Skip to content
136 - Anakin Didn't Need a Lightsaber, He Needed Therapy episode artwork

Jun 30, 2022 1 hr 40 min

136 - Anakin Didn't Need a Lightsaber, He Needed Therapy

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: AUDIBLE Let Audible help you discover new ways to laugh, be inspired, or be entertained. New members can try it free for 30 days. Visit http://audible.com/ndq or text ndq to 500-500. STUFF IN THIS EPISODE: Amy Lutz on Twitter Star Wars Hotel Galaxy's Edge Obi-Wan Kenobi TV Series Star Wars Release Dates Taco Bell Star Wars Pogs Burger King Star Wars Action Figures Novelization: Star Wars Prequel Trilogy Star Wars Expanded Universe Clone Wars Thrawn Kathleen Kennedy from Disney Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau The Bad Batch Darth Maul Force Ghost Boba Fett Hero's Journey Prequel Memes Reddit MacGyver Extended Republic Theory of James Madison R2-D2 Rogue One Lars Mikkelsen Federalist #10 CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

136 - Anakin Didn't Need a Lightsaber, He Needed Therapy

0:00 1:40:47
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

All right, I'm Destin and you're Matt. I'm Matt and it's the note of questions podcast. We have a very special episode today. We have Amy Lutz, the correspondent who is also the guardian of memories.

That is correct. We just gave you free reign today. We're just gonna see what's up. No pressure, glad to be on though.

Yeah, it's gonna be exciting. We will follow your lead because you keep tabs on all the things that happened before now, that is your area of purview. So that would include the things we said 15 seconds ago because you're the guardian of memories. So that can be anything, that can be politics, science, history of medicine, history of culture, history of film, I think you took your hand and maybe we're doing history of film.

I did a little bit. So we're talking a little bit about a very exciting historical world important film series, Star Wars. I heard this. I would hope so, because this would be a very interesting podcast that you're not.

Well, yes. So you're talking about the history of Star Wars? Is that what, or like, just Star Wars in general? Just have fun with it?

What are we doing? I think I was telling you guys in the so-called brain room. I think we'll look at this as I did when I was a grad student. I'm gonna throw some questions out.

I'm gonna throw out my very in-depth theories about various Star Wars things and then we'll just see what happens. I think we should wrap up, keep people on until the very end, with our definitive Star Wars rankings, because mine are correct, but I would also like to hear what you all think as well. I like it. I like it.

Okay. When we do rank at the end, are we gonna be ranking the characters or the episodes? What is it we're going to be ranking? So I can be thinking about it as we talk.

Yeah, so I think we just do movies. So we won't talk about TV shows, which are great, are in their own little bubble, but we're just gonna do the movies. However many there are, I should know off the top of my head and we'll just go and order. See what we all think.

Okay. I love it. I'm in. Let's do it.

All right. Well, I'm done. You guys, have you heard the latest Star Wars news about the Star Wars Hotel? Oh, yes, I heard there was a Star Wars Hotel.

We should all be doing this podcast from the latest Star Wars Hotel. I heard the Star Wars Hotel rollout has been, not great. Maybe not what the Star Wars people would hope. Well, it hasn't been great because every night is about $5,000, something like that.

What? You expect a lot when you pay that to sleep? Yeah, it's very expensive. It's very immersive.

I mean, not that I've been, but it's not rolling out and the creators can't figure out why it's not working. It's because it's $5,000 a night. $5,000 a night. I'm trying to think of how you could burn $5,000.

I mean, what service, whatever. Anyway, that's a lot of money. We won't go too deep into it. Okay, got it.

So is it a Disney Land or Disney World? So I think it's in Florida. I was thinking about this recently because I was actually at Disneyland about six weeks ago and I was at Galaxy's Edge. Have you guys been to Galaxy's Edge?

Starlink? I have. It's great. And so the hotel is kind of immersive because if you go to sleep there and there are characters around.

Anyway, not to dwell in the Star Wars Hotel. But being at Disneyland and being at Galaxy's Edge got me thinking about all of this and we have this new Kenobi show. Have you guys been watching this? I haven't.

We have a rule at our house where the whole family has to be together in order to watch either Mandalorian or Obi-Wan and my kids have been doing camp stuff. And so we haven't actually been able to watch Obi-Wan yet and it really burdens my heart because he's my favorite character of all of Star Wars. Well, he was. I'm gonna have to sit here and try not to spoil you on one half of this.

Okay. Okay. I mean, it's just one episode, right? No, it's four.

It's on the fourth episode. Are you serious? Yeah, it's almost over. I feel like a bad person.

Nope. You're allowed not to watch it. It's okay. Oh my goodness.

That is a great unintentional segue into some of the things that I wanna talk about today. Wonderful. So the idea of choice is so central to Star Wars, right? And so at some point, let's kind of put a pin in this and I wanna talk about during this episode, really what the moral of Star Wars is?

What does it mean? Why do we watch it? What do we get from it? I have thoughts and I have many thoughts after watching the trilogy again, but it's pretty cool trilogy and suffering through that.

This week has given me lots of information. But here's where I wanna start. Some things to think about. Star Wars came out what, 45 years ago?

Quite a while ago. It's been 77. So that would be about. In 45 years ago.

Okay. For a long time. And it's become this big behemoth. So I wanna think about, and I've got a couple of thoughts, but I'd be curious to hear what you guys think.

Why are we still talking about this? Like why on a podcast in 2022? What is it about Star Wars that we are still sitting here talking about it? Okay.

This is what's so interesting about this to me. I feel like I am sitting down at the table with two people that really know story and really care about things. I feel like the odd person out here because I think about photon torpedoes and like all the things. But you guys are at your next level.

I feel like the child at the adult stable right now. Come on now. I just gotta do this stuff. Yeah, but I actually enjoy it because I wanna see, you know, I feel like Matt finally gets to talk to someone that understands him.

At least it cares at his level. Amy's always been good for that. Yeah, I know. But- But- But the humanities brain.

So I would say that I enjoy Star Wars because of the escapism of it. And I enjoy connecting with the characters. So the character arc of each individual character is interesting and unique. Not unlike Top Gun that we talked about last time, which is why by the way I have this mustache, Amy.

So- That explains it. Yes, thank you. So and also sorry. I think that the character arcs are fascinating.

Anakin turning into Darth Vader. For me, my favorite moment in all of Star Wars is the lightsaber duel between Obi-Wan and Anakin. That's it. Like that is an amazing moment for me.

And I know it was in the prequels. And I know that, I don't know, for me that was one of the redemptive things about the prequels was the fact that that scene got made. So I don't know. Why are we still talking about it, Matt?

Well, first of all, the prequels just keep looking better. And that's not a compliment to the prequels. That's a question about what on Earth is going on now. And I think we get right into it by asking why are we still talking about it?

Well, that answer comes in waves. For me, wave number one of why it worked and why it embedded itself as a modern myth that people care about is because it leaned into all of the pulp of the 20th century. It captured a hundred years of wondering about the stars and technology and what we could do. We think of that as being all one block, but 45 years ago, we'd never seen anything like that.

Nobody had ever imagined what it would look like if there was a whole other existence. Yeah, the names and the faces, they look kind of similar. We'd seen it in books, but we'd never seen that on the screen the way we saw it. And it felt like there was this whole world behind it.

And we were just getting the little tip of the iceberg. But in this alternate reality that is a long ways away and a long time in the past, there's still this thing that just makes people, people, that makes characters, characters. And so we could divorce it from a whole bunch of things we might have been worried about in 1977. And we could go to this other place and explore the things, the classical themes of humanity, good, evil, slay the dragon within.

So you can slay the dragon without all of those things. And so it was probably the most influential swing at the hero's journey, mythos, in American history. I don't think you could talk about anything that more captured imagination and the more created or rather tapped into categories of good, evil, right, wrong heroism, mentor, mentee relationship, love, intrigue, all of that stuff. I mean, it's an ortho-mythology, but in space with wizards and with American sensibilities.

And I think in wave one, that's why it caught everybody's attention because it was so imaginative, so different, and so big and bold. And the character arcs paid off. Then you get to the prequels. And that's wave two.

And there, now we're into a whole new age of marketing, weaponizing Taco Bell Pogs, and Burger King action figures, and Pepsi Summer of Fun Yoda Kitch. People wanted to see a cartoon Yoda flip around a lot. And for there to be a light saber somehow attached to him. That's what people wanted.

And they gave it to us. Boy, did they give us light sabers. I mean, countless light sabers. And everybody went to all three of those movies and came out and was like, that was awesome.

Five, four, three, two, one. Wait, maybe it wasn't. Oh gosh. Oh no, what just happened?

What was dark dark? Oh, yeah. And the CGI is not age well. I can confirm that.

No. You went back and watched it. I did. I did.

Oh wow. OK. And so that was different. It stuck because a gajillion dollars got spent on a global marketing campaign to seize on the first round of nostalgia and make it work with mythology.

Now it's in everybody's psyche. It's in the mindset because somebody took a myth, and they don't know what to do with it. They spent a ton of money on a new myth. And they don't know how to complete arcs.

They want to move away from a hero's journey. And I get it. We've seen that story for thousands of years. Maybe some fresh turn it on its head take could be appealing.

But that lack of a plan wouldn't be a big deal if it weren't a lack of a plan over the top of a mythology that everybody already embraced and made a part of their personality and that they allowed to shape themselves. And now the myth gets reshaped. And people are like, I don't know how I feel about it. And so why does it matter?

It matters because of birth, weird middle age, and now whatever this is in its old age that causes people to go back and reread the way they adopted the myth early on. That's my theory. I have two questions about this. So I'll ask them both at the same time.

The first question is, were the books written before the movie, the first movie, the second question is what is a hero's journey and how does it apply to storytelling? So yeah, whatever order you want to answer. These are great. And so actually, it's funny.

I'm going to use an example from the wrong movie and say that Matt and I have a mind meld going on because you effectively just gave my answer as well. No worries. I have lots of lots about the book. So no, the books, there's kind of two sets of books.

There are the novelizations of the films, which come with a lot of films like this. And then there's the extended universe, which didn't used to be the extended universe. And so I as a very strange high school kid read the heir to the Emperor's trilogy, the Timothy Zahn books, all of those books, which by the way have made it into the sequel movies, lots of elements from the EU, whether it's intentional or not. I do think it's intentional.

It's an actual character that's made it. EU meaning extended universe, not European Union. Extended universe. Gotcha.

Thank you. I was thinking about euros. I appreciate it. European Union.

OK. No, the extended universe, which is not canon. That is the important part, although I think that. So what this is helping me.

I thought we were just going to talk about our favorite movies. But this is so much better than what I was expecting. What is the line between normal Star Wars? I don't even know the terminology and extended universe.

What do you call it normal Star Wars? That is the canon set of Star Wars movies. The Skywalker trilogy and everything associated with it. OK.

And what is the extended universe? Where is the line of demarcation? So the extended universe are primarily a set of books. Actually, right now, I think they're all books, maybe some comic books that have been video games that have been written over the last 30, 35 years, maybe a little bit more.

That before the prequels arrived, before the sequel trilogy arrived, were kind of considered to be canon. They were considered to be actual real. So what I mean by canon is the canon are the movies, the books, the video games, the television shows that actually track the actual story within the Star Wars world. The extended universe are those pieces of the property that are essentially fan fiction.

I mean, I think that kind of minimizes them a little bit because I think some of them are quite good. But they're not considered to be part of the actual Star Wars universe in the general sense. So for example, the animated series Clone Wars is canon. That is canon.

That is canon. Yeah. OK. And OK, I see.

What makes it canon? The fact that it was made by some Lucas film. Is it the only one that owns it? OK.

It's actually the other day. It's that crass. That's a great answer. Yeah, exactly.

OK. And then they pull these little threads from the EU. So let me get real deep into the extended universe. Not really, actually.

But you talk about the character of Thrawn, who came from the extended universe, makes it into the animated series, and is now making it into the live action series, someone we haven't seen shown up yet. So that's someone that was actually pulled from the extended universe and moved into the canon. And so there are elements of that. And I can hear me talk about two hours about the elements of the EU and the sequel trilogy.

There's pieces that have been pulled in made canon. Oh, OK. And there's a panel. Like I think we talked.

There is a, let me pull this out from the back of my mind. Someone I've talked to, I'm not going to reveal their name, because I don't want to, I don't know if they're like George Lucas. It was me. I was just kidding.

Like, for example, Disney, before they make a decision that has anything to do with the princess, they have this board of people that's like the princess board or the princess panel. And they have to approve of the decision for that particular princess. Would she do that? OK, well, we will allow that to happen.

So there's this panel of decision makers that make that happen. And so the branding around the princesses of Disney are so strong, they have to kind of defend against things they don't want in there. Is there a governing body, maybe, associated with Star Wars? They're like, surely they would call themselves the Jedi Council or whatever.

But like, do you think there's got to be a group of people somewhere that approve these stories? Because some of them are weird. And I don't know. You can tell like, as Star Wars goes along, it was George Lucas got to call the shots.

And then as we went prequels, you could tell that there were some liberties taken. And then more recently, the one-off movies, there's some really weird stuff happening story-wise. Like what? We can, yeah.

So anyway, what are your thoughts on that? I see Matt nodding his head wanting to jump in. But yes, I think it's Kathleen Kennedy and Co, all these Disney executives, right? I don't know.

I feel like, yes, Ish. So Kathleen Kennedy, Descent Ringip Speed. Kathleen Kennedy is, I would say, beloved by none, but indifferented by many. A lot of people who are like, OK, there's Star Wars.

You got space lasers and stuff? Cool, whatever. Whoever makes that happen. I want to watch a thing with my kids.

Give me some space lasers and maybe a little frog pig thing that hops around. And I don't know. Maybe some trade route regulation debate. Just give me that.

I'm fine. And those people who just want that, I would say they don't know Kathleen Kennedy's name. They don't care about her role as executives. I am in this bucket.

This is the bucket. They never cared. They never cared. Like they had a Jedi they liked.

And it's fine. Then you've got the folks who are not a fan. And those folks, their accusation against Kathleen Kennedy would be that she is the face. She's the person who ruined the franchise after Disney bought it.

Now she predates the Disney purchase. But she took it in this kind of nonsensical direction that a lot of fans feel is disrespectful to what they felt about the stuff growing up. I do not have such passionate feelings about a movie franchise. So I used to go to that extreme.

But generally speaking, I thought the story has been most interesting when it's in the hands of John Favreau and Dave Filoni. Yes. Dave Filoni is just our ros guru who had connections to George Lucas's ideas about the story. But Filoni is a better storyteller than Lucas.

He's an excellent story craftsman. He's good at linear storytelling, nonlinear storytelling, onboarding new characters, all of the new beloved characters that have come on board since the first six episodes. So mid-2000s on have been overseen by Dave Filoni. All the characters no one cares about.

Like, look, what it is. The characters that haven't hit look like Kathleen Kennedy brainchilds. So child's children, whatever. And so there is a rivalry within Star Wars fandom between those who are like, no, this is saying important social things.

And we like how more of the Kathleen Kennedy led projects, highlight those items. Then there are those who are like, I don't know. I really like the Star Wars lore. And I feel like Filoni and his buddy John Favreau, who's happy in Iron Man and just hugely talented men.

We like the direction they take it more. And Mandalorian is their brainchild. They executed the seasons of the Mandalorian. The Clone Wars is a Dave Filoni project, Bad Batch.

I think it's directed by a guy named Jennifer Corbett. I think it's Jennifer. And that's a fantastic series that most people don't know about. But it's genius.

You don't get really lightsabers or Jedi or anything. It's just some guys trying to figure out their relationship with this new evil empire that used to be good, but now it turned evil. And it's great. And so what you have is, theoretically, it's one corporate entity.

It's Disney Star Wars. But you've got this imagined attention that the fans project onto it. Maybe it's there, maybe it's not. I have no idea.

Between Kathleen Kennedy and a couple of these dudes who've had more success and who've created more beloved characters and more beloved story arcs. The people who like the Dave Filoni John Fabro, Mandalorian type stuff, they want more of them. The people who don't care, don't care. And that's kind of the way I think the scene breaks down.

So there is no board that you can point to and be like, hey, we hate the myth. We'd like to just let you know we don't want this character to do this or become this. It's just it's dumb. Please don't take the story there.

Go anywhere else. There's no one to appeal to. So then this fandom conflict manifests in such a way that people discontinue their Disney Plus service, say angry things on Twitter, or just offer valid criticism on Twitter, that then Star Wars goes victim mentality on and tries to act like with some kind of cruel attack, or sometimes maybe it is and sometimes it's not. The point is people super care and there are definitely divisions and there is no board or recourse to express your concerns with what the company does with your beloved myth that you've allowed to become welded to your soul.

Thus you get Star Wars chaos. How was that Amy? Does that sound like your experience? I think that's fantastic.

Let me say I actually take kind of like a third bubble. You know, we talk about those two areas in the fandom. Here's my thing. Because I think of, and I can't be the only one who thought about this.

Why is it that there is so much of this fracturing and kind of plot confusion and narrative confusion in Star Wars world that you don't see as much in the Marvel films. Like there is a thread in the Marvel films. And that is the big difference is that with the however many 20-some odd Marvel films there have been over the last 20 years, there is an intentional thread through each one of them. Many of the people involved knew where they were going to end up, all of that.

Whereas because of this kind of inner turmoil, and because there isn't, you know, there is not one person. There's not a qualified year, whoever it is at the helm saying, this is where Star Wars is going to go, it fractures. And you please some people and you don't please some people. I mean, the phlony fabric of a world is objectively in my mind, much better.

I love the Mandalorian. I love what they've done. Objectively. It very clearly is.

I think it's because you have these two sides that don't go together and there's no narrative in it. You know, one of the things, if we jump to the sequels really quickly that my brother and I were actually talking about is the problem with Rise of Skywalker aside from the name, because it is the worst name in the history of Star Wars. But the problem with that movie is that they tried to please everyone. They tried to please the people who grew up with Star Wars.

They tried to please the people who like to flash Jedi, spoiler alert, I may be one of them. And they tried to please people who like to teach. I mean, all of these different things. I thought it was one.

So there was a bit of a narrative mess. And I think that's the problem we're seeing. But Star Wars, the entire universe, is that there just has to be some sort of connection to it. Otherwise, it's just going to be these interconnected little pieces of property that kind of look alike, but have their own independent identity.

And so we've really just gotten into this world of chaos, which again is another great theme of Star Wars. The idea of chaos in order. I remember being a 13 year old boy going over to my friend Steve O's house and they would have all these Lego characters. And they had read all the books.

And they had the Chewbacca character. And they had all these other characters. And his favorite was Boba Fett. That was his favorite character in all Star Wars.

And I remember not understanding where these people fit. And so if I understand you correctly, are you saying that from one character in one movie to the next, that thread of that individual character might not be continuous from one to the next? Or is it just the overall story is not continuous? Which of those are you saying?

It's more the overall story. But I will say within the canon, so let's put the Eusi for a second. Within the canon, there are story arcs and threads that go in unexpected ways. It's probably the best way to look at it.

So if you look at, I just re-watch Phantom, and then I can't. Not a great movie. Darth Maul appears to have died. And then he shows up in the animated series.

Suddenly he's alive again, which is something that people who have been separate directly in half with all of your organs in your abdomen and then falling down a bottomless pit, not guaranteeing of death. No one's ever really gone. And that's the problem because there's no stakes in it because anyone can come back. Anyone can show up, even if they're just showing up as a force ghost or in a prequel trilogy or something.

And so it kind of pulls the emotional tie from the movies out, which is why, you know, going a different direction. It's actually why I think the one movie is fantastic because it has such an emotional core to it. And it has stakes. And it ends in a way that's very sad.

And so I think the universe has gotten very out of control in a way that's very allegorical to how the actual narrative of Star Wars, what exactly are prequels? Well, yeah, I thought you were going to say, which is allegorical to us. Well, it is. That's a little much.

That's a little much. Yeah, right. How long has the debate existed? I don't know.

You guys are like for life imitating art. I mean, this is so long. That's the long time. To understand existential conversation of.

I hear you. The fact that there's no stakes makes a lot of sense to me because when the force ghost appeared in, was that rise of Skywalker? The first time we see the force ghost? I mean, that was way earlier.

That shows up early. You know, you should show up in Last Jedi. No, right. This guy, yeah.

Yeah. But they show up throughout, you know, throughout the series. Yeah, Yoda shows up as a ghost and counter man's everything he taught and said every other point in his existence. Right.

When that happened, I just remember thinking, oh man, you're absolutely right. Anybody can come back at any time and there are no stakes. And if they feel like I'm not as excited as I should be, they can bring back something from a long time ago to make me excited again, that kind of thing. That's pretty much what you're saying.

Well, that's what happened with Boba Fett, right? Is Boba Fett really had a couple scenes in the original films, but because of the you, because of the prequels in a sense, if you see Jane Govet show up and then a young Boba Fett. Because he looks awesome. He did look awesome, I get it.

He had all the toys and things with Boba Fett and his jet pack. But that was really hearkening back to the original trilogy, bringing Boba Fett to the Mandalorian. And then ironically bringing the Mandalorian into Boba Fett, which actually made it better. It did the best episodes of Boba Fett are the back door episodes of the Mandalorian.

And at eight close, yes. Boba Fett is Mandalorian season three. It is. And it's right.

But at least the parts where the Mandalorian shows up. But let's pull back to an area. That's more destined. We're all maybe a little bit.

No, I kind of like watching you guys go there. And it's like seeing people play in a really fun place and not knowing how to play the game. And you're like, I need to learn the rules. That's what it feels like.

I remember watching people play volleyball at a church camp years ago thinking if only I could play volleyball, but I don't know how that's kind of what this feels like. But it's really fun to watch you because I am all by watching you guys talk about it. So that's where I'm at. I'm going to play volleyball at a metaphorically too destined.

I'm sorry I made you watch our volleyball game. This episode of No Dim Questions is sponsored by Audible. And Matt, I'm about to do this thing where I legit try to convince you that we should listen to a book together. You ready?

I do know what book you're trying to convince me about. I do not know anything about said book. And I'm not going to make it easy. OK, this sounds great.

It's great. So I'll go ahead and read the offer we have. If you want to try Audible, go to audible.com slash in DQ or text in DQ to 500 500. That gets you a 30 day trial of free book and access to the library.

You can do that by going to audible.com slash in DQ or texting in DQ to 500 500. Audible is a place where you can get awesome audiobooks. An audiobook I'm going to recommend to you is called The Apollo Murders by Chris Hadfield. Now this book is interesting because I know Chris Hadfield.

We know each other. And he mailed me a copy of this book. And he's got right here in the front cover, Destin, I felt smarter every day by researching this. And then he says something that plays into a pivotal moment in the book.

I will now try to convince you that we should listen to this book, Matt. So Chris Hadfield is an astronaut from Canada. And he has flown in Russian spacecraft and American spacecraft. And he's spent a lot of time on the International Space Station.

So Chris is fluent in Russian. He's fluent in French and English. He's a very interesting person because you've got American astronauts. You got Russian cosmonauts.

You got everything in between. And he's a Chris was from the Canadian Space Agency. And he wrote this book, which is a fiction book. And it takes place back in the late 60s, early 70s, kind of time frame.

I guess it's the late 60s. Yeah, that's Apollo. Yeah, exactly. The premise of the book is there are some murders that take place.

And they're trying to figure out how and why they happened. And you are following the point of view of several characters, one of which is a test pilot who lost an eye during a bird strike. And this test pilot is now being put in the position of, let's just say, an operations expert. And so he is an advocate for the crew, the Apollo crew, on Apollo 18, which didn't happen in real life.

But Apollo 18 in this book is US military astronauts who are going to do something in space that involves, how do I say this, subterfuge slash sabotage of Russian space hardware. So the murders are to keep this trip from happening and to keep the mission from succeeding. I'm not going to tell you who gets murdered by whom, because that would give away too much. But I will tell you this.

Let me just go to the back. So at the very end of the book, now, I'm narrated by a guy named Ray Porter, who's a very, very, very good reader in the very back of the book. It's all fiction. However, the people in the book, most of them are real.

Like, for example, there's a sheriff in Texas that's involved in the story. Chris went back and researched that sheriff in Texas and then wrote some fictional things that this sheriff would do. You've heard of Gene Krantz and Mission Control. Gene Krantz is in the story.

And he has put into fictitious situations. But knowing what we know about Gene Krantz, it's almost like we get to run this artificial intelligence that is Gene Krantz and see what Gene Krantz would do in the situation. Did you feel like all the characters who are actually historical figures behaved in ways that are consistent with the trajectory of life that they created for themselves when they were alive to do that? I think so.

So that's what's so interesting. Like, for example, there's one African-American astronaut that was going to be the first African-American astronaut ever to go to space. He died in an Air Force accident. So Chris keeps that person alive, and he's part of the mission.

And I mean, there's so many interesting historical things that Chris did in this book. And there's so many technical challenges, because the Apollo flight profile is well known. And so what Chris does is, he puts some of these characters along that flight profile. But there's all kinds of things that happen in between.

And let's just say that the Russians get involved, like in flight. The Russians get involved in flight in ways that are really, really interesting. I will read one small section from the author's note. It's the Almaz Space Station.

The Soviet spy space station in the story was real, including the fact that it was armed with a KarTech R-23 machine gun. It launched unmanned on April 3rd, 1973, but it was fatally damaged after two weeks by an explosion and depressurized into a trail debris before the crew could be launched to dock with it. It's orbit decayed until it burned up in the atmosphere on May 28, 1973, and a subsequent Almaz station was also armed with a R-23 gun, which was fired once in a successful test. The Russians had a space station with a gun on it, like a big gun.

And I didn't know that until the story. Let's put it this way, check off's gun in this book. It's fired? Yeah, I mean, you can't have the gun without the...

Yeah, I have a question. Yeah, I have a lot of questions. Would you have to burn to counter the effect of firing a bullet in space? I mean, wouldn't that affect the orbit in positioning of something in Xergy?

That is a very good question. This was actually a problem encountered by the military at some point, and they actually came up with a way around this, something called the Davis gun principle, where you could have a gun that ejects the powder out the backside of the weapon. It's also referred to as a recoilless rifle. But that question you asked is very, very good.

And the answer is yes, if you have a casing of some sort. I mean, and so there's all kinds of questions, like what happens to the casing from the bullets? I don't know anything about a R-23 machine gun, but I want to know about it. Anyway, this whole book, the whole story that Chris created, it's all fiction.

It's worth your time. If you want to just kind of escape and go on this mental journey of what could have been, also all the physics holds, we're just going to run a different simulation on what Nixon's doing, what Al Shepherd's doing. Very, very interesting. Okay.

Who am I tracking with as we go through the story? Is it somebody who's trying to uncover what's going on with the murders? Is that that detective kind of feel? Is it a multi-perspective thing with chapters from multiple point of view characters?

Exactly. Yes, there's multiple characters. There is this guy I told you about, Kaz. Kazemere Zamekis is one of the characters.

There's also, there's some cosmonauts that you go into their brains for a little while. You also go into this lunar geologist. You go into a priest in Berlin who is Russian. You go into the mind of someone in the Ukraine who is commanding a lunar rover called Luna Holt.

It's interesting. I learned so much about history through the window of this murder mystery, essentially. It's really cool. I did not know what to expect, but it's a passive.

Everything I expect. It's hard for me to tell you more without giving things away. Ask me a question and I will give you a new story. Now let's just say this.

That passes the nuts and bolts test of a book I think I could enjoy. That coupled with your recommendation, that would normally for me be enough to be open to trying some out. What if I try to get Chris Haffildall and we can talk about it after the fact? Heck yeah.

Yeah, that adds a wrinkle. Yeah, now I kind of feel bad for being on the cookie in Snudian. Like I'm the designer of what books should be read and not read. Oh crap.

Sorry, man. Sorry, Mr. Astronaut. Very excited about it.

Please don't put me in your next book as a bad guy. If you're interested, go to audible.com slash in DQ or text, in DQ to 500 500. That gets your 30 day trial, free book and access to the library. Go to audible.com slash in DQ.

We can discuss if this airs, then we know that you decided it was okay. There's tons of stuff on audible. I mean, you can, there's a million different things that I've listened to, actually not a million, like a lot of things I've listened to. I've been to space several times, thanks to Audible.

So yeah, check this out. There's also a huge audible plus catalog. Once you're becoming a member by going to audible.com slash in DQ, you have access to the huge plus catalog, tons of really cool titles in there. I think you'll enjoy it.

That's it. audible.com slash in DQ or text in DQ to 500 500. Get your 30 day trial, free book access to the plus catalog. It's worth your time.

Let me pull back a little bit. We're still kind of on this cultural relevance of Star Wars. You know, one of the things that I thought about that Matt, you hinted about, it brought up another question in my mind, which is, think about this, his time in history when Star Wars came out. Your point is a hero's journey story.

It's a very, you know, to your question, Dustin, which we did not answer. And Matt, I'm sure can give a much more detailed answer than I can. Now you got this. But a hero's journey, it's got like 12 steps.

It's a pattern of stories that has been around for a very long time. And it's typically focused around this idea of the chosen one, usually someone who lives in a backwoods area like Tatooine or Jakku, or all of these other Star Wars planets where you have all of these chosen one figures come from. We're under the stairs. Under the stairs are Mary Potter.

And you're nobody. Living with his aunt and uncle in New York, as Spider-Man was, I mean, you could just go through. So like the Odyssey, the Odyssey would be a hero's journey in ancient literature? Yes, a little different cultural sensibilities, but the nuts and bolts.

Yeah. Well, I mean, the ultimate hero's journey is about a man who's born in Azareth. He's born in his backwoods town and then bla bla bla bla. We know the end of that story.

I mean, we talked about Spider-Man. We talked about, I mean, do as a hero's, I could just sit here and talk about 12 different heroes' journeys. But there's steps to it that. And there's different twists on it.

There's different versions that usually meet a mentor with a mentor, usually dies pretty early. And so you've got Obi-Wan Kenobi and the original prequels. You have essentially all of the main characters who show back up in the sequel trilogy, eventually die. And so it's a pretty standard form of story that we are all very used to.

And what is very, at least appealing, I think, not just to me, but to everyone. Is there something about it that you can almost project yourself onto it? That is such a standard story that you could look at and say, this is a movie about a long time ago and a far distance away. But maybe, maybe I'm that kid who's going to do something great, who's going to come out of nowhere and there's something very like wish fulfillment about it.

I think it is also very familiar. So that is part of my answer, which is it is a familiar story and it is a familiar story that landed at a good time. I mean, it came out in 1977. What the world is dealing with in 1977 does that look a lot different than what the world is dealing with right now.

You have high gas prices. You have kind of the backslide ending of the Vietnam War. You have inflation. You have quote unquote, malaise.

Whoa, you're right. And so it's a time when people, yeah, it's a time when people needed that. And this happens throughout the history of film. So the first Spider-Man movie, so this is the Sam Raimi.

Toby Maguire Spider-Man movie. The first one was a huge box office hit because it was the biggest box office poll after 9-11. People needed something to feel kind of uplifting. There's some recent arguments to be made that Spider-Man No Way Home was the first big blockbuster after the pandemic where people were excited to experience a movie together.

And so it makes me wonder if I'm looking at the historical similarities and there's no answer to this. But if I'm looking at the historical similarities between the late-90s and now, what is our Star Wars? What is that thing that's going to bring it together? Is it the last couple of Marvel movies that have happened?

Have they already happened? Or is it something that's going to happen next year or something that's going to happen that you're after? I mean, we don't know. Historians are bad at predicting the future.

But these are the things I sit up in the middle of the night and think about what is our Star Wars going to be? And I don't know what it is. Not Star Wars. I mean, that's a really good question.

It may be Marvel. Yeah. It was. But out of Phase 3 and into Phase 4, it's dead in the water.

It's dead. No one cares. It's not happening. It's not the same.

It's not the same. What was Phase 3 and Phase 4? I don't know what this means. Oh, Phase 1 through 3 on the Marvel side were all of the Hulk Iron Man Thor.

The core of everybody knew these heroes existed before the movie saving came out. Then in Phase 2 and 3, you started to introduce characters who comic book fans maybe had heard of but they couldn't tell you anything about them. When Phase 1 happened, people knew Bruce Banner was the Hulk. People knew that name.

A lot of people would have been able to tell you, eh, Stark, Tony Stark, I think that was it. I mean, these are the most famous characters outside of the X-Men that Marvel has to serve up. And so you could trade on decades of history and nostalgia and there's a reason these characters are popular. It's the best arcs that Marvel ever came up with.

Everybody can relate in some way. The Avengers aren't so much a collection of superpowers. They're a collection of different types of stories. For example, Bruce Banner's story is not the hero's journey.

That's the monster in the house. That's the Jekyll and Hyde archetype, which is a great archetype. Not everything needs to be a hero's journey. And so each of the characters doesn't just represent superpowers.

They represent a story you might connect with that is the narrative that most resonates with your experience. You put them all on a team, you give them all their strengths and weaknesses, then you give them opponents who represent your antithesis, your Nege, your dark version of yourself. The story you hope doesn't happen about you, but there would be a sound about motives for such an evil version of you to happen, and then you have them fight the thing out. And once you get past that core group, the stories are thinner.

I feel like Black Panther is the last character they introduced where the story is going to resonate with a ton of people and not just because he's Black. It's because the story archetype transcends the whole planet and there are people everywhere who relate to his version of the story. Once you get past that first batch, now you're repeating story archetypes. It's why Guardians are just space avengers.

And if they didn't have James Gunn at the helm to make it wildly fun, it'd feel a little bit repetitive and you'd be like, I already get it. So you get into the end of Phase 3, you introduce these ancillary characters who just aren't based on a really strong story structure that anybody resonates with. And they just don't do as well. They just take up a space.

They become a mechanism to make the plot move forward, but we can tolerate it because we still have to deal with the dark version of ourselves, which is a giant purple monster man who I often hold to, who has motives. It's a great Halloween costume. My kids made all of my profiles that my kids make when they went to separate the kid one from the dad one. They put it in the art of all of their and they label it ineditable.

And that means it's monka. That's great. That's great. I can work with that.

So Thanos, we need to know that the hero character archetypes, the story types that we relate to, can defeat the scariest negative archetype, which is what if I thought I was right when I was wrong and I was actually a monster, but I thought I was good. We deal with that insecurity whether we think there's a God, not a God at the spiritual soul level, and phase three took us to the point of rounding out this 10 year epic where everybody's got at least one good rooting interest on that screen. And so when Dr. Strange starts opening up all the portals and on your left happens and everybody emerges and people are weeping in theaters, it's not because the world became comic book nerds for 10 years.

It's because walking through those portals was at least one person who is an idealized version of your story. Wardson all walking through there to defeat the evil version, the evil possibility of you to thwart the scariest version of you. And we needed them to win. And we needed them to win in a way that involved sacrifice and heroism and all the lessons they had learned along the way because it affected us and it mattered.

Phase four is what's happened to sense and it doesn't matter. It's irrelevant. It'll be forgettable no one will ever care. It's nonsense.

It's like the Star Wars holiday special or the Luke Skywalker Muppets appearance. Nobody cares. So I think the tension that is sitting out there that you're asking about Destin and that Amy you brought up beautifully is there a next story or was Marvel phase three was end game. The last time we can come together and agree that all of our stories could overlap and there is an evil version and capacity for evil we all share that we can all come together with our stories to defeat together.

I hope we got another story. And I'm sure we do. I mean did people know that Star Wars was going to come out and be what it was? I mean the people who created Star Wars did not expect it to be the phenomenon that it was.

I mean it only came out and it was a really limited number of theaters initially and then they expanded in because of the popularity. But let me add one more thread in here that kind of connects to what we were talking about in terms of the chaotic world of the Star Wars universe is you got this weird thing with Marvel between Disney and Sony. And so you have these two weird paths between the kind of more of being the most recent version venom of this own little subtle universe, the Sony universe that kind of crosses over into the Disney side but kind of doesn't. I mean there's a lot of people who are coming out to mention that Sony's own Spider-Man right?

And then there's the field anyway. There's going to be an inevitable legal break as well that's going to continue to cause chaos in the Marvel world. So I think maybe unfortunately we're looking at that developing in the same way that Star Wars is. It's just you know into Matt's point you lose the connection to the characters.

I mean it's not only are you connecting with the characters or seeing yourself in them. But look I mean these I think the first Iron Man came out in like 2004. I mean as I'm sitting and something like that. A little later.

Sometime when I was a teenager let's go with that. Okay. Oh that's how it is earlier. But as I'm sitting and watching endgame I'm thinking like oh my gosh I remember high school me.

I was watching Iron Man and really liking it and then me when I lived in California and watching these other specific movies and it like brings your life together in a weird way because you have these cultural touch points and so there's this culmination when it comes to something like endgame which is huge. I mean literally it's let's bring all of the characters you have ever seen ever together. End it. And then it's like what do you do?

What do you do next? And so to your point not only do we have these kind of oh my gosh BCD level superheroes that people don't really know. It doesn't mean you can't necessarily elevate their stories but they just don't have the historical tie. But remember I mean when did endgame come out 2018-2019 this was alright before the pandemic.

And so it's interesting how phase three kind of went out as the pandemic and everything the chaos of the last couple years has come in and it's really symbolized the fracturing of phase four as well. And this is really depressing. So I don't know. So I don't know what our star wars will be but I do have faith that we will have one.

Let me ask you this Amy being you know the keeper of memories or the guardian memories. What was Star Wars before Star Wars? Was there a story or a mythology like way back in the day you had you know all the Greek mythology and stuff like that. But but now in the 1800s 1900s you know moving towards us was there anything in there not now but you know what I'm trying to say.

Was there any stories in that era that kind of unified people and that is a much bigger question I think that it actually sounds I don't know of anything there probably was something regionally but we as a people weren't as unified when the internet and mass media started rising so so I don't know if there was anything like that. That's actually kind of where my brain is going is movies especially have been a unifier in the absence of the unifiers that we used to have in history. And so back in the say the 19th century and before you don't have the internet you don't have the internet you don't have the internet you don't have mass media you are pretty well connected to the people theoretically in your own little community in the United States your state being a really a really big part of your identity. But as we've gone through history beginning in the 20th century and then the 21st century as people have gotten more connected and less connected at the same time and we've gotten more diverse in good ways but also more fractured locally and ideologically there are not as many things in part because we're just a lot of people there's a lot of people in this country that unify us and I really don't know the answer to your question because I think movies have taken the place of things that used to exist before movies did.

So maybe that's why Star Wars was so important when it did hit maybe I don't know. Yeah I think that's part of it I think you know one of the things that historians talk about a lot is you know that movie to come out during the course of the Cold War right before the Cold War really ramped back up. During a time when I will say this is a vast oversimplification but there is something to it there was something very unifying about the idea of you know we are on this side and the Soviet Union is on that side and then you can kind of mirror that into a film like Star Wars but then 1991 when you see the end of the Soviet Union now it's like what do people believe in it and not what do people believe it but what unites people. What is it?

What's the common enemy we don't have one anymore and so it's like I said I think movies have taken that place. I kind of want to unless you guys have something else I kind of want to twist move it back a little bit. Let's go for it. Star Wars world although this is really fascinating.

But we talked about the prequels a little bit and I have so many pots that I would like to discuss. Can we do this just just for my order of operation because I know towards the end of the episode we're going to have to rank our movies. Can you just go through what movie was released when? It doesn't matter the year but just like the order.

So we started with. So 77 was a new hope. Okay. Star Wars when it was released but a new hope.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 40 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on June 30, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.