Skip to content
144: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest episode artwork

Dec 8, 2020 1 hr 3 min

144: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

from Classical Stuff You Should Know Hosted by A.J. Hanenburg

Alright, don't get cross with me. I did a more modern book. It's interesting, though, and we talk a little about LSD, some about busses, and a bunch about gambling. See? It's fun.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

144: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

0:00 1:03:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a podcast about books and books and more books My name is Thomas Magby. I'm joined as always by mr. AJ Hannenberg that's me and mr.

Graham Donaldson. Hello. All right, and today we're gonna take a little you know jump off the track We're gonna go for something a little different than normal. We're gonna be talking about some of our favorite movies So I think we're starting off with a this surprised me as your first pick the 1975 classic one flew over the cuckoo's nest It's great.

It has Danny DeVito. Yeah, sure. I'm serious and what's his name? That was the first Joker?

He's got Jack Nicholson. Yeah, that's how you remember Jack Nicholson? How do you remember it was shining shining? That's what I would say to sorry about that.

I think I corrected So we're gonna have a one-hour podcast on a two-hour movie. So this seems about right. So take it away. I feel judged So you're also not actually talking about the movie.

I'm talking about the book This is about the movie, but I am doing one flu over the cuckoo's nest by Ken Kesey And I got kind of a little a little flack from my co-hosts here about it not being classical So here's my argument for its classicity. It might not be it's a little bit modern. It's a city award that feels made up classic fullness Thank you. That's much better.

So it's it's from the early 60s and You'll it'll become clear why it's important in the history of the United States And I'm not sure if it like we don't know if it's gonna last for the next two 300 years But as far as being a cultural touchpoint for the United States It is certainly that and so understanding how we got to where we are and what sorts of things influence that this is an important book in Development of this country. I mean the other part that's funny is that Graham was the one who raised that concern and I believe he had two episodes on Book from the 90s, so yeah, it's a guy talking about the Bible. Yeah, sure. We're just very loose with this definition of classical anyway Yeah, we're playing fast and I've always I've always felt this podcast was a little bit Wild West so We talk about our in almost no regard every time I don't know where super soggy Okay, so I'm gonna do this book and I'm gonna kind of develop it in in episodes And the first episode is going to be me reading one star reviews from Amazon about one floor of the coosness Wow, this is a new hobby that I like to do for both my students and my great books class for parents So like when you start reading the Iliad with your students you'll pull up one star Amazon reviews It is a fantastically fun.

It's a fantastic practice to do before you read any classic I can't I just can't comprehend leaving a one star review for Homer like I just yeah I can't I can't comprehend that you're welcome to look up Iliad reviews if you'd like in the meantime But here's it here's a couple of my favorites. I've seen better crap in my cat's litter box There's one that just said stupid There's one that says good book, but I guess it's not for me kept falling asleep multiple times Especially towards the end I prefer reading Brave New World which in no way is a book connected to this one or it would They're not even both dystopias is it a better book. No, okay? There you go I would actually I'm actually I might actually go out on a limb and say this one is a better book Okay, it's the pros is better written.

I think the writing is better than that of us. Okay, I'm not sure if it's a better conceived book But I like the writing better and let's see here's a few more I very very rarely ever rate something at one star So when I do it means something this was absolutely terrible Let's see people can read into the symbolism if they want but it seems merely a glorification of every type of ism racism Sexism etc as well as a quote bucking the system and quote is a justification for those things. I guess I guess is that I'm nervous Well get there the narrator is not very reliable So you don't often know if you're hearing the right story or if he's hallucinating Is not like a point of the book. No, not really.

It's actually very easy to figure out if he's hallucinating or not It's okay. It's pretty straightforward and one of my favorites I can't I really can't believe they make high school or students read this kind of crap. Okay, there's We don't make our high schoolers read great one floor over the coo's nest. It's not an art curriculum.

Correct. We do make them read brave new world Yes, yeah, okay I'm gonna I'm gonna skip ahead to talking about our writer So this is Ken Kesey and if you've ever read the electric related acid test or it's by Tom Wolf And it is about this particular point in history that Ken Kesey's involved in and Ken Kesey was born So there's a wacky drug go across America on a bus generation. Yeah, hey spoilers, man So he was born in 1935 and he lived in tell 2001 and he was born in Colorado to dairy farmers in 1946 at the age of 11 They moved to Springfield, Oregon in high school. He was a championship wrestler and in college as well He's still one of the most winning college wrestlers in Oregon And he was gonna be on the Olympic team except a serious shoulder injury sort of stopped his wrestling career He was an avid reader an avid film goer He took John Wayne and Edgar I's burrows and Zengrais as role models.

He toyed with magic ventriloquism hypnotism He's a weird guy, right? And in 1956 at 21 years old he eloped with his high school sweetheart sweetheart sweetheart sweetheart sweetheart Norma Fay Hacksby whom he had met in seventh grade and they stayed married as far as I know until his like his death Right they were lifelong partners although sometimes it was more of an open marriage than a close marriage We may get to that in the future and she was sort of his anger his oh his touch point Right he was he was as we'll as you'll see later sort of the harbinger of the drug fueled period of the 60s And so he had a lot of opportunity for Extra marital affairs which he engaged in a few but he would have totally lost himself to it without Fay as an anchor in touchpoint Right he was that influential to be a harbinger of all that in the 60s Oh, yes, and I will I will sort of elucidate where we're not quite there yet in college he originally had a football scholarship but eventually switched to wrestling and He got his bachelor's in speech communication, but he was eventually getting bored by playwriting and screenwriting So he started under a guy named James B. Hall who sort of cultivated his interest in modern literature and after a few tries as a struggling actor in LA He published a short story and successfully applied to the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship at Stanford And so he studied creative writing at Stanford and he his kind of his fellowship was kind of complicated He wasn't really allowed to work towards a Masters So he just sort of studied in the non-degree program at Stanford's creative writing center He lived in a place called Perry Lane Which is a at the time was a really famous sort of Bohemian enclave at Stanford It was it was all where the smart kids went all the writers and the promising philosophers and they all lived in this one spot and drank A lot it was near the golf course and they sort of a lot of major thinkers came out of that little area And that's where he lived and he he and his wife were sort of the farmers of the group Like you had the intelligentsia and the elite and he was the guy that had you know like a busted Washing machine sitting on his deck for two weeks, you know, he's he was a little bit messier That's kind of how he came across right he's sort of like a good hometown boy that he's not as like refined as these other people I mean he was born to dairy farmers right yeah, he's not quite as refined And he is actually not really a favorite with the people that are running his the Stanford creative writing program He frequently clashed with the center's director who thought him a highly talented illiterate and rejected his application for the Stegner Fellowship But permitted him to attend as a Woodrow Wilson fellow When that guy the head guy left He told everyone that he had gotten permission to audit a bunch of classes and just sort of lied and then I did a bunch of classes under this imaginary permission He had gotten from the director when the director was gone And he at the period time was writing a novel in progress that was awesome and it was great So during this time while he's studying creative writing He also and this is where his importance kind of begins he was part of the CIA finance study called M project MK ultra Have you guys heard of it? No, okay, Graham.

What do you know about MK ultra the LSD project? Oh, okay, so what would you know the goals were and what they were trying to do? They wanted to basically test the use of LSD on people I think as a weapon so either like as a weapon for against the Russians or as to see if it actually gave somebody some kind of like My insights are mine. Yeah, it's real.

Yeah, look up in K ultra. It's really great. It's my my controls I am so yeah, it was basically testing LSD to see if they could use it to for the military for the military Yeah, right, so they're giving all these people all these drugs So he is one of the test subjects in MK ultra So he was one of the first few people to really try out this whole LSD thing right they tried LSD's Let's see where's my little list here LSD silo sibin Mescaline cocaine a empty and DM T and during that time He was also working in the hospital where this thing was going on and interacting with a lot of people who were insane there and this little period of both experimentation and work would eventually lead to his novel one floor of the cuckoo's nest and So it's weird that we actually have records of his his sort of vocal experiments and what he was saying while they were experimenting on him And it was weird. Yeah, and if you are interested in any of that, there's actually a We call that documentary on Amazon about him and his bus trip that I will tell you about right now So the results of that study are public though.

That's I think it's already been declassified I mean, I guess because we know about it. Yeah parts of it already classified. I'm sure yeah Yeah, so he eventually Peri Lane was torn down and he moved to a different cabin and he decided to take sort of a sightseeing trip with his wife and it sort of Snowballed into this giant bus trip to the world's fair across the country And he got a whole bunch of people together and called them his Mary pranksters And they painted the name of the bus called further and then painted the bus like six times And so it had six different layers of paint on it and it was driven by Neil Cassidy. You guys were hurt him You ever run on the road by Jack Carowak?

He's a character I think they call him Dean Moriarty in the on the road novel But same guy, Neil Cassidy and he was sort of a weird character He talked a mile a minute and he was a bus driver and he mostly could drive the bus all the time and talk to my limit Cuz he was on speed right so they they get in this bus and they start to go on this bus trip And it is supposed to be as far as Kesey is concerned to sort of a trip into enlightenment by this time Kesey has written one Thor the coogus nest he wrote it shortly after his creative writing stuff and the experiments and so the way the reason He can do this is because he's got sort of a fancy writing career going on He has enough money to sort of fuel his experimentation And so he becomes the head guru of this magical bus trip that would later become the inspiration for the Beatles magical mystery to her You know the one where they do the bus yeah, that is what they were imitating was Ken Kesey Neil Cassidy and his band of Mary Pranksters as they traveled to the world's fair and experimented with LSD This is weird right? It sounds like he's starting a cult or something. He's kind of yeah Well, he wanted to push the boundaries of human perception right he had experienced with LSD He thought it was enlightening they tried to make contact with a few other people that were also experimenting with LSD Those never went very well and it for those of you who are like yes push the boundaries it sounds idyllic But there was a lot of weird relationships that happened and he was married to his wife But then he had had had you know with her approval had some extra marital affairs with a woman named Mountain Girl And then he had a kid by her that would later get raised by her and Jerry Garcia the head guy from what's the grateful dead who they were Closely involved with they would run things called acid tests where they brought everybody over would paint things and play music and Like he was just he was at the very forefront of the acid movement of the 60s They actually on this bus trip were the people who invented tie-dye They did it on accident when they're bus broke down they were playing with paints They did the guy shirt and hit the guy was really mad because it was a nice clean t-shirt He's like you guys just screwed up my t-shirt I'm totally hacked with you and but it was kind of terrible people got jealous of each other when you are so free in your love Sometimes that doesn't quite work out with everybody and so some people actually had psychotic breaks on the trip and would leave but Keezy didn't he corrected He didn't he's he sort of a positive time He's enjoying all this he was the group that ran everything Yeah Right he would set up the times when they would all get together and do drugs and he was the guy that was encouraging the filming of everything And would have these ideas for what they could film and after they were done The goal was to set up this film that they could show everybody and he tried to cut together 40 hours That they could make into a movie and he never really successfully did it Amazon has taken a lot of that footage and put it into their documentary about the subject but eventually he would Go home and he got arrested for possession of marijuana in 1965 and faked his suicide and fled to Mexico And then came back about eight months later was arrested by the FBI since to six months and then after he got out He was arrested again eventually after serving his time and sort of getting out of the scene You know at a certain point you get tired of it and people have been coming over his to his house so much Eventually, they just put a big sign on the lawn that just said no Just go away. We don't want any more people here doing drugs because it was snowballing into the movement of the 60s At that point he can't control it anymore.

He's kind of tired of the whole scene So he retreats to Oregon as he said he'd written the book as he published the book. Yeah, I mean He's a pretty famous writer at this point. He's published two two books I haven't read the second one and this one is famous and I think the movie has already come out by the time he is sort of Retreating if I'm right the one for the cookies. No, I forget when that came out.

That came out 75 yeah, so 10 or 15 years after he published the book and then he will continue to write short stories and teach classes on creative writing in 1984 his son Jed a wrestler suffered a head injury when his teams van crashed and they like didn't have seat belts It was a really poorly put together van and so he got mad and started bringing it up to like He donated his own money to buy the team of and then he started suing I think he sued the state because of the conditions of the van for his high school Which makes sense he was diagnosed with diabetes in 1992 and in 94 He toured with some of the members of the Mary pranksters to perform musical that he wrote He even got Alan Ginsburg to perform with them like all these guys You know Alan Ginsburg and Jack Kerouac actually met Jack Kerouac on a bus trip and they found him really boring Oh, and because at this point He was kind of burnt out and he had already been famous He didn't really care what they were doing and Ginsburg was actually on the bus for a little while and he got connected with it So it's all connected right and Ken Kesey is actually mentioned in Tom Wolf's book I can't remember if he's mentioned in on the road, but but they're all kind of together right and from him would come the LSD Movement of the 60s so he's a big important figure and the goo's nest comes right at the beginning of that Right does that come make sense? You know find this whole like movement like frustrating I don't know why would you say frustrating? It's just like maybe my all maybe my thoughts will coalesce as we go along You just generally grumpy well, it's just no no the Production of the line-izing of somebody who has producing art like you're thinking like Amazon put documentary together I'm just thinking they're documenting I'm just trying to think about how you would market that thing It's like oh, you know travel inside the mind of a man who like you know so influential in era But when you sort of think about what he's done and what he's produced and the ethos that he that what he's done is is Spousing it's like I don't want to line eyes. This is this is not virtue.

This isn't the way to live This isn't how you want your like By the way, it's sort of art not married to ethics in in Amazon's defense He's not lionized They do a pretty fair treatment of what the bus trip was like and interview a whole bunch of people that were on the bus trip and had Sometimes had a good time sometimes had a bad time with a documentary about it That's a lot. I mean like even though it shows positive negative. It's like the same things were like when you make a mobster movie It's like I want to show how mobsters are bad. It's like yeah Well, every kid in college has a scarface poster Anyway Staking us yeah, because but in in the book will it go into all this about LSD not at all yeah exactly because it's more about mental health Yes, so that's I'm wondering if the book will go in a different direction brand than your It will for certain but I like the documentary just as a again a culture touchpoint Right?

It's a moment in history that that caused a movement that I now understand better because I watched the film and I Think it the Tom Wolf Electric CoolAid acid test book sort of does the same thing where it sounds really romantic and then near the end The Grateful Dead is playing to an empty bar basically singing We failed over and over and over again because the movement that they had envisioned never coalesced and But LSD LSD pushing the you know the edges of perception kind of failed Yeah, but I do hear what you're saying of even by presenting that story some people will take that story the wrong way But just as some people take the and granted it's not the same thing but Paradise Lost the wrong way They think Satan is the hero rather than the villain Yeah, I guess it's just you know Tom Wolf with his fancy white suits is living up in New York and Grateful Dead are these cool heroes and I know there's this whole this whole idea The whole counterculture ethos of the 1960s and I'm sure this is reflected in the book It's like you have those that everyone thinks is crazy and then you have society Which is actually the wicked ones like it's the nurse ratchet who's evil and the crazy people who are the counterculture all Okay, so you're giving your Just like but again, I'll be curious if the book reaches different conclusions in the movies I just I honestly don't know at this point your point again I think this with Tom Wolf's vampire the vanities right that the portrayal of financial figures who should he villains become heroes It's just the same frustration I have with like the Holden Cawfield. Yeah, seeing him as like a guy. Yes. Yeah sure I can't I'm bored with that.

I know that I necessarily disagree All right, so let's go into the Cuckoo's nest for the moment I'm gonna read you the dedication because later I'm just gonna ask you guys what this means because I'm not sure I've totally figured out either But it's to Vic level who told me dragons did not exist then led me to their layers one flew east one flew west one flew over The Cuckoo's nest it's from a children's full crime. I don't really understand Graham is looking grumpy over there I just mean you don't think it means anything or you met Because it's it's giving the pretense of like being insightful when it's just like babble from someone on drugs You read this? I think I actually I think I had to read it in high school. Yes, okay.

Well just I think there's some good things to be had here in this book It was certainly the light to read and I'm just just ungrump for a little while and then you can re-rump at the end of the book I'm not worried about two episodes on existentialism and now this I don't you don't okay over there. Yeah, what's yeah, seriously I'm doing fine. Okay, good. Yeah, I'm good.

I'm having a great time Okay, so we at the beginning of the book I'm gonna kind of give you just a rundown of the plot and the characters and and then we can talk you know themes and development afterwards I'll try this quickly as possible. I'm on time over there. Oh great. Oh geez.

Okay So we first are in for introduce to Randall Patrick McMurphy at the beginning of the book when he comes into an Mental illness ward that is filled with two different groups of people the Acutes who have problems that can be solved and the chronics Who have problems that cannot be solved right? So there are two different groups the Acutes they have daily meetings to kind of hash through all their issues and try to help them Reenter society the chronic sort of lay on beds and are fed and they're the people that are way too far gone and will never be helped right? They're cooked and so he enters and it turns out he comes from a work farm and it's just because he has sort of a he says it because he likes to fight and spend time with ladies too much and And that's why he's there and it's also because he's a big gambler and he wants some new he wants some new people to fleece And basically it's better than the work farm where he was at for jail, right? So he opts to get off to get transferred and he's kind of fine with the transfer so long as it means four square Earthy square meals a day and new people to gamble with so here's a little description of our main character He talks a little the way Poppy used to and then the narrator here is a a Native American named Chief Brownin who is not deaf and dumb But everyone thinks he is he's been there for like ten years and he never speaks and he never acknowledges when people speak to him And he just pushes a broom around and he believes that in the walls there's all this machinery He is subject to this giant machine called the combine that runs the place and then the nurse in charge is sort of their their representative at the ward but their job is to listen on people and control things and use the machinery in the walls and sort of Remove the humanity from everyone and keep the machine running right?

Sort of synonymous with society is the book moves on in the book Do you know from the beginning that you can hear and that he can speak? Yeah pretty much okay? He gives that away pretty quick. Okay, so this is him talking about the entrance of Randall Patrick Murphy He talks a little way the way the way Poppy used to Val sorry voice loud and full of heck I'm gonna change some of the swears here But he doesn't look like Papa Poppy was a full-blooded Colombian Indian a chief and hard and shiny as a gun stock The guy is redheaded with long red sideburns and a tangle of curls out from under his cap Been needing cut a long time and he's broad as Poppy was tall brought across the jaw and shoulders and chest a broad white devilish grin And he's hardened a different kind of way from Poppy kind of the way a baseball is hard under the scuff leather a Seam runs across his nose in one cheekbone where somebody laid him a good one in a fight and the stitches are still in the seam He stands there waiting and nobody makes a move to say anything to him He commends us to laugh nobody can tell exactly why he laughs there's nothing funny going on But it's not the same way that the public relation person laughs It's free and loud and it comes out of his wide grinning mouth and spreads and rings bigger and bigger till he's laughing against the walls All over the ward not like that fat republic that fat public relation laughs.

This sounds real I realize all of a sudden It's the first laugh I've heard in years who comes in and his Randall Patrick Murphy whose initials are RPM right revolutions per minute is he is sort of the archetype of manhood right he's loud he's brash he loves to fight he loves like ladies He likes to gamble and smoke and make jokes and wrestle and he's he's kind of like I think he's he was almost writing himself into This book he's kind of like a keezy right he's a big guy kind of a wrestler I hate you're supposed to ungrump till the end of the book you can regrump then I'm writing my notes Okay, and then so after he enters and kind of meets everybody and says hey let's gamble Let's have some fun gambling. I'm here to take all of your guys's money They have a meeting where and at these meetings the goal is essentially to rehash over everyone's problems And nurse ratchet it's not spelled like a a wrench ratchet but ratchet with a D But I mean that you have RPM who gets right you know revved up and then nurse ratchet who's kind of like cranking out on everybody Right so they go to the meetings and she will focus in on someone's problems and talk about their problems and everyone else is supposed to voice their thoughts On this guy's problems and so it kind of becomes like a big dog pile So I have a problem Everyone else will pile on top and sort of insult them and ask them questions about it And it is emasculating and emasculating is sort of one of the central things that happens in the books everyone's dignity Like it's taking his biggest fear pulling it out of him and putting it on display for everyone and so after that experience nobody feels good Right, it's under the guise of it's supposed to be therapy But it's supposed to be therapy and actually help anyone and I can actually read you about why they do it So I've heard and this is again She's probably talking I've heard that that theory of the therapeutic community enough times to repeat it forwards and backwards How a guy has to learn to get along in a group before he'll be able to function in a normal society How the group can help the guy by showing him where he's out of place how society is what decides who's sane and who isn't so you Gotta measure up all that stuff every time we get a new patient on the ward the doctor goes into the theory of both feet It's pretty near the only time he takes things over and runs the meetings So there is a doctor but usually it's the nurse that runs it He tells how the goal of the therapeutic community is a democratic ward when completely by the patients and their votes working towards making worthwhile citizens to turn back outside Onto the street any little gripe any grievance anything you want changed He says should be brought up before the group and discussed instead of letting it fester inside you Also, you should feel it using your surroundings to the extent you can freely discuss emotional problems in front of patients and staff talk He says discuss confess and if you hear a friend say something during the course of your everyday conversation then listen in the logbook for the staff to see It's not as the movies call it squealing It's helping your fellow bring these old sins into the open where they can be washed by the site of all and participate in group discussion Help yourself and your friends probe into the secrets of the subconscious There should be no need for secrets among friends Right? So that is the theory that they're all running on but Randall or McMurphy sort of keys in he's like oh my gosh This is horrifying right there. They're stripping you guys of your dignity right?

So he has this thing and then he says look he starts to gamble with them and says that he doesn't like this nurse and The way that she treats everybody so he says I bet I can get under her skin in a couple weeks You'll see me her kind of like split at the seams and here's where we kind of meet the The characters so we have our main character Randall Patrick McMurphy Then we have a guy named Harding who is clearly an intelligent man I think he was a professor and he's emascally by his wife who's good looking and he feels kind of threatened by her and all the looks She draws some other men we have a guy named Billy Bibbit who is sort of controlled by his mother and we have a guy named Chezwick Who's a big talker but not big on action and there's a whole bunch of other patients But those are sort of the big ones chief Bromdon and these all I picked three guys Right each of those those all sound like kind of normal things is yeah I'm just observing that I don't know if that's a point that will be brought up or something Or if you have a thought on that it seems strange that they're put into a ward for something well that Billy is I think 31 years old and still acts like a child and stutters a lot right? It's it's sort of a escalation I think he is voluntarily on the ward and so is Harding But we don't know this at this point that they are there voluntarily and that they could leave any time they want right? They feel like and this is where Harding talks about it He says they feel like rabbits in the world right? This is where it is safe.

It is easy They are not threatened by everything that goes on outside They don't feel a part of society and so here they feel safe even if that safety is at the mercy of nurse Nurse Ratchet who like holds the place in an iron fist and loves things to operate to work on work on time Hence the name right well, she's a she ratchets things right like she keeps machine going yeah, exactly She is she is representative of the combi she keeps everything running exactly the funny thing is early in the book You don't really like you kind of sympathize with her I sort of understand where she's coming from with a group therapy I get why she'd want to have a schedule right people that are mentally ill have a lot of trouble adjusting to big changes Right? She wants to keep the place clean She wants everyone to take their medication for a good chunk of the first part of the book You're kind of split as to whether she's the bad guy or the good guy or if she's even really evil or if it's just a whole bunch of mentally ill Guys complaining that they have to do everything the way that she wants right exactly Okay, so we have after this sort of a hallucination by chief rumbed in about you know everything being machinery and while he has This hallucination one of the patients gets opened up and it's all just machinery and wires and it's basically saying how The combines sort of removes the humanity from people right would maybe the symbolism of this whole dream that he has and he wakes up From the string to find out that the guy he was listening about actually did die during the night um and then We we have a scene where are you guys still tracking with you guys? So and then we see have a scene where Murphy is gonna make his first bid at sort of getting at the nurse and messing with the nurse ratchet And he says we should open up the tub room so that we can gamble in there right? We can't he's trying to run Run games of blackjack and he can't hear himself think because she's got this music going on the ward and so he says Hey, can you turn that down and she says well, there's only you're only considering the Acutes There's also a whole bunch of people here who can't really hear very well and they need to hear the music And so I have it up really loud and he's like why can't run a game while we're all shouting at each other?

Why can't we open up this room to work on and so we kind of pushes her and pushes her and pushes her and it kind of Gets under her skin right that she there's this guy trying to get things done And he does it with the doctor and the doctor kind of says it's a good idea and everyone eventually like it happens And it's the first thing that she's not really in control of and he hasn't really messed her up yet But she's looking kind of grumpy. Yeah, and then I was gonna read a section But I think I'm thinking we're running short on time here 30 minutes. Okay. Yeah, we're unsure.

It's where they all have an Awfully game. It's really fun. It's that's the game they play is monopoly Why do they play all kinds of things and it's just a scene where it's kind of a scene simply there for the comedy and to show how fun like How crazy a game can be in this place? That's one thing that I can't convey to you as easily about this book is hilarious The pros is really funny the characters are really funny There are moments of sheer clarity that I like laughed out loud reading the book and then he Randall Patrick Murphy makes another bid to mess with the nurse when he basically votes to get the World series game on the television he thinks they show up But she says well, that's gonna mess up our schedule We can't really do it and so he's like why don't we put it to a vote?

This is supposed to be a democratic kind of therapeutic community, right? So put it to a vote and she he doesn't get everybody because she's counting the chronics the people who don't even know where they are Who are laying on beds who have no idea what's happening around them? They count as votes and so to get anything passed he has to get over half, right? Right, so they consider Chief Bromden to be one of the votes because he's deaf and dumb and just sort of stands there And so he keeps on trying to get someone from the chronics to raise their hand and finally Chief Bromden does raise his hand and she but she says the meeting was closed before it happens so she refuses to put out the television for them to watch the World Series and In protest he plunts himself down in front of the television and then starts narrating it sort of as if it's actually happening on the television Even though it's not right and then all of the people all the guys join him all their whole rest of the world all sort of sit down behind him And are watching the game that's not actually happening but they hear the description.

It's like it is happening Right, I can't remember he's actually describing I may be mixing in the movie there in any case They sit down and pretend to watch the World Series. It's not actually on television, right? I'm looking for the little section here if I can find it. There's an ugly game.

I was gonna read No, oh I've lost my little marker that was gonna show anyway at that point the nurse loses it She starts to scream at them to stop what they are doing because they're having so much fun They're making so much noise and we see her finally lose control of herself and the ward and one of the last comments is Watching her scream and watching us watch the television. You couldn't really tell who was crazy, right? Is this where you lose sympathy for her a little bit? Yeah, I mean, it's just the World Series It's not really and not even right.

It's just them pretending they're watching the World Series. Yeah, it's Not really a big deal And so she kind of loses it and they have a staffing to figure out what to do with this guy and she says we're gonna keep him on the Ward because she really actually holds all the cards He's committed she gets this to decide when he leaves and she knows that given enough time she'll win right? She doesn't have to beat him like the war is hers no matter how many battles he takes right to win this thing and Then the a couple days later they go to a pool as a group of men They have these recreational days and so he goes and he talks to one of the lifeguards who turns out is a Chronic on a sort of different ward He's a football player that got a head injury and he's been on the ward for eight years after being picked up for drunkenness orderly And he'll randomly like tackle nurses because he gets confused and thinks he's playing football And so the guy tells him like yeah, she decides when you leave there's no There's no end date here. You can't serve your time and go you have to be declared sane and then you get to leave the ward Yeah, and so after Murphy here's that realizes that he's not really serving out a jail sentence He's serving out a sanity sentence he kind of chills out and lets her begin to win and Chezwick remember that guy who's all talk and not a whole lot of follow through tries to in the next group meeting Challenge her that she's been taking all their cigarettes because McMurphy keeps on winning him and in games And she doesn't want him to win all the cigarettes on the ward and McMurphy doesn't back him up And so he feels like he stranded out there alone and he is not the kind of guy like McMurphy who can go up against the nurse He instantly folds and he's taken away by some of the aides in the book And then later they return to the pool and he commits suicide by hanging on to the great at the bottom of the pool He felt like McMurphy was his last hope and when Murphy folded he folded right and so This kind of jogs McMurphy back into play right especially because one of the days They one of the following days they go out for x-rays and he sort of sees what they do with the electroshock therapy Because it's in the same building and and he starts to be like how can you guys let them do this?

And they're like well It's just part of our therapy and that's when he finds out that many of them are there by choice There's only like one other committed guy there that has to stay and he's totally confused by this He thought they were all there because they were forced to be there And so he realizes what kind of power he has to bring them hope and save them from this amasculating environment that they're in And so he got he decides to go back up against the nurse even if it means Him staying there longer and what's the power he has resistance yeah the power of Standing up to authority you have not de-grilped. I'm just like oh man great Great story of like just like rip the system and to take it to the man and like screw society man. Let's get out of here Let's go like live free in our van There are bad authorities and their shredded is a bad authority right needs to be rebelled against Yes, so there is a failure so society has failed But the hero is not like a degenerate who then sort of says what we need to do is watch our sports and gamble Like that's not I mean if that's the hero well then that's that's a much more that's a bigger problem I got my thoughts like well get there you're supposed to de-grub until the end and you can grump all you want and I'll chat to you about your Grumps and I'm excited for it. I'm glad I'm glad there's some conversation coming up Okay, so she she decides to take back the tub room cuz she feels like she's winning over McMurphy Right and he in response walks up to her nice clean window at the nurse's station puts his hand through and grabs the cigarettes and breaks the window and says Oh, I plum forgot it was so clean I couldn't see it and starts to resist again He decides to start a basketball team and he's got him running up and down the halls dribbling basketballs And then he tries to set up a fishing trip because they're allowed to take these recreational holidays And he gets ten people and she makes every effort to stop from happening She doesn't succeed he ends up taking the doctor himself He convinces the doctor to go to chaperone because he likes fishing Right and then he convinces some ladies of ill repute to come with him one of them kind of bales But he does get one lady and eventually they do leave and go on this fishing trip and it's a hilarious bunch of scenes The doctor catches the biggest fish out of any of them It's it's a really funny scene especially because they kind of hijack the boat because nobody contacted the rental agency like they were supposed to And so he sort of just throws everybody on the boat and they go fishing and they bring it back and then he he has sort of a Knockdown fight with the guy after they bring the boat back and then us wages him with some beer and they have a good time And then he shows him the really big fish and everything's okay Right and then they go back to the the ward having done this and he knows at this point that It's it's not going well Right when he gets back he ends up in a fight with some of the aides and he gets sent up to disturbed Which is where they send you for shock treatments and lobotomy is not sort of thing and he gets shock treatments there And then comes back and everyone's afraid that he'll be cowed by the shock treatments But he's not he's like they just charged my spark plugs I'm ready to go and they gave me so much juice I run for days right but he knows that it's not going well and eventually He's he's never going to win over nurse ratchet to the to his sanity And so he plans for an escape and a going away party and they have a party He invites ladies over one of the ladies spend some time with Billy Bibbit who you know His rule by his mother and has the stutter and has sort of not been allowed to come into manhood battle fix them and then hey Hey Right doesn't right it doesn't get an open scene Yeah, and then they all kind of get a little to waste it and then next morning instead of escaping like he was supposed to he fell Sleep on a couch and then in the morning He's a little too tired to do it and I think he wants to stay around and make sure that goes okay Nurse ratchet finds out all this stuff and is furious and then goes and finds Billy with the with candy the girl of ill repute He can't and and threatens to tell his mother and sends Billy to the office of the doctor and Billy frantically cuts his own throat and commit suicide and in fury McMurphy strangles the nurse he decides that this is it has to end and then they take him they give him a lob I mean when he returns to the ward he is no longer himself all of them in the ward like yep That's not Murphy I don't know what they're trying to do passing off this mannequin is a murphy but that ain't him He must have escaped right they all kind of keep the narrative of McMurphy the Savior going through their minds and then most of them Opt to leave the ward right her her powers over them, especially because I guess McMurphy damage her vocal cords are done They no longer feel cowed by her and so most of them elect to leave and at the very end the narrator this chief Brandon fellow who McMurphy has been working on throughout the entire book to sort of bolster him back to feeling his size right because he's a huge person throws a big thing through a window and makes off for Canada and Decides that he's going to live an actual life rather than in sort of the fog he's been living in this whole time But McMurphy is left behind yeah Well actually he before he leaves he's mother's been working for a pillow because he can't see he can't stand to see McMurphy living The bottom eyes just laying on a bed that wouldn't want that wouldn't be how McMurphy wants to live And I'm glossing over a ton of extra content here just to give you just the general story of rebellion But that's kind of the deal so let's talk a couple of themes first McMurphy as Christ figure So he goes and you start to notice some funny things before they quickly before they give him the shock treatments He they put conductant on his on his head and they say he's like oh conductant alright What should do I also get a crown of thorns right there's a hint there that he's a Christ figure he receives three shock treatments Like you know being dead for three days and the fishing trip if you come up people on it if 12 people right so and they are fishing His death is what allows freedom for people and his death is what brings freedom to the ward Yeah, there's also the theme of essential human dignity right one of the things he is there to do is stop the focus on their problems And bring them some normalcy yes some of that normalcy was gambling as Donaldson has pointed out But so it's just watching the world series right that's a basic human thing And he just tries to return some normal human life to the ward basketball swimming fishing watching watching the world series and And kind of taking away this emasulation is the thing that allows them to sort of I don't take charge of their own lives We also have society as a presser and insanity being defined by the combine which is essentially society So one of the things that can tease you the author learned while he was on the ward with those guys is that a lot of them were pretty normal Except for a few quirks that society just didn't seem to want to deal with and he says so what's so wrong with these people that they have to be Locked up right yeah, they're a little weirder than everybody else, but they're not so weird And it's unfair that they should be you know shock treatment did and lobotomized and that sort of thing when really they're just on the edges of society And so I think he tried to show that in the ward with all of these people like bit It just had a stutter and Harding just didn't like his wife very much and wasn't escalated right They're all a little weird, but the guys who were really far gone which he did acknowledge were the chronitry They had to stay in the ward none of them got out They were the guys that were too far gone But there were some guys on the edges that just had some problems Granted one of the criticisms of this novel is that it's anti feminine and in most ways it does seem to be ratchets terrible bit is controlled by his mother Harding is a masculine advice wife and The only other girls are women of ill repute right there aren't any good females in this story Which is a little bit rough, but and and they live under a matriarchy right I think he made the feminine and Emasculation one of the themes and so there isn't any good representation of the female in this book at all right nothing's crazy ever Was that without her talked about I don't know I haven't looked so far into that whole theme But it's not just society that is removing their dignity It is it is women like even their sratchet rules over the doctor because she knows he might be addicted to opiates and can suggest it and then get In fired and so she runs everything on that word even though there is a doctor right and then the other the last thing I say before Donaldson can chime in here and tell me why everything's wrong tear apart.

It's great. I'm excited I'm not trying to put you down for it is like really right life should involve and for keezy This was especially true living on the fringes free sexual expression right and wildness Right? So there should be virility wildness and free sexual expression in life And that's that's definitely an element of the book right ken keezy is partially in the war because he likes to express himself sexually Right and so those things are themes I think partially brought by the author that we see play out through the 60s is this idea of freedom and virility and wildness Okay, I mean that is that is the whole thing yeah thoughts the thing that so the feelings that I have about this book and I see this book sit as an American version and there's a bunch of British versions of a same of a similar kind of book with similar kinds of characters I think brides head revisited is probably the British version I can think of and Also a lot of Hemingway works But so the play between Ratchet and McMurphy to me is like another version It's the same feeling I have with William Blake so the idea of God's stony law and then the rebellious Satan whose whole purpose in life is just to like Express himself and you so So it's not that I mean maybe keezy is I'm keezy maybe kezy wants to set McMurphy up as a Christ figure But he's clearly I see him as like a Blake Satan type character He exists to point out the fact that there is the the law is in charge and the law is there to not just to take away our freedom and turn us into conformity So I mean I understand so the problem I have is What the author sets up as society and then what the author sets up as the solution to the problem of society So he says what society is for is to like limit our freedoms and make us and make us sort of fit rigidly into the system and The noble and romantic thing that the hero should do is you know is kick against that system and try to Go and have his own his own pleasures in life because in the end we all die So let's take our fishing trip and let's have sex with our girls and let's do our drugs and do our gambling and watch our world Series and anybody who tells us otherwise is just a jerk face and we should sort of fight against that band all of our Mary friends together to you know To you know tell our mothers that they can you know leave us alone and so then the solution is kind of this radical individualized freedom which was Supercharged in the 1960s and very American and very American but that I mean but that radicalized individual freedom of the 60s play that program 60 years later and and that ethos isn't has not been a net positive for Society well you end up with the heroin and crack problems from the 90s Yes, exactly and with the heroin crack problems with the 90s you end up with marriages that don't last you end up with people who don't see themselves as having any sort of duty or responsibility to their fellow citizens But purely to like live out their own their own fantasies and they're a hero for doing so because it's society Who's the problem and by fighting against the nurse ratchets we can we can sort of you know Be a sort of play out our our heroism. So that's why when I when I read the story I feel like what we're so yeah in 50 years when we look back on this book will be like ah here's an here's someone who thought The solution was X But it turns out that that ended up being a more a much bigger problem for American society because we have everybody think that there are P.M.

Everybody think that they're McMurphy then you have sort of the the dissolution of But I think what you're saying is why I haven't had as much problem So he might only interaction with this is the movie not the book But I have fewer problems with the story because in the specifics of the story McMurphy should have stood up to bad authority. He was he was being brave and courageous while men around him were not cowardly And so he set an example of standing up to that authority Ultimately overcame that authority in a way that put his life at risk there type of bravery there and even this is where I don't know if I'm like I think kesie has done a bad job if he's setting up nurse ratchets all of society because all of society is not as micromanaging as nurse ratchets I mean the evil is the the combine which I think would be the the thing the machinery of society and not the individuals I think we also have an example of someone who is a piece of society that isn't evil in the doctor The doctor honestly wanted to help and he went on the fishing trip and he was happy to restore dignity to the people also I've never been in the game. Oh, yeah, he helped with the game So what he wanted was actual good for the the people and he was a part of society And then there's that element of society that that is painted as evil And I think I'm gonna have a problem with that and perhaps rightfully so that wants type-fisted control and to keep them subjected. Yes, yes So McMurphy stands in for a kind of person Either either society has gotten to a place where it produced McMurphy and has failed McMurphy and McMurphy is sort of in violence against society That's fair.

Just like I always think of um So there's an archetype of characters in 1930s British literature if you think of um like tom from the sonal surises Or Sebastian bryse had revisited these sort of characters who are rich they're aristocratic and they're or even um, um, what's the guy's name in uh dorian gray The lord oh lord Henry so this kind of character that is Um Sort of joyfully nihilistic in their worldview and they've got too much money and they've got no responsibility and um, they have witty clever phrases and Um and tom and lord Henry and Sebastian and bryse had revisited are all these characters who are sort of like the products of the end of an age Um, and then so the the English empire the British empire, you know produced all these virtues and then the British empire began to fall apart And then the men they produced in society where these kinds of foppish Um, uh dandy aristocrats who had more more money than sense and they tried to push the bounds of morality and build a little effect about you know Being hedonistic Murphy to me is the american this is the american version of that kind of of that kind of story So the society from what how the author sees it embodied in the machine is whatever has happened to the united states or whatever happened to america And the author's mind um and it's and it's produced it's not producing Quality of men of virtue it is now producing um these uh, frankly sort of selfish men like McMurphy doesn't Well, you're mad about the morphe. I was gonna comment on the other men who are in the Ward well that as well so the masonry man, but then also me murphy comes in and he Well one he came in not to save the man and not because he had some sort of noble ideals But he wanted to take money from them right? He only did that later when he realized when he gets there then he realizes oh, you know I'm supposed to help these people kind of but he's but he's only helping them to be like him which is Eat drink tomorrow. We die a kind of mentality of like let's watch a world series and go fishing and just like screw everybody man If we just get all these guys out of this war and put him in a bus and give him drugs like that's real living It's like no, it's not because in the end of that story like you haven't solved any problems You haven't improved their lives you've you know, it's I think that's there's no so he doesn't have a vision of the good life He doesn't have a vision of what it means to be a man.

He has a vision of like sort of um old Childhood I think that's a little bit unfair. I see where you're coming from but but there are some things about basic humidity He restores the option not even the compulsion to watch the world series if you want right to go fishing and enjoy the outdoors To play on a basketball team like to have your cigarettes when you want them right and granted like his vision of the good life Is a little further than everybody else goes But he is he is pulling them from tight control into a little bit of like basic human freedom And and I think I think you are right in saying that this vision doesn't end well And I think it didn't end well for kiwi himself as a writer either Remember the the grand ideals of the bus trip that ended in broken relationships sadness arrests and like it wasn't good and and and Amazon document points that out it didn't end well and he feels that it was a failure too But it doesn't necessarily fail all the men at the ward many of them leave and leave with dignity intact including the chief brahmedan who could not talk Could not acknowledge anyone believe the world around him to be run completely by machinery and at the end he is headed to live in the wilderness in Canada He is he is at least restored some of his dignity and the amasculation that was there sort of removed from him And the method granted probably not the best yeah No, I mean that kind of rebellion ended poorly for McMurphy as well like he ended with a lobotomy and then being smothered by pillow I didn't end well. It's the vision of so I mean it's it's McMurphy So does the McMurphy rightly finds the proceeds of problem the problem is is that nurse ratchet holds The rain is too hard and has too much control and is taking away the simple You know the pleasures of life and any little rebellion is parroting mad at a greater rebellion of her losing control Yes, huge problem that should not be how society is set up But his vision of the solution is not is this sort of subversion of of squeaking out your little pleasure as well You can like that's not the solution to that problem granted I don't think is that what the end of the book is saying so whoever yeah Well, what's the guy's running off to Canada to like The other examples the person who was nervous about the attractiveness of his wife he goes back to his wife correct So they're going back to face the problems that are in their life instead of hiding from them and not really fixing any Which is what they're doing they feel like they're trying to charge right instead of men Yes, they feel like yeah I mean they actually talk about themselves as rabbits and one of the guys to illustrate the point is like Jeff Show them how rabbit you are show them your nice fur and the guy immediately complies right they are subservient and so that little bit of And granted rebellion may not be the best way to to bring dignity back But in this case it was rebellion against an actually oppressive person right right and his method not great He could have gone about doing all of that by writing his senator and getting the problem looked into you And I think the other message here is not just like buck the system It's also the people on the fringes that we put away as embarrassments also deserve human dignity I think there's a definitely a piece of the message there, but Graham I agree with you He went about it wrong I got him in trouble and that ethos played out into the history of a nation is bad And I think we see that come to roost in the 90s Yeah, right though. Do you wonder is this a picture of what they thought they were doing in the 60s?

They were freeing people. Yes. Oh absolutely Yeah, but so then it's almost more interesting as a historical art. Yes in that regard to say this is what they thought they were doing What actually came from it you all are pointing to the 90s you could probably point any cultural moment that follows the 60s It doesn't create the utopia that is imagined correct.

Yeah, and I think that's important to remember is reading I'm not putting this forth as an example of good human conduct by any means I think it's like I said, I think it's interesting to the history of the United States as this is the vision of the 60s by the Man who essentially started and and to understand the ethos and where it's coming from and then to see how that works out Not only for Murphy, but for America in general is is interesting and then to bring into the notion of this wild man As as a Christ figure is it's just interesting right? It makes for interesting thought and discussion but there is something to be said about basic human dignity for mentally ill Remember this is during the period where lobotomy was practiced right if somebody is causing a problem You just ramble their brains and no more problems and I think he was right to protest against lobotomizing Sure, right? That's not the problem. We should not do that to people.

Yeah, I mean There are let's not pat ourselves in the back as modern people there are comparable problems and civil-bottomizing You know there are pharmaceutical pharmaceutical solutions that we give to restless people right but it's just yeah, so My distaste of it is that this is set up as he served this great romantic figure kicking against cruel society But it has created a society of everybody who thinks they're counter cultural as the culture and that has been a a Fraying or a corrosive headspace a corrosive sort of societal current and That no one wants to admit it or few people want to admit it people look back and 60s like Oh, you know those those idealistic 60s what happened to that? What happened to that as you continue living it out in the 70s 80s and 90s and yeah, I think that's that's true Maybe there's a rebellious streak in you though. I think I think very sorry. No, no, no, no It's not that you have a rebellious streak It's that I don't have a rebellious streak immediately which is what yeah, which is also like gets my fur up about I owned a bus to live in for a little while and I don't mind living a little bit on the fringes And I've always had sort of a healthy suspicion for some of the norms of society They don't see make sense like having to use a box spring for your mattress My mattress goes on the floor the floor is enough to support my matry rack fine.

This is my box ring And one of those things on yeah with the legs on it. You know, I'm pretty sure those are only to avoid bugs Lots of pillows on top. Yeah, I think I think there is something to be said for enjoying those those freedoms that are available to man But when those freedoms leak into sexual dissolution in and addiction to substances they are clearly misdirected Right if if God has come to bring us life and bring it to the fullest You can live freely and in virtue at the same time And I think you are recognizing that his version of freedom is devoid of virtue Yeah, and I guess those are inevitable so the little pleasures of life slowly leaking into vice is inevitable when society is hard-fisted and is totally about compliance like the relationship between What society ought to bring to the individual and how the individuals duty and responsibility to society is such a fragile thing Yeah, and this is kind of what I'm gonna be talking about in my podcast because we're gonna be analyzing a poem about this It's such a fragile thing that When it starts to go bad those things intention begin to sort of go bad against each other the the the controlling side of things becomes more controlling more Overbearing and the freedom side of things becomes more Lessentius and then you have And then you sort of have this like flywheel problem where it picks up steam picks up steam picks up steam It's a feedback loop, right? Where the rebellion will become more rebellious the type of system become more type of system And how will you ever get back to a sense of personal responsibility to the community and the community having trust for the individual freedom of the individual or for the freedom of the individual and that thing running on trust and I don't know but But a book that sets itself up not as I don't know if it sets that's the thing does it setting itself up as a solution?

I don't think so. I just but I imagine people reading this me like yes, that's what's wrong It's society man. I think to get us need to like throw off the shackles of society and run to Canada Just like the chief at the end of the book. I think that's it's fair It's fair to worry that that'll be the reaction especially because this is what kizie glorifies right?

I don't think this is the kind of book that you present to just like a mr. Mitha Sisyphus. I don't think this is a book that you present to me or we even play a conversation You you don't give this to people who aren't ready to read it with their head screwed on straight Right? This is one of those things that could have a pretty negative influence But it does have some things to say about essential human freedom and dignity that I think are important and but I I'm like I'm totally sympathetic with your arguments and I can see how played out over time this causes problems You keep this conversation going in the Anything else to say before I wrap up.

That's good. Well, thank you all for joining us If you want to listen to our in-between episodes you can find this on patreon patreon.com slash classical stuff You can also find bonus episodes which are posted weekly on Saturdays and then also we have we get a little more real a little more raw So I mean that there's bonus episodes or old conference talks mostly given I think They're also in between so you get two additional audio episodes every week if you are a patreon supporter It's great. You can find us on YouTube. Thank you to everyone who subscribed last week We now have enough subscribers to have a custom URL so we now have that so YouTube I think it's among that feels that way YouTube comms classical stuff You should know now goes to us instead of slash R3 four seven whatever so anyway We now have a custom URL for subscribing much appreciated Tilda you can you can I said my tell that I'm like that's my purgatory episode You can email us at the guys at classical stuff.net you can find us online at classical stuff.net there are so many ways to get in touch with us I think that is everything yeah, thanks gentlemen.

Well, that's great discussion. Thank you all for watching and we will see you next week. Bye

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Classical Stuff You Should Know?

This episode is 1 hour and 3 minutes long.

When was this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode published?

This episode was published on December 8, 2020.

Can I download this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.