Hello, and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a classical eight pod. It's quite a podcast about It's okay classical things old stuff old books old things and it's put on by three classical educators at Veritas Academy in Austin, Texas I am one of those my name is AJ Hamburg and I'm joined by Graham Donaldson. I am Tom and Thomas Maggie Hello, and we are talking about a Scottish play the name of which I can't say You know what I'd say the name of the play only in a theater.
I thought you were not in a theater right now, right? Oh really is that the rule correct my understanding of it. Oh, yeah, you should be safe to say it But what if you break your leg as soon as you say it? What if I say it in tinglatin?
Is that work Beth me? Yes When I was a kid my grandmother invented a language that we she taught to us kids and it was called avenglavish And essentially what you did was you just put the letters O V in front of most syllables or vowels in English So English is avenglavish And so as I would say havolavo, havolavo, avenglavo, avenglavo But you don't do that for all words you say it's only some words or some words and syllables I mean it's a notoriously difficult language And there's a new language complex. Yeah, but I just said hello. How are you my name is Graham.
Don't know the video? It's impressive that you anyway think you can speak that quickly Yeah, and then we then we'd create great hilarity when you try to put words like monopoly in avenglavish cause we like mama blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah but anyway yes that's a for you younglings at home you can have do your language there's no way to start understanding this language for today's episode yes it's a classical language okay and romantic language sounds okay it's very romantic done by the slobbs slob blah blah blah okay no today we are going I there's they've been reading so our seniors have been reading Shakespeare plays and me and Hanenburg and another English teacher Ms. Ball who friends the podcast will remember from way back when an earlier episode like episode 4 that she was on We co-teach the class all three of us and they've been reading all sorts of plays and the one that I have been with One of the groups that I'm in charge of is Macbeth and I've been rereading Macbeth And there was just a motif that stood out to me in the first act that I thought was very interesting and pertained not only to like government and authority but also just to the soul's health and And a notion of virtue like how virtue works itself out in not only in a body politic, but also in like a human person So I know that sounds a little convoluted, but so in the first act of Macbeth So we in earlier podcasts I've said that if you want to do these kinds of analytical interpretations of a play you can't just pick one example of something and then blow it out of Proportion so like the dude with the sword in Beowulf that it's like a technology. Oh, yeah So that's not fair But what is totally fair is to if you can find sort of a heap of arguments or if you can find a heap of images and they all sort of Work with each other then you can bring some sort of analytical framework to the story So the one that that exists in the first act of Macbeth And I'm now reading it very slowly to try to see if it continues its way on I know it continues its way on in terms of the plot Is this idea of that?
of like That a good king grow it brings health to the land almost like a good farmer So like the land is going to produce in a healthy way if you have a good leader in charge And then when you have a bad leader in charge you're gonna get the souls so you're gonna get the hell the desolation of the land Shakespeare didn't invent this this comes her goes way back Probably the most famous example of this in the Middle Ages is the myth of the Fisher King You guys know any of this myth of the Fisher King nothing so the Fisher King is a king who has been mortally wounded and he's slowly dying He other got stabbed in the gut or in the groin in some sort of battle and he can now no longer produce an heir And so he's dying and he's not gonna have an heir and because he is mortally wounded and cannot produce an heir his lands Have also no longer produced grain So like the crops aren't growing as a famine and so it's kind of like Symbolic of the kings infertility and so the king spends his days going down to the waters to fish to try to get enough food to feed his people And of course fishing is an incredibly fickle thing. You can't really plan your fishing and and you other like get a lot Or you don't it's a lot, you know, it's less reliable than crops So the Fisher King is kind of this the sad story and then it's part of the Arthur grail romance and eventually Whichever night finds the grail on his way back to bring into Arthur like takes a detour and goes and pours some of the grail Like what liquid from the grails on to the king for us And he was the Fisher King and all of a sudden the king who could no longer produce an heir and his lands were dying is now He'll because of the grail that represents Christ or Mary or whatever anyway So there's a passage in in What got me cued into this is a scene where when Duncan is going to give make a Beth all of the spoils of battle Yeah, okay a little bit. Okay, so I'm a Beth yeah, so a little overview of the play So this is a play where McBeth and Banquo are coming back from war and they are these nobles of these things and there was a rebellion The Norwegians were a valley and Norwegians were invading and then there was a stain of cottor who was Alight himself with the Norwegians and McBeth and Banquo come in and they absolutely throw down and win the war for King Duncan and they kill all the rebels and all this kind of stuff well McBeth and Banquo are coming home and three witches appear and Have beards they got beards so these these are elderly women he says yeah, you should be women But your beards forbid me to say that you are so like that you're like I think you're ladies, but pretty here actually I think that plays into this idea of of like nature and natural order of things that the witches are Very earthy and then but also sort of like go back and forth between what's natural and orderly, but that was also completely disorderly They're using natural things like frogs foot and toes and stuff for ways other than they are intended in order to do wicked things and Their forms are hard to tell and they're also like these creatures that like slip in and out of ephemerality like they disappear And that's not natural anyway, so these witches come and they say what's up. I'm a Beth you are going to be Thean of glamis and that's like R.
M. And it's like are you gonna be famous? Yeah news to nobody and he's like you're gonna be thean of cottor He's like, okay, you're gonna be king here after and we best immediately goes whoa. That's crazy does that mean I'm gonna kill the king Which is like I don't want to bet that's my best first thought but anyway, and then they say to bank well Hey bank well, you're gonna your kids are gonna be king one day, but you're not and bank was like Oh, okay cool, and then immediately the witches leave and then a dude rides up and it's like hey Macbeth Um, Duncan just made you think of caught condor.
I think you're saying condor three days of condor great movie But you just made you think of cottor and him and bank will look at each other and they're like whoa crazy Anyway, so this is the scene where Macbeth just pulls up to the king and the king is going to grant this Faindom upon the Beth. This isn't really podcast about the whole play of Macbeth And the rest of the play is Macbeth murders Duncan becomes king is and then is immediately beset by this by supernatural Not only guilt but then also madness his what happens to him is he no longer sleeps And what happens to his wife who's in on this thing is she goes crazy And they have other natural consequences They have no friends because they keep on murdering people and turns out they're real bad at governing They've got no friends. They can't have kids because it turns out that Lady Macbeth kind of like sells her soul At the beginning of act. I've seen three they don't need kiddos what a little bit.
Yeah, how do you kind of sell yourself? Well, it's just not like she's like, you know, I know she's evil he spirits to inhabit her and unsex her That's right. Turn everything that is nourishing about me to turn her milk into bitter skull I mean, that's not that's not you're not gonna be a good vessel for a child with that anyway, and so so the murder takes place and And then Macbeth becomes king and then eventually justice gets served because McDuff Who is a true loyal servant to Duncan sort of finds out about everything and then kills Macbeth And it's the coolest thing because Macbeth has gotten the thing that he can't be killed by man born of woman And then McDuff comes up and he's like, you can't kill me you're born of women He's like I was guess what I was C-section bro. Yeah, and then murders it.
Yeah, it's a technicality And there's also the way to say this in a very true like You know when the when the oracles kind of screw you up by telling you something true that you they play on your impressions of things And they also say like you're not you're gonna be king You'll stop becoming king when the wood when I think it's else and or whatever when the woods don't burn him wood burn him wood Isn't it doesn't mark your house? I think it would approaches your gates Well, it takes trees a long time to grow so that's not gonna happen for a long time And then one of his little dudes is like oh Beth you won't believe it But the woods are walking towards the castle and that's like oh crap well turns out it's an army carrying branches I'm going to this guy's number now fun fact JR our Tolkien that what he says that was one of his greatest disappointments in all of literature that the trees themselves did not March against evil Macbeth He wanted the trees to march against Macbeth out of rage for basically destroying God's holy order by killing Duncan And that's why he created the ants in in Lord of the Rings. So he could have trees that throw down And cool anyway, so that's sort of the overview of the plot about Macbeth But there's this there's this one interaction between Duncan Macbeth and Banquo when Duncan is giving Macbeth his Faindom and then it's And then this this idea is kind of picked up with Lady Macbeth in the next scene when she's asking the evil spirits to take away her nature Or her natural inclinations and then something that happens when Duncan is killed so here it is okay so when Macbeth is Well, no come back to that. All right, so here's that scene where Duncan is Giving Macbeth his his do he's given He's like all you know Macbeth says only I have left to say more than is I do than more than all can pay so he's like here is a thing of Condor our con cow door or whatever And Macbeth says the service and the loyalty I owe in doing it pays itself Your highness as part is to receive our duties and our duties are to your throne and state children and servants Which do but what do they should by doing everything safe towards your love and honor so Macbeth says to the king I've only essentially been doing my duty and it is natural king.
It is your part to receive our duties and it is our duty to Our duties to your throne and your say the state children servants So we this is what we're supposed to do Duncan says this welcome Heather I have begun to plant the and will labor to make the full of growing because what Duncan says to Macbeth But don't basically says I is the king and now basically like turning my attentions to you Macbeth I have planted you in the ground and I will make you full of growing and then he turns to Banquo the other guy He says noble Banquo that has no less deserved nor must be known no less to have done So let me and fold thee and hold thee to my heart He's like I'll Banquo I love you too buddy and Banquo says there if I grow the harvest is your own and then they continue on So you see the little metaphor that's already here right that the king is laboring to grow his subjects his his people and And and Banquo says oh, you know, and whatever good is done to me by your you know Your attention and your favorite king is a harvest that you have then the scene continues on and And then Macbeth leaves by say, but in his heart We all know he's playing I'm doing some murdering and then Duncan ends the scene by saying this when looking at Macbeth walking away He's like wow true worthy Banquo. He is full so valiant Macbeth and in his commendations I am fed it is a banquet to me Let's after him whose care is gone before to bid us welcome it is a peerless kinsman So so Duncan says that I've received my bounty like I am fed by Macbeth's Loyalties so eyes the king have been doing my gardening and my citizens my my my lieutenants have been growing up in virtue And then they prevent they present their fruits to me and I am fed by this This is this is kind of that metaphor And I would sort of posit that this is kind of the metaphor of the of that sort of medieval order of Kingdom Kinghood is that you have a good king and and when you have a good king you have fruit You have good subjects and you've got this sort of like reciprocal Relationship that goes back and forth that the king is fed and the kingdom is healthy Because like gardening takes a lot of time and attention This is something that I have learned this past summer by watching my garden slowly like like die But now you're at a point where it is feeding you in the same way, right? But it takes that time and effort, but then you get a reward from it. Yeah now this metaphor continues on and so now So we have this metaphor of of gardening that the king's job is he sort of is is raising up these plants and these crops to feed him And to feed his kingdom Banquo when he when the when the witches are coming in and they are talking to Macbeth about the future Both Macbeth and Banquo talk about how unnatural it is to be able to do this to talk about this that By doing what they're doing is they are they are the weird sisters and that doesn't just mean that they're like wacky The weird sisters of the witches is that they are doing things that are unnatural and being able to tell the future is one thing Banquo says just sort of in passing says this to the witches that sort of adds again into this theme In the name of truth are you fantastical or that indeed which outwardly you show my noble partner you agreed with present grace and great Prediction of noble having an of royal hope that he can that he seems wrapped with all to me you speak not So he says to the witches like hey you what you just said to me Beth like look at him He's like thinking about it over there You haven't said anything to me if you can look into the seeds of time and say which grain will grow and which will not speak Then to me who neither bag nor fear your fever your fears nor your hate your favors nor your hate So bank was got this little line saying like hey Which is if you seem to have this ability to tell me which seeds are gonna grow and which these aren't gonna grow well Then let me know what's my future What's what do I get and of course by doing this my fortune cookie exactly?
But the way that he describes it is telling which seeds are going to grow and by doing this by trying to sort of Jump the natural way of things so the natural way of things is you don't know what she's are going to grow Which she's are and so what you do is you plant a lot of them You plant lots of seeds and the ones that success you sort of Baby and you and you let those ones go and the rest of the seeds that aren't going to make it because it's true Every seed that gets planted isn't gonna grow into you know a tomato plant or whatever And so the natural order of things is to let it unfold as it should But we assume beings don't want to do that We all have this desire to be able to have assurance of the future especially when we're talking about power and money and status and this kind of stuff and so bank will end Macbeth when presented with the opportunity to Step outside the natural order of things know the future someone tells them hey I can predict the future and that sort of seduction Well, it ends up badly for them right by knowing the future this is this is a bad thing So one of those weird self-fulfilling prophecies would Macbeth have made any motion to become king if the sisters had this anything Exactly now Macbeth so quickly turns his attention work So wait as soon as the witches like whisper hey, you're gonna be king here after me best like is it true am I gonna murder Duncan? It's like whoa, it just didn't say nothing about murder He gonna like you know fell off the ox cart and turns out that you're in his will or something right? Yeah, I mean he's encouraged to it by his wife is he like he isn't fully like I'm gonna do this until she's like this is happening He's not fully I'm going to do this but he's definitely says it's pro it's murder Yeah, in fact, he thinks he decides it's gonna be murder before he goes to his wife because Duncan in the next scene before Macbeth Goes to talk to his wife Duncan's like hey guess what my son Malcolm is gonna be king. I'm the best like alright.
Well murder. It is. Oh, what is it? That's a step on which I must I must Follow her I must more steppers tumble off off or whatever.
Yeah. Yeah, Malcolm is okay so Macbeth and Banquo by hearing the witches and allowing them to talk to them our Allowing themselves to like get out of the natural order the natural way of things. Oh, we got copies of her So the witches are presenting this seductive thing by saying hey by telling you the future and they're doing it by all sorts of Unnatural means when I mean unnatural. I mean taking things and using them in the way that they're not like using them in the wrong way So it's famous the double-double-boiled trouble They're taking these natural elements like frogs foot like what is it tongue of frog and eye of newt and tongue of dog and all this kind of stuff All these things that we can sort of we consider grotesque and they're making something out of it to try to Basically get out of nature to supersede the natural order of things to see the future Before Banquo and Macbeth show up the witches are talking about like what they did that day and one which is like I was really hungry and I saw this woman She was eating nuts and I was like give me some nuts and one was like get out of here You gross hag and then I so I decided that I was gonna conjure up a wind to blow her husband's boat into the shore Like she's like I found out her husband is a is a sailor on the boat tiger same with a boat And so I need some help ladies to to destroy his boat and the laser like totally have my wind They're like awesome, right?
So they can use this sort of magic this This is where I struggle with with the interpretation are the witches using natural are they like? No, clearly they're outside the bounds of natural order. They are wicked. They are not they are not like using God's holy order The way it was intended.
Okay, so then so here they are and they are sort of on the outside of nature or at the margins of nature And they're giving Macbeth and Banquo the the option to know things unnaturally, okay? But that conversation between Duncan and Macbeth is kind of a defense or kind of a little picture of how things ought to work in power structures in society there are those in authority there are those under authority and Those in authority should be good and should work towards the goodness of their people and Gardeners gardeners and then the people who are the plants will produce fruit and life and health and That is not only gonna be good for the king, but it is also gonna be good for the kingdom But that that's the natural order of things That's how at least in the in the medieval Christian mind God set up the world to work So when we talk about the divine right of kings, which is that thing we all learn in ninth grade history Or at least that's why I learned it in ninth grade history is like this great terrible thing that the glorious French Revolution finally rid us of Sorry, my sarcasm runs deep on that. I hate the French revolution That's what we're talking about. That's what we mean when we say the divine right of kings It's not just that like all the men of society were like Hey, if we can convince all these morons to believe that our kids are the best thing ever then we can keep our power Like that's a cynical way to look at it the non-cetical way to look at it is there needs to be those in control or there needs to be some sort of authority structure and And so those in authority need to be good and work towards the health of their subjects and those who are subject need to work towards the health of the monarch and these Two things need to go back and forth and when these things break then you have a whole host of problems when the subjects are wicked But the monarch is good.
You're gonna have friction when the monarch is bad and the subjects are good You're gonna have friction and there's all sorts of shame and monarch is bad. The subjects are bad. You have creeped. Yeah, yeah, exactly So this is sorry, I just read the Bible verse where there's like it's an axiom that cretins are like all liars and thieves and Basically scumbags and he goes this is true.
So be on your guard Like if you're if you're if you live on Crete and you're a Christian like how do you preach that verse you like I mean I mean the only reason to work. We still call people cretins. I know it's terrible poor cretins Unless they earned it. Yeah, maybe they earned it like a pretty even god was like yeah These guys are kind of a mess if you live on the island of Crete and listen to our podcast give us defense of why your island is Perfectly fine.
We were the second-range podcast in Macedonia. Oh, yeah, I think in the art section though for what it's worth But art section of Macedonia we can see a lot of listeners out there Oh wrong role. Yeah, where was that? Oh, yeah, so this is a plate where you have a bad king and good subjects Eventually like McDuff is a good as a good subject.
You've got bank goes a good guy You have good subjects and a bad king and the subjects eventually killed a king and it's not Duncan McBeth And that's not a bad thing the play starts off with a rebellion and Duncan's saying like how it's a good thing that we killed the rebels because if we didn't They would have brought what does he say? I can't find it but basically they're saying that he was like an illness a sickness in the kingdom and by killing him and cutting him out We're gonna stay healthy. We can sort of take these cancerous cells out kind of thing And then McBeth is still one of these these cancerous cells in the body politic For fun a play where you have a Yeah, another play where you've got like a wicked king and a wicked king and I don't know if he's a wicked king But you have subjects that decide who's gonna take out the king. It's probably not all that fair on the king is Richard the second maybe not rich the second kind of had it coming But that's another another one of Shakespeare's plays that sort of deals with this theme when is it acceptable to take down an authority placed over you by God?
Anyway, but in the case of Richard the second does that go better? Does that go better than McBeth? Yeah, and that one it's more of a like everyone respects the he's placing authority over us by God But he's like really pushing it with his pettiness and on this one Duncan did not deserve to die And and Macbeth totally deserves to die and he's not and Macbeth wasn't like placing authority by God Macbeth jump the line Macbeth use unnatural means to get there. Okay, just to continue on this theme of nature Let's see is the speech that Lady Macbeth gives on the next scene So she gets a letter from her husband saying that this has happened and she's like oh Macbeth's never gonna kill Duncan He's too much of a wussy which is hilarious because the whole couple of acts just talk about how valiant Macbeth is and there's like some really bloody Descriptions about how Macbeth like cuts a dude in half from navel to chops And so Macbeth is not a wussy, but Lady Macbeth says he doesn't have it in him to murder She then very much sounding like one of the witches Gives this speech about how if they're going to do this thing and if they're going to take the throne They are going to have to put away their own bodily nature Macbeth basically says I need my body to not work in the way that it's intended so that I can ignore all of those things that are gonna Cause me to stop killing somebody cuz murder is unnatural cuz murder is I'm natural to get and your body was also like Your very human nature was set up in a way to not want to do it.
So Lady Macbeth calls on the darkness to Unmake her unnatural so that she can go about doing these things. I'm gonna read that section The Raven himself is hoarse that croaks of fatal entrance of Duncan under my battlements come you spirits that tend on mortal thoughts Unsex me here and film me from the crown to the toe top full of direst cruelty make thick my blood Stop up the access and passage to remorse that no Compunctions visitings of nature shake my fell purpose nor keep peace between the effect in it Come to my woman's breasts and take my milk for gall you murdering ministers wherever in your sightless substance you wait on Nature's mischief Sorry whenever in your sightless substance you wait on nazors mischief come thick night and Paul the in the done most smoke of hell That my keen knife should see not the wound it makes nor heaven peep through the blanket of the dark to cry hold hold Probably one of Shakespeare's most chilling as passions passage. It's one of the best beaches in Shakespeare It's just it's so terrifying and what she is asking for she's basically like asking Like the devil to give her to take her way her humanity and give her this unnatural power of lacking remorse and giving her cruelty Yeah, you ghosts come and make me all freaky and terrible. It's so chilling She says she wants no light Thick night and Paul in the done to smoke of hell so no one can see my knife move so hell smoke it up So I can't see the wound I haven't can't see me making it earlier Macbeth says that he said he says stars hide your fires so that there's no bit of light that can see to my blackest Desires, which is yes where Mumford and sons get to get that line for which is maybe rethink that song I was like trying to think the lyrics of that song because it's basically best saying like hey everyone turn out the light So I can so I can murder this guy and then also not see it because that would you know rough me up if I actually saw it I'm a Macbeth He's almost he's kind of like I don't want to look at this thing that I have to do and he's At this point he's not going nearly as far as his wife life is like it's game time Let's get cruel with it and she has to kind of like convince him into his ambition She does convince me to his ambition.
Yeah, and but for her she asks the demon She asked the darkness to take away her femininity that all of the the aspects of the the feminine that she has she wants to sort of sacrifice for the power of Taking the throne of being able to do this vile murder her unsex me here take take the milk that I have and bring it into bidders goal later on we find out that making me back to not have children and So it's almost like a natural consequence to it right that the demons are like yeah sure I'll insects you and now you can't bear Child because she find that out after that scene. Yeah. Yeah. She finds it out way after the murder room Lady me Beth ends up losing her mind and she always she thinks her hands are always bloodied And so she's constantly washing her hands like the dream scene.
Mm-hmm. She's she's like up She's up sleep walking and she keeps rubbing her hand saying out out damn spot thinking that there's blood all over her hands Which is a line of Shakespeare. I always remember because it was the thing my dad said every time he let the dog outside out Damn spot. I was a dog.
He was a spot But but he would say it and I was like my dad swearing and then I read Macbeth I was like oh, he's just being funny. So weirdly enough that scene the the lady Macbeth Crazy walking crazy scene. So I directed a version of Macbeth if you remember it was terrible. I was ghost I was which no I was ghost I was ghost of a dead king.
Yeah, you're ghost of the dead king half of the way I conceived It was terrible. No one could see what's happening over here anything. It was really goofy I said in Arizona there were there were it was looking see but but one of my students Just I'm on a side of modern day. They were killing the governor Okay, it's okay, and it was easier because we could dress in Western clothes Cuz we don't have a whole lot of like medieval dress sure and so but the performance given there I have only ever seen one other professional Shakespearean Macbeth that comes or Lady Macbeth that comes even close to how she delivered it It is still one of the best versions I've ever seen because I think she had some stage fright And so there was that vulnerability mixed in with all the rest and she just absolutely nailed it And so if you're listening I still remember that as one of the best deliveries ever That's a great great.
Yeah, something great. It was like there was that weird vulnerability and switched It was like it was like watching a woman fall to pieces in front of you. It was awesome. Um, anyway, so then I forgot where we were where we didn't spot them so maybe Beth ends up losing her mind And so she gets well She basically gets what she asks for she asks to be on natural and then as the play goes on she ends up being unnatural She loses her rational faculties her her mind and body no longer work the way that nature intended She can't sleep she is is crazy A fix she sees things that aren't there and she can no longer have children Macbeth himself also loses sleep He can no longer he can no longer sleep and he is beset and by ghosts they haunt him But when Duncan gets murdered there's a scene.
I was just flipping through and I couldn't find it fast enough I can't really know where it is If you just give me one let me get scene two Maybe or there's there's a Apologies I can't find it anyway, there's so when when when Mac Duff gets murdered on the next morning There are like serving people talking about that what happened that night and when and it was a crazy night There was a wild storm that came out of nowhere like a clear sky and then all of a sudden lightning and hail and storm And the animals went nuts and the image that I was remember from reading this in high school was like horses The horses ate each other. There was one horse that ate another horse in the stall And so you had this sort of unnatural Occurrences that happened that that by when Duncan gets murdered nature itself begins to experience some Nature begins to experience the unnatural That when a great evil is is done against the the order of the universe that somebody who was in charge And who was responsible for the health of many and was ordained by God is killed Nature almost has like a violent reaction to that thing that the way that things normally work don't work anymore storms out of nowhere horses eating each other Wasn't cannibal horse a cannibal corpse parody cover band. I don't you know what's kind of a horse So then So I'm trying to think of like how do we bring this whole thing together that when you That I'm just thinking about your podcast last week Annenberg that doing a great evil or when you do an evil thing you you are doing something unnatural like you are you are stepping outside of The way that things are supposed to be and in order to do an evil you have to You sort of have to twist twist health does this make sense Do you know where it is? It's a 73 if you want to do that cool Yeah, I do want to do that bottom of the page and then we three Yeah, just one flipping to find it back to you seen for and then while getting there even when it's Duncan who's murdered Really Duncan his silver skin laced with his golden blood and his gas stabs look like a breach in nature for ruins wasteful entrance That's it.
That's an earlier scene, but even just add your theme of nature being destroyed good. Yes, here it is Does unnatural yeah, so the old man and Ross is another tick are talking about what's happened. Well, maybe old man Sure, you know the only I'll be Ross three score in ten I can remember well within the volume of which time I've seen hours dreadful and things strange But this sort of night have trifled for knowing ah good father I'll see us the heavens as troubled with man's act threatening his bloody stage by the clock Tis day and yet dark night strangles the traveling lamp Is it night's predominance or the day shame that darkness does the face of earth in tomb when living light should kiss it? Tis unnatural even like the deed that's done on Tuesday last a falcon towering in her pride of place was by a mousing Owl-hocked at and killed and Duncan's horse a thing most strange and certain Beautyous and swift the minions of their race Turned wild in nature broke their stalls flung out contending against obedience as they would make war with mankind to set They eat each other they did so to the amazement of mine eyes that looked upon it And then McDuff comes in and they continue on to talk about those about about these things so when the king is killed nature has sort of like a like an illness a flare-up of Discord disharmony go thinking back to your podcast and I'm just trying to think like okay This doesn't happen anymore like this isn't a thing that we experience in the world or it does and we just don't have eyes to see it Right like when there's comments in the skies I mean bad things are happening or these kinds of things when a when a virus ravages the land We don't have sort of horses eating each other with that kind of thing But what is like Shakespeare's point or what is the this?
If that's sort of the motif for the metaphor that that that nature turns into discord at the killing of a king To me that sort of makes poetic sense, but I can't quite put into words why I feel like that's like it's an appropriate thing Yes, it makes like it makes symbolic sense to me that the horses would eat each other after Duncan's murder But I can't quite figure out why I think there's several things going on So one thing that we haven't sort of talked about in containment attitude toward the divine right of kings We I think we've talked about other podcasts, but it was that the job of king was not one that you want it Yeah, there's the sort of damocles It's a famous tale that says being a king is like having a sword tied by a hair above your head never know when you're gonna get killed Solen the legendary king of I think Athens was press ganged into being king he's even wanted he wanted to be a farmer And so it was kind of an old adage that if you are wise you'll refuse the kingship It's a recipe for heartache difficulty assassination Discord you can never trust your friends again like no one wants to be king and so if you have a good king like Duncan And then you murder him that is that is absolutely against the natural order Macbeth clearly was not suited to being king right he had to be Convinced by his wife and by other people around him to do the thing that need to be done unlike Duncan who when we first meet him Is beheading a someone who is bringing unrest to his kingdom when he does the thing that needs to be done? He rewards those under him. He is kind he even promises to see them grow more and so after getting his promise of consistent goodness He would make Beth repays him with murder and even the very act itself of murder is inhuman right to kill another person Is not something like we're not gonna eat him. We're not like animals that do kill each other for food And so this is outside of the natural order This this murder is one of ambition and even strange ambition he was promised greatness in more than one way and took it off his own accord by unnatural means and so the world is Upset the natural order king and subject is undone and then the natural order of man is also undone and it's reflected in nature Is that a fair I think so I mean a couple of interesting things for me is in this medieval mind and I mean I know Shakespeare's Renaissance, but he really is still holding to this view that in the media in this This medieval mind is that There was that nature also reflected the way government was supposed to be set up and In so far as the government was functioning properly nature was also functioning properly and when government was not functioning properly nature was not Functioning properly we serve as modern people don't really have this view at all We don't really connect these things at all if government is entirely a construct of man or even the opposite Like so there's probably even some on the on the fringes of some more like anarcho environmentalism that say nature will only be running properly When there is no more government or when when there when maybe even a few beings aren't even here so But in the medieval world There was a structure to nature there was a That nature was part of the realm of man and in so far as man ordered his civic society The way it was supposed to with a good king serving his subjects and the subjects submitting and loving the king That's kind of the way it was supposed to go then nature would follow suit Even the concept of horse like the reason why the horse was so romanticized in that I mean it was because Horses would only allow What would only submit to man because they knew that man was going to bring about a good thing right so like the king upon a horse is this vision of Man and nature working together in this sort of majestic Relationship that the nature was going to support man as long as man was going to go off and do I'm noble noble things and then a horse would unsaddle or would His rider if you know he was doing bad stuff so But we don't have that today we have a sort of the divorce of that when we don't have comments in the sky every time there's a presidential election All that we did this year Yeah in July during the like the high election cycle There was a big comment that was in the night sky for a number of days in July And we also just finished a meteor shower that lasted like a week I know if we were more superstitious folks, we would say that you know in you know Suspicious times were upon us, but hey, whatever and we have planets aligning if yeah, well, this is the thing So it's like okay What if nature silk is continuing to operate in this way is just we don't we just don't believe it anymore We're just like, oh, no It's just Jupiter and Saturn getting really close to each other so parking back my last podcast reading August team Yeah, he was he was they were all into astrology back then and yeah Is astrology a real deal and so he's like, okay, how do we disprove it?
Well say you got twins and they're born pretty much one right after the other and one twin is really successful and the other twin is really Unsuccessful they had the same stars you guys. Oh, that was a really important minute. Yeah, like where where the planet became unaligned or whatever He's like that twins right there disprove that nonsense and the other sort of interesting thing that this brings up maybe is going back to another podcast that you talked about in terms of When we were talking about psychology and the soul's health and right thinking about things. I can't remember which episode that was So then here's Lady Macbeth who has said I want to divorce myself from my body in order that I can get power Yeah, and it she gets it and she gets it and she is miserable and Macbeth has a lesser version of it He goes along with Lady Macbeth, but he too he pulls trigger or holds a knife and he no longer sleeps And so he is now living an unnatural existence And so I don't know there is something to think about like Are there examples of things that happen nowadays where people are willing to give up their very bodies in order to gain power And then getting it and it not going the way that they they thought so maybe not they're very bodies, but like the natural order of things Anyway, I can't think of anything that wouldn't get the podcast in the trouble But I don't know about natural order, but like what you're describing is like you go and get your JD and then you work a hundred hours a week to make a bunch of money Yeah, I mean I guess it's fair.
Yeah, I'm a pursuit of wealth that puts human thriving as a lower good than wealth you generate That is that close to what you're getting out sure? Yeah, no that is Yeah, I mean Beth and Lady Macbeth can definitely be seen as like the ultimate power couple like they are kind of what was that really bad Tell the show cards cards. Yes. It was the first couple of reasons were excellent Yeah, the first reason was not bad.
I stopped watching it got weird. It did get way worse Anyway, but that kind of idea yes that in order to gain the ultimate power going and doing unnatural things So my sort of thesis of this podcast is that that interpretation of Macbeth is also buoyed up by the language that Shakespeare uses even little things by bank will saying like hey, you can see which seeds are gonna grow and Macbeth later on says my heart is knocking well. He says like my heart is knocking against my ribs in a way that is unnatural he says I am think of cottor if good Why do I yield to that suggestion whose hoard image doth unfix my hair and makes my seated heart knock it to my ribs against the use of nature? So is all these little phrases that are dropped in the sort of the body light of language that Shakespeare uses that lead us to say okay This is what's at play This is sort of an interpretive tool that we can use Shakespeare's giving us in the words that he chooses in his diction He's giving us a lens to interpret the story And at least for this my interpretation of this is that to do a great evil you have to step outside of the natural order of things And the character of the witches I find so fascinating as these these agents that seem to allow people to do this Like why are they doing this?
What are the witches motivation? Are there's jerks? It's Lady Macbeth like one of them. I don't know I just I find that concept of the witch to be a really fascinating one Are they are they evil?
I mean they they bring about evil ends, but they're almost like catalysts to human evil like Macbeth They're totally evil that when asked that lady for not some lady's like I'll give you nuts and she's like I'll kill your husband Yeah, they overreact just a little and then the other ones like what do you have? I got a thumb from a guy who crashed like yeah, I wouldn't say they're exactly wholesome No, they're not wholesome, but it's like um, but if they're evil they don't exist isn't that how do they get that way? There's something good to corrupt. Oh wow really nice beards Wonderful.
So a place or function anything Graham is when remember when we were last we we had a podcast before this one that was Short-lived and only populated to like I think how many people listen to it like three. Yeah, it was my mom your mom Yeah, it was a long time ago. Maybe you'll post it on sound clap. I listen to yeah It was it was five episodes one act for each one episode for each act I don't believe you all posted all the episodes it was not great sure But one of the things we noticed was a repetition of like birds showing up here and it's like the birds are a thing I just looked and the birds are mentioned It's when Duncan is arriving at the castle and his presence nature is reacting positively like birds are betting down They're having a good time.
They are singing his entrance So when he enters nature is reacting in a good way I've always wondered about that because you guys kind of convinced me there's something going on there But I think it the picture only becomes complete when you realize that it's it's set in juxtaposition with the abuses of nature that happened later Mm-hmm. Yes, cool My point is me. I mean, I don't really have much more to add to it Just that Shakespeare's cool Shakespeare's cool. No, your point is about nature that this establishment of authority in particular, right?
Mm-hmm. There are more consequences to throwing that order aside than just you get a different king something that is not at peace in the world itself at that point Yes And how what if this is? How do we how do we how do we as people who live in a republican form of government and in a constitutional That's Canada that we live in a republican form government United States where we have representative government like do we have us? Do we have metaphors that have to do with this?
We don't have kings But I don't know. I'm just like does that metaphor kind of die with the era of the kings this idea of that there's a natural order to the universe Or is I was gonna say or is nature waiting for a king to return? I was like, oh wait. Yes, actually Is that is that It's almost like the Middle Ages was a and having the government set up in a monarchy was kind of like a passage or kind of like a Prefiguration.
Yeah, a prefiguration of how God's holy order is established Um, that's what they thought. Mm-hmm. Yeah, anyway, I can be accused as a monarchist in the comments or whatever it's and right It would be right and also an aristocrat dirty dirty aristocrat. Yeah, all right So this has been classical stuff.
You should know you can find us on the twists You can email us at classical stuff the guys at classical stuff that net you can find a website classical stuff This is just got stuff that it's okay And then you can find us on patreon and you can support us there if you want We have all kinds of goodies for you if you do including banter before the episodes and an AMA every month and some other fun things that you can Have including my episodes from quarantine those are now for our patreon subscribers So yeah, you can find us all there. We're glad you're listening and that's it from us happy holidays and stuff. Ciao. Ciao.
Ciao. Bye