2024 SCC 25 – R. v. Hodgson
from dicta – law in audio Hosted by dicta
To support us, please follow us wherever you're listening and visit our website to provide feedback. Criminal law — Appeals — Acquittal Criminal law — Murder — Elements of offence — Mens rea Criminal law — Defences — Self‑defence (00:00:23) Summary (00:00:33) Facts and Procedural History (00:01:37) Disposition (00:01:41) Per Per Wagner C.J. and Karakatsanis, Côté, Martin, Kasirer, Jamal, O’Bonsawin and Moreau JJ. (00:09:04) Per Rowe J. (00:09:38) Joint Reasons for Judgment: Martin and Moreau JJ. (Wagner C.J. and Karakatsanis, Côté, Kasirer, Jamal and O’Bonsawin JJ. concurring) (00:09:51) I. Introduction – 1 (00:12:06) II. Facts – 5 (00:15:25) III. Judgments Below – 10 (00:15:27) A. Nunavut Court of Justice (Charlesworth J.) – 10 (00:18:49) B. Nunavut Court of Appeal, 2022 NUCA 9 (Schutz, Campbell and Pentelechuk JJ.A.) – 14 (00:20:25) IV. Issues – 18 (00:20:51) A. What Does It Mean That a Crown Appeal of an Acquittal Under Section 676(1)(a) of the Criminal Code Is Limited to a Ground of Appeal That Involves a Question of Law Alone? – 19 (00:22:30) (1) Historical Foundations of the Crown’s Limited Right of Appeal – 22 (00:25:04) (2) Rationales for the Crown’s Limited Right of Appeal – 26 (00:27:29) (3) Defining the Scope of the Crown’s Limited Right of Appeal – 32 (00:30:31) (4) Failure to Articulate an Error of Law for the Mens Rea for Murder – 37 (00:35:43) B. Did the Trial Judge Err in Law Regarding the Mens Rea for Second Degree Murder? – 45 (00:36:53) (1) The Legal Test for Mens Rea – 47 (00:45:22) (2) No Error of Law in Respect of Lemmon and Cooper – 59 (00:49:03) (3) Did the Trial Judge Err in Law in Failing to Consider the Common Sense Inference? – 65 (00:51:37) C. Did the Trial Judge Err in Law in Relation to Self-Defence? – 70 (01:03:27) V. Disposition – 83 (01:03:34) Concurring Reasons: Rowe J.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.