Skip to content
141 - Weak People Make Bad Times episode artwork

Sep 15, 2022 1 hr 2 min

141 - Weak People Make Bad Times

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: RAYCON Go to https://buyraycon.com/ndq for 15% off your order. Brought to you by Raycon. AUDIBLE Let Audible help you discover new ways to laugh, be inspired, or be entertained. New members can try it free for 30 days. Visit https://Audible.com/ndq or text ndq to 500-500. STUFF IN THIS EPISODE: Michael Hopf quote Those Who Remain by G. Michael Hopf Edward Gibbon Strauss-Howe Generational Theory The Fourth Turning by William Strauss and Neil Howe CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

141 - Weak People Make Bad Times

0:00 1:02:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

All right, Matt. Mm-hmm. I'm going to, you're the history guy. Oh, I'm the, I don't know, I like to do engineering stuff.

I like things like that. You're so good about not saying rocket scientists to shut up. So, no, my mom put me in my place once. She did.

So I've got a quote that I have read. And I would like to pull the thread and just kind of chase it wherever it goes. Some time ago on this program, I commented, and it sounded a little bit like an old man complaining. And I took a little heat from people that reached out and messaged us.

And we're like, hey, I don't think Destin gets it. That was when I was referring to what I was seeing around me that I referred to. The word I used was weakness. Weakness.

Yeah, I knew where you were going to that. So I'm going to read a quote. And I just want to see where you're at on this. OK.

It is a quote most often attributed to someone named Michael Hoph, H-O-P-F. OK. From a book, I kind of believe this was written before this person. There's a book called Those Who Remain.

I haven't read the book. Don't know anything about it. But I think I've heard this long before this individual said this. Hard times create strong men.

Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And weak men create hard times. Is that what you meant when you used the word weak a while back?

I don't know. I don't know. So what I meant when I used the word weaknesses, there was an inability to think creatively. And you just kind of accepted what you were told.

And I haven't changed my position. I have observed an inability to think creatively in situations. I went to a place recently. And I don't even want to explain the interaction, because it's embarrassing for all parties involved.

I asked for a certain type of, there were two ice cream cones. And I asked for a certain type of ice cream cone. And there was a sugar cone and a cake cone. And I'm trying to watch my weight.

And so I was buying some ice cream for some young men that had helped me work on some stuff. They didn't really know how to use hammers and stuff like that. So I came up with this thing that I needed done for these young men that I'm working with. I needed help destroying this wall.

Wonderful. And so I was like, OK, I need you to knock that wall down. And they're like, really? Yes.

With this hammer. You're like Ronald Reagan talking to Michael Gorbachev. It's inspiring. And so I've seen how you parent, you've seen how I parent.

We intentionally stretch our children. We ask them to do things that they don't know how to do. And we expect them to figure it out. And fail some.

And if they mess up, it's not them that failed. It's us. Or the plan was to fail. Right.

It's OK. Like in some video games, you're supposed to die at the beginning. Figure out the way to get through this obstacle. And so I still remember my dad asking me to drill a hole in a round steel shaft.

And I ran home. And he was fixing the lawnmower. I grabbed the shaft. I ran home.

I set up on the drill press. And he said, Justin, look, I need a hole right here for a cotter pin. Now here's what's going to happen. You're going to try to drill this thing.

And it ain't going to work. So go over to the belt sander, sand a flat on it. Then you can get through it with a drill bit. You understand?

Yes, sir. All right. Run. Go do it.

We're going to fix this lady's lawnmower. Yes, sir. And so it was a neighbor down the street. He was fixing her lawnmower.

So I took that rod and I ran. Probably shouldn't have ran with a big long steel rod, but I did. I ran and knew how to use a belt sander. He had taught me that before.

Put a flat on it, chucked up a little one-eigh-inch bit in the drill bit. Very excited. I was using, you know, I was getting down from daddy, right? Turned on the drill, brought down the drill bit, broke the bit.

He hit walked off center, broke the bit. Oh, man. Well, I know where other drill bits are. Chucked another one up, broke another drill bit.

Finally, I learned on the third drill, but I had to like start really, really slow and get the hole started. And then I pulled it all the way down through there. I was probably 11, 12 years old. How much of those bits cost that you broke?

Probably a buck each. So much time did it take you to break them. Oh, 10 seconds. Yeah.

So one minute of total breakage with bit changes and two bucks. Yeah. And you've got it for life. Yeah.

Sounds like a good investment to me. So I ran back down the street to the neighbor. Dad was six and a long, I said, Dad, I'm so sorry, because I knew that drill bit's reported to dad. And I never put him back.

It's just kids never put drill bits back. And I said, Dad, I'm sorry. I broke two drill bits. It was my confession, you know?

It's OK, boy. That's why I told you to stay in the flat on it. Otherwise you'd have broke 10. I said, I knew you'd break him, but thanks for throwing the holes.

Yes, sir. I remembered that. Because to me, it was a failure to him. It was a positive.

He was teaching me how to drill a hole in the shaft. But what he was really teaching me in that moment was how to parent. And I didn't know that because I didn't know the Lord would bless me with children. So that happened.

So fast forward to now. Recently, I'll give you an ice cream cone thing. I wanted a certain ice cream cone. I said, can I have one of those small ice cream cones?

I don't know what to call that. But can I have that one? How do I order that? And the individual behind the counter looked at me and said, I don't know.

And behind this individual, there were 10 people working. And I just looked at them and I said, OK, that's the one I'd want. How do we do that? And they said, I don't know.

Nothing else. Silence. I don't know. And I thought, whoa, this is what?

I didn't know what to do. And I said, well, where is ice cream on the menu? And they said, it's up there somewhere. And I turned around and I pointed.

I said, well, let's look. And so I went into teacher mode. I said, well, let's look at the menu. And I thought, well, maybe this is a person that brand new.

Does it know? First job, whatever. Let's look at the menu. Huh, let's look up here.

OK. All right. Well, there's ice cream. It says dish.

OK, there's a what is that? There's a sugar cone. Oh, it says it's a cake cone. That's what it is.

I'm sorry. I should have ordered a cake cone. Can I have a cake cone, please? And they said, I don't know how to do that.

I don't know how to ring that up. And I looked and there was the individual did not want to solve the problem. And what do they want? You could order something else?

I didn't know. I didn't know what to do. And so I said, well, is there someone we could ask? Is there someone here that knows how to ring that up?

And they looked at me like, don't let me ask. I was like, oh, man. And I felt pity. And I felt sad.

And I was like, is this individual oppressed? What's happening? Like, do I need to help this person? Like twice.

Yeah, I've played twice if you're in danger. So I didn't know what to do. So we worked through that. I turned to my son and I said, what was that?

He said, I don't know. That was strange. We went to GameStop. Later, it was my daughter and myself.

And my son has started playing Legend of Zelda, the gold cartridge, right? Oh, it's awesome. We sit around and we play together. It's the most video game magic I ever felt.

Same. And so we've been playing together. He's troubleshooting and problem solving. And I'm encouraging this.

And he's getting into these types of role playing games. And I've heard I didn't play it as a child. But I heard that Final Fantasy, like the old school Final Fantasy games, were really good at that. Yeah.

And so if you ever played those? Oh, yeah. I think Final Fantasy I is still one of my favorite games ever. And I really liked three as well.

I played the later stuff on more sophisticated consoles. Which one should I get him? One? One?

OK. OK. So I went to GameStop. And I said, do you have any of the old Final Fantasy games?

I'd like to buy one for my son. And he goes, ah, let me look. He goes to the computer. Now we don't have any in store.

I was like, well, I thought to myself, I was like, well, I can clearly go home and just Google it and get one off eBay. I was like, no, they're in my community. I want to support the store. Can I order one from you?

And you just send it here. I'll pay full price right now. And you just send it here. And I'll get it.

And yeah, can we do that? So yeah, totally. That's great. And so he takes a minute.

He starts packing away the keyboard. And he's like, OK, cool. Yeah, we'll do it. What's your name?

And I was like, oh, oh, no. It's the thing. They want all my information. And I was like, I just want the thing.

And I want to give him money. I was like, Josiah Pennywessel. That's the name I ordered things on. So I'm doing a way that's not lying.

I was like, that's how I ordered things. Josiah Pennywessel. They're like, OK, let's see. Yeah, what's your phone number?

I was like, yeah, I'd rather not do that. And the guy looks at me and goes, I have to put a phone number in. I was like, great. 999 555-200-256-256-256-1.

You know, or whatever, 256-256-256-1. He's like, yeah, I can't do that. And I was like, it's cool. I mean, whatever you've got to put in there, I just want to order the game.

I just want to buy it from you. He's like, yeah, I don't know how to do that. Just act like you're a walrus with flippers, move the flippers over to the number pad. And then bang your flippers repeatedly until all of the spaces are populated.

I just want to give you money. And so what I realized is every business has a mission or every organization has a mission that they're trying to accomplish. And I believe that people are losing sight of whatever that mission is. If I'm selling you ice cream, my mission is to put ice cream in your hands and take your money.

That is why I'm here and that's what I'm doing. Yes. If I'm at GameStop, my mission is to put a game in your hands and take your money. But I'm noticing that the mission is becoming more about, well, I have to do all this stuff.

I've got to acquire this information. I have to do this. It's difficult for people to think outside of the box and be like, you know what? We've got this thing we've got to do.

I just need to whatever in order to just make it happen. Ultimately, I'm just going to give this guy a game. But maybe that is the mission. Maybe the business model of GameStop has changed and where they actually make their money is selling that phone number.

And maybe they get penalized if phone numbers come up bogus. Maybe. I don't know. You know what I mean?

I don't know if that kid would know that. Yeah. But you're right. Mission clarity is what you need for a thing to work.

And drift is what happens when it's not working. So for example, you know, I had this idea one time that since we're so very, very, very different, we should have a podcast. And the mission would be that we talk about things that we care about as friends anyway, and share with other people. And if even a very small percentage of those people are edified, are edified at the point that they're like, I would want to kick in on that.

Or I could buy earbuds from someone else, but I'm going to get the ones that help make this thing go. And even if it's a very small percentage, well, that would work. And then somehow we could support our families by being friends and thinking about things with intentional scheduled time together. That's the strategy, right?

But to be clear, the mission of this podcast is what? To not have dumb questions. We're stopping those once and for all. People thought that was some like statement of affirmation about, hey, you can ask anything here.

It's not. It's a warning. Don't bring that crap in here. We don't do dumb questions around these parts.

Jack Waggens. No, I think honestly, the mission is to promote authentic deep friendships. I'm just making this up. We've never talked about this.

To promote authentic deep friendships also to demonstrate as we figure out how to give and take with people you disagree with. Yes. You and I disagree quite often. Yeah.

I feel like that showed up more early on. I think increasingly, as we've gone along, it's gone from, huh, we really are pretty different. We come at a lot of these things really differently to more gradually just now. I understand why you're coming out of the way you do, Destin.

Okay. Again, that's informed my thinking. I see my thinking informing your thinking on other points as well. And increasingly, I feel like our conversations are as much as anything about like, what does it look like when I know I can't wreck a friendship with one conversation?

I'm safe. I can't wreck you. I can't break you. I can't ruin your brain.

I can't destroy your life. Your stable and our friendship is stable. What does it look like when you have the luxury of a friendship like that? Just think candidly about the stuff that comes up in life and the things that are on your mind.

So increasingly, I feel like we got two separate processors that are gathering day to day in and day out all the time. And then from time to time, we come together and we let our processors work the same problem together. And I find it really satisfying to see what happens when I have an external processor that I think is dynamic and excellent to point at whatever problem or topic we're dealing with. So I think the mission of the show has not drifted, but I do think it's evolved.

I'm not afraid of offending you. How dare you? I'm not. I'm not.

I know that there are things that you and I way disagree on. Way way way disagree on some of those things we talk about on Mike, some of those things we don't. And you provide grace to me in the areas where you disagree with what I do and how I conduct my business. I provide grace to you in the areas because we know that ultimately we're pulling in the same direction.

We're unified in purpose. Trust your process and the goodwill of what you're trying to accomplish with your life, even when I disagree with the strategies you're employing. Don't disagree with them morally. I just, I mean, my biggest points of disagreement with you are strategic.

Yes. And all that to be said, let's come back to this quote because I think herein lies the issue. Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men and weak men create hard times. Change that to whatever gender you want that to be.

Talk about weak people. How do you want to say that? I think right now, as I read history, I don't read as much history as you, but I know that there's a cyclical nature to societies. I can see that, right?

The British Empire, right? I mean, they break the same way. They do. And so when the times get very, very good, people get weak and we start to manufacture things to disagree about and argue about and we lose the ability to have grace and interact with each other in a really good way.

We forget how to disagree and we're like, well, you know, maybe we should just quit being unified and maybe we should just fight. Yep. And so, and then it happens and then some, there's a rift that occurs and then there's this big rip in the fabric of unity and society. You think it'd be better if you weren't together anymore and then it turns out you were dead wrong?

Right. Exactly. So, Matt, in this cycle, hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, weak men create hard times. That one.

Where? So last one, weak men create hard times. Yes. That's where we are.

Yes. Yeah, unequivocally, don't care who I offend. Yes. Unequivocally.

History of thought, the evolution of society. Look, I don't very often do the appeal to expertise, but this is what I do for a living. That's where we are. So it's just, it's that simple.

I'm telling you with maximum conviction, 10 out of 10, that's where we are. This is what has happened to the great empires and the great civilizations. There's so many factors. It's very fashionable and tempting even for me to jump on a mic and be like, and the things that ruined it are all the things I don't like.

Some of the things I don't like are what ruined it. Some of the, is that thunder? That is thunder. Oh, I hope people can hear that.

That's awesome. Like that lends a lot of credence to whatever it is I'm saying right now. I do all that stuff. I just feel it.

I hear it in the store or something. A lot of theories about why Rome broke and maybe be fun to do a whole episode on. Ever given he was the big theorist in the 19th century speculated as why Rome broke and what people have done in 140 years of dialogue with Gibbons, but weakness certainly factors in. And what I mean by weakness is not, I mean a lack of fortitude, a lack of connectedness with the actual problems of humanity and what you're trying to fix and in outsourcing.

So much outsourcing that human helplessness takes over. Remember when it was cute like 25 years ago when somebody was like, hey, nobody knows how to take a mouse. And we were like, oh, that's wild. Huh.

No, that's actually a problem. When people see problems in chaos, they solve it. Somebody rises to the top. It's like everybody listen up rally to me kids stand here, women and older men stand right there.

If you can lift more than 70 pounds over your head, you got to come with me right now. We're doing this now. And everybody goes, nobody's worried about lawsuits. Nobody's worrying about whether this is best practice or how people will feel you solve that problem.

Eventually, in the interest of going into protection mode, institution mode, societies get to a place where that capacity for action, think about identifying problem, solve problem, that ceases to be the defining thought process of a generation of a people. And then what happens is not that you get pitiable weak people. I don't think that's what you're saying. What happens is you just have cultural paralysis.

And the only thing you can really muster is outrage at other people who you imagine are 100% responsible for why you feel the malaise of cultural paralysis, why everything feels like this impotent whining at everybody else and begging authority figures or experts to come and solve your problems. Even if you could solve the problems, you're red taped out of even doing it. You can't do that. People start punching people in a parking lot.

Nobody helps them anymore. Somebody shooting somebody. Everybody gets out their phone and not even calls for help. They just point the phone at the people who are shooting people.

That to me is where I see the weakness on display. See the problem. Not everybody does that. Not everybody.

I'm speaking in hyperbole. Yep. But in broad cultural strokes, we're seeing this everywhere. Why does a TikTok video exist of a guy on a crowded subway grabbing an Asian lady by the hair and putting her in a headlock and walking her around and ranting insanely while clearly on substances and everybody looks at their shoes except a couple of people who turn on their phones.

Did that happen? Yes. Yes. Why?

Just think about the reality that that video exists. It shouldn't exist because the 80 people in the subway car should have beaten the living daylights out of a man who is abusing a woman in front of their face. But because of who everybody was in the equation, because of where that situation happened on the map, because of Twitter and because of impotence and because of a general societal inability to say, there's a problem. I need to do something.

I am the solution. That video exists and it should never exist because nobody should have taken the time to even think to get out of camera. Somebody should have done something to protect that woman and they didn't and it's happening all over the place. And that to me is your canary in the coal mine.

Yeah. I think we're in phase four. This episode of Notum Questions is brought to you by Raycon. Raycon makes earbuds that we like a whole bunch of different kinds.

They even got some new ones. They got gamer earbuds. We were seeing. They got cool colors and all different shapes.

And we've been using these things forever. We love the Bluetooth functionality. We love the sound profile. We love the fact that they hold a charge until the end of time.

End of time. Yeah. You're fine. And they might even charge off of the heat death of the universe.

I don't know. They work really well. I'm not sure the heat death of the universe will destroy my Raycon. It's even tough.

If you'd like to support the sponsor which supports the podcast, this is how you can do that. Go to by Raycon.com slash in DQ. I'm going to do that now. I'm going to tell you what I see on the page.

So I go to by Raycon.com slash in DQ. That pulls up a page with a banner up at the top. It says say 15% with promo code today. Agma.

And I'm going to go up top to the little nav bar. There's all kinds of stuff you can and they have more than just earbuds now. You can get. They have new things.

Stop, Dustin. We're just supposed to get people to buy the earbuds. Okay. Well, I'm just going to click on earbuds.

There's other things there too. You can get lost to your mind if you want to look at it. So there's four types of earbuds you can choose from. The everyday earbuds, the fitness earbuds, the gaming earbuds or the work earbuds.

So yeah, you can check those out. The gaming earbuds are new. Go check those out. If you go to by Raycon.com slash N.DQ and use promo code NDQ and then you will also unlock an additional 15% off.

Thank you so much for supporting the sponsors. That supports the podcast and we are grateful. So how do we fast forward through the bad? How do we get to the strong place again?

Well, the answer is on the front end of your list of four things. What you're talking about right now is the Strauss How Generational Theory. The what? Strauss-How?

Oh, really? That's who I think made it popular. Strauss-H-W-E. Yeah, they wrote a book called Generations.

Oh, wow. I think it's two guys. I think I think I like it. There's a whole Wikipedia article on this.

It's one of the ways that people interpret the unfolding of history and it's become a rather popular one and not on one side of the aisle or another. People from all over the political spectrum agree that this has merit. Other people from all over the political spectrum think that it's oversimplified hogwash. For those who think it has merit, they would point to repetitions in all kinds of marginally to very free societies and say, look, this is what happens.

They would point to what was John Adams what he was saying about, like, my generation must become masters of war so that my son's generation can learn to farm and manufacture so that my grandson's generation can make art and music, something like that. Really? You got to earn those things societally. Maybe it was John Adams with somebody in that range.

Oh, Ron, it says, I'm just looking at the contents page on the Wikipedia page. It says, defining a generation says the cycle. Okay, they call it a cycle. Let's see.

The first turning, they call these turnings one, two, three, four, there's turning. The first one is the high. The book that's famous is called the fourth turning came out in the late 90s, like about same time as the Matrix. So it says the high, the awakening, the unraveling, and crisis.

Is this a book? I read, how do I? Yeah, you can grab the book. There's a book.

Okay, what'd you say? I read that Al Gore gave it to every member of Congress when he was vice president. Really? What's it called?

The fourth turning, I believe. Okay. The fourth turning, an American prophecy. What the cycles of history tell us about America's next rendezvous with destiny.

Holy cow, that's a title. Well, think about this. It came out about the same time as the Matrix and think about the premise of the Matrix that was laughable back then. I had to read Pills.

I was tweeting about this lately. The idea was that the machines set the Matrix in 1999 because it was the high point of human civilization. And we were all like, no, it wasn't. But then I'm kind of doing the math on the last 10, 20, yeah.

Like, yeah, if I could pick a time that I would freeze humanity until we figure out our crap, I would go right back to just before what we do for a living. I could go right back to just before we crammed everybody in the room in one giant party and thought there would be no consequences. But we still had just enough connectedness to travel, maybe get on the phone together. Maybe everybody can make art early 2000s.

To me, that seems like the Matrix was pretty close. That was about the golden age. There's an audio book option for this. Wow.

Wow. Man. Are you familiar with Audible? I've heard of it.

It's a question for the program. Oh, that's right. Yeah. That's it.

Okay. Do you know that if you text and EQ to 500, 500, you get a 30 day free trial. You can go in and you can access it to the whole lot of old plus. That's amazing.

I just know that. Yeah. Dude. Okay.

All right. So obviously I'm going to read this. All right. So my point is, well, heck, you know a lot more about this.

And I do. Have you read that book? No, I've not. Okay.

Nope. Just familiar with the argument. Okay. So this is what I want to do.

I want to figure out how to fast forward. Yes. Yes. Yes.

It'll work in the Old Testament where you can see the children of Israel. They. Yes. They.

The judges cycle. Yeah. You know, and then they kind of saddle up next to God and they start doing what's right. And then at some point, you know, people start doing what is right in their own eyes that statement in judges and in those days, Israel had no king and everyone did what was right in their own eyes that right there that alone.

You can see it. You can see what's happening right now is everyone is doing what is right in their own eyes, even the far right. That. And the claims to like God.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. There's enough problems to go around for everybody, everybody looks bad here. Yeah.

Yeah. I want to take control of everything. I want to think exactly what I think. I want to try my eyes to be the way that.

Yeah. And OK, two things. People you don't know how we as poor as us. How does society happen when that is how we understand right, wrong, how things ought to be, how to treat each other?

What makes morality in that situation? Because there's no agreement. Everybody's doing what's right in their own eyes. Ethical relativism.

That doesn't translate. That's your own opinion. Sure. But how do you make policy out of ethical relativism?

Of course. You create the illusion of consensus. So you get morality by consensus. 52% of people think this is right.

Therefore, it's right now. Or you exploit the mechanisms of power to make your thing win. And you do whatever it takes to make sure the thing that you are sure is right in your own eyes wins. And it doesn't matter who you run over.

It doesn't matter what happens to truth. I saw a clip the other day where there were protesters. And it doesn't matter what they were protesting. But they were in the street.

And they were all kneeling blocking four lanes of traffic. And they had their sign talking about the thing that they wanted you to. They didn't care about the people in cars. They cared about lawmakers or somebody like that.

Thinking exactly what they thought. And then that Italian guy grabbed one and threw him all the way over the side of the road. Did that happen? That's how I feel like that guy gets out.

And he grabs this 100 pound college kid and throws him in a sign. I didn't say that. That's a strong man. I didn't care.

He looked like one of those high waisted mustachioed circus guys with the circular dumbbells. He looked just like that guy. Sorry, go ahead. The one I saw a guy gets out of his car and he goes to the person that's sitting in the road blocking traffic and he says, sir, I'm on parole.

If I don't make it to work on time, they will send me to jail. I need you to move. I'm pleading with you to move from the road. Got it?

What you're talking about? Super important. That's great. But I need to be at work on time or they will come get me and take me to jail.

I'm trying to do the right thing. And they wouldn't move. And he gradually started accelerating and getting more and more heated. At one point he rips his shirt off.

He's trying to physically move people out of the way. The police showed up and arrested the man trying to move the people that were blocking the road. How do you think that makes me feel? About like it made me feel.

I'm being cool. Yeah, I know. Look at my body language. Yeah, he looks really cool.

Yeah, I'm being cool. Yeah, so I don't feel cool. The people that needed to be arrested are the ones blocking traffic. But the man that tried to solve the situation, he was the one that got hauled off the jail.

Granted, he lost his temper. But that tells me something's wrong. Something's wrong. We are.

Yeah, we're just wrong right now. Society has jacked up. What the fun thing about this story is I don't even have to tell you if the people that were protesting were on the left or the right because you don't know. And part of the problem is that it was only one of those two options.

Yeah, that's part of what's wrong. Yeah, here's the thing, dude. This fourth-generational turning thing, I kind of buy it. I'm not sure it's always so neat and tidy.

It looks really, really big. It looks much more complicated in the little quote that I started with. So I'm going to reserve judgment and say that because you and I have not read it, we cannot say that it is the same thing that we're talking about here, right? I feel like I'm pretty familiar with the theory.

But I have not read the book. I haven't heard the arguments. To me, I am pretty skeptical of any singular metanarrative that explains all sweeping human phenomenon. I just, I'm not that deterministic.

And that's one of the big critiques of the book is that it's overly deterministic, overly behaviorless. It's just simple. I think stuff's a little more complicated than that. I think this is a useful descriptor in broad general strokes for a phenomenon that can run itself two or three cycles, but maybe not forever.

That said, you remember when we were talking about Topan Maverick and we were talking about Star Wars? I think back to back conversations, I took the risk because it offends everyone. But pointing out what to me is a more accurate descriptor of what's been going on for the last 30, 40 years of our conversation in our country. And it's that we've been dominated by theocratic fundamentalism.

First a Christian version, then a far leftist version. And both of them are incredibly dangerous and reactions against each other that will just keep going back and forth. And each time the pendulum violently swings to the other one, the stakes get ratcheted up and we're more likely to have something really, really bad happen on the other side. From the mid-2000s to the late 20 teens, I was even willing to use the word libertarian to describe what I thought, not the political party, but kind of Western liberalism approach.

And part of the reason I was willing to use that term to describe myself during that time is not because it has somewhat charge. I'm a Republican who likes weed, not a Republican, and I don't like weed. So I hate that. But I felt like, man, right now here's a pathway forward.

You have to stop the pendulum somewhere. You have to slow down the violence of these swings. You've got to find a way to differentiate between what things should be dictated to others by whoever has the momentum right now. And what things just aren't touchable.

You get to talk. You get to make contracts with people, even if I don't like all your contracts, you get to. And we're going to honor your contracts. You've got to give everybody the blessings of life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, everybody.

You've got to invite everybody to the game. You can't good old boys club it and deal people out. There's a sane way forward for us to function together. And I had kind of hoped that maybe there would be some moment in between 2005 and I maybe started to lose faith in this in 2019, 2020, somewhere in there.

That maybe there would be a way for a movement to occur where we would just grab the pendulum and be like, no, I understand that 10% of us on the far left and right are super angry and worked up and everything's apocalyptic, but no, you two are the problem. You are the problem with your fundamentalism and your inability to tolerate anyone who doesn't think like you. We got to stop that pendulum right there. And we have to find some new mechanism for how we think and talk and function peaceably with each other.

We're not going back to this weird fundamentalism. We have to stop the cycle. And it didn't happen. The cycle accelerated.

So my point in that is to say, look, I'm not even sure I necessarily, I think I have a little different view of the unfolding of history right now than maybe the Strauss Howe thing. But also I could be wrong because I'm super sensitive to fundamentalism because I was raised around it and because I'm in a lifelong process of rejecting my own moral superiority and fundamentalism. And so maybe I'm just going to see those patterns more readily than I see the patterns that Strauss Howe theory would observe. One way or another, stuff happens for a reason.

Stuff doesn't happen in a vacuum. All the things that are happening are somehow a reaction and they're somehow connected and there are canaries in the coal mine. And one of those canaries is honestly the difference in the experience you get when you walk up and talk to someone who has a basic job at a basic place, maybe a first job, whereas 20 years ago, maybe they understood the point of the job and their first objective was do it and fulfill the purpose of the job. Whereas now, maybe even through prudent self preservation, that doesn't seem to be as readily apparent.

Even if I understand the calculation that that employee is running, there is a canary in the coal mine going on there. The fact that we cannot reopen the lobby of an RVs is a canary in the coal mine. Right, yeah, experience that today. Matt, today's sponsor, one of my favorites.

I'm excited to tell you about it. Well, I'm excited to hear. Audible, I actually knew that. Yeah.

So Audible is a place where you can go get audio books and make your brain better. And today I want to talk about the plus catalog. Okay. Open up your old Audible app there.

I got that open. So the way I get to the plus catalog in mine is I'm going to go to the search. Okay, search. And then I'm going to go to the plus catalog.

It says Audible plus there. I'm going to click on that. And I can, these titles are included with membership. And so I have all these different things that I can click on here and I can get these for free.

So I can listen to a hundred of these a month if I want to because of my Audible subscription. That would be very impressive. That would be very impressive. I wonder if truckers listen to like a whole lot.

I would, if I was a trucker, I would like devour audio books. There was a guy, a certain guy who a while back in my circles made some very public claims about like, I read easily a book a day. And everybody was like, but if he was using Audible, maybe he was powering audio books like that. I don't know.

I haven't done the math on it. I think it's possible. So if you were like listening at 5X, but the point is get your phone. If you would like to check out Audible, highly recommend it, go to audible.com slash in DQ or text in DQ to 500 500.

That gets you Audible free for 30 days. So again, that's audible.com slash in DQ or text in DQ to 500 500. All these books, man, you have access to all of them. And you can look, there's, dude, there's many, I almost read one of the titles I was looking at called Napoleon's Hemorrhoids.

It sounded like you actually did. Read it now that I think about it. Yeah, so I was like, oh, what is this? And so yeah, totally.

There's a book here called Napoleon's Hemorrhoids. So I mean, oh, I've always wondered. It says Napoleon's Hemorrhoids and other small events that change history. Okay, that's actually, look at this.

Because this is the plus catalog, boom, added to my library success. Thank you. Look right there in my library. What's the worst that can happen?

Napoleon's Hemorrhoids and other small events that, wow. You get four or five chapters in. You're like, all right, I think I understand what the hemorrhoids did. I think I'm good here.

Well, that's fine. It was right there in the plus catalog. Look at this. I'm scrolling through your enders game alive, the full cast audio play.

Oh, really? Like the cat? I think that's kind of a fun way to do it. That's in the plus catalog?

Oh, 1984. I like it. Nobody likes 1984. But they like it's important.

It's important. Yeah, it is. It's sure. Like home stuff.

The point is audible expands your life in ways you didn't even anticipate. I never thought when I woke up this morning, you know what I'm going to learn more about today. Napoleon's Hemorrhoids. Napoleon's Hemorrhoids.

Absolutely. But now my life is more enriched. So what's happening right now? What?

There's a whole bunch of people who whenever somebody says Hemorrhoids, they're like, oh, yeah. Who are now finally Googling what Hemorrhoids are. Oh, really? You know what's happening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 2 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on September 15, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.