Hi, and welcome to Classical Stuff You Should Know, a podcast about classical education, old stuff, old books, the ancient world, and the not-so-ancient world, done by us, three guys who love it. My name is Graham Donaldson, and I'm joined with Thomas Megby and AJ Hanenberg, and we podcast about... Oh my word, we can do this, this is what we do. I just realized I was about to repeat everything I just said, and then we were going to cycle back there.
Do you have that happen when you teach where you say something, and then you say it again because I probably didn't get it the first time? Yeah. I notice myself repeating everything twice. The thing is, especially when you teach that class three times a day, you're like, did I say this already?
They're like, yeah, I'm sorry, kids. Do they only point out to you when you say it twice, in class? Usually I will, it's not necessarily saying the same thing twice, it's I will say something and then instantly rephrase it another way, because a lot of times they won't do it the first time. Anyway, so based on the notes, we're doing what looks like some sort of new Japanese video game.
Enchiridion! Yeah. Or an expansion of a current video game, I don't know, Final Fantasy 20, Enchiridion. Oh, that sounds like an actual thing.
That'd be fun. Yeah. So we are doing the Enchiridion. It is a, if you're a fan of Adventure Time, it's the manual for how to be a hero, but if you're not a fan of Adventure Time, cartoon?
You haven't seen Adventure Time? No, I'm an adult. Easy, easy, easy. Classic cartoon.
I'm just kidding. Wow. I'm sorry, I made fun of your cartoons. Wow.
Dark Souls. Dark Souls. That was a reference back to the September AMA we just recorded, for those of you who aren't privy, aren't in the know. Yeah, so the user question was, who has the darkest soul?
And Graham won, I think, with a resounding. Okay, so we're talking about Epictetus and his book, The Enchiridion. So let's talk a little bit about who Epictetus was, and then we'll get to the meat of the Enchiridion. So Epictetus was a fellow born between 50 and 60 AD, I think somewhere in Phrygia, and then eventually he made his way all the way to Rome.
We don't exactly know how he got there, but when he got there, he was a slave. Was his name just Titus and he did something amazing? And then he became Epictetus. Epictetus.
And then, so he was a slave to Emperor Nero's secretary, who was a, I think, yeah, like another free man, but I'm not too clear on the secretary status, but while he was there, he was a slave. And while in that guy's service, he took courses with a fashionable stoic, and everyone was so impressed with his engaging, dynamic personality as he was doing things. Eventually. Wait, slaves could take classes?
Apparently. I really think slavery was a different situation back then. And so he eventually became a free man, and then he started teaching philosophy on street corners in the marketplace with very little success. Just nobody was interested in the guy spouting out philosophy on the street corner.
Well, do you listen to the guy somewhere? Yeah. Yeah, but I mean, even though he thought there was a chance of it, I just feel like it's such a different world, right? That there was a market for people who were like, I'm teaching philosophy, and people were like, oh, really?
Which street corner will you be on? Yeah. I guess I'll stop going to the bakery and sit down and listen to you. Yeah, exactly.
I just, poof, the, different cultures, right? Different times. Is he the change my mind guy, like on the principal team? Oh, man.
I kind of hope so. That's probably more Diogenes. I get some Diogenes doing that. Okay, so he was eventually exiled under the reign of Emperor Domitian, along with a bunch of other philosophers between the years of 89 and 92 AD, and he went in his exile to a city named Nicopolis, clearly founded by Nick, where he founded himself a school, and his school gained such renown, and he gained such renown as a stoic philosopher, that Nicopolis became the place where Epictetus' school was more than anything else, right?
That's how his city got famous. There was another guy that was eventually consul named Flavius Arian, and Flavius Arian came to the school probably to be between 123 and 126. At this point, Epictetus is 60-some, 70-some years old, depending on when he was actually born. And so Epictetus is already an old man, and Flavius was enamored.
He loved this guy. Apparently, Epictetus was an extremely dynamic teacher, and he would tailor his discourses to the needs and concerns of his students, right? And so he wasn't just up there, and he would preach at Gen and leave. He had a wonderful back and forth, and Flavius was so enamored by this, that he is the guy who actually recorded everything.
So Epictetus' discourses are recorded by Flavius, as is the Enchiridion. It is a sort of a collection of Epictetus' sayings and teachings taken in shorthand by Flavius while he was there. So it's like lecture notes. Yeah, and I didn't know that shorthand was a thing back then.
How long has shorthand been around? Do you guys know? I have no idea. I'm out of genuine curiosity.
Have you ever seen anybody do shorthand or ever learned it yourself? I've not learned it. I've seen it. My grandma did it during sermons, and I had no idea why.
I was like, it's a circle-loopy thing. It's kind of neat. I think now that we have computers, people can just type so fast. Yeah, probably don't need it anymore.
Yeah. Okay, so the discourses of Epictetus, you can read those two. Those are also published, but they are more, again, about the dynamic teaching style of Epictetus than anything else, and they are having to do with the concerns of the students and all of his conversations with those kids, and that's not what we're focused on today. The Enchiridion is like a Stoic manual.
This is how to live as a Stoic, and it's kind of aimed at the already fairly initiated that wanted to go deeper into philosophy. It is short. It's only... It's like a how-to?
Yeah, kind of. It's just like, here's some basic precepts of Stoicism, and they're very simple. And one of the criticisms, I think, that's leveled at Epictetus is that he just wasn't that concerned with the physical world. He didn't talk a lot about the cosmos or cosmology, and he wasn't talking a lot about our physical makeup in the natural world.
So physics wasn't his jam. It's just moral philosophy. Here's how to live. And in that way, it seems almost kind of moralizing.
I've always sort of heard it presented almost like wisdom literature as opposed to philosophy. Yeah, I can see that. It's kind of close to maybe wisdom literature. Because it's a lot of little aphorisms.
But it's more specific than that, isn't it? I think wisdom literature, I think, kind of the vague. It's meant for really thinking about. Isn't this more of a do this, do this, do this?
Yeah, it's kind of a do this, do this. And apparently, he's one of the only three real surviving Stoic literature originals that we have. Apparently, the most respected Stoic, his big manual, kind of the standard that everybody went by back then, is gone. It's lost the time.
But we have three people, apparently. I forget the third, but Marcus Aurelius is one of them. The emperor. The emperor.
And Epictetus is another one. And then there's a third guy, I forget his name. But, so I'm bringing you this guy today, and I will hopefully continue on. All of this is stemming from a book I have called The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers, or something like that.
It's one of, it is our primary source for many of the philosophers that lived back then. It's a biography. So, for example, Diogenes. We don't actually have any of Diogenes' teaching.
I think the only source we have for him, really, is this, The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers. So I couldn't quite get an episode on Diogenes together for today, but, you know, look forward to that in the future, because I'll be referencing a lot. All we have with Diogenes is Twitter feuds. Yeah, and I want to do Epicurean as well, because the entire tenth book of The Lives and Opinions is dedicated to Epicurus.
Speaking of, those cookies you have are tasty. They're really good, right? Shout out to H-E-B Mochaccino Oreos. Keep doing your thing, H-E-B.
It's making tasty. Okay. I think Seneca's the third. Seneca?
That's right. All right, so today we're just going to go through this, through a few things in the short volume. There are 51 small divisions. They're kind of like moral precepts that you go with.
So I've taken a selection of these, and I can read them, and you can tell them what you think. In my reading, I have come to realize that I am a stoic. I think I adhere to many of these precepts, but I think there are some problems and some downfalls. Maybe you guys can point them out as we go.
Hopefully we won't get bored. But if you, a listener, really want to go about reading this, it's only going to take you, what, 45 minutes? Yeah. Maybe?
Something like that? After you left me to the Communist Manifesto, and this time you're doing the Incubitian, which is also very short, I think you're doing this podcast thing right. I need to pick shorter books is what I'm learning right now. I'm a busy guy.
You're a busy guy. You got a lot going on. Smart guy. Yeah.
Thanks. Okay, so the first couple of precepts, I feel like, kind of set the stage for all the others. So these ones are a little bit longer, especially this first one. I feel like all the other precepts kind of build on this one single idea.
So, precept number one. Let me get you in your opinions. There are things which are within our power, and there are things which are beyond our power. Within our power are opinion, aim, desire, aversion, and in one word, whatever affairs are our own.
Beyond our power are body, property, reputation, office, and one word, whatever not properly our own affairs. Now, the things within our power are by nature free, unrestricted, unhindered. But those beyond our power are weak, dependent, restricted, and alien. Any thoughts so far?
You saying I'm weak, body? Yeah. It's restricted, and it's alien to you. The body's including the...
In the things not in your power. In my power is literally everything else. Wait, how you feel is in your power? Desire, aversion.
So if you like stuff and hate stuff... That's your power? Your aims, in one word, whatever. Yeah, opinion, aim, desire, and aversion.
You can disagree with it. Yeah, I just think, like, your initial desire and maybe your initial aversion aren't in your power. Maybe impulsing on them. Yeah, but then you get to choose sort of what you do with that impulse and desire.
For example, I didn't used to like coffee, or I also didn't used to like whiskey, but I had the... I wanted to be... You know you like both of the same. You know you like both of it together.
No, but then... But I liked the idea of coffee and the idea of whiskey, and I eventually developed a taste for it. So I was initially... I don't know.
So you're also very stoic, is what you're saying? No, I'm just saying that I think, like, emotions are how you feel often are beyond your control, like, on the outset. But you can master them, and you can control them, so that's within your power. But you don't control that, like, if you saw a pathetic thing.
Like, if I saw a little cute kid at our school, like, in their little kindergarten uniform, licking an ice cream cone, and then they lick it too hard, and it plops on the ground, and they start to cry, it's beyond my control that I'm going to feel bad. I will feel bad because it is a bad thing that has happened. But what I do about it is in my control, right? So you feel pity for this kindergartner, and, you know, some mean student might laugh at that.
Exactly. So there is something in there where there's a difference. That difference comes from somewhere. I think, as I would say, it's from the cultivation of certain attitudes toward others.
Okay, we're not even close to finish with number one. Let's talk about this for the next 45 minutes. Let me finish number one, then we can talk about it for a minute. It's talking about penguins.
Then we can watch it. But the things within our power are by nature-free, blah, blah, blah. Remember, then, that it was... Did I nail it?
I can't do an impression of his voice. Of Werner Herzog? No, not Werner. What's his name?
The guy that was in Shawshank Redemption. Oh, I don't know about that. I never watched that movie. I don't know.
You never watched that movie, really? You love that movie. Okay. Werner Herzog, and the penguin goes off towards the mountains.
Why? Obviously, he's such a thing. Werner Herzog's doing more to the penguins or something. You know how he's crazy.
Google Werner Herzog penguins. He's done a documentary asking the question, do penguins feel nihilism? And his conclusion is. Yes, that's true.
It is not a lie. My favorite is when he's interviewing the guy who actually hangs out with the penguins. He's like, do penguins ever feel this fair and want to leave the community because of some deep emotional angst. He's like, I mean, they wander off sometimes.
I've never seen a penguin go, you know, do that. He's just clearly like, uh, no. Sorry, Epictetus. He has something to say to the penguin.
He's really good watching stuff. It's really awesome. And I want Werner Herzog to just narrate my life. He gets in his car, feeling distraught about the morning commute.
That's why you don't want to do it. Dark soul. Yeah, yeah. He has a dark soul.
No chance. Sorry. He's licked the ice cream too hard. He's fallen through his cone.
Watch what he do now. Okay. So remember then that if you attribute freedom to things by nature dependent and take what belongs to others for your own, you will be hindered. You will lament.
You will be disturbed. You will find fault with both gods and men. Basically, if you let those things that aren't under your control, if you are under the impression that they are. But if you take for your own only that which is your own and view what belongs to others just as it really is, then no one will ever compel you.
No one will ever restrict you. You will find fault with no one. You will accuse no one. You will do nothing against your will.
No one will hurt you. You will not have an enemy, nor will you suffer any harm. Aiming therefore at such great things, remember that you must not allow yourself any inclination, however slight, toward the attainment of the others, but that you must entirely quit some of them and for the present postpone the rest. That sentence is kind of vague.
I've been trying to tangle with it. I don't really understand what he's aiming at. The references there are kind of detached. I don't know what references.
But if you would have these and possess power and wealth likewise, you may miss the latter in seeking the former, and you will certainly fail of that by which alone happiness and freedom are procured. Seek at once, therefore, to be able to say to every unpleasing semblance, you are but a semblance, and by no means the real thing. And then examine it by those rules which you have, and first and chiefly by this, whether it concerns the things which are within our own power or things which are not. And if it concerns anything beyond our power, be prepared to say that it is nothing to you.
Right. That is the end of one. Are you taking notes? I am.
Okay. So that's the end of one. That is the big precept, right? There are things in your control, and these include your opinions, your desires, what you hate, what you like, and there are things that are not in your control.
It pretty much includes everything else, everything outside your own brain. And so things inside, free, things outside, alien, restricting, slave, right? I can't control whether or not I break my foot. Like, I can maybe take some measures, but I might get broken, right?
So if I attach my happiness to those things that are external, I will always be compelled, offended, disappointed, and frustrated, right? Whereas if I restrict my happiness only to the things inside, I can remain happy. No one will ever come to me do anything. Or that no matter, so let's say you break your foot, you still control your internal epictetus to help you move your couch.
Like, is he a good friend? Does this kind of philosophy lend itself to being a good companion, friend, husband? It seems like if he's like, I'm sorry, I can't control you, Thomas, therefore, I'm not going to, like, worry about you. Sure, you know, marriage epictetus where it's not your problem to your problem.
Oh, man, okay, so let's jump to another section. No, no, no, we will, here you go, 16, this has to do with exactly what you're asking. When you see anyone weeping for grief, either that his son has gone abroad or that he has suffered in his affairs, take care not to be overcome by the apparent evil, but discriminate, be ready to say, what hurts this man is not this occurrence itself, for another man might not be hurt by it, but the view he chooses to take of it, as, well, seriously, I know, but is that what you say to him? No, so he says, as far as conversation goes, however, do not disdain to accommodate yourself to him and if need be, to groan with him.
Take care, however, not to groan inwardly, too. Like, look, your friend's in a place, and whether or not he should have that opinion of that place is, like, that is his affair, right? Yeah, maybe something bad happened in his life, he can, he is disappointed, he can choose to be disappointed, he can choose not to be, you can't let it affect you, but he's your friend, you should, you should groan with him, right? You should fake it.
Don't feel yourself. Yeah, well, I mean, like, do you feel, to the fullest extreme, every misfortune of your neighbor? No, I don't. Nor could you, I guess the question is, should you, is that what you're trying to get at?
No, it's, um, um, it just sort of seems like it's giving you license to not really be bonded emotionally to your friend. Sure. You keep, you, your real opinions are kept separate from how you act. Yes.
With that person, so they don't really know you. So in some sense, like, if, if, if, if, if Epictetus writes this book, everybody reads it, they're like, ah, this is your moral philosophy, and then your child dies, and Epictetus comes to comfort you, you know he's just, like, saying, well, humans like it when we comfort them, so Epictetus robot will, you know, run that program. I think that's the cynical way of looking at it, because you could just as well say, Epictetus is focused on what does that other person need, and I'm going to act that way. Would you act, would you say that the person who just responds in the moment is better to that person?
Like, they're doing what they want to do, as opposed to what AJ just read of. This person's in grief, I don't feel that same grief, but I'm going to act comfortingly toward them, because that's what the situation requires. I think if they adopt my grief, like, is that, is that even their right? Yeah, no, you're probably right.
Do they get to have my grief just because they're nearby? I guess it's, um, maybe I'm making a jump that Epictetus isn't making, which is, he has disdain for the person who's letting their feelings swamp their behavior. Right, because they're inferior. Because they're inferior.
And maybe he's not making that jump. He has to make a statement about people who aren't disdain. Oh, he does have to look it up. Let's call him.
Sorry, I've got to find it. That's my concern, is that he's like, look at all this. look at the sheeple with their emotions oh man hold on I gotta find it it's gotta be in there it is I don't think I took a note of it so as I look for this quote in my Kindle app you guys can discuss I guess my point was gonna be Graham I can love you as a friend do I have to do that with desire that may be frustrated if you act in a way that does not adhere to my desires can I love you without having to be affected by if you are feeling messed up or if you're angry at me or whatever can I love without any any desire for a certain outcome does that make sense can I give without expecting I can love you even if you're angry at me even if you are having a bad day you're having a horrible time I can still love you without any change to the steadiness of mind my own ship doesn't have to be rocked because yours is in a storm that's what I'm saying I can help you from my ship and give you aid without bringing my ship into the storm itself that's fine but do you act in such a way that you think I'm lame for piloting a ship through a storm we might have a conversation about it later I think in the middle of the storm I can't shout at you and say it's stupid to be in a storm but maybe a conversation later about hey man one of the reasons you're affected is your own choice this was a question that I wanted to have in the after show how do you talk to people who are I was thinking mainly students if you have students that are getting upset over things that they shouldn't get upset about because they're immature what is that sort of proper response Epictetus would say they need to master their emotions and I think there's a lot of that that is true but then for the person who has not mastered their emotions and is going through difficulty I always feel like Epictetus or the Stoics are going to be kind of like punks be like look at the weak no I mean he says to like if your brother's growing you're going to have to let it affect you and then I don't think he ever talks about disdaining others it's very much a self-rule thing and he even says look let the way that you talk in public and this is stuff I wasn't intending to read but let the way that you talk I mean if they ask you you can tell them but it's not about you so he even says you take in grass the grass of philosophy but you don't walk up to another sheep and go let them all your grass you let the evidence be and you're like you're wool and milk I love that quote oh you know that yeah yeah no student the sheep does not show that he's basically saying I can't remember the way the phrase it I have it in my complex book but the sheep does not show that he has eaten grass by throwing it up in front of you but by having wool and milk and so the idea being that the student or the learner doesn't show that he has learned something by barfing it on a page but by the virtue and by the person that he becomes so if there ever should be among the ignorance any discussion of principles be for the most part silent so if they're talking about moral philosophy you can just shut your mouth for there is great danger in hastily throwing out what is undigested and if anyone tells you that you know nothing and you are not meddled at it because we are ways in here this is precepts 46 you know you shouldn't be if somebody's insulting you you shouldn't be bothered by it then you may be sure that you have really entered on your work for sheep do not hastily throw up the grass to show the shepherds how much they've eaten but inwardly digesting their food they produce it outwardly in wool and milk thus therefore do not make an exhibition before the ignorant of your principles but of the actions to which their digestion gives rise so I don't have to disdain people just because they're chatting I can you know just do my do my work at home yes you see the guy that says don't argue about what it means to be a good man be one is that up to you specifically yeah the last section is talking about okay we talk about whether it's good to lie and we talk about okay what is lying and we talk about where does this precept arise that we question about lying he's like philosophy is all about number three when we should really be concerned about number one should we lie he's very much like boots hit the road kind of moral philosophy so here's the section about looking down on others the condition and characteristic of a vulgar person is that he never looks for either help or harm from himself but only externals right so if he's having a problem he's going to go somewhere else for him if he's yeah the condition and characteristic of a philosopher is that he looks to himself for all help or harm the marks of a proficient are that he censures no one praises no one blames no one accuses no one says nothing concerning himself as being anybody or knowing anything so yeah there is the vulgar there is the philosopher but someone who's moved along he's not going to go around dunking on people just because he's a philosopher he also won't praise anybody yeah so he's not going to give you a very good best man speech if you're not worthy of it I mean the other side in theory he could be giving a best man speech to a great stoic as well he could be seeking his wedding or something like that he would praise that guy at that point he would praise his internal characteristics right saying it that way doesn't make it seem like a bad thing you're locating the praise in a place where it's something they've actually controlled as opposed to praising someone because they're lucky that they got rich and part of the encouraging also talks about hey you don't know what's going on in a guy's life maybe he drinks a little too much but you don't know how his day was so you can blame him for drinking too much but you don't have any idea what's going on in that guy's life so can it right maybe a guy bathes hastily but you don't know what's going on what he's got to deal with or what is happening in his day so that's where part of the don't praise or blame comes from it's don't you know don't start off about stuff you know nothing about it's kind of you need to walk a mile in his shoes before you talk about his life but can you but that's the question once he's walking a mile in his shoes will he then talk about his life or is he saying you never can hold on let me look up that section you guys are running me all over I just want to know if you can judge people you want to judge people you do that okay hold on so this is precept number 45 sorry does anyone bathe hastily do not say that he does it ill but hastily does anyone drink much wine do not say that he does ill but then he drinks a great deal for unless you perfectly understand his motives how should you know if he acts ill thus you will not risk yielding to any appearances but such as you fully comprehend like if you don't know why he's doing it you can't make any claim about it there's another one that talks about like yeah you might be more eloquent than this other guy you might be faster than this other guy but all you can say is that you're faster than him you can't say that you are better at all and so he even talks about that like yeah maybe you're eloquent maybe you're quick but you does not consist in quickness or in eloquence so you can't say you're better but does you consist in emotional control like the things that you can control then do you make the value of judgment that the stoic who when his son dies you know is like this doesn't affect me versus the man who is weeping are you trying to ask whether or not he would say it is better to have emotional control because clearly yes like that's the whole point and that's the point of like we just talked about this in AMA of all education you have to make some value judgment at some point and so the value judgment here is yes it is better to control your emotions in every case there's no health in having an emotion expressed is there a healthy expression of emotion? it is supposed to be in accordance with nature and he's like much of what you are expressing are emotions that don't really need to happen like he talks about okay look say the neighbor kid breaks a cup you're not going to be real torn up about it what if you break a cup?
what's different? like you should have as much like you should have as much emotional attachment to his cup as to your cup it's just a cup it's not you it's outside you right so you should be just as torn up about a lost cup but what if it resulted because of your own personal carelessness and in that broken cup you realize that you're a pretty careless person that would should tear you up more than realizing that like your neighbor is a careless person but I think that would be but in that case you are not torn up about the cup you are torn up about your own carelessness which is a thing that you can control should you not be torn up about the carelessness of someone else? not necessarily you can't control it they can though should Thomas be concerned about Asher's inability to carry things you know what I mean you wouldn't comment on he did ill it's just you would say he broke a cup so it sounds like it lacks that emotional aspect to it or it lacks a judgment it's trying to be objective in the description of this is what happened not why it happened yeah or even that it was terribly negative there's one part where he talks about so you lose something you lose your cup you lose your wife you lose your kid if you simply say like these things were given to me and they have been restored to their original owner that's a way different perspective they weren't yours they were outside of you and they were just taken back and weirdly enough he does comment upon faith he's like they have the gods have ordered the universe they've set everything in motion they're perfectly wise they know everything if you submit to them instead of being given up to the you know the like up and down of life if you just say hey they've perfectly ordered the universe you can do your faith simply and easily without having to worry about much at all there is a thing that I think will make you grumpy and we are way off the rails here yeah yeah we are way off the rails as far as what I planned for this episode which was to kind of go beginning to end so audience again you are not getting the flow of this oh no I think it's fine because each one of these is kind of distorted like there is a flow but after precept one and two it's all just kind of variations on the same theme okay so if you would improve lay aside such reasonings as these and I think this is where you work so he's telling me lay these aside buddy gotta be over it if I neglect my affairs I shall not have a maintenance if I do not punish my servant he will be good for nothing basically if I don't do anything things are gonna go screwy if I don't take control of my world my world is gonna go upside down he says for it were better to die of hunger exempt from grief and fear than to live in affluence with perturbation right so I would much rather be free and live under a bridge than be worried about my wealth all the time and like running my house and it is better that your servant should be bad than you unhappy so yeah if you don't get all up in your servant's business you're probably gonna turn out to be good for nothing but man you're gonna run yourself ragged doing it so it's better to just have kind of a bad servant and be totally you know happy yourself than run yourself ragged trying to correct him all the time yeah again that's the point that Graham was raising before of essentially everything that's outside of yourself kind of gets lumped into this one category of they take care of themselves I take care of myself and I'm only concerned with it taking care of not even my body because body counts as external correct he does say that you should you know do what's necessary for maintaining your body like you know give it the exercise it needs and give it the food and drink it needs and treat it nice yeah but all socialism is kind of ironing out there being any social relationships so that you know we've conflated at this point the cop versus my servant's behavior versus the death of my son like they all kind of become something external to myself that should be viewed similarly right because they're out of my control I shouldn't get too worked up about them because I couldn't have prevented it anyway if it was truly beyond my power yeah to quote is a little oil spilled or a little wine stolen say to yourself this is the price paid for peace and tranquility and nothing is to be had for nothing like yeah it's a little wine but that's the price of being peaceful and when you call your servant consider that it is possible he may not commit your call where if he does then he may not do what you wish but it is not at all desirable for him and very undesirable for you that it should be in his power to cause you any disturbance right if he knows I'm not going to come and really stick it to my master if you're like I don't give two flips then it's better for both of you and so much of this is I think not necessarily about just making sure you don't have personal relationships but that you take appropriate perspective so there's one part where it says if you are insulted right you can either take offense or you can say if he had known all my other faults he would have stopped there right like be aware of your faults and yeah he probably meant to hurt you but you don't have to be hurt and so it's much more saying like yeah these things and he even says evil doesn't exist it's a really short passage it's one thing he says you don't set up a target for the purpose of missing with the arrow therefore the nature of evil does not exist and I'm like whoa I feel like that's a leap but you know Augustine was in the same place and so it is so much more about controlling your own attitudes about things that have gone wrong like if I didn't desire it to go perfectly my way in the first place I can't be totally happy if it didn't turn out and for this reason he says you should keep the matter of death constantly before your mind right you're going to die one day if you're listening to our entire conversation in the search for your entire last paragraph that's hilarious anyway you're going to die one day and he's like we fear death not because we know it is bad because nobody knows it's bad right we fear death because of an attitude we have about it if we can change our attitude about it we shouldn't fear it take for example Socrates didn't fear death had an appropriate attitude about it right again same thing that Socrates himself had this view toward his death which is different from the view toward the death of my wife the death of my child and that's where I mean that you know we should continue on and like actually hear the argument that Epictetus is making but stoicism tends to be something that I think is right for like 80% and 90% situations and like yeah you shouldn't get worked up about the kid across the street breaking up your example from before I do think there contrast that with Aristotle's view toward friendship where the friendship of excellence is one where you match the feelings of those your happiness comes from the happiness of others so there is an emotional aspect to it but it's not just the I maximize my own happiness it's or rather I maximize my happiness by maximizing that of the people I care most about that's all maybe it's in between conversation maybe it's toward the end of the episode no no I think this is a this is a fair thing I mean you guys kind of have just the book I mean clearly we've been jumping around hitting multiple things I'm about to hit another one but if your happiness is dependent upon the happiness of your friends I think that's where Epictetus would get cranky but if he says and if he says you're a worm I hate you I can be like you don't know the rest of my faults you bring me cookies every day and I say you bringing me cookies is outside my control therefore I am not I'm going to be impacted by these cookies okay man you guys are just leaning right into everything I want to read I love it this is perfect yeah seriously it's like you're just setting me up for every single thing I wanted to read you're like Graham you're my best friend and I'm like I can't control that I will not react to it you know what I'm saying yeah I'm just saying and this is one of the biggest questions I have at the end I don't want to get to yet but all of this is kind of leading towards so pleasure's coming we're going to have a party you guys guard yourself against being bewildered by it but let the affair wait your leisure and procure for yourself some delay so you're like the party's coming I'm going to have to take some time on myself then bring to your I'm serious right get some delay before you jump into the pleasure then bring to your mind both points of time that in which you shall enjoy the pleasure and that in which you will repent and reproach yourself after you have enjoyed it and set before you in opposition to these how you will rejoice and applaud yourself if you abstain so as I'm thinking about the party I have to keep in mind when I am doing it when I enjoy the pleasure and when later I'm going to reproach myself for having enjoyed the party and then how much I will congratulate myself if I have refrained for enjoying the party and even though it should appear to you as a seasonable gratification take heed that its enticements and allurements and seductions may not subdue you but set in opposition to this how much better it is to be conscious of having gained so great a victory so you stay away from the party and we're like hey man what's the deal and you're like I've gained a great victory over myself today that I was not overcome by the pleasures of the party this reminds me of Mary at the ball in Pride and Project where she's just kind of dunking on everybody so this is where I think it might break down a little bit and you guys have mentioned a couple spots where it also seems to break down but if I have a son don't I want him to grow isn't there some sort of filial responsibility paternal? filial son right?
yeah paternal responsibility paternal responsibility there that I have towards my kid it seems a sketchy thing to me to just go there's a kid and now he's outside of my control and what happens to him is completely disconnected from my feelings yeah this is the question I wrote what is his view on duty and responsibility because you were saying oh I can't keep my fortune from dwindling so my fortune is up to fate well you can be a good steward of your finances and yes there may be something that completely wipes you out but that doesn't mean you shouldn't have any sort of responsibility to making an effort yeah making an effort yeah also talks about you know becoming a member of the state and he's like you can only do it so much as you can control and do it safely and without you know getting into externals without you know giving away too much of your self-control so you know only going so far as much as you were willing right which i think is probably good advice right there's some boundaries you can overstep and there's a really good section at the end where he's basically like you know what you should do stop procrastinating and do it which is great advice but but this does lead to the okay granted if i'm too attached to external things can be a problem right and we've seen this with students we've seen students that are over affected by things that are happening in their lives and they're not taking a healthy perspective of things and there's a point at which i said something mean yeah and then there's a point which i certainly do this like you wreck your car well you get torn up about it or think hey i was looking at a car in the first place there really is a point at which perspective matters right and can totally control your reaction to the situation yes um then what is the correct place for passions especially responsibilities your passions for is a great question for a stoic did you say he has an answer to that question he doesn't he doesn't seem to uh he wants to act in accordance with nature but even there there seems to be a breakdown because by nature humans are pretty passionate creatures well that may be the answer that that there is there are natural passions that should be played through naturally maybe he doesn't go there but that's always been my my thought that has to be the stoic answer is that there is there are appropriate emotions to feel at appropriate occasions that need to sort of work themselves through and then at the end of it you kind of feel embarrassed about the fact that you let those emotions happen but you should do it you should do that anyway i think you'd only be embarrassed if you let them happen in excess yeah but there but i certainly agree with look you don't have to be offended right there that's a choice you don't have to be disappointed when something material of yours is lost right you're lucky to have in the first place if it was a gift the gifts can be taken back there is a way to go through life with just not being affected by those things yeah the the offended man chooses to be offended is a helpful heuristic and i think i agree with you maybe like 80 90 of the time but then there are like when the sacred is disagree yes oh and and out of the sanctity of a relationship with your wife um uh if if you're at a party if you're at a dinner party and a member of the dinner party is just like making really inappropriate comments about your spouse and you're like i can't agree victory by not having to offend me it's like no you're also at some point you're now like uh you're complicit or not you're doing your duty responsibility as a husband yeah i have i have had to walk away from conversations like that yeah where you know someone was getting dressed down i just couldn't be part of anymore so i yeah i think there is a point at which this breaks down it's like yeah 90 of situations it's great exactly right you can you can be separate from the whims of fortune and being totally under the control of things that you cannot control right if i've given away myself control to things that no one can control but but there's a time there's a place for emotions like on my wedding day i should feel happy that something external is happening yes you would not win great victory for yourself by keeping in mind the time that i would approach myself for having enjoyed my wedding day or if god did the same thing with his children if god was like well they're on their own and i've gained great victory by not caring what happens to them right no but he condescends and becomes human and so there's something you know it's a good thing god wasn't stoic but aj you started this by saying that reading this has shown to you that you are stoic do you want to say more about what you mean by that in in many ways i am and this is maybe the key right in many ways the 80 percent the 90 percent all right sorry no no you're right i i do think in most in most situations i try to take perspective where things just don't affect me and i honestly think this came from being picked on pretty heavily as a kid you had to learn how you go crazy right if what you and this is what i felt every day at school is betrayal kids would hang out with me after school we'd be friends the next day they would betray me in front of their friends right so after so many betrayals and being physically messed up i'm not doing this for pity it's it turned out to be one of the greatest things for me because i had to learn how to be okay with external things just not going my way right and trying to learn a different perspective on it which is like these kids are not that mature right they want to look good in front of their friends they don't know how to navigate that very well and i get it i'm also pretty nerdy i think the extent to which i was nerdy they'd probably be harder on me and there are there are ways to navigate that with just not getting offended and being okay with it were they doing wrong probably but i can't stop them but i can certainly but with the whole you know turn the other cheek and submit to others and if someone takes your cloak give them your shirt like there's a way to go about being abused or you know i'm trying to be careful not i understand yes yeah so but again that's even you putting that caveat in there like and this goes back to the conversation that the three of us have had a thousand times already but like i hear that point that's all point about like three things is that well then why not also improve your situation i understand that there's a virtue to being able to be resilient in any given situation i'm not speaking a bit here specific oh go ahead i'm not though i'm just saying that like if someone came to you and they're like yeah get good aj well that's the thing in fifth grade i got tired of it and i left like i walked out of school in the middle of the day and walked home just no class that's not stoicism that's you required an external thing moving yourself to be better right you know i mean yeah but you did the right thing everyone just skipped school that's what i'm saying on the podcast you did the right thing by doing something external as opposed to i'm going to you know get tough and not let this impact me does that make sense that's the problem and that's and that's why i want to be careful how i talk about abuse because there's the point which you like gotta get out of there yes you know and the answer is not just get stronger and not impacted by things yeah that's what maybe this is a question you say for the after episode is is there a limit to the trauma that a person can feel even just like on our neurobiological level where we can't think maybe we can't sort of like perspective our way out of it um i'm just thinking like is there is there situations or external things affecting you either bodily or emotionally that are that are so extreme um even to the point of like uh affecting you cognitively affecting you uh emotionally uh so much so that like the very physical makeup of your of your hormones and body get all out of whack that can't just be fixed by a perspective shift i think so yes yeah i've seen it yeah like my uh my nephews struggles with this yeah he was adopted i think some of that early trauma has had a lingering effect right that he can't necessarily counteract no matter how much he thinks about it and i i think i was maybe this is just and the other thing is okay then people who like i lived a pretty have lived a pretty charmed life a wonderful childhood family loved me uh uh had friends sure i was picked on in school but i've never had when i was young growing up real difficult situations and so then when i've been in a difficult situation that i was outside of my control i realized i actually don't have any kind of tools to deal with this um and um whereas other people who probably like that's old hat would have been like that's so bad so i just wonder if um if yeah can there be such such traumatic uh things that perspective that stoicism can't fix oh yeah i think absolutely repeated severe is like i think it is stoicism is hard pressed to survive that kind of trouble yeah right repeated severe difficulty i think it just might not go far enough i think for your everyday bottom dollar offense and for just like a little bit hardship like there's a certain extent to which you should be able to after those and be prepared for more hardship normatively speaking or if we wanted to talk about like average common life yeah then yeah then this kind of this ability to be able to put things into proper perspective is a good thing for a person to be able to cultivate yeah but so to go back to my experience i'm i'm trying to just be very everybody else's there's a point which was too far like i've been punched in the face too many times i've had rocks around too many times this particular day that i walked away from school i tried to join a kickball game and they threw the kickball at my head until i left the whole team yeah and i was like you know what i'm done yeah i think i'm kind of like i had been through all the emotional trouble of trying to be stoic and find a good attitude and get over it and it was just it was time to be done so i left so is your takeaway from that that that is a weakness of stoicism or do you look back on that and think you should have stayed in that environment i my life was so much better after i left and i like i learned a lot of good lessons from that time but i think remaining in it would not have been good for me and so is this a weakness of stoicism that is unable to deal with everything everything well yeah i think it's not a weakness no i think can't be you can't can't deal with everything except this is a it's a philosophical worldview and it's like for 80 percent of life like if you think of it that way then that's helpful yeah and even the bit about not getting overwhelmed by a upcoming pleasure i think it's pretty good rule right don't don't give yourself up to it and feel awful when you've gone way too far but you should also probably not do that when your friend's throwing a party or when someone gives you a present or when christmas is coming up like yeah those are pleasures that you should indulge in imagining that someone you love gives you a present in your responses this has no impact on my life this is outside of me and i can choose to be excited or not excited about it i think it's easy to um make fun of it the message of you are in control of your response to these things is an important one that is a you know you said this book takes 45 minutes to read it's probably worth everyone reading right yeah it is a great read and a lot of these things are quick and obvious and easy to internalize and so important in and if one of them like sticks out to you and is like wow i you know i do take things personally from people who don't matter to me or something like that yeah that makes it worthwhile for whatever 45 minutes we're getting super friends about one small thing you're like you know i have a lot more problems than they're even getting into right yeah do you think are we making a character of stoicism do you think that like would victory disagree with how we're characterizing this kind of lack of emotion and important i think i think the entire is maybe a little too simple to fully encapsulate exactly what stoicism is i am sure that the masters had conversations about okay where what role do the passions have in everyday life and i'm i'm tempted to read the dialogues of epictetus to kind of find some of this nuance that feels like is perhaps missing from the entire because it really just feels like a basic daily manual and i don't know it feels unfair to characterize stoicism based solely on this one document and then say there are problems and therefore right right that's where i think we're all bringing in all the other stuff we've read about stoicism which i think it's fair to your point there of and also because stoicism is having a moment these days yeah but epictetus is not writing like the full history and the full ideology of stoicism he's not giving cosmology and he's not giving yeah even metaphysics he's just saying don't get offended when people make fun of you which is great advice yeah yeah i think that's pretty good wow that's just a way different path than i thought we were going to take but it makes more fun though right yeah is this what you're like every time this is what we do to you this is i'm so sorry i'm nervous about the next one i just don't stop talking so that during my episode no during mine so that no one can get a word and if you do that's why i give you that look i feel like i'm usually there i usually just hit i just start with a book and i just keep going and you guys just go but today we got more conversation very good we got more i i mean like i could go back and start reading back from the beginning but i feel like we you know i got questions for the after after show okay i think we did pretty good cool like i said that that first precept kind of sets out the whole overarching idea and then just sort of works itself out into everyday life in a few different areas uh that second to last precept about if you know what you're supposed to do why don't you do it you're a grown-up do it yeah it feels almost like a precursor to the books by what's his name the oh i thought you're gonna say the shia labeoff meme just do it do it yeah anyway cool awesome well this has been classical stuff you should know with graham thomas and aj and you guys know what to do do it this is you can find us at like it's described um hopefully this podcast has uh as an external stimulus has affected you emotionally uh and if it has you should feel ashamed of that um but if you want to email us email us at theguys at classical stuff.net or you can tweet us at classical stuff on the twits uh spelled wrong or um you can i spelled it wrong oh there's classical stuff already was taken um and uh thank you for listening and also you can maybe if you want leave a little review on itunes it helps us out and uh hey if you think we're three or four that's fine i know we can take it i don't need to i don't need to it's someone else's opinion if they do all the other problems the podcast has then yeah exactly yeah anyway um but thanks for listening and we'll catch you next week you