Hello and welcome to Classful Stuff You Should Know a podcast about the future and science fiction and the great of the last 40 years of science fiction authors. My name is Thomas Magby. I'm joined as always by Mr. Hannenberg and Mr.
Graham Donaldson. Now today we are talking about Little known fact I sometimes talk about getting my degree in psychology. I actually got my degree in psycho history That's a Fascinating what's coming next magnet is what's coming next now unfortunately it's a lot of symbols as I remember But we can also predict 500,000 years in the future. I forget what the number is.
Yeah, so man. Yeah, I guess we'll get into this Psychotherapy sounds like the autobiography of the Joker. Yeah, it's exactly right. We're like that girl.
You know in college Foundation we're gonna talk about Isaac Asimov's Foundation trilogy We're probably not gonna talk about the third book because I don't want to give spoilers for Hannenberg Who's still reading it and maybe you get you said that the first book was not your cup of tea I feel like our podcast is maybe getting a little long in the tooth cuz all our books are like I'm on this book Whoa, I hated it. No, I do not hate the foundation trilogy. I did Why we reading this so I am not a big science fiction reader. I never grew up reading science fiction The most science fiction I ever read were really bad Star Wars x-wing books.
That's pretty much all I read I read Dune maybe as a college and I was like I like this but it didn't like make me want to go devour the rest of the genre I read the moon is a harsh mistress Which was kind of a cool book that's where like an AI computer takes over the moon or something and they they bomb people by just Launch moon rocks at Earth. Yeah, it's kind of Like a redberry or anything like a straight man. No, I read fair and high for five one because we had to read it in I think it's like your short stories. I read here.
There we dragons. Yeah, so I'm okay I've read some but there's like the three-body problem, which is like the book these days in science I don't see book these days It's the one that I've heard about that everyone tells me I should read not read it anyway But I thought I should go back and read some classic science fiction so Isaac Asimov's foundation trilogy, which is cited as being like a Star Wars precursor that maybe George Lucas really liked and but anyway The reason I was on my radar is because Apple TV had television show and I watched the pilot episode in hot dang It was a like it was like it was like you know when you when you make soup and you're really excited for like a boy steaming Bowl of hot soup and supposed to be really comforting and you and the first light it's cold Full of hot no, it's just like it was cold. I don't know the book the episode I watched I was like they don't know what they're doing this is all over the place and it turns out that they're being true That's literally all the characters right so the foundation trilogy is will tell it will set up the world in a second But it's not a story with like main characters that you follow because every kind of chapter every little book or vignette Jumps ahead like three to 500 years in the future So you don't really get to learn to love these characters They're sort of these sort of placeholders for this world of ideas So this sort of this one idea that Isaac Asimov's writing about okay, so here's the here's the the story In many I don't know like in the future It's a is this supposed to be way in the past to just like Star Wars. I'm like no no no no no I did the future because they talk about like we don't know where humans came from and I'm like I do but anyway in the future humanity is many trillions of people on many many thousands of worlds and And there's this and it's all united under this one empire called the galactic empire They really reach in for that name.
Yeah, and there's the Roman Empire wasn't exactly the most crazy I said okay, so there you set this way so Isaac Asimov I think you like this book and I think you like this book. Yeah, Isaac Asimov loved the decline fall of the Roman Empire the Gibbons book about the Roman Empire It's aptly titled yes, and he wanted to think about what would that could you do that? Sort of story setting it in future. He wanted to sort of do the decline fall of the Roman Empire in space I won't make that joke the whole podcast and so then what he did was he set up this galactic empire and they all there's an emperor and he's a sort of like God man and There is one world that is this giant bureaucratic machine that its only function in the world in the universe is to be the bureaucratic machine for the Empire and The Empire is like never seen the sky That's right because they live underground the nursing the sky and this empire is trucking along smoothly and everything is working perfectly And you know there's rule of law and there's trade and you know the world's working the way it should be and And there's this man named Harry Selden who is a mathematician and he is Psychohistory, I apologize.
Well, he invented this thing called psycho history where correct me if I'm wrong He gets all of he's got like this algorithm or this formula where he can get all the data points of the universe and he can use it to Predict generally what's going to happen in the future so he can't predict AJ what you're going to eat for breakfast But he can predict when the galactic empire is going to crumble because um Because human beings on aggregate are predictable, but each individual human person isn't I guess Chaos Chaotic things you can't predict the individuals but you get normal distributions or some kind of function whenever you have lots of thing individual That's right. So you can do a chemical reaction and know what's gonna happen But if you go down below the level of the atom, it's going to be chaotic random movement of quarks and whatnot right that kind of idea There's random movement the lower you go There's predictable movement the higher you go and if you get to the highest level of society that you can everybody in space You can make these pretty accurate predictions in the future So this is what Harry selden Has implemented and he now can do it and this is what was very hilariously depicted in the television show with this like glowing cube And you like push a button in the cube kind of expands and there's got these like glowing math formulas and only the nerds can read it and know What's going on like in book three that's like the book one that's in the book I'm going your cube going your cube in the second Oh There's a glowing cube the person like Yeah, I know you know We're taking off iTunes like that He there's like this math competition and somebody wins this math competition and comes to the galactic empire work under Harry selden But in reality like on day one Harry sounds like hey buddy guess what the galactic empire is about to fail It's about to crumble. It's gonna be destroyed and we're gonna save it. No, we're not gonna save it Harry selden says there's two paths open to humanity 30,000 years of barbarism or we can preserve all of humanity's learning and technology and science What called physics in the book we can we can keep everything together and we can shave that 30,000 years of barbarism into 1,000 years of uncertainty and then the rise of a new galactic empire that will sort of be better than the other one Those are the two options forward not a popular option not a popular, you know He's arrested so he says it and he says to the emperor and the emperor is like that's heresy I don't want to hear this he's arrested.
He's put on trial And then he's banished to a backward planet called terminus. Yes, which is you know the in a line So he's he's banished to a backward planet called terminus and Harry selden says just as I predicted Which he says a lot everything is going to be like and he's like he's like I knew this is going to happen I've already established the foundation on terminus The foundation on terminus has a mission and they are to well the mission that stated is that they are to create a giant Wikipedia article about humanity That's essentially like yeah, we're way ahead of the game with actual Wikipedia. Honestly. No, so they're to make the encyclopedia Universica, I think it's called something like that.
Go back to go whatever. They're making this No, we're not called content. Oh you came here to learn about the stuff that we know That's whatever is whatever. No, how many episodes is your list?
Oh nine No, no, it's actually 18. Yeah, exactly. Well, these are these are This big this big Wikipedia article about humanity on foundation But then there's a rumor that there is a second foundation on the opposite end of the galaxy And this is floated in book one and then this is gonna be what book three about the third books about called the second foundation Yeah, hi the titles are wildly uninteresting if you're looking at it's like foundation foundation and empire and second foundation Makeup tutorial very confusing if you read foundation then second foundation you have no idea what's going on The three books that are the original trilogy are actually books two three and four if you go and look it up right now Oh, are there there's a one written for the three years later Foundation which is not the foundation is the second book Foundation and empire is the third book and then second foundation. We're talking.
Oh g foundation Yes, exactly. Um, and so, okay, so Harry selden is he's an old man and he basically says like this is gonna happen And lo and behold it does the current there's um in the television show They make it really cataclysmic. There's like a 9-11 style attack on terminus. No, sorry on tarantor the main planet Where like someone blows up their um like sky bridge.
I don't know it's like the space elevator Um in the book. It's more like they just kind of got problems with their supply chain It's kind of like imploded in fighting in their one They were trying to like codify their power rather than being bold and And selden says that you won't know that this was the beginning of the decline Yes, but this is the beginning of the client you won't know it and it's true because as the book goes on The middle book of the trilogy called a foundation empire is about basically the last battle of the empire that falls apart So the empire lasts for another 500 years, right or whatever it is So he's talking about you know the client fault room an empire. It's not like it doesn't yeah It doesn't happen in a day but it didn't fall in a day. That's right But the apple tv television show made it happen in a day in fact It was like Harry selden's on trial was like the empire will fall and everyone's like no it won't and then the sky explodes Somebody runs in the empire just so yeah exactly.
Oh, no That's where I turned it off Did you know i've been watching the new bobafette show Galactic emperors Okay, um anyway, so And then book one is done and that's it is harry selden saying like all right boys We're going to terminus to start the foundation and he said this thing is going to become the new empire in like a thousand years And so the end of the book one yeah No the end of like the first the first the first story in book one oh Oh seriously listening to us the entire time. Oh wow Leesings happen yeah We're going to terminus to start the foundation. Yeah, this literally what series was recorded Um, so yeah, sorry not book one. Why not the whole book but like the vignette one and that ends It's a series of short stories.
It's a series of short stories It's like a collection of the first words Yeah, and they were all published as like serials So they do have the annoying habit of like halfway through book two There's like a whole chapter where it's like we're counting what happened in book one It's like I've never heard a psycho history so let me tell you about it And then you go this sort of anyway It does feel like it jumps around a lot since it's jumping forward and it's jumping forward and so they don't get you know Don't get attached to characters because they're you know only around for a little bit Um, all right So that's the end of the first vignette the foundation starts and everybody who's going there kind of knows that they've got the secret mission And everybody else in the galaxy doesn't really know about them and thinks that they're like woo-woo That this is you know, they're saying they're weirdos and don't care is because they're in this planet with no natural resources It's quite you know, it's sort of said to be this sort of crappy planning They've got like dirt. Yeah, they don't even have any metal which is gonna be a big problem It's just soil. Yeah, and they can't even grow stuff. Yeah, okay So then and then the next little section of the story happens I don't know like 80 years in the future or something and The foundation has been sharking away and it's basically run by a bunch of academic bureaucrats And they are every day waking up and doing a little encyclopedia thing and they're like we got to publish this It's gonna save the universe.
Um, and then there is a mayor of the little town that's built up around the foundation So it's think of it think of this little town as like literally a university town And the university is the sole thing there There's this little town that exists solely just to prop up the the foundation of the university and all of these I think they're called Psychologists, well, they're not they're actually psychologists. That's right. They're all physicists. That's right Okay, I'm there.
It's like these like a pedia's these they're like these you know historians and their job is basically to preserve science And you know, it's because right in the 1950s. So of course everything is the magic of nuclear science. Oh god I'm gonna have to say that word a lot. No, I'm self-conscious.
How do you say it? However, you say it is the right way to know it's time. Yep Just I'm just gonna leave it out on the second. Nucular.
Nucular nuclear nuclear nuclear nuclear nuclear nuclear Okay, great job. All right audience what you don't know is that like one in the morning on one thesis deliberation night at our school Mr. Donaldson over here said something something nuclear power and we're like wait say that again nuclear. We're like nuclear He's like yeah, so I said nuclear like nuclear Yeah, so I don't hear the difference.
I know I still don't hear the difference And it took us I wrote it on the board and even did the same new new new say clear clear and then I say it's a new killer It's like a 45 minute conversation, but he seems to have mastered it. So nuclear I'm trying anyway So they're preserving all of this knowledge right because Harry selden says well What's gonna happen is the galactic empire is gonna forget this and the empire is gonna fragment and everybody on the fringes Are gonna go sort of barbaric Sort of warlord type civilizations and they're not gonna be nuclear powers They're going to be sort of steam powers, which is kind of funny And then the the empire will kind of like truck along but they no longer have any like mojo to their society They're just gonna slowly unravel and they're they suck a lose tech. Yeah, they forget how to make stuff They forget how to make things Then they sort of you know He's very much thinking of like the roman empire when the west falls and then you still have the eastern Byzantine empire which becomes kind of this bloated thing anyway Okay, meanwhile the foundation is trucking along and they are keeping there in psychopedia and all of the historians are Like pretty high in the hog about their importance to history and then there's this mayor And his name is His name is selva harden yeah selva harden and he is kind of incogorous of about the the encyclopedia He thinks this is kind of dumb and he says um listen boys if we're not careful like we're gonna get invaded because we have all this technology And the encyclopedia is like no, that's we don't need to worry about that Uh, we know we have the selden plan we know that one day we are going to be the um, you know the Game in town and we're gonna be the empire what we gotta do all we gotta do is make this encyclopedia And once we do then we'll be able to you know like we just got to trust the plan trust the math and um And selva harden's like I don't really know about this and he's worried about like his planet and getting taken over and there's this Warlord another planet who's kind of saber rattling. I'm not gonna give you the whole plot because that's not really what I don't want to be I don't want to swell the whole thing, but um It turns out that every Every time every time the foundation is getting to this pivot point in history that has been predicted by psycho history Um the ghost of harry selden know the hologram of harry selden's going to appear In a big like room on on a holodec or whatever and he's going to say like listen you guys are going through a crisis and here's the crisis that's coming Or sometimes it happens after the crisis like the job on avoiding that crisis And so every time there is a crisis harry selden kind of shows up and talks about what the crisis is going to be and it's kind of cryptic and kind of not And then the first one happens and harry selden shows up and basically says um You know you guys are now established on this planet on the fringes of the galaxy and according to the math The uh the empires outer rim has kind of crumbled and it's now basically these like barber swarlords who have low grade tech And they're planning on taking over your planet And so meanwhile the mayor Um harden is like i told you nerds like this is a problem and then harry selden says oh Um, um, the encyclopedia doesn't really mean anything you guys don't have to do that Like i just had you do that because we kind of needed you to get off the ground To keep you busy you had to keep you busy and we just Selten says so selden's recording this like 80 years in the past and i'm listening to an 80 in the present 80 years So selden is long dead at this point.
Yeah selden is long dead and he's like he's like this had to happen We had to sort of like um have you guys uh preserve all of this and but really what's important is your planet is going to become like the center Terminus is going to be like the center of the next the next galactic empire and um your first order of business is that you're going to basically um like defeat these warlords and I don't want to get into all of the various different stories Um, but it turns out they just have like a technological advantage and they can like turn off the invading warships And so the guy's coming and he's like i'm going to go over your planet and then Guys like okay, he turns off his show engines off. Yeah, and then he's like oh crap And so there's this anyway terminus ends up becoming a political power Whereas all these encyclopedias are like we are not entering into the politics of the age We are scientists and men of knowledge and snaul just gonna save us turns out no Turns out superior technology and political power and political power is going to save us with prior prior to the oligarchs the traitors Yes prior to traitors. Yeah, okay. Um, and then uh Then that mayor who's it was the name again?
Or hartin he then sort of consolidates power and he turns terminus into a real player in the region That they're not the galactic empire think of like, you know He's charlemagne to france right like it's that kind of idea that he's now sort of unified the sort of backwater thing into Something that is one day going to be you know, lewie the 14th or whatever Um, so he's unified terminus and a couple of these rogue planets that try to invade him and then he takes them over and because of his superior Technology has this balance of power. Okay, other stories happen where um You know fast forward. I think it's like 20 years and hardens an old man and People have begun all of these sort of backwater um barbarian planets have started to worship Um, the keepers of this technology as if they are these sort of like mystical scientists They're called the magicians because they can do stuff with nuclear power that other people can't and sort of this like primitive faith has built up around this and salvar harden has decided he's gonna kind of like crystallize that faith into a fake church that all the morons can believe but it really Consolidates the power of the foundation and isn't it convenient that all these people think it's it's like god and religion But really it's just like better technology and i'm gonna i'm gonna use this if they believe it and it keeps them in line That i'm gonna use it as like a power base And so you know he wins a battle because he's got a prophet who's you know curses all the warships and he's secretly like turning them off in this kind of stuff Anyway, um and then you know fast forward another four and so the netbooks done fast forward another 400 years and it turns out the foundation has turned into almost like a Venice where they are this merchant power and what do they have well? They've got this technology that other backwater planets don't have and it turns out these backwater planets like regard the technology as impious or like wicked and so they ban it and but it's really useful and meanwhile the foundation has grown to become this like merchant empire and They're really rich and then there's a whole bunch of like you know sort of fun swashbuckling stories about a traitor who goes and and kind of expands the The reach of the empire or the reach of the of this first foundation, right?
so we get and every now and then Harry selden shows up at this crisis point and I can't remember do they actually have the dates listed of when Harry selden's gonna appear or do they have like a dude who's waiting in the hologram room until like The lights dim. I think they generally have an idea. It's like every he shows up like every 60 years or something like that The first one's definitely scheduled. Yes, the first one's scheduled He shows up and he basically can predict or he's saying like here's the crisis you're in and here's kind of the way out of it and the way out of the you know the third crisis or whatever is The traders figure out how to reach this like free trade agreement and they break through the bureaucracy of these backwater planets that don't want to trade with them And it turns out that they do like their gold and their technology works and they like you know This is why I joked in earlier classical stuff episodes that like the climax of one of the stories is like free trade Which is maybe probably why you've said oh my goodness.
This is not compelling It's kind of hard to get into this book. It does work better probably as a serial partially because yeah, there are no continuous characters Like selden sticks around but everybody else is there for like a chapter and then they're marginalized by the next one But by book to sound doesn't mean anything because he then his psycho history doesn't work anymore So tell us more about it. We'll get to that in second. Okay, um, but book one the foundation ends and it's The end of it you're like, oh, this is a little bit formula book one ends or the foundation ends the book one ends But the one called the foundation is still there.
Okay, so foundation is still there But book one is ending um and it's ending but as a reader you sort of realize it's kind of formulaic. It's like This empire this little fledgling empire is growing and they're getting rich and they clearly have a galactic advantage with their technology Um, but then there's like big scary guys that want to take them over and then harry selden shows up And he's like you will defeat them with math you will defeat them with a trade agreement Um, and then they do and then everyone then everyone's hailed a hero and then there's another golden age of the foundation as it kind of like absorbs These backwater barbers planets and by the end of the first novel you're like, all right I can kind of see where this is going. Okay, we're not gonna get we're not gonna do book three. We're just gonna get to book two Um book two the first half of book two is there is a war between someone who is considered the last great general of the empire and the foundation So the foundation has an army of the foundation has an army of itself the foundation has this great navy and the foundation Is now big enough that the empire who kind of like gave up their backward planets has lost when they kind of lost their ability to control Them and to and to sort of maintain their empire the empire is crumbling.
They don't realize it Yeah They're you know, it's not weird out. Yeah, there's you know, there's probably at some point like a nice where the roman empire stopped caring about I don't know spain or something. Yeah, um, well definitely Britain. Yeah, yes, exactly And they sort of left it okay, um and the empire has done this but they hear that wait a minute the foundation We keep hearing about these guys and we hear their magicians and we hear they got some amazing technology Or they don't realize this technology this like amazing stuff and there's this general who kind of It's all very roman empire who like maybe himself wants to be emperor one day And the emperor is kind of a doofus and so this general says i'm gonna go and have this big war I'm gonna take over the foundation and then by taking over the foundation I'm gonna come back and become emperor and reunite all the colonies and become like, you know, the guy And he takes along the emperors like right-hand man And there's all this sort of political intrigue and there's this sort of emperors suspicious because you know who who wants to let this general have a spot That's right.
Yeah, so we kind of wants the kid to fail even though he kind of wants him to win first That's right. Um, and uh, you know, the general he's kind of bloodthirsty and he's not a very nice guy And there's again sort of these like fun space adventure swashbuckling stories of intrigue and politics and spying space and space and um the uh general Ends up being defeated by like political intrigue the emperor finds out and calls him back and and the little the emperors right-hand man is the traitor and Anyway, so it kind of like all fizzles out and the war never happens and the foundation is saved again And the foundation basically went toe to toe with the empire and held their own and it's obvious that they're the ascending power and the empire is the Failing power cool. All right book two begins with like again, hary selden like predicting the future. Okay Um, then the half the second half of book two Says that there's this new warlord on the scene and he's known as the mule and he's called the mule No one really knows why but they suspect because he's a big giant dude.
Um, and he's kind of cruel Um, and um, and he sort of seems to be taking over planets super easily and no one really knows why all they know is that as soon as somebody like talks to the mule They're on his side like They bought in to his cause and sometimes they don't even know why they bought him They're just like I like the kind of that guy's gym. Um, and they he sort of you know, there's all these really taking really big military planets with no effort That's right and way fast like one night later and then apparently he's just some huge monstrous hulk of being and rumors He's immune and rumors. He's immune and no one really knows what kind of mutiny is but he's like maybe he never dies or and just they're the mutant like Thor yeah, or like bane right? Oh, yeah and And uh like battles are happening where generals are like retreating when they're in a position of power and then getting routed and just really weird stuff Okay so the foundation sends like a little ingenue of spies into this place like planet where they think that the mule may be heading and Um, the husband and wife team go there and they're sort of on this planet trying to collect information And they're on a beach one day and then there's like weird little dude shows up and um and he says that he's the court jester from the mules Court and can he protect them?
They're like, yeah, we can protect you and he's kind of this do-face and he kind of talks like yoda and um, um, um, And he's a musician, but he sort of is almost like, he's like golem almost right like he's kind of this broken man Um, who's um and the wife whose name I can't remember Um, the taurian or beta beta the wife beta she sort of takes a liking to um, this this little musician guy Uh, his name is um, is he emilymous? No, what's his name? That's the, emilymous is the scientist magnifico magnifico. That's him magnifico.
So she takes a liking to magnifico He's a bit of an acrobat. He's got a long nose. He's got a long nose kind of ugly. Uh, I imagine he looks a lot like those, you know Those perusion masks the venoush masks.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I imagine he just looks like that He wears motley kind of thing just add to that and uh beta Sort of develops a liking of him in a pret- and sort of a fun is for him and kind of protects him Okay, um Then it turns out, you know that the foundation itself is kind of in crisis and the foundation is kind of gotten fat And the foundation itself has kind of gotten weak and every day sort of tr- and they're they overly trust the seldom plan They're like everything's gonna work out for us. We're the foundation. Harry selden like tells us what to do the math helps us stonks always go up Donks go up. How could it go wrong?
How could it go wrong? And whoever this mule guy is like, he doesn't have a prayer because we're the foundation and we're destined to win Okay, so then our math god king has told us that we win. Um, okay Then there's another very public viewing of Harry selden appearing and talking about the crisis and it is Wrong way off base. It's like now that you've just been through a civil war and they're like, are you kidding?
We're from the mule. Yeah, oh no, no, no, no, you've been through a civil war You know you will arise from the ashes and no they're not they're in a war with this like mutin name the mule And so everyone's like oh crap. He's selling the math wrong wrongs. Yes And so they get they everyone kind of freaks out and actually there's almost like an immediate dissolving of the power structures like people just lose faith in the foundation and then then it goes to war with the mule um and uh The empire like the old empire has been has parts of it have been taken over by the mule and I think the mule is taking over all the empire and the foundation is the only thing left and There's this like one planet that's holding themselves out and they just realized that everybody in the planet are like There's just losing the will to fight and beta has this like, you know, sort of World war two bunker conversation with this girl and she's like, hey, you know, we're on the right side We're doing the right thing.
She's like, I just I don't know what I just don't know what to live for I don't know why we're doing this I feel so despondent and beta goes her husband She's like do you feel like everyone's super bummed and he's like, yeah, I don't know why all right And they're like, hey Harry selden told us on the other side of the galaxy was the second foundation and they can save us And so they go this like wacky scientist who's been obsessed with the second foundation and they go off So this scientist is maybe my favorite character ever miss is that yeah, and he's he's the kind of Scientist that won't take no gut from nobody and he's like, I don't care that you're a politician I'm gonna come in here and my same hair brain schemes You don't tell me to leave and don't tell me to get a chair and he'll like yeah He's one of those guys. Yeah, they'll be like He's like around from uh from the back to the future. Yeah They're like would you please you know set the point and he's like we don't need an appointment This is the end of the world we're talking about. Yeah, he's that kind of a guy of it.
He's great Then decide that they're gonna go to the old Library on the empire home planet, which is now completely deserted and it's like a farming community and is But the library's still there, but it's just like a bunch of peasants like work in the land. They're like this used to be an important please Okay, um they go to the library I feel about venison Yeah, they go to the library and magnifico and the scientist dude spent all this time in the archives while the husband and wife are just kind of like You know sitting around waiting to see if the scientist guy finds the second foundation And as this goes on like they're just getting these reports that everything's failing Just the foundation is getting absolutely trashed by the mule and no one really knows why and he keeps winning these battles with like super inferior forces And people just seem to be losing the will to fight All right Then as this goes on magnifico becomes sort of closer and closer with the scientist and then one day the scientist He's just like all he's really pushing himself to learn where the second foundation is to the point of like mental exhaustion and magnifico is there Really grandma Friday. That's right and magnifico is there really like, you know In the game on being like hey, let's keep going We got to find this thing and then and then all of a sudden the scientist one day is like I found it I know what the second foundation is and beta takes out a gun and shoots him in the head What and kills the scientist what and magnifico goes? What are you crazy?
Why'd you do that? And she's like you're the mule aren't you and turns out that may know Nifico is yes magnifico is the mule um and he was spindly dandasy musician He likes to do physical tricks like he does cartwheels and things and he's a mule and turns out that he's a mutant not in physique But in mind and he has the ability to like rearrange the mind of every person to basically bend to his will It's yeah, he takes he alters your emotions And then not only can he alter them while he's present but he can stick him there like pin Yeah, so if I talk with you I can make you all of a sudden love me I love every idea I've ever had just leave you feel great about this whole thing And then I send you on your way and you are all of a sudden loyal to me forever So in your mind you may say I really don't like this new empire of the mule, but I kind of do and so everyone so he's I feel it real great about it So he literally has changed everyone's mind He's literally has changed everybody's mind and he has overtaken over the galaxy because he is this big mind And some of you know it yes He's like I know this is true He's like I would never betray you mule and he's like yeah you would though because I've sort of changed your emotions and you know If I took that away you never turn on you He's like no you probably wouldn't he's like I hear you I don't think so But he never changed bat his mind because bat it was the only person that believed in him And so he's kind of like an ugly nerd when he's young right and so he never changed her mind because she loved him for who he was But she should have changed his mind because she figured it out and she realized that Magnifico wanted to know what the second foundation was because that was the last thing to take over And if he figured out where second foundation was he would take over everything So she shoots the scientists sealing the second foundation's secret for history Because the second foundation might have something it had psycho historians didn't it? Yes, so whereas the first foundation was all about the technology The second foundation was all about like trying to basically expand the capacities of the human mind As far as possible maybe even like mind reading or doing those types of things that the mule can do So they're going you know if the first foundation is going real wide on technology The second foundation is going real deep on like human potential Full hog full hog. Full hog.
This is the end of the second book and the mule is like gosh darn it And then he's like you're right I am the mule and I've taken over the galaxy and now I'm gonna spend the rest of my life looking for the second foundation you jerk And he says turns out the reason I'm called the mule is because I can't have children So this presents a new problem that when he dies like the guy that's controlling everybody's mind dies and who knows what happens? So we don't know if their mind's changed back. I think they do they kind they change back or at least they die their kids minds can do whatever they want Right, right. They're not stuck in in anyway, and so then it's like oh crap We've got Oh, he's like he also realizes that as a mutant he doesn't like he kind of die early like he's all kind of messed up Um and he can't have any kids and so there's no like you know Pre-migeneitors accession laws or anything right?
It's just like when he dies chaos is gonna happen because he kind of turn it all into this one dictatorship and crap now It's gonna happen and then he's obsessed with finding the second foundation Okay, the third book Which we're not gonna talk about is the story of the second foundations defense against the mule and what they do to try to defend themselves And then this and then yeah, okay, and then the foundation becoming a galactic empire at the end and so the When I was reading this I You're twenty more okay when I was raised I had a hard time not reading it thinking about like Post-war America 1950s optimism right because it really is setting itself up It feels like it's setting itself up in that in that vein He's writing the decline fall of the Roman Empire in space and then he's sort of talking about you know The seeds of the Roman Empire getting started in the monasteries and then from the monasteries becoming the enlightenment and then this new European You know civilization born out of the Roman Empire, but there's also a huge feel where you know Maybe this was me I don't know If you had this feeling maybe in your first reading of it that the heroes of the foundation felt really American Yeah, the villains of the galactic empire felt really like British and European Maybe even German or the old world new world. Yeah. Yeah, that the world the heroes of the foundation were kind of like these Cowboys in space being like Yeah, we used you know America and then the bad guys were really like you know fuzzy Empire right like so I had a hard time de forcing reading that kind of History into it and of course, you know the joke that one of the climax of the books was like a free trade agreement As like the solver of lots of problems, you know as that was sort of a very post-war thing in America But so maybe question for you as the mathematician is there something to that idea that with enough data you can make predictive? You know claims about humanity in general.
I mean, that's the entire field of sociology. That's a point from The book the guy who's gonna get killed and gets comforted by lady philosophy. Oh, yeah That's what the philosophy says that that I don't know her exact quote It wasn't anyway, but she says that if you had all the information in the world You could predict all things that are happening Man's problems that we are limited and we're doing that so Yeah, I mean what's the you guys ever see that but on this on this topic you see that Netflix show That's about the invention of quantum computing. No, I forget It's about but the point is this guy he's some you know ultra billionaire that runs a tech firm and he builds one of the first quantum computers And the whole point is it's right because there's no quantity beer yet.
Well, we have some there's not very good yet But he basically gets it to the point where it is so powerful It can predict the flows of nature and not only what like will happen but what did happen So he can look back and see Jesus because it can it does enough computing power to look at all of the information They're feeding it and recreate what happened and so the hope he wants to like see his kid again or something crazy Or like see his family or where they are now where they would have been if it would have been different or there's some sort of like time travel thing to it But but that it's on that premise right how about the information you can predict the future? Yeah, I don't know if this is what the I think that's the science fiction version of you'll see this if people model what How does it look like or pick your favorite Egyptian or your person so now? Obviously, they're all guesses and probably none of them are right, but yeah It just seems like patently obvious that if you have a large enough group of people you're capable of predicting what that group of people does You are less and less accurate as you go into the future. Yeah, I think is that's the leap that cycle history is hard to go Well, but the conceit of the book I think kind of shows this tension of the I don't want if you call it the like the data purists and the classical historians right like With enough data we can predict the future and Harry Seldon has like sat in his office and he's been able to predict And he's recorded all these little videos as to what happens But then it's and he was accurate for like 300 years and then and then something happens that the data couldn't take into consideration Or was that 1% risk that you know, we were 99% sure that there wasn't any civil war But it turns out we have this genetic mutation called the mule that just showed up around the time that this new crisis was happening And he completely blows up the plan So there's like, you know, Harry Seldon could keep putting out his videos But they don't make it they don't mean anything anymore because this one guy showed up and this great man of history showed up and kind of changed everything And so that to me is kind of like the tension that we have even talked about this podcast of history like talking about reading history Do we talk about great man or do we talk about like?
All of the numbers all of the like the general person was doing and My great men were including women as well. Yes I mean like the people that we sort of ascribe the narrative to being the people that change history So the big events the big men the big women the Eleanor of Aquitains the rich of the thirds these kinds of things as opposed to you know The you know the long slow progression of the invention and the ascent of like money or pick your technology or the printing press or these kinds of things Because the psycho So we have a listening email list of history there is a field of psychosicki is not the same as a mob is But I also think of there's a political scientist named Bruce Bueno de Mesita And this is now I haven't read him in a long time his book the prediction years game is what I liked a lot But he makes some pretty bold claims about his ability to forecast individual decisions now He doesn't publish his models. So I can't like verify any of that. Like this is a like of course We would want to try and predict you're trying to kind of separate out social forces versus individuals Well, also this method can be used for individuals to try and say If this situation were repeated a thousand times in 60% of them This is the thing that would happen therefore we predict X and the thing that's unrealistic about selling this is Is this certain?
Yeah, this with 100% certainty is happening 10,000 years in the future. That's what it's more general than that It's not like he said, you know, this guy came and did this but he basically says like somebody in here probably realized that you could Turn this into a religion that they would believe and you could control them that way. So good job And and that's what had happened now, but I get yeah, I Personally think about that I like that tension of how much do we try to think about how much predictive numbers how much stocks we put in Predictive numbers about our lives and how much should we you know Put our our hope in those like serendipitous black swan events or if you want frame it that way if you had that algorithm that model Yeah, and you could with we'll say 80% certainty predict people's behavior. So you invent it one night.
Mm-hmm What do you use it for stock market? I was thinking pretty good boxing like betting. Yeah, yeah Yeah, stock market I feel like it would be the big swabs of what people are gonna do like if I could know that others gonna be a disaster next year of Some sort, you know, you're short the market then and then but the problem with these again This is where I'm just trying to that you can't you can't predict the stock market people will disagree with that statement But sure, right great, but the thing you can face is magnate That's for thinking So the but you can make certain statements about when it when this certain stock goes down 60% of the time It goes down a second time So like those kind of trends are the ones that you can profit off of because you're essentially flipping a coin a hundred times But the one that says with 100% certainty the S&P is going down 10 points tomorrow That's the one that doesn't make any 20 bucks a month for that kind of concept you do But yeah, I'll try to the things that can be predicted are going to be either across multiple iterations of something or across a Large number of events happening so a thousand stocks you could predict that some number of them will be positive, right? But you can't say apples gonna go up 10% tomorrow.
Yeah, we've kind of grown like we're guys in our 30s We've kind of I think of money ball You're almost me 40 I think of money ball and I think of the popularity of what of what money ball did so money ball for listeners It's it's some where using sort of different kinds of performance analytics on athletes the Oakland athletics were able to compete against the New York Yankees with like Multiple levels of financial difference like a third of a button. Yes I think the third baseman of the Yankees was when they when they met in the 2000 in 2001 World Series 2002 World Series when they met the third Basement of the New York Yankees was making more than the entire roster of the Oakland Athletics all 22 players or whatever right back on Thing so and they just use different kinds of analytics and this sort of spawned a whole movement and a whole sort of area of people in sports betting but also in like the thinking of franchises and the thinking of using data analytics to build out businesses or to model things and The we ball approach has not had much success outside of baseball and your problem is in all sports is that you have so many different numbers Yeah, you're problem than is which one's matter that's actually the scene in the movies like they're all arguing I forget what the status they're all arguing about some stat and then whoever the main character is like not matters Yeah, it's if they don't base. Yes, exactly. That's the Yes, you can collect lots of data and yes, you can try and predict But you still have this like human intuition problem of what part of it matters The point I was gonna make with that is that not that the data is changing behavior But people are beginning look that there is a certain way of running organizations that I'll give you some from basketball So basket with the game of basketball has Has sort of undergone what a lot of people are calling refinement culture refinement culture meaning like if you look at in the 90s Where the majority of points came from on a basketball court?
It was all over the place It was like evenly distributed amongst the court whereas I think in the like 2015 or 2016 season you look at where the majority of points came from the NBA and it was all right under the basket So layups or dunks and three points around the rim because you know the game of basketball is rewards you for Three points if you can shoot from there So everybody has been working towards becoming better three point shooters and the low processor the high percentage two pointers that come There's no point in dribbling in the paint and taking a shot from there You might as well go all the way to the rim or you might as well pass back to a good shooter outside the paint Who can get three points right? Refinement that's come and my sort of Hypothesis is is it's come with the advancement of thinking or maybe or of the reality that using stats and analytics to make our decisions Has tripled down to coaching and has sort of changed the way the game is played right now, right? So the mechanism wasn't necessarily Better at three point shots. It's that because the game rewards you this way everyone's been trained to do Yeah, and just the fact that that beginning to think about The game using that analytical sort of framework is different than thinking about the game Where was like we just got to get the heart and the passionate on the field And we got to give you the hot hand you had more of these like which is what was happening in the moneyball like the folks He whizzed him of the of the scouts.
He's like he just has a look of a baseball player and he's gonna marry his girlfriend So that's like a good sign that he's like, you know stable and the analytics guys like we talking about he gets on base way less than everybody else right so it was like the clash of of two different ways of assessing the game and And you know in the foundation book you've got the Harry Selden model and you've almost got this snobbishness of the foundation That's like we clearly have the upper hand because we have math on our side And then you have the backwardness of the rest of the galaxy Which is like clinging to the old ways of you know royalty royalty and succession of some sort of like rudimentary spiritual faith And these kinds of things and you know so It definitely had that sort of shine that sort of like I was I'm not saying that Isaac guys I was looking down at his nose on history, but it definitely has that kind of like America's inevitable or modern the modern age is inevitable and you there's nothing you can do to stop it because we've got the best Minds thinking of this. Okay, that's very much the thinking of 1950s America and that very you know and then you have The have you ever read the book the things called the smartest man in the room with smartest guys in the room? It's about McNamara So it's about that kind of thinking of if we just get the smartest analytical minds together to make our decisions we're gonna make sort of better decisions as as a government and And then the Vietnam War was sort of an example of you know, it didn't work out that way that We don't have enough time to get into Robert McNamara and and that kind of Hubris it's basically the hubris of analytics a little bit. Yeah, just so you referenced this the book title before Maybe just as a counterpoint to what I was saying about things being predicted the three body problems Yes, that's a book But the three body problem in physics is that if you take three planets or three orbs or three things that have a gravitational pull on each other And so they have a random motion that they're capable of making and they each influence each other.
That's the important part It's impossible to predict where there's three things will end up at T point in time. Yes So and I want to say it's like I don't think you can even predict the next time step So like the the chaos from there being so few Things and they're impacting each other makes it an impossible task and this isn't a computation problem It's that the range of where they could be is just too wide so that here's probably now that I the point I'm trying to get at is That's the reality of the universe But the cartoon version that a lot of people believe is that math and science can be Harry selden and can solve all of our problems Or we can predict all these things if we just have enough enough sort of data points And if we begin to if we organize society thinking that we could eliminate risk in society because we've got more advanced predictive power That's bad. That's a dangerous thing that there's gonna be a mutant one day. And you believe that precisely is I have predicted Anyway, that's a math prior to podcasting today boys.
It's a fun book It's maybe doesn't think it's fun. No first book reborn But it's kind of it's fun. I read it all the way through and then you will end it definitely gets better It's just characters because it's a consistent characters and all of a sudden It's not pretty to bowl It's not like Harry sounds gonna show up and be like you won the war because of your enlightened trade agreement It's like a fagory in the fair. Yeah, it's now you know This is the chaos has sort of re-entered the story and now then it becomes a kind of a better story is the third book pretty good I don't know Yeah, there's some yeah, although I don't want to spoil anything But the third book is fun the sort of denouement with the mule is really entertaining.
All right I'm interested. Um anyway, that's that's sort of all I got for this perfect Thank you all for listening This has been classical stuff you should know you can find us online at classical stuff not you can email us at the guys at classical stuff Not my mr. Twitter at classical stuff clsc al stuff You can also support us on patreon patreon.com slash classical stuff we post in between episodes after every episode We have monthly amas and we like actually reply to things on the patreon So like email, you know, we'll try and reply to your email, but like we really reply to patreon people so go there Uh, I think that's all that we have for today. So go for gram aj.
Thomas. We are signing off. Bye. Bye