Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. How's it going, Uri? Pretty good. How are you? I'm good. I'm still processing. We've gotten a lot of feedback from the last episode, especially the man-stater segment. And there's been a lot to think about. This weekend, I had a bunch of discussions with people over the weekend and even earlier also at my perm suda. Yeah. I also, this past week especially, have been talking to a lot of people about some of our segments. And it's a lot of fun. It also stresses me out a little bit because it makes me realize that people are actually listening to what we say. And I don't even know if I agree with everything that I said. And they're like, you know, now this is what you said. You must have. But I think just to start these conversations is really...
at least my goal, I think our goal of this whole thing. So it's exciting. Yeah, exactly. One of the first things when we first, you know, characterized what we wanted to do is we wanted to create sort of like more interesting, more thoughtful, you know, Shabbat meal conversations. And to that, I really feel like we're accomplishing our mission. So I'm excited about that. Or even if it's not more interesting, just kind of taking some of the most interesting ones that are already happening and just turning them into a easily packaged thing that we can share with other people. Exactly, exactly. So I hope that's encouragement for all of you, right? If you think, oh, why should I email them? They're not really thinking about it. They're not engaging with it. Yes, we are. Please continue to send us your thoughts. Okay, so on that note, Rifki, what did you want to talk about this week? Okay, last week, the UGA, which is the Jewish Federation in New York, and an organization
Hitoveri co-hosted a panel at the Jewish Center, which is an Orthodox synagogue on the Upper West Side, about social justice and modern orthodoxy. It was a fairly big event, actually, for a random weeknight. I think the organizer said they got around 150 or 175 people at the event, which is pretty impressive. The panel was hosted by Alex Rothkahn, who works for the UJA, and the three panelists were Rabbi Saul Berman, Dr. Lana Steinhain, and Rabbi Eli Weinstock. Rabbi Berman, I've heard him speak a few times. He's a pretty interesting guy. He's a longtime advocate for civil rights, and he actually spoke a little bit about his history. He was arrested in Selma in the 60s, and has definitely spent...
time with the civil rights leaders of that era. Dr. Stein is a Torah educator who also lives on the Upper West Side. She used to be a member of the clergy team in Lincoln Square Synagogue, and she's currently an educator through the Hartman Institute. And Rabbi Ellie Weinstock, the third panelist, he's a rabbi on the East Side. He's a member of the clergy team at KJ, and he's a faculty member at Ramaz. So, Ari, before watching the video for this panel, I mean, I was a little bit skeptical. It feels like sometimes social justice is this buzzword, and we just kind of want to get it into things like, oh, is modern orthodoxy into social justice? Yes, of course, but I don't know. Is that really true? Like, it feels like, you know, you and I...
You know, we both grew up Orthodox. We know what the community focuses on. It doesn't feel like social justice is sort of like baked into the essence of what Orthodoxy really is. But, you know, try to have an open mind, you know, watching this panel. And I actually thought it was more interesting and kind of gave me more food for thought than I thought it was going to. I don't know. What do you think, Yuri?
I found the panel very interesting. It wasn't a debate by any stretch, which is fine, because I don't think anybody is going to argue social justice is a bad thing. But I think all three of the panelists kind of came at it from their own angle and their own kind of agenda, which I found interesting. And I think the whole question to me is pretty interesting and complicated, because again, if social justice is just making the world a better place, how could anybody be against that? The first question was, how do you define social justice? And let's let the panelists describe it for themselves. So Dr. Steinheim actually broke down her understanding of social justice into really four quadrants. She opened with sort of the idea of awareness, being aware of what other groups...
especially minority groups, are experiencing, how people are being left out of systems, how systems are really oppressing and hurting specific people, and just being aware of that and caring about that from sort of a knowledge and emotional perspective. Her second quadrant of social justice was do no harm, recognizing how I, myself, may be contributing to the problem and how I might be obligated to therefore fix that problem. Her third quadrant was taking action in specific moments of urgency. So, you know, Uri, I have a job, I have a family, I have a lot of priorities, and it's not, you know, my responsibility to be involved in major systemic change for every single thing in the world, but in moments of specific emergency, I am called to social action. And the fourth quadrant was kind of the more generic one, which is about ongoing social action. And it's specifically, she mentioned, outside the Jewish community as well. She wasn't saying non-the Jewish community, but she was saying it's the Jewish community, but also really outside the Jewish community. And let's play a short clip just to get a sense of what Dr. Steinheim was saying. So I would say kind of the lowest bar is simply awareness. Awareness of what other groups are experiencing, what minorities are experiencing, how people are being left out of systems, and how systems are mistreating people. Rabbi Weinstock went next, and Rabbi Weinstock agreed with Dr. Steinheim, but to him, social justice comes from the language of versita.
do what is straight and good. In terms of when being asked that question of what is social justice, for me, it turns into a search through religious categories as to what it is that motivates me to try and do the right thing. And when I'm asked that question, what stands out for me is the verse, that I think that in many ways, social justice isn't necessarily a specific category within. Judaism, but it's what Judaism asks of us in a larger context. Rabbi Berman actually had a slightly different understanding of social justice. Instead of answering sort of the straight question of how do you define social justice, he specifically talked about how do you interpret the values behind the laws of the Torah that seem to imply some sort of social justice aspect. When the Jewish people conquered the land of Israel and Joshua divided up the land, it's not only every tribe that received a portion of the land, but that every family received a portion of the land. That initial assurance that every family within Am Yisrael would receive a relative
So before we move on, I want to just stop and talk about their definitions. What do you think? Do you agree with any of them? Do you think they were disagreeing with each other? What do you think about the way they were talking about the language of social justice?
I don't disagree with anything that any of them said. I don't think any of the panelists disagree with what the other ones said. So I think each of the three panelists came at this from a different perspective. Rabbi Weinstock is sort of the most simplistic. He's saying social justice means doing the right thing. And as a Jew, we're commanded to do the right thing. End of story. And if doing the right thing means helping another Jew...
you do that. If doing the right thing means helping a non-Jew who needs help, you do that. Then moving on, let's say to Rabbi Berman, he also is painting this through a Jewish lens, but he's getting more specific. He's not just saying do the right thing. He's saying specifically based on sources from the Torah, this is an economic issue. And so the Torah is basically, his interpretation of what the Torah is saying is like people were allotted relatively equal plots of land and given equal opportunity. And we should learn from that, that people should have equal opportunity and things have to be done externally to make sure that people have equal economic opportunity.
Then Dr. Stein Hain, in my opinion, gets even more specific, where she's talking about systems and minorities and outside groups. And again, not that there's anything wrong with that, but I think it's just interesting and telling that when asked to define this term of social justice, that's where she jumps to and that's where her head is. And I think that is going to get into some of the conflict that this panel was trying to address of the conflict of the Orthodox community with this idea of social justice. So do you think that when Dr. Stein Hain talks about social justice and doesn't...
and didn't explicitly use a Jewish frame, do you think she was saying that it's not an explicit part of orthodoxy? What do you think that means? I think she, of the three panelists, from what I can tell, is more plugged in to the current moment. And so when she's defining social justice, she's defining it as the social justice movement as it now manifests, let's say, in this country, while the other two panelists were either in Robert Berman's case, he's seeing it from social justice, what that meant 50 years ago, because that was sort of like his. I don't want to say his prime, but that's when he was most active, let's say, in these type of protests and movements. And Rabbi Weinstock, to me, seems a little bit less plugged in. And so he's giving it, as a rabbi and as a Jew, do the right thing. But Dr. Steinhain seems to be coming at it much more from the actual social justice movement as it appears today. Right. So what do you think, Ari? I mean, forget about what the panelists are saying for a second. It sounds like, you know, you think there's value in what each of them is saying. But would you use one of their three definitions of what social justice is to you? What do you think? Well, it's semantics, because it's not like the Torah says, do social justice. And now we have to understand what social justice is in order to know what to do. If anything, we're commanded to be good people and to help others.
It's interesting that to talk about social justice specifically, I think what the panel and what I hope we really are talking about here is mostly along the lines of Dr. Stein Haynes' answer, which is there is this movement happening now. It's called social justice. And here are some of the things that it involves. It seems to be that the Orthodox or the modern Orthodox community is not so involved with that. It's not so plugged into that. Why is that? And is it a bad thing that things are that way? So that's actually a really good transition, I think, into the second question that I thought was really critical that the panelists covered during this conversation. Let's play the clip.
You've all offered a number of sources that, to my ears, point to a clear imperative that social justice is an essential part of being a Jew. And in fact, Rabbi Berman has now explained to us that all 613 of our mitzvot roll up to this topic. And I really appreciated Dr. Steinhane's historical lens. I think that's very true. Because we were people who have been persecuted, the mandate to respond is critical.
So that leaves me and perhaps all of you a bit baffled. With all of this, why is this not the discourse? Why are we not waking up every day and after Moda'ani thinking about this imperative in our lives? So, Uri, before we dive into the answers that the panelists have, I want to just ask you, what do you think as you're listening to this? Do you agree with the moderator that social justice is meant to be sort of a critical part of modern orthodoxy that is kind of sometimes put on the back burner in the way we think about it? Do you disagree with her? What do you think? And if you do agree, sort of, why do you think it is? What do you think are the reasons for why this is happening? What were you thinking as you were watching it? Well, again, I think...
It comes down to defining terms. What are we saying? Are we saying, how come Orthodox Jews aren't doing enough to help other people? Or how come Orthodox Jews aren't doing enough to help people outside of the Jewish community? Because for the first part, I think we could always be doing more to help the world and help people, but I think we are doing a lot to help other Jews. I guess what she's asking is, why aren't we doing more to help other groups? And then that comes down to a question of how much of our time and resources should be used for helping the in-group, other Jews, versus the out-group.
non-Jews. Yeah, I definitely took it in the same direction. It seemed to me like she was very much referring to people outside the Jewish community. And I think based on the answers of the panelists, it seems to be that they also thought that. That the fundamental question is, why doesn't the modern Orthodox community, though they kind of pay lip service to the idea, do more to help the world and the society outside the Jewish community? In response to the moderator's question about why the discourse in the modern Orthodox community isn't as social justice heavy as we might have thought, and let's just play a few clips that show some of the reasons that they gave. I think that reformed Jews have taken the mantle of tikkun olam, and I think that there is a discomfort with using that language and being in that discourse in the Orthodox community.
community as a result. We live in a transitional time, in the sense that in the era immediately following the Holocaust, for Jews, not only those who survived, but those who were not even directly affected by the Holocaust, but knowing of the destruction that Am Yisrael had experienced, knowing the destruction of six million Jews, of almost all of the institutions of Torah study, of the entire infrastructure of Jewish education and Jewish culture, knowing all that had been destroyed. The Jewish community, I think, fundamentally responded, in every wing in its own way, responded by saying, now is the time that we need to rebuild what we lost, because we can't afford to be spending our time on ancillary matters. We need to rebuild what we lost. Let me raise one other thing that I think is a barrier. I've spent over these past four years, spent some time each year visiting campuses in various parts of the United States, and the significant barrier that Jewish students confront in those campuses is the issue of intersectionality. That is...
The social activist communities have been persuaded that all organs of oppression in the world are interconnected and that therefore anyone who opposes any evil or any oppression needs to be able to sort of sign on to all forms of oppression. Our cousins and their supporters, the Palestinians and their supporters, have been using this particular contention of intersectionality as a way of gaining an enormous amount of credence. within every other social movement, within every other social justice movement in the United States. And what they do, as they did, for example, in Black Lives Matter, is that they are fundamentally irrelevant to Black Lives Matter, but they joined in. They became one of the 70 different groups that are associated with Black Lives Matter. And when Black Lives Matter decided that they needed to have a general...
sort of statement of their purpose. One particular Jewish woman, as a matter of fact, who was deeply supportive of the Palestinian movement and is deeply anti-Zionist, said, okay, listen, I'll write the part of the platform that has to do with another piece of this oppressive world system, which is Zionism. And since there was nobody, at least at that time, and still isn't as far as I know, nobody in Black Lives Matter who was deeply committed Zionist... supporter, you know, she was able to get away with that. And therefore, a piece of their, you know, whatever it was, 300-page platform had a very deeply anti-Zionist statement in it. And what that did is, those Jews who were Zionists, who are Zionists, said, oh, you want me to now support this organization which is anti-Zionist? I can't support something which is anti-Zionist. Now, the reality is that, at least I believe, that that's not a wise response for us to make in these situations. I think that in these situations, we need to be able to put ourselves into these...
organizations into these settings and use the force of our presence as a way of combating that anti-Zionist position. So there are other answers, Uri, that I think are really valuable and interesting. We don't have unlimited time, but guys, I would really urge you to listen to it and look for specific answers because I think a lot of them are really worth thinking about. How legitimate do you think those reasons are? So I think they're completely legitimate. I mean, there's two things, right? There's A, are these true? Is that really why orthodoxy does not engage in social justice? And there's B,
Are these good reasons? Are these reasons that kind of should stop us from engaging in social justice, right? So the example that I think is most interesting here is Rabbi Berman's example, that the reason we don't want to engage in certain issues is because of this... discomfort with intersectionality and with this idea of feeling like, are we really included? Do we really have a place there? Rabbi Berman is making a very strong statement that the only way we're going to get to change the conversation is by being in the room. I think that's a very, very, very compelling argument. I think that's incredibly important. I think he's making a really valuable statement about what it is to religiously engage in social justice. So to me, that felt very strong. My take on that perspective is, on the one hand, in theory, I agree. And I don't have a problem with that idea. I'm not coming and saying that I can only work together with somebody on a common cause if I agree with everything that they said. Obviously, that's absurd.
But I think it's a little bit naive and it's also a little bit unfair to hold ourselves to that standard because I don't think any other group would hold themselves to that kind of standard. I don't think any black individual or black group would unite with a white group or a Jewish group if part of that other group's platform... was racist. Doesn't Linda Starsour, I mean, not to be, I'm not quoting her as if she's, you know, my postache, but doesn't Linda Starsour sort of explicitly say there are plenty of people, I think in response to this particular thing, she says there are plenty of people who are involved, who are involved in the women's march, who are involved in feminist movements, who are involved in social justice movements, who I don't agree with. Yeah, if I recall correctly, yeah, her example of someone she doesn't agree with are people who call for abolishing the prison system. And she's like, that's not me, I'm not there yet, but I still work together with those people. Okay, so what? I don't think those are analogous, which actually brings me to another thought that I had when I was watching the panel, which is that, first of all, I'd rather not prove anything based on Linda Starsour, but aside from that,
Engage with the disagreement. I think that it's part of what makes this whole topic complicated and part of what makes me uncomfortable with intersectionality and I think a lot of other people also is that... it's not just about doing the right thing and helping people. There's a lot of politics involved. There's a lot of identity politics involved. And there are a lot of double standards. I think a lot of the movement and the people mean very well and do really good things, but there are double standards. So there are basically like these written or unwritten rules of who's on the ins and who's on the outs. And there are people on the ins because they check off X number of categories on the intersectional checklist. Even if on a purely logical level, there are some blatant contradictions in what these people stand for. So for example,
Just this week, Louis Farrakhan, an African-American activist and the leader of the religious group Nation of Islam, gave a speech at an annual conference of his, where, among other things, he said things like the following quote, where he refers to himself in the third person, and Farrakhan, by God's grace, has pulled the cover off of that satanic Jew, and I'm here to say your time is up, your world is through. This is just one of the many blatantly anti-semitic remarks that he said in this speech and almost every speech that he gives. And it's not just anti-semitism. He's actually extremely homophobic as well. And he manages to tie those two together. In 2007, he declared that it's the wicked Jews, the false Jews, that are promoting lesbianism, homosexuality. And now he's updated that to include a remark about transgenderism. Quote, the Jews were responsible for all of this filth and degenerate behavior that Hollywood is putting out, turning men into women and women into men. Okay, so I don't want to go on and on about Farrakhan. It's really a treasure trove of anti-semitism and all kinds of bigotry. But the reason why I brought him up was because one of the...
organizers of the Women's March, Tamika Mallory, was at the conference this week. And not only was she there, she tweeted about it and she was proud of it. And she would not condemn Farrakhan when asked about his anti-Semitism afterwards. And this is along the same lines as Linda Sarsour, who would not condemn Farrakhan and who was also an organizer of the Women's March. My point is...
This is part of the hypocrisy, and this is part of the reason why a lot of Jews, like myself, feel very uncomfortable with a lot of these movements. They stand in theory for one thing, which is equality for all and helping all groups. But in reality, there is actually a lot of bigotry there, and they are very selective on which kinds of bigotry and which kinds of people they will call out and which ones they will not call out. Okay, so it sounds like you're really disagreeing with Rabbi Berman. Rabbi Berman is saying people like her, who is willing to partner with Louis Farrakhan, should not be off limits. And you're saying, you know what? He is so vile. He is so disgusting. He is so explicitly against us and against so many minority groups. I can't even look at him. I cannot be part of someone who would accept him. Is that what you're saying?
I think as important as a lot of these causes are, such as women's rights and minority rights and black rights, realistically, those causes are so important that we have to figure out a way to promote them and push for them regardless. But I would, yes, I would not go as far as Robbie Berman is going, which is to say to join up with these actual... groups that have these anti-Semitic and anti-Israel elements to them, such as Black Lives Matter, I would say no, an Orthodox Jew should not be marching in a march or going to a meeting of Black Lives Matter because of anti-Semitism and the anti-Israel, but we have to find other ways of promoting those same shared goals. Right. Well, I don't want to put words in Rabbi Berman's mouth. The way that I would sort of respond to that, which I think is what...
Rabbi Berman is suggesting is that if you're in the room, if you're in the conversation, if you're part of the team, then things like that don't happen. I think it's easy to say that. I actually don't think somebody who's known as a proud Zionist or even wearing a kippah, I don't know, would be allowed into some of these rooms without protesting. What's your evidence for that? As we saw at that dyke march where, you know, these...
lesbians who were carrying a flag that had a Jewish star on it were kicked out of the protest. It wasn't about Israel. They were just promoting their LGBT rights and they were kicked out because their thing had a Jewish star on it. So I think that's just an example. I mean, that is a pretty extreme thing. And a lot of people who were involved in organizing that movement and that march in particular came out very strongly against them. So that was really bad. And they called how problematic that was. And especially, I mean, there were a lot of Orthodox Jews. I had a lot of friends who were involved in attending the Women's March and made very clear that they were Orthodox, they were proud Zionists and didn't have any hassle. You're right that there is something that I think on a personal level, there is a little bit of a fear of sort of like, oh, if I tell people I'm a Zionist, am I going to be rejected? I've heard a lot of very positive stories.
And especially, I think, once you get up to the point of the leadership, you really do have the ability to change the conversation. Okay, I mean, listen, I'm willing to be swayed on that. And I think even when it comes to participating and being involved in these movements, there's different ways of going about doing that. Do you do it unequivocally and just do it wholeheartedly? Or do you do it, but you make it very clear, I'm doing this and this is an important cause, but I'm also a Zionist and I'm not going to hide that in my participation. I'd be more comfortable with that way. I totally get that. And I think Rabbi Berman...
agrees with that. And I think Ray Berman is very much saying that. I'm saying, you know, don't avoid it. Be part of the conversation. Be very clear about who you are. And, you know, that's the best way for you to yield your power, for you to wield your power and wield your influence. So now let's go on, you know, beyond the moderator. There were also some audience conversations that were given to the moderator beforehand. And we're not going to be able to go through all of that, but I think there are some of them that I think were particularly interesting. And I know that I was thinking a lot about. The first question that I want us to talk about is specifically about racism. The question was given to the panelists. Is there racism in the Orthodox community? And if there is, how do we overcome it? So they all seem to agree that there is. Ray Berman spoke first. And Ray Berman, obviously, he has a very long...
long history as a civil rights advocate. And he spoke very clearly that racism is unfortunately all too endemic in the Orthodox community. He spoke a little bit about how Israel is kind of at the forefront of getting past that. He spoke very personally that it was really interesting. A bunch of his family members, I think he said he had three family members in Israel who are married to Ethiopians. He of course said, you know, it still exists in Israel as well, but that it's definitely better. And it's something that we as a culture must really strive for to eradicate completely. So Dr. Stein Haid had a little bit of a different take. She argued that, you know, look around this room and everyone...
basically in this room was an Ashkenazi Jew. And she said, not only is there racism within orthodox jury against the larger world, we have to be a little bit introspective and look just at our immediate community, right? We have to look at the racism that we kind of often will... feel or espouse towards the Sephardic community. And she said, you know, it goes the other way also. Sephardic Jews very often will make sort of disparaging remarks or think differently about the Ashkenaz community. But she also kind of, she was pushing the audience, which I thought was really interesting because it kind of took it in a different direction, that she as a mother feels uncomfortable pretty often because her kids are growing up, really going to school and interacting with people who are just like them, right? They're other white, they're upper class, you know, they grew up on the Upper West Side. And she was kind of challenging herself and all of us to, how do we...
create meaningful experiences and relationships for our kids. Not chesed, right? She was very explicit about this. Not like, oh, I can go to a homeless shelter and feed poor people. But how do we create meaningful relationships and meaningful experiences where people can interact with other people and sort of see the shared humanity there? I thought that was a really interesting take. It kind of moved the conversation not away from racism, but sort of talking about the natural limitations in orthodoxy in creating this sense of...
not relating to the other. Right. So on the one hand, I had a problem with the fact that all the panelists seem to readily acknowledge that the Orthodox community is so racist because I don't really agree with that. And I also think it's a question of levels. Obviously, it's not the same thing when you're talking about the white nationalists in Charlottesville.
they're racist. And then talking about an Orthodox Jew who makes an offhand comment about, I don't know, about a Schwarzer or something. Not that that's okay, but those are obviously not the same level of racism. But I do agree very much with Alana Steinhein that from my understanding of the world is that the more personal interaction you have with other groups and people outside of your comfort zone, the more... empathy you have and the more connection you feel and you will then be much less likely to do or think even anything negative towards those other groups. Yeah, I mean, I think about for myself just when I went to college and I started getting involved in the Hillel and it was really the first time that I had really significant, thoughtful interactions with non-Orthodox Jews who thought deeply and cared passionately about their own denominations. And I think that was a really transformative experience for me. Just go back to the first thing you said. I don't disagree with you. I mean, of course, there's a difference between the racism of Charlottesville and of that march.
And the racist, the sort of harmless, quote unquote, racism of, you know, my elderly relative, you know, using inappropriate language about, you know, about black people. But I mean, we're sophisticated people. Are you like, I'm not so worried about that. I mean, maybe this, it seems to me comes to a fundamental disagreement that we have pretty often where I think you're much more nervous about the language. I think it makes a difference because it's a question of action. The people who are marching in Charlottesville, they wanted action. They wanted the country to change, wanted laws to change. I think when it comes to a lot of this racism in the Orthodox community that the panelists are just saying, oh, of course it's there. I think very, very few people in Orthodox community.
would want anything to change or would want anything other than equality for everybody. I guess when it comes to this particular example, I'm just being defensive to my community because I don't want it. It just bothered me that people were just so quick to all say, oh, yeah, of course they're racist. Like, I don't I think there's a difference between that and saying we can be more sensitive when it comes to the way we speak about other groups. Right. The last questionary that I think, you know, is worth talking about, because I think this is something that is very often in the back of our minds.
gets to something that we don't speak about very often, is how has status and wealth in our community, in the modern Orthodox community, influenced the way we think about social justice? Rabbi Weinstock was the first person to answer this question, to take this one on. He said that, yeah, definitely, you know, wealth and status has led our community, by and large, to become a little bit more conservative, as sort of this want to happen. But also, you know, he defended wealth, and he defended sort of, like, the power that comes with wealth. And he said that's also opened opportunities for more charitable giving, you know, and I think... I thought that was a really great answer. When he said it, everybody kind of, like, nodded. Like, we wouldn't have a lot of these movements if it wasn't for the wealthy people who are backing them and funding them. Yeah, absolutely. And he is the rabbi at KJ, which is obvious.
a very wealthy modern Orthodox community, and I think he recognizes, looking around at his community members, that they are leaders in charitable giving, and I think that's a completely reasonable thing to say. Wealth is a mixed blessing, and it can be a little bit complicated, but it also gives you opportunity to share that wealth. Ray Berman had a little bit of a different take, and I thought his take was really fascinating. What Ray Berman argued is that... We as a community have really been accumulating wealth recently, which is a blessing, but also we've been accumulating this wealth without really being given a fundamental understanding of what one's purpose is as it relates to that wealth. And that is destructive. And it relates similarly to what he talked about before. I don't think it's surprising. And I don't say this in a disparaging way. He's clearly socialist-minded and anti-materialistic, which I sort of am also. So I think he's uncomfortable with...
a lot of the materialism that has seeped into our community. Yeah, and I think that's true. And I think he basically said that we are not sufficiently taught how to engage with our wealth and making sure that sort of the spiritual values that are meant to be associated with wealth are there and present. Not to say that Dr. Weinstock is wrong. People do use wealth for good, but also we use it in a way that isn't necessarily always so good. A spiritual life also means engaging with this wealth and acting with it in a spiritual way. I thought that was a really interesting sort of way of capturing the idea that you must utilize your wealth in the same way that you utilize other sort of things that we think of as more spiritual in a way to give expression to your fundamental values as it relates to religion.
as it relates to spirituality. Right. I mean, I think there is, as Rabbi Wensack and everybody else agreed, there is tons of charitable giving in the Orthodox community. I guess if anything, the argument would be, even though they didn't say this explicitly, is that maybe as a percentage, some of that money should be given more to general causes and causes outside of the Jewish community and not as focused inward. I think that's because I think as a percentage, the Orthodox community is way overrepresented in charitable giving. Yeah, I think so too. I think also just tying this...
theme back to an earlier theme the well thing and why orthodox jews often feel alienated from some of these movements i think you see things like the bernie sanders movement even though he is jewish and many of his followers are jewish i mean all these things are there's paradoxes and interesting contradictions in all of it but there was all it was basically class warfare there's a lot of talk of the one percenters and painted as evil so if somebody finds himself technically speaking in the one percent It's understandable that they would feel defensive and that they would feel that these movements, which are all interconnected because of intersectionality, that somebody in the 1% is the target of these movements, is the bad guy, basically. And I think it's understandable why somebody might feel alienated by that. I think that has to be overcome because it's avoiding the real issues and you have to be mature about it and say, like, okay, if somebody just wants to paint any rich person as evil, they're being stupid. It's not my problem. It seemed to me, and maybe I'm wrong, and I want to put words in his mouth, it seemed to me that what Rubberman was specifically calling out, though very implicitly, was the consumerism that I think is really rampant. I think we both agree with this, this consumerism that is very often rampant.
in the larger world, but it's also really, really seeped its way into the modern Orthodox world as well. Right, I don't think it's worse in the Orthodox world. I think we just hold ourselves to higher standards. And like I said, he strikes me as a particularly anti-materialistic person, which I think is commendable. Right, and I think actually that goes straight into what Dr. Stein Haynes says, which is, she also, addressing this question, she also speaks more explicitly about consumerism in the secular world and consumerism in the religious world, and she specifically calls out that there's way too much overlap, and that's what she thinks is the problem. She also was very careful to say that wealth is important and it's valuable, and it's only because of wealth that gives us power, and I think that brings us back to Washington and lobbying.
back to APAC, which is, I think, what we're going to be discussing next week. So stay tuned. And I think, Uri, with that, let's wrap it up. I really enjoyed this panel. I think you did also. And I enjoyed our conversation. Yeah, I think it gave us a lot to think about. And I think we all agree that we can always be better. We can always be doing more. And this panel was a really nice way of bringing up a lot of these issues and giving us a lot to think about. Absolutely. And of course, again, we will urge you not just to listen to us, but to listen to the panel for yourselves. You know, tell us, do you disagree? Do you think we were mischaracterizing anything? Give us, you know, a lot of pushback. That's what we're looking for. And email us, as always, at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And of course, get engaged in the Facebook group. You know, let's keep the conversation going. As always, we'd like to thank Drive-In Productions for sponsoring our show this week. And we'd like to thank Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade.
for giving us our theme song and being the official band of Talking Tacos. Bye, everyone. Bye.