Skip to content
161 - How to Make Two Bullets Collide in Midair episode artwork

Jul 13, 2023 1 hr 20 min

161 - How to Make Two Bullets Collide in Midair

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: RAYCON STUFF IN THIS EPISODE: Smarter Every Day - Bullets HITTING Bullets Two Bullets That Met in Mid Air Magnus Effect Kalman Filter Sear Mechanism Radiometer Harold Edgerton CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

161 - How to Make Two Bullets Collide in Midair

0:00 1:20:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Here's the situation. We're in Rapid City, South Dakota. We're in my basement. We're hanging out.

You have been busting your butt for two days, slaving over the computer to finish line something really awesome. And you finally got to push it over the finish line this morning. This big deal, a lot of people helped you with it. You started talking about this ages ago.

I couldn't tell you how long. You've been talking about this video, thinking about this video since forever. And today you published it, so congratulations. Thank you.

Brilliant. The task you were trying to achieve in this video is very simple. You're trying to take two things that are incredibly precise and small and targeted and make them be in the exact same place at the exact same time. Yeah.

And that just doesn't naturally happen. And I've watched you when I've been in Alabama. I've watched you have your friends over. You've got elaborate things set up in front of you with clocks and levers and machines and cranks and steam and maybe not those things.

But it's elaborate. The workshop that I've seen you goofing around with in the tweaks and everything that you've been making for years while you finally published the video. So you made two bullets hit in mid-air. Dude, it was awesome.

And we, it was several of us. We've been working on it for a really, really long time. We're very, very excited that it happened. Also, I will give you a comment.

The plan will show up in Rapid City. Got about three days. We're going to hang out. We're going to do some fish in.

We're going to do some stuff. We're going to record a couple of podcasts. And I've stayed up to like 3 AM for two and a half nights. And I've burned through a lot of our time because of the rendering problems that we've had.

And you've been very, very patient. I haven't felt like you were pressuring me. Because I guess number one, you get it. You understand what I'm doing.

Number two, you understand how important this particular video was me. And so I would just like to say thank you. First of all, forgive me for that. That's what nothing to forgive.

Secondly, I appreciate your patience with me. Because it's been frustrating for me. And by proxy, I know it's probably been frustrating to you. But you've done a good job of not even showing that.

Not showing it because I'm not feeling it. So the timing just happened to work out. That this is when it got toward the finish line. Camilla and I were working on plans for dinner or whatnot.

She's like, what's Destin doing? Is he hungry? Yeah, he's having rendering problems. He's working something out.

He said it'd be about half an hour. And she said, so three days? Yes. Matt, you have to understand that anytime you say half an hour, we automatically triple it and then triple that.

Yeah, I know. So the reason it's easy to be patient is one, because I do the same job as you just worse. Two. It's because I mean, this is a school of videos that sit the internet in forever.

It's legitimately a remarkable achievement. There's a lot of people I know on the internet and root for it on the internet. If they make something I know they worked hard on, I'm going to watch it because I care about them. And the video's pretty interesting.

This is a showstopper. Well, it's an amazing achievement. For me and my buddies, so let me just say, David Linderman, who's a gentleman that goes to church with me is very intelligent individual. And we spent a lot of time working on this together.

He, much like you were patient with me and doing this, David was patient with me on the mechanical side. Because I started talking about this five years ago. No, five and a half years ago. I've had this idea for a long time.

The technology involved in doing this is something that I did in the early to mid 2000s on something else I did. It's been in my head for a while, but five and a half years ago, I realized, oh, I know how to do it. Like I know how to do it. You know what you're like going to bed at night and you just kind of like, you're falling asleep and you're like, oh wow.

And then your mind just, yep. Everything clicks into place and you get the perfect four lines and tetras and whatever the thing is. What do I do? Yeah, so that happened.

And I was like, whoa. Not only can this happen, it will happen. And this is how it will happen. It's been a thing I've been slow rolling in the back of my mind for years because I wanted it to be done right.

And so I got several people involved. My buddy Ernie, who was in the Navy back in the 80s and he's really good at circuitry and stuff. Jeremy Fielding, dear friend to both of us, who's really good at mechanical design. He designed a critical element of this and David.

And so we all worked together on it and it was just a blast, man. Or actually it was two blasts. Ah, yeah. That's too much you did.

Anyway, I'm excited about it. So thanks for the mental high five that you're giving here. I appreciate that. It's very much an us and we thing and it was a team effort and George as well.

We had a very, very tight window to get this done about the size of a bullet. Well, there's that, just the physical things about it. But there's also, when you do videos on YouTube, it's weird because you have all these external pressures that a lot of people don't think about. And we had a time commitment that we had to, hey, in order for this to work, you have to do it in a certain time.

Right. And you can't afford to make the video sometimes. Right. When it's an expensive video to make that requires equipment and help and time, you can't afford to make it without having a really good and committed partner to help make it happen.

But also they have pressures and times of year that things need to happen and deadlines for when things need to come out. And so I'm sure it looks to an outsider like people like you who make awesome videos. Just do it and you just get to it when you get to it. But you're not as in control as that.

There really is a window. And if this project is gonna happen, it has to be now and it has to be by this point. And so the reason I asked you to walk in here and turn on mics without really knowing what I wanted to talk about was because you are in that place where the baby is born. You did it.

We did it. You got it done. A big thing that George did for example, this is how weird it got towards the end. We were waiting on weather.

So first of all, we have to do it in spring or the summer because we have to have light for the high speed cameras. We've had the hardware for ages and we just couldn't do it. We were just waiting on the right major logical conditions. And then we wanted to do it early in the month and then we got a week of rain and you're like, okay, well, I can't do it then.

Then five day forecast comes up and it's like, okay, looks like we got a window. And then the man thing got it wrong. And so we had one day of sunlight and the rest was rain that week. And so the following week was like, all right, we'll do or die.

And so we went out every day, David and I, and we worked on it every single day. We filmed a ton of stuff. I was processing high speed camera data, which in itself takes a long time to do. And then I would run back at night to the computer and I would start uploading.

And then George would take all of that mountain of data, imagine five cameras running six hours a day. You have a terrible day to every day. And it occurs to me, the third chairman, I know who George is. George is our mutual, very good friend, former Hollywood producer, comedian, storyteller, just a good, honorable man across the board.

There are people you meet who choose the right thing every time, even if people aren't watching. And he got a great upbringing from his parents. His dad was a judge, a federal judge, who had a very clear sense of integrity in that role and passed it along to his kid. This would be clear, George is not just some guy.

He works with me, it's smarter every day. He's, yeah, so. He's important to both of us. Yeah, absolutely on a personal and a professional level.

But one thing he does is the best idea wins. And so it's important to surround yourself with good sounding boards that are morally aligned. And it's also important to surround yourself with people that will tell you no. And he's one of those people.

And we knew each other as friends long before we ever started working together. And in fact, I met George in a very similar way to how you and I met. We saw what each other was doing on the internet and we had a conversation and we're like, you know what, as an adult, I'm going to decide to be your friend. Yeah, you know, I have a friend slot currently.

Yeah, exactly, hey, that sounds funny, but I think it's important to identify when you have a friend slot and figure out who you wanna plug into that. We are nowhere near done with the bullet conversation, but I wanna pull on that thread just a little bit. How do you know when you have a friend slot? Wow, that's a great question.

I don't know what your answer to that. Like right now, like this phase in life, we both have children and the fuses burning and we have a limited amount of time left. We're counting summers that we have left with certain children. I remember walking into my friend's office one day.

He's about 10 years down the road from where I'm at. It's so smart to eight and 10 years. And I walked in the room, we were gonna jump on a call together to talk to some people or whatever. He's like, yeah, go and shut that door.

And I shut the door on the back of his door. There was, I don't remember if it was a dry race thing I guess in the Cindy Crawford Sports Show in 1988, Baking Suit, Coaster, that you won't have to buy at Walmart. No, that's not what's not was there. But it was almost like a vision board and he's more mature than I am just in all the ways.

And it said something like all his big projects that are his and I'm not gonna repeat what they are, but they're honorable and they're big, good things that make the world better. And then this word and then it had time and like the key items, this word and all this. And then it just said kids and it said six years. And I looked at that and I said, what is this?

And we were supposed to talk about something else. Oh, that's how many years I have left with them and under my roof. And I said, that's a big deal and I had never thought that way. It simultaneously hurt and also motivated me to be like, man.

And so right now, friend slots are precious and don't really have any because like you and I were talking the Deepwater last night when we had an option to turn on microphones and we decided not to because we need to catch up on personal things in each other's lives. Those friend slots just don't exist at the moment. I kind of stole your thunder because you kind of said that yesterday, you know, we were talking about intentional relationships and you were like, I'm gonna plug in all the time I can with kiddos. And so I guess that's how I know I have an open friend slot.

How do you know if I've got windshield time and I got nobody to call if you're traveling, a couple other friends are busy and I'm driving along and I got but I have 20 minutes. I should use this time. That's so right. That is so right.

What a hollow feeling when you just look at your phone and you kind of scroll through your speed dial. No, I can't. Another busy there. Oh, I guess it's just me.

I guess I'll just think about some things. I wonder if introverts feel this as well or if it's just us the extroverts that I'm an introvert. You're not an introvert, man. Matt, you're the least introverted person.

I know you're the least introverted person. Your face is the least introverted person. I knew it was going to happen eventually. OK, all right.

I'm not as extroverted as I maybe once was. I will say that. I am able to appreciate time by myself more than I used to. But I think about those friend slots, those inventory slots.

What a way to dehumanize my friends. But you know what I mean? Yeah, at times you got room and the rhythm can change from time to time in terms of just who you have a project going with or whatever and some friends kind of come and go out of your life a little bit because of circumstances. Then some others are just sort of permanent.

They're on the windshield time dial list automatically. Yeah, OK, the point is all these people in your life are awesome and I respect you for giving a mountain of credit to everyone else. What are you talking about in the video? Yeah, and it's true.

You're not just blowing smoke or trying to deflect. All those people really did contribute hugely. I watched it happen. This episode of No Dumb Questions is brought to you by Raycon, who makes earbuds that we both use all the time and like a ton and they've been a friend of the show forever.

Destin, what do you like about Raycons? Raycon, they're simple. Stick them in your pocket. It's like a little pill.

Got two earbuds in it and carry it everywhere with you. It's like an everyday kind of carriic thing. They just do what they're supposed to do. Low profile in the pocket.

They're very cost effective. I think it's great to have them. I got one of my daily carry sets of Raycons right here. This is the blue one.

In my phone in the Bluetooth list, this is labeled blue Raycons because of the color. And this is what it sounds like when you hold that Raycon pill. What? Am I supposed to be able to hear that?

No, I couldn't hear it. Let me hold it louder. Okay. I can't hear that, Matt.

Well, I'm moving it in my hands so my hands when they interact with plastic taste. Listen harder. I'm listening. Oh, yeah, yeah, the holding.

Yeah, that's what I hear. The problem I have with Raycons and I do have a problem. I know. My problem with Raycons is that my family steals them.

I have them and I put them on my, like, right there on my sink in the bathroom and then they go away and I'm supposed to go back and get them and they're not there. And that's a problem. So the only solution is to go to buy Raycon.com slash in DQ and in DQ listeners can get 15% off their Raycon order. So just go get whatever you want by Raycon.com slash in DQ get 15% off.

Okay. I a moment ago suggested that you were being amateurish for not hearing me holding the Raycon case and that this was your first time. And then you made that glorious, beautiful segue. I know.

I mean, I can't ask for better. I think it's why people are here. I'm insane. I'm humbled and I apologize for my earlier criticism.

Wait, you get this. I'm going to tell you some of the perks of Raycons. They have a 32 hour battery life, including eight hours of playtime. So you can get to listen to what you want when you want for a really long time to have custom gel tips for your ear hole size.

That's my favorite part because it's fun to talk about people's ear holes. And then, yeah, they start out about half the prices of the premium audio brands, but they sound just as good. That's 50%. What?

Yeah. 50%. That's half the price. That's math.

And they also come with a 45 day happiness guarantee. So you can't lose. You just try it out. If you don't like it, be like, Hey, I didn't like it.

So you can create your own soundtrack with Raycon right now, NDQ listeners, which includes you and me because I listened to this podcast, we can get 15% off our Raycon order at by Raycon.com slash NDQ. That's by Raycon.com slash NDQ to say 15% on Raycons. And then just the last bullet point here in the talking points that Raycon has provided us is Destin sings the Raycon jingle. Nope, it doesn't say that.

It doesn't say that. We might have different scrolling. It doesn't say that. I mean, it's all right.

That's by Raycon.com slash NDQ. They're like, you're not looking closely. But I want to get to the heart of the matter, which is you figured out a way to make two bullets hit each other in midair and film the collision. I guess my question is, how does one do that?

So the trick is, so it's all a timing thing. I mean, the alignment is easy. You can accomplish a tremendous amount with Reddit fasteners and just bolts and screws and creating things that can pivot and you can adjust it in fine ways. That's how you do the alignment of the barrels.

But the timing is the trick, actually. So there's this thing that all weapons have. It's called lock time. And let's say you have a revolver, easiest thing to conceptualize.

And let's say you a revolver, just for people who aren't into guns at all. We're talking about a handgun. This is what you see a cowboy have and like, you know, two little spinny cylinder right there in the middle of the gun. You know, I fire five shots with six shots.

It's the spinny kind. So we usually have a hammer. Let's just go to why a revolver exists. Okay.

This is interesting. I had a friend named Wally who had an old Navy pistol. And so if you think back to the Civil War, the action was what we brass cartridge technology for bullets had not been developed. So the bullet is the part up front that's either copper or gray lead, right?

That's part of the flies. That's part of the flies and the brass part in the back, the yellowish metal part. That's the part that contains the powder. And what do we call that part?

The cartridge. Okay. So we have a primer and the primer is usually a it's got a chemical in it. I want to say lids, the hyphenate.

I don't know what it is. That sounded like chemistry. That sounded like chemistry. I don't know.

It's something. No mercury fulminate. I thought it might be sodium glutamate. That sounded like chemistry.

Is it mercury? What is it? That's also chemistry. Anyway, it's a chemical.

Okay. So you got this chemical in the back in this little metal cup. It is sensitive to shock and friction and heat. And if it hits a certain value of all those things, it'll explode.

It'll detonate. Is that detonation? What projects the bullet? Or is that lighting something else on fire?

Yeah, that lights something else. That's the thing that lights the gunpowder most often. So there's three stages here. The initial ignition, which is a detonation.

It's a supersonic burning. This is important. So that's a detonation. Okay.

The powder burning on the inside of the cartridge is a deflagration. That is a subsonic burning of the powder. Okay. And then that creates a pressure.

Super sonic, not all the time, but in some cases a supersonic projectile. Okay. And yeah, depending on the design of the barrel, the barrel link, the chamber pressure and a lot of stuff. The amount of explosive.

Yeah. Yeah, a lot of stuff. I'm excited about how to do this. We're like, okay, well, what we're ultimately trying to do is replicate two bullets that hit each other in Fredericksburg in December, 1862.

What was going on in Fredericksburg in December of 1862? It's 1862 or 1963. I don't remember giving me grace on that. I don't have a quick opinion in front of me.

But the United States Civil War. And so you had two sides that were going at each other and there were a lot of people shooting rifles at each other really, really fast. What's interesting about that is somewhere on that battlefield, a Yankee soldier and a rebel soldier were on two sides of a field and they shot at each other. And the bullets that they fired traveled across the field toward each other and they hit nose to nose somewhere on that battlefield.

That's a metaphor for the Civil War. It is. It's like when an unstoppable force hits an unstoppable force, they hit each other and they created a plane, an intercept plane that happened. And so you have this axial bullet flying along its flight axis and another one flying in the other direction and when they hit nose to nose, the momentum equation balances and they stop.

They stop each other. So I'm to believe that that that display that I've seen a video that you shot that display with the bullet kind of in the other bullet is reflective of something where two bullets came right at each other. They hit and they just dropped to the ground. They nullified the momentum of each other equally or close to equally.

I don't know. I thought about that. Well, that's the way people think it happened. But here's another interesting thing.

Some time in the future from 1862 to 1863, I'd really like to know the answer to that. I've got it in the video. Do you mind looking that up? Not a problem.

Somewhere in the future, there was a person. They were probably a hobbyist or maybe they were a professional archeologist. They were running over that battlefield and they were either just maybe the field was plowed up for a farmer and a person was walking the field looking for artifacts and bullets. I found arrowheads when I was younger down by the Tennessee River when the farmers would plow the fields.

That's when you go walk and look for arrowheads and sometimes you find them. Was it a 63 or 63? Right at the end of 62. December 1862, which means I mean early part of the Civil War, either way, early part of the Civil War, though, in Fredericksburg, Virginia.

So the thought is this person found these bullets and they're like, oh, wow, look at this. And they're like, this is two bullets. If you look here, there's a back of a bullet on one side and there's a back of a bullet on the other side and there seems to be a plane where they mushroom against each other and they spread out. That's incredible.

My brain instantly imagines what that dynamic event was like. It plays it out. It says, okay, well, there was a person with a rifle on this side and a person with a rifle on that side, both with dreams and ambitions and parents and they fired at each other and those bullets hit and the bullet didn't go to where it was trying to go. It stopped right there.

And so, you know, there's another part of your brain that plays out. Wow. What happened because those bullets hit and didn't go to their intended target? You know, that's interesting.

Yeah. And to be clear, you've spent a lot of time working on defensive systems when it comes to ballistics, weaponry, et cetera. Where would you rank on a scale of let's say zero to a hundred as a defensive strategy for when bullets are being shot at you, just trying to shoot the bullets down with another bullet before it hits you? You know what you just asked me and you know, you know, there's stuff I haven't told you.

Yeah. Well, I'll never tell you. I got stuff I haven't told you before. Yeah.

Yeah. How about that? I kissed this one girl in 10th grade. Yeah.

And I did not like her anymore after that. Really? Yeah. So I got stuff I don't tell you to is the point.

Oh, I got stuff that's classified. It's really interesting. That question is really, really interesting because when you pull the trigger on a rifle, it starts to fly. It's on a ballistic trajectory.

And so what that means is you have to detect the launch of the other projectile. And you have to track it and calculate its future trajectory. Mm hmm. Because bullets don't just go online.

They don't like lasers. No, they don't. Not like they do in Star Wars. Is it just because of gravity and wind?

Well, air resistance. Yeah. Drag. There's all kinds of other things like the fact that the bullet is spinning matters because the Magnus effect comes into play and the bullet will fall in a certain direction.

There's so much to send it like Barrett. Yeah. Beckett. Well, I was just switching it over to a gun reference.

Oh, I see. That's good. So it's very interesting to think about all that. And then let's say you're able to calculate where that bullet is at with perfect knowledge and you're able to calculate the last 10 milliseconds of where that bullet is.

And if it was a supersonic bullet, I just remember speed of sound is about a foot per millisecond. And that's a really good back of the envelope kind of thing. So if you had 10 milliseconds of data, you'd have 10 feet of flight tracking, you would then say, okay, well, I have a ballistic device on my end. I get to choose where I point it and I get to choose when I ignite it.

A hyper accurate late 1850s model muzzle loading rifle. Right. Yep. Hyper reliable.

Exactly. So if I was going to track something in flight, let's make it easier. Let's say it's a mortar. Okay.

A mortar that goes up up and then falls down on you and it goes to terminal velocity as it's falling. So you have to figure out where it is and then you have to calculate where it's going to be. And in that equation, you have to say, well, it takes my thing X amount of milliseconds to get from here to there because it flies at a certain velocity. Oh, by the way, that's not a constant velocity.

That's a decreasing velocity because of drag. So I have to say, well, if I point it here, I can shoot now, but if I wasn't able to get the shot off, I can point over here and anticipate it being there, but I'm not going to slow my bullet down. So you have to anticipate all these things. There's a fancy pants math thing called a Kalman filter.

Oh, and a Kalman filter uses past data or data you know about a system to predict what you're going to do in the future. This is how wars are fault. It's also how I catch footballs when they're thrown at me. I can run this algorithm.

Yeah. Just there's a certain speed at which my on the fly calculations can't keep up too much data too fast and I just can't run that. It's why I don't know about now, but it's why steadily I could hit a ball in the upper 80s if it didn't have too much movement on it, playing baseball. And if I knew that a guy was just grooving pitches in the low 90s, I faced that and I could put a bat on that consistently.

When that guy moved his finger, facing a major leaguer in this particular batting cage session, when he moved his finger a little bit off of the seams and put the tiniest bit of cut on that low 90s fastball. I hadn't seen anything like that before. No chance exceeded my calculation speed. I simply could not make the bat that I was throwing in a sense at that position that I was anticipating the ball being at.

It broke my calculator. I love the way you said that because the beautiful thing about swinging a bat is you're defining a plane and you have a pie shaped piece of space that the bat can occupy in the amount of time it takes for the baseball to traverse the plate. Okay. That's a fun thought.

I've never thought about that. The way you just said that. That's great. Thank you for that.

Well, it's just one of those things where we all do this thing you're describing with mortars and with running this Kalman filter. Kalman filter. You do it at a very basic slow level and the stuff you're talking about grossly exceeds our ability to calculate and the idea. You and brains are great at this.

They are great at this. I'm going to throw this at your face right now. Why would you do that? I'm getting that.

I'm either trying to knock that all the way across the room. No. I'm going to wag over me wagging my face. I mean, you asked for it.

You threw a thing at me and now it's over there. So that's interesting that you were able to calculate that. But in this particular case, we wanted to figure out how to hit a bullet with a bullet. And so what do you do?

You start systematically eliminating every variable. We wanted to fly in a straight of a line as possible. And that had been a bit, if we can create symmetry, then the math gets even easier. So if you want to smash a bullet into a bullet and you want it to fly into as straight a line as possible, there are two things you can do.

One, you can shoot the bullets harder so that they maintain their forward velocity without degradation on that flight path longer or two. You can shoot the bullets slower, but move the two firearms closer. Yeah, that's a great point. And so we wanted it to be in free space.

We wanted the bullet intercept to be out in the middle of something. So I bought an I-beam. Okay. It's about 12 feet long.

Apple makes those? No. And so you've got a little percussion primer, meaning you hit it percussively and it explodes. They didn't have that in a cartridge.

What they had is probably a muzzle loading rifle. Like the one behind you on the wall. That's exactly that rifle. Go grab it.

Oh, yeah. Okay. What you have there is Johnny Bannon's rifle. That's the one that my grandfather, the marksmanship instructor, who really taught people how to shoot for years and years here at the base, Elsworth Air Force Base, where we're right next to you here in South Dakota.

That is the rifle that he learned to shoot on in Bannon's Hauler, Iowa. Johnny Bannon, for whom Bannon's Hauler was or is named, showed him how to shoot on that. And that is a civil war era design. I think the rifle itself was manufactured just a little bit after the civil war.

It's beautiful. What's interesting about it is there's no breach. Right. Like you don't put the bullet in the back.

Right. Like on an AR-15, you pull the bolt back and you put a bullet in there. This is like a long pipe that's closed on the backside. Mm-hmm.

I don't know if the ramrod will come out. Okay. I just want, I let you don't do it. It's old wood.

But describe what you were reaching for. So the ramrod is underneath the barrel. And so you pull the ramrod out. And so what you do is, this is like a pipe with only one end open.

That's the barrel. And so what you do is you take your gunpowder in the civil war. They had paper cartridges. And so you have this, it looks kind of like a half a cigar.

And so you have a lead bullet, then you have some paper and then you have the gunpowder all wrapped in one little, that was a cartridge then. And so you take out that cartridge and you take your teeth and you bite off the end of the paper and then you point this barrel to the sky. Mm-hmm. And then you pour that gunpowder down the end of the barrel and then you take some of that paper and you shove it down in there on top of the powder.

Okay. And then you can tamp that down into the way back here in the back of the barrel and do they put the bullet in first before they tamp it with the ramrod or they do it. My understanding is they did. Okay.

So I bet it's my understanding. But sometimes what they did is they put beeswax on the bullets too. So you get a good seal in the bore of the rifle. I've wondered about that.

Yeah. What's really cool is, so you got this and way back here at the back of the rifle, there's this mechanism and I'm going to cock it now. And then I'm going to pull the trigger. Is this unloaded?

It is unloaded and has been for several generations. Also I can tell that there's not an issue here because this little part right here, there's a nipple on the back that is like a little bit of hole that's drilled into the base of that powder. And if I was about to try to fire this thing, what I would do is I would kind of poke a little piece of wire in there to make sure I had a clear path to the powder. And then I would put a percussion cap over that nipple with that mercury fulminator.

I'm wondering if lead siphonate was the tracer stuff. But mono sodium glutamate? Shut up. So we have to by the end of this episode, we have to know what chemical percussion primers are.

Anyway, you put the little percussion cap on there and then when you pull the trigger, this hammer falls and hits that nipple. Like so. I'm so glad that didn't fire. Yeah.

I would have just hated that. That would have been the most embarrassing thing ever. And I wouldn't have edited that. I would have turned this into an episode about guns safety.

Yeah. So it's really neat. This is a really neat rifle. I've never had one.

Do you know what type of rifle this is? I don't know. It's great compared to rifles like this. I've seen the Enfield rifle.

I don't know. It's amazing though. It's beautiful. That Yankee and that Rebel when they were firing at each other, they each did that.

And if you can imagine there's a spring on the other side of this hammer when I cock that thing and pull it, that spring has to accelerate the hammer and the hammer has to go fall and boom land right there against that percussion cap and that takes time. If a bullet travels 10 beat and 10 milliseconds and it takes that hammer 40 milliseconds to fall or 10 milliseconds to fall, whatever it is, the amount of time it takes for that hammer to fall is important. And that's called the lock time. Didn't know there was a term for that.

And then the amount of time it takes once the primer is struck and the burning process starts, you get the detonation and the deflagration and the pressurization of the barrel that starts pushing the bullet down. And if you think about it, the volume of that burning is changing as it moves down the barrel. All that is called the bullet dwell time, the amount of time that it takes for the first spark to happen to when the bullet exits the barrel. Okay, so we're active, but we're not out of the barrel yet.

That's the bullet dwell time. Bullet dwell time. Okay. Yeah.

So you've got a lot of time and you've got bullet dwell time, block time typically around 10 milliseconds. Bullet dwell time depending on the powder, depending on all the things, you know, you're looking at like more like a millisecond and a half. So one, one and a half thousandths, the H of a second. So super hard to dodge.

Yeah. Yeah, it is. All that being said, in our problem, if we were to try to shoot a bullet with a bullet with revolvers, for example, that's difficult because that lock time is not predictable because friction and it's different every time. The aha moment was, oh, wow, we can't shoot at the same time.

I think Adam Savage and Jamie, if Mythbusters, they tried this a while back. I did not watch the entire episode, but I remember a scene of them having a pistol and they had some way of pulling the trigger. I think it was a string. I don't remember exactly how the rest of it went down, but Adam's great.

Adam's great. Adam's an awesome, awesome dude. I had a chance to chat with him recently at an event and he was very charitable with his time. That's it.

The lock time is the issue. It's not repeatable. And if you had a way of deleting the lock time from all the equations, the math problem would simplify. And that's what we did.

Let's let that question hang there for one second. I see the conundrum. You've done a great job of explaining it. And I'll admit I did not initially see the conundrum.

It will just pull the triggers at the same time. Clearly, you can't just grab it with your hand or both hands and be like, all right, we're going to try to tap it and type it with your brain. You're telling me that even if you could do that in a way that was safe and you can't, even if you physically pulled both triggers at once, the specificity of time we're talking about here, microseconds, it's not going to be uniform. Even with your brain physically controlling your fingers, you won't get it quite right.

What would be interesting is if you took your fingers, like you were just trying to pull your, you had to imagine your pencils in your hands, you were trying to pull the triggers at the same time of the trigger finger, what would be interesting is to take your two fingers and try to tap them on a table at the exact same time, three, two, one. That sounded like the same time. I think it's a rhythm question. My friend Jeff, who does all the music for the daily, the TMBA, the TMDH, Temitive Bible Hour podcast, he's ridiculous.

He's awareness of tempo and his fine muscle control. That's not natural. What he's able to do. My guess would be that if we got out the phantom and we did a synchronization of both hands competition between Jeff and somebody who's a musical hack, Jeff would annihilate them and we would see it in super slow motion that his taps would indeed be synchronized.

And the other person, I think would have trouble syncing up their two hands to the same degree. But it's an interesting problem, right? Because it's an interesting problem. Because it's, it's a distance thing.

Like, where does the contact between the drums thick and the drum head actually happen? In the drum problem, that's very interesting because that gets into the vibration of the drum head itself. It's in different places depending on where it is in the amplitude and if it's a bass drum versus if it's a snare drum, that's interesting. Never thought about that before.

Well, even what we were talking about years ago in terms of how a snap happens, the actual sound of the snap occurs after the friction is released. All that kinetic energy built up is now free to fly becomes or the potential energy that becomes kinetic. And it's when you hit the fat part of your thumb. So I think I can make these snaps match.

I could actually hear that it wasn't. That's not a match. Wow. I was like a hundred milliseconds off.

Yeah. That was pretty close. That's very hard. That's a great illustration because most firearms have a device called a seer mechanism in them.

And so what the sear is, can you spell that? S-E-A-R-S-E-R. Okay. I think, man, you got me questioning everything today.

Just like on snapping your finger. Man, it's a great explanation, man. I appreciate this helping me. The fact that you don't really know when your finger is going to break friction with your thumb and start accelerating towards the fat of your hand, the sear is the same way.

You don't really know where the sear is going to quit. Imagine trying to slide, like you have a pencil and you're moving it off a table. When does it actually break free of contact and start moving? So that matters depending on if there was a little piece of dust in the sear mechanism between one shot and the next is, you know, the heat is going to change the timing because the sear, Paul itself or whatever, the word of it, if it's hotter, it's going to be longer because of writing.

I mean, there's so many things that go into that and yeah, it's fascinating. So you had to figure out a way, okay, still the conundrum is set up really well. I am super understanding that and intuitively without just thinking about it. I'd be like, well, how would you do this thing?

We just pull the triggers the same time. Like I don't get some string or something. Yeah. And then just be like, one, okay, wait, are we going to pull it on three or where four would be?

Okay. Let's go where four would be. Okay. Ready?

One, two, three, go. And I would think you could get pretty close with that. But I understand as we think about snapping, as we think about double tapping on the desk, drumming, I understand why, no, that's not, I mean, at the level of specificity and precision, we need that's not good enough. So, so let's say we wanted to put a solenoid on those triggers, like a little, you know, a electromagnetic coil that pulls the trigger because our fingers just can't be repeatable enough.

Sure. Would you want it to be like a really strong coil, like something you plug into the wall or would you want it to be something you run off batteries? I don't know which better achieves this. But I would want is something that has a very predictable breaking point.

You want batteries. And the reason you want batteries is because the AC power that's coming out of that wall right there has a 60 Hertz cycle. There's a sine wave going up and down and up and down and up and down. And depending on if you trigger it at the top of that wave or at the nodal point where there's literally no voltage or the bottom of that wave, there's a 16.67 millisecond variance.

That's way too much. That's way too much. That's way too much. At 16 feet if you're super sauna.

And so you can't use AC power. That's out the door. You have to use DC power. What kind of solid state electronics do you want to use?

Because we want to get things that trigger at the same time, right? Or we're going to use solid state or we're going to use relays, like clicking relays. No, you're going to use solid state electronics, right? And so all this stuff matters.

And the threshold voltages on certain pieces of silicon can matter. It depends on what you're doing. There's things that have to happen. Like imagine these collisions that they do in these particle accelerators.

Non exaggeration like femtoseconds matters. I've never even heard that term. So my brain thinks in because of working with timing of stuff like this for weapons and stuff, I have a fundamental unit of time in my head. And it's not seconds.

It's not minutes. It's not hours. It's milliseconds. And I even think in microseconds as well, I don't think in microseconds.

You want to show what I'm trying to say, right? I think in one 29 point something. Oh, the second. Do you know why?

Brain rate of a camera. That's exactly it. Yeah. Yeah.

I used to think in seconds. Now I think in roughly one 30th of a second for how I want to what I control what I do. For example, if you're bit rate, it's okay. People don't know what this means.

But it's just the bit rate in which your audio was encoded on your camera, which has your just clumsy camera microphone on it. It's not going to sound good, but it's just giving you a comparable audio. And you record say on the equipment we're recording on right now, these road microphones. You still do up to like 192?

192? 192? Killer? 150.

Yes, at least more than that. Yeah. But if the bit rate is just slightly different, then what happens is you get audio drift over the course of syncing the audio to the video. So your audio source is separate.

You put it together. It sounds fine at first. But you'll notice an hour into a file. Oh, this sounds terrible.

You actually go in when it sounds wrong to your ear and you go all the way down to a single frame view, your tightest view in a sequence and editing window. You know this. Actual issue is one-thirtyth of a frame. One-thirtyth of a second is the issue that you're actually contending with.

It just makes the audio insufferably echoey. You can hear it. Your brain knows it's not synced at eight milliseconds. It's the point.

Makes you angry. Yeah, it makes you angry. It doesn't. It's not angry.

There's a video I have on the channel right now that I know it was wrong and it bothers me. I want to be able to fix it if I can't. All these things add up and they matter. Yeah.

So this percussion primer becomes the issue. It's the striking of the percussion primer that's the issue because it even gets more interesting there. So when you start with percussion primers, the threshold of mechanical deformation required to trigger the chemical would matter. Meaning the moment the hammer starts to hit the percussion primer, it has to crush it and move it into the chemical in order to create the friction required.

It might deform at a different rate than the opposite cartridge. Yes. Depending on the day it was formed, depending on the alloy of brass. How much air?

There was the mixture and the pour. The stoichiometry. Wow. All the day that it was made, all that stuff matters.

It's super cool. And so anyway, you got to think about all kinds of things you don't normally think about. And then you start going through and you do a time budget and you're like, okay, well, this, there's my tolerance stack up. I could be off by five microseconds right there.

I could be off by whatever. My spring might not be repeatable. You know, all these different things. And so the answer, the obvious answer is get rid of all of the mechanical mechanisms that trigger that percussion primer.

There's a thing that's used now all the time in the Olympics. You mean human growth hormone? No. Oh, no, sorry.

Marksmanship in the Olympics often comes down to a shooter's ability to predict this lock time because if you think about holding a firearm, this gets even more interesting. A human holding a firearm, when you pull the trigger, every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction. The fact that you're moving a physical hammer into a firing pan means that the gun itself has to move in response to that. Yes.

So the heavier the gun, the lower the distance it will move in response to the acceleration of the hammer itself. Yes, I've seen tiktok videos of dudes handing their girlfriends a shotgun and they don't shoulder it. They're holding it above their shoulder and I'm thinking, oh, you're just not familiar with this principle yet. That gun has to go backwards after you pull that trigger.

I'm talking about even before you pull the trigger. Look at this rifle right here. I'm holding it. When I pull the trigger, you're talking about the action of the trigger that this hammer is moving forward and the trigger pull is moving backwards.

Well, there's that. What has to happen? There's a momentum thing that has to, so the gun has to physically move backwards or at least push backwards. Yeah, you can restrict that with resistance.

I would assume I would assume you could nullify that. Yes. Yes, you can if you have something rigid enough. So that's important, right?

Yeah. But in the Olympics, can you do that? No, you have to hold the gun. Sure.

French Your Way Jessica: Native French teacher founder of French Your Way Boost your French listening skills and test your comprehension with this one of a kind series of podcasts. Get the chance to listen to a real conversation between native speakers talking at normal speed AND customise your learning experience through carefully designed sets of questions (2 levels of difficulty) available for download at www.frenchvoicespodcast.com. All interviews also come with the transcript. French teacher Jessica interviews native speakers of French from around the world who share a bit of their life and passion. Where else would you meet in one same place a French yoga teacher based in Melbourne, a soap manufacturer from Provence, or a couple cycling around the world? The Course Mentors Podcast The Course Mentors Hey there, future course creator! Ever feel like turning your know-how into an online course is like trying to solve a Rubik's cube blindfolded? Well, grab your headphones because "The Course Mentors Podcast" is here to be your secret weapon! Meet Aimee and Odette (that's us!), your new best friends in the course creation world. We've been in the trenches for over a decade, and for the last five years, we've been rocking the online course space. Now we're here to spill all our secrets in bite-sized, 15-20 minute episodes that'll fit perfectly in your coffee breaks. No fluff, no filler - just real, actionable advice that'll take you from "um, what's a landing page?" to "holy moly, I just hit six figures!". We're talking everything from crafting your course to marketing it like a pro and building a business that'll have you pinching yourself. Whether you're dreaming of ditching the 9-to-5 grind, adding a sweet extra income str

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 20 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on July 13, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.