Skip to content
2023 SCC 3 – R. v. Hilbach episode artwork

Jan 27, 2023 1 hr 50 min

2023 SCC 3 – R. v. Hilbach

from dicta – law in audio Hosted by dicta

To support us, please follow us wherever you're listening and visit ⁠our website⁠⁠ to provide feedback. Constitutional law — Charter of Rights — Cruel and unusual treatment or punishment — Sentencing (0:00:08) Reasons for Judgment: Martin J. (Wagner C.J. and Moldaver, Brown, Rowe and Kasirer JJ. concurring) (0:00:17) I. Introduction – 1 (0:05:07) II. Legislative Background – 8 (0:14:01) III. Judicial and Legislative History – 20 (0:14:04) A. R. v. Hilbach, Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench – 20 (0:17:23) B. R. v. Zwozdesky, Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench – 23 (0:20:03) C. Alberta Court of Appeal – 26 (0:23:05) D. Legislative Amendments – 31 (0:23:49) IV. Issue – 32 (0:24:02) V. Analysis - 33 (0:24:23) A. The Test for an Infringement of Section 12 – 34 (0:24:26) (1) The Framework – 34 (0:27:58) (2) Mandatory Minimum Sentences and Indigenous Offenders – 39 (0:32:30) B. Application – 47 (0:32:59) (1) Application to Mr. Hilbach's Case – 48 (0:57:56) (2) Application in Mr. Zwozdesky's Case – 83 (1:22:03) C. Conclusion – 110 (1:23:08) Concurring Reasons: Côté J. (1:24:09) Joint Dissenting Reasons: Karakatsanis and Jamal JJ. (1:24:14) Preamble – 114 (1:26:47) I. Background – 120 (1:26:49) A. Ocean William Storm Hilbach – 120 (1:28:17) B. Curtis Zwodzdesky – 123 (1:30:00) II. Analysis – 127 (1:33:22) A. Section 334(1)(a)(i) of the Criminal Code – 135 (1:40:55) B. Section 344(1)(a.1) of the Criminal Code – 147 (1:50:20) C. Section 1 – 164 (1:50:33) III. Disposition – 165

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

2023 SCC 3 – R. v. Hilbach

0:00 1:50:58

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of dicta – law in audio?

This episode is 1 hour and 50 minutes long.

When was this dicta – law in audio episode published?

This episode was published on January 27, 2023.

Can I download this dicta – law in audio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.