Skip to content
130: Why English teachers ARE liars episode artwork

Sep 1, 2020 1 hr 4 min

130: Why English teachers ARE liars

from Classical Stuff You Should Know Hosted by A.J. Hanenburg

In this episode, we discuss a psychological reading of Beowulf, and why it fails to approach the text honestly. Weirdly, we all agree. The whole crew. It's strange.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

130: Why English teachers ARE liars

0:00 1:04:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi, welcome to Classical Stuff You Should Know. We are a podcast about classical education in the world of old stuff. We are three guys that like talking about this. We work at a classical school here in Austin, Texas called Veritas Academy.

And classics, we love them. It's good stuff, rock and roll, nailed it. My name is Graham Donaldson and I am here with my associates, my colleagues, Mr. Arthurian Hannenberg.

That's me. And Mr. Thomas Mayby. Hello, associates.

I feel like we got that promoted or something. Well, I feel like the associates, that feels a little cold. Oh, sorry, what would you rather call my brothers? Hello.

Well, we're good. I feel like, yeah, I'm gonna do what I think we should probably be doing and then say, like, we've been only talking about the Patreon, like the end of the episode and everyone stops listening. So we have, just before we get into the podcast, we have set up a Patreon page where there's some little extra goodies that you can, if you are a subscribed member on our Patreon, you can get access to. And I forgot them.

What are they? What are the benefits? $5 level, you get all of our episodes, which will be ad-free, even as we add on ads to this regular podcast. We also offer some additional talks that we've given outside of the podcast.

You can access those through the Patreon at the $10 a month level. You get access, you can ask us questions for a monthly Ask Us Anything. You also, that's where you get the between banter, right? And the banter between the episodes.

That's right, we have very interesting and elucidating banter in between episodes where we talk about such topics as... The modern global order and Bitcoin. That's right, we talk about Bitcoin. We've talked about my theory about that we're living in the 19th century.

We talked about rappers a little while ago. We did. Did you delete that one, or is that actually going to go up? I thought it was last week.

We talked about it before, a while ago. Anyway, so we got some fun banter where we're just like getting the episodes set up. Yeah, you're just gonna hear what we talk about in between, which is some of my favorite stuff. It's kind of fun stuff.

And then, what's the last level? At $20 a month, you get to propose topics for us to talk about, propose and then vote on topics for us to talk about. And you also eventually... And we'll do them.

Hello. Well, we'll do them. We won't. We'll do it.

And also get to help us decide on merchandise and other stuff that we would sell as part of the podcast. And also, yeah, giving thoughts on other... Like helping us shape the direction of where the podcast will go. That's why we call them Aristotelians.

They're the best of us. So, cool. And so maybe if I wanted to do that, where would I find that? You would find that at patreon.com/classicalstuff.

Rock and roll. Okay. I'm feeling very salesy right now. That's very good.

I mean, no, I like it. Okay. So we are, now, if I looked at the notes properly, we're talking about my ability, that I lie to children. You're a liar.

I'm a liar. Yeah, your profession is lying. I like that you pretend that we have notes for these episodes. That's the real joke.

That's the real punchline of yours. Yeah, they can see us on YouTube now. Crap, I got all the mystique. Nobody's fooled.

No, you just put the paper in front of the microphone and hope that it makes it sound like we're shuffling papers. All right. Yes. So today is my episode.

Usually, I don't know if Graham says this on air usually, but before most of his episodes, he'll say, I don't know if I'm actually gonna fill an hour. I'm actually feeling that way right now. So we'll see how this goes. I don't think I'm gonna fill an hour next week.

Have you... Okay, but when has that ever happened? So this is a short one. Then rock and roll.

I'm fine with that. Are you saying I do not eschew surplage? Why? What's the word that is that from?

The style guide? The Stone Bell? That's... I don't think that's Stone Bell.

That is Mark Twain's version of the Stone Bell rule, which was... Before the short is the longer. That's my Wi-Fi password for a while. Eschew surplage.

I figured no one would get it. That's a good one. Oh crap. You have to change your password now.

Seriously, you have to change your password now. Do you have a bank password? What's your social security number? Bitcoin full life.

I would actually believe that 100%. This is a good episode. AJ led those on how to write gooder, I think is the title, is where those come from. So if you wanna write gooder, you should listen to those.

Okay, so the topic for today is vague and amorphous, as most of mine are. So as a part of posting our videos to YouTube, by the way, all of our episodes are up on YouTube if you want to go listen to them there. That gave me a chance to revisit a lot of our old topics to remind myself of what we talked about years ago at this point. What episode number are we on roughly at this point?

Are we counting quarantine stuff you should know? I don't think so. We do have a good 15 or 20 in there. I don't think those count.

So I think we're up in the 120s. Is that it? So whatever, this is 80 episodes ago. Then we had an episode called Why English Teachers Aren't Liars.

It's a great episode. It's episode 45. Go listen to it if you want to. Graham led a discussion on a theme in Romeo and Juliet, and he presented this evidence.

And it's super frustrating because AJ agreed with it. There was no conflict. It was just way too happy happy. So...

That's the way the world works. Nope, it isn't. So today we're gonna try to get on a similar idea of what that episode was getting at. And listener, don't worry.

We'll get into what that idea is. So I don't actually have a title for this episode. It's probably something more akin to why English teachers are liars or potentially the limits of allegory because I like bombastic titles like that. But as an introduction to what we'll actually spend our time talking about, I don't know what fear and dread you all bring in coming into your episodes, but you know, I had my moment a few days ago realizing I needed to come up with a topic and, you know, rushing through my notes to find something and found a quote from a book that I read years ago that I've always wanted to get your, y'all's reaction to.

So we're gonna do that live on air. Ready to react. Yeah, so if you could be just like filled with rage, that would really make my day. No, I'm just, I'm getting into a place where maximum reaction.

Wow. I do a lot of YouTube unboxings, so I'm already ready for this. You're really used to this. I do a lot of reaction videos, but that's only like excitement, isn't it?

Like, what about... Well, I also do reaction videos to like what PewDiePie says last week. Like I watch other videos and I do reaction videos. Tell me anything PewDiePie said last week.

Just anything. Go for it. He said like, well, I'm a, I'm a Norwegian. I'm a guy.

I love my wife. Oh, he's married? Yeah, he married Marzia. Who's Marzia?

It's like his girlfriend. Okay, cool. Great. She's his home star runner's girlfriend?

Marzia? That's Marzipan. Oh, that's different. Okay, this is, we're off to a good start.

Okay, so we will be... What's happened? Oh, do you want to do more home star runner impersonations? That would be a much better episode if we did that.

So I will be reading a section from a book by David White. Do you all know David White? Nope. So I'll be talking about a book of his from the 90s.

And I'll get to that in a second. It's not classical. It's not classical, but we'll get into a class. Like the 90s.

Like 0090. 90, like only a few years after. That feels a little cold. Oh, sorry.

What would you rather call them? My brothers. Oh. Wow.

Look at that. Like, yeah. I'm going to do what I think we should probably be doing and then say, like, we've been only talking about the Patreon, like the end of the episode, and everyone stops listening. So we have, just before we get into the podcast, we have set up a Patreon page where you, there's some little extra goodies that you can, if you are a subscribed member on our Patreon, you can get access to.

And I forgot them. What are they? What are the benefits? $5 level, you get all of our episodes, which will be ad-free, even as we add on ads to this regular podcast.

We also offer some additional talks that we've given outside of the podcast. You can access those through the Patreon at the $10 level. You get access, you can ask us questions for a monthly Ask Us Anything. You also...

That's where you get the between banter, right? And the banter between the episodes. Oh, that's right. We have very interesting and elucid I'm not trying to derail you on this, but someone else who does this kind of thing and has gotten popularity for doing this kind of thing is Jordan Peterson.

He does that with the Bible and I think he's done with Pinocchio. This kind of modern psychology using these sort of psychological readings, very Jungian readings of these stories to talk about human personalities and that kind of stuff for the purpose of like something practical, the practicality in the workplace or your own life. I think Peterson did one with The Lion King. Yeah.

I hope he's doing well. He had a rough, he had like a breakdown. He was ill or had a, he was uh. He only been eating red meat for like four months.

No, no. Yeah, well that too, but yeah, anyway. I don't know the details of that. No, do I.

I just, I don't really, it's not really a story I follow. Um, AJ, I mean, this is a book that you teach. Do you have any, do you have any thoughts on White's approach so far? Again, I'll give you a longer example in a second if you want to think more about it, but does anything strike you as we dive into this?

Um, so a couple of things. We do know where Grendel within AJ, we do know where they came from. They came from Cain's clan, right? So that's one thing.

And when he talks about our disowned side, that must be what he's referring to is Cain, right. Cain and their bunch. Because we know that that's where they descend from. That's interesting because White doesn't explicitly bring that in, but you might agree with what he's saying, but actually have a deeper, like, you know, there is a part of us that's the evil side, which would be the Cain side.

Yeah, exactly. I'm not, I'm not disagreeing with you. Cain as in like Cain and Abel Cain? Yeah.

Cain. Like that's supposedly where demons come from. We also know where they live. Like she lives in a specific mirror that they go and find and you know, will swims in.

It's filled with lizards. A mirror? A mirror. Mirror, like the water.

Like yeah, like an actual mirror. Where the cats come from. You can find it at night. So, that's not added how good that joke is.

Sorry. He already said where the cats come from, the meerkats. Sorry, cats. Anyway, I, I wonder at the compulsion to take these readings and make them allegorical when I'm not sure they were in the first place.

Yeah, you tripped AJ's like, AJ hates this stuff. The allegorical readings. Like, uh, it seems, it seems like a reduction, right? This was, this story would have originally been told by a Bard who was singing it to a group of people in like a castle, right out of feast, right?

They would have had, it was entertainment and entertainment is supposed to be a fun story. I don't know that it was originally written with allegory in mind or with symbolism in mind. Like we can read all sorts of symbolism into it, but at some point I wonder if it isn't just a, a story of a Viking killing monsters, right? This was my point in the English teachers not liars podcast though.

Kind of with a different point. I think you want to say what you think. Well, it's just that if you're going to do that, the text needs to give you enough clues that it wants you to do that. So the example that I gave that we're doing in Romeo and Juliet is the fact that, that there are so many allusions to light and dark and so many allusions to religious conversion, you then are allowed or, um, your, your case has a little more credence because all of this, these sort of motifs are sprinkled throughout act one.

And if this is confusing, listen back and listen to that. But, um, so that leads you to say like, okay, it's probable because of this motif that we can make, we can sort of say this analogy, allegory that Romeo is like the dark and Juliet is like the light because the text has sort of given you enough breadcrumbs to do it. Sure. I will say the main reason I wanted to do another episode, first off, the next section is the one where I'll be curious how you two respond and if it's different or not.

But your point in that, in that last episode was primarily around a theme within the work itself and whether Shakespeare is using this as a theme within the work. He wants to be like a, like a universal theme experience. Yes, yes. And so he's doing something, what's the best way to say it?

It's like the application of this book to say that, well, Grendel is actually, or what Grendel's mother actually is, is the mother of your problems, which is the problem you must deal with. Does that make sense? Like it's not only within the book. It's then to say, how do we apply this book to our lives?

That's the next step that White is attempting to do here. And I'm curious if we like what he does here, what reaction. I don't mind application. I mind that if he says that is what this is about, it reduces the story to something lesser.

Sure. Right. In my opinion, a lot of the allegorical readings, unless it really is allegory, do so. They say this is about that, right?

Instead of Grendel's mother being what she truly is, which is a horrible monster descendants of Cain that steals her son's arm from a group of people that took it as a trophy, right? There's a lot you can talk about there, but if I say what she is is the mother of your problems and Grendel is only representative of your problems. Yes. I miss out on maybe another, a lot of other readings that could also happen.

My, my, um, criticism of this kind of, not criticism, but my third thought on the sort of thing is once you kind of, yeah, it's, it's sort of piggybacking on what AJ says. I hate that phrase, piggybacking anyway, whatever. Hop on your bro. It's not going to be awkward at all.

Um, it's like once you say that you're doing that, like it's, it's sort of the art of doing it. So if someone was saying like, Oh man, I just can't, I just can't quit drinking. I'm just going to like throw away all my booze. And someone came to them and said, you don't kill Grendel, you kill Grendel's mom, right?

And that person knew the thing they were talking about. Okay. That's sort of like an artfully applied lesson, right? But then to sort of, um, just sort of sit down and say like, here's how we can use literature to solve our problems.

Like, um, I don't know, there's just something, yeah, reductionistic about doing it that way. Even though I don't think maybe, I think maybe the practicality of what he's doing is correct, but it's, it's basically what he's doing is he's, he's giving an analytical tool. Here's how you can read books to do X, Y, or Z or to help you improve yourself. But if, um, but if that's the only tool that people bring to stories, then you're then at best, you're just going to reduce the story.

At worst, you're going to be able to like say whatever, any story can sort of justify or say whatever you want. Exactly. Yeah, that was my, what I was just going to say was it leaves the door open for me to make really any plausible interpretation. Like my own, my own motivations I can bring to the text.

So there needs to be like a guiding ethos behind the story. Right. And then like the story is a sort of a portal to that, to using that guiding ethos. Does that make sense?

Yeah, we will get there. We'll get there. Cool. And I don't know.

Uh, let me, let me keep on with, um, the example he does and how he is applying this method to it. And then we'll try and kind of piece the stuff together at the end. Sounds good. Um, so this is a longer section.

At any point, please interrupt me. Otherwise I'll just ramble for three pages, which I guess is most of what I do on this podcast. But anyway, feel free to cut it. If something especially makes you mad or you love it, just jump in and say so.

Uh, this is if you're following along at home, which would be insane. We're on page 54 of the heart aroused. So whatever, live your life. Uh, let's do whatever you want to.

I'm not your dad, whatever. Okay. Glad in his web of rings, Beowulf leaps into the water and sinks to the very bottom of the lake where Grendel's mother waits for him. These are, there are clear, marvelous details etched into the story at this point.

They will find the great sword hunting, hunting, hunting, hunting, hunting, given to him by the Danes to help him in his pitch. Black travail is useless against this chee monster, as is another gift from above the Danish King's helmet. He is forced to throw them away and wrestle barehanded with Grendel's mother locked together in a death like embrace. They tumble into her den where Beowulf sees glowing on the wall and unknown but marvelous sword.

He breaks the chain on his hilt and with a sudden blow killed Grendel's mother with the glowing blade. So these are accurate descriptions of what happens in the story. Roughly accurate descriptions of what happens in the story. Okay.

So then we move into interpretation. However well we arrange for our self protection beforehand, our preparations This is that he is abusing the story and ignoring pertinent details or making it fit his interpretation. And that drives me crazy. Yeah, so this is the danger of that sort of view is the, well, actually guy.

I'm not saying that it's real. I'm not saying that it's real. No, I'm saying that as like, like, that's the problem. It's like, if you're going to, if you're going to draw major significance from details, then the details need to be.

Don't get the details straight. Then you can't ignore other pertinent details. Like, yes, his technology didn't work, but other technology he brought with him did. And he found more technology.

But AJ, do you think that if he incorporated all of those details and then brought in a reading, that you'd be cool with it? I would be more cool with it. But wouldn't you still have a problem with the way that significance is attached to what seem like details in the story? So I always feel a little uncomfortable with that when I don't think the original author intended it.

I don't, I think this story was written as a monster story. I don't think the author was thinking like, this is the representation. And I get it. If you want to interpret something about your psychology, like, we all go through things like this.

And if you want to talk about that, like, look, man, sometimes you got to deal with your problems. Grendel, he really was a problem. And then you got to deal with the thing that sired it and, and really ferret out all the last little bits. I'm totally fine with that interpretation.

It's true in the story as it is in human life because the story somewhat mirrors human life. What I don't like is when he is, it seems like he's pushing the story as a square peg into the round hole of his interpretation, ignoring pertinent details, and that drives me nuts. Is there anything, is Beowulf just like born super special or do they talk about that in the story? He's actually ignored largely in his, in his home of the Aes.

When they send him off to go help the Danes, they didn't, they didn't think he was this big, big amazing thing. And then he proved his worth over in Daneland, right? Yeah. And then when he came back, everyone's like, dang, this guy's the real deal.

And then he wasn't even immediately made king. Um, his, his Lord had a son and that son eventually died and Beowulf was going to help usher him into kingship. That son dies because he made a foolish decision and housed some guys he shouldn't have in his home. And then Beowulf takes over once the kid is gone.

Okay. And so it's not like everyone instantly renowned him as this great, wonderful thing when he said he was going to do what he was going to do and fight Grendel, nobody knew if he could really do it. Okay. That's at this point, it's like pulling out small details, but there's some part of this where, like, he has trained and prepared in such a way to be in combat.

Like, that's the thing that makes him ready to face, um, Grendel's mom. Sure. You know what I mean? The preparation is actually super useful.

It's why he survives any of it. All the points you've drawn out of the technology actually helps him, right? The, the chainmail helps him sink to the bottom of the, No, he swims to the bottom. And the chainmail, at one point in the story, he actually swims with chainmail and a sword on top of the water for a very long time.

So they're, they're not even like totally square on whether chainmail helps you sink or float, but he swims to the bottom and then he finds the mother, he fights the mother for a little bit, and then she drags him to the layer. And that's where he finds the sword, kills her, cuts off Grendel's head and then brings Grendel's head back. And they don't have to drag it back. As far as I know, that takes less than a day.

It's like evening when they finally roll in and yeah, his chainmail is integral because she's got these big claws that would kill him otherwise. Sure. Graham, am I misunderstanding? Are you more sensitive to this?

More okay with this reading, I guess. I am. I am. But then my stipulation is always, um, the story then, like you got, the details need to be able to drive that interpretation.

Sure. Seems like we're agreeing. I'm okay with an interpretation as it applies to life, but y'all get the details right. The reading has to be honest.

And I think you have to acknowledge, but also I like to acknowledge when I don't think the author intended it, but it does mirror life. But that's what I'm asking of. Does it matter what was intended in the first place to pull on details and say this one detail means technology is bad is probably not what the author would have thought. Right.

Or we don't know, I guess is more specific. Yeah. If I was the author, I'd be cranky about it. Sure.

That's fair. These are all fair points. Okay. So that is what David White does in this section.

Uh, I guess to just full disclosure for me, I could not finish this book. I love David White. I love consolations. He has another book called The Three Marriages, which is very good.

It's about, um, work and relationships and like hobbies. Like it's a, it's a very good book. Um, but this one I couldn't finish mostly because, uh, well, I guess because of these first few chapters, because I think these are bad readings of Beowulf. I don't know Beowulf as well as AJ does, but it's this pulling on details and putting too much weight on each one of them that bothered me in reading it.

And so I just stopped reading it. So that for whatever that's worth for me. Um, but bravo, Maggie. Yeah, thanks.

Welcome. Welcome. Welcome. What do you mean?

You're in the, you're in the club of the malcontents. We've just had him. I feel like I've already talked trash about enough people on this podcast. Anyway, David White, I very much respect you.

Please listen to our podcast. Um, now I think this matters less for Beowulf, but matters, uh, the same thing that White is doing with Beowulf. I think he's done all the time in reading scripture. I won't go too much into this, but for Patreon listeners, I'll post a talk I've given called Reading Scripture for Interpretation about bad ways that, um, scripture can be used to apply to certain situations.

Usually, anyway, go listen to the talk. I think it's kind of okay. Um, the problem I think that's happening here, and I want to see if you all agree with this or maybe not. So I guess you're getting at a, you know more of the details than I do to say he gets parts of it wrong.

My problem is that he's, this maybe AJ is exactly what you said. He's taking good practical advice and, um, graphing it onto a story where it wasn't in the story before. So like, if you took out the Beowulf part and you just kept the advice that was, don't depend on your technology too much, that's good advice regardless. And deal with the thing that is causing you fear.

Yes. Like those, like, you don't need the story to make those points. And so there's kind of no point to having the story. Does that make sense?

He's using the story as a prop. Yes. Or trying to use it to give credibility to his argument when the book doesn't actually do that. When otherwise it just seems like a platitude.

Yes. I don't know about, I guess it would be a platitude. It seems like one. If he just literally had a chapter that was like, you know, face your fears, you know what I mean?

Um, so, but it's more like a persuasion technique at that point to say, like, this deep secret is actually in Beowulf. Um, but the, the one, I guess all things are like tensions and contradictions. Um, he's applying a method. Um, one of you pointed and called it allegory earlier.

And I think that's the right word for it. Um, and it's one, that's a method of reading I'm not generally comfortable with. Um, but I, what's the right way to say this? Have you all ever had students read a book and get some like huge impactful takeaway from it that you've never read into that book?

Yes. And sure. Is it wrong that they did that? No.

So, so help me. Those feel like disconnected. Well, maybe they're disconnected. It's only interesting or if they're right.

Well, um, if they get a right to take away from the book in the place. No, it's a takeaway. Like, um, if the takeaway can fit with the rest of the book. So if, so, okay.

Uh, think about it this way. So there's like, um, when you read a book or poem, um, uh, you can read it. So there's poems that I will read or a book that I will read and it will give me, it will remind me of something and I will get a great amount of the same with songs, with music. So you now have like personal connotations with songs.

So you listen to a song. I listened to the White Stripes elephant and I am back in first year university. And I can feel it. And so then that gives it like, I associate that with like youth and freedom and the sort of like really fun, interesting time of life.

And it's not necessarily in that album. Right. That's not what the If you are using the skill improperly, it's going to bite you at some point. Let me try for what a few of these tools or methods or whatever might be called or named.

We already pointed to one, which is allegory. I think the way to think of this is that you are taking only the story itself and immediately trying to apply it to your life situation. So this was AJ's critique earlier. It's both a critique and like literally the definition of allegory.

Beowulf is no longer Beowulf. He becomes a symbol for the conquering of man over difficult situations or Grendel is no longer Grendel, but becomes an image for, you know, unknown evil from outside the civilization or whatever. The characters are no longer themselves. They become, again, symbols for something else.

That's an allegorical reading. They are dangerous because you can very quickly lose the core of the book or the message of the book. If your first time reading through Beowulf, you're like, what does Beowulf mean on page two? You don't know what the book is about.

You know what I mean? You are drawing messages from it that might have nothing to do with what the story is actually about. I think that's a danger of allegory. I think one of the great dangers of allegory and drawing my own conclusions from things like that is that it inoculates me against what C.S.

Lewis says is the reason we read old books, to have the attitudes of the old world impress themselves upon us and to inoculate us against the attitudes of our own world. If every book I read, I'm like, here's the lesson that fits right in with my life, I'm not actually learning from the book. I'm putting my current learning on the book. I don't actually get their old attitudes.

Beowulf is from a time that is totally alien to us. It's very different. And if my solution is, don't trust technology, I don't think that ever went across Beowulf's head at all. Swords are good.

Swords are good. We had swords forever. What technology are you talking about? And like, he brought a sword in the first place, right?

He thought it was good. Yeah, we've had chain mail for a hundred years. There's no such thing as new technology. I took the technology that we have, right?

Let me take that point and still, so allegory would be, I apply the book just directly to my life, and all these details become symbols. Another method, which I think is closer to what you're saying there, but it's still, I think, an inferior reading, is to read the book itself, have some understanding of what the book is about, and then apply that lesson to my life. So, said differently, I've read all of Beowulf, and I know that there are parts of the story that are about growing old and passing on power to the next generation, or there are lessons about bravery in the story that I can apply to my life right now. I think that's still a weaker reading because, I think it's because of what you just said, though, AJ, that because the context is so different from where we are right now, I can't take a lesson from 3,000, how old is this book?

This one was probably 9 to 1,100, somewhere around there. But I can't take a really old book and immediately apply it to my situation right now because 2020 is different from when Beowulf was being written. Does that make sense? Yeah, that's true in some ways, but in some other ways, the human experience has never changed.

Humans are the same. Yes, but this is, so I think this leads to a third, so again, bad form of reading. First is allegory. The second form is sometimes called moralism.

You read a book, you get the lesson of that book, you apply it to your life directly, moralism. This third method would be to read within, I only ever have like four topics I talk about, so this is one of them. The Great Conversation. So you take Beowulf, but Beowulf is not the only comment on courage, on growing old, on being an adult, on facing evil, on combat, on any of those things.

It's not the only word on those things. So, what do we do? We read Beowulf, and we read other books that come later that develop a theme that has started in Beowulf and then grown from there to then get to, what is the conversation around any one of those topics? And then at that point, we can say something intelligent about our time today.

I think it's also beneficial to, I mean, if we're going to read it, we can read the lessons that are actually there that we might miss because of our modern context. For example, when Beowulf goes to fight the dragon, all of his men abandon him, right? Every single one except for one, right? Wheeloff, and Wheeloff stays.

But first, he goes to the woods and he says, you dopes, like you big cowards. He gave you swords and he was throwing them away. And so the lesson here seems to be, be faithful to your lord, right? That is the mark of a courageous man is faithfulness to a lord.

If the lord has given you your due and has helped you make it in life, then you owe him your fidelity and your life, right? And we don't have that same, like, I owe my senator so much because he's given so much for me. We don't have that same thing. But we do have an attitude towards authority that is often skeptical and negative when the question should be, okay, what has the authority really given up for me and what do I actually owe them?

Right? I mean, I try to apply that here at school, and that means that sometimes I have to trust the administration, even if I think they're making a bad decision, because that's the place. They deserve it. I'm, the argument I'm making is that it is better to read in that last way of across many thinkers, across many books, across time, to read historically, but you can't do that for everything.

Like, we have lives and we have stuff to do. And so I think there are good things to get from each level of reading, to which I'm agreeing with you, of, like, you should take away those moral lessons from Beowulf. But I think those moral lessons can be deepened by reading it in the context of a conversation that intersects with Beowulf at some point. Yeah, sure.

There are a lot of old books that have to do with fidelity to your lord and which, within to your Lewis quote, would show fidelity as maybe a value we've lost in 2020 but it's actually been really important for all of written history. We should therefore value fidelity more. Yeah, so in what way can we sort of seek to rescue it? Yeah, and so, but I guess this works both ways to say that that level of taking a moral from a book and applying it to my life is a good reading.

It can be improved by reading more. Of course, I mean, this maybe ties in with your topic for next week, Graham. But, you know, a bunch of people who read books are going to tell you to read more books. But I would flip it to say, I do think there's still value in that allegorical reading that there are true moral lessons we can take away from a book, even if it's a bad reading of the book.

This is not like a satisfying place. Anyway, I just wanted to throw that out there. I don't like that. I mean, that one gives me, it makes me a little nervous.

It's kind of like, you really need to use the bathroom so you poop in your sink. Like, that's... It technically does the job, but that's not a habit you want to develop. That is fair.

Right? That's kind of how I think about it. That's a little... You're thinking about that one because my grandpa had to do that.

Yeah, right. Like, you were in such a place of... Toilet didn't work. Yeah, nothing was installed.

Any harboring storm, right? Sure. As, like... Any harboring storm.

But you don't want to use that as, like, your method moving forward. I guess I'm trying to leave space. Because it's going to crop up more problems in the future, like... Yes.

I guess I'm just trying to leave space for that category we said earlier of your student reads something, gets a lesson that, like, you don't think is in there, but still, like, radically transforms their life or is helpful for them. I don't think depending on that is helpful. I'm just trying to say, I don't know. I just saw...

Maybe I'm more cynical. I was in my mind thinking, like, oh, man, as soon as you read that book again in five years, you're gonna realize that you're wrong. Or you're gonna... If you're not realizing you're wrong, you're gonna be like, oh, I can't believe I thought that when I was 15.

And, uh... But I think that's more the work of the person introspecting. Like, they are realizing something in their life needs fixing much more so than the book says X. Yeah, that...

Maybe that's one thing. So it's not a good way to read a book, but... So the book's then a mirror. Yes, exactly.

Even though it's... Yeah, the book is not... Yeah, the book isn't intending to be one. Yes.

Or... It just ends up being one because of the person reading it. And you're forced to read it. I don't know.

Uh... So, again, these are... Um... I wanted to say in writing my notes, there are actual notes If you try to leave three or four times and every time dad run back and anyway, it's a really good book under the unpredictable plan, especially if you work in a ministry setting.

Do you want to read something? I was looking for something. So J.R. Tolkien actually has one of the seminal criticisms of Beowulf itself.

And one of the things he talked about is how everyone seems to want to plummet for historicity and all those other things. He's like, it's a work of art, right? And it's a story not even made up by the poet himself, right? He's clearly saying somebody else's story.

I was trying to look for something pertinent to what you were talking about, where we look for one thing and Beowulf would be another. I didn't find anything. It's too long a criticism to find what I want to find. Like that point would fit into the conversation about Beowulf.

Maybe we should come to the conclusion of we shouldn't look for the deeper meanings. It's just a really good story. But that's a fine anyway. You all will still have some like minor disagreements there.

But I find that it's helpful to envision, especially these stories. So Beowulf, the Iliad, the Odyssey. These are these are primary and secondary epic where the place in which they would have been delivered is the setting in which you will, which you should imagine yourself reading them. So if you are going to read Beowulf, you should imagine yourself sitting in your very best clothes, clothes that cost you months worth of salary, right?

The very best of the very best. You're eating the best food you've ever had. You are around the most wealthy, important people in the realm. And in front of you is someone who has been brought to entertain you with a story of bravery.

And so you sit with your ale, with your friends, with the senators and the most important people, with the king who is your benefactor and who has been doing good things for you, who you support. And then he has provided you with this entertainment. It will change your experience entirely of reading the book. You don't like very few people are probably sitting there thinking, what is this about?

This is clearly that I have to tackle my problems by approaching the mother of my problems. Like that's not what they were thinking, right? It's a different experience. I find that that's helpful for my students as well as me when I read these old epics.

Yeah. I mean, it's also telling that like all of our descriptive models for what these stories mean come from the early 20th century. You know what I mean? Like, it's not whoever wrote Beowulf didn't say, you know, I'm basing this off of the hero myth.

You know, like, yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure. Cool. Well, man, I feel like it's gonna spawn lots of other future podcasts. Good.

I hope so. You'll probably have more refined thoughts. I just I ramble for as long as I can. I'm glad that you did me the solid of preventing you from reading that book.

Now I don't have to read it. I didn't think you would want to. But I think I think I didn't get again. I only made it to the first two chapters.

I think he does Dante for two other chapters, too, like The Inferno is one of his kind of stuff. I would assume so. I never read it. That's the thing.

I quit after the Beowulf chapters. I think you can do it. I just think it's harder than people think it is. Yes.

Or or I think actually you should you should feel free to give up when you're not, you're not getting any blood from that stone. Like there are just some books that maybe don't have enough breadcrumbs to get you to that. Or, you know, don't don't bring your own notions to the book. Draw the book's notions out.

Oh, that's again, constellations. This book of essays is great because he doesn't do that part. He just says his ideas and like the really interesting ideas. I just don't.

You don't have to pretend that, you know, they're in Beowulf because they're not. Yeah, it's fine. Just tell me the idea. Cool.

Well, this has been classical stuff. You should know with Thomas, AJ and Graham. We thank you for listening. You can email us at the guys at classicalstuff.net.

You can find us on Twitter at classical stuff, CLSSCL stuff. You can patronize us at Patreon dot com backslash classical stuff. Is that it? And you can find all of our episodes on classical stuff.net.

We think thanks for listening and we appreciate you guys emailing us funny things. And yeah, cool. We love interacting with you guys. It's nice.

It really is. All right. Thanks. Bye.

Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Classical Stuff You Should Know?

This episode is 1 hour and 4 minutes long.

When was this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode published?

This episode was published on September 1, 2020.

Can I download this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.