2023 SCC 8 – R. v. McColman
from dicta – law in audio Hosted by dicta
To support us, please follow us wherever you're listening and visit our website to provide feedback. Criminal law — Impaired driving — Random sobriety stop Constitutional law — Charter of Rights — Arbitrary detention (0:00:11) Joint Reasons for Judgment: Wagner C.J. and O’Bonsawin J. (Karakatsanis, Côté, Rowe, Martin, Kasirer and Jamal JJ. concurring) (0:00:14) I. Overview – 1 (0:01:19) II. Facts – 3 (0:03:42) III. Relevant Provisions – 8 (0:05:17) IV. Judicial History – 12 (0:05:19) A. Ontario Court of Justice – 12 (0:06:59) B. Ontario Superior Court of Justice – 16 (0:08:31) C. Court of Appeal for Ontario – 19 (0:11:38) V. Issues – 24 (0:13:25) VI. Analysis – 28 (0:13:27) A. Was the Random Sobriety Stop Authorized by Section 48(1) of the HTA? – 28 (0:16:44) (1) The Meaning of Section 48(1) of the HTA – 34 (0:25:52) (2) The Random Sobriety Stop Breached Mr. McColman's Section 9 Charter Rights – 51 (0:26:48) B. Should the Evidence Obtained Have Been Excluded Under Section 24(2) of the Charter? – 53 (0:28:46) (1) The Seriousness of the Charter-Infringing Conduct – 57 (0:35:12) (2) The Impact of the Breach on the Charter-Protected Interests of Mr. McColman – 66 (0:37:21) (3) Society's Interest in the Adjudication of the Case on its Merits – 69 (0:39:50) (4) Balancing the Grant Factors – 74 (0:40:29) VII. Conclusion – 75
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.