Skip to content
2024 SCC 15 – R. v. Edwards episode artwork

Apr 26, 2024 2 hr 43 min

2024 SCC 15 – R. v. Edwards

from dicta – law in audio Hosted by dicta

To support us, please follow us wherever you're listening and visit ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠our website⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ to provide feedback. Constitutional law — Charter of Rights — Independent and impartial tribunal (00:00:58) Summary (00:01:07) Facts and Procedural History (00:03:27) Disposition (00:03:32) Per Wagner C.J. and Côté, Rowe, Kasirer, Jamal and O’Bonsawin JJ. (00:14:43) Per Karakatsanis J. (dissenting) (00:22:26) Reasons for Judgment: Kasirer J. (Wagner C.J. and Côté, Rowe, Jamal and O’Bonsawin JJ. concurring) (00:22:35) I. Overview – 1 (00:35:39) II. Background – 16 (00:41:09) III. Judicial History – 31 (00:41:11) A. Courts Martial – 31 (00:41:13) (1) R. v. Edwards, 2020 CM; R. v. Crépeau, 2020 CM; R. v. Fontaine, 2020 CM; and R. v. Iredale, 2020 CM – 31 (00:42:53) (2) R. v. Christmas, 2020 CM; and R. v. Proulx, 2020 CM – 33 (00:43:27) (3) R. v. Cloutier, 2020 CM; and R. v. Brown, 2021 CM – 34 (00:44:07) (4) R. v. Thibault, 2020 CM – 35 (00:44:21) B. Court Martial Appeal Court of Canada – 36 (00:44:24) (1) R. v. Edwards; R. v. Crépeau; R. v. Fontaine; R. v. Iredale, 2021 CMAC (“Edwards et al.”) – 36 (00:49:37) (2) R. v. Proulx; R. v. Cloutier, 2021 CMAC (“Proulx et al.”) – 45 (00:50:20) (3) R. v. Christmas, 2022 CMAC; R. v. Brown, 2022 CMAC; and R. v. Thibault, 2022 CMAC – 46 (00:51:05) IV. Issues and Submissions of the Parties – 47 (00:55:47) V. Relevant Constitutional and Statutory Provisions – 54 (01:06:09) VI. Analysis – 64 (01:06:11) A. Implications of Généreux – 64 (01:21:50) B. Do the Requirements in Sections 165.21 and 165.24(2) Meet the Standards of Judicial Independence and Impartiality Under Section 11(d) of the Charter? – 84 (01:22:05) (1) The Framework for Assessing the Independence of Military Judges – 84 (01:24:32) (2) The Three Essential Conditions of Judicial Independence Are Met Through Provisions of the NDA – 87 (01:32:53) (a) Security of Tenure – 99 (01:33:58) (i) The Concerns Identified in Généreux Have Been Addressed – 101 (01:35:33) (ii) Security Against Removal From Office Except for Cause – 103 (01:43:24) (b) Financial Security – 113 (01:44:39) (c) Administrative Independence – 115 (01:46:05) (3) Arguments Advanced by the Appellants That Impugn the Institutional Impartiality of Military Judges – 118 (02:09:43) VII. Conclusion – 149 (02:10:16) Dissenting Reasons: Karakatsanis J. (02:10:21) I. Introduction – 150 (02:14:01) II. Background – 155 (02:16:01) III. Analysis – 160 (02:17:08) A. Legal Principles – 162 (02:23:26) B. The Disciplinary Framework Applicable to Military Judges – 174 (02:29:03) C. A Reasonable and Informed Person Would Apprehend Bias – 185 (02:33:36) D. The Existing Safeguards Are Insufficient – 194 (02:34:22) (1) The Oath of Office – 195 (02:35:56) (2) The Removal Process Through the MJIC – 199 (02:37:40) (3) The Presumption of Independence by Prosecution – 203 (02:40:50) IV. Conclusion – 208

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

2024 SCC 15 – R. v. Edwards

0:00 2:43:54

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of dicta – law in audio?

This episode is 2 hours and 43 minutes long.

When was this dicta – law in audio episode published?

This episode was published on April 26, 2024.

Can I download this dicta – law in audio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.