Skip to content
202: Wayne Himelsein – Betting Against Stability episode artwork

Sep 4, 2020 1 hr 8 min

202: Wayne Himelsein – Betting Against Stability

from Chat With Traders Hosted by Kevin Avery

Wayne Himelsein begun his career on a proprietary trading desk at Carlin Financial Group in the mid-90’s, doing statistical arbitrage—complimentary to his mathematical nature. Come 1999, Wayne launched his first fund to begin managing money for clients and institutions. Then in 2011, Wayne founded Logica Capital Advisers, where he currently takes the role of Chief Investment Officer. Logica, as a quantitative investment firm, relies on rigorous research to develop its various model-driven strategies. For the most part, these are mean expansion strategies that generate alpha from being long volatility.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

202: Wayne Himelsein – Betting Against Stability

0:00 1:08:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Markets, speculation, and risk. This is the Chat with Traders podcast hosted by Aaron Fifield. What's up, folks? Welcome to Chat with Traders podcast number 202. Featuring on this episode, I have with me Wayne Hemelsein. Wayne is a clever mathematical mind who views markets through a quantitative lens. He started trading on a proprietary trading desk in the mid-90s doing statistical arbitrage. Come 99, Wayne launched a fund and began managing money for clients and institutions. Then in 2011, Wayne founded Logica Capital Advisors, where he currently takes the role of Chief Investment Officer.

Logica is a six-person team using various model-driven strategies, which, for the most part, generate alpha from trading volatility. So that's essentially what this episode is all about. After some brief discussion about Wayne's early prop days, we then move on to talk about trading long volatility, modeling methods, and Wayne impart some wisdom from his 25 years in markets. Just an FYI, this interview was recorded 9th of June, 2020. And if you do like this episode, Wayne's also done a really good interview with Real Vision TV that you might want to check out. I'll pop a link in the show notes.

Anyway, let's get to it now. Here is Wayne Hemelstein for episode 202. One of the places I'd like to begin with, and we won't spend too much time on this, but it might just be good for a little bit of context. You began trading mid-90s, I believe. Where did you start out and who were you trading for?

Sure. Yeah. So the firm, you're right, it was mid-90s, specifically 1995. So I can't get more mid than the middle. The firm was called Carlin Financial. And I say was because they actually acquired around the year 2000. They were acquired by Royal Bank of Canada. So it became RBC's prop desk. But Carlin was a really cool firm. And some history to that is, of course, I'm sure you've heard of Millennium Capital. So Millennium was started by two individuals, Izzy Englander, who's, of course, now famous for his involvement with Millennium and built it up. And then his partner, when it was first started, was a gentleman named Ron Shear. So they started together.

I guess over the first few years, returns weren't so hot or it wasn't working out as hoped. And so Ron and Izzy had some disagreement about the future and split up. And Ron said, I'm out of here. And he left to start a proprietary trading firm of his own, which was Carlin Financial. And so it was Izzy's ex-partner. And of course, the funny future story is that Millennium and Izzy went on to become one of the biggest, best hedge funds in the world. And Carlin, of course, was a good prop trading shop, but certainly not the magnitude of growth of Millennium. But that was its history. And Ron was an amazing trader. And I think what was most beautiful about the environment was the diversity of

trading styles on the floor. And so I was at their Midtown Manhattan office. I think they had about, let's say, 50 or so offices around the country. It was a decent-sized prop firm, I think one of the larger ones at the time. But the Mid-Manhattan office had some of the better, I guess, traders who had been at generally bigger shops before that and now had come to trade a mix of either their own capital, the firm's capital, a bunch of smaller hedge funds. But the nice part was that everyone, for the most part, had really good experience at some meaningful place. And I remember, of course, so well, the guy who sat immediately to my left had been on the floor of the, it was either the CBO, I forget exactly what, but he had been on a trading floor for, he told me, 13, 14 years.

everything that would come out of his mouth would be how you'd see the order flow on the floor. And so that's like on my left ear. And then my right ear was a Lehman Brothers fixed income arbitrator and eight, nine years at Lehman. And so he had just a completely different view of the world. And one's on my right, one's on my left. And this went on as you went on to the different desks or around the floor, I should say. There was that much diversity in views and approaches. And so that was just a beautiful experience to come out of college. I came out of UC Berkeley, I had a great education, but then to be immersed in this world of...

just knowledgeable traders doing so many different things and all very interesting. And me, I was just so immersed and absorbed in how much I could learn and grow in that environment. And I did. Being surrounded by such a diverse mix of traders, how were you trading in those early days? What type of strategies did you gravitate towards?

Yeah, that's a great question. Of course, we always gravitate to what is more naturally us, I guess, generally would be the path. For me, I had a really strong math background. I was always a quant at nature. When I say at nature, I just look to the world numerically or geometrically. When I was a little kid, I'd note things that were symmetric and things like that. It was who I was. It was in my blood, so to speak. For me, the natural inclination was anyone doing anything really quantitative. The discretionary traders who had ideas they'd talk about in companies, I was less interested in that, but I'd go sit down next to people who are running big spreadsheets and doing some...

other forms of programming and try to understand what they were doing and how they were viewing it. And so, yeah, the easy answer, high level, was quant. And then the more granular, the more mathematical it was, the more it intrigued me. And I remember that one of the early models that got my attention was a quant model in StadArb. And that was the first strategy that I fell in love with, was looking at a statistical view of the market to understand what was kind of normal or abnormal, I guess people would call it anomalous behavior, versus the normal, and using statistical methods to derive that or to extract that. So that fascinated me. And of course, therefore, I went down that road.

What sort of products or assets were you trading the arbitrage between? So at the time, my initial entry was through equities. I was trading just as simple as you call it, stocks, right? And I think that's certainly the right place to start. It was a good place for me to start just to get familiarity with markets. I was happy that I learned both along and the short side early on. A lot of traders start out more long, biased, or tilted. And I think for me, the idea of being around a lot of arbitrageurs who would take on trades, of course, that were both long and short, especially in Statarb, there's always a pair. I mean, in fact, they called it pairs trading as a nickname. So with that.

initial take on the market, I didn't have this early on get brought up, so to speak, with a directional view that the market had to go up. And so I was equally looking for longer short trades in equities. And then over the course of time, I started to get intrigued by options. And of course, once again, the mathematical nature of optionality and the mathematical modeling behind converting an underlying equity into an option was all just, you know, of course, Black-Scholes is the standard model. But the math behind that and how something could be a derivative of something else just pulled me right in. And so I got into options trading. And between the two, between equity and options, that's where my career has gone from there on with those two instruments.

Okay. Did you still go through the same stage of trial and error like many new traders do? I mean, I guess it was a great advantage that you were in this particular environment where you were surrounded by so many more advanced traders, but did you pick it up pretty easily? So, yeah, to your first question, did I go through trial and error? I cannot say without any, or I'll say with absolute certainty, yes, I did and have continued to. I think trial and error is the crux of everything. I think all we do is as we age and get wiser in the markets and learn more, it's going through those trials quicker and finding the errors better. But trial and error will never stop. That's the bane of markets always changing on you. So that was to answer that question. Yes, I went through trial and error. And yes, I had a leg up in the sense of the wisdom that was around me. Sorry, I forgot. What was the second part of your question? Did you pick it up?

Oh, I picked it up quickly. Yeah, yeah. So I did. I did because I guess I'm a smart guy, so that helped. But particularly on the quant side, the stuff was really intuitive to me. I call it a fish in water. And so I just loved it. I picked it up quickly. And the more I picked it up, the more I wanted it. I think there's this common among...

people who get good at stuff is having a passion for it because that drives you to want to put in the time. And so for me, I was right away passionate. And I remember half the trading floor, if not more than half, the majority of people would leave after the close. By 5 p.m. Eastern, everyone's gone. And I stayed and I was out there using all the computers and the systems. I'd stay till late in the evening. I was like one of the only people there when it got dark. It's just because I was so immersed in wanting to understand and wanting to know. And yes, it was easy for me. And yes, I was passionate. So put those two things together and you get better at stuff. Yeah. It's like when you're good at something, you kind of want to see how far you can take it.

Exactly, exactly. And it's enjoyable. I remember at the time, people tell me, you work too hard. They still tell me today. And I'm like, yeah, but I don't actually, I don't feel like I'm working. I'm having the time of my life doing this stuff. So I'm not really, I don't know what they mean when they say that. Right, right. So let's jump forward many years. I know we're missing a lot out here, but fast forward to, I think it was around 2011 when you formed Logica. Can you just briefly describe what is Logica today? Yeah, Logica today is, I'll say, the culmination of all my trial and error over 15, 20 years.

I'll call mean expansion investing or long volatility investing. And the way I understood markets from an early standpoint is, go back to the statistical arbitrage and all the different ARBs that people do, is there's a lot of reversion trading going on. And whether it's value investing, which is buying a position that people expect to revert, back to the upside, of course, or arbitrage trading, where there's a pair that's on and something that is out of whack, should come back together. So all of this was one side of the big market that a lot of people were doing. And I, early on, took this approach or the other side of that, which I call mean expansion. So that world fits into, for example, momentum or trend.

following. It's where you expect things to continue. It's the exact opposite of a reversionary trade. So all my education into investing in, I don't want to call it momentum because that really dilutes, it's such a broad category, but things like stocks that would break out to the top side or the convexity of options that, you know, the ways to participate through option structures, these versions of long volatility or mean expansionary investing all came together for me in my mind with starting logic to say is I want to come up with a better mousetrap for that type of investing. And one of the problems with long vol or trend following, all the things that fit into the expansion category is that they tend to have a low hit rate, meaning they can do well.

for a period of time, but you need to wait for that swing. It's like you have to be patient, and then a big swing comes, but you could wait a long time. And people will know that in options world, you can lose money month after month, and then eventually you have this big payoff. It's like the lottery, right? And of course, you get paid a bundle when you get paid because you have such an asymmetric payoff structure, but it can cost you either in actually losing money or just in not making any money and being flat in a period of waiting. And so I understood this, and I love long volatility and expansion investing. That's where all my...

career had been. But I understood its flaw or its void, which is having to wait or lose till you get that big payoff. So Logico was set up to say, how can I fix that hole? How can I be a long vol investor, but make money along the way, like they do in mean reversion, like they do in arbitrage. And that's what's so widely loved about the whole other side of the world, the mean reversion side, and all this arbitrage is that it's consistent. People pump out 50, 100 bips a month like clockwork, because that allows for it in that type of investing. But then to their void, they have this once in a while big drawdown. And so it's got what's called negative skew. It has a lot of little ups.

and once in a while, a big down. I like the idea of either flats and once in a while, a big up or being up a little bit. And then once in a while, an even bigger up, right? And so that became the core ideas. How do you achieve that? How do you take something that does have those big ups, but layer on it an ability to make money along the way? And that became, of course, many years of research and work. Okay. Well, I'd love to drill down into this further and spend a bit of time here talking about trading long vol. Sure. So just in very simple terms, what does it mean to trade long volatility? Like what is the objective here?

So going back to, I guess, what I just said in that last paragraph, or however long I was talking, was that volatility is mean expansion, right? So something is going to take off in a direction. And so I guess that's one side of it. I'll answer it in two different ways. So it's that pop or expansion that you want to take advantage of. That's one version of long volatility. You want to be long a big change.

Take the word volatility. Volatility is just, of course, uncertainty. So that's another way to think about it. But it's change, right? Low vol is less change, and high vol is more changing. So to be long change is to say, I expect a bigger change to occur. It's that simple. So if you expect a big change to occur, buying a lottery ticket is betting on a big change. You have $1, and you're going to make $100 million on this one exchange or on this one transaction. That's a long vol payoff.

That's one way of thinking about it. Also, being long vol is saying, I believe more that there's going to be more drastic change in the future than there has been in the past. So you, in a way, bet against stability. You bet against an environment that is just status quo and say, well, something drastic is on the horizon. And there's a big difference. People often associate long vol with being more focused on market downside. But for me, it's not. You can be long vol to the top side, too, meaning the easiest version of that actually just happened the last month and a half where we came off the March bottoms to now being basically flat on the air on the S&P with the V recovery. Yeah, vol itself.

crushed, but you could be long that expansion in the market. If you had bought the bottom on March 22nd or whatever that date was, that it was the absolute bottom and held that through today, to me, that's a mean expansion position in the market. You rode that whole thing up. And so it's a little bit of a conundrum because volatility itself, the way it's measured in the market, did come down over this period. But that would be that.

payoff structure, let's say had you bought a long call in the market, would be a long vault payoff because there's an extension to an extreme of the distribution. So, I mean, people talk about it in different ways and I guess more of the world is focused on volatility being to the downside, but I see it on both sides. And so, we're trying to take advantage of both sides of volatility. Okay. So, just to save any confusion, the way you positioned, you are market agnostic, like you have no bias on direction. Correct. Okay. Yeah. To me, it's dangerous to have that bias, but yes. Right. So, can you give an example?

for like a long vol model? Like how would you express a long volatility trade idea? Well, I mean, long volatility is the simplest way to think about it is through an option, right? If you're long vol and you want to take advantage of the market going up, you buy a call. That's as simple as it gets because by owning a long call, you are long volatility. You're in a volatility instrument, i.e. a call option. But you're betting on the market's upside. You're betting that the upside will be much more extreme than other people think. So what do I mean by that? I mean, as if you think the market's going to just cruise its way up.

Over the course of time, you would want a linear payoff to that upside movement, to that trend. If you believe the market's going to take off rapidly, there's convexity in that. You'd want a better payoff if you knew that information. If you knew that was going to happen, that'd be this huge upside move. You want to take a bet on that right tail payoff, so you do that through a call option. And then, hence, your long vol for what I call an upcapture. And it's different than sad. We don't use the words long or short because we are long all options. But if you're long a call, you're long upcapture. And if you're long a put, you're long downcapture is the way we talk about it.

Okay, so I think it might be interesting to pick up on one of the things you highlighted a little earlier. You spoke about how there can be kind of long periods where you may lose a bit of money or you certainly don't make much money, but then every now and then there's a huge payout. Sure. So how do you hedge your portfolio to minimize the bleed during those periods of what I presume would be low volatility? Yeah, so that's the magic, I'll call it. And that's what we spent many years trying to figure out, because that's the whole problem, is how do you make money while you shouldn't be making money, while you should be losing? So in that easy example, if you were betting on market upside, you can just get a longer call. And if you did that naively, you'd say, OK, I'm going to buy some S&P calls, and you're going to hold them for the month and roll them until the next month. And if the market doesn't do much that month, that's going to cost you. You're going to pay theta. You're going to pay for that cost of ownership for that long vol that you're buying, for that convexity that you're trying to own. That's going to cost you, of course, without price of the option and the decay of that option over time.

The easy answer for me, I guess, first, generally, I'll say that the way people traditionally finance that trade would be to sell optionality elsewhere. So if you want to be long in the market, you might say, OK, I'll buy a long call at this level, at this strike. I want to short a much further out call to give me some income to pay for this call because I don't believe I believe the market will go up maybe 10 percent, but there's no way it's going up 25 percent. So I'll short some up there where I think it's highly unlikely. And that income will pay for my for where I want to be long. So that's the traditional approach. I did not like that approach because I viewed it as.

being a counter trade. It's kind of going against what you want to be doing. And so my version or my method to paying for that ownership was, I realized, could be through trading. That was one of the components. Meaning, instead of just buying that call and holding it for the month and waiting for the market to do what it's going to do, one could trade around it, right? The way you might think a market maker could trade, right? So my experience on a trading desk was learning to trade. So the cool kind of realization for me was being able to lay over or...

combine trading with holding long volatility. And so how do you do that? You say, OK, instead of buying and holding this call for a month, do I believe that the market's going to be a bit down over the next few days, let's say, as a swing trader? I'd say, OK, it looks a bit toppy here, so it's going to pull in. So I'm going to sell some of the calls I have. And the market pulls in over the next few days. And then you buy them back. And you buy a bit more because it looks a bit oversold. And then the market runs up for the next few days. But you had more than you needed because you bought a bit more when it sold off. And so after it runs up, you take some off the table. You're taking a little bit of profit, but still keeping some of the calls you have. What you've effectively achieved, or if you can do that well as a trader,

you've maintained this long volatility exposure, scaling up and down your holdings. You're modulating your inventory. But by doing that, you're scalping. You're pulling out little profits out of the market, all the while holding on for this big pop for when it's going to happen, right? So if that lasts for two months, you're trading the noise while you're waiting for the pop. That's the idea. And that's what ends up working out, I guess, fairly well. And in fact, it has for us.

And even more so is aligned with volatility, because volatility itself tends to be a more mean reversionary asset, meaning it moves up and down a lot. So if you think about a low volatility environment, and I'll use an easy example of this, the year 2017. most people would agree, was a really, quote, low vol year, right? So you'd say to me, well, there's not much volatility there, Wayne. It's the lowest vol it's ever been. Let's say VIX down at 10. Yeah, sure. It was low vol. It was down at 10. But it didn't just sit at 10 every day. In fact, it moved from, let's say, 10 to 13. Let's just give it that small range. That's a small range, 10, 12, 11. And it's bouncing up and down with a little bit noisy around there and a few points of vol up and down. But 10 to 13 is 30% of movement. That's a ton. I mean, if I told you a stock's going to move 30% tomorrow, that's an incredible thing to trade as a trader, right? That's like trading Netflix or Google or whatever it might be.

So or probably Tesla, right? That's the kind of thing that moves a lot that you want to trade if you're a trader. So that idea that even in a low vol year, you get a lot of a lot of noise. And so if you could buy that vol every time it dipped down to nine, you bought up the VIX and it popped up to 11 and you sold some and then it popped back down to nine and a half and you bought it back and popped up to 11 and a half and you sold some. You're long the VIX the whole time, but you're trading the noise. You're scalping. And all that requires is being a good enough, I guess, swing trader to be able to buy those lows, sell those highs while maintaining your long vol inventory. And it even does exist during low vol years. That's the beauty.

When you are trading around in the noise, are these directional trades you're placing? They're directional. partly in the sense that, yeah, if you buy more calls, you're buying more upcapture, right? So there's a bunch of answers to that question. So the first answer is, yes, they're directional in the sense that you're adding or subtracting to a direction of the market. At the same time, the instrument itself has a convex, of course, upside and a concave downside. So go with the example that you buy some calls. If you're wrong the next day and the market continues going lower, your delta shrinks, right? You've got negative gamma. So you're less wrong than had you bought that underlying because it's like a bill.

in stop loss. The amount you're losing is shrinking really quickly. All you could lose at the end of the day is your premium. So if you had a hundred bucks and you spent only a dollar or 1% of capital on this long call, sure, you can make $10 if you're right, but if you're wrong, you could only lose a dollar. So in a sense, you're going more into a direction, but you've still, as a trader, capped your downside. So that's one kind of piece of the more complex answer. The other piece of that is that at Logica, because we're market agnostic, we're going to do that same thing on both sides. So as much as vol is coming down, I'm buying some more calls, I might be buying some more puts.

And effectively, we're adding upcapture and downcapture at different times. So we are definitely tilting. But then you end up trading not one side, but I guess the position would be called a straddle. Once again, a naive straddle would just be saying, I'm going to buy 100 calls and 100 puts from at the money. And so you wait for this V-shape to pay off your long both tails or your long upcapture, your long downcapture equally. The way you do it as a trader is say, I'm going to do that same thing, but I'm trading around the noise, but on both sides. So I might be adding a few puts, selling a few calls, adding a few calls, selling a few puts. Therefore, all the time.

You're anti-fragile in the sense that if the market goes extremely in one direction, you have convexity to that direction and concavity in being wrong. You're going to lose your premium on your puts, and you're going to make a bundle on your calls, or the opposite is going to happen. You're going to make a bundle on your puts, and your calls go to zero. It doesn't matter because you're along the other side. But you could trade the noise on both sides, and then each side is, quote, paying for itself. And collectively, the whole thing is paying for itself. That's, to me, the most beautiful trade there is because you're along the extremes. You're going to participate in both directions, but you're managing yourself. You're making money while you're waiting for those big pops. Now, just another question on this still.

Trading around in the noise, are these trades model-driven still, or is there some discretionary which comes into play? Yeah, so there's a beautiful interaction between the two, and I always struggle with this question. Not personally, but to me, it's such an inner weave in the sense that a model is discretionary because we, the human, built the model. I don't mean to be all philosophical here, but in a way I do because, yeah, I build a model, and it's a model, and everything that went into that model was how I understood as a discretionary trader how that... things should go. And all I've done really is codify the rules in my head. Okay, so now that's done. And that's a model. I say, okay, it's fully systematic. And then it starts trading. And let's say a month later, it does something that I'm saying, well, wait a second. That's not exactly what I would have done there. It really bought too much on that dip. And I don't like that. So I go back to the model and I tweak it for not being as sensitive to certain moves or changing its rate of modulation or whatever it is that I'm going to tweak as a parameter. Now it's a new model or it's a refined model based on my, once again, discretion. So for me, the idea of being systematic is nothing ever that's going to be plug and play or let's plug it in and leave it alone.

It's going to be forever infusing my discretionary understanding of markets and interweaving the two. Yes, I'm trying to codify all the rules and we want to just be able to plug it in and let it go. But it never works out that way because markets are always a little bit different because things change because this V recovery was unprecedented. The rate at which the market went back from its lows to now is just, I mean, I think it's definitely on record as one of the biggest moves in history. So had you built a model to all past behaviors, well, you wouldn't have captured this. So models work and then they don't work. And so I'm a big believer in a systematic approach to.

I'll say, set the boundaries of your trading and to give you a framework with which to trade, but we'll never stop. Every day I'm in the market understanding what the trade that's going on and asking myself, is that what I would do here? And if yes, all good. If no, go back to the model. And therefore, is it systematic or not? I'm not sure. It's both. Okay. That's a great answer. And I have quite a few questions for you around modeling, which we'll get to in just a moment. Just one last question before we do.

You spoke earlier about the insurance costs, I guess you could call it, the bleed, which can go on during low volatility periods and how you try to hedge against that. I guess that is one of the risks of running a long vol strategy. Are there other risks which are inherent to these types of strategies? I mean, I think all of the risk surrounds the cost of ownership. You call it the cost of insurance or the bleed. It's just how much of that risk, right? So in other words, if...

I guess you can be directionally wrong, but in a straddle, that's not going to happen. So if one gets tilted too much to one side, if you only bought calls or only bought puts, you can be in a much worse situation than if you're buying both because, of course, you can be directionally wrong and you can bleed. But given that you're in or that you take a market agnostic approach, you can't really be totally directionally wrong. So then it just becomes about the bleed. But the bleed itself isn't just, oh, you can bleed. There's many ways in which you can bleed, right? So you can bleed in, of course, just the market being still.

and not moving much. And you can bleed in being whipsawed, where you can, I guess, this would be really not as much a bleed, but more a directional misjudgment, where it goes one direction, you get tilted to one side, and then it goes the other direction, you get tilted to the other, and you keep on getting it wrong, because the market's just not doing what it's supposed to in your mind. So that's a kind of directional mismatching. But the other form of bleed is in volcrush, where the market can go up and vol could drop a lot. Vol doesn't always totally associate with what's going on in the world. I mean, right now, we'd say we've come.

back to all-time highs. I guess the QQQs have made all-time highs. S&P is right about flat on the year. But vol or the VIX is still up around 25. That's still close to two times the historical vol on the S&P. So with extended vol, you can be right in a direction. But if tomorrow the market goes up a percent and VIX crushes, let's say, 7%, you could have been right in buying your call, meaning your direction is perfect.

you lose more because vol crush more than the delta made, right? So your short vega is worse than your positive delta. That's the problem. So that's what I mean when I say there's different types of bleeds. You're more subject to bleed when the overall environment is at higher vol. And so you have to be more right on your directions or you have to do something else to manage that height of bleed. So I guess I can call it the magnitude of bleeding changes. And that's relative to where vol is and how choppy the market is around that position or around that vol. Okay, okay, gotcha.

Wayne, let's focus in a bit on modelling, just in general terms, and perhaps some words of wisdom for aspiring quants out there. My first question around this might be, what are some of the mistakes or the flawed practices which you made early on at the beginning of your trading career? I think, I mean, I'm very happy to say that I didn't make one of the worst mistakes or flaws, which is overfitting. I understood that from the very beginning. I understood that if you search enough in data, you can find anything. And I think that's not something that I was subject to so much, but I believe that that's something that is very prevalent or widespread. And so that's what I caution everyone about is the ability to find something. It's so easy to find something. Everyone's out there searching for...

different data sets and looking at different things at different angles and trying to find a pattern in data. And if you do that enough, inevitably, you're always going to find something. It just doesn't have any meaning, and it may not last very long. And so that's my biggest caution is the whole curve fitting mining concern. But I think that's known generally as a risk by people. I think the problem is not understanding in testing how easily that can creep up on you. And I think that's where, so I guess going back to myself, I knew intuitively that I can't just, I don't want to just search for a pattern. I want to have an idea in my mind and I want to look into the data to try to confirm that idea, right? So it's not seeking a pattern. It's seeking validation of something that my mind thinks it makes sense. So that was step number one. And therefore I had curve fitting or data mining licked from a top level. But where it went wrong for me, I guess.

or trial and error helped to learn was you can make those same curve-fitting mistakes even though you start with that premise, right? What I mean is that, let's say you have an idea and you test for confirmation or validation of that idea and it doesn't come out exactly as you hoped it would, right? And then you say, okay, well, let me turn that, let me shift, let me, you know, instead of... buying it every 10% down. I want to buy it every 9% down. And you test that. And so what you've done is you've started out with a good thesis that was independently hypothesized by you. And it's got a sound approach. But once you start testing and not getting the outcome you'd want, you start tweaking until you get the outcome. That's terrible, right? So it's terrible because you started out with a good thesis. You start out trying to not be a fitter, but then you became a fitter in the testing process. That's something that I probably made a mistake, not probably, I definitely made mistakes with early on and learned very quickly how incredibly aware one has to be.

on every test you do and every iteration you make to know that you're not biasing your test. It's almost unbelievable how we check ourselves today before, I'll say the time it takes, the biggest caution is taking time to set up a test. Today, when we have an idea, we don't just go do the test. We talk for hours, like brainstorming, like, is this the right test? And what are we missing? And you want to go through all this brainstorming and discussion just in setting up the experiment.

to know that you haven't done anything wrong in the experimental phase, then you go test. And if the results don't look right, then you move on to something totally different. I guess that's the biggest learned or trial and error learned lesson I've had over decades is getting better at that feature of testing. And it's just so easy to do. We so easily fool ourselves as humans, especially when we're, of course, biased to want to find something, right? When we're sitting there as quants testing, we want to find something. We wanted to dig for the gold and there's a little sparkle in the ground. Oh my God, I found it. And we want to make money. And so we're so inclined to believe quickly.

And it's much harder than people think to find things that work. And so most things don't. And therefore, spend more time being sure and spend more time setting up one's experiment and expect it not to work. And the anomaly should be when something does work out really well in testing. Okay, that's interesting. So you spend a lot of time, as you said, brainstorming these ideas all before you actually go to running a test. And if you run a test and the first iteration of that test shows undesirable results, you pretty much just abandon that idea altogether.

Yeah, it's a great follow-up question to what I just said, but the problem is there's nuance there, right? So would I say I abandon that idea altogether? Sometimes, yes. Other times, I'd say if there's something about the idea that struck me, then I may not abandon it altogether. I might sit there and think or discuss and talk about what did we miss. What I will not do is say, okay, let me just shift this one parameter by seven degrees and retest. That's the big no-no, right? So there's somewhere in between.

Tweaking parameters of a model and going back to the drawing board and saying, OK, we believed, and whatever, what's some silly thesis? We believe growth outperforms value. And I get into that big debate. And that's not the kind of things that we do at Logica. But just to talk about that one as an easy concept. So you could do that and say, OK, and you do a test and it doesn't work. Say, OK, let's try, instead of big caps, let's try small caps. Well, it worked over there. So that's interesting because we understand the difference between big caps and small caps. And why growth would be more powerful in small caps makes sense because there's perhaps more room to grow if you're small versus when you're already big. So in that example, there's a...

When you tweaked that parameter to look at not large caps, but small caps and trying to identify the benefit of growth or the alpha in growth, you've not just tweaked it by some mathematical metric. You've sat at a table and said, wait a second, maybe large caps don't have as much room to grow versus smaller companies because by definition, there's more room. And of course, we'd say this is not true of Amazon or some of the bigger boys, but put the anomalies aside, is that there's a sound reasoning behind. changing a parameter and now going to a new test where you've deliberated and you've understood what was wrong in your first experiment and why in your next experiment, you've stuck to the core idea that there's alpha in growth, but you've changed a parameter that has a reasoning for it to change and a logic behind why the new one should work. So that's the difference between just saying, I'm going to run this array of tests and find something. Does that make sense or is that helpful to that answer? That does make sense, yes. As you stated that most or in all cases, before you run any test, there's always a goal and a brainstorming process which takes place beforehand.

For newer traders out there and aspiring quants in particular, where do those ideas come from? How do you form those goals? Yeah, that's a great question. The toughest part is the paradox, I guess, is that you said for aspiring quants, is that for me, those ideas have come from experience. So how do you put experience in a new trader, right? That's tough. On top of that, though, I think there's, if I had to say, like the merging of three different things. So one is, of course, experience. Two is reading and just absorbing from other.

great investors slash traders out there. When I was young, I stayed late at the trading firm, and then I went home and read a book. It's just absorbing yourself in what all the wisdom before you has had to share, reading and taking in all you can from those who have done it. The third thing is trading on your own capital. I can't stress that enough. This idea of simulating and idea of paper trading and all that is just absolute nonsense because all of it comes down to emotion. People try to

build systematic approaches because our emotions can do us wrong. And as much as they're systematic, people go in and try to trade a systematic approach and they end up over trading it or disagreeing with it. And it's because the emotions always come in and you say, oh, this doesn't feel right. And you do something different. And so for me, the biggest gain in ideas has been just literally to put money in an account and start doing it. And I tell this, I get into a bunch of conversations. I do a lot of tweeting and I guess I like the Twitter environment. And a lot of people ask me, they DM me, new traders know, what's the best way to start? And my answer generally is open an account and put in some money and start trading. I can't think of a better version of gaining real life experience on your own capital to feel what it feels like when you're sitting there and you think something's a good trade and you get in and then the floor just drops and it just starts falling rapidly. And what do you do? And your body freezes up. And understanding how those behaviors work and how you feel and how the market...

does it and where so many times traders will say like something goes wrong against them and they stop out and then two minutes later it reverses right and it's like this common not it's a common thing that people talk about is being that that being shaken out that's because everyone behaves the same and so unless you go in there and do it you don't learn that behavior and once you learn that behavior by doing it then you could start to model you know okay now i can see like it's where my emotions are coming into play and where behaviors need to be overridden by certain rules and so you can better build a mousetrap by knowing what it is that you're that's going on uh so that's where my advice i guess culminates yeah great Are there any testing or modeling methods which you use that are unique in some way, you know, from common practices in the industry or common practices used by, you know, quants just generally speaking? Yeah, I mean, I'd say that we generally don't like to use just what's out there, the off-the-shelf models.

Um, there's a lot of stuff that you can, I mean, I know people read and I do too, the white papers, there's new ideas every day and being published. And I guess I have the general feeling that if it's a white paper and it's being published, especially if it's published by AQR, uh, who are putting out so many, like it's like the market knows that you're not going to learn anything there that know that people are sure. Sure. It can continue working. I'm not, that's, you know, maybe it will, maybe that's just enough of the way the market works, but if it's a white paper, you're not the only one who has seen it. Right. And so if there's some mathematical approach that, you know, in volatility investing, people use Garch as a very typical model for the way volatility behaves. Uh, and so.

What we say is we're not going to use any of that. We're not going to do something off of a white paper. We're not going to do something. We're not going to use GARCH. We're going to develop our own stuff based on how we understand it. And so, for me, the beauty of that in using, I'll call it proprietary mathematics, is that, yes, you can be wrong, but by definition, you'll be different. And if you can figure out something that has alpha, where you can be, quote, right, and you're using different mathematics, then people won't come upon it, right? And don't go issue a white paper on it, because then it will be known, and then you'll be competing with yourself and all the others that saw it from you, right?

And I think my broad answer will be that, yes, we do all our own stuff. We use interesting mathematical approaches. I like integrating, I guess, more disconnected ideas in mathematics. So, for example, the PhD that we have in-house is an algebraic geometer, right? So what does that mean? His PhD is in the combination of algebra and geometry. And those two are beautifully intertwined. It's a little bit of math history. Here's the first formula or algorithm that combined.

algebra and geometry was the Pythagorean theorem, right? That you could take this A squared plus B squared equals C squared, that there's this algebraic formula that perfectly fit this geometric shape, that the hypotenuse would be the square of the two sides, right? That's a cool way that geometry and algebra came together, and that was the first one where they did come together. So building on that approach, now come shoot forward thousands of years in markets. people can use algebra, but you could also use geometry. And so for me, when somebody is looking at, for example, standard deviations, I want to look at that topologically. I want to look at that in geometric space. What are the distances between two things? That's more interesting than how much they specifically deviate as a percentage. And if you can come up with distance relationships and what that means, and do things take on certain shapes or symmetries? These are ways of using mathematics and doing things differently than most other people are. And I think they help if you can figure stuff out using such approaches. Just out of curiosity, what is your level of mathematical education? How much of this is self-taught versus formal education?

Yeah, so it's a nice mix. Probably not probably most definitely more self taught because I'm so much older than I have been out of school now for 25 years. So by definition, I have more time out of school than in school for four years. Right. So therefore, I definitely have more self teaching. So the background for me is I certainly had a.

strong mathematical understanding or as i talked about earlier as a kid i just i saw things numerically very easily and so i had that intuition um in fact so much so that i got more advanced in math as a youngster and um in high school i was so advanced over my peers i started university level math and getting through i remember i was like sorry i guess college calculus in 10th grade of high school and so i was really leaping ahead But then the funny thing happened to me is because I was taking all these college classes when I was in high school, by the time I actually got to college, I was kind of sick of math, right? Or I was just like, I had been that youngster in the college classes, the high school kid in there. And so when I got to college, when I actually went to formal university, I thought to myself, all right, at that point, I didn't want to do it anymore. I didn't want to be that. I had kind of negative experiences with being the younger kid in those college classes while in high school. So I said, you know what? I'm not doing any much math. And I was able to transfer all my credits because I did so much university work. And so I actually...

took on an English degree and did English and creative writing out of Berkeley. So in that way, I didn't formally go further with my math education, but I was this advanced math kid. So when I came out of college and then got into the real world, of course, my love for math was quickly pulled back in. But what it gave me the opportunity to do is to understand things really quickly in the mathematical realm and to be able to pick up where I left off and then self-educate for the next 25 years. So my love, my passion, my intuition for math has grown.

a lot of education in me, but formally it wasn't actually even that much other than this advanced stuff I did early on. So I love the way it came together for me because it allowed me to see things in different ways than people learned who did the, I'll call it the formal route. For someone who doesn't have a strong mathematical education, but is very interested in quantitative trading, do you have any advice for someone in that situation? Yeah, I mean, I would liken that to myself, right? Is that if somebody has the interest, and not just the interest and passion, but the intuition in math, if you're intuitively good with numbers and with understanding that sort of thing, then self-education is amazing. I mean, it's incredible what you can get online now. And I mean, they didn't even have as much of it when I was, I mean, they did, of course, 25 years ago. Wikipedia was still around, right? Or was already around, I should say.

Today, there's even more. I mean, the classes that you can get through Coursera or any number, I mean, through Khan Academy, it just goes on and on and on. I mean, there's online classes out of every major Ivy League put through different online entities. So one can fully educate. I mean, you can give yourself a PhD if you want to by just taking online stuff. The answer is if you have the passion and the basic understanding and intuition, then just get out there and do it. Grab everything you can and learn, learn, learn. I mean, that's what I...

did for myself over decades. And you just keep on going. I mean, again, it's like that thing where we were saying earlier is if people say you work too hard, but no, not if you love what you do, then it's not really work. So same for me. It's like on the weekend, I read math stuff because I'm so just interested in it. In fact, I remember there's a funny story. I was out, I'm a big cyclist. I go biking. It's my kind of sport of choice. And for many, many years, I was listening to math lectures in my iPod while I'm biking. I was out somewhere biking and I ran into somebody I knew and he saw my, I had my iPhone, I had my little earphones in and he knew me. He walked up to me and he said, oh, what do you listen to? And he grabbed my ear.

thing and he stuck my the one the left he pulled the left he stuck it in his ear and there's some like you know partial differential equations he's like what the hell is this right and that's but that's what i wanted to do when i was biking and it helped me to like take it in as i you know because i was concentrating on listening i could climb the hill better right so that's my answer is if you love something then do it and you can learn all you you want um and um and if you if you have the intuition then it'll come to you that's a great little anecdote there um yeah just jumping back into uh modeling Before jumping on this call with you, Wayne, I spent more time than I expected to scrolling through your Twitter feed. It was just fantastic. Thank you. One of the things I pulled from it was you had a tweet about trade frequency and the importance of it. And I think you may have called it mastering the art of trade frequency. So I just thought that would be an interesting question to ask you to get your thoughts on the importance of trade frequency, I guess.

So trade frequency is, I'll say, I love that idea in the sense that there is no right frequency, right? There's not an absolute version that works. And so the important point is that one has to use multiple frequencies. And the market actually shifts. A lot of the time, the general behaviors don't shift, but the frequency shifts, right? So markets run up and down, but at different frequencies. And so it's very, very hard to time, just like it's hard to time a regime shift, let's say, from a value to a growth regime or on the broader level of factors. It's equally difficult, if not more, to really hone in on the right.

frequency and or shift in that frequency. So my general approach, and that's something that we do in Logica, is to have multiple frequencies running at the same time. And it's like, I guess I liken it to hedging, right? So let's say I have one frequency in which we do, which is which day trades, right? It makes a trade per day. And another frequency, let's say, which twice a month trades and another which is monthly, right? So you have slower and slower at different rates. So what could happen there is on a day trading level, the market's overdone. And so you take some off the table, you sell some S&P, let's say. But the next day, of course, unemployment comes out.

the number on Friday much better than we expected, right? Still drastic, but of course, much better than the world thought or the US thought. And so boom, the market caps up 2%. So as much as the day before was extended and your day trade sold some, took some off the table on your two-week frequency trade, you still were net long, right? So you're hedging not being wrong. And so it's not that one was wrong or not that the day trade decision to take some off the table was incorrect. It's that both were correct.

that each is correct under its own time frame. And I can't stress that enough. And the market, people use these words of, you know, that your profit or loss being right or wrong. It's not really right or wrong. It's that there's a lot of different things going on. And a day trader is right to have taken an overbought position off the table. But if you're a month-long trader, you want to hold on to that mean expansion longer. And so by having both, you're hedging your own ability to time. And you're taking both approaches that over time can be successful. And of course, merging them to have a more, I guess, noise canceling the downs. And of course, hopefully keeping the alpha associated with whatever edge you have in each frequency.

Wayne, let me ask you one last question. As someone who mostly ignores macro, more focused on the math and in their trading, what have been the greatest observations for you from this recent market crash and recovery? Like, as you said before, it's probably been the greatest rise in markets which we've seen for a long time. And I think very few people expected to see this and people have been making predictions everywhere and almost everyone's been wrong about what's actually happened. What has this taught you or what has this, if not taught you, what has it kind of enforced?

It's enforced to keep on ignoring macro. As simple as that. Two things. I want to say that, and then I want to actually contradict myself in a second. So the first thing is that what's long been my premise is that nobody has any idea. The funny thing is I actually did an interview a while ago, which was after the December 18th.

sell-off in January 19 recovery. And what I talked about on that cast was how wrong people got it, right? In December of 18, as the market's selling off, people are saying, our economy's done, and this is it. The bubble has burst. And then three weeks later, in January of 19, everything's back to normal. The market's right back up, new highs, and nothing happened. And I was talking about how wrong everybody got it on that V and how doomsday the world got. And it became on the initial weeks in December. And then suddenly, how optimistic everybody was in late January.

And lo and behold, the exact same thing happens again, right? In February, March, the world was ending. This was worse than 08. This was going to be the gloom we've all been waiting for. And here we are again, having made new highs on the NASDAQ and close to it on the S&P.

So the highlighted point is, once again, nobody knows. Once again, people get the emotional behavioral side really always just falls into the what's happening now. And if you look at even the Twitter environment, the FinTwit, or the media in general, most of the panic is associated with what happened in the market today and yesterday. And that tells us so little. And all the people that follow that media end up getting immersed in what's being said now, which is just a function of what just happened, which inevitably tells us nothing about the next two weeks. So I double, triple, quadruple down on that thesis.

OK, so that's that's where everything stays the same. On the other side of that, I've had a really amazing new experience in the last year where I actually took on a new partner, somebody I finally met on Twitter, Michael Green. He was at the time he was working at Teal Macro and he had traded in the fall space for a while. And so we came together and just having a common respect and understanding what each other was doing, I guess, having found each other on Twitter and met and started talking about some stuff that was I didn't know about. But he was sharing with me that there was this big reasoning from a macro perspective of why the trades I was putting on were working really well.

And, you know, he basically said to me, it's like, yeah, you're producing alpha, but it's not all yours, right? And in a very polite way, like maybe, you know, you have something for sure, but there's more alpha associated with what's happening in the market as a function of passive, the growth of passive and how that's distorting the market where you have this, I'll call it agnostic. buyer, so a long-only buyer, whose basic model is if cash, then buy. And every two weeks, everybody's paycheck dumps more money into this premise, if cash, then buy. And here's every two weeks, more cash in everybody's retirement. And of course, corporate match plans and all the rest, trillions of dollars that's going into the stuff on a regular basis, just buying, buying, buying. And by definition, exacerbating momentum, because the more the stock is represented in the S&P, the more it gets bought. So passive indexing becomes the self-fulfilling prophecy. And so all of his work around, from a macro perspective, how that has been influenced.

investing market structure over the last 10, 20 years. opened my eyes to this whole new framework of macro, which is not to say we're going to use macro to predict the future or to make a forecast about the economy in six months. It's that we're going to use macro to understand the structure of the market and therefore how we can better profit off of that. And so integrating Mike's work with what I was doing, we now had a better mousetrap because we could say, OK, that does make sense. That's why a straddle, you know, a lot of short vol exposure out there is helping push down the pricing of our vol we're trying to get long. And so this call overriding is bringing down the price of calls that we're trying to get long. That's why there's a little bit more alpha there. So yes, I had a good idea, but I was being helped by this large.

larger structural dynamic of the market. And so I now have come to a newfound appreciation for macro in its ability to help explain what's going on and to help, I guess, structurally build a model or to design a model to what could be more of a thesis behind why something's working. And so again, we're not using it for making predictions other than saying, hey, if this is going to continue, which it looks like it will, as just in line with the US population and growth, then... The market should continue to do this. Therefore, we can make certain bets. Therefore, we could bet more on extreme outcomes. Therefore, what happened in February, March, and now April, May, this insane V in the market.

was to be more expected given the influence of passive. This explains it better. Therefore, going back to what we were talking about before, trade frequency, if that's the case, then we have to slow down or perhaps speed up or make changes to our trading cadence because this is the market will take on more extremes based on the influence of passive. So it just adds this whole new dimension to what we're doing. And so for me, it's a way to infuse a macro view without actually being a forecaster, which is what I'm always going to stay away from. That's brilliant.

Wayne, thank you very much for coming on the podcast. Very grateful for your time. This has been an incredible conversation. So yeah, once again, thanks a lot for coming on the podcast. If somebody wants to follow you or connect with you online, where is the best place to do so? And I know you also have a nonprofit as well. So would you like to give that a mention?

Sure. Yeah, the nonprofit. Wow. I started that back in 2003. That's called Informed by Nature. I just love, love, I guess, scientific thinking and rigorous experimentation and this mathematical view of the world. And so as a believer in that, I wanted to fund some projects that did that type of thing. And at one point, we had these little solar cars that kids were building in a classroom and things like that. It's done different things. Right now, we work with some journalists who are promoting some kind of innovative scientific ideas and another group that does a science camp for budding scientists, younger scientists.

are scientific thinkers. And so it's just a way to give back to the world for me, what has helped me so much along my path and the way I think. So that's what that does. And then... how to get ahold of me. That's pretty easy. I guess I'm on Twitter, right? And to your point, I've got my, a lot that I like to say stuff often, and I've got a lot of thoughts that I like to share. So there, my handle is just my first and last name, at Wayne Hemelstein. And so, and from there, my firm, Logica, of course, we're at logicafunds.com. So that's easy. And I guess, you know, if one were to just Google me, there'd be a lot of stuff, I'm sure. That's what people tell me. These days, I think anyone's easy to find, right? We're Google away. But yeah, I definitely think that if someone's interested in hearing more, then my Twitter is a great place to start because I love sharing my thoughts as they come.

Yeah, folks listening to this podcast, I would certainly encourage you to follow Wayne on Twitter. You know, there's very little fluff, very little feel good stuff. It's just a lot of really wise thoughts. So we're worth your time. Wayne, thanks once again. And hopefully we'll chat again soon. Thank you. Thank you very much. You've reached the end of this episode of Chat with Traders. But rest assured, there are more episodes loaded with real market insight and zero hype on the way soon. So to stay updated with each great new release, subscribe to the podcast on iTunes. And we'd love it if you'd leave a rating and review. We'll catch you next time on Chat with Traders.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Chat With Traders?

This episode is 1 hour and 8 minutes long.

When was this Chat With Traders episode published?

This episode was published on September 4, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Chat With Traders episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.