That's in a very presence. Oh, dude. Okay, here's another one. I normally give you presents and you're giving me a present.
Oh, come on, I give you presents? I mean, yeah, you do. You sent me a pair of pants on my birthday one time. I'm gonna level with you.
That was weird, but I love the pants. I knew you would love the pants. I know, but you sent me crotch comfort underwear. I did.
The first Christmas that I knew you. You're telling me it's weird, I sent you pants, pants are one layer further away from your skin than underwear and you're fixated on the pants. You're right, you're right. You've logically put me into a corner here.
Yeah, I know. Anyway, thanks for the gift. What is it? It's a it's a struple awful from my flight on United.
It's a struple awful. I remember the first time I had a struple. You just pop that open. Like I went, I'm not going to eat it right now.
I'm not going to eat it right now. No, I don't want to eat it right now. Oh, have you lost your mind? There's a struple awful in front of you right now, physically, and you're going to not eat it.
I'm gonna wait for coffee. Okay. Yeah, I mean, I respect your decision, but when you open it, I mean, you'd like maybe 10% of that could go in my face. Okay, well, wait.
I'm like a struple awful. This episode not brought to you by struple awful. This is real good. I'm gonna write something else.
Okay. Okay. These are for you. Oh, they're coins.
Yes. And they're in plastic. Oh, it's an Apollo 1150th anniversary, one ounce of silver coins. There's space coins.
Oh, dude. It's got the module on it. That's so cool. It's got the Earthrise and it's got the module in the background.
I mean, it looks like it's performing a very aggressive maneuver. So it tells me whoever made this coin, it says trans earth injection of the CSM command service module. Look how aggressive that turn is. I don't know that that makes a ton of sense, but it sure makes for cool looking coins.
It makes for it. Look at the composition. Oh, here's another one. Neil Armstrong, Michael Collins, Buzz Aldrin.
Oh, wow. It's their faces, like the side of their faces. And then there's a moon and then like a shoe, not a shoe, like a footprint, Apollo 1150th anniversary, 1969 to 2019, 0.999 fine silver. These don't say United States of America on them.
These aren't like government coins. They're not government coins. Okay. And I've been fascinated by not government coins of late.
I mean, I like government coins too, but I have discovered in the last six months or so what a lot of people have known for a long time, which is there's this whole world of silver, independent coin manufacturing where people figure out how to strike a coin they wanted to make as a not government just because they wanted to. It's a mint coin. Well, we're striking a coin. Okay.
Two different ways to make a coin. But those are two different things. Striking a coin and minting a coin. Yeah.
I mean, man, there's so much to that. So to mint a coin is really just to make a coin in general. It's a generic overarching term because coins were created in Roman times in this temple dedicated to a lesser known god named Junomoneta. So in Spanish.
Oh, Moneta. Yeah. Mint somehow would seem to be a derivation of that word, Moneta, of that deity. So the idea was that the Romans were saying, your Roman official coinage is descended from on high.
This has not only the backing of Rome, but it also has the full faith and credit of the gods above trade this in confidence. And so money was made in a temple. Okay. And so when you mint a coin, you are creating that new run of a coin.
So the mint is like the introduction of the new line, the new coin, the new thing. When you strike a coin, that refers to the old system that people still use today of actually making the reverse and obverse of a coin. Okay. So like a stamp, okay, you put your blank.
You put the negative of what you want to be on the coin. I'm actually doing something similar. I'm making injection molds for plastic parts. And I'm designing a positive of the part in software.
We put a material around the outside and make the negative. And I make a step file of that, which is a 3D CAD file. And then I'm printing the mold. I'm 3D printing the mold for injection molding.
I'm doing that lately. Anyway, so the point is somebody actually makes the reverse on some type of metal that you didn't hit with a hammer into metal. Yes. And a softer metal.
Yes. So you have a metal that stacks on top of each other and has room for a blank, a chunk of silver in this case that goes in between. You put the two together, you whack it with a hammer, hopefully once. You pull the mold apart top and bottom and what's left is that blank is now imprinted with both sides of the coin.
And it looks like it looks like. Okay. So that's when you say strike a coin, it's because there's physically a hammer strike involved. But a mint or a molded coin is the kind where you do exactly what you're talking about doing with your 3D printing.
And in fact, people do make coins. It's exactly the way you're making the parts. You create that negative. And something that you'll see online that's pretty cool right now is people making their own coins.
And they do it with a specialized kind of red sand that you can then take your 3D printed piece. You put it in that red sand that is contained in two halves of a matching box. You set the coin in there, you lock the top and bottom of the box together. Then you remove that and you look at it and you're like, oh, they're perfectly imprinted in the sand.
Half the relief of the reverse of the coin here. Half the release of the obverse on the other side of the box. Then you put them back together and you got a hole to dump that silver or whatever metal you melt into. Yeah, it's true.
Hey, hey, please even doing this. And you dump that in there. And it might take a few tries. I mean, it looks like it's not easy.
But you melt any metal you want, make a coin out of recycled cans or out of a precious metal. Like silver, if you're really ambitious and sure of your skill set, maybe even gold. And so there's this whole world that's developing that is especially aided by 3D printing of people making their own coins of things that they care about and like in a more rough, poor, primitive way. That's what it would look like, not just if I do it, but when I get set up and do it, I'm going to do it.
Sure. Yeah. OK. Then there are also these independent mints that make the coins that they think people would like.
And I always like to goof around and go and look at all of their different websites and see the things they're making. And I saw these two. I was like, you know what I'm going to do? I'm going to start giving people.
Coins that are reflective of things they really care about. And it's actual value. So it's silver. Yeah, this is an ounce of silver.
Yeah. Yeah. So this is like, what's this worth now? Like 50 bucks?
No, two ounce coin, I think, has been worth 50. That's a one ounce coin. So right now, 25, give or take a buck or two. OK.
And that's not accounting for the rarity of that particular design or coin and that can add value. So one ounce of silver, even if it's garbage silver and the whole molding process went wrong and it's ugly, I mean, it still has its mineral value of roughly 25 bucks right now. OK. But that same one ounce, just like a baseball card, or a limited print on a work of art, can take on value and meaning of its own.
And because there's a trade market. Scarcity. Yeah, yes. Exactly.
So there's two different types of value for the coins what you're saying. So we've got the actual material value because it took energy to mine it out of the ground. Yes. And then you have a secondary type of value.
And that is set up based on scarcity supply and demand. So for example, NFTs. Yes. Non-fungible tokens.
So a non-fungible token in the crypto world is a way of proving that I have ownership of this digital asset. I own that monkey in a sailor hat. Right. To be clear, I've spent a lot of time learning about cryptocurrency.
We did a whole episode on it back in the day. I'm not sold on NFTs at all. Me neither. Why are you not?
Well, because of the same reason you handed me this coin. So the coin itself has physical value. I can use it for something. What do you mean use it for something?
If everything else goes wrong or whatever, I can take this and melt it and use the metal for something. Yes. OK. So it has value because of the scarcity of the metal or in Earth.
Yes. And because of, as you mentioned, the physical work it takes to get it out of the ground. Right. Yes.
Right. Those two things combined give it intrinsic value. It took human life energy to do it. So an hour to get the ore out.
It also took some type of fuel energy, whether that be solar power or coal or wood converting to steam, power to steam shovel or something, or a jackhammer more than likely to get it out. And then it was crushed in a crusher. And then the ore was separated and smelted. So that's valuable.
But for me, an NFT seems like people that are trying to capitalize on the, oh, look, it's got to design. So it'd be like, if you were to somehow hand me just the picture of these astronauts on this coin. But you can't do that because this actually has silver. So I don't know.
My brain's kind of all over the place right now. Well, I think the difference between the two is what we're discovering is what we're testing out, rather, are the limits of ones and zeros as reality. If that picture of a monkey wearing a sailor hat were to, the weaknesses, you can't break that NFT down into anything else. There is no rudimentary form.
It's not like we used a certain amounts of our ones and zeros on that. And if we absolutely were desperate for more ones and zeros, we could melt down the digital picture of the monkey in the sailor hat and reuse them on something else to get by during a difficult time. You can't do that. Do you want to open this can?
Because I've spent so much time thinking about this. I do want to open this can. We're going to have that discussion about fiat and all this. Oh, I think we should go up ways down that road.
I think it's interesting. And I think it's something as simple as holding that coin in your hand here. I want to hold your hand. Something as simple as holding this coin raises a ton of questions about what actually is value.
So right off the bat, we have established two forms of value. Yes. One is an intrinsic value. These may be the wrong words.
But the fact that these atoms are AG, they're silver. That has intrinsic value because of this. Like you take all of Earth and you take all of the atoms on Earth, a certain percentage of those atoms are silver. Not very many.
But because this is the domain that we play in as humans is Earth, let's say there's 0.005% of the atoms in this rock that we live on that are silver. Therefore, it has a certain scarcity. And that's the value. So that's an intrinsic value based on the amount of silver here.
Certain scarcity and a certain usefulness. Like let's say 0.005. Let's say there was a we found a new element called turd. T-R-D.
No, let's do like unobtainium or something. Oh, it's clever. Because it would be hard to get. Fantasticoid.
Oh, that's even better. Have you ever heard of no way-n-n-n-um? That one's crazy. How long can you do this?
That's good. That's excellent. Well, it's not there. It's very rare that we sit and do this.
And I'm over here. Like I just a minute. I got one. And you just keep reeling them off.
I said, you win. I've been there. So no way-n-n-n-um. OK.
No, I want to go with turd-n-n-n-um. OK. So there's a new element called turd-n-n-n-um. And maybe it's just as hard to get out of the ground as A.G.
is silver. OK. But all turd-n-n-n-n-um does is it just smells like turd. OK.
You can't use it for anything. Well, you can put the same amount. I can't give something useless for turd-n-n-um. I'll burn it on somebody's porch.
Run away real fast. In a bag. Dammit, Melanie! It's burning turd-n-n-n-um again.
Well, put it out, Carl! Oh, man. That's good. Oh, silver does things is the point.
The unique properties associated with silver means that it's not just that it's valuable. But also over the course of history, we discovered that it can be used for different things. Killing werewolves. It has all kinds of various properties that give it value.
So the value is really twofold. It's the work that goes into getting something hard to get. But also the thing that you get, it has to do something, even if it's just pretty, and turd-n-n-um is not pretty. It's brown, gross, smells bad.
Silver, even if we just go with it shiny and beautiful, that gives it value aesthetically. But also, there are things you can do with silver that you can't do with other things. So it has value because of its properties, and also its rarity. Oh, my gosh.
You just made me think of something. The reason gold is valuable is the standard, right? It has to do with the cones and the human eye. You know?
Look what you're doing. You know what I mean? So you might have palladium or platinum that might be just harder, harder, I don't know. They're pretty, but they're boring.
Yeah. But they may be just as conductive as other things. Man, that's interesting. So the reason gold stood out to the inks and the Egyptians or whoever is because of the way you can see it with your eye.
So I wonder if, does you know if platinum oxidizes? I don't. I don't either. Gold does a pretty good job of keeping it's luster.
Yeah, it's interesting, though, because not all gold is the same. Certain Chinese pandas, I mean, the Chinese gold, government coins have pandas on them all the time. So they're called pandas? They're called Chinese Panda.
They come in quarter ounce and full ounce. And I mean, there's a lot of money for a little bit of gold, but they will develop little red dots on them. It's part of how you can tell it's real gold from the 80s in China is wherever they're getting their gold. Gradually, it interacts with the atmosphere in such a way that little tiny red flecks will appear.
And you know what you can do to make those little red flecks go away? What? Blowtorch, really? Put it on a piece of metal, turn on a blowtorch, and hit it for about five seconds.
And those little flecks of red go away. Looks just like the coin was just brand new, minted, and shiny, and perfect. Do you have any theories as to why that might be? Because I don't know.
I do know that. There's a lot. Dude, my brain's everywhere. Sorry, this is my fault.
I'll just give you two real quick. Number one, if you want to make red glass, you put gold in it. In celibate glass. Yeah, gold, if you, gold is used to make glass red.
Another thing is when the Nazis were coming in to. It's like a Nazis. All the different places. A lot of people had gold coins from the Olympics or like a Nobel Prize and stuff like that.
They would make a solution. What's it called? A cyanide? I don't know what it is, but it's called something like, the word sounds like ambrosia.
It's not, but it's a liquid. You can liquefy the gold, put it in a chemical form, and it's a red liquid. Can I Google? Are we allowed to do that?
You're definitely allowed. It's like, rouge. Gold is super interesting, though, because it can be separated and affected by other elements and other compounds in ways that strike me as super interesting. There's a, as you're googling here, there's an abandoned gold mine that we used to write ATVs up to in the gold country in Wyoming by where it was.
Aquarigia. OK, what does it do? I don't know. You can dissolve gold into liquid form.
It's a mixture of nitric acid and hydrochloric acid. So you get that mixture and you can, you know, it's like a solvent and gold will liquefy. Aquarigia. What are you?
Resalitify that. I don't know. Although, it's typically an inner metal. It will dissolve in aquarigia because of the unique action of nitric and hydrochloric acid.
But all the atoms are still there. They're just in molecules. And you can then, yeah, boy, that's fascinating, isn't it? So again, there's value because of the properties of these metals.
So you are right that the human eye and the prettiness of gold is part of why we liked it. But the ink is also understood that gold could do things other metals couldn't do. Like what? Stretch, be stretched incredibly.
Very ductile. It can guild. You can make it into sheets and put it on things. In ways you can't with.
So the ductility is, yeah, I've read where you can take just like an ounce of gold and you can pound it and cover like a whole football field or something crazy like that. It's nuts. You go to the state capitals all around the country. Tons of them are gilded.
But it's not like that whole dome is solid gold through and throughout. It'd be worth gajillion's astronomical amounts. It's a tiny bit of gold that's covering these entire enormous domes at the top of all these capital buildings because gold just has weird properties. It does things other metals won't do and a little bit goes a long way and there only is a little bit and that adds to the value equation.
That's interesting because there's a house that I pass often that's it burned down and they're rebuilding it. And I notice they're putting in copper gutters and I love copper gutters. I think they're beautiful. I mean, crazy expensive.
But like I love it when people choose to invest the money in the copper gutters because I get to see it and it's pretty. And it makes me wonder why we don't use other like, why do we use copper versus gold gutters? And the answer is because there's not a lot of gold. And copper is also pretty but it's much more abundant.
Yeah, I'm sorry. I'm all over the place here. Okay. Because it's one thing to not think about value at all and just say, oh, it's valuable because the computer said so I googled it, it's worth this much.
It's another thing to really stop and try to think, well, why is an ounce of gold worth more than an ounce of quartz? Quartz is pretty. Why is this one so important? How come I can buy a giant 100 ounce brick of copper in ingot form on Amazon for like 50 bucks as a paperweight, but that would completely change my family fortunes forever if I had it in gold.
They're both pretty. They're both shiny. The colors are sort of similar. They have some similar properties and the value equation that answers that hypothetical question.
Why copper instead of gold? The value of gold is set because of the amount of atoms on earth. If we lived on a planet called no way better or you know, gold upper. Sure.
That's a great name for one. Yeah. And the rocks were gold. Salt might be valuable.
Well, and that's what happened in the 16th century with the Spanish expansion to Central America. There's a whole bunch of gold that came back. It flooded the European economy and it messed with things. Really?
It was set at a certain value and you got these Spanish galleons coming back with the fortunes of the new world. Stuff that the Aztecs had worked for a millennia to get out of the ground. Stuff that had been pulled out of the ground in the native gold fields of northern part like Guyana and South America. All these ships come back and well, what happens if there are a hundred ounces of gold in circulation and you show up with another hundred?
The value of the gold that was in circulation is now half as much because it's now half as rare. Depending on the population. There were pressures. That's an interesting thing too, right?
It's my understanding that physical gold is extremely valuable in India. So from a young age, your daughters will be given jewelry and you gradually accumulate more and more and it factors in. I don't remember how but somehow it factors into the wedding dowry. I don't remember how but I went up to the Hindu temple in Nashville.
It's been a lot of time with a buddy of mine, Sharad. I just want to understand Hinduism and culture and things like that. It was explaining to me that actually having the physical metal, at least back then, was important. The currency in India, even the paper money, had a thread of precious metal woven into the bill itself.
So your coinage had intrinsic value but your paper money also had intrinsic value because someone would have, I don't know if it was gold or what it was, woven into the bill. So I thought that was interesting. I just got a couple of bills like that that are almost entirely gold. A bill is gold.
There's a company making something called goldbacks. I don't know who it is. I don't know if I think the same thing says them but I was intrigued by it. They came to an event in Rapid City and they were given out $1 gold backs as a promotion.
Like, hey, look at this. So I got a couple of those. This is really neat. It's about the size of a $1 bill and it's got sort of that classic lady Columbia kind of art.
You can picture that like 19th century holding the torch of liberty. It's all that kind of- Like the Chicago world's fair kind of feel. Exactly. Yeah.
Except the bill is literally gold. It's like paper in its thickness and consistency but it's literally gold and then you've got colorful printing on it and they're issued in the names of three states, not by the states. I don't think New Hampshire, Nevada and Utah. I just ordered a few of them.
It's not like a lot of money. I don't have a lot of money to go in buy a bunch of precious metal. It's more just kind of fun and interesting for me to see what money I spent. I could be wrong.
So this is obtainable. Yeah. Oh, yeah. This is for normal people for sure.
But it's beautiful. So I've been giving stuff like this as I just did as gifts. I bought one ounce silver coins from an independent meant with Christmas of the given year on it. And then I just gave it to all the kids in my life this year.
And all of them got the old man speech about this right here. Has value. Has value. This is real.
And so I'm just doing that for Christmas and Easter. Every year I'm buying the year and the coin. I'm giving it to people and my buddy opened his business last week. And so I got a special coin with the year on it and went up and greeted him a couple hours into his first business day And it's given the coin it doesn't cost me a ton of money I mean it's not an outrageous thing But just something to be like hey you're trying to make something here that has real value Here's something that has real value to commemorate the occasion cool.
Good job And I love it the beauty of it. It's anything I think yeah like I'm sitting here holding this and it's gonna I mean to be honest is probably gonna go in a drawer somewhere sure and I'm gonna open the door I'm gonna see it I'm like huh there's that thing is that coin and I have the value of it the physicality of it I don't know if that's right word but like the fact that it is here in 3d meat space and it's not in the hard drive of a computer at My bank it's a real thing so it's repurposable because once again It was hard to get that ounce of silver just in your hand harder than getting a turd and also it has more redeeming value It's more repurposable than something stupid or useless Do you mean to show you what I think the most important function of this is? Oh, yes I think I would like to see that hold out your hand okay Done I handed it to you and now I have 25 dollars transfer it to you and nobody has to know that So right now what I'm discovering but they do know it because you said it into my I did whatever All right, okay. Can you hand it back to me?
Who knows if he did who knows if I did ah ha ha ah? I do I have a code in my hand nobody knows oh did we just change it and do the opposite of what we just said who can say who can say untraceable transaction between the two of us there is $50 worth of silver and we don't know where it is I'm concerned that's interesting. I'm not voting accident. Yeah, I think that's important the concept It's it's on a US dollar for all that's public and private This episode of notum questions is brought to you by Raycon they make earbuds that we both love and use all the time What do you like about them?
Oh, I like that they fit my ear well because they have custom earhole adapters Did you actually cycle through all of those I did do a couple I'm impressed Yeah, and currently I've got the little earhole adapter pack on my newest thing my newest every days And I have to change those out because I want I want to just a little snugger fit So I'm gonna transition over to a different earhole adapter I think I might have the standard issue earhole yeah, like where I'm a little below average in terms of height Yeah, I think I might be precisely average in terms of earhole diameter Yeah, cuz those things right out of the box they fit full great And so I was like oh look it comes with these things I could adapt it well Let's see what's wrong with the initial fit boom oh man that goes into my ear about as well as the magnets pop back into the box I think I'm good here. So I go standard. Have you explored hitting the buttons? Yeah, okay?
So what have you discovered? Okay? If I need to hang up on somebody cuz this conversation's just gone on too long the tap gets that done and then that kicks music right back on For me if I was already listening But if not and I tap it again I go back to the last music I was listening you can also hold down the button and that goes to the the mode where you can hear Everything around you yeah, what's the awareness mode alertness mode? Here's up mode it's something like that and it works like a charm.
It's good Yeah, so if you want to check this out go to by raycon calm slash in the queue that gets you 15% off your order If you want to order you mean these things are cost effective the thing about Raycon's is you're not worried about breaking them Or losing them a I've never broken mine But like if you lose them it's not the end of the world because they're at a great price point But the quality is there and the batteries last for an age you get eight hours of playtime or 32 hours of total battery life at Raycon's I looked it up the name of that mode where you can hold the button and you can hear everything around you It's called don't get savagely mauled by a grizzly bear while fly fishing mode Oh is it yeah, you hear the grizzly bears come in you don't get savagely get mauled still not savagely Oh, I'm not 100% positive. That's the name, but it should be yeah, you get the idea Thank you for supporting the sponsor by raycon calm slash into queue 15% off your order. We are grateful Thank you to everyone who supports the podcast The concept of me being able to like hand that over to you and not replace it immediately You know, there's scarcity there's a sting in Ithaca, New York called the Ithaca hour we talked about that when we talked about Bitcoin Oh, that's right. That's right.
That's right. That's good. I mean just yes This is familiar to me. Yes, I don't know.
What is the Ithaca hour a measure of what gives it value the Ithaca hour in Ithaca, New York Is a measure of one human's time or life energy for one hour? Yes, and I don't know if it's still a thing, but it was you know, I used to really like to read about it back in the day I don't know what do you what do you think about? I don't know, you know where I'm at I just think it's cool that I can hand you something and it has value and it can't be traced I think that's important for privacy reasons. Yes, so this non-bungible token business Yes, we're all doing kind of the idea is there's a decentralized record of someone having ownership But everybody knows that you have ownership, right?
So the value of the decentralized record keeping is the immutability of it meaning the unchangeability. Yes, yes It's final. It's done the way we do this when I hand you a coin or you hand me a coin because nobody knows if I have it You have it right now the reason we know it happens is because you can go get it out of your drawer and show that you have it Yes, exactly That's why you have the value and I don't but if say we both had a one-ounce silver coin right now in our hands If we traded the one-ounce silver coins and they were identical we still have the exact same value in our possession Even though we traded a physical thing. That's what makes it fungible.
It's the same value same thing What? Just make sure I understand I understand the concept of NFTs non-fungible tokens pretty well One thing I'm not completely clear on is what the actual word fungible means I'm not entirely sure that non-fungible token passes muster definitionally Fungible means I buy a 50 gallon barrel of oil. It's ready to go the right way That's the exact same thing as that other 50 gallon barrels sitting right over there assuming them to be identical upon inspection It doesn't really matter which barrel you have it's fungible. It's interchangeable So the idea of a non-fungible token means that picture of an ape wearing a sailor hat that you have is somehow different Than the one that I have that's just a JPEG of it We could not just exchange those two things and have it have the same value because we said it doesn't and so the unsatisfying part of that is there being No physical expression of a non-fungible token and no Elemental level you could break it back down to and I think that's why a lot of people are very slow to jump on that bandwagon I'm sorry.
You look at some of my good. Yeah, I just got definition here. What is fungibility? I'm reading now from a website called Investopedia Fungibility is the ability of a good or asset to be interchanged with other individual goods or assets of the same type Fungible assets simplify the exchange and trade processes as fungibility implies equal value between the assets a gold is fungible Yes, because an ounce of gold is an ounce of gold is an ounce of gold if I own an ounce of gold But you're holding it and you've got a hundred ounces of gold that you're holding for different people and it's just raw gold It's not minted a particular way or special It doesn't matter which of the hundred single ounces you send me when I call it in you send me any of them So the Mona Lisa is non-vungible there you go And why is it non-vungible because one it'd be very difficult to paint that again Two the materials were used in a permanent in a permanent way where you can't change it You can't break it down into its elemental form and have it have any value the value is who painted it when they painted it The material it was painted on and the value is what all of humanity is done in the several hundred years It's existed to imprint on it and say that's the freakin Mona Lisa.
It's irreplaceable. It's invaluable But it's a it's an arrangement of atoms. Yeah, so it that's look behind you over there. You see that table Yeah, that's what my wife calls Destin's hobby table.
That is a dumpster fire. It is not a dumpster fire It's beautiful. So every little box you see there contains film. Yeah, that part.
I like yeah, and on every single shot of the film There's a moment in time that was captured. I have images over there from 1945 August 1945 taken in Paris. I've seen them. They're amazing Yeah, some of the images are on acetate film some of them are on glass.
Yeah, but those are non-vungible The negative is non-fungible. Okay, go on if you printed them and Made a hundred copies that are identical in every way from the printing process and you set up a website That was like by Destin's picture of Paris from 1945 calm You can buy it, but I'll hold it and then you let me know when you want it I'll keep it for safekeeping and then a hundred people buy it and eventually the first one patty She's like all right. I'm gonna need my picture. You're not gonna go and be like, okay.
Well, it has to be picture number seven I had a hundred identical prints doesn't matter which one you send her. It's a print so that is fungible. It's entirely interchangeable Within the limits of how many exist in this case we say a hundred but the negative right now There's only one yes, and you couldn't just be like well I'm gonna give you one of a squid taken in 1963 by jocker Stowe's crew Well, no, that's not the same thing those aren't interchangeable. I wanted that I own the Paris negative You can't send me the squid negative right yeah, and that's what's interesting about all that That some of my favorite ones over there were taken from the coast of Brittany France like the turn of the 1900s And you've got these they look like schoolgirls and they're wearing bonnets And in the background you can see these sailboats that are clearly fishing boats and they have nets with weights on them And the weights are just rocks tied into the rope and it's this weird like whoa that looks modern But that looks ancient at the same time and what's amazing is a photographer went to the coast of Brittany France over a hundred years ago And snapped a photo and somehow some redneck in Alabama now has that in his on his hobby table, and it's irreplaceable It's irreplaceable getting back to NFTs non fungible tokens I think we're trying to create scarcity out of something that So let me let me say this way the technology behind NFTs is Interesting to me because you could do something like say hey I have this concert ticket, and this is the only copy of this concert ticket right now What we do is we have we scan a barcode and this barcode lets you into the concert with barcode is copyable.
Yeah an NFT is copyable as well But there are technologies where where you can actually Prove that you have ownership because you own this secret code you own this address and that's where the crypto in the cryptocurrency Yes, which Star Wars anticipated with the concept of chain code what way back in the day what I think Chain code is original cannon from early in the days of Star Wars is that in the movies it featured most recently in Mandalorian season two when Boba Fett's like that's my Alma and he shows like this was given to my father The best guard pulls up the best car and he pulls it up out of his wrist and it projects into the air and it shows the What do they call that Star Wars? Arabesh I think is the name of their script in Star Wars universe it shows the Arabesh from getting that right chain code And it's just a whole bunch of digits and stuff that I don't know what it means or anything and Dinjarin the Mandalorian looks at it and it's like oh yeah, it checks out like you have the chain code So that armor is an NFT Boba Fett's armor is an NFT in the physical world that is verified by blockchain by chain code That is a unique identifier that cannot be duplicated So the physical presence of the physical ownership possession is nine-tenths of the law Coupled with the digital ownership code is enough for Boba Fett to show someone else in that universe I own this armor it is owed to me and for someone else to say yes in this universe that is what ownership looks like on every level It is irrefutably yours. Wow Huh? That's interesting.
So so one level of value is I have these atoms arranged. Yes. Yes. Yeah another level of value is the human agreement of Ownership is that right which is very easy when you have that?
I mean this is in my hand. It's it's more of an extrinsic thing So we have the intrinsic ownership that is the atoms Yes, we have this extrinsic thing that is oh well I agree that you own it that's interesting because right now your bank account is set up for all I don't know let's go back Fiat. Let's let's talk about Fiat So Fiat is when a currency doesn't actually have any intrinsic value. It's not backed by gold We agreed that there's value and we're kind of holding each other hostage to be like hey a dollar's a dollar right?
You're like yeah dollars dollar. Okay. Cool great cuz dollars a dollar. I would like a coat Please yes, and as long as we have a green dollars a dollar can I have that coat?
You know what I mean, but the market don't lie So if you invent yeah, cuz we don't even physically print money when we do this if you invent say six trillion dollars in a very short period of Time which point announcing what what I just announcing that now the government sponsors these ones and zeros that represent money And we sent you a check with no physical cash that everybody can put in their bank that represents money if you introduce six trillion Dollars the market will notice that and we will all without meaning to agree to it agree that now that dollar is worth less It purchases less let's instead say that twenty five dollar chunk purchases less But your silver coin that you're holding should stay almost exactly relative to the same amount of goods and services Regardless of what amount of printing happens with fiat currency because this is a different kind of value Then we all agree something is worth this much and it's really just kind of fake You're right in identifying the way you're talking about the different expressions of value the different things that make it valuable But they're also right in there the two competing theories of value that people have had through the centuries about interested in terms of talking about economics Do you know this up? You had the main competing theories of value? No, I don't well. Let's just give it out What makes something valuable in general?
What determines what something is worth? Let me ask it that way what determines what a supply and demand Okay, so that's the market theory of value. Yeah, that's the market theory of value. Yes And I think that's true So what is the demand from the population and then how much of it exists and that changes how much people will want to give to get it?
Yes, what is my used phone worth? Monotarily probably a hundred bucks or to put it another way whatever anyone is willing to pay for it today. Oh the market value, right? That's that's the truest thing that we all agree on yeah in all of life not issues about social stuff for sex or Identity or taxes or any war like none of those political hot button issues Nobody agrees the thing where we have the most shared agreement amongst us even if we're very different people is what a thing is worth on a given day Yeah, the market makes that the truth that we have in common and there's a very there's unifying power in that that we underestimate and underutilized right now In our society and in modern life.
I agree with almost everyone about what almost everything is worth And what a cool thing to just be able to say we might disagree about so much else, but we agree on this value That's pretty cool. We have values in common I have opinions about this when you start jacking with that like if you say hey food has value Mm-hmm, and so in order to eat you need to contribute some value Yes And so when you start saying you know what you can just eat no matter what if you change the the way that people get money It changes people's desire to provide services in order to you know exchange money for food Well, you know their desire to do that It basically changes the demand for a person to work if money is real and has real value It creates one type of human motivation and one type of motivation for us to interact in ways that are good If money is fake it creates a different set of motivations And I think can put friction between us unnecessarily in terms of how we interact But also if you don't do something to include and on board and on ramp and care for folks who are just getting into the game That wrecks the game too like everybody's got a play in order for the value game to work or it scrambles What makes something worth a certain thing? So people who are in the game earning spending buying determining values are Behooved to always be expanding the circle and welcoming new people in young people as they come up through the ranks People who've made mistakes and are trying to get back into society folks who got dealt a real tough hand It is best for the truth of the market for everybody who's in the game and playing to always be welcoming with that circle The more of us who are playing the value game the more accurate the values are and the better everyone will do All ships rise with the tide absolutely the mall is the market like you go to the mall you're doing business But also like you're there to see people you're there to interact and people watch and engage and going to market No matter what political persuasion you're of is a beautiful Expression of what it is to be a human I'm taking things that are representative of my life energy that I own and I'm going out to see what It's worth and I like some things that your life energy is produced and we're gonna exchange some things What it's implicitly saying is you're valuable my friend what you've done It's not what I do. I'm not like you I don't share the skills or abilities or values that you share necessarily But I see the value in it from a distance and I'm hoping you'll see the value in the things I've used my life energy on and that we could swap some things It's a very affirming thing between us well, it's it's all about Efficiency like we are more efficient together Then we are you trying to grow your own grain and trying to build your own car Yes, you know, we're more efficient when we work together and so you go do the thing you're good at I'll do the thing I'm good at and then we use the market as this way to touch each other and basically help I think there's two primary market forces.
I'm making this up. I'm not an economist I feel dumb saying that as if I know what I'm talking about there to the come to mind right off the top of your head What are they? Yeah, the first one is the avoidance of pain and the second is the desire for pleasure And so the reason I want to buy food is because of the hunger pain in my stomach and if it's tasty food It's also the pole factor is that's gonna taste good. Yeah, and then the other thing is the anticipation of a pleasure Like I might go to the mall to buy clothes because I would really like non-ripped pants That'd be pleasurable to me to wear blue jeans that you know I would like that it would also help me avoid the pain of cold and stuff like that So theory of value number one is one that you and I agree on a thing is worth whatever people will pay on a given day And if you mess with that what you can do with violence with threats with force with lying that has serious consequences But the second theory of value that personally I reject is the labor theory of value and the labor theory of value You know, that's why you heard this one you remember this from school No, this is value is determined by the amount of time a person spent so I go to work for X number of hours They like to hit the hour.
Yeah, so the workers came together to build a car the entrepreneurs and risk takers and financiers They don't really own the value of the car the workers who physically took the metal and put it together to make the car The labor is what makes the car valuable the life force that goes into it Yeah And what I would say is the weakness of the labor theory of value is it doesn't take into account the market side The strength of the market side is it does take into account the labor But the labor is only part of the equation a whole bunch of other intangibles are the rest of the equation And I think the market theory of value is more reflective of reality Yeah, when I would do cost estimates for things as an engineer, I would do materials and labor But I don't think everyone's labor is not the same. No. Yeah, I don't think that's a mean thing to say Yeah, I'm gonna pay a surge and more money to operate on me than I would pay you to operate on me Why would you pay me to operate? I would not So yeah, that's an interesting concept so then that dovetails into money because physical money coinage metals Fia currency paper all of these things tell a story about your theory of value So for me part of the appeal of physical resource money that I can put in your hand as a friend and be like there is one ounce of silver And maybe I just physically did that maybe you gave it back or maybe you didn't is Is no one else needs to know or participate in the transaction?
That's of value But also it doesn't matter what outsiders do to try to mess with the value of that coin Short of going and finding a whole bunch of silver and flooding the market with it The value of that is what the value of that is and so it's a secure transaction and that it happens away from other people's opinions But it's also a secure transaction in that it's very hard to come in two minutes after I hand you that And jack up the value of that coin and wreck it and make it so now it was valuable when I gave it to you But now it's trash. I don't know now. We should we should talk more about this later This episode of notum questions is sponsored by hello fresh the meal kit delivery system I'll call it. Oh, I like that Yeah, it's good They deliver food right to your door they've got a little recipe card the right amount of ingredients the whole bit You just get online you just pick the meals you want and it shows up and you get to make it and it's awesome And I have an update for you Matt.
I'm ready for your day Do you remember how I told you that one of my friends is making these hello fresh meals and he's like going all am He's like I'm gonna make a hello fresh every night you remember that you take a picture is like super beautiful pictures You said yeah, exactly you got some yeah, so he made a post on Instagram And hello fresh commented on his photos what yeah hello fresh commented you are a five star chef This is looking incredible and they tagged him on there So yeah, they tagged karsten is cooking do I have the opportunity to see it because you keep holding the phone is pointing toward you I was I was wanting to look at that. Yeah, yeah Oh, I the photograph is on here. It's on there. It's just small.
Oh my that is a beautiful presentation Did you get it? Yeah, like a one two three four five one two three five you put the shrimp in a pattern It's like a little coil pattern on either side of it looks like pork cut let's wonder if he's got like some golden ratios that was on the beautiful I continue to just really really like hello fresh and You know how back in the day bands would produce albums as opposed to just songs that go on spotify like we do it now And you'd have a whole whole album and it would mean something and each thing was meant to compliment the other songs and somebody almost like it Told a story or something and it's fun to go back to those albums where you just got the first thing you liked and you fixate it on it It's fun to go back and catch all the deep cuts and discover the genius that you didn't catch on the first pass I feel like that's what I'm doing with hello fresh right now is discovering that I thought I knew what was there And there's just so much more horizon expansion available to me dude That's great. No, but I'm sitting here looking at Carson is cooking on Instagram My buddy and he's got jobs man. He's doing a really good job.
He's got this fancy Japanese knife dude Just going through some hello fresh. I'm kind of emotionally invested in his hello fresh journey right now I see why yeah, he's sparing no thought in oh, yeah, there's yeah, it's like painting with food. This is beautiful Yeah, it's really good press yeah So hello fresh can be whatever you want it to be it can just get the job done it can feed you and the family It can also be a whole experience in and of itself. However, you eat it's gonna work Whatever your weird thing is ever you like to do it.
It's gonna work. Yeah, you're a vegetarian They have vegetarian meals you want to do more lower calorie stuff. They can do that quick stuff You like meat like matt. Yeah, do that.
Yeah, it seems like they're always adding new menu things They do seasonal menu things. I got salmon and a pasta prima vera option that I saw we're cropping up right now If you want to add protein to the vegetable meal you can do that. There's all kinds of customizing options now I think that's really smart check it out What is our promo code is indq16 and you get 16 free meals? So if you want to go to hello fresh calm slash indq16 use the promo code indq16 at checkout 16 free meals Start to be and three free gifts.
Awesome. Yeah, that's it. Thank you very much for supporting the podcast by supporting the sponsors Hello fresh calm slash indq16 promo code indq16 at checkout I don't want to criticize the gift you gave me. Oh, why would you even start with something like that?
But I have something to say that concerns me. Okay, okay, so um You know how all coins have ridges on the side of them. I do look at the the bottom side of this coin That's a silver coin. Look at the bottom side of it.
Yes. You can see that part of that coin does not have ridges Do you see it? I do see that so the reason ridges were originally added to coins Was to prevent people from taking out a pocket knife and shaving the edges off the coin to skim some of the value away from the coins Yes, I'm sorry Matt But I'm afraid this coin is not intrinsically worth $25 to me because it looks like Um, it looks like it hasn't been minted to its full volumetric atomic weight or whatever I do not want to criticize the gift of your presence but your face That said What's going on here is different though because this claims to be one troy ounce of silver. Okay, you take that out of its little Case and use it empirically go put it on a scale.
It's a troy ounce of silver So we have ways to get around the deficiencies of shaving Why is it that way? Well, it would seem so that whatever this little code or detail is here. Uh-huh can be imprinted on the ridge So the edge of the coin there's a number of the coin identifier. This is coin number 4104.
What does that one? This is coin number Uh, the tab is right in the way. I can't yeah, it's hard to read it But that's the thing right that the ridges there's a word for the ridges on the outside of a coin What does that word? I can't remember it and someday I will and it'll be great, but it will be far from here So for example take a look at this one.
Oh, this is different. Oh, this looks old. This is a whole other rabbit trail We will pursue in a future conversation, but what you're holding there it's copper. This was cast.
Yes This was not okay. So there's there's when it comes to making metal you've got forgings and castings and forgings are I'm gonna hit it really hard and it's going to assume the shape and all the little um voids inside the metal the little air pockets They get squished out so that that's a forgings. It's strange because on one side it appears to be cast I may be wrong about that, but it at least looks like it and on the other it's only hit on one side or struck On one side and it appears to be good grief. Oh, it's a it's a it's a head facing to the right there we go and the person has I mean, I can almost determine an ethnicity of the of the face like it dread lightly sandlin What ethnicity would you say that is and what features are you looking at to determine this?
I don't want to say because uh that's best not to do armchair fornology in this day Anyways, what's fornology? What is the thing where you look at the shape of somebody's forehead and determine their relative intelligence level Like 19th century eugenics like height of human bigotry. Is it really? Yeah.
Yeah, where is this going from? That is a early fourth century coin minted by Constantine the Great Early fourth century forgive me. Where is it so turkey roman? So yeah, Constantine had holdings in the western empire the old roman empire But he's the guy who really officialized the move east the modern day istan bowl was constant an obel Constantinople is named for Constantine the first Constantine the great who defeated sir They might be giant song here exactly he defeated his rival Maxa nightis at the battle of mille and bridge secure power over the full east and west and Centralized the headquarters of government in Constantinople is this copper?
I Assume that it is and I think it might have had a silver wash over the top at some point I see hints of it on there that again like currency and intentional devaluing of currency is something we need to It's a bigger conversation for another time But what's noteworthy about that coin is that you identified it correctly it was struck or it was cast and then struck okay So maybe with an old sand mold somebody cut out several circles for the blanks for the coins And then there's a little channel in between a tab that goes in between so that when you dump in your copper in this case It goes into the first and then it distributes it runs down like when you fill an eye stray with water Yeah before you put it in the fridge And so then once that hardens comes out use metal shears to take off the tabs that connect all of the blanks your picture And what I'm saying yeah, yeah, he blanks connected with little tiny tabs in between like breakaway tabs Yeah, you throw those in a bin melt it down and use them again on the next batch Now you have the blank and presumably at the temple of Junomoneta in the Roman Forum You can still go stand on the spot where that temple operated for all those centuries Some coinsmith in there put that blank into mint and struck it and as a result you get the impression on the obel In reverse one of which is very worn down So you really only get a good look at the figure on the one side on the other side It's very difficult to see because it's an 1800 year old coin 1700 year old coin. Oh wow Okay, it's only just now occurring to me that this is 18 year old like you said it now It's like okay, whatever history, but then I was like whoa Yeah, a lot of people have lived and died since this corn was struck Yeah, there's not a lot of things every day that you hold in your hand that were made by people and Made by people 1700 years ago. What is this called? What is this coin called?
I don't know it's difficult to identify I've got it down to one of four or five coins that were struck during the time of Constantine really But I'm not a hundred percent positive as to what it is yet I need to get my mitts on a few more to compare how much did you pay for this not a ton? Yeah, that kind of coinage right there was in circulation up to the time of Napoleon Roman coinage would still be in use up until the early 1800s in Europe Are you serious mineral value man? The two features that give it value are it's interesting wait in mineral and then who stands behind it? Well the Romans stand behind it and up until the modern age history was looking back in Europe to say like we were at our best When Rome was in charge?
Yeah, we still use their roads. We still use their money We still use their laws we still use their ideas They knew how to do war better you go into the Middle Ages and it's just kind of this big bomber and people like yeah We're trying to get back to that we built castles of stone and marble back then now we build a man of logs It's just not the same and so classical humanism think about all the art of the Renaissance Is it looking forward or is it looking back? That's trying to recapture the artistry of the Greeks and the Romans so the same thing happened with their money the cultural assumption was Rome represents authority The old myth the Genomenate of the God gives you bequeat this value to you that lingered for a real long time into the modern age So the reason we still have this sitting around is not because some collector kept it for a thousand years and handed it down through his Families because I was probably getting used because some French got traded this for a pint there you go Yeah, that that had value it still has value but that had street currency tradable Oh, yeah, I recognize that coin value until a couple hundred years ago. You avoided my question was this two hundred dollars No, it's no you can get a coin like that for a reasonable price say the number I don't know like you can get a coin like that for a reasonable price.
You don't want to I don't remember I okay, that would maybe be worth 50 bucks or less. Okay, maybe 10 or less I don't know I think it had silver on it at one point again something for a future conversation And as the silver wash that it got dipped in I mean originally that probably looked like a shiny silver nickel But gradually that goes away. It's rubbed off on hands and in pockets and whatnot It's exposed for what it is which is a not that valuable coin. That's part of a government deception again longer conversation about the devaluing of currency Are we gonna have that conversation not about here?
But yes, it kind of goes into the shaving coin things it does but not not the shaving of the coin It's the what's the word dilution of the basement the basement that's the term when you change the alloy Yes, and still hold it out as being of the same values the previous thing So you effectively just make money out of nothing. Yes, so you it's kind of a partial lie because you change the okay We have to you change the intrinsic value But you you tell people that the extrinsic value is the same your reasoning your reasoning backwards is why this is a longer conversation But the reason I gave you that coin was one to tease this future conversation and two to show you look at the edges on that One of those edges is a clean cut where the tab came off after it was after it was yeah, yeah The other edges have just gradually been worn down by contact or nipped just a little bit here and there There isn't any reason to nip it once it gets down to the copper because the copper is not worth anything So the nips that are on that happen back when the silver wash was still on it and to the disappointment of some the first time They probably trimmed that edge they were like what? There's a bunch of dark metal in the dog dang it emperor you got me again Okay, and so there wasn't really much of a reason to keep trimming the edges of that coin and that's why it's in relatively good condition Because it's copper it wasn't silver. Yeah, so there's just no human motivation to steal the value off the edges Could you not get much which is interesting because quarters are like that now they have different materials do this is so this is what's interesting This That's what I like to collect and the reason I like to collect those is There's stories.
Yes, like individual like a photo one single photo tells an entire story and so there's probably three thousand photo negatives over there and Sometimes I just sit down with a little light panel and I pull out the film and I look at it And I just imagine who this person is what are they doing? There's a couple of interesting things I've been doing lately for some reason I like boats and photos I like looking at photos of boats because I imagine what it would be like to be a sailor I'm not a sailor, but but I you know, that's like exploration So I really like looking at those I also like looking at photos of old sports teams So imagine the leather helmet football type things or are they like the really weird looking baseball mitts I like looking at those photos because that was a group of people that were together and they were together for a short period of time And they had interactions and all that so anyway, that's what I like doing to me you wanting to collect coins Can we say at this point you're a coin collector? Yeah, my collection is not very impressive, but yeah Yeah, I think they're neat. I'm willing to say I'm a film collector I'm not where you are with film with coins, but yes, I'm a coin collector sure Okay, what I think is cool is this makes total sense because of who you are what I mean you understand ancient governments or you at least like to research ancient governments and the struggle for power and the push between this kingdom and that and a coin is a A way for that big organization that is the government to push its power into the people in a very interesting way into the fabric of their lives Yes, and so I can see how this would be interesting to you in very I mean, there's a ton of different ways why I could see that your mind would like it Which which is why it's interesting that you handed me a coin that was not minted by government in a modern age I can see why this is also interesting to you 1800 years from now.
Nobody's going to pick up this coin And say oh look this was minted by the United States of America or whatever There's gonna be like oh look somebody thought silver was neat and so they made a coin And so that's that's a very different thing so it doesn't have the weight of the history behind it This is more like a You know, it looks like they copied the eagle landing on the moon from the half dollar pieces. I mean, that's the Apollo 11 There was an eagle landing on the moon with an olive branch on the Apollo 11 patch and then Michael Collins book He tells the story of why they chose that eagle But it looks like they copied that eagle to get some of the what does the word regal mean regality? You know what I'm trying to say, right? Yeah, authoritative.
Yeah, but authoritative from almost a monarchy perspective Just this is authoritative because of authority. Well, it's a different because it wasn't minted by government This is if there's a person's like hey this really cool thing happened and it should be commemorated And there's nobility in that apart from anything involving the state, but it does have mint spaces on it has their names on it Michael Collins Neil Armstrong buzz Aldrin 50th anniversary I don't know. It's just a really interesting thing It strikes me as odd that you handed me this coin and not a Chinese panda or I guess they're I want to give you that those are expensive, right? Well, I know you can get those in a silver too But I don't know it's just interesting.
So what would it have meant on a friend level if I gave you a Chinese panda in a silver? I see it would mean here's 25 bucks. I see why on earth would I give you 25 bucks? So you gave me this because you like space.
Yes, there's a reason that when it was your birthday the first year that we were friends I didn't send you 79 dollars Uh-huh I sent you cool pants because they're comfortable and they have a gusseted crotch and it makes it easier to do active things while wearing durable pants outside Yeah, and I thought I bet you'll like those pants too. Yeah, the 79 dollars would have been a stupid gift Like if I just gave you 25 dollars an eight cents right now It would be weird, but instead I'm like this has intrinsic value people work to get it out of the ground That metal is something that if you ever need it You can melt that down and use it for different purposes and further look what's on it. You care about that too I do and so this immortal metal is combined with this immortal moment as something that has value and implicitly it reinforces that moment has value And so yeah, that's why I want to give somebody something like that And now into the place where if I see a coin that has anything on it that reminds me of somebody I really care about Like I'm buying that coin. I know exactly who to give that to because it just says something and that's the objective Well, thank you very much.
I appreciate the gift. You're super welcome Yeah, uh, and nobody knows how many of these things I have in my hand I do have one at least at least one. Do I have a second or you did a second ago? Yeah, I could say who I just put your hand out I may or may not put that back in your hand.
I don't know if I have it or not This is off the books. There is no blockchain. Yeah, well, thanks for being a good friend and uh, Thanks for understanding what I was going for and giving you something as simple as a silver coin with a spaceship on it Thank you for imparting value into my life That's that's the objective The give and take of friendship. I think is better expressed in silver than it is in paper