*13.3 Makkos Daf 09 A (8 lines Dn)*

*13.3 Makkos Daf 09 A (8 lines Dn)*_*Suggestion:* Before listening to the recording take a minute and review yesterday’s gemara. It will help to lock it in in your mind, and today’s gemara will flow better!_*Summary**Another version* of the foregoing discussion: *One _possuk_ states* “These [sanctuary] cities will be for you _(the bnei Yisroel)_ *and for the _ger (toshav)_* amongst you”. *Another possuk states* “The sanctuary cities will be *for you”* . And we understand “But not for the _ger toshav_ ”. So it’s a contradiction.*Rav Kahana:* The second _possuk_ refers to *a _ger toshav_ who killed a Yisroel* _(galus is not enough for him; he’s put to death),_ and the first _possuk_ refers to a *_ger toshav_ who killed another _ger toshav_ .**Challenge: Beraisa: A _ger toshav_ or a gentile* who murdered, is put to death.We don’t distinguish between the victims of a gentile, and even if he murdered a gentile, not a Yisroel, he is put to death. So *it seems that we don’t distinguish between the victims of the _ger toshav_* either.*Rav Chisda:* The ger toshav goes into _galus_ when he killed with a downward blow, just like a Yisroel (10.1-10.5). But *the beraisa refers to when he killed with an upward blow* . Since even a Yisroel does not go into _galus_ for upward killing, the _ger toshav_ cannot go into _galus_ and is executed. See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate