Skip to content
*18.1 Makkos Daf 12 A (Top line)* episode artwork

Apr 19, 2020 22 hr 35 min

*18.1 Makkos Daf 12 A (Top line)*

from BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. Hosted by Ed Levy

*18.1 Makkos Daf 12 A (Top line)**Summary*_We have reproduced the last summary in full since today’s learning is a direct follow up_*If the _kohen gadol_ is disqualified from _kehunah_* _[he was found to be a challal. If he was found to be a Yisroel there is no question that it is considered as if there was no kohen gadol at all]:_ It is a dispute between *Rabbi Ami* and *Rabbi Yitzchok Nafcha.* According to one; it’s like *the kehuna died* and the murderers go free. According to the other, *the kehuna is cancelled* and it is considered as if there was no _kohen gadol_ at all.*Question: Is this dispute the same* as that of Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yehoshua?*Mishna:* If a _kohen gadol_ was bringing _korbanos_ and *he was discovered to be a _challal:_ Rabbi Eliezer: All his previous _korbanos_ are disqualified. Rabbi Yehoshua: They’re kosher.*It seems that the amora who posits that *the _kehuna_ died is following Rabbi Yehoshua* and the amora who posits that *the _kehuna_ is cancelled is following Rabbi Eliezer.**Answer: The disputes are not necessarily correlated.* While Rabbi Eliezer certainly is of the opinion that the _kehuna_ is cancelled, *both Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Yitzchok Nafcha can explain Rabbi Yehoshua’s position* in a way that matches up with their own.*Rabbi Yehoshua agrees* even with the position that ‘the _kehuna_ is cancelled’. He only says that *_korbanos_ brought by a _challal_ will not be disqualified* because of the _possuk_ regarding _poeil yadav_ [the _korbanos_ he brings] in which he *darshens* *the word _cheilo_ to include _challalim._*_The Torah states that a murderer must be taken to be executed from near the mizbeach (from doing the avodah). However the gemara in Yuma teaches that while a kohen is actually on the mizbeach, he is not taken to be killed.__Before his death, Dovid Hamelech commanded Shlomo to execute Yoav ben Tzeruya. Yoav fled into the ‘tent of Hashem’ and grabbed onto the corners of the mizbeach. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

*18.1 Makkos Daf 12 A (Top line)*

0:00 22:35:30

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us.?

This episode is 22 hours and 35 minutes long.

When was this BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. episode published?

This episode was published on April 19, 2020.

Can I download this BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.