181. Movie Review: Murder at Yellowstone City

Episode 21 of the Our Taste Is Trash podcast, hosted by Our Taste is Trash, titled "181. Movie Review: Murder at Yellowstone City" was published on May 19, 2025 and runs 43 minutes.

May 19, 2025 ·43m · Our Taste Is Trash

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

Join our hosts, Josh and Jade, for this movie review episode of the show. This week the review the 2022 western film, Murder at Yellowstone City. Set in a gold-rush boomtown that has gone bust, a prospector strikes gold and is murdered. Sheriff Jim Ambrose (Gabriel Byrne) assumes that the killer is a newcomer, a former slave who calls himself Cicero (Isaiah Mustafa), because "he's the only man who doesn't know what [Ambrose will] do to him." But as it becomes clear that Cicero is innocent and as the mystery of the prospector's death deepens and puts the whole town in jeopardy, the town's new minister, Thaddeus Murphy (Thomas Jane), and his straight-shooting wife, Alice (Anna Camp), must stand up to Sheriff Ambrose and bring the true culprit to justice.Learn why this all-star cast falls victim to plot holes and questionable dialogue choices inside the episode. Listen to the show for 45 min. so you don't waste 120 min. on this movie on Netflix.

Episode Description

Join our hosts, Josh and Jade, for this movie review episode of the show. This week the review the 2022 western film, Murder at Yellowstone City. Set in a gold-rush boomtown that has gone bust, a prospector strikes gold and is murdered. Sheriff Jim Ambrose (Gabriel Byrne) assumes that the killer is a newcomer, a former slave who calls himself Cicero (Isaiah Mustafa), because "he's the only man who doesn't know what [Ambrose will] do to him." But as it becomes clear that Cicero is innocent and as the mystery of the prospector's death deepens and puts the whole town in jeopardy, the town's new minister, Thaddeus Murphy (Thomas Jane), and his straight-shooting wife, Alice (Anna Camp), must stand up to Sheriff Ambrose and bring the true culprit to justice.

Learn why this all-star cast falls victim to plot holes and questionable dialogue choices inside the episode.

Listen to the show for 45 min. so you don't waste 120 min. on this movie on Netflix.

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

7 Years of Correct Opinions!

Nov 27, 2025 ·56m

Frankenstein's Monster and the Bad Science Daddy

Nov 13, 2025 ·53m

Rember Remember The 5th of Novevember

Nov 5, 2025 ·3m

The Future of Science Fiction Conventions

Oct 30, 2025 ·55m

We're Still Traumatized By This Writing Debate

Oct 16, 2025 ·55m

Spooky Season Books and Hellbenders

Oct 2, 2025 ·56m

Similar Podcasts

Salt or Sugar Podcast L,J,&B This podcast was created to be a safe space where we can share similar experiences from different perspectives. Our goal is to highlight the realization that we are not alone in our experiences. We hope that our vulnerability about our own experiences encourages others to live out loud instead of feeling isolated within their own reality. This is an authentic space that we invite you to join us in weekly. Thanks for joining us and we hope you enjoyed, a taste of perspective! Explicit TheONcast theONcast Hello! Come listen to TheONcast Duo discuss all things trending from tv & movies to politics & sexuality. We are cousins: one from the US and the other from the UK, but both with a taste for sarcasm, banter and gossip. Living an ocean part, our bond is virtual but strong - and entertaining! Explicit Tea Total Tea Total Tea-Total: How do you like it? Hosted by four women of colour, we wanted to create a podcast steeped with knowledge, that brews discussion, and tastes different.We want to delve into our personal relationships with tea as well as the rich history and culture surrounding the beverage across the globe throughout the millennia.Armed with tea related puns and an open mind, we are able to cover every topic imaginable from relationships to colonial history. We truly believe a good cuppa is a is a vehicle for change and something that unites us all. Explicit Critically Optimistic: Movie Reviews Mathew A C. & Janko G. We are your hosts Janko and Mac, welcome to Critically Optimistic: Movie Reviews. Join us as we create some exciting double features and show our opinions on various movies, our likes and dislikes and everything else that makes a film tick. We release a NEW episode every last Tuesday of the month. For more of our personal taste you can follow our letterboxd accounts listed in our social media. Jarjar: https://letterboxd.com/JarxesMaximus/mac: https://letterboxd.com/foeapple/ Explicit

URL copied to clipboard!