Skip to content
156 - The Forbidden Island episode artwork

May 1, 2023 1 hr 24 min

156 - The Forbidden Island

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY STAMPS.COM Get a 4-week trial, free postage, and a digital scale at Stamps.com. Thanks to Stamps.com for sponsoring the show! PATREON You can support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you YOU CAN SPONSOR THE SHOW By clicking right here to place a bid or by visiting nodumbquestions.fm/sponsor STUFF IN THIS EPISODE North Sentinel Island Shaka Zulu Boer War Through Gates of Splendor Huaorani People Mission Aviation Fellowship William Knibb Rodney Stark Brave New World CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day) YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY MATT'S DAILY PODCAST: The Ten Minute Bible Hour Podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

156 - The Forbidden Island

0:00 1:24:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Here we are sitting at your desk where we got together and recorded a bunch of episodes last year. I'm seeing these little sheets of paper. Everyone gave you these sheets of paper. Yeah, a little brown swiss house or whatever.

Shally. Shally my bed. Yeah. You haven't cleaned here for a while.

Shut up. No, it's like artifacts. The historian in me loves it. You just left it untouched.

Oh, yeah, okay. We'll go with that. It's like your archaeology. The further you go down and the layers on the desk, the more further back in time you go.

Right. It's right. Yeah. Your sister in here.

There is. Nice place you got it. Okay, well, let's have another conversation. You heard about this Sentinel Island thing?

Sentinel sounds like a robot that you used to guard a place, but I have heard of Sentinel Island. It's somewhere in the, where is that? Is that in Asia? Yeah, they have been gone.

Okay. That's near India. Yes. Okay.

And the Sentinel Island, North Sentinel Island, specifically is the one that's in question for this conversation, is a part of an island chain that looks like to me, the naked eye is part of another island chain that runs north to south, closer to Laos and Thailand and Mayan, Maury wouldn't look where it's sitting. It doesn't look like it would be a part of India, but a good chunk of it apparently is controlled by India, including this one little circle shaped jungle look in island called North Sentinel Island. And this is where you probably have heard of it before our conversation today. There is a people group there who are overwhelmingly untouched by modernity.

They're not connected to civilization anyway. Okay. Where does that take your brain? Well, they've seen airplanes.

They had to have seen airplanes. Yeah, about that though. What? In 1953 or 56, India passed an act entirely dedicated to the preservation of non-contact with these people.

I think that included air traffic. You can't go close. It's five nautical miles for any kind of boat. The whole idea was to create this non-contact bubble where they would not see or be exposed to the outside world.

Are they technically citizens of India? Well, that's interesting. I dug into that a little bit. Well, first of all, this island is owned by India.

It's owned kind of by India as much as it's ever agreed to be owned by India. Okay. I mean, really, doesn't somebody there have to sign off on it and some point for them to be Indians? And I don't think anybody ever has.

So it's an island with a people group ranging somewhere between 40 and 400. And so many inhabitants are out of it. How would you know? It's thick jungle.

You can't go on there. A few people tried way back in earlier times. Somebody violated the rules while back with a helicopter and they fired arrows and threw spears at it. And so we have images of some Sentinelese tribesmen.

But the people on the island threw spears at helicopters. At a helicopter. Yeah. Like they got close enough to try to land and they thought they would hit the helicopter or they were just like, hey, you're a thousand feet in the air and I'm gonna throw the spear at you.

The image I saw, it looked like it was a closer swing than that. You have your computer there? I do. Just pull that up.

Build Sentinel Island helicopter or something like that. I think you'll be able to see the images. Okay. I mean, they pop up around the internet once every year or two when people are talking about interesting things and mysteries of the world.

Oh. This island island comes up. Did you get it? Oh, so you got some some guys here on the beach.

These are the warriors. Okay. We've got big spears. Got long bows.

They have long bows. Okay. Isn't that an at-lattle? The one guy has there?

I can't tell. It's kind of grainy. And so yeah, so this is a low elevation shot. So somebody got pretty close and this is this is the head on look of somebody aiming a bow at you, a long bow and not only like aiming at you, but this is somebody that knows how to use it.

It's like the long bows at an angle. You can I don't know. You can just tell that this person knows what they're doing with the bow. And if you saw Avatar 2 recently, you know that long bows are the ideal weapon for taking down helicopters.

Yeah, I learned that recently. I haven't watched that recently. Every single time. I haven't watched that.

Why even have a helicopter? I'm also seeing a picture of a boat here and it looks like a pretty modern boat. Or at least the construction is made out of wood. Yeah.

So I'm going to throw a flag on the fact that they're never, they're never contacted because I'm looking at the construction methods of this boat. Now, I just recently went to Peru and I saw a boat like a dugout, a dugout canoe right there on the side of the Amazon River. Yeah. And it looked less modern than this boat that I'm seeing, but apparently was taken from a boat over the year.

I wonder if this boat like drifted up on the island or something. Here's what happened. I know what picture you're looking at. A few years back, some fishermen got whipped into a storm and ended up beached on Sentinel Island.

They were immediately killed and efforts were made to recover the bodies. Now, my theory is, and I don't know this off the top of my head, I'm sure you could Google it and figure it out right there. Those helicopter shots of people on the island. I bet that was authorities trying to verify that those fishermen were indeed deceased.

So that boat might have been some sort of rescue craft or lifeboat kind of thing that ended up landing them on Sentinel Island. I know of two visitors or two groups of visitors, if you will, who have set foot on Sentinel Island in recent memory. And that is one of the incidents with the fishermen. So I bet that's the boat you're looking at.

Really? OK, very interesting. So what are we talking about today? Well, I want to go back to the very general question I asked you a minute ago.

Where does that take you emotionally? Like what questions is that prompt for you? It's a really weird proposition, isn't it? Well, prior to 1999 or whenever the Matrix was in the film came out.

I would say, you know, it would be great to contact them, right? And you know, we probably have things that they, you know, we've discussed this in the past and you said something like, hey, medicine or something. What was your position? We could take the medicine.

Yeah, we've talked before about the ethics of reaching out to a people group, a civilization with reduced technology. The basic question is, well, do you go in there and like surely they have cancer? Everybody has cancer. Well, we have some treatments for cancer.

How can we monsters withhold treatments for cancer and other diseases? We solved all that. They're dying from it. We can help them.

Or is the ethical thing to say, they want to be left alone. They are making their own way. They're solving their own thing to show up to quote unquote help is to effectively end their civilization experiment because it's over. The second, the Stone Age meets the postmodern age and the advanced digital age.

That's not a fair fight. It's not balanced. The one is just going to devour the other. So what do you do?

Ethically, I think that's a conversation we were having a while back. Yeah, I'm reminded of several things. OK. I'm just going to tell you the thing.

You know how everybody has their own life experience and different things come to mind. I'm just going to tell you a few things that come up. OK. One of which is there's an old movie about the Zulu, I think.

Shaka Zulu. Sure. And so he's this warrior in Africa and the British colonists come over. The empire comes over and there's this battle between these villagers and these British that have machine guns.

And you know, Shaka Zulu is really good with a short spear and he bangs a short spear on his shield and just this dichotomy between super sophisticated modern technology. They can smelt iron and they can make steel and they can make guns and all that. And you have this other side that has spears and stuff. That's interesting.

Yeah, the bower ward is like the Dutch as well in that part of the world. So they are. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah, sure. Yeah. It's an interesting clash.

Yeah, that's interesting. The other thing it makes me think about is I don't know where I saw this, but there's a documentary about this one tribe. I think they were in the Amazon and part of their tradition, the men would wear these things. Here's a content warning for parents that maybe in the third chair, like we have kids around, I'm going to give it about five seconds a year.

I know what you're going to talk about. Let's give him seven seconds. Seven seconds. It's a duty.

Yeah. Seven seconds. It's an image that's not going to go away. OK, assuming I know what you're talking about.

Is that enough time? Is the second word in what you're about to describe sheath? No. Oh, OK.

Well, it's the penis scored. What? How's that difference from a penis sheath? Well, there's this.

I don't know. It was just called a penis gord. I don't know if it was National Geographic or if it was whatever it was. But I remember watching a documentary.

I've never had a microphone conversation about penis attire in my entire life until right now. And I want to thank you for that. Well, there's this there's this tribe and there's different there's different things that people wear and some tribes, the females will wear stirrts and grass stirrts or whatever. But this particular tribe, there's this thing called a penis gord.

And the men of the village will take a there's a long gord that grows near where they are. They hollow it out and they take a string and tie the string around their neck and they hold the string out. And they put the gord over their penis and they tie the string to the end of the gord. And so it just holds it there like that.

Have you ever seen this? So again, we cannot content worn hard enough for talking with the kids, but I genuinely want to understand. So I'm going to ask question 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 is the idea that this function is almost like foot binding or other long-term alterations of physiology. We're trying to change the penis.

No, no, no, not at all. It's just a way to conceal from honesty is my understanding. And so then how does the yeah, I don't string factor in instead of like a belt. I don't I don't know.

I just feel like you're judging my heart right now. This is this is a cultural thing. OK, and if you don't understand this, that's on you. You're right.

But but one thing that's interesting is the place it took my mind is there was a moment when a group of researchers or I don't know if they were linguists, what they are, they went into this village and they had a do you remember back in the 80s? There were these old plastic flashlights and you would open the top of the flashlight, had an old lamp like a filament lamp. Yes. And you put two C size or D size batteries in there.

The cheapest generic red flashlight. Yes. Yeah. With a white switch with little lines across the group on the little plastic lens like thing over the land.

Absolutely. Yes. We were talking about the same thing. Yeah.

And I'm not so sure that modern children will know the flashlight we're talking about, but you know what I'm talking about. And so we're torches. Yeah. For listeners in the UK and UK and close world.

Yeah. And so the people that were there from the, I'll say the modern world, which you know, who's to judge, but you know, the people that had access to plastic injection molding technology, we'll say that. Okay. They had a flashlight and one of the villagers took the flashlight, took the batteries out, flipped it over and used it as a penis gourd.

And it was his attire and it was socially acceptable in his tribe that this is how I can seal myself. And what's interesting is there didn't seem to be any, god, I wish I don't remember where I saw this, but I remember thinking, oh, that's weird because you know, you think that there would be all kinds of social awkwardness things going around with like what type of gore do you use and how big is it and all these kinds of things. And it just wasn't a thing to these people. The issue was I need to conceal myself and this gets it done.

And I remember thinking that was fascinating. And so it was this strange blend of modern technology being plastic injection molding and you know, the social norms of this particular village. I just remember thinking, there's a lot about this. I don't understand.

And the little boy in me wants to laugh and go, ha, ha, look how funny this is. I mean, there's obvious jokes there. Come on. That's reasonable.

I mean, anything that's, anything that's farts were parts of the body you covered with clothes like there's going to be some impulsive people have to chuckle about that a little bit. But also the fact that people cover those things with clothes means that that's a cultural text. It means that there's a cultural shared agreed upon decision that's happening there, meaning that it's full of meaning. But what was interesting is that the fact that they were covering that part of the body and nothing else.

Yeah, and nothing else. It was almost like, I don't know, it was very clear to me that there's something about that I didn't understand that was accepted within that specific localized society. I thought that was fascinating. I thought that was wickedly fascinating.

So anyway, that's the second thing I thought of. And the third thing I thought of, which is not what I thought I'd be talking about immediately after talking about the last subject was the book through Gates of Splendor. It's by Elizabeth Elliott. It was actually a formative book in my life.

A famous missionary's wife. Yes. Yes. Jim Elliott was killed in Ecuador along with four other people.

There were missionaries. Let me just look at their name here because I don't want to get this wrong. Nate Saint. Yeah.

Nate Saints, the one that comes to mind. He was the pilot. So Jim Elliott, Pete Fleming, Ed McCully, Nate Saint, and Roger Uderian. And so these five guys and their families, they went down to Ecuador and they said, Hey, we're going to reach this unreached people group with the gospel of Jesus, right?

We're going to tell them, we're going to give them the good news, which also means telling them the bad news first. So for the outsider, and I understand it's easy for people like you and me to just take it for granted that that's some people just heard and know about. We're talking about the message of the kingdom, the idea that there were all sinners, the long-promised Messiah who is the one who solves the human problem of sin and death and suffering and ech and all of that stuff. And that somehow what he does by dying on the cross and being resurrected deals with the brokenness of humanity.

Yeah. You spoke about that work. Okay. Yeah.

You accept the grace that's given freely through Jesus. And so the three things that are easy to say, God, great grace, buddy of mine, Steve, says it that way. So this is what makes Jesus different. Jesus God.

He actually died rose from the grave and that his grace is freely given. There's nothing you can do to work for it. Sure. Yeah.

And so we're on the same page. We're on the same page. Cool. And so they being Christians were like, I'm going to go down here to this unreached people group.

And I'm not okay with the little, you know, as soon as you're in Sunday school and you're like, but what are the people that don't hear about Jesus? You know, yeah. Yeah. They're like, well, I'm going to go let them know.

Right. And so because there's a conflict that happens in your mind when you're like, but you know, they don't know about the good news. I need to tell them the good news. And so these five missionaries went down and it did not in well.

They had a very specific plan. They were working on the language. There was a, it's an interesting word, Donnie with the tribe. Well, Donnie.

Yeah, the known locally is the Alka, A UCA. And so I read this book just before I left college and I went to Ecuador shortly after that. It was huge for me. And because I don't know.

The one thing that Jamelia said that I thought was fascinating and it resonated with me is he is no fool who gives up what he cannot keep to gain what he cannot lose. That's something I think about all the time, even now. Also, another thing I loved about the book in the book, Nate Saint, who is the pilot. He developed this really cool way.

He had this really cool yellow airplane. He developed a really cool way using drag. And I think I've told you about this before. You fly the airplane and you have a bucket on the end of a string.

And if you slowly let the bucket out, if you can imagine an airplane flying straight and you imagine a string rolling out of the bucket, it will drag, will affect that bucket differently at different altitudes along the string, right? Well, the bucket obviously has a lot of drag. The string has less drag and you have tension up there at the airplane. You have tension on the bucket all the way down.

So Nate Saint developed this really cool thing he could do. He could bank the airplane, have the string coming out of the airplane, and he could slowly fly out that or roll out the string until the bucket reached the ground. And if he's at a certain bank angle, he could fly in a circle in that bucket. He could drop things on the ground.

When I say, imagine a bucket, you look up and you see a bucket and you see a long string and an airplane going in a circle around it, but the bucket's not moving. It's stationary and it comes all the way down to the ground. And because he manages the drag and the drift and all these things, the airplane velocity, because he knew he was a good pilot and he's got a feedback loop, which is him looking at it as he's flying, he could communicate, so to speak, with the ground. He could even put a telephone on the ground with a wire all the way down.

Talk to people and he could put it, one of the things they did is they put a chicken in the bucket, you know, you put a chicken in the bucket and you drop it down. This is how they initially made contact with the tribe, drop it, chicken in the bucket and they even put some stuff and they brought it back and you know, they got really excited. Then they went in to visit these people. They developed a way to land the aircraft on a small little beach along a river, along an oxbow in the river, and they were ultimately killed.

So it's fascinating. It killed the spears. Yeah, and there's a description even of how the interaction went south, that there was some initial promise of positive contact, even some maybe exchanging of gifts or something that looked like it was going well, and then things just flipped. And somebody went and procured one of the spears that was used.

Those are still made. And have it right here. Oh, you do. That's the same one I have.

I think somebody must have sent us both of these at once. And I'm embarrassed that I no longer remember who, but for years now, I've had this in my office. Exactly that. Yeah, I remember the letter because in the letter they said to maintain the balance of power between Alabama and Wyoming, I'm going to give him a spear as well.

It was even before and it's even after. Yeah, I'm embarrassed that I don't remember who sent this as well, but it's really cool because there's a string on the end because you throw the spear and then you can unwind the string and pull it back. It's really interesting. They found some of the spears that were in the men.

They found the pages, some of the pages of the Bible that the men had left in that area. And so it looks like the tribesmen had put things on the spear that they intended to use to kill the specific individuals, which is wild. It's really, I'm confident we've talked about this before. Yeah, we have.

But I love it. So here I am again. Yes. And the long story short is eventually there was forgiveness between the people who killed those men and their families and ultimately that message of the kingdom of God and all of that ended up really taking root in that particular community.

Now, if we are to be honest about the history of missionary movements and all of that, you have to also acknowledge the things that didn't work because there's some awesome, amazing stories where things are great and there's a tremendous benefit for everyone. There were also incidents of exploitation, imbalance, weirdness on the whole. I think right now it's very popular to treat any kind of look back on the missionary movement. It's just this total racist colonial debacle.

That's just not fair or true at all. At the same time, then of course, folks who really cherish those memories are going to want to counter with what no, the whole thing was beautiful and perfect. And the truth is, I think the missionary movement is something that went right alongside the rather exploitative colonial economic movement. And it was the missionary movement, not governments.

It was the church that went and really held back the full exploitative impulse of the resource grab that went along with 19th century colonialism. A great example of that is in Jamaica. The story of William Nib. Diver told you about William Nib?

No. High schools are still named as the biggest high school in Jamaica. I think it's still named after William Nib. He's their Abraham Lincoln liberator of the slaves.

Amazing dude. Put everything on the line to side with the people of Jamaica, with the locals, with the natives of Jamaica and business hated him. Government hated him. He was an English guy.

His church got burned, his home got burned. There was a bounty on his head. He's hiding in a ship just offshore for more than one night trying not to get killed. But ultimately he's the one who was looking at it and was like, we cannot own the people of Jamaica.

You can't own humans. You can't buy, sell and trade people. Slavery is an abomination in the eyes of God. Slavery is incompatible with the Bible.

This has to go. And Nib won. But the forces of government and business, they wanted to keep that relationship as long as they could. So it's stories like that where you got to look back and realize that this, it's not a very accurate depiction of being like, oh, well, these gold grubbing business people, they partnered up with Jesus people and went enslaved people in all that business.

I can point to some examples where that happened. But for every one of those that you can bring up, I think I can show you a 10-20 where it was the missionaries who gave up everything, all comfort, everything, because they saw not just an opportunity to go reach somebody with what they believed to be true about God and Jesus and all that. But their sense of God inspired justice was offended by what they knew to be happening in these places of initial contact that were occurring in the age of colonial boom. They ended up being the ones who went and looked out for the people who were getting exploited by greed.

I just don't think they get enough credit. I think they get crapped on a lot. So that's me sticking up for them. I know people like that today.

I mean, I actually know them, like people that spend time in other countries that we can't talk about. Yeah, you can't talk about them because if people, they're in a different country and they're doing something and they might be working a job locally, but they're actually missionaries. And one of the things they're trying to do is they're trying to make sure that people in the local area are treated well. And that's enough to say about that.

Yeah, because there's literally nothing we can say, because you and I are both connected to the same kind of stuff. Because they could die. And we absolutely can't even give hints or wink, wink, nod, nods about it. But you and I both know what's going on.

Yeah, exactly. And I think that's cool. I think so too. And I think that brings us back to the Sentinel Island deal.

You have to imagine that that's going to capture the attention of somebody that somebody who pictures the adventure missionary travels of Dr. Livingston, I presume, in the 19th century, Zimbabwe and Victoria Falls and just all that legendary stuff. People who were raised reading through gates of splendor and know the story about what happened in Ecuador, it could be really easy to look at that and fixate on the adventure high risk, high adrenaline aspect of that. You could also say that that that specific method is not particularly effective.

I say that with weight, because we know some of the ancestors of some of these people, like grandchildren, and we know them. And we say that from the comfort of these microphones. Absolutely. We're not even doing this live.

That's how low the risk is. Like anything we think is stupid, we can just make go away. Right. But I think there's an argument to be made on like, what is the most effective way to reach people?

And what is the purpose of reaching people? Yeah. Jesus anticipated that question. I just got done doing that whole book of math.

My podcast book of Matthew thing. I call it. It took a long time. It was a lot of work.

But even there, Jesus commissioning of the people he sends out with this message about really overwhelming. It's a message of justice. He sends them out and he's like, hey, you got to be sure to serve and send innocentest doves here, because things are stacked against you and the people who are doing evil, exploiting other people abusing their power and position, they're very entrenched and they're very good at what they do. And you guys who I'm sending out, he's got like a bunch of fishermen and small business owners and stuff, like total Motley crew ragtag crowd that Jesus had gathered and that he sends out in the one third mark of the story of the book of Matthew.

He sends him out. He isn't just like, go be good. And by just your supreme decency and not swears, everyone will know that I'm the Lord. It's not like that at all.

He tells that he's the word shrewd. You got to read the room. You got to look at the situation and think about what you're doing. Well, those guys bumble through the rest of the book, but we know that after Matthew history and tradition and other parts of the Bible, they looked a lot more shrewd and they're what they did when they went out after the Bible holds out as a death and resurrection.

Jesus did not look the same depending on where they went. Now, all but one ended up meeting the same fate as Nate Saint and Janellia. I mean, eventually you're saying a message that is a complete paradigm change when you go out with that particular message and Jesus said that wouldn't always be greeted well. Isn't that interesting that Christianity, I mean, as soon as I say that people will be like, with the crusades, but like Christian example, yeah, it's a excellent kind of example.

But for the most part, Christianity has spread by people being killed as opposed to conquering. Yeah, I mean, that's why it caught on. There's this, I don't know what he's saying, watching the state, Baylor, he's been a few different places. Rodney Stark is a sociologist.

I've read all his stuff. Absolutely. That is. It's okay.

He's a guy who focuses on why things stick historically. I mean, there were 50 Messianic claimants we know about in the time frame of Jesus. Tons, Josephus, the Jewish historian who's a contemporary of Jesus, he gives us probably 20 stories of different people. I'm the Messiah, I'm raising an army, we're going to start from here and we're going to kill Rome.

We're going to kill these guys. I mean, it's crazy. I've done videos on all these different claimants holding themselves out as Messiah, but only one suck ever for all the people who've claimed that. Well, Rodney Stark's question as a sociologist is, how the heck did that happen?

Why that one? Why that guy? I really like his look at it because it's not like a evangelical apologetic make you feel good about your beliefs kind of book, sociology. And he's got a series of arguments for why he thinks it caught on.

One of the big reasons is they didn't have the sword. They did not have the opportunity really for 400 years before you really start to see things begin to flip toward Christians having any kind of authority and they didn't become a meaningfully persecuting group ever until about 700 years in in pockets when they started to meld with government and so to start, it's very compelling. He's like, they didn't, they didn't catch on by killing all of their rivals. They caught on by outliving their rivals by when plague hit compelled by their understanding of how God is and what he would want.

We just can't leave everybody to die. So we're going to say here, anybody who's here, we're going to nurse and nurture back to help. And so then Stark goes through and he has chapters where he analyzes how what percentage of increased survival that kind of nursing or attention would give given what we know about what diseases were each of these and made up each of these different plagues. And it's fascinating to just see somebody put math to it and be like, all right, the plague hit this percentage of the empire.

That's this many people who would have been affected. The death rate in general without care seems to have been about this with care. It seems to have been this and we've got all of these primary sources saying that Christians hung in. That means when those cataclysmic events occurred, either Christians caring for Christians, which promotes the growth of Christianity or Christians caring for non-Christians, which would be compelling for the non-Christian, like you stayed in risk death to look out for me.

That would result in the proliferation of Christianity. Stark needs a lot of those moments as being kind of quantum leap jumps in Christianity gaining a foothold by living out its stated values. I like it. Yeah, I really like that.

As you were sitting there talking, I was sitting there thinking about the Shema. I think it's interesting in Deuteronomy, it's all your heart, all your soul, and all your strength. But in Matthew, when it's re-quoted, it's all your heart with all your soul and all your mind. So that laying down of your strength, I'm kind of reading things in between the lines that aren't there.

Sure. Yeah, I am. Let's be honest. But I think it's interesting that the mind component, the mental component is brought in.

And I don't know if people are one with logic, and the logic goes something like this. Oh, you're not asking for anything. You're actually just helping me? Why?

That doesn't make sense. And so it's the counter logic that ends up making it work. Yes. And then it's upside down.

Right. And that brings us back to your question about the shrewdness. Jesus word there, not mine, or efficacy of the strategy we're talking about that the Sentinel Island thing got us into. Does it really feel to the recipient like you're just doing something for them in that kind of circumstance?

Or would the people of, let's say, Sentinel Island? Let's go away from the Ecuador example. Let's say you and I went around some churches and raised some money, we printed out bright yellow t-shirts to say, Matt and Destin mission trip to Sentinel Island 2025, and we wore a hats and we did a mine show, like all the things that they used to do in the 90s. Let's make it take a puppets.

Let's go with puppets. A very dramatic puppet show. Oh, it hurts. It hurts.

But let's say we did that. It's not going to work. No, wait, let's think about a different way. Okay.

You and I are on the island. Okay. We're on the island. Okay.

So we're in violation of international law and Indian law. We are from Sentinel Island. Oh, okay. North Sentinel Island.

Okay. And we're there and we're sitting by the fire and we're like, hey, man, I think tomorrow, I want to go hunt some pigs. Yeah, I do. Look at my new arrow.

Look at this. You see this? Yeah. Dude, I've sharpened this for so long.

Look how sharp this thing is. Touch it. Oh, it's very pointy. Pointy.

Might say pointy. My daughters, they mingled two words when they were kids. And so they couldn't say pointy. And so it ended up being pointy.

And anything that sharp, we still thought like pointy. No, we're on the island right now. Yeah, they don't exist in this reality. I hate this reality now.

But all right. It's pointy. Pointy. Yeah.

Okay. So I'm thinking about tomorrow, going out and shooting a pig with my arrow. Are you in? Yeah, we should jam some fruit in its mouth after that and put it on a spit and rotate it.

I'm gamed, dude. That's what I want for tomorrow. It's way better than all this fish. Absolutely.

We go. Yes. Okay. Okay.

We sleep. You know, lots of jungle sounds. Wait, do we create to tribal God before we get a bit? No, we're not even.

We got nothing. We don't even know concept of that. We don't know. Okay.

Cool. Okay. So we get up. Yep.

We're going on. Hey, dude, wake up. Wake up. Oh, is it big day?

It's big day. Let's go. All right. So don't forget the new arrow.

Oh, yeah, the pointy one. Yeah. Yeah, I got the pointy one. Okay.

So we go out. Yes. And we start on our pig hunt. Wonderful.

Are there pigs on this island? Let's say there are. I really want to know now. Like, this needs to be rooted in facts because of how factual this example is.

They got to have fat. They got to have protein. So you can get fat from fish head. Can you get fat from fish?

Yeah. Yeah. Like a fish head stew will produce fat, but coming up with fat is one of the tricky things on islands. But that's why you get like Hawaiian barbecue because lots of different pigs species can do well because they root around for anything in that kind of environment, while you don't get larger game than pigs.

Okay. So we're we're kind of out towards the edge of the perimeter of the island. Okay. We're still in the end of canopy.

Okay. And then we walk out and then we see on the horizon a boat. Okay. It's a big boat.

It's like a container ship. Wow. What do you think about this big thing that you and I just saw on the horizon? What do you think about it?

Now, like in this reality, I don't know, our parents have talked about boats and flying things, you know, so was a story handed down from grandparents about flying objects that used to go right over the island all the time. I think there's like the guy to be smart. They know. But we've only seen that once in our lifetimes.

Only one time has one of these flying objects appeared. But we saw it plain as day. I'm telling you, island destined. I was there that day.

And I saw that flying thing before it left. That was real. It's like our grandparents. And it was loud and terrible.

Yes. And we hate it. Yes. Do we hate it?

There's a couple of the kids from the younger generation who are uncomfortably obsessed with it. That's going to be the downfall of society. So we're going to preach hard against that. Yeah, we hate it.

That's how all the things work. It doesn't matter that we're on this island or if we're like here, it's true. Interesting. We just rally around the thing that we hate together.

Interesting. Okay. I don't know where I'm going with this example. It's just kind of interesting.

The shipping container shows up. Oh, yeah. Yeah. How do you feel about that island destined?

I don't know. I mean, that's big. It looks like that looks like a craft of war. It's bigger than ours.

We have this little bitty thing that we sometimes go out fishing and that thing's big. I feel uncomfortable around that thing. And I don't like it. I just don't like it.

Yeah. It's powerful. It's using technology. I have no chance of understanding.

I don't see any rowing or sales. Yeah. Yeah. It looks like magic.

Again, do not mistake my little role playing here as being, I think these are unsophisticated midwits. We would go on to that island and immediately die given the tools they have. We have no cultural memory of how to survive like that. Even with our fancy educations, we're not going to live out a robust, happy life like they're going to be able to pull off on that same chunk of ground.

It would be torture for us. We would not know what to do. We would not succeed the way they've figured out to succeed. They've got a billion shortcuts.

I don't think these are idiots. I think these are competent people with solid core aptitude and ability at the level of the brain. But come on, look at how big that ship is. If I can't touch it and poke at it and take it apart, if I don't have time with it, I can't just figure that out from a distance.

It's just intimidating. Interesting. And I think that communication barrier or that experiential barrier that's there, as long as we just don't let that thing penetrate that barrier, we're good. We have an enemy and we understand it to be an enemy and we don't have to worry about getting close to it and all that kind of stuff.

So I think if I was a person in power, I think it would be really important to tell people, hey, you have to keep the barrier up. The last thing we want to do is communicate with those people. That's the last thing we want to do. So interesting thing happened.

I was reading something a while back about a guy from Sentinel Island. Something happened and he ended up on a mainland hospital. He learned Hindi on the hospital. I think this was generations ago.

We were talking decades and decades ago and then returned to Sentinel Island. Maybe. I'm not sure if you went back or if you went somewhere else, but I think he went back. And there was a lot of interest, apparently, in going to interview this man because I'm not aware of anybody understanding at all the language of the Sentinelese.

I don't think there's any possibility of verbal linguistic communication at this point. But there was a guy some time ago who could have served as the, what was the dude's name when the settlers came to New England? And they met a guy and spoke English. Oh, it wasn't Squanto.

Oh, wow. What was his name? Was it Squanto? Yes.

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for knowing my discipline better than I know it. Yes.

That's the guy. So you could have a situation like that where just inexplicably you've got this liaison between cultures, between languages that could fast forward everything. And I don't think any of that interview ever occurred. But I could certainly see how somebody in the anthropology world would be like, this is the greatest prize.

It'd be like interviewing someone from the distant past. We have to get this interview. We have to do it. And ultimately, I think the strength of the law and the enforcement behind that Indian Protection Act from the 1950s or whenever probably prevented such an interview from occurring.

You understand the appeal, right? Like what we could even learn about humanity. If you could get that conversation, untainted, untouched before all of the robots and all of the technology and all of that contact happens. If you could get a meaningful, mostly pre-contact interview with someone from there, what could you learn about our distant past?

Have you ever read the book Brave New World? Yes, I have. Okay. There's a thing that happens in this book where you have this person in the modern world.

And I would say it's a dystopia. Oh, yes. Yeah. So it's a world where they're all this Huxley, right?

Yes. It's a world that's so civilized that they plan out every person that is to exist. And you are rated according to your capabilities. And so it's kind of like if we were to maximize, is that even a word that you worked for me?

You know what I'm trying to say? Everything about society. And we're like, hey, you're a beta or you're an epsilon. Like we're going to score you based on your capabilities.

And we're going to plug you into certain jobs. And that's how we're going to do things. There was this individual that went to America and he went to, I think it was New Mexico. He went to a reservation and he was allowed to observe this tribesman.

And this guy was doing all these really strange things. And he was trying to say, what on earth is happening? And it was weird because this guy was more in tune with his humanity, that the tribesman was more in tune with humanity than this modern person was. And it was interesting.

It was just like, I didn't really understand it. I remember getting to the end of the book and thinking, what was that? I thought it was rather interesting the other day on the way home. I've been inside a lot.

I've been looking at streams. It's the winter. So I've been doing all kinds of work. I've been working with CNC machines.

I've been using my brain a lot, but I was driving home the other day and I had somewhere to be at a certain time. And I looked at the river and the sunset was beautiful. And it was beautiful an hour earlier. But because it's the winter, the sunsets take a long time.

And I was like, you know, when's the last time I got out at the river and just walked down to the river? So I got out. I just blinker on, pulled over, got out of my truck. And then I started running back towards the bridge.

And I couldn't get a good view of the bridge or the sunset from bridge number one. I had to go to bridge number two. And to get to bridge number two, I had to run across bridge number one. And there was no shoulder.

So I had to run basically in traffic on a really skinny bridge. I was like, I'm going. And so I went to bridge number two. All my way to bridge number two, I crossed a dead deer that was on the side of the road to sofas that had apparently flew out of somebody's vehicle.

It was awful, like litter and stuff. And I finally got down into the mud on the riverbank and I could hear the birds. You noticed, you know, when we've been riding together, I've been looking, you're smart. You've seen me look at the birds every time we're driving.

Of course we do. Yep. So I finally got down there. And I looked at the sunset and I looked at the birds and I took some pictures.

And I thought to myself, why the heck have I not done this more? I live here, but I've been inside all this time. Do I really have it better? And so that's another thing that makes me think of.

You got these guys on the beach with their bows and arrows and their spears. I think it's pretty cool. You know, because there's something about stepping on the riverbank next to a mussel shell that's been opened by a bird and the mussel's been eaten out and just watching that or something cool about that. And I feel like I've gone too far.

I feel like I have once the word. I feel like I'm very self-centered and I think that my world is extremely important sometimes and it's really not. Am I making any sense at all? Massive amounts of sense.

I live somewhere beautiful too. I picked it. It was on purpose. The last two places I've lived are the two most magical places that I could ever imagine when I was a kid.

Yellowstone National Park and the Black Hills of South Dakota. Those are the places that inspired all my curiosity and interest. This is what my child-like image of draw a mountain would look like, draw nature. I would just draw a kid version of those two places.

I love them. And this stretch that I've been in, you know, I've been going pretty hard working on some stuff for various projects and really pushing things, YouTube and podcasting. Plus work and I'm down there in my basement and I'm going to hit phones on so I can't hear things and other people are doing so I'll get interrupted and I stare at that glowing rectangle and I stare and I stare and I read some books and then I talk into a mic and then I stare at the rectangle and then I read some books and then I talk into a mic. Days will go by.

I'm like, what are you doing, dude? You moved here because of the beauty that's right outside your window and you keep that window closed so the glare doesn't cause problems on your precious glowing rectangle. And then I will just blow things off. On zero notice, I'll even tap out of an appointment if I have to and I will get in my vehicle and I will go be with the fish in the mountains.

It's this abrupt kind of, no, I have to address this now. It can't be, I need to reconnect with this someday and make a new habit. I have to go now when that impulsates me. Am I understanding you?

I think so. I think so, which is why I think that it's important to get more in touch with that side, which is why what I'm going to do now is I'm going to take this water bottle. I hated that and I'm going to cut the end of it off here and I may do a penis cord. Thanks for picking a two-liter.

French Your Way Jessica: Native French teacher founder of French Your Way Boost your French listening skills and test your comprehension with this one of a kind series of podcasts. Get the chance to listen to a real conversation between native speakers talking at normal speed AND customise your learning experience through carefully designed sets of questions (2 levels of difficulty) available for download at www.frenchvoicespodcast.com. All interviews also come with the transcript. French teacher Jessica interviews native speakers of French from around the world who share a bit of their life and passion. Where else would you meet in one same place a French yoga teacher based in Melbourne, a soap manufacturer from Provence, or a couple cycling around the world? The Course Mentors Podcast The Course Mentors Hey there, future course creator! Ever feel like turning your know-how into an online course is like trying to solve a Rubik's cube blindfolded? Well, grab your headphones because "The Course Mentors Podcast" is here to be your secret weapon! Meet Aimee and Odette (that's us!), your new best friends in the course creation world. We've been in the trenches for over a decade, and for the last five years, we've been rocking the online course space. Now we're here to spill all our secrets in bite-sized, 15-20 minute episodes that'll fit perfectly in your coffee breaks. No fluff, no filler - just real, actionable advice that'll take you from "um, what's a landing page?" to "holy moly, I just hit six figures!". We're talking everything from crafting your course to marketing it like a pro and building a business that'll have you pinching yourself. Whether you're dreaming of ditching the 9-to-5 grind, adding a sweet extra income str

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 24 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on May 1, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.