Hello and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a podcast about old stuff and education and books and stuff We feel like talking about my name is Thomas Magby. I'm joined as always by mr. AJ Hannenberg and mr.
Graham Donaldson. Hello. All right, so we are moving on to a book 10 of Plato's Republic today. We did it.
We are now in like such a vaunted territory as friends friends at 10 season Beverly Hills 9 to 10 seasons and so did small bill small Man I had like so much interest is added to me about that show about the one character who be I came part of a cult. Oh yeah real life. That's crazy. Yeah, that's a thing.
Yeah, that's a thing, right? What's that called? I don't know. Some sort of like weird New York City cult.
I think the game is a cryptocurrency, right? Who knows? So AJ, can you give us like brief recap of So I'll do my best to recap. I actually look back on book nine just to see just to see if I could give a recap So it begins with Socrates and his boys and they're hanging out before they go off to see sort of a horse race, right?
They get chatting and they get chatting about who is better the Unjust who can do whatever they want or the just right who's got a better deal who's got a better deal? And so for the sake of argument they say, okay Let's say that you have a perfectly just man who has a reputation of injustice and you have a perfectly unjust man who has a reputation for justice And see if they actually like devoid of all of the accolades that usually come with either if internally it's a better system And so they launch into this argument and they go into okay Well to understand the inner workings of a man it'd be easy to understand that you're like looking at a macro level right? Understanding the inner workings of a state and see if we can't compare the two and so they come up with the three parts of man Right? You have the appetites You have the will and you have the intellect and that justice is the harmony between those three parts doing their correct functions So intellect the top and via its will kind of forcing itself on the emotions right making the emotions go where they should go And everything is run by your intellect.
There's some modern thinkers who think that oh man It's like a flea trying to drive an elephant right because you're emotions with the thing that driving the whole bus But Plato thought that that still doesn't mean that he's wrong, right? Maybe that flea should be driving that elephant so then we talk about the different types of government We end up talking about how do you guys remember the forms? I mean to me and there's a democracy the rule by the I think the democracy is rules by the worry glorious warriors There's being like oddly prescient about there's the philosopher king He's the best yeah, so we start with philosopher king and then it goes to glorious right What happens is the the warriors get so much glory and then they should be in charge the democracy We know we move to an oligarchy rule of the rich right is that all there's a aristocracy That's the first one every stock is real the best and then there's a rule the glorious and then there's a rule the wealthy and then Go to democracy, and then we go all the way down eventually to tyranny and tyranny is the worst Was there not like a rule of the jacked like the spirited that's democracy. Oh, okay, Timmy democracy Yeah, yeah, I feel like we're missing There's Dimitri that was democracy, and then there's a Tyrone, which is tyranny.
Yeah, right so democracy Always remember that democracy always devolves into tyranny and we spent the last few chapters looking at what those kind of people look like Sorry, what does a person who is ruled well look like what does the democratic man look like and he looks like one who is like Taught by his dad the good virtues, but doesn't then he gets some friends, and he's like all right All these pleasures are kind of sweet so he has a little bit of a mix of both But he still kind of admire he admires the the good pleasures and virtues and so timbers himself and his kid is not taught those same values His kid is Tyrone and his kid decides that man his dad has some pleasures I'm gonna get me some of that and just falls all the way into full debauchery And then it paints the picture of the Tyrant the tyrant and how he has no friends about him because they all fear him And eventually yes to kill them all how you know it Totally bloodthirsty rule by his passions has no good in her life It's just a terrible way to be before you know you've appointed your horse to the Senate. Yeah, you know what's happened Yes, and periculate Well, he was an emperor of Rome and he was so bonkers and Thought that the Senate was a big joke and he wanted to show this thing was a big joke So he appointed his horse to be a senator and actually sat in the Senate and I don't have to pass anything besides What horses naturally pass what do you think the horse a name like on the official list of the Senate like his name is there They take role, please tell me They only voted name What a way to start off a podcast, okay, so we just finished talking about Tyrone and that kind of draws Basically to a conclusion the whole thing book nine kind of finishes the argument They've shown that the virtuous life is the best life no matter what people think of you you have inner harmony Right you are not driven by your passions you are master of your own ship And there's all kinds of good things if you want to go back and listen to those episodes You can you should if you're on YouTube, but we've probably set up a little playlist where you can listen to all ten in order Maybe maybe you're probably sitting here on hour ten just being like what are they talking about? Yeah, yeah, I was just like straight through like like watching Lord of rings like there's reading along cramming cramming for your play Okay, so this one is kind of like an epilogue and it's a two-part epilogue Right the first part has to do finally with kind of Plato establishing his world of forms Which I feel like we've taken out of context in all honesty. We've blown out a proportion like us three like the world out large He did this I mean maybe he talked a little bit more about it with his divided line But it seems to me that he doesn't spend a whole lot of time talking about this crazy heaven full of the world of forms That's not it seems to me that this is less about that he talks He's actually addressing his rule about imitative poetry and why we should keep those dang poets out of the state And then his name for your final epilogue weirdly enough is a defense of the immortality of the human soul and the eternal benefits of being a virtuous man Well that that's quite a way to book.
Yeah, I know it's kind of it All right, so let's start with the beginning he starts off by saying you know what now that we're done with the convo I got to say that my favorite rule is the rule against imitative poetry because those guys are a bunch of donkey-brained idiots, right? It's not We watch the language, please. This is a donkey brain. Whoa, wait, whoa, wait, come on Of course brains you So he says yeah, it's all of these political imitations are realness to the hearers and that only the knowledge of their true nature is the antidote To all of this nasty terrible poetry that's out there all this imitative poetry and so they're like, okay Can we just back back a little bit?
What was the what was his deal against why he didn't like imitative poetry? He thought that it was oh, we're about to go into it Oh, I thought we but he did talk about it He talked about it briefly now. He's going to give sort of a full defense of why he thinks poets are hacks, okay, okay? Okay, so first tell me what's an imitation when you try to make something like something else try to make something look like something else Or be something else, but it's not okay, so let's say and he's like, okay, let's talk about what an imitation is derivative Yeah, let's say that there are let it he says let us take a common instance There are beds and tables in the world and plenty of them are there not can you deny the existence of beds and tables?
We cannot talk to you happy the redder wise yeah, but there are only two ideas of or forms of them one the idea of a bed and One the idea of a table and the other guy goes true I'm talking about and he says and the maker of either of them makes a bed or he makes a table for our use in accordance with that idea So when a carpenter sits down to make a bed or a table He is pulling from the original idea of bed right is it the function of bed or is it an idea of bed like it like is he Specifically thinking it is a place where someone sleeps or is he saying I would say the function is in essence with the idea Right part of the idea of bed is that someone sleeps on it. Okay, that's that's in the idea But no artifice or no carpenter made the idea himself. Mm-hmm. No one is like, you know what bed from nowhere I bet it's a bed.
It's been a bed forever And so there must be another artist the guy who came up with the idea in the first place You can call him the first artist and he is the maker of all the works of all other workmen right workmen are making essentially Reproductions of ideas and there's one guy who made all the ideas you have me so far Okay, I am is there a reason there has to be that first he's saying that for like there's a first person who thought up a bed or There's an idea of beds, and so he's the one who created sort of that first essence of all things and this is essentially God Let me read you a little section of God when God made everything He also made this idea of he made the world of ideas before he made the world of matter I guess just stay with me a little bit and we can talk about the actual efficacy of this idea or legitimacy of this idea So he says wait a little and there's more reason for saying so for this is he who is able to make not only vessels of every kind But plants and animals himself and all other things the earth and heaven and the things which are in heaven or under the earth He makes the gods also and the guy goes he must be a wizard I'm not kidding quote. He must be a wizard. No mistake. Oh, I go.
Yeah, that's some theology. Okay. He says and Socrates says Oh, you're not a believer You mean that there's no such maker creator or that in one sense there might be a maker of all these things But another not do you not see there's a way in which you could make them all yourself Do you guys know that I know for a fact that both of you could also make all things what yeah? I know for an absolute fact.
I don't we can make all things because someone has made it before it's a riddle here You guys figure it out. I'll give you it's guessing obvious as soon as I do it. You know how you know how you do it No, hold a mirror. Yeah spin around.
Oh, yeah, all of a sudden you have made all things inside the mirror in reflection That's not true riddle sure. It is you guys thought you couldn't do it. I just use made a whole bunch of I just reflect them. You mean that's kind of imitation, but there's like the essence and everything is an imitation of that first form anyway Yeah, and but those would be that's what the guy says.
Yeah, but those are appearances only he says offer good You're going for real that is an imitation and not the real bed and so essentially we come to the point that there are three beds There is one existing in nature made by God for no one else can be the maker because if he was making it after a different idea that original Person will be the maker you with me. Yes, the second level is the work of the carpenter Someone who takes that idea and makes an imitation of the idea in real life The third level is the painter who looks and makes an imitation or an appearance of that thing but not the actual thing So he hates poets and artisans because they're doing they're like two standards of deviation away from the real thing Yeah, they're an extra ways away from them So and then he says there is only one single idea and you know why he how he can say there's only one single idea of bed No, no, it's because if he made two then he would be making those after some other original idea It was a source for those two things. So there has to be one original idea for bed Yeah, otherwise like there would be one it's like a you'd be one order removed from that, right? So that's it that's where he gets his notion from right if I make two of something I must be using some other original idea So the original idea had to come from somewhere and this he calls God or essence or nature, right?
Sure. Got you. Um and so he is would be the author of all things he created a bed Which is essential and nature only so third in the descent from nature is an imitator and a tragic poet is also an imitator Wait, so Plato doesn't make any differentiation between naturally occurring things and things that human beings do so like a tree has a form But a bed also has a form. Yes, like it's it's kind of like an idea Right a tree is a thing made after an original and then a bed is also a thing sort of made after an original but there's nothing That different differentiates it because it is produced by human beings where as a tree is generating itself.
Sure, okay I mean we can also like make changes to the ways that trees grow we can be selective and you know plant and cultivate and that sort of thing Yeah, he says pretty much the imitators a long way off the truth He can do all things because he lightly touches on a small part of them Right because he only views them from one angle and he will what he will get will be a portion of the truth But not the real thing actually gotcha and that part will be an image For example a painter can paint a cobbler or a carpenter and he will show like what they're doing But he has no idea what they're actually doing and he'll deceive simple people who also don't know about those things But not the people who actually know for example like to bring in a modern day if you guys watch action movies, right? Yes, somebody gets stabbed in the back and dies instantly, right? If you don't know anything about actual warfare, you'd be like, ah, yes He must have hit the artery and that man is instantly dead from being stabbed if you know anything about war that doesn't happen Right, if you even if you get stabbed in the heart, you've got what four minutes before all of your blood kind of Before it stops going to my brain For yourself going to your brain or at least you run out of brain oxygen You it'll take a while if you get stabbed in the gut, that's a four-hour injury, right? So that's horrifying And nobody wants to see that but but like the imitator the filmmaker knows enough about it to fool people who don't know that much about how wounds happen Right, or have you ever seen something in a movie where you're like, that's not the way it happens, right?
For example, one of my favorites is they do a pottery scene I hate to bring back a pottery again, but they do a pottery scene Not ghost, actually funny enough in ghost they do a pretty good job I'm talking about in Karate Kid 3 Nope, the one with the girl The one with the girl, she has like these motions where she does pottery and they end up being karate motions Those motions would never be used to pottery and if you did you would ruin your pot Was it me on the end of the day? I really wasn't it wasn't at the same girl that was in like a millionaire baby million dollar baby? Oh, um, Dame Judy Densch, no No, no, I think it was Hillary Swank It's not a good movie Karate Kid Part 3 or Million Dollar Baby? Yeah One great one best picture Yeah, so anyway he fools all these children and simple people And he shows them the picture of the carpenter Because it's not really It's not really what's happening He doesn't actually know how things are put together and how the tools are used and what's actually working And he says if anyone comes and says like he's found someone who knows all the arts everything he can paint all things He's so wise when really it's poor It's probably more likely that what he's found is someone who can imitate those things Who doesn't have full wisdom?
Who doesn't have all these things? But can do a good enough imitation to fool the dumb dums, right? So what would Plato say that people who are depicting pictures are not doing it to try to depict things They're not trying to be realistic, but they're saying something other using the vehicle of a carpenter So yeah, okay, fine. You drew a picture of a carpenter and his tools aren't really the types of tools that you would use for the project That's depicted in the painting, but he wants to talk about like or the painting is is about something not being realistic But about like the romance of carpentry or something Then why not engage in the actual romance of carpentry?
It's still an imitation I haven't produced the romance of carpentry Because if you have shown the romance of carpentry But sometimes if you're a carpenter and you just sort of go about your business It's not until you see somebody interpret what you do abstract it from it that you may begin to see it in a new way But that's my very point is that anyone who does carpentry knows that often There's not a lot of romance in the carpentry like you're covered in wood glue You're covered in sawdust there are a lot of loud noises You've got a vacuum to get up rid of all the sawdust. It's not this idyllic thing. It's sweaty. It's smelly It's covered in wood glue.
It's not it's not as romantic as that painting would depict and so not only is it showing an imitation It's an imitation of a non-reality. Is that Plato's point of that? It's both not the actual thing and it's lying in a certain sense. Well, he so so far.
He has talked about painters Okay, the next section says okay So if we hear people saying about people like Homer that they're so wise and they know all these things Maybe there's a similar illusion happening where we give Homer the credit for being so wise But really it's all imitation and we he doesn't actually know the true states of man What it's like to be a king what it's like to be a warrior what all these things are like and so we should check Maybe Homer's a snake. I'll say let's say let's maybe he's fooling everybody So the first question is do you suppose if you were able to make the original as well as the image? He would devote himself to the image making branch like if he could be a king Why would you choose poet over king sure if you're so good at being a ruler if you're so good at being a warrior Why choose the imitation this yeah, it's been a long time since we talked about it but the what about art episode this is making me think of that of To look someone who is not a king cannot look back and critique a king. They don't know the mindset They don't understand the desire to grow a kingdom or whatever exactly is it likely that Homer the bard had any notion of what it was truly Like to rule day by day no, but if Homer was a soldier then he would know about combat or I'm guessing since he was blind He was probably not sure exactly or he was made blind for rocks the other way.
Um, yeah Homero didn't really exist right no I don't know and then he says the real artist who knew what he was imitating would be interested in realities and not imitations So man would desire to leave as memorials of himself works many and fair and instead of being the author of incommiums like talking About other people would prefer rather to be the theme of them So Plato would be okay with those like insufferable modern artists that say things like I'm doing art about being an artist Yeah, so he would be okay with that because it's like yes now you're sticking to your profession That's all artists know about is how to be an artist so don't paint me a painting about carpenters No, it's like a four art about art if he's wrong if he has a problem with two derivatives That's like four derivatives right like I was wondering what what Plato would say about like a picture of a painting in the museum And then like a reddit post of that picture and then a facebook share and then my screenshot and then my showing you like this Oh, man, like how many Homer would just be pulling his hair out. Yeah, like so many times We played over yeah, Plato. This is gonna be hopeless here But does he does he say anything about education or teachers in this context at all or is he only in the area of? It's just the same thing of like to teach the works of someone who created works like all right Well, I don't know if you are connecting that or thinking that also doesn't mean like we are I didn't say that But shouldn't we be poets to talk about poetry or be authors of we talked about this on your criticism Remember that yeah having gone back through like all of our episodes post on YouTube has reminded me of a lot of things So, but I just wonder does Plato make any connection like that or is he only talking about a bad form of poetry?
Like that we should be doing those things I think he's saying that the imitation isn't worth the actual practice Sure why write a poem about a life that you're not living why not go and live that life Yeah, sure right why write about romance if you can go have romance. Yep for honor to be respected as a writer of the thing Going back to the part our last week's podcast So that the thing can be immortalized forever Yeah So like you go and have romance and then you die and the romance is done But you like this is Shakespeare when he writes about this in his sonnets that his love will last forever because he immortalized in poetry poetry Sure, but I would think that was right I think I would have a problem with a lot of stuff that we teach I mean one of the first things we teach 9th graders is Homer for a long time And so I mean that's that's kind of the next question we have after after I get through the little argument You guys can sort of evaluate it, right? So remember there's two parts of this the second part will be I think a little bit shorter This first part is more argument and stuff, but he basically says alright Can you guys name any states that Homer ruled well? Nope?
Nope any battles he directed? Nope? What about okay, so maybe he lived well maybe he was really wise Yeah, what about followers was there any like homerids the people who followed him around as a teacher? No, in fact what we what is usually said about him is that his friends neglected him while he was alive because he just wasn't that fun So clearly his wisdom didn't extend to interpersonal relationships the truth is also getting about bad marriage.
Yeah, bad marriage He had a little little underlings that loved him. Exactly. There was there was at least some wisdom going around the city corrupted Yeah, but nobody followed Homer around the city and so he says Isn't it likely? Can't we infer that all these political individuals beginning with Homer the very top are only imitators They copy images of virtue and the like but the truth they never reach the poet is like the painter who Will make a likeness of a cobbler, although he stands nothing of cobbling right and his picture is good enough for those who know No more than he does and judge only by colors and figures So we judge his wisdom because we don't have any oh say that last part again So we are okay with all of the wisdom he is giving us about ruling in about warriors because we don't know what it's like That's fair.
I also don't know if it's possible to have good things to say even if you haven't yourself ruled I don't know. Yeah, this is a pretty narrow world and what sort of currency does any human have with anybody else? Well, you do the thing itself if you earn real wisdom you make yourself useful to other people in that same domain So if you're a good carpenter, you can help other people be good carpenters But you can't extrapolate lessons from your carpentry to talk about the good life for example Sure, you can but you're not imitating you live a good life if you live a good life No, this is spot on because to give it. This is a it's like taking advice from financial advisors Who have gone broke like or have gone bankrupt from following their own advice like you wouldn't do that, right?
They shouldn't do that you should not do that. I'm sure many people have but you should follow the advice of someone who has succeeded in gaining wealth. That's right everybody who writes like a Blog article or a newspaper article should have a score when they were wrong Yeah, or it's one of nothing to live things is that when you make a prediction and you should put money on it Yes, and so you put that money on you find a way to trade your opinions And then you only have clout if you've accumulated wealth if there was a website that gave stock tips and every every writer had to like show Close your eye invested in this not full disclosure. I invested but say of all the articles I've written Here are the things I invested in and here's my record.
Well, the record was down 38% I'd be like I'm gonna listen to this don't which I think spot on but the other the flip version of that is that so Barron's is a I think it's a weekly newspaper that where they give stock tips And so there are two portfolios. One is the do whatever Barron says and the other one is do the opposite Whatever Barron says and most of the time the opposite of Barron's is the one that wins Yeah, yeah for sure. So anyway, okay, so he says all right Let's let's take another way of looking at this there are three arts considering with all things the one that uses the one that makes And a third which imitates for example a flute right so Sam a flute maker and Graham is a flautist Okay, right, so Graham I will make a flute you will take that flute and you will play it flouting all the day flaut all the day Maybe I make a terrible flute like one of the keys sticks one of the notes is off and it's goofy and you give it back to me Like man, this flute is the worst. You'd be like, what do you know?
You don't make flutes No, that's the thing is like you do know you play it And so I will change my flute making based on you the professional player who plays the flutes I will give it back to you and then you can review and in that way we are both improved You are using the actual thing. I'm improving my artistry your artistry improves from a good tool But the imitator never gets feedback. He doesn't have to interact with you. He doesn't have to interact with me Well, we can hate you one time.
What would be the imitator of a fuck a painter? Maybe a painter imitates the picture of someone playing the flute or they write a poem about how great it sounded when the flute player played Exactly, but the thing is is he is so disconnected He knows nothing about either playing or making and so he is so far disconnected that he is in a brilliant state There's a little bit of sarcasm here like the imitative artist will be a brilliant state of intelligence about his own creations He's like ah very much the reverse But he'll go on imitating without knowing what makes a thing good or bad and maybe expected therefore to imitate only that which appears good To the multitude and he has no knowledge necessarily about that which he is imitating so Plato gets the shorts and wide because all these Artisans were what's their what they call something? Imitators. They are all about optics and not about I'm not about like actual craft or whatever Yeah, and then he he kind of goes into Talibs yeah the interaction of of the soul so he has a little example So when we use our eyes and we look at something to see which one is bigger sometimes they're fooled right Especially if we're looking at some underwater or it's skewed by waves or like distance or have you ever looked at two things and thought?
One was bigger when it actually turns out they measure exactly the same yeah A little optical illusion he says well There's that faculty vision and then there's like the measuring faculty our rational faculty where we measure it and we always Exceed to the measuring faculty we we give up our visual opinion in favor of the measurement right because that's our Actually take out a ruler and you do it and we trust you actually trust remember those things where you could like cross your eyes and get Really close and then there's a dolphin in there something yeah, I remember those things with 3d magic guy That's right. They would have like they would be frame pains of them all no he says though So the same faculty cannot let's see So when those things are contradictory there appears a contradiction right same faculty can't have contrary opinions about the same thing at the same time So that part of the soul that has an opinion contrary to measure is not the same that has an opinion which is in accordance with measure right? So there's part of you. It's like yeah, that thing's bigger And then there's the other part of you that's like now It's the same and you always give favor to the rational soul got you that's one should yeah And so that's kind of like a vision soul and a math soul right?
There's one that is the perceptive faculty and one that's the rational kind of and so he says okay Let's see if this plays out in hearing right So is this poetry have the same kind of effect where there will be the perception and then there will be rather the rational principle And that they're pulling against each other about how a thing should actually be okay Does that make sense yes, and so he says there's a principle of law and reason in him which okay? So say say a guy is filled with sorrow from something say he loses his kid. He's got he's got a big loss Is that the example play uses or? Yeah, so let's see a good man who has that's a fortune to lose his son or anything else Which is most dear to him will bear the loss with more equanimity than another he says not necessarily But will we say that he has no sorrow or that he'll because he can't help sorrowing him home moderate Which is more true that he'll have no sorrow or they'll moderate moderate.
Yeah, he'll probably moderate is more likely to struggle at home or in public Like we'll give him to a sorrow more or a home room in more at home because he's not in front of everybody Yeah, cuz you're sort of ashamed to be seen doing this So there's a principle of law and reason which bids him to resist the sorrow as well as a feeling of misfortune Which forces him to indulge his sorrow do you see the two things right? There's the force to indulge and the force to resist right? These come from two opposing principles, right? And so he says one of them is a good thing and like you're supposed to follow the guidance of the law, right?
He says here's a here's a quote It's he says the law would say that to be patient under suffering is best and that we should not give way to impatience There's no knowing whether such things are good or evil right? Sometimes you have a good loss and it turns out that it's a good thing But perhaps he loses his son at a time of prosperity and the next ten years are times of incredible loss hardship and disease And he's glad that his son had been in a happy place before going Yeah, right depending on what your view of your life is sure. He says also because no human thing is of serious importance Apparently Plato's just like whatever about everything and grief stands in the way of that which at the moment is most required It's like you guys like what do you mean most required grief is standing away of it? He says that we should take counsel about what has happened and when the dice have been thrown order our affairs in the way Which reason means best not like children who have had a fall keeping hold of the part struck and wasting time and setting up a how Well, so he's like what we should do is take counsel and figure things out not like hold the part that hurts and go Like that But always a customing the soul forthwith to apply a remedy raising up that which is sickly and fallen Benishing the cry of sorrow by sorrow by healing thought the by the healing art So instead of like indulging in my sorrow like it's tempting the best thing is to take counsel figure things out and figure out How to heal that sorrow rather than indulging right the imitative art would have us indulge the sorrow, right?
So this is kind of like the boethius the boethius charge against the muses Yeah, the muses are the the yeah, like the key to go you've got dumped And he's just like listening to his room all day wants to stay sad instead of moving past it. So go like I don't know carpentry. Yeah, he says that the imitative art doesn't often imitate the calm and wise temperament partially because it's no fun It's not right. It's not much to appreciate or be imitated in a public festival.
Nobody likes that, right? His art isn't intended to please or affect the rational principle in the soul very rarely does someone say like this man has had a great loss Look how well he is doing like he has solved his sorrow by applying rational principles and feeling out You know like thinking through his philosophy and doing it well. That doesn't make for a good play, right? Um, so now we kind of put it next to the painter.
We have one where his creations I bet there has been some sort of like stoic play someone was like I'm gonna play about you know the stoic acceptance about things and it's just like super boring Yeah, yeah, he's concerned with the inferior part of the soul It's like a point and that the rational part should be the one that we are into and so we kick this guy out He's no good for us, right? It's and not only that but it harms rather than helping and he goes on to say like you at a play will feel very good in like Feeling sad for somebody who's had so great a loss, right? Yeah, somebody who's had trouble and then you'll feel more okay with Shopping around your sorrows for yourself, right? If you practice it in public you will practice it at home So maybe there are like crude jokes that you wouldn't be willing to make in public But then you go see a movie about it and you see somebody else doing it in public and then now you're like, all right?
I can maybe go do that at home and I'll play the fool, right? So basically it trains you that these affectations are okay because we're showing we're shopping around in public and they're not okay That's interesting The same is to be said of lust and anger and all the other affections desire pain and pleasure which are held to be inseparable from every action in all of them Poetry feeds and waters the passions instead of drying them up She lets the rule although they ought to be controlled if mankind are ever to increase happiness and virtue So play would not be done with Netflix. No, actually I think he would be directly he says that that's probably one of the worst things for our country is Netflix because it puts forward It's creating sentimentality. Yeah, it's only point is to incite your lusts desires sorrows frustrations It is it is playing to the basis nature of you How many Netflix shows have you seen where it's like this person has suffered a sorrow, but here's the truth of the matter, right?
No, one can say whether this is true or good. Here's their real situation Here's how they dealt with it. Well, and look how fine they're doing like that That doesn't happen and so instead of training the public to be People who can deal with their sorrows and their emotions well It trains the public to give in and to like not only perhaps indulge themselves But be okay with marting that to everybody else in the public sphere Okay, so I can see how Plato would not like that where you had some sort of Netflix show about somebody dealing with their sorrow and they had some sort of You know Milk toast lame moral at the end where it is gotta like live life and love people and you have some sort of like moral that Leaving yourself and do your best. You know, it just has some sort of thing I can see I'll play it will be like this is my right, but what would Plato say about a book?
That's also doing something similar, but to a greater quality like the comedy Yeah, or even yeah, listen. I don't know if it's raining and thunderstorming here right now. So also when we build a divine comedy There's Dante also doing something that is training the reader of how to deal with their own problems problems through this text But but I would contend that his most popular work is the one that incites the passions the most we are most excited to hear about the rust of Francesca and Paulo true we want to Are farting we want to hear the sick guys who fight each other and punch each other in the tummy Yeah, we want to hear about all these horrible things. How many people are like what's medieval Italian for tummy?
But even belly, but even play that when we built our city earlier said that the warriors still gets music Yeah, but the music is only that which and he actually talked about how we are allowed to have praise songs of the gods And those things that encourage us to perch you as for them It was like militant drums all in the happy mode none of them in minor key all saying what great like what the church I'm just trying to I'm trying to see if this new ones is correct of is he saying all poetry and all music and all art is bad Or is he saying most of it is bad? We need a couple like again We like two good songs he's saying imitative imitative poetry is bad right that poetry that like shops the lives of good men Yeah, like we could read a biography of Roosevelt see how that goes He's not saying that that's a bad thing looking at the real lives of real men and learning how to imitate their virtue or avoid their vices good So the comedy would be exempt from that criticism because at least as far as Dante is concerned Dante is describing what is as opposed to But that's like a biography was sort of describing what is I guess but Dante was not like that ever happened Yeah, but he probably has some kind of midlife crisis like is that what you mean when you say Graham Are you saying that the ghost of Virgil did not take Dante all the way through hell? Yes, I know through purgatory to please and in heaven for a lot of patience, but Are you trying to say but there is a real aspect to it of Dante's working out his stuff like yeah I guess I just don't I'm just trying to understand why that is Like Dante is not a real voyager to the underworld. He's just depicting it in a poem You know what you see you know what I mean like yeah, because there's art that is helpful Art that helps us figure things out or it shows us the right way to respond in certain situations Yeah, but there is also a lot of bad art and I guess I guess that's what I'm trying to figure out That's what Plato's trying.
What is he what is he actually against but I can see how yeah something like Netflix would would scandalize play Oh, and to creating sentimentality agent. You've taught you we both teach that from that It's not I think it's stone in Bell's book. There's one section where they talk about sentimentality mistakes in tone Yeah mistakes in tone, but did you catch the point that the author I guess it's stone Says that the sentimental people are often like more vicious people interesting Because they so he gives an example of a woman watching a movie with some sort of sentimental romance and also Like the kid next to her hating the movie and fidgeting and her like barking at the kid and then going back to the movie and crying There's some sort of like detachment from real emotion that comes from too much too much sort of manufactured emotion with sentiment that stories bring So anyway, it's kind of interesting. I'm really sort of like yeah fit that into a working theory yet But it seems like Plato's kind of he's not looking into the viciousness of sentimentality But he's definitely leading to the fact that these derivative arts can sort of produce a They're just inciting the passionate soul helping the rational soul through the past like simply said they are trying to delete the justice of the Person they are trying to make your body miss like disorganized.
Yeah, and I how much time do I have left twenty more minutes twenty more minutes? Okay, I don't know if we have enough time to discuss if we should actually be teaching Homer Sure or I mean like the listener can draw their own conclusions right he makes an argument against these things I would say that perhaps they're an inoculation like I don't think it's enough credit to the people who are viewing right But I think what's required is a good education in philosophy beforehand and when I can see the vices and others How is his creation of the city exempt from his criticism of derivatives so that's it doesn't actually And he himself has never ruled one and he's never been a warrior And but I think he would say like he is perhaps well organized as a person and so that's what he's trying to he's a just man So he's writing about being a justice and followers, so that's interesting I guess the question last time like that's interesting Right sure that that's the thing that distinguishes you like if Socrates had bad followers You know what I mean? Yeah, is that actually incredibly that's that's the things like he had great followers He made Aristotle and oh sure like he succeeded in drawing people to his wisdom, so he writes about wisdom He's not screwing around. He's the wisdom maker.
He's not emitter I'm not talking about when he's when he's accused of corrupting the youth like these are people who would have been the Socrates Hi, oh, yes, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
Just a character. Sorry. Sorry, but people who would have been like high Hypositioned well of government officials in Athens like reject all of that to go follow Socrates. Yeah.
Yeah I don't that speaks to his credit or against you Imagine people who are set up for life of wealth and power rejecting it to like go after truth in my word That's just can't even imagine what that would look like or for perfect. Yeah, terrible In Snoop Dogg kind of that I guess very briefly I just knew blind the funny thing is that he actually leaves room for poetry to make a defense. Oh, look She's real charm and I get it like glock-ons like yeah, I'm totally charmed by poetry He's like if she can make a good defense, then hey, we won't say no, right? Okay, that's fine We'll rock and roll and we'll let her back in but only if she can defend herself well And that's where the turn happens So that's the end of part one talking about why poetry is the dumps the part two is the immortal soul and wine being just as good So he starts with a defense of the immortal soul He says okay for everything there is an evil quality and a good quality the evil quality is sorry I know I'm moving kind of fast guys the evil quality is that thing which destroys so that which destroys corn is evil for the Corn like a corn disease.
Yeah grasshopper corn disease is it destroys it internally right at the band of the crop corn I would never talk about corn being a disease You're like one of the bands. They're kind of awesome. I mean, I'm not sure I'm not a fan of their bass player, but okay I remember I stayed away from the guys like corn in high school They were honestly very nice people You were one of them. I hung out with them good.
They listened to a lot of corn But I think it's like a mild of the beast they're also the system of the down Also a great man. Um anyway He says that thing which destroys it is the evil of that thing right, but the evil of the soul in justice vice Doesn't destroy the soul interesting and if it can't be destroyed from internally it certainly can't be destroyed externally Right the evil of the body is disease But the thing is is like you can get disease from food I can eat tainted food and then that will turn into an evil of the body right internal destruction And I say like get the runs And so he says like even that which is external because it cannot fur confer like say somebody stabs me They're not conferring injustice into my soul. They're not giving an evil of the soul Yeah, it's being sort of it can't be really destroyed from without and I think that's the premise I take issue with One says deviator right before he goes. Yeah, it says it is unreasonable to suppose that anything can perish from without Through affection of external evil which could not be destroyed from within by a corruption of its own So I cannot say that like something could get destroyed from without if it can't even get destroyed from within and injustice certainly doesn't destroy it In fact injustice usually seems to keep in unjust people alive, right?
Like if I'm a murderer murder is gonna keep me going So it doesn't do good things for you and so he says the soul therefore is probably Immortal right it's not dissolved by merely external evils and certainly not dissolved by internal evils So but the more people you kill don't should become like a worse person on the inside become like a jerk Yeah, but the soul isn't destroyed. It's still there, but it's worse. So sick. Yes, it's sick But I can't die can't die and he says what we see as the soul is kind of like and he compares it to a like a sea god It's like our imagine of I think the sea gods name is cloud con something I forget but he says it's kind of like that guy how he's been buffeted by the sea so often and totally covered in seashells and Seaweed and sand and stuff.
We don't know what he really looks like. He looks disgusting Right, that's the same situation the soul is in and if we can see it for its truth Then we could see it at its best which is mer man mer man Oh man, we could see it's love for wisdom, right? And then he says okay now that we sort of won our argument right the just man We did it the just man is the better man Okay, let's enumerate the benefits that aren't that we sort of stripped from it in the very beginning He refers back to his first couple chapters where remember their supposition that we take away the reputation of the just man Right see if it's good to be just just without the reputation that comes Okay, now that we've established that it is Let's restore all the things that we took away in supposition the good reputation that comes for it the good monetary gains The good like all the things that forsake of argument We sort of took away from the just man because it's true the gods love the just man and they make everything work out for the good You'll be popular people will love you right you'll have success in business You'll have great kids all of these things beyond the internal good that comes from being just are things that usually accompany justice And then but that's the thing is the soul is immortal The just soul doesn't end with death it goes into the afterlife and then he paints this awesome picture of the afterlife and by means of a story This is totally different than what we can do it like he's been arguing up until now the argument about the eternal soul as far as I can tell Is the last one after that he tells a story of the afterlife Crowned laurel good men get crowns. Okay, so he says let me tell you the story of a fella named Er okay, er fella named er the son of Arminius a pymplian he was pymplian he got killed in battle And 10 days afterward when they took up all the bodies his was found unaffected by decay looked fine They took him and they stuck him on the funeral pyre two days later still looked okay But I guess I don't know what the logic was there for everybody else.
They're like my what right probably fine Like we could probably burn this guy, right? He hasn't decayed, but she'd be fine I wonder if he wasn't a kid now like like go ahead and check his breathing hold the mirror up guys make an effort But apparently maybe he was a jerk people didn't like him because they're like let's burn this stinker So they had him on the funeral pyre and he popped up right and he said guys Let me tell you what it was like in the other world. Okay, okay So when I when I died 12 days ago, this was a 12-day journey He said I found myself in like this big field and there were judges in sort of an intermediate space And then two openings into heaven and two openings into the earth like judges just in the field Yeah, the judges and they're basically telling you where you go This is very heaven hell kind of thing and if you did good in your life Then you make you go up to the heavens and you spend your a thousand years being rewarded He said the lifespan is about a hundred years right men live men can live about a hundred years And so whatever you did that was good you received the benefits a hundred times like 10 times over So if I was really nice to somebody over the next 10 lifetimes, I would get that 10 times right so everything I did I suffered 10 10 x returns the same was true of hell if I was a horrible person Then I would be tossed into hell to suffer all of those things returned on me 10 times over And that's what's been happening to these people for a thousand years So they go up for a thousand years and then they come back and they hang out in the little trail again Right in the field in the field And so but there's that's the thing is some of the guys were so bad that when they came out of hell And then expected to like ascend into heaven and take another trip or go back to life or whatever The mouth of heaven basically roars and says no they will never enter here And then I kid you not fiery devils Huh come it says uh Whenever any of these incurable sinners or someone who had not been sufficiently punished tried to ascend Then wild men of fiery aspect who were standing by and heard the sound seized and carried them off Through them down flayed them with scurges and dragged them along the road at the side Carving them on thorns like wool and declaring to the passerby that what were their crimes what they were being taken away to be cast into hell These guys did not get out rough that stinks. Yeah, seriously So after eight days of like hanging out So you're in the meadow if uh when the spirits were in the meadow had carried seven days on the eighth day They were obliged to proceed on their journey and after four days of journey You came to a place where they could see above a line of light straight as a column And so this is where it gets a little weird.
I think what they're doing is painting a picture of the universe as the spheres This is where it gets weird. Okay, it gets way weirder And so there's like a giant chain that hooks into a series of concentric bowls I like ranging here. Yeah, like uh, like yeah, I like a big range They call them whorls whorls whorls whorls whorls And there's eight of them and I think that's the spheres as far as I can tell And that big chain that hooks from the heavens into those whorls spins and it spins all of these whorly bowls Right, right and uh and it goes into great detail about these whorls And it's basically a big spindle and everything spins around it So the first and outermost whorl has the rim broadest and the seven inner whorls are narrower in the following proportions The sixth is next to the fifth and size. It goes in great detail great Don't need to go there But the largest or fixed stars is spangled and the seventh the sun is brightest Okay, the eighth or moon color so it goes on to talk about the different spheres So the whorls sound like the medieval spheres.
I think so except they're in the wrong order, which is weird I don't really understand it, but it says it's only their 12 days You got the moon and they're like sure Yeah, you're going back at the end of the week So they turn on the knees of necessity, right? And on the upper surface of each circle is a siren who goes around with them humming a single tone or note Right, I think this would be the rhythm or song of the spheres Right, so each one has an intelligence spins with the sphere and kind of goes Like as they go past right and on them are three of them are the fates, right? Laquisis seeing of the past Clotho the present and Atropos the future And what they do they arrive and they have to go see laquisis But first they stop at a profit who ranges them in order and they all kind of shake lots And then before them are laid brand new lives to choose from And they can sort of look at them, there's all kinds of things You could be a bird, you could be a duck, you could be like cat You could turn into a woman if you want, you could try something else, whatever you choose And by lots you get first choice or last choice, right? There you go But she says let the wise not be hasty and choose well And after you choose your life you get your genius, which is your intended spirit And then you're ushered off and I'll talk about what happens right after that So she warns them, but the thing is your vice or virtue in the past will help determine how you make that decision So the first guy that chooses in this little parrot To help you make the decision or it's like the category of things you can pick for always It helps you don't be at all and like So for example, the first guy who chooses a tyrant And he immediately chooses again, or like he's a jerk He immediately chooses the life of a tyrant It's great He's trying to jerk things all over it He gets all these pleasures, everyone has to listen to him, but he was hasty And he didn't realize that he chose a life where he actually has to eat his kids And he's like, oh no And he starts blaming everybody like Chance and the gods and that's the thing Look, he just said just said like, don't be hasty, you idiots And so everyone else chooses and it actually talks about some famous people that choose So here's kind of a fun list Let's see, make it so more just, last comer, have it only, no philosophy So Orpheus chooses, I don't know who Orpheus is, but he chooses a life of the swan Because he didn't like women Um, I don't know why swans are against one, I don't know Apparently, they hate each other The, and then we have, this was the 20th lot The person who got to chose 20th and this was Ajax And he chose to be a lion because he remembered that the injustice of man that had been done to him At the choosing of Achilles' arms Oh I'll be a hammer!
Exactly, he's like, I'm gonna break stuff and I don't want to be a people Same is true of Agamemnon, he chose an eagle because he hated human nature By the reason of his sufferings Thursites, the jester Mm-hmm He decided to be a monkey Because he was a bit of a goof Odysseus And he was last, having yet to make the choice And he looked and he's like, I just want a quiet life of a quiet man With no cares Like private, no toils, I just want a quiet life And he went and he looked and lo and behold, there it was No one else had the wisdom to choose An unimportant life of a quiet man with no cares And it's what he would have chosen first Just because that was the wisdom that drove his decision And then you all take it to Lechesis And then, uh, you kind of get your genius, it leads to your souls to Clotho And then she attaches him to a sphere And then figures out your destiny And then you go to a tropos who spins the threads and makes me reversible And then you pass through the throne of necessity And you march onto the plane of forgetfulness Which is apparently a barren waste with nothing there And it's terrible And then you encamped by the river of unmindfulness So how did Erm rose? Oh yeah So it gets to it Um, each one drinks from this river And forgets the whole thing Yeah, basically you forget everything you knew In the middle of the night, there's a thunderstorm and an earthquake And you are driven upward like a shooting star And you're back in the earth, right? And you've forgotten everything that's happened You've forgotten your choice And you are destined to grow and learn and change And maybe choose a new life And maybe choose a different life on your next cycle Because Plato maintains that Nothing eternal is ever destroyed So this is an argument of the episode So we'll continue And not only that, but souls are never made The amount of souls never increases or diminishes Because then mortal things will be making Immortal things, that'll make sense At least to Plato But Err, our guy, wasn't compelled to drink And he couldn't exactly say how he found himself Lying on the funeral pyre He's like, I didn't do the drinking I didn't do the thing they did But now I'm here And that's my story And here is the very last bit of Plato Chapter 10 Wherefore, let's see And thus glaucon, the tale has been saved And has not perished And will save us if we are obedient to the word spoken And we shall pass safely over the river of forgetfulness Forgetfulness And our soul will not be defiled Wherefore, my counsel Is that we hold fast ever to the heavenly way And follow after justice and virtue always Considering that the soul is immortal And able to endure every sort of good And every sort of evil Thus shall we live, dear to one another And to the gods Both while remaining here And when, like conquerors in the games Who go round together gifts We receive our reward And it shall be well with us Both in this life And in the pilgrimage of a thousand years Which we have been describing That's the end So maybe you could have been any Maybe you were Socrates Because I haven't been anything Socrates chose the life of a banker turned Baker turned educator Turn educator He's like, I want to be rich first And then I want to teach kids The no-care That's interesting So there you go The two parts and the last part is the story About the eternal soul And the thousand year journey So what's justice? Justice is the true organization of the inner self And that same outward organization of the state Whereas it's ruled and directed By those most capable to rule and direct it Everyone is doing their part And keeping their nose clean And not everybody else's business And the same is true in the soul You keep your passions at the bottom And you enforce their movement with your will And that's kind of illustrated by He talked about that guy who lost his kid And he's like, okay, he has two options To indulge in his morning Or to get after it and fix the problem Apply the healing art to his soul And move on That's good Interesting I feel like we need to have like a Plato wrap up one I mean, it's just like you were saying There's other things to talk about So much With the teaching of stories And that kind of You know, does go against the idea That the study of humanities at some points For some level or the argument Is that there's a liberating factor That is making the human soul more free But Plato's saying that it's Making you more sentimental Or it's not actually giving wisdom Or benefit to Him and Boethius seem to agree Yeah, that's interesting I think that's interesting We have to wrap up here And I do want to give a preview for next week I know I've still got Genghis Khan on the list It's still interesting at home But I'm working on the Poetic Eddas Which is the source for all of the Old Norse myths Can you bring some mead?
I've actually found a great mead source The mead floweth, Graham The mead flow That's a mead source Because it's not Clearly you're buying it from the store, right? No, I'm like, there's actually a place in Austin That makes it really good First and fourth from the north That's what I'm gonna say Well, it's me who can be said to be really good I've never had a good mead It's always really gross Yeah, it's really sweet I've never had mead It's honey, honey booze But it's like the most heavy metal set of myths I've ever heard in my entire life It's fantastic Cool, yeah, anyway Alright, anything else before we wrap up? I'm good Alright, this has been classical stuff You should know You can find us online at classicalstuff.net You can email us at theguysatclassclesstuff.net You can find us on Twitter at classicalstuffclstf C-L-S-S-C-A-L stuff You can find us on patreon, patreon.com We've got to add that to our ex- Extra! Is it outro?
Extra! Is it really about me faulting? It's really about the actual extra It's a very bad movie that's called Extra as well Oh, is that like where it's really extra? No, I don't think it's about it I'm extra Yep, nailed it Alright, that has been it for us As always, it is Graham, AJ and Thomas Thank you all for listening And we will see you next week Bye-bye Bye-bye