Skip to content
2021 In Review episode artwork

Dec 16, 2021 50 min

2021 In Review

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week, Toby Hemmings discusses the biggest stories of 2021 with Jacqueline Maley, columnist for the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, Kishor Napier-Raman, federal politics reporter for Crikey and Rachel Baxendale, Victorian political reporter for The Australian.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

2021 In Review

0:00 50:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Great news, the Federal EV rebate is back. Eligible customers get up to $5,000 with the Federal EV AP rebate on select 2027-volt and 2026 Equinox EV models. Visit your local Chevrolet dealer today for more details. Hello and welcome back to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism.

Coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on Gagga Lands of the Aura Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device via podcast. I'm Toby Hemings. 2021 is coming to a close and for many of us, it's the dog days of a long year. While 2020 may have been the year where the world was upended, 2021 has not been the return to normalcy that many of us were hoping for.

Today, in our final new episode for the year, we're looking back at the big stories from COVID-19 to Christian Porter and examining how well the media did in covering the stories that defined the year. Joining me in studio is Khashore Napier-Ramin, Federal politics reporter for Krikey. By Azum, we're also joined by Jacqueline Mele, columnist for the City Morning Herald and The Age and Rachel Baxondale, political reporter from the Australians Melbourne Bureau. Jacqueline Mele, Rachel Baxondale and Khashore Napier-Ramin, welcome to Fourth Estate.

Thanks for having us. Thanks for having me. How are you doing? Thanks for having me.

Let's start with the pressing topic of the day as much as we might not want to cover it. COVID is the undisputed biggest story of the year and it seems that it's ending the year with a bit of a bang. There's a lot of uncertainty around the new variant spreading, Omocron. Given the limited information we have around this variant, I suppose I should open by asking what do you think journalists should have learnt from covering Delta that they can then apply into covering this new variant?

And I might start with you, Rachel. You were introducing us to that question. I thought about where we were this time last year. I think there was this feeling of certainty that 2021 couldn't possibly be as bad as 2020.

Eventually we're all going to get vaccinated and things were going to be better. Certainly in Victoria, we'd locked down and had worked against the pre-alpha variants. Although it was long and painful, we had got through that. I think there was this feeling.

Even if we ended up with more cases, even if we got more leaks out of hotel quarantine, we were going to be able to deal with that. I am still optimistic. We are in New South Wales and Victoria today. We've got the highest case numbers that we've had in six weeks.

New South Wales has got the highest case numbers they'd ever had. But we're not seeing, and yes, it's early days as a bit of a lag effect. We're not at this stage seeing the numbers of death and hospitalisations that I corresponded with these sorts of case numbers in a second wave or even with Delta. I think that should be caused for great optimism.

But I guess it is a bit of an unfortunate reminder that we're not out of this, that we're not just going to snap back to 2019 normal. Possibly, I think, because everyone's vaccinated, moving into a phase in our lives where, and I welcome this, where we possibly will have a little bit less government control and we might have to take a bit more personal responsibility. We might have to use common sense and get a rapid antigen test if we know we're going to be seeing older, more vulnerable people, for example. What about you?

What do you make of how we can cover on a crime going forward? Well, I think the thing to say is what we're seeing at the moment was utterly, utterly predictable. When we opened up, we were going to eventually see a rise in cases. It obviously took some weeks for that to really kick into gear in New South Wales.

But we knew that at some point there probably would be a new variant. I think the thing to say about Omicron was, it seems to me that there's still a lot we don't really know about it. But what's been fascinating is to see that the responses to Omicron have fallen down very predictable lines. You've got people who have generally been a bit more, I would say, risk averse or maybe to be less polite, alarmist in how they view the COVID situation sort of being glass half empty about Omicron, pointing to the fact that they think it might have made vaccines, pointing to one small study about how effective AstraZeneca is against it and holding that up.

And then on the other hand, you've got the COVID optimist, the half-glass full-type people who have talked about how it's maybe a milder variant. And I think both camps probably are partially right on some aspects of Omicron. The fact is that we just don't know a huge amount. So I think the thing to say here, from a perspective of the journalist covering it, is I think to, I guess, be very wary of how little we know and maybe be able to about that.

Take with a grain of salt any kind of prescriptive definitive sort of prediction about what's going to happen. A really interesting example of that is, yes, Brad Hazard came out with this figure that we could have 25,000 cases a day in Sydney, New South Wales, rather in January. Now, we've seen throughout the pandemic lots of big, modelled numbers have been thrown out and sometimes they've been accurate, often they've been not accurate. Those numbers do scare people, they make a good headline, they make a good news lead.

But often I think that that has to be tempered with a bit of like Rachel was saying, people taking their own personal responsibility for things and also understanding that, yeah, this is just going to be the next phase of the pandemic. It was always going to look like that. Reopening with high case numbers was always going to lead to this kind of situation. And it's deeply unfortunate that that could ruin Christmas in New Year for a lot of people.

But I think we've got to keep a sense of calm about the place because I think that is important to given how stressful and anxiety inducing these last, however many months have been for most of the country. If we can jump backwards in time to the dominant variant for the majority of the year, Delta, there was a bit of a narrative being pushed by some journalists and medical experts regarding AstraZeneca. Now at that time there was a lot of rhetoric around that AstraZeneca was a subpar vaccine for protection against the Delta variant. And also there was a lot of concern regarding the extremely rare blood clotting side effects.

Kishore, I can take you back. Do you think that the media was too quick then to write AstraZeneca off particularly given what would then transpire in later months? Sure. I think the media did make a lot of errors around AstraZeneca.

I think part of that was, you know, there were tabloid papers, you know, putting AstraZeneca blood clot shame and putting pictures of people in hospital with a clot on the front page and splashing that around. I think that was in retrospect very dangerous and even at the time quite dangerous. I think you also had quite prominent media experts and commentators who I think were generally quite risk-averse about all the pandemic and I think maybe put that risk version into how they assessed the effectiveness of AstraZeneca and really over-height both the side effects and how effective it was. But equally, I would say the media is not the only sort of institution that was at fault there.

I think the messaging out of the government on AstraZeneca was quite hopeless. I mean, Scott Morrison holding a press conference, what was it, like 11 minutes after a Tiger had given him new advice about the risk factors and not communicating that very well. The Tiger itself, not communicating that very well. Labor, not communicating it very well because they had a vested interest in trying to own Scott Morrison.

Everyone made a bunch of mistakes there around AstraZeneca and yes, in retrospect, it meant that we perhaps didn't get the speedy uptake of the vaccine rollout that we could have got. I was very proud to have gotten my AstraZeneca job back in the middle of the year. Me, who? Yeah, there you go.

And look, purely anecdotally, but having been in close contact situations, having known other people with AstraZeneca that have been in super spreader events and not picked up COVID, I mean, seems to be doing some work. I love that we've reached the stage of politicization of the pandemic but we're now having like, you know, vaccine branding wars. AstraZeneca is always a Chad vaccine. Yeah, yeah.

AstraZeneca heroes out there in front. Jacqueline, do you think that we are really focusing on vaccines as the dominant way of dealing with this virus? Is there something else that we should be potentially looking at going forward? Well, I think a couple of things.

I do think it would be interesting to see how the booster rollout goes because this is purely anecdotal that I've been trying to get a booster for Pfizer and haven't been able to get one for level money around where I live. And I just wonder if the government has been caught a bit short in terms of supply for boosters. That will be extremely politically disastrous for them, I would say. And the other general point I'd make is just there's a conflict there has been a conflict the whole way along between government and the sort of health authorities who want to push a public health message and also a political message and journalists in the media who are not in the business actually of public health messaging.

That's not our job. It's the environment in which we should operate for sure and we should operate with responsibility and with always with a view to the highest difficult standards. An example that I was thinking about was Dominic Peritay at his press conference yesterday. There's some people who think that Dominic Peritay is going too hard and too fast with New South Wales opening up.

There's all these scary statistics around that Kishol was just talking about in terms of modeling and he was sort of chastising the media or focusing on case numbers when he wants the media to focus on hospitalizations and death rates. Now I can see why he wants people to focus on that stuff and I think it's probably for the better of the psychological health of the community if we focus on just hospitalizations and death rates rather than huge case numbers. But it's just sort of an interesting thing because who's here to tell journalists which numbers they shouldn't report? Like if there's case numbers to be reported, their facts that we should present to our readers or our listeners.

And then on the other side you have the Aspisernica scare campaign. I mean it was treated responsibly I suppose by some media but again if people are getting blood plots from the vaccine that's being rolled out pretty quickly, that kind of is a story, right? So I don't know. I think there's just been a sort of clash and the thing that I found even more tedious than the pandemic itself is just the extreme politicization that we've seen and the fact that yeah you have to have a position on a vaccine brand or strong positions that people have on lockdowns or on masks even.

I mean it just strikes me that that is a very modern disease that they maybe didn't have in the Spanish flu epidemic or the Black Plague. But it's just a very much a sort of symptom of social media I suppose. Continuing on from what Jacqueline was saying about the politicization of this, I think that's been a really interesting thing as a journalist. I mean I think in Victoria, Stainland is very good at kind of setting up a you know you're either with me or against me kind of dichotomy which I think is very often a bit of a bit of a false dichotomy.

And very often his line has been to journalists and the way he kind of projects for Victorians is to sort of imply that if you're even questioning what I'm doing here you're somehow you know against the health advice and you know you basically want to kill Victorians and that's been kind of an interesting position to find yourself in as journalists and I think as journalists we've got better at it I think in Victoria throughout the two years of really fighting because I will know we're not questioning the health advice. They're conflicting health advice. They're a different expert saying different things. It's our job to question this and make sure that you know we really are doing the best we can.

And the Dan Andrews thing is like there is no higher moral ground than I'm on the side of protecting people's lives. You're either with me or against me and if you're against me you're essentially trying to kill people. Like there is no higher moral ground than that and it's also so disingenuous the way the politicians have tried to convince us throughout the pandemic that they don't have any sort of difference in interest to the public health authorities and of course they do. I'm not saying that they've been blatantly political in their treatment of people's lives or people's safety but they have a different set of interests and it's our job to sort of try to pick apart that different set of interests which I would say you know a lot of people think is happening in these self-laws at the moment where there's a bit of divergence maybe between the political and interest of the government and what the public health authorities think we should be doing.

Building off of that it must be hard to be a journalist in these situations attempting to critique power and actually interrogate these decisions regarding the health advice when on social media you have cheerleaders basically people acting for the government who are quite vocally pro or quite vocally anti-government actions in 240 characters or less. I mean Rachel you've been really on the front line of this scrutiny from Twitterati, whoever you want to call them these people who are tweeting about this. How do you navigate that when you're just trying to do your job? Yeah I've got used to it.

It was a point sort of in the middle of 2020 where there was kind of this sudden wave and you know all of a sudden I was weirdly trending on Twitter and it was all quite bizarre and it took me a little while to come to terms with it and you know I probably took to heart a lot of stuff that I really shouldn't have and wouldn't now to better all work I think I've developed a pre-16. So conversely that's our job of work out how to get out the truth and we will face obstacles in doing that. I think you know social media probably is an obstacle that previous generations of journalists haven't had to deal with in quite the same way but it's also a double edged sword. I think you know as time went on I realized that you know as much as I was dealing with all kinds of nonsense and death threats and rape threats and nasty stuff on Twitter.

So every one of those I was getting 10 really nice messages and more to the point when I was doing my job I was getting messages from people who were giving me really interesting stories and they knew where to find me whereas previously they might not have you know realized that that was a way that they could sort of shed light on what they were going through. Because sure I know you're also hopelessly online in terms of how you've seen this year play out online do you think there is a divide between people who are consuming news media outside of social media and how they see what's been unfolding as opposed to people who are following these profiles who are tweeting out these things in quite inflammatory and high modality language. For sure it always fascinates me when I log on and I find you know regular people they're not the news media or anything like that but they spend 20 hours a day on Twitter and have very strong opinions about specific journalists and go down wormholes of all these absurd conspiracy theories about the way an ABC news presenter contorted her face when talking about Dan Andrews and other states of power, saying shit like that I'm just like oh my god go outside and touch grass for God's sake. I mean I'm on this platform all the time and I rationalize it because it's like I don't know important to my job as some rubbish but you guys have no excuse like get off do normal stuff I don't know but yeah no I think it's probably just been a symptom of so many people being sort of stuck indoors for a long time and the COVID situation is unique and that we've not had a singular story that's dominated everything in that kind of way in anyone's lifetimes really.

While some aspects of the COVID response to falling down partisan lines I think what's been really interesting is how something's about COVID sort of fractured those partisan lines. Traditionally you had a lot of progressives who are I would say quite pro things like lockdown and you know water colleges and that kind of thing out of this sort of progressive protecting the community kind of ethos but then interestingly you had more libertarian minded people on the left of politics who ended up agreeing with IPA guys and people on Sky News and they came out from a lot more of a I suppose anti-authoritarian progressive perspective. I think all of those kind of fissures that were going on within existing ideological groupings I think made people a bit more insane because you're like suddenly seeing people that you've agreed with about so many things all your life on the different team with COVID and again it goes back to what we're talking about before with the politicization of the response and the tribalism and everything like that you know adding the being stuck at home being able to do nothing post-dune scroll and that kind of like weird partisan shifting that was going on that idea of wanting to be on a certain team on the COVID front and I think it just did cook a lot of people's brains and that's probably why my mentions are often so cursed every time I say the word Victoria in a tweet. My column is in the sun age as well as the Sun Herald in Sydney and I must say whenever I mention into talking about Dan Andrews you just get so much well you get a lot of anger and emails as well as tweets but there are also other people who are like thank you for questioning the line on this but it's kind of a weird position to be in because you're like this is the readership at the age right so how much do you write against your readers like how much do you sort of what an alien age of like the readership I've had conversations with the Sun Age where he's like just be really careful man because you're not down here and everybody here is going through this really difficult time and everyone's a bit crazy so just just tread lightly.

You are writing for your readers and it's interesting to hear from both of you that you know as people in Sydney that every time you mention Victoria you get a certain kind of reaction and certainly that's okay for me and I guess writing from a national paper there's often the perception of us bashing Victoria even though you know I live here and I'm living it and you know it was interesting the way we as a Melbourne Bureau for a national paper I think sometimes the things we were writing were possibly slightly different angles from what other parts of the paper were writing and I think that's probably the beauty of being in a national paper is that you can and you should be writing for your whole audience and challenging people and possibly people in Melbourne didn't like what people in Sydney and the US were saying but it might have made them question their views and conversely people in Sydney might not have liked what the perspectives they were getting from Melbourne at the time but at least they were sort of getting a sense of how things were being felt on the ground. I think just to add to that as well one of the other sort of breakdowns we've had during this pandemic is a real case of state versus state parochialism that I don't think is really existed beyond like the state of origin normally like I don't think many people thought of Australia really as a federation before last year but really every state had I think quite a profoundly different experience of the pandemic and every state despite having that experience most people have kind of appreciated what this state leaders have done I mean you know in New South Wales I think explained some of the enduring popularity of Gladys Baragiclian despite ICAC and all that kind of thing I think a lot of people were like well cool we didn't cop what Melbourne coped last year and that kind of thing and similarly in Victoria a lot of people were like well you know Dan Andrews helped us stay safe and sacrifice and get through a really difficult time and so I think people kind of project criticisms from outside and think that people just don't understand what they've been through the uniqueness of their experience is probably the same in WA every time someone talks about the border and you know it does a little jig of them losing their ashes test right like everyone's got that deeply reaffirmed sense of state parochialism which has been weird to watch I suppose. We are seeing audiences fragment in certain ways we are also seeing and if I can take it back to Melbourne a lot of protesting particularly down there against the lockdowns with some really unsettling images I guess considering that we're seeing more of the audience fragment in that way so some people are really anti what the political decisions are being made and willing to protest in quite confronting ways but then on the other hand some audiences are just completely dropping off they're not interested in COVID if you're trying to cover these more extreme points of views how do you do it in a responsible way but also how do you keep audiences informed without basically grinding them down on COVID COVID COVID and I guess I'll start with you Kishore. It's interesting that you said that people might be getting alienated because you know certainly someone who works in a smaller subscription based publication our subscription numbers have been going really crazy for the last two years and I think I don't know maybe some of that was again people being stuck at home but it's been I don't know people have been interested in subscribing and reading what we have to say in terms of how do you cover the crazies it's sort of element I sometimes feel like there's almost been a bit too much of a kind of ongoing sort of live blogging and filming of like every rally now and it's sort of like we've done it we know what they're about and I think that's something that needs to be stressed when we look at these people as they are a really really small minority of Victorians I mean I say Victorians because they seem to be happening more so in Melbourne and I think that's probably just like a symptom of Melbourne being more locked down than any city of the world and given that the fact that there is only a small minority obviously that are losing their brains and doing all this you know horrible imagery and that kind of thing probably speaks to the fact that most people are just like pretty normal and have done the right thing got vaccinated stay at home when they're asked and all that so I think there is sometimes maybe a risk of inflaming the depth of the sort of anger out there and how big an impact these people do have on the other hand though I mean because obviously I cover federal politics and the only thing people want to think about right now is who's going to win the next election in that kind of context it only take a few people going down those rabbit holes you know preferences and UAP and that kind of thing to really put the whole electoral map a little bit off kilter so I think that it is worth looking at the impact that they could have in terms of how father influence might grow but I think we've also got to be very sober about how many people we're talking about here and how all this stuff is pretty marginal at the end of the day.

Yeah I would definitely agree like you look at the vaccination rates I think it overall for Australia it's nearly 90% and in individual states it's higher which is extraordinary really and you know we're a country that actually loves vaccination we're good at doing what we're told you know we have really strong public health programs and I think a lot of Australians are quite proud of that but yeah it is really hard to balance that with also reporting on these extreme elements because they're absolutely worth reporting on and particularly given that the intelligence authorities in Australia at the federal level and at the state level are now looking at far right neo-Nazi elements as being sort of the bigger terror-fresh and some of these elements are floating rather assiduously with politicians so I wrote a story a couple of days ago about this so called Freedom Ball you know a lot of these types of people a lot of them actually flying up from Melbourne and Craig Kelly is one of the speakers and is very much fertilizing with these people Craig Kelly is a member of parliament who was until recently a member of the government so it's like I think it's I know this sort of the whole thing about no platforming and all that stuff and I get that but I also think well you've got to record on that stuff particularly if it's as you say sort of infecting or brushing with our political system and the parties within it. Yeah I think it's a huge challenge I think by completely ignoring something like this you are trading it differently and I guess adding to these groups arguments to some extent but by the same token you don't want to give them too much attention and you know validate them I guess the other issue I think is that yes there are some really dangerous really awful elements involved in these protests but there also are some people who don't see themselves as being part of that and aren't part of that and aren't yet radicalised and I mean in Victoria there were people who had completely legitimate concern from a human rights perspective from a legal perspective about the Andrew's government's pandemic laws and certain about that from groups like the Victorian Bar Council and human rights groups ultimately fed into some pretty important reforms to that legislation. Some of those people were rocking up to their protest there were also you know other really ordinary people who might have had the not entirely unreasonable view that they didn't think that their children should be banned from going to school camp because they hadn't been vaccinated which I think is you know a little bit different from mandatory vaccinations for adults particularly given the elevated risk that COVID has for older people but I just worry that in kind of lumping all these people in with each other and basically saying if you were at the protest you were a neo-Nazi risk radicalising people because they feel as though they're being treated differently even though they might not be that different from the mainstream and they're probably sort of at the mainstream end of you know a scale that does sort of pretty quickly go pretty extreme as you look at who was there. There's like a sort of persecution complex or a sense of victimhood that goes along with some of that sort of anti-vaxxian hesitancy and also a sort of weird feeling of being somehow a bit special like part of it not an elite but like a sort of special crew who knows stuff that other people don't know and it's pretty to information that you know the ordinary folk who read the mainstream media and stuff are not pretty to you so yeah you have to be really careful not to smoke that because I don't think I don't think you've been arguments that way I guess.

Yeah and I think it's very back to what we were saying about social media before and about you know the extent to which we're becoming extremely fragmented and siloed and people can sort of fall one way or the other and once they fall the other way they're not getting their news from the mainstream media they don't trust the mainstream media they're getting all their news from some crackpot on the internet. There's only so much that the media can do but I think we do have some responsibility to try to bring people with us. Let's move off COVID I think let's move on to one of the other biggest stories of the year and that would be the treatment of women particularly in politics. Now the real litany of stories that came up with Grace Tam being named Australian of the Year then Brittany Higgins going public with her story in February, Chanel Contos and her work around sexual assault and the march for justice in Canberra and across the country it really felt as though this year in particular was a watershed for these stories.

Jacqueline how do you see it? Do you think that there was just something about 2021 that led us to this moment or has this been percolating for a while now? I mean you've got to say that it's an evolution of the Me Too movement. I don't think you can really see what's happened this year in any other context and in Australia we have had within the media a lot of difficulty reporting Me Too stories because of the heaviness of our defamation laws.

So I mean it's been interesting in a way that we've had these victim survivors or whatever you want to call them these young women who themselves have sort of stood up and talked about their experiences and in the case of Grace Tam she of course famously was legally gagged from speaking about her experience for a long time. You know before her activism meant that that law of particular law has changed. So yeah it's definitely an evolution of me too and you just had this I don't know you just had these incredibly strong and you know this is a word that's kicked around a lot but very brave young women. What I love particularly about Grace Tam and everybody has their own different style but people criticize Grace Tam for being too rude or too impolite or like she's buying her hand at Federer because she was pointing at Australian in the year and now she's being really critical of the government and I don't know I just feel like you're really missing the point if you expect an activist of her sort of style to be polite and nice and to not say things that annoy people and to not say things that rock the boat.

I think she's marvellous and then you have someone like Chanel Contos who is coming from a very particular demographic and who's just kind of taking the lid off. What is essentially the other end of the spectrum I suppose from rape and sexual abuse which is the lower level of sexualization of young men I suppose and the fact that as she says young men experimenting with their sexuality often means that young women get hurt and that's just sort of the way it has always worked and she's saying well maybe there's a different way we could do that or maybe we could teach boys a different way. So I know I've looked upon it with great or actually all of it unfolding and I think that there's been a lot of Kant at the federal government level in terms of handling this stuff but I also think that even the Kant that we've seen shows that they can't brush it under the carpet anymore and even if it's just because of fear of exposure that a lot of people will be behaving differently and protocols will perhaps work differently within camera from now on. It has felt as though this year on top of this there has been a lot levied at the behaviour of politicians.

I mean was this year when we had the allegations surrounding Christian Porter and his press conference in March we've also recently had the Jenkins report into behaviour at Parliament House and it's I guess status as a workplace environment. Now for many people you could easily just say it's politicians behaving badly this is pretty normal stuff but at the same time there is this sense that the public is frustrated by this. Sure is this more than the usual politicians behaving badly? I mean you're working at Parliament House at the moment.

Yeah I mean I think the public frustration exists for a very good reason and I think it's probably not more than the usual it's just that people are paying a little bit more attention to it. I think as Jacqueline rightly points out it's sort of maybe belated dregs of me too hitting but also a constellation of factors falling into place. The response from the federal government has to me seen quite lackluster it's often been one of those things and I think the Morrison government approaches a lot of things like this is a political issue to be quickly resolved and written out and I think that that has sort of framed a lot of the response to sexual harassment sexual assault in Parliament House and to the Jenkins report in general. I think one other thing that struck me just being in Parliament the week that that report got handed down.

Firstly from the media perspective you know there were male newsroom figures without naming any names who sort of down played from what I heard a lot of both what was in the report but also stuff like the allegations against Alan Tudge that happened later that week and that was genuinely quite fascinating to me as well. But another point as well is that the Jenkins report actually contains some really interesting stuff about culturally and linguistically diverse people, people from LGBTI backgrounds and how those other identities intersected and led to an even greater sense of marginalization within Parliament House and it was fascinating to me as a journalist working in one of the whitest places I've ever encountered in all of Australia that looks nothing like the rest of the country. How little attention this part of the Jenkins report got from the sort of surrounding media discourse as well because it strikes me that you know all of these things kind of go together and are important and you know when that gets overlooked. I guess I found the Jenkins report really interesting from the perspective of having been a reporter in Canberra a few years ago now and having had staff both Labor and Liberals come to me with pretty well documented cases of pretty lengthy periods of systematic bullying by their bosses.

You know I've kind of thought for a long time about the extent to which Parliament House is so different from just about any other work place in that there is no HR department and basically every MP's office is there are little reasons where you know where if they're a really nice person it's a great place to work but very often because of the lack of nature of politics the fact that you've got to have a pretty unreasonably high opinion of yourself to even get into politics in the first place so often does mean that the pretty pretty awful players work and I think it will be really interesting to see how they go about fixing that. I guess the other thing that I sort of find interesting looking forward is that I feel one of the sort of main challenges that this whole movement that we've seen this year is up against is the difficulty in treating a lot of these things in court obviously you know that Brittany Higgins cases currently before the court and I guess conversely you know allegations against Christian Porter and Alan Cudge haven't been tested in court but nonetheless there has been you know pretty irreversible consequences for them that have happened as a result of that and I think what we're dealing with now is kind of moving to a paradigm where justice is in some ways meet it outside courts and I think that sometimes that might have good outcomes sometimes it may have unjust outcomes and I think it'll kind of be interesting to see how that pans out in other cases as time goes on. Yeah the Christian Porter Nash I found one of the most difficult stories to report on that I've ever had to tango with I mean like a lot of people I got the written statement like a long time before it came out and I just remember reading it as deeply shocking and you just think well there's no way that this can be published because of the defamation laws but also because there is no way of verifying it you know you don't have any contemporaneous accounts and you would completely destroy a person's reputation by doing so in their life with their life you know it was just the stakes were too high was too little sort of independent verification but but then of course it came out anyway and we all had to find a way to dance around it and it was sort of a matter of gradually bit by bit people got more and more on the record of what the alleged victim had written in her statement of a few years ago I still think about that a lot and think about whether or not it was fair whether or not it was right whose interests were served it was a really really tricky one and obviously it's all washed out now and Christian Porter's political career is basically over I still don't know if that one it's a really really tricky one me I mean I think it really goes down to the fact that there is no way of knowing what happens when you've got one key witness is dead and you know the other ones obviously not going to incriminate himself and even though you know in the eyes of so many people he's been found guilty even though you know a court could never find him so given the lack of evidence I agree and then I go back to first principles as a journalist and you think well a historical rape allegation against the attorney general is a story like you know I have to work with you so you think well of course it has new value it has huge public interest value and then you have to work your way through the ethics and the legal mind field of it but to go back to first principles yeah I mean anyone who says that wasn't a story it's not a sort of domestic action we've all made the story yeah before we look towards 2022 I didn't want to ask each of you are there any stories that you thought deserved more attention but ultimately got lost in the swirl of this past year and I'll start with you Jacqueline well I was going to say sort of sports sports and those you know we had a sort of rash I think that was this year we had a rash of stories about various grants programs and the car park grants programs I would have said that however in recent days you know the city morning hell and the age of public is incredible sort of digital journalism which is all about the sort of gross disparity in grants government grants you know the gone through schools and schools of government grants and found the gross disparity between the money awarded to coalition electorates and marginal electorates and those that go to labor and other electorates so that's sort of been I guess amended a little bit by the great journalism of my own organization but yeah I do feel like because the public got so distracted by you know the threats to our existence that covid represented some of those transparency brought in stories got a little bit buried or a little bit like you know everybody got a bit time distracted to follow them up perhaps yeah I completely agree so much of this year I have been reporting on covid and nothing else and yes it was the story but it has been really frustrating that there just hasn't been the time so there would be in a different year to put in those f oi applications and I guess with my sort of Victorian political reporters hat on there's been a bit more attention you know in recent months and obviously with the iDAC inquiry down here on ranch stacking but I think everyone in Victoria knows that it's not just limited to the one branch of the labor party that's being investigated in iDAC I think just the issue generally and Jacqueline was getting out of earlier of the use of tax payers money so basically the party political benefit is a pretty big theme and one that I hope will have a bit more time to devote to is this journalist next year. Sure how about you?

Look for me I would have to say the story of Australia's withdrawal from Afghanistan was criminally under-follied and didn't sort of get the attention to deserve purely because I think well a bunch of reasons firstly it happened in August and you know the whole country was sort of in some form of lockdown everyone was losing their minds about that but more importantly I think that you know the way Australia delayed sending an evacuation flight to spike in war for months and years that people that we'd worked with were at serious risk of being murdered by the Taliban and just didn't really do anything about it it was a moment of real great moral failure to me also because for the months before we sort of the media knew about it and you know some of us did cover and write about it but again those stories just don't seem to get the traction they don't ministers don't get asked about them in press conferences ministers don't front up to press conferences ever so really it fell by the wayside and at the end of the day we really we took in a fraction of the number of people that we could have we gave out fewer humanitarian visas than several past liberal prime ministers have given out in similar situations I mean this was our longest war and we left with a whimper and we left in a moment of real humanitarian failure I think and that really didn't get talked about enough you know this is again just a fraction of the story is the disservice of the attention that unfortunately covid has sucked up looking forward into 2022 a big story will be that it is a federal election year what do you expect to come to the surface what are you keeping your eyes on going into the new year and I'll start with you Rachel you've got a computer hearing your federal election with the most recent one in 2019 you know there was a very strong expectation from the vast majority of political journalists and I was one of them I have to gradually admit that Bill Shorten was going to sail into power and I guess there's caution this time about what the polls say and exactly how things will pan out I guess the other thing that I will be watching and find interesting is we don't have this sort of unprecedented number of independence running this time round and it will be really interesting to see what happens there certainly going back to covid I think it will be really interesting to see how that plays out obviously state governments have in a lot of ways been the ones who have really taken control with that issue but I think there is certainly in Victoria in a lot of the electrics and a lot of them are really safe labor at Western suburbs out of suburban labor electrics that were really hard hit by covid pulses and just anecdotally people are picking up a huge amount of this engagement in places like that people who feel that even though they're historically being pretty strong labor voters they're not necessarily overwhelmingly happy with Daniel Andrews and Anthony Albanese they're looking for an alternative they're not at this stage convinced that the coalition are that alternative and I think it'll be really interesting to see I guess on the one hand in the seats that they're running which is sort of in Melbourne more of an eastern suburbs um regional thing how well the independence do out of that um and that's more in liberal health states but I think you know it'll be interesting to see how how minor parties do in some of those traditional later states where people aren't necessarily all that happy but that probably don't want to vote for the liberals Jacqueline how about you? Yeah I mean I guess the big story of the year next year that we know about that's far will be the election and I've been running a bit on the independence being a kind of candleating the sort of metropolis and seats in Sydney and I think that's a really interesting story I'm excited about covering it because it's just it's always a lot of juicy fun stuff like politics coverage and election coverage can be so say me and so bland you know the local members like more interesting characters in Sydney you've got Wentworth which is you know lots of big eastern suburbs names like you know it's kind of a little bit like we're in Gabbat not you know it has a different demographic as well like I just think all that stuff's kind of interesting on a human level and also it's just a really interesting expression of democracy that you know the two party system particularly in relation to climate has just proved so in effectual as sort of resolving any real policy on that matter the these sort of renaissance of independence is by that the system is found to kind of amend that or to bring a solution to that and I think it's really interesting that they're all women and they're all sort of obviously we're looking at that they're sort of quite highly educated successful women they're kind of exactly the kind of people that the liberal party in an alternative universe where they're a little bit more functional at a large level would be pre-selecting for themselves so I think that's really interesting like I'm kind of keen to cover all that stuff and then I think you know just going back to what we're saying before I just think there would have been so many politicians and you know high level bureaucrats who were sort of rubbing their hands with glee during the pandemic that journalists weren't finding out about this secret and weren't finding out about the dead body that they buried I think it might be good reckoning I mean terms of putting in FOIs trying to dig around some of the programs that the government's been running or you know trying to uncover stuff that I suppose has been lost in the fall before of the last year or so because sure how about you well look frankly I'm more excited about the World Cup next year but look if we if we must talk about the election and then we must on this kind of podcast then yeah that will obviously suck up so much of the oxygen over the first few months of next year and for me everyone is really burned and jaded by 2019 because like Rachel said there was this very strong narrative about short and romping home and that seems to me what was we all thought that was going to happen and then it didn't and so now everyone's second guessing themselves which I think is kind of good because I don't know if journalists and pundits should spend too much time being in the business of crystal ball tea leaf reading I think you should just be trying to like you know report what's happening on the ground and all that and people can just be patient and wait to election night and then you can find out who will win and you'll find out that it will happen unless of course there's a hung pilot which is quite a distinct possibility for next year but at the moment I think one of the things that interested me about this is we found out coming out of 2019 where it was a very tight election result we had quite a divided country you know over the issues like climate the divisions are really deep and they're really fierce and you did also have a huge amount of voter disengagement I mean there was a huge primary vote for parties like One Nation in a lot of those key central see how big the vote for UAP and One Nation is next year will be really interesting but the crucial thing to me is that because everyone's had a different experience of the pandemic and because the pandemic's been so unpredictable I mean we saw this on micron thing emerged just when everyone was getting a little bit more relaxed how that election goes will be so much contingent on like when Scott Morrison calls it for the mood of the country at the time and that kind of thing and really it's going to depend so much on people's vibe at that time that the next three years could really be determined by what is a very temporary sort of feeling and even looking beyond that we've got a couple of options we either have a change of government and potentially a minority government which would be a radical radical departure from the politics we've seen over the last whatever eight nine years on the alternative to that is a reelection of the Morrison government who really what do they really want to do it's it's not very clear what their agenda would be for another term you know their election pitches the COVID situation is probably better here than the rest of the world so it's really like what happens then you've got three more years of a government that doesn't seem to be able to get much through parliament doesn't seem to have a very strong agenda in terms of what I believe in so yeah it could be an exciting time I guess for some of us what a note of optimism is yeah well look last year I said that 2022 would be deeply cooked because of vaccines and unfortunately I was kind of right so thank you so much for joining forces state today everyone thank you to my guests Jacqueline mailey because Sean a Pia ramen and Rachel back Zendell before we go we'd like to pay tribute to Glenn Daniel a renowned figure of Sydney radio for 39 years who passed earlier last week Tina Quinn was one of the many journalists fortunate enough to be mentored by Glenn she recorded this tribute to him last week Australian radio lost one of its giants the renowned journalist and presenter Glenn Daniel Glenn actually began his career at the very station that we bring you for the state from each week to a CR 107.3 here in Sydney Glenn leaves a huge hole in our industry over the last number of decades he mentored an extraordinary amount of young journalists who were coming up in the industry he gave many of them their first job I was one such journalist who benefited greatly from his mentorship I can say from firsthand experience that nobody was more generous with their time or with their spirit he was a mentor to many and a friend to all thank you Tina and thank you for listening to Forth edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network Forth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support make sure you subscribe to Forth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a whole lot in between we'll be back with more in 2022 but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter our handle is Forth Estate AU a big thanks to my executive producer Anthony Doprel

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 50 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on December 16, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.