of it that he's on someone else. So whatever would hurt them, you are sending their way as a means of being effective. So in a sense, you're projecting yourself onto that person as a means of having the comment be effective in the way that you want it to be. Now, what's interesting though, is when I make a video and I put it on the internet or just generally in my interactions with people, for example, I just finished a video with indie film lab.
They make photography, they develop film and things like that. And I asked them on the phone, I was like, hey, you just did this entire video thing with me. Can you give me some negative feedback? Because negative feedback is something, it's great to hear that people liked what you did, but it's only in the negative feedback that I can grow because I can find the things that didn't work and I can fix them and make them better.
And so I will genuinely inquire for negative feedback. What's interesting is when people offer negative feedback on the internet, I'm less likely to take it because it's typically what you're saying. There's a bit of a sting to it. The negative feedback I often see on the internet is meant to hurt me or meant to create pain.
Right. Right. And I wonder if the person leaving the feedback, did the sandwich technique good, then bad, then good? I wonder if they would actually help me.
That's interesting. We did this one thing one time, Matt and I kind of came to it together. We had a person that made this really weird video on the internet and we wanted to help them. And so we kind of gained out how to leave the comment.
And the first thing was, hey, thank you so much for, you know, we did the sandwich thing, good, bad, good. And it was a genuine moment where we had an opportunity to speak into this person's life offline and I think move the needle in the right direction. Matt, I think you know what I'm talking about. I do.
What I tend to do with comments is just not comment. I take the Ben Franklin approach. He said that people would write him really nasty letters and he would read the letter, internalize it. In the next time he saw them in the public square, he would say something nice to him as if the letter had never been written.
And he said that would just destroy them because they were just so angry because they really needed him to drink a little bit of that. Is there a level of vindictiveness in that as well? I think he's doing the metagame. Indictiveness makes you kind and forgiving towards someone.
That's my kind of. Yeah. Right. I think the world go round.
That's a tasty poison. I guess what Barnaby is saying is it's a matter of the heart though. Like if you're doing it for the wrong reasons. Yeah, motivations are fascinating actually.
I think artists, I guess I'm an artist doesn't sound too pretentious. I think we have a privilege of it's a naval gaze, you know, and that can go a bit crazy at points. But there definitely is, again, I talked about this with Martin actually. Sometimes your naval becomes like a magnifying glass that you can examine the world through.
But sometimes you just get stuck on your belly button and you go nowhere with it. You know, so you can when it comes to kind of analysis of motivations, which is really important if you're going to do something, especially if you think there's a moral component to it, I think. And I think that's important. I might just not finish that sentence properly, but I think that's important because the people coming after you on occasion or at least the people that came after me are very convinced that they're on the side of love and they're standing up to hate.
I'm fairly certain when they're typing these comments that they must be feeling that kind of those emotions associated with hate because you can hear the venom as they type almost, you know, as you read the comments back. So that disassociation that they have, I think, is a result of not examining their motivations in enough detail, you know, or maybe at all, or just assuming they're on the right side of history so they can type whatever they want to signal that. It's fundamentalism. This is what the pendulum is just swung.
The fundamentalism I grew up with as a kid was overwhelmingly born out of a religious context in my country. It was overwhelmingly born out of a Protestant evangelical context. There were a lot of nice things that also came out of that, but the wing of Christianity that we're currently rightly reacting against is the weird fundamentalist controlling. I don't care what the narrative of the Bible is.
I want to find phrases that tell other people what to do. And I'm not really interested in the phrases that push back on my preferred behaviors. That hypocrisy was something that came to light in the 80s and 90s. And a lot of people in my generation saw it and were turned off by it.
Some of us came out of that thinking, yeah, I think they're still a God. Others of us were so burned by it that we came out of it saying, now I don't think there's anything to it. I think it's a control mechanism. Some of us went through a phase of both.
That's what happened to me. And so that's what I think is going on right now. That's probably difficult to detect for a lot of younger internettors is what's happening right now is very much a dialogue with what happened 20 to 40 years ago when evangelicalism and a little bit fundamentalism, that very legalistic rule oriented expression of evangelicalism when that was the dominant mentality. Now, what is so often the pity when we look back at history and social reactions is that we often react against the thing we don't like with exactly the thing we don't like.
We just want to be in charge of it and we want to be in the power position this time around. So in fundamentalism, you have to have in group signaling and you have to have a bad out group. Just 20 years ago, the bad out group were people who didn't like God, who said naughty words, who had romantic relationships with the wrong kind of person who liked marriage. Juana, it's a plant that the kids can dry now.
You can smoke it or eat it. I'm told it's becoming very popular in a lot of corners around the world. I'm unsure of it. I hear it as with appetite.
So the thing that the thing is it flipped that quick. And we shouldn't forget that lesson. This fundamentalism that she was on the other foot no time ago in the grand scheme of history and the vast majority of people were overwhelmingly sure they were moralistically on the right side of history. And if they had to burn down a few people who were wrong to make examples of them, you've got to burn down a few people.
People were rightly hurt by that. And so they've created a new orthodoxy to say that was screwed up. And I didn't like the way it felt. But unfortunately, to me, it feels like so much of that new orthodoxy often manifest in the comments is just punitive.
It's an attempt to say that sucked. You mistreated people. Let's see how you like it. And I for now makes the whole world blind.
I am eagerly awaiting the moment when we graduate from this counter reaction, this new orthodoxy with a new in group and a new out group. And I really think at some point people of goodwill are going to win out. We're going to see these big patterns and we can make that pendulum maybe come to rest somewhere a little more in the middle. Instead of vigorously swinging, I don't think we have to have an out group.
I think it's possible for us to get to a place where we ignore those extreme ends of the distribution. We listen to the bell and we treat everybody with patience and tolerance. I think that dream of the west is still alive. I think we can do it.
I think it's the bomb that everybody is dying for society. But right now I feel like the pendulum has swung in a reactionary way against the fundamentalism of old with the fundamentalism of new. And just like we had to wait out the last version of fundamentalism. If you like, we got to wait out this version of fundamentalism.
Yeah, you're probably right. I think it will it will require people who are on the side of the pendulums already. I sometimes see it as almost like multiple pendulums. Maybe we have a political one, maybe we have a cultural one, maybe we have a social one.
So sometimes you'll say the pendulum is so far this way and I'll say no. And then they point to maybe the economic one or something like this and say, but look at this, it's like, no, there's kind of multiple ones. I think YouTube and the internet is definitely in a certain direction right now. And there are certain mechanisms to stop anyone that they don't trust getting hold of the pendulum and taking more towards the middle from getting hold of it.
So people that are, you know, the other side of the political spectrum just have no chance of obtaining this pendulum or having any sway over it, sway over it literally. But the people who are on the side that it's kind of reached the extreme is on, you know, there are still words that can be leveled at them, but they're less words, I suppose. So I think it is dependent on people who, I don't know, it's so hard not to sound kind of preachy. When I say, dependent, it's like, this has to be people's own volition.
You know, they have to do it because they feel it's right, not because they didn't believe into it. So I say have to very tentatively, but I think it would be helpful if they were able to gain control of the trajectory and to trust the other side to a degree, because you have to, because it's, you know, trust breeds trust. And if one side has seen the other side just gripping on white knuckle to this pendulum for 20 years, when they get hold of it, it's like, we can, we have to make sure they don't get hold again, because remember what happened last time. So as a result, what happens, white knuckles gripping on the other side.
So trust needs to kind of come across the aisle by a kind of, I think, just a good will of the people on the side that it's reached the extreme, just kind of correct, just slowly tweak it out of the fingers of these people on the extremes and just let it rest in the middle. And the other side wants to grab it and take it a little way. Don't ever react, you know, things kind of things go in that motion anyway. It's when they get magnetized at extremes and held hostage there that we get into some problems.
That's so well said. And the playbook of the fundamentalists of any type, when they most have the pendulum their way and they're white knuckle to keep it swung all the way their way, is the danger language that we can't let people think that or say that it's dangerous. People could get hurt. This is not new.
That use of language was being employed by the exact opposite side 20 to 40 years ago. And this at some point, and this is what I think is the genius of the Western liberal revolutions of the 18th and 19th centuries, we had seen the English Civil War. We'd seen the 30 years war. We'd seen political discord that cost hundreds of thousands of lives in destruction.
We'd seen religious discord that created the exact same mess in Europe. We'd seen these mega monarchs who had come along. We want power here. We'd seen the people come along and say, now we're going to kill the monarch and we want power here.
And then along comes this group of thinkers in the 18th century who are like, we have got to come up with a way to settle this pendulum in the middle. And the key concept was tolerance, religious tolerance, ideological tolerance, lifestyle tolerance. You just got to cut other people some slack. And if we can get everybody to agree to that, then maybe we can get that thing to come to rest in the middle and it can work for everybody.
Have we ever fully realized that? Probably not. But I still think this experiment has legs. And I'm excited for the next little undulation.
I'm hoping we can land it in a better spot. Yeah, absolutely. I get excited. Thanks for tolerating me on that, Barnaby.
No, no, I agree entirely. It's interesting. I do see a lot of fear being induced in a lot of people these days with the language being used and also the repercussions of the speech that some people are even well meaningly saying. And my first guest actually who is a social scientist or social psychologist, social psychologist, I believe.
I think I'm right. So you mentioned that when people are scared, they do a lot of thinking with the reptilian part of their brain, which isn't where the best thinking happens. It's kind of like survival. So I think if the more we are scared of the other side or the more we feel victimized in whatever sphere that could be, the less cognitive capacity we have to solve the problems that are plaguing us.
So Barnaby, receiving all these negative comments, how has it changed the way you comment on the internet? Well, good question. I don't know if I do comment on the internet really hardly at all, actually. There's been instances probably in the past where I have engaged and I haven't in a way that probably is you're saying like, what would hurt this person?
Yeah, absolutely. I've done that when I was younger. And it very rarely ends up with a better outcome than if I hadn't said anything at all. So I usually just don't.
I use Twitter. I put clips of my videos up on Twitter and I tried to be very civil. I remember when things were blowing up, what was it a month ago that I said, okay, I'm very interested to hear your feedback on this kind of thing. And again, more hate did come my way, but I did get some interesting suggestions too.
I think I read all of it, or maybe I did read or some people say, shouldn't read the comments. I didn't never really bothered me too much. This is an interesting thing too. Before you embark on this, and I mentioned it before, you do have to really examine your motivations.
And you feel like you have to preempt not what people will call you, but what people might call you that could potentially be true. You know, and you kind of, I call it all, it sounds very pretentious, but I call it like checking your armour. So you sort of punch yourself in a certain area, say, does that hurt? Does that hurt?
Does it hurt? Does that hurt? And you do that over and over again, and you lose a ton of weight and you get that really stressed and all this kind of stuff. When people come after you to that particular part of your armour, it's like, guys, I've tried this over and over again.
You know how many times, you don't know how many times, but it doesn't work. So keep going if you like, tell yourselves how you want. Who do you think comments on internet stuff and who do you think doesn't? I would posit that the commenting public is different than the public public.
I guess question one is, do you agree with that supposition? And if so, how do you think those two things differ? I remember I used to listen to Howard Stern back in the day, and he said this is going to sound something. But he said that people that call into radio shows are most often the fair bit done other than the general public.
And I wonder if there's a crossover sometime. Not all the time. Sometimes, like I say, I see some wonderful criticism and some really interesting feedback. But maybe, I don't know.
I'm not sure what that would be. I'm thinking about it now. So any answer I give wouldn't be well considered. I kind of wish I could go across all the comments I've ever written on the internet.
I'm sure someone at the NSA can. And you go back and you look at everything you've ever written, and like if there were scales, and you're like, generally you were uplifting and edifying to those around you. Or in general, you were a fun sucker. You kind of took the fun out of everything and you kind of tried to hurt people most of the time.
I wonder if there was like a global comment score. You got to believe that such a technology exists. That would turn Black Mirror really fast though too, right? It could.
Whatever you incentivize, that's what people do. So if artificial niceness and uncritical thought is incentivized, then we'd have an artificial niceness and uncritical thought crisis. I'm not saying we should incentivize it. I'm just wondering if you could measure it.
Like if it's quantifiable, I'm not saying you should act on the information. Once you quantify it. But like in general, I wonder if my comments uplift people or if they push people down. And I think that would be telling you by religious gentlemen, that you maybe do you think Saint Pete has a list?
No, not at all. I fail on every metric. Yeah. Yeah.
I just the 10 second answer to that is my thread of religious understanding is such that as a person, if there is a deity who's perfect and flawless, I don't stack up. And so any potential for any kind of rightness between me and the first cause of all existence has to be because of a movement on the part of the first cause who's excellent and perfect and flawless, I have to accept the fact that I am flawed. And therefore, my list would not be good enough to earn favor with such a deity. But still, it would be good to know if you like, what kind of actions you left in your wake, meaning like were people motivated to do good after interacting with you, or were they motivated to do bad?
Or did they like turn inwardly in a negative way? It would be interesting to know. Ideally, it would be good to edify others in every interaction. And I think you can edify people with build people up with a negative comment.
I think that is possible. In fact, I know it's possible people do it with me all the time. The people that take me aside and they say, Hey, Destin, you know, away from other people. And they're like, I know this is what you were trying to do in that moment over there, but it could have come across like this.
You might want to reconsider it. Those are the people that I can tell instantly, they have my best interests at heart. They want me to be better for me. And I'm going to carefully consider what they say.
That's absolutely key. You know, I run this video by a few people that I really, really trust just to get the sense if, you know, just to get it from their perspective, I don't want someone that comes at it from the same perspective or that will agree with me. But I do want someone who has my best interests at heart and kind of gets what I'm doing. They don't have to agree or they don't have to be the same type of person, whatever, regardless of the demographic, you know, as long as they have your best interests at heart, you kind of have to employ a little faith on it.
But I feel that I have a good sense of who has that and who I can ask with regard to these specific series of videos that I'm doing. So you develop trust with a person, and then once you've developed the trust, you can receive the negative feedback in a different way. Maybe that's the problem with internet comments. Maybe we...
The anonymity to a degree. Maybe we don't have any trust, perhaps if we had an opportunity to see the humanness of the other side. I think so. I don't know.
There's one conclusion that I came to in the misinformation series is if I assume people are human and I treat them as such, it changes everything about how everything happens in the rest of that particular thread. You know, if you could just find something that's common with a person and you say, hey, I see that you like whatever, motorcycles, you know, my dad likes motorcycles too. It's really cool that you do that. So, you know, and I do see where you're coming from on XYZ.
I just think that maybe we differ in this one little place and that's okay. You know, I think if you treat them like a human, then you can kind of get through that armor instead of just like... Absolutely, to try and see it from that perspective or try and get a sense of where their heads are. And you can never really know either.
I mean, someone, you know, just getting up on the wrong side of the bed, but some of the worst things could happen to a person in the morning than that, you know. So it's good to bet those kind of things as possible reasons for a certain behavior or a certain attitude. For sure. That's just benefit of the doubt thinking, right?
To use the example of your video, Barnaby, one of the things that I found difficult to stomach from several of the worst comments I read in your thread were the people who assumed that they did not want the same things as your guest. When who is against everyone thriving? Surely no one from the bell curve. Maybe there's some people on the wacky ends of the distribution, but they should be relegated.
If your opinion is, I don't want other people to thrive and I like suffering. I'm sorry. You're welcome to have that opinion. You're just not really welcome to shape the discussion.
You're a jerk. You've got a problem. Something's wrong with you. I don't know what it is.
I'm sorry for whatever it is. If your parents or something happened at school, if you were a victim, I'm sorry. I'd love to be empathetic and help even with any of that, if I could. But you don't get to bring that disease into the conversation.
And everybody who's healthy wants everybody else to thrive, right? Sasha wants that. That's her name. Right?
Sasha? Am I getting the right Sasha? Yes, Sasha. Yeah.
She wants everybody to thrive. And I would hope that even the probably very young people who are practicing a version of new moral internet orthodoxy with where that fundamentalism is that currently they need to signal I think orthodoxy see I made a negative comment. I think it surely even those people want everyone to thrive. No one wants all the Democrats or all the labor party people or all the Republicans to just wither and die and fail, right?
I mean, nobody wants death to all the religious people or all the a religious people or all the whatever group isn't like you. And so if you start with the assumption that odds are that whoever I'm hearing from on the internet would like good things and blessings and flourishing for everybody. If you can even see a glimmer of that in the comment, then it feels like there's some kind of there's something we can connect on. We have a moral thing in common.
My atheist friend who believes things totally differently than me, we both want people to flourish and I'm willing to even put energy into that. And so are you. So wow, we just disagree on how to best achieve it. But it seems like 90% of the conversation is already taken care of.
We want the same ends. Let's see how we might reason through different ways to do it. And I might have to land in a place where I'm like, I don't think your strategy is best. But you're giving me some leash to try to do what I think will best help people to thrive and be redemptive and good in the world.
So I probably got to give you a little bit of leash to go and do the same. And then we don't have to feel like we have to overcome all these enemies to even try to do good. And it seems like there's a pathway there toward thinking about the comments I encounter a little differently and thinking about the people who I know are out there who really don't like my ideas very much a little differently that benefited out. I think it's almost like, I mean, we're bound to think very differently.
And there's certainly a merit to I'm working on a project currently and I'm collaborating a lot with really talented people that have a different skill set than I, but also a different way of thinking about things. So we progress in a way because an obstacle to me might not be one to them and something that comes simple to me might not come so easy to them. So it's, I guess it's almost like evolution in a sense. Let's try this strategy.
Let's try this way. But together we move forward if we allow those people to voice their perspectives, you know, I see the benefits of it. And I see we could be losing it if we're not careful, I guess. I've got a question, Marty.
What's next for philosophy? Well, for the next few months, I'm working on this collaborative theatre project for a while. And I was very keen to get that video kind of done in my headspace because it just consumed me really for a long time. And this follow up video too that I'm working on is doing somewhat the same I'm dropping it tomorrow, I believe.