2024 SCC 34 – R. v. Wolfe
from dicta – law in audio Hosted by dicta
To support us, please follow us wherever you're listening and visit our website to provide feedback. Criminal law — Sentencing — Criminal negligence (00:00:39) Summary (00:17:36) Reasons for Judgment: Martin J. (Wagner C.J. and Karakatsanis, Rowe and O’Bonsawin JJ. concurring) (00:17:47) I. Overview – 1 (00:22:04) II. Background – 8 (00:22:06) A. The Relevant Legislation at Issue on This Appeal – 8 (00:31:04) B. The Underlying Offences and Proceedings – 17 (00:31:07) (1) Circumstances of the Offences – 17 (00:31:34) (2) Saskatchewan Court of Queen’s Bench (Danyliuk J.) – 19 (00:33:41) (3) Saskatchewan Court of Appeal, 2022 SKCA 132, [2023] 3 W.W.R. 574 (Kalmakoff J.A., Schwann and McCreary JJ.A. Concurring) – 22 (00:36:37) III. Issue on Appeal – 26 (00:36:56) IV. Parties’ Positions – 27 (00:36:58) A. Appellant (Mr. Wolfe) – 27 (00:37:52) B. Respondent (His Majesty The King) – 28 (00:39:19) V. Analysis – 31 (00:39:22) A. Governing Principles of Statutory Interpretation – 31 (00:40:28) B. Interpretation of Section 320.24(4) – 34 (00:40:34) (1) Text – 34 (00:41:16) (a) The Criminal Negligence Offences Are Not Enumerated in Section 320.24(4) – 35 (00:45:17) (b) The Distinction Between Findings of Guilt and Convictions – 41 (00:50:26) (c) Included Offences – 48 (00:57:48) (d) An Additional Signal in the Text of Section 320.24(4) – 57 (00:59:03) (e) Comparison of the English and French Changes to Section 320.24(4) – 58 (01:00:34) (f) Conclusion on the Text of Section 320.24(4) – 60 (01:01:47) (2) Statutory and Broader Criminal Law Context – 62 (01:02:02) (a) Other Provisions in Part VIII.1 of the Criminal Code – 63 (01:10:58) (b) Rule Against Multiple Convictions – 70 (01:14:44) (3) Legislative Purpose – 77 (01:23:39) (4) Conclusion on Interpretation of Section 320.24(4) – 88 (01:26:15) VI. Conclusion – 91 (01:26:45) Dissenting Reasons: Moreau J. (Côté, Kasirer and Jamal JJ. concurring) (01:26:54) I. Overview – 93 (01:32:34) II. Background – 100 (01:34:29) III. Issue – 104 (01:34:56) IV. Analysis – 105 (01:34:58) A. The Modern Approach to Statutory Interpretation – 105 (01:36:49) B. A Finding of Guilt for the Principal Offence Necessarily Entails a Finding of Guilt for Lesser Included Offences – 108 (01:37:24) (1) A Finding of Guilt Is Distinct From a Conviction or Discharge in Section 320.24(4) – 109 (01:43:21) (2) A Finding of Guilt for a Principal Offence Necessarily Entails Findings of Guilt for Lesser Included Offences in the Criminal Code – 118 (01:44:54) (3) A Finding of Guilt for Criminal Negligence Under Sections 220 or 221, Where It Arises From the Operation of a Conveyance, Contains Findings of Guilt for the Lesser Included Offence of Dangerous Operation Under Section 320.13 – 121 (01:46:57) (4) The Availability of a Driving Prohibition Order as a Penalty for Criminal Negligence Is Consistent With Criminal Law Principles – 123 (01:52:25) C. Consequences of Competing Interpretations of Section 320.24(4) – 131 (01:54:30) (1) The Availability of a Driving Prohibition Order as a Punishment for Criminal Negligence Is Consistent With the Stated Purposes of Section 320.24(4) – 134 (01:59:03) (2) Criminal Negligence Is at Least as Serious an Offence as Dangerous Operation of a Conveyance – 140 (02:01:45) D. Conclusion – 143 (02:03:02) V. Disposition – 144
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.