155: The Search for the Best American Rums with Mainland Rum's Seth Benhaim episode artwork

EPISODE · Jun 20, 2026 · 1H 25M

155: The Search for the Best American Rums with Mainland Rum's Seth Benhaim

from The Rumcast · host Will Hoekenga and John Gulla

Note: As a reminder, Rumcast Reserve bottles are officially available in stores and shipping from our online retailer! You can grab your bottles here.You can watch the video version of this episode on YouTube.In this episode, we sat down with the founder of the only independent rum bottler exclusively focused on sourcing rums from the United States, Seth Benhaim of Mainland Rum.Since launching a little over a year ago, Mainland Rum has released some of the longest aged American rums to hit the market in recent years, including a 10-year-old Louisiana and a 9-year-old California to go along with releases sourced from Georgia and Florida.With their first unaged release from a Minnesota distillery set to hit the market soon, we figured it was a good time to catch up and learn more about Mainland's vision. We discussed:Arriving at the idea to focus solely on American rumThe challenge of sourcing longer aged rums from craft distilleriesNegative perceptions associated with the categoryThe double-edged sword of releasing rums from closed distilleriesFirst impressions of Mainland's unaged "S. Pombe" release sourced from Black Frost DistillingThe future of the American rum categoryAnd moreHave a listen and let us know your thoughts or questions!Learn more about Mainland Rum on their website.

Note: As a reminder, Rumcast Reserve bottles are officially available in stores and shipping from our online retailer! You can grab your bottles here: https://www.rumcast.com/reserve You can watch the video version of this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/zIAF12lf1hg In this episode, we sat down with the founder of the only independent rum bottler exclusively focused on sourcing rums from the United States, Seth Benhaim of Mainland Rum. Since launching a little over a year ago, Mainland Rum has released some of the longest aged American rums to hit the market in recent years, including a 10-year-old Louisiana and a 9-year-old California to go along with releases sourced from Georgia and Florida. With their first unaged release from a Minnesota distillery set to hit the market soon, we figured it was a good time to catch up and learn more about Mainland's vision. We discussed: Arriving at the idea to focus solely on American rum The challenge of sourcing longer aged rums from craft distilleries Negative perceptions associated with the category The double-edged sword of releasing rums from closed distilleries First impressions of Mainland's unaged "S. Pombe" release sourced from Black Frost Distilling The future of the American rum category And more Have a listen and let us know your thoughts or questions! Learn more about Mainland Rum on their website: https://www.mainlandrum.com/

NOW PLAYING

155: The Search for the Best American Rums with Mainland Rum's Seth Benhaim

0:00 1:25:23

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of The Rumcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 25 minutes long.

When was this The Rumcast episode published?

This episode was published on June 20, 2026.

What is this episode about?

Note: As a reminder, Rumcast Reserve bottles are officially available in stores and shipping from our online retailer! You can grab your bottles here.You can watch the video version of this episode on YouTube.In this episode, we sat down with the...

Can I download this The Rumcast episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!