Skip to content
132. The Phantom Flan Singer episode artwork

Mar 18, 2024 1 hr 9 min

132. The Phantom Flan Singer

from Retrospection Hosted by Colin and Paul

The Phaaaantom of the opera is here, but not that Phantom because of legal reasons. It's a different creature that stalks Brian De Palma's, Phantom of the Paradise (1974). Join us as we tackle the plight of a disfigured man filled with revenge (but enough about Paul). Along the way Paul admits he'd sell out in a heartbeat, Colin wonders just what he'd sell his soul for, and we both talk about our love of a nifty split screen.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

132. The Phantom Flan Singer

0:00 1:09:53
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Retrospection, and as the curtain rises and the lights flicker into life, it's a musical journey for the past of love, horror and fantasy, as we cast the spotlight on Brian DePermis' rock musical, Phantom of the Paradise from 1974. I thought you were talking about my life for a second, then I got worried? I did say, horror, but I also mentioned love, so it couldn't be your personal. This is true, this is true, no love here.

Hello, my name's Colin, and I'm under contract too. For what? For this podcast, I signed in blood. It is true actually, I was there, that's what we'd happen.

You made me do it. Well, you were there, you were there, you were there, you were there, you made me, you're the devil. You know what you're doing? I'm just going to be a lemon scented candle.

I took you over for a meal first. What did you up? Ooh, it's not like that good Paris, is it? My name's Paul, and I would never let my personal desires influence my aesthetic judgement.

Yeah, you would? All the time. Name of, name of any instance when I've done that. Oh, I can't, it's for legal reasons.

I think there's a little bit there actually, yeah. Yeah. The film's there as Paul Williams of Swan, who wrote the scar in the lyrics of Bugsie Milog? Yeah, he's a legend.

William Finley, as Winslow Leach, Jessica Harper as Phoenix. Garrett's Graham? Yes. Is that right?

George Mimmoli as Philbitt, and actually Han as the juicy fruits. That's what you call your man boobs, right? Well, yeah, tasty. Who says everyone?

Oh, everyone. Really? I don't know what you're saying. I almost said, yeah, they're full of moisture, but, you know, only in the summer.

Look at his face. That's a horrifying thought. I don't think he'd have his mould. Direct with Brian DiParma, a writer's heir, Brian DiParma, and Louisa Rose who's uncredited.

Ryan DiParma. Mm, I said that. Directed this moving. Yes.

Yeah. Okay. The director was often cited as the leading member of the new Hollywood Generation film directors, people like George Lucas, Francis Fudd, Coppola, Steven Spielberg, John Villius. Yes, that Brian DiParma.

He's done some films. Yeah, yes, you're right. All right, that came out, Rob. I mean, he's choices often.

Is this deep knowledge that people listen to this podcast far? Is it? Right. Yeah, you're all that Brian DiParma.

He's done some films. His choices are quite mixed, aren't they? He's quite a mixed bag of choices that he chooses to do. He's got a lot of favourite Brian DiParma films, including this one, obviously, because I keep the game away.

Obviously the untouchables. He's got to be up there, isn't he? Yes. And I do kind of like Dressed a Kill.

I thought you didn't like it. I've watched it again since the first time I watched it, and I've learned to appreciate it a little bit better now. I think it was the twist that got me last time, kind of irritated. You slagged it off left-right and said to me to see that.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, and I've grown a bit since then. You've grown a bit since then. Yeah, was it six months ago? I think it was a bit longer than that.

Who was this time I should use. That's it. I think it was the Italian exploitation cinema. So maybe that's softened me up to Dressed a Kill a little bit.

I can see that because it is lit. Yeah, it's very jowl though, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I like Blowout.

He's had a confession. Yeah, I've finished you to be up. I just love it. Like Riff, I do.

That's the travolta movie, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I like that one. Yeah, that's a good one.

Any others? Alright. Probably let's remember off my head. Well, I've got one, but I can't really say until the end.

I don't think I've any of it away. Oh, interesting. Sissy Spacek was the set dresser. Yeah, and apparently she did such a bad job that it cost a day's worth of filming.

I've seen this film. How do you do about the set dressing for it? It's that age-old question, isn't it? Like, you know, how do you in a really bad work situation, how do you make it?

Don't laugh at me. How do you make it worse? And she was Sissy Spacek. She was...

She was Sissy Spacek. She was a little bit about her name. Sissy Spacek is really difficult to say, especially when you had a couple of drinks. What?

Oh, well, I'm drinking. What is this? You won't be familiar with it. I think people call it Whatter.

It's quite tasty. It's good for you. No, no, no, no, no, no. No, no, no, no, no.

Yeah, she lost out to Jessica Harper for the Royal Phoenix. She auditioned for it, but didn't get it. I liked Jessica Harper, isn't this? She's good.

Yeah, she's really good in another musical for a few years later called... She's not a bonkers out there, maybe called shock treatment, but don't you sing that? Isn't that supposed to be the follow-up to Rocky Horror? Kind of, kind of, yeah.

Kind of, yeah. Is it only in the sense that it has similar people in it? Is it that kind of? It has Brad and Janet in it.

But not played by the same actors and actresses that played in Rocky Horror. In fact, Jessica Harper, I think she plays Janet in it. I think she does, yeah. She's good in that.

She's got a great voice. Yeah, is that her actually? Yeah, yeah. She's got a great voice.

Yeah, yeah. It's very sultry and treacle-y, I find. All right. Interesting.

It's something like you're talking about a wine. But actually, wine kind of says a very similar to audio files. They describe things in the same kind of way. That's very true.

They use a lot of tactile expressions, don't they? To describe things. Yeah. If you had to choose a tactile expression to describe this movie, what would you use?

Fuzzy fact. I'd go with wet. Oh, really? In a good way.

Oh, in a good way. Yeah. Can wet ever be a bad way? I suppose it could be.

You really want to go there? On the podcast? No, I don't think you know. No.

This movie was a flop when it was released, surprisingly. Although, apparently it did well in Winnipeg, Canada. Why, but in particular? Hey, why did Voyager Rock A do well in Germany?

Oh, that's a place where David Hasloff also did well. There is, there is, you know, history, though. I guess so. I guess so.

But yeah, there's any place that did well. Dash Punk, you remember them? Yes, it does. This is one of the, they call it major influence on the music and work.

Explains a lot. It does. It does. In the original screenplays, one was named Spectre.

And apparently the character was basically on Phil's Spectre. They almost got it right, didn't they? You think about it? Yeah.

Yeah. Wow. I didn't know this was a documentary. Might as well.

This is interesting because we should probably talk about wine a minute, but it was, this was originally going to be called just the Phantom. But the people that ran the Phantom Comics script demanded that it be changed. Oh, yeah. And we are going to do that movie next, don't we?

I think so. Yeah. The Billy Zayn film. Yeah, we haven't done a Billy Zayn movie yet.

Surprisingly, everyone. Yeah, that's true. We haven't. We have not done the Great Billy Zayn yet.

We should do a Zaynaphon. We should. We should. Yeah.

Top three Billy Zayn performances. Oh Christ, I died. I don't know. Who does Billy Zayn films off the top of their head?

Do you do free? I bet even he can't name three movies he did. Even his mum can. And I like Billy Zayn.

I like Billy Zayn as well. I like Billy Zayn as well. I've got nothing against Billy Zayn. Nope.

Nope. Just can't remember what he's doing. No. The film was subject of various lawsuits.

They had one from the estate of Gaston the Roo, the writer of Phantom of the Opera. Well, I can see that. They had one from Universal Pictures. Oh, because it borrows from some of the horror types material.

And then, like I said, they had problems with the Phantom Comics script, people as well. So there was a lot of trouble going on in this movie, I think, behind the scene. Yeah, it was worth the effort. We'll find out, won't we?

Yeah, we will. Gary Graham. Great. Gary Graham.

Who you seem to not recognize from anything else. Nope. Nope. Nope.

Tell me, later on, we'll have seen him before. Chud, too. Oh, of course. He was very unwell during the making of this movie.

Why? I couldn't find out what was wrong with him, but I know when he did his big number, life at last. He could barely walk, apparently. No.

Well, those pants are tight, though. They are very tight. Yeah. So maybe that's why.

Cut it off circulation to your innards. Yeah. And your actors. Both.

And you did either the Rolling Stones or the Who to portray the singing group in the movie, but they proved too costly. You can see that. That's a surprise, yeah. Anyone over a tenner?

There's also, this is one for you, actually, because you're into your novelizations. There's an infamous novelization of this movie. Apparently it's notorious for its rush writing style. We've never been accused of that, would we?

No. Don't know what you mean. And apparently it removes any and all supernatural elements from the story. And it turns a winds down and fiends into a much more perverse and unsympathetic characters.

This was published. Oh, definitely go to track this. Yeah, I thought you might. Yeah.

Again, a hint of flash Gordon novelization. Yes, yes. I'd be interested if he was written by the same guy. I wouldn't know that would explain a lot.

Yeah, now I'm thinking, yeah. And the film was originally slated to be released in the summer of 1972, but ended up coming out around 74th Halloween period. And I think that was probably due to a lot of post-production problems and changes that they had to make to things because of all these lawsuits and everything that was going on. So it's 50 years old this year.

I gotta say, though, 50 years old. Even though obviously its style is dated, it doesn't feel like a movie that's 50 years old. I thought the exact same thing when I was watching it, that it feels like a modern movie set in the 70s. Yeah.

A budget was 1.3 million. Do you want to take a stab at how much it grossed, Colin? Right. So it lost money.

We know that. It lost money. All right. Okay.

And so you said it like that. 100,000. You're being a little harsh. A little harsh.

I might have. 250,000. Yeah. Oh, I was going to 250,000.

Okay. So it is a massively cult movie. A lot of people love this movie. I know people that like this movie and talk about it a lot.

Oh, oh, that would be disappointing. I think they do listen actually. Yeah. It could be interesting.

Would you group this film with Vojd at the Rock Aliens and Streets of Fire, those kind of films? Definitely Streets of Fire. I think it's a cut above Vojd your okay. It's as much as I like that movie.

I think it's a little above that. Oh, please no. Oh, that's interesting. You said that.

Oh, dear. All right. Okay. I am genuinely looking forward to finding out what you think about this because I don't know which side of the fence you're going to jump on here.

Let's also make one for clear. You've seen this numerous times. Oh, yeah. Yeah.

And you're wearing a t-shirt with it on your t-shirt right now. I thought I'd make an effort for podcast. Yeah. You've put it on.

I've never seen this before. This was my first time. Yeah. That's why I suggested it because I'm curious to find out what you think.

Okay. Okay. Let's go. Well, yeah.

Let's get on with it. So how do you even start? I'm hoping the ratio by Rob Serling of all people don't. We do.

Yes. Did you, did you, did you record this? You have it written down? No.

No. All right. Can't, can't stop doing that these days. Well, it basically just, just tells you how evil swans going to be.

And that is something mysterious about it. No one quite knows what it is. Yeah. So we, we kind of open up a band that's called the Juicy Fruits and they're doing like a 1950s style number.

Yeah. Well, they're acting a little weird because they're attacking members of the audience. Yeah. But, but it looks like it's all, all contrived because once they get attacked, they kind of move away out of the shop.

So it's all like an act. I thought that they were filming something for like a TV show or something like that. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. One of them's going around in the background feeding Juicy Fruits to the rest of the band. Do you know, isn't that? No, I didn't.

But that's a never band. So that must be the gimmick, right? And then this band will change styles throughout the film as, you know, Nibi. They'd come up golf band at some point.

It's a good song that I was opening it with. It's a good song. It's very, it's very reminiscent of that 1950s where someone died or kills himself over a woman or the woman's in a car crash. Yeah.

Tell, wasn't her, Tell Laura, I love her, that kind of. That's the one. Yeah. So it's got that feel about it.

Yeah. Because the song ends with the lead singer, Mok, Savid himself. And there's an eight one point he ramps the microphone quarter. He's tends to like over the top.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

But he's going, I like the opening. Get you straight away. Get you, get you, get you, get you, get you, get you, get you, get you up. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. And then we get Winslow Leach, right? Yeah. It's first song at the piano.

It's kind of Gilberts Sullivan-esque, isn't it? Yeah. Nice. Well, Swan likes that song, right?

Mm-hmm. He wants to steal it. And he's going to get his second in command, Philbin, to steal it for him. And they're never going to play, pay Winslow any money for this.

Oh, no, they're kind of non-screwing him by everything. Yeah. But they're going to pretend that they're going to produce him. Yeah.

Yeah. And Philbin is also kind of like a sleazy, I'll do anything for Swan henchman kind of guy, which I'm sure that these people exist in the music industry. I think they exist in podcasts too. We're trying to say, Colin.

Oh, nothing. Nothing. Nothing. Whatever that contract.

Where have I ever screwed you? I've got anything. Well, glad you finished that sentence. Nobody's listening as Winslow's performing his song either.

Do you know what's that? Well, they're just going on about the business. Everyone's just walking out and doing what they need to do in the studio and just ignoring him completely. Right.

I see someone walking behind him and stuff. Yeah. Yeah. It's a good song.

I do like William Finley's performance in this because he starts the movie off being so kind of innocent and naive, doesn't he? By the end of it, he's a monster. Yeah. I do think he could have turned it off a bit though.

Well, even more bonkers than the one you've been on. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.

And it's yeah. I'll tell you the reason when it appears. At least I think so. I know it's just my opinion.

We do see that he's got a bit of violence on though, even at the beginning because when Phil mentions that someone else could sing his music for him, he does kind of turn a little bit, doesn't he? Right. Because they want the juicy fruits to do it. That's right.

Yeah. Yeah. Well, you would turn too if you'd written this haunting barwood and you want some beat combo to do it for you. Wouldn't you?

Depends how much it would play in me calling. Oh, I forgot. Yes. You're more of the Philbin character.

I'd sell out. You'd sell out. Yeah. It's just the principal's path.

I'm worried I got you. That's it. I'm facing you. Yes, exactly.

There you go. Yeah. You're right. Oh, what a fool I've been on my life.

What a fool. One month later. Mm hmm. So it takes him a month before winds are going to hold on something's a bit suspicious here.

Well, he's not even trusted. Isn't he, I guess? He's like me. You're right.

So he goes to Swans. Deaf records. Sorry, what? Deaf records.

Speak up. I mean, the joke doesn't even work. He's not spelt D. A F.

Yeah. I'm saying yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. It was funny. I liked it. I like the look of this movie a lot.

It's got, so when you go to the record companies or Stark and White and very clinical looking and then you're in the movie, everything's very Gothic and lots of deep colors and things like that. Although if I was going to criticize something about this movie, I would say that it's too well lit at times in the Gothic, but it's like in a movie. Everything's very well lit. Oh.

You want it partly lit? I just like a bit more atmosphere. Oh, you like a party with an atmosphere. I'd say that I thought you could do Ross Abbott here.

It's a musical film. I'd imagine Ross Abbott turned up. It would be good. It would be good.

Yeah. What Ross Abbott character would you want? Oh, I know you're asking me to remember any of his Ross Abbott characters. Basilton Bond?

I was in Aang, wasn't it? Yeah, Basil and Bond. Yeah. What was the Scottish guy?

Remember one of the braces? See you Jimmy. See you Jimmy. Yeah.

I think Basil and Bond would be better for this film. It would. Yeah. You always were like about like a barlachliver and a frogman slippers and a navy suit, right?

Yeah. Yeah. I got a clue. So he's trying to get into the records to find out what's going on with his music, but he's thrown out.

Yeah. Why do I get the feeling that this is how all our pitch meetings would go if we tried to sell something to a major company or studio that we'd be thrown out like this? Well, probably because you'd turn up drunken just for all over everybody. I can't hold it together when I have to.

I'm not a monster. Yeah. When you hold it together, you're doing it in public. I thought you said we weren't going to mention that anymore at the podcast.

Oh, there's nothing we can't mention. Was that right? Oh, well, except, you know, those six months ago, I don't mention it. Yeah.

My life. Yeah. What happens in car food stays in car food, right, but I'll. I thought you were going to say bop now.

Oh, you went abroad for this. Lars are different. I think it's a good thing that Alice knows that we're doing a bit and it's not real. Yeah.

Oh, are we? Yeah. I didn't know that one. That's that.

You just go with it. Oh, OK. So yeah, they throw him out. They throw him out.

And then he later tries to sneak into Swan's private mansion, right? There's a whole line of women all like singing or trying to sing because they've all got the song sheets, right? Yeah. And this is where we meet Phoenix by Jessica Harper.

Yeah, because Winslow finds her singing the best. She's really beautiful singing. And he recognizes the lyrics as being his own. Yeah.

She doesn't quite believe him at first, but she's kind of innocent as well, though, isn't she? Compared to all the other women that are waiting to be auditioned as well. Yeah. Yeah.

And we discover our innocence. She is because we realize that this audition isn't really an audition about singing, is it? No, it's more like your kind of audition process, right? Yeah.

Well, but one second before I said it's the audition is just Philbin having sex with the women. You recognize that interview technique, don't you? I knew it. I knew it.

I like that in there. Yeah, you do it. I like to get in there fast. Yeah.

Leave me. We know each other too well. I do. It's just a question of who gets the first.

It is, it is. Yeah. But it all ends badly for Phoenix and Winslow, doesn't it? It's all auditioning.

Yeah, because she obviously doesn't want to be seduced by this Philbin character, so she storms out. And Winslow gets thrown out and beaten up. Yeah, he does manage to sneak in wearing a dress, doesn't he? And he's in the middle of the, the orgy thing that's going on on the bed.

Yeah. And then Swan comes in. He swans in, you can say. You could if you were a bit lazy.

Yeah. So he's beaten again. He's framed for drug dealing by two cops, right? Who swans paid and he's given a life sentence in Sing Sing.

Which is kind of fun. We should point out this movie's been running what? 20 minutes at this point? It moves really fast.

Yeah, it does. Yeah. They got some weird program at this prison where they remove your teeth and replace them with metal ones to stop infection. Shoeing you would not want your dangerous prisoners to have metal teeth.

I mean, we all know what Jaws could do in the Bond movies. Yeah. You don't want to go down that route. Yeah.

No. Shoeing through the bars and yourself. That's a very good point. Yeah.

So what's the point of it? It's funded by the Swan Foundation. So what's he doing with the teeth? Who's the music guy, right?

So what's he doing with the teeth? Yeah, what's he doing with the teeth? He's got a teeth fetish. Maybe he likes to bathe in teeth.

Oh, maybe that's how he makes his money. He puts them on the pillows and then the tooth fairy keeps leaving him money. And that's how he keeps his business going. That's a busy tooth fairy.

Unless you put a load on your pillow in one go. You know, like a lump sum kind of thing. And tooth fairy just writes a check. Yeah.

Very modern tooth fairy. Oh, he puts the teeth on one of those machines where you slide your credit card on that. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I miss those.

What? Those machines. No, those. Oh.

Wait, I'm getting on. You know, they had a good solid whack to them when they did the credit card thing. Yeah. Yeah.

I've never even seen those machines. I've been not. I was just too young for those. I've seen them in films.

Granddad told me. Did he? Okay. Okay.

I'll believe you. I'll believe you. I'll believe you. So you're scared by jumping through a window.

I hope that's not as easy as that to actually escape from a prison. Yeah. It's a bit of simple. Doesn't it just guys himself in a box as well?

Yes. Yes. Yeah. It's a bit simple.

But it's time in reality anyway, isn't it? I mean, it's not. It's a crazy movie anyway. Yeah.

I've been talking about it. In terms of everything else that's going on. I can go with it. It works within the logic of the film.

Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. So he breaks back into the death records and he starts crashing the place, doesn't he?

Hasn't he also part of the reason he escapes, isn't it? Because he's heard that the juicy fruits are making a record. That's right. Swans going to help him.

Yeah. I think he comes on the radio, doesn't it when he's in the prison. Yeah. Yeah.

So that gives him the impetus to escape. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

And he breaks into death records, like you said, but he's seen by a guard. Yeah. And then he gets squashed in a record press machine. Yeah.

And then he gets manufacturing press. Yeah. And they put rubber, like foam rubber things, like it was a record press, but then it needed squashed his head anyway. Apparently the screen that he let say, when he's trying to get out of it, it was a real screen because he panicked.

Method, sort of like. Health and safety on the 70s movies. You've got to love it, haven't you? Well, it's not much better now, is it?

Yeah. That is very, very bad. Yeah, yeah. I don't think about that.

It's still ongoing, man. So when he gets disfigured, but his body's never found, he jumps in the river, doesn't make your fores into the river. Yeah. Yeah.

His vocal cards are damaged as well. Yeah, they are. So it's a bit later and the Paradise clubs get ready to open and we get the POV shot with someone heavy breathing as he makes his way into the club. Yeah, I thought it suddenly switched on to your personal films.

I knew that was coming. Personal films. But then, but then after it climbed two flights of stairs, I knew it wasn't you. Because the camera would have just fallen forward to all you tears.

Well, like a dumb idea. That's not parl. You're probably right. Yeah.

They do look steep. They do. Yeah. It's a fire escape as well.

Yeah. Do that. Not anymore. At my age, I must be joking.

Yeah, I age. Yeah. If you've jumped out a few fires, get to the time. Those little husbands.

I wasn't seeing them. You were? I mean, I'm not chasing you because they were disappointed. Always a possibility.

Yeah. So he breaks in and he finds himself a costume, doesn't he? He does. Yeah.

He chooses a good one. Could have gone horribly wrong. I like this costume. It's kind of, it's Gothic horror meets glamorock, isn't it?

Yeah. You mean you like it as a costume, not one you'd like to wear at your next dinner party. I would not wear it, Colin. I wouldn't not.

I wouldn't not. I wouldn't not wear it. Hold on. You would wear it.

I'd say I wouldn't not wear it. Wait, wait. Why won't you just say you would wear it? Why are you making it completely?

You can imagine me wearing that helmet, can you? Try not to. Oh, just a helmet. You're not wearing the rest of the costume.

Well, I mean, obviously, I'm not just a helmet, I'm not naked. A helmet and then just a normal suit. That'll be weird, won't it? It would have been a helmet and where my, you know, Phantom of a Paradise t-shirt that I'm modelling at the moment.

You could, yeah? Yeah. Yeah. And we get some 70s split-screen stuff as we...

I'm trying to do it in the movie as well, isn't it? I think. I can only recall one split-screen. I'm trying to remember if that was this point.

So, I think so. Yeah. So, we get to see the juicy fruits and now have been remodeled into kind of like a beach boys type band, haven't they? Yes.

Yes. Can I do like the split-screen from the 70s? Yeah, I do. I do.

I do. Do you know what I like? I like when they did modern the split-screen when they just got really crazy and it had like far different, like you had a box and everything, you could see all different angles at the same time. Yeah.

I kind of like that. Yeah. Yeah. That's actually using the format.

Exactly. So, an advantage that you can't get on a TV? It was something though, and it was a gimmick I suppose. It was a gimmick.

But it was something that had a very small window, didn't it? Yeah. It just disappeared. Yeah.

And I assume it came about just trying to stop people watching it on TV going to the cinema instead because you couldn't get that on the far by for each one. Yeah. I think so. Yeah.

Yeah. It's a shame. But, yeah, I think the Burke Reynolds one, I think that has a lot of it. Yeah.

And I think there's that Elvis concert movie or the Abba movie. I think they use it as well. It's perfect for a concert. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. I think Tarantino's used it once a time. Well, he was.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Retrospection?

This episode is 1 hour and 9 minutes long.

When was this Retrospection episode published?

This episode was published on March 18, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Retrospection episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.