Skip to content
#2096 - Josh Dubin & Sheldon Johnson episode artwork

Feb 1, 2024 2 hr 40 min

#2096 - Josh Dubin & Sheldon Johnson

from The Joe Rogan Experience Hosted by Joe Rogan

Josh Dubin is the Executive Director of the Perlmutter Center for Legal Justice, a criminal justice reform advocate, and civil rights attorney. Sheldon Johnson is a criminal justice reform advocate. He works with at risk youth at the Queens Defenders in New York. https://cardozo.yu.edu/directory/josh-dubin

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

#2096 - Josh Dubin & Sheldon Johnson

0:00 2:40:21
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The Joe Rogan experience. Train by day Joe Rogan podcast by night. Okay. Good to see you again sir.

Mr. Rogan. Always a pleasure. Introduce your friend.

This is my friend, my client, my brother Sheldon Johnson. I figured we'd do something a little bit different. Typically the person sitting to my right is someone that was wrongfully convicted. So I don't want to bury the headline.

Sheldon is guilty. I thought it would be a real interesting conversation to learn his background, learn about his upbringing, learn about the crime that he committed, and hear the sentence he got, which I don't want to shade it and inject my opinion. I have a strong one, but it's pretty astounding how he was treated by the system. I think that there's a real interesting twist that happens at his sentencing.

I know I've said this before, and it probably sounds repetitive, but another miracle sitting to my right, just like a marvelous human being who was basically told by an African-American judge that you don't matter. You don't count, and I'm going to throw your life away for a crime in which the victim received two stitches and on a second offense, his first offense being a gun possession charge. I will say this, that he received a sentence that far eclipses a sentence that would be commonly doled out for murder or manslaughter. So with that, here's Sheldon.

Sheldon, how long have you been out for? I'm going on nine months. I got out May 4th. And you were in for 25 years and five months.

Two stitches. Two stitches. Cheers. But one of the things that always struck me about Sheldon was I didn't know him.

And I got a call from these two remarkable attorneys at an organization called the Center for Appellate Litigation. Barbara Zolot and Allison Hopped, who had been working on his case for a long time. And they called me and Derek Hamilton and said, you know, we know you're working on some stuff with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office. We have this case that sort of hit a snag.

I want you to take a look at it and see if you could help us. And I called Barbara back and said, I think that there's a mistake here because it says that he was sentenced to 50 years. I mean, that's no bullshit. I could not believe what I was reading.

And then I read about what Sheldon had accomplished while in prison. And then his earliest date of release was, I think, 2049. And he had already served 25 years. So I was just blown away by the level of accomplishment and the mental wear with all that he possessed to accomplish what he did while incarcerated.

And then the path he's taken in the eight months since he's been out is, we talk about on these episodes, how do you make change happen? He's living it and making it happen. So I thought it would be just fascinating to go through, like I said, his life, how he got to where he was, why he got this, what his thoughts are and our thoughts are on the sentence he received, why that happens too often to people of color. And I know there's one thing I want to say that I'm going to shut up and really let Sheldon talk and you talk.

I get this a lot. Why always bring up race when you talk about the system. And my response to that is, if you don't talk about how it impacts the system, even for people that have been found guilty, it's like having a conversation about President Biden and ignoring the very obvious apparent cognitive deficiencies he has. It would be like talking about Donald Trump and not recognizing that he seems like an unhinged lunatic.

It would be like talking about Kamala Harris and ignoring that she didn't do much to advance criminal justice reform. You have to confront it. It's just there. Is it that all people that get wrongfully convicted or people of color?

No, but most of them. Is it that all people of color get disparate sentences? Oh, absolutely. So that's why I thought that this is an important conversation to have.

And getting to know Sheldon just thought he has a remarkable story to tell and a perspective on his circumstances, the system, and he's someone that's taken responsibility for what he did. I think it's a living example of what can happen if we think long and hard about if someone's life is worth just throwing away and putting behind bars so that they can rot in a dank cell because he would have been 70 years old when he got out way past his life expectancy. You know, one of the things that's happened through all of our conversations that we've had on the show is it highlights how insanely broken the criminal justice system is and how little oversight there is and how few people are looking at these individual cases and that you can have one judge who does what they did to you. And no one's looking.

No one cares. No one pays attention until someone like you goes in and starts combing over this and then coming up with a strategy for, you know, to actually apply real justice or at least get someone out. I mean, the only way to apply real justice is how a fucking time machine, right? But it's broken.

I mean, it's so broken and it seems so overwhelmed. And the root cause of it is never addressed. The root cause of, I mean, I've said it ad nauseam, but I'll say it again. Where the fuck did we come up with?

A hundred and whatever billion dollars to send to Ukraine and we don't have any money to try to do something about these insanely impoverished crime ridden gang ridden drug ridden communities. We don't do anything. We have nothing. I mean, this is my take on this whole make America great again thing.

You want to make America great again? Make it so there's less losers. Make it so that more people have a fucking chance. The idea that everyone starts on the same line.

I mean, I'm not talking about equality of outcome. That's not possible. But equality of opportunity is possible. That's a possible goal.

At least we could advance that. At least we could do something to just change the course of who knows how many people's lives. And we don't do a fucking thing about it. I mean, we're looking at each other because we just had lunch before we came to the precise conversation that we had.

I told you this is a motherfucker that gets it. Oh, I know. It just makes no sense to me. It makes no sense to me.

And it's not a subject of any presidential debates. It's not a subject of anybody who's running for Congress or running for Senate. We have to fix this. This is a problem.

It's been going on for decades and decades, back through Jim Crow, back all the way to slavery, the same communities. And we don't do anything. Pull that a little redlining. Everything.

Pull that mic up a little bit. Yeah, just, yeah, that's good. Yeah, that's good. I mean, it's wild.

It really is wild. And, you know, the race part of it is a major factor. It's a major factor. And it's a factor that gets ignored when people start talking about racism, systemic racism in the country.

Talk about sentencing. How come that's not talked about? Yeah, well, that's a vestige of... When you travel well, your KLM Royal Dutch Airlines ticket takes you to more than just your destination.

It takes you to front row views, voices lost in the music, and new shared memories. And when the last song fades, the KLM Royal Dutch Airlines crew is here to ensure your journey home hits all the right notes. KLM Royal Dutch Airlines. When you travel, travel well.

That's a vestige of slavery, segregation, Jim Crow, redlining, everything. It's all in your right to a jury trial, the punished twice. Yeah, it's hard to know where to pick up because we just had this conversation. But you're, you know, look, well, let's preface the episode by saying this.

We are doing something about it. Keep telling you that this forum keeps paying dividends. We are making progress. We are opening people's minds.

I'm getting letters from prosecutors. I'm getting letters from sheriffs. I got a letter from a sheriff in Oregon last week. And he sent me a badge and said, I want to show you how committed I am to try to make change happen.

And it was from this show. So we're doing it. We're addressing it. We're making it happen.

Why politicians don't... You know, what drives someone to want to get into politics these days is for a different psychiatrist. I'm not going to tell you what the allure is, but, you know, like there's such a swirl of ego and power struggle and divided loyalties. I can't even wrap my head around it.

But, you know, we're doing it. We're helping. We got to do it. Grain of sand by grain of sand until we have a sand castle.

So that's what we're doing. So I do think we're making a difference. But, you know, it's crazy because Sheldon and I are the same exact age. And we didn't know that until we were on our way down.

One day is apart. And he flew when we flew down. It was the first time he'd ever been on an airplane. Wow.

Was that like fucking weird, right? No, I actually loved it. I was very excited. I'm kind of like an adrenaline.

I like adrenaline rush. Just the speed of it and just the whole idea of just... You know, I had this analogy in my head when I was up in the clouds. And I'm looking down and I said to myself, I just came from the bowels of hell.

Spinning 25 years in prison. And now I'm in the sky above the clouds in Heavens, headed to a destination to talk about change and to talk about all of the things that brought me to this place today. And, you know, the conditions in which I grew up and how social conditions play a role in the decisions that we make. Or the lack of achievement.

So opportunities like Jo just said a couple of minutes ago, those opportunities are very important. And being able to start that line where everybody is not necessarily equitable, but, you know, everybody has that same opportunity. You have a chance. You have a chance.

A real chance. Well, so tell us about your upbringing. So I'm a coder. My mother's deaf.

My father's deaf. My sister's deaf. My aunt is deaf. I grew up in a deaf household.

What's a coder? A coder is a child of deaf adults. So that's crazy. It's a second podcast in a row.

I'm doing it with someone else like that. Yeah. Motion Cashier was on yesterday. His parents are deaf.

He signs and he's got to translate for his mother his whole life. Same with me. So as a child growing up, my mother's also white. My grandmother came to America in 1918 from a boat from Sicily.

My father is Nigerian. He's African. So there was always this contrast where I wasn't really sure where I belong that. You know, kids are cruel.

So growing up, you know, kids would say, oh, you're a lot, or you're half-breat. And, oh, you're adopted. And for a long time, I kind of suffered as a child with an identity crisis, not really knowing where I fell at on either side, what my identity was, who I was supposed to be. And my father, I'm also a product of intergenerational incarceration.

My father was incarcerated when I was young at an early age. He did about 15 years. I was incarcerated. My grandfather was incarcerated.

My great grandfather was a slave. And my son killed somebody when he was 12 years old. So there's this cycle of incarceration based on the conditions and social conditions and where I come from. I grew up in New York City, Harlem, on the borderline between East side and West side on Fifth Avenue.

You hit Fifth Avenue, you're like, oh, wow, you're living a nice place. Okay. Crack every Harlem, 80s, 90s. You know, when I grew up, you know, protecting my mother, interpreting for my mother, my mother could hardly ever keep a job because of her handicap.

There was always somebody that would replace her. A lot of people saw my mother as a victim. She was a white woman on 112th Street in Lennox Avenue in all black community. So as a child, I grew up protecting my mother.

So I never really, I feel like in hindsight, I didn't really have an opportunity to be a child. I had to grow up and be a man early in my life in order to be able to protect my mother. And a lot of people didn't even know that I was, that I could hear. So there were times where I would be standing there with my mother.

And like people would just be making all type of random comments and just disrespectful, you know, just hateful stuff. And I would sit there as a kid, just kind of like looking up like, like, dude, I can like hear you. So, you know, I think my life took a significant turn and when I was in the fifth grade, I was always pretty smart. But, you know, as being smart and growing up in these neighborhoods, you know, the school systems are not really equipped to handle the numbers.

The number of children that's coming to. So you had one teacher and like 30 kids. And me just being who I was, I was always pretty smart. And when I was finished with my work, I would kind of just clown around.

I had this teacher in the fifth grade, my math teacher. And what he would do was he, when you acted out in the classroom, he would call you to the front of the classroom. He had to stack a ruler. Today he would be arrested back then.

But it was back then it was permissible. It was considered as, you know, just punishing kids and he would call you to the front of the classroom. He would make you stick out your hand and he would put salt. He had a big salt shaker that kept on his desk and he was sprinkled salt in the palm.

And he would smack the ruler into your hand and the salt would kind of embed itself into your palm and would kind of have like a little burning sensation. So one day I decided that I was tired of it and he called me to the front of the classroom and I put my hand out and when he swung, I moved my hand. And he almost fell over chasing me around the classroom. I ran out into the hallway.

He chased me into the hallway. I grabbed the fire extinguisher off the wall and I sprayed him. That was my reaction too. I was like, he was cursing and, oh man.

Well long story short, I sat in the back of the police car for three hours as they determined my fate as a 10-year-old. Put me in handcuffs and everything. And I had a counselor at that time. And I guess she convinced him to send me to a hospital.

So he sent me to Mount Sinai Hospital, psychiatric unit. And I remember them sticking me with a needle, a door to the end. 10-year-old kid man. Just, you know, just in a straight jacket being escorted to a hospital.

They stick me with a needle. And so for months from Mount Sinai, I went to Metropolitan and attempted to escape for Metropolitan and they sent me to a more secure area. What's Metropolitan Metropolitan Hospital? It's also a cycle.

So why did they send you to a psych ward for that? I guess they, you know, I was considered as a young black kid who's out of control with behavioral issues. And, you know, I'm not sure exactly the gist of the conversation that took place. But from what I've gathered now in the future is that my mother felt that she would rather see me in the hospital than to see me in the jail.

Because it was either that or they told her that they were going to send me to spaffered. So I went through that just being subject to just a whole bunch of different medications. Meloril, Haldor, Lithium, Colgian. And then they transferred me to Pleasantville from Pleasantville.

I went to Hawthorne. And, you know, and I'm going to be honest, this is where I learned how to become a criminal because prior to that I was just a kid. They put me in this place where, you know, I was around all the kids and these kids were really like about their life. There was stuff that was really bad stuff happening.

If you look up Hawthorne's seat on all's to this day, it's been closed for allegations of sex trafficking and child abuse. Just so because we know it because we're from New York, but those are juvenile groups. They're like group homes yet. They're like juvenile detention facilities.

So they considered me as a person. They put what they called a pin on you and it's a person of interest, a person in need of assistance. And they put you in these places and they just kind of just leave you there. So I finally got out of there.

I went to Alata. I was molested by a counselor. And I finally escaped from there. And I just went back into the streets at 13 years old.

And I just was spending for myself. I was out in the street. So it was three years of that? Three years of that?

For one instance. One instance. Hit you with a fucking ruler. Yes.

Wow. And I always look back and I see that as a trajectory in my life that just changed everything. I went from it changed me as a person. I lost my innocence.

I felt like after I left that place, I was a darker person because of the things that I saw and the things that I went to. So I come back and we talking about this is 1988. Crack that all of them. You know, you got kids 13, 14 years old, making $1000 every two, three days selling drugs, looking out of the corners.

And I was like, real stuff. You see New Jack City, New Jack City was for real bad. People who grew up after that do not understand pre crack and post crack. Oh, yeah.

It was wild. Devastated my community. It was wild. And how the fuck did that happen?

Like, how the fuck did that happen? When you go through the whole story of it? I mean, come on, man. I had Freeway Ricky Ross on here twice.

Oh, go. I got to say the last night. We were talking about this and we were talking about like, what do we want to accomplish today? And last night when we were talking, he's like, well, you know, the CIA brought crack into.

I said, you might want to stay away from that, but here we are. The fuck out of staying away from that, man. My friend Michael Rupert, rest in peace. He was the guy who stood in front of the city council on television and exposed that he was a former Los Angeles narcotics officer.

And he said, I personally witnessed the CIA selling drugs in the inner cities of Los Angeles. And that was the Freeway Ricky Ross situation where they were using that money to fund the conscious versus the Sandinistas in Nicaragua. It's really not as crazy because last night Sheldon's telling me about it. And I spent a long night into the early morning hours reading some of what you told me to read.

Really not. It's really not in dispute that it happened. Not in dispute at all. And what was, well, well, I'm going to let Sheldon tell what blew me away about it was that not only was it known how addictive it was, it was also known how easy it was to reproduce the process.

And how much cheaper it became. Yeah. Not only that, the difference isn't sentencing. The difference is a single one.

That's a wildest thing. One to five is like a one to five ratio. Yeah. And then you had the Nelson Rockefeller drug laws that came into effect that required mandatory minimums and et cetera, et cetera.

So when we talk about social conditions and we talk about situations that were created for the purpose of what you know, they separated, you know, you separated families. You had mothers who and really grandmothers who had to take care of the children because the mothers were industries smoking crack and the fathers were either industries using drugs selling drugs or in prison with astronomical sentences and removed from the family structure and totality. Because of these conditions. So now you have the child just kind of left to fend for itself.

And we're not even talking about the children who were born that were subject to mothers who, you know, the crack baby, right? Yeah. And that's just, I mean, let's just go on and on. We talk about social conditions and we talk about the long term effects of these conditions and how it produces behavior.

Like Ivan Pavlov, one of my favorite psychologists, he talks about stimulus in a response, right? A classical condition. So you introduce the stimulus and then you have a response, which leads to the condition that we see. And you're also talking about what we were talking about earlier.

You're still dealing with these communities. They're still suffering from segregation, Jim Conner. And then they throw crack in it. Like just gas a lean on a fire.

It's crazy because we've had this conversation in the abstract. We've had this conversation, you know, about this very subject. And then the more I got to know Sheldon in his story, I said, well, here was someone that not only lived it. And I want to make clear.

One thing that has always struck me about Sheldon is his vulnerability, but also his honesty. He's like, I hope he's the first to tell you out of the gate. I did it. I could have made better choices.

He's not asking for a pass based on his conditions. What he's always said to me was, I just want people to consider how it may have impacted me. So, and to me, you just can't ignore it. It doesn't say, well, poor Sheldon.

I think that because I guess, you know, I know him and the human being. So I like, I trip out when people are like, anybody that murders a Rob's or doesn't lock him up and throw me the key. I always feel like, well, look, why don't you explain to me how you have gotten to know somebody that has been brought up in different conditions than you are? How long have you sat and listened to them?

How long have you considered how that might have impacted them and compared it to the conditions you grew up in? How many people like him have you gotten to know? So again, I'm trying to walk a fine line between sounding preachy and just saying, let's just consider the circumstances in which he was born. We're both 48.

I don't want to get into my family struggled financially but had different opportunities. My mom was a school teacher. My dad was a knock around Brooklyn guy that did what he could do to provide for his family. It wasn't always great at it, but he was a wonderful man.

But I can't ignore that I had different opportunities than Sheldon did. So when he gets out and then he arrives back on the street, I don't think anyone's going to argue with the fact that you're impacted and molded from 10 to 13 and forward, 13 to 18 by the people you're around. What have the conditions you're born? And I never even went back to school after that.

So I'm talking about after the fifth grade, I went back to school maybe four weeks when I was 17. So I'm watching over in high school. I went to school four weeks and I just dropped back. I just saw no purpose in going to school.

And I really didn't go back to school. I really educate myself until I went to prison. Today I'm pursuing a master's in human services. Before we get to your master's, why don't you explain to you get back at 13?

So I get back into my community at 13 and I'm just kind of not only am I kind of trying to wean myself from all of the narcotics that happened to me. I'm talking about I gained so much weight. I went from a slim kid to being fat because of the medications that they was getting. So what did they give me?

They would give me how do I lithium, thorazine, milleril, another medication called jit. And those are the ones that I'm aware of. And I'm talking about I was just like heavily sedated. Just.

And that's what they do all the kids. And that's what they did the most of the kids. They just want to keep them calm and quiet. Keep them calm and quiet.

Are they giving you any counseling when you're in there? Are they done? It's superficial. It's not really it's not really it's not really a good thing.

It's not really it's not you know, you got a bunch of kids who sit around in the group and you know, they do a feelings check, but the counselors really the counselors as far as I was concerned, the counselors didn't really care because they were there. Yeah, there was so much going to counselors was just there for check. There was so much going on that was above and beyond what the counselors could control. It was just ridiculous.

You know, the kids going down into white planes, breaking in the cars, stealing, getting high, going across the campus, having sex with the girls. It was just insane what was going on. And I learned how to become this person. I learned how to survive there.

I learned, you know, what it meant to go and steal a Benzibox. Remember the Benziboxes where you can snatch them right out the car? People used to hide them. I learned how to, you know, break into a car with older guys and how to take a Benzibox and sell it.

So I learned how to survive there. I mean, I've always known how to survive superficially, but from from I just feel like at that point, I was put into a place where instead of getting real therapy or real help, I was just kind of put into a place and I was I was like, I was malleable. You know, I was I was young. I was impressionable.

And this is what I was seeing. These became my role models. These were the guys that I respected that I looked up to. They, you know, they were selling drugs.

They didn't have a care in the world. They had all of the girls and you know, ironically prison in my community was almost like a writer passage, right? In my community, when you went to prison and you came back and you didn't you didn't tell nobody and you were able to hold it down, you know, and work out back to the streets that you didn't get robbed or you know, you didn't get pumped. People looked at you differently.

Treat you differently. I remember when I was 15 years old, I wanted to go to Rikers Island so bad that I lied to the office. I got arrested for smoking up. I got arrested for smoking weed is legal now.

But back then, like weed was a thing like if they saw you smoking weed, that gave them justification to get out, stop you, take you down to the precinct, run you for warrants and all kind of other stuff. You sat in the bullpen for three, four days before you even got out. And I remember lying to the officer. He said, I hold you.

I said, I'm 16 because I wanted to go to Rikers Island so that I could come back and be around older guys and tell them, Hey, listen, I went, I still got my sneakers, you know, and girls and everybody just treated you different. And it's really sad. But that was a reality that I was faced with. So I come back.

I'm 13 and I'm going to this stuff. My mother's still struggling. She's on SSD with your Social Security for disability. My father's in prison.

And it's just, I started selling drugs. Guy offered me an opportunity to be a lookout. He said, listen kid, I just need you. I'm going to give you 75 hours a day.

I just need you to stand on that corner. And when you see the police car, just yell, Oh shit, oh shit. That was like a little thing. And I was just standing there.

And eventually I just slowly moved up the ranks and I became this person that I feel like I was never meant to be. But because of the conditions and because of where I was at and because I what I saw what I was exposed to made me into someone else. It turned me into into into this person that I was never meant to be. And I just, you know, just when you're in these, these, these, when you're in this melting pot of just insanity, you know, you lose sense of what's, what's permissible and what's not and what's impermissible, right?

You know, I'm committing crimes and it just doesn't even matter no more. I was never guiding, you know, to hurt any old people. My era, you know, when you see old people come through, you helped them with their bags and we have respect for others. That was something that was always taught to us.

Now these kids, it's just, that's a whole other story. But yeah, I'm just, and I'm coming and I'm getting arrested for little stupid crimes driving without a license, standing on a corner, little smudge, petty drug cases. And I'm just, I'm just kind of just moving through my life with no purpose. But I'm providing for my family.

My mother doesn't, you know, at the end of the month we don't have to worry about just eating grits and cheese no more. You know, we can eat chicken and velvety shells and cheese, you know, and for some people that's significant. You know, I can buy a couch now, I can buy a real couch with that, that's comfortable. I can buy a TV for my mother.

And I can buy a couch with a little, you know, set up a cable where she can watch HBO. All of these little small things that I wasn't able to do that she couldn't really do for herself after she paid the rent, was significant. And it made me feel like I had a purpose. It made me feel like a man.

When the actuality, you know, many of the values and the morals that I adopted growing up, which is so warped and so misplaced, like Scarface the movie, right? You know, you have this, oh, I don't break my balls in my word for nobody, right? You know, and I remember one time a friend of mine, he came to pick me up. And he was on a run from the cops.

He had a warrant, office arrest. He had a car full of drugs and a car full of guns. I was in my word. I felt like I couldn't back out of the situation.

Nothing bad happened. But it's just the idea of sometimes growing up and adopting these values and these morals. And you begin to take them on as part of your characteristics. And you just make, you end up making really, really bad decisions that can cause you for the rest of your life, like my son.

Like when my son, when he got into a fight with an Asian guy, they called him the Columbia Law Student Killer, right? He gets into a fight with this Chinese guy. And this is not to take away anything from that man's family. And you know, as a man, as his father, I felt some type of way.

But the guy goes into the street and gets hit by a car and he dies. But this is how fast your life can change from just one simple mistake, from one mistake. And I just felt like, you know, a lot of times these conditions are created and there's really no alternatives. I had never been on a plane.

Like I said, I never even thought about going on a plane. So I'm growing up in this community. My father's gone. My mother's, you know, she's deaf.

I ended up having a son. My son was born in 1993. And that just made things, that just exacerbated the issue, right? So now I'm really, you know, what am I going to do now?

You know, I have a son. I have someone to look at. And then despite how many times I said that I was never going to be who my father was, my actions were actually setting me up to be exactly who my father was and removed me from my son's life. And in 19, I caught the gun charge that triggered the felony that allowed them to be able to sentence me the way that they did in 1994.

I also caught another case. At that time, I was what you call, given out consignment on drugs. Two people in particular, I gave consignment to when I ended up getting arrested for a case. And when I sent someone to go pick up the money from them, they kind of just was like, you know, whatever.

I'm not paying them. So when I came home, one guy in particular, I ran into him with his girlfriend. You get that case, got dismissed, right? The gun charge?

No, the one that you were away for. You got arrested for something. You're in jail. Yes.

These guys figure since you're in jail, fuck it. We're not going to pay them. Yeah, I'm not going to pay them. And then the case that you arrested for got dismissed.

I got to wait. Then you come home. Then I come home and you know, I need my money. I need my money.

I'm just just me being honest. This is misbeing straight. I gave you something and we had to understand it that you were going to pay me. And when I came home, when I finally located this particular individual, he had his girlfriend with him.

And this guy owe me $5,000 for some drugs that I gave him on consignment. I gave him an eighth of a kilo, which is 125 grams of cocaine. And when I saw him, he had a bunch of jewelry on. He was with his girlfriend.

She had a bunch of jewelry on. I said, Hey, man, where's my money at? Oh, y'all, I was going to pay you. And as far as I was concerned, his jewelry was even.

So I robbed him. And I took his jewelry. And his girlfriend happened to be there and unfortunately she got caught up in the situation. I had a bunch of young guys with me.

And they robbed her as well. And he got hit in the head with a gun right here on the side of his head and he got two stitches. And they gave me 25 years for that case. Did you hit him in the head?

No. One of the guys that I was with hit him in the head. And he identified me in a photo array, unbeknownst to me, he identified me in a photo array. This guy, you know, as far as I was concerned, he was in the streets just like I was.

So I didn't really understand that. Like I said, we go back to morals and values and principles and how warped they can be, right? In my mind at the time, this is a guy who I gave something to. He's living an illegal life.

I'm living an illegal life. So as far as I was concerned at that time, I was a fair game. And I was like, as I moved on and I became more mature and I began to reevaluate myself. And I realized how wrong that was.

But that was later on. At this time, I committed the crime and I just kept moving. Another guy that I ran into, he also owed me some money. He owed me $7,000 and it kind of went along the same ways.

He was selling drugs out of an auto parts store. He was a Spanish guy. I got worried that this is where he was at and he was selling drugs and I was going to get my money. And the same circumstances kind of suit.

So I'm, hey, what's going on? You know, reading in between the lines and outside the margins without really going into all the details, I robbed him because he owed me $7,000. Did he get physically hurt? No.

He didn't get touched. Got roughed up a little bit, but there was no physical, there was no physical harm. Nothing. Going back to morals and values and principles, right?

In my mind, he was very gay. He's selling drugs. I'm selling drugs. You owe me money.

I came and take what you have. In that world, that was considered as permissible. These are one of the rules of something that was permissible in that world. Long story short, in December 1997, I get arrested for both cases, really for one of them, for the one with the guy and the girl.

And then the other case drops with the auto parts store. Got it. I said there was some drugs out of the auto parts store. I am in the process of going to court.

I'm going back and forth to court. I'm on Rijkaz Island at the time. It's just crazy on Rijkaz Island. That's when the gangs was involved.

Prior to that a year before that, I had it got involved with the gangs. I was blood. I was a gang member. This is where it comes from on my face.

I have a bunch of stab marks from just being in those environments and being on Rijkaz Island and just warring with other rival gangs, mostly Latin kings and then yatas. My final offer before trial was 23 years. Which kind of blew me away because my lawyer kept telling me that my maximum sentence was 25 years if I went to trial. So my mind, it just didn't make no sense to me.

Why would I forfeit my rights to an appeal if it's only a two year difference? I told the judge, I would take 15 years right now. I acknowledged that I had made some mistakes and I had done some things that were wrong. I said, I'll take 15 years right now.

He refused to accept my plea offer and I went to trial and ended up getting 50 years. Five zero. So they give you 25 for each case? 25 for each case.

Consecutive. I remember blowing trial and just not really understanding what was being there but it was almost surreal. I remember when I went and got sentenced and the judge said 50 years. I had a black lawyer, a black judge and a white prosecutor.

And I remember when he said 50 years. He said, well, it's all of these reasons why he was sentencing me the way that he was sentencing me. There was never no post, there was never no, they're supposed to do a report prior to your sentencing and it's called a post supervision interview. Presenticing, investigation is called the PSI, presensing investigation.

There was never no presensing investigation. There was never no mitigating evidence presented on my behalf to highlight why I made some of the decisions that I made. And he just called me a minister society and he gave me 50 years. And I remember when I first got the gown state which is a processing facility.

And they give you what they call it as a time computation sheet. And on the time computation sheet gives you all the numbers like the beginning of your bid, how much jail time you have. And I just remember 2049. That's all I kept looking at.

And I was like, so fucking serious? This is 1998, 1999. And I'm trying to do the math and I'm just like 2049. I'm like, that's 50 years from now.

And I remember going to the law library and I forget how I get the world on that. And something just says, look up the life expectancy. And I look up my life expectancy. And as an African-American me and my life expectancy at that time, the 67 years old, I did the math.

And I said, I'm going to die in prison, man. I just really believe that I was going to die in prison. One thing I learned really, really quickly when I got to prison was that prison does two things to you. It brings out the best or brings out the worst.

And what I saw was I saw individuals who were at their worst and I saw guys who were at their best. The guys who were at their best were guys who were involved in education post-secondary education programs. They were running the program. They were running the violence groups.

They were running the substance abuse groups. And I remember saying to myself, I want that. And I remember just being involved in so much bullshit because I was in a gang. I was top of the food chain.

I had my own nation. I wasn't just like the random gang member. I had a whole nation under me. And I was just in and out the box, in and out the box, solitary confinement, which has been considered as unconstitutional now.

And I remember just having these moments of reflection and just asking myself, like, what are you going to do? Can you spend the next 48 years living like this? I said, I couldn't do it. I had lost all my privileges.

They took everything from me. I was in Southport at the time, which is closed now. It's a solitary confinement facility in New York State. I was on a loaf, which is also unconstitutional now.

So the loaf is a dietary restriction that they give you. It's a chunk of bread. And it has cabbage and carrots in it. And they give you like a quarter of the cabbage and they give you a cup of milk.

When they can't take any more of your privileges, this is what they would give you. Six days out the week on the seventh day, you would get a hot meal, breakfast, lunch or dinner. And then they would go back for 21 days. They would do the six and one, six and one, six and one, six and one.

And it was at that moment where I really said I have to change my life. I have to change my life. I just can't do this. I had a wife.

I had family still. My son was growing up. He was hearing stories about my so-called notoriety. I just didn't want to be that dad.

Like, I really was looking at myself and really evaluating asking myself, like, yo, what the fuck are you doing? I was still smoking a lot of weed at the time. I was drinking on jailhouse, hooch. And I was at my worst.

And I had to figure out how to get to my best. So I decided to, when I got out of solitary confinement, I did 42 days on the loaf. I went from being 210 pounds to like 168 in like a matter of seven months. They flated me.

And when I got out, I made a decision that I was going to walk away. And I didn't care about what the consequences was. And I said to myself, I've been doing bad for so long, I'm going to try to do something good. If all else fails, I could always go back to doing bad.

But let me try. Let me give it a shot. And I ended up getting to a school program. I got my GED.

I left the gangs alone, which was a benefit for them because, you know, I was what you called an authoritarian. I was a rule guy. I'm still a rule guy. I like rules.

I like structure. I like things to be a certain way. And it was still the advantage to get rid of me anyway. Plus, I knew a lot of the guys who were at the time.

Why was it to their advantage to get rid of you? Because I was the type of person who would say, you doing that for what reason? No, you can't do that. The rule says that you can't do this.

You can't do this. This is the rule. And I was the rules of the prison or the rules of gangs? The rules of the street.

Yeah, there was rules. Give us stuff for instance. Okay, so for instance, I could be in a whole other facility. I say I'm in Greenhaven and the guys in Attica, and they want to do something to him because they feel like he's not sharing his proceeds of drugs that he's bringing into the facility.

The rules say you can't do that. That's his property. That's his belongings. So I was a rule guy and it was still their advantage to get me out of the way.

And I decided to take a step back. They were like, yes. And it was to my advantage as well. And this was in 2005.

So there was no resistance. No. And at that time, this is where a lot of what they call set trip and began, the organization began to implode on itself. The gang organization, there was a lot of infighting sets against sets.

And I was just always against that. And it was time for me to go. And I didn't care whatever the consequences was. I was fortunate that there weren't any consequences.

But I didn't care what the consequences was. I just walked away. That begins your journey. This begins my journey.

I got into school. I got my GED from there. I got involved in correspondence courses. I started interacting with guys who were teaching AOT, aggression replacement training.

And I started to begin to understand how these concepts worked. What's positive visualization is deep breathing, how to remove yourself, conflict resolution, all of these ideas of change began to take place with me. Substance abuse, I stopped smoking weed. I stopped smoking cigarettes.

I was smoking like 30 cigarettes a day. I mean, I'm literally having chest pains from smoking cigarettes. And I realized that I wanted to live. And the only way that I was going to be able to live and walk out of prison was to remove myself from these substances.

I had seen so many guys get carried out. I see guys dying. Not just from just being stabbed or with altercation from officers. I seen guys dying from one guy.

I knew he used to drink so much. Who, who his liver failed on one night? He died in the cell that night. The one when they came to do that count, he was frozen.

He was stiff as a law. But these are the things that I was seeing. And I really, I was really in a situation where I had to ask myself, do I want to go out like that? And I didn't want to go out like that.

Tell me about jailhouse, how are they making that? So it's a bunch of ways they could make it use fruit juice, but a lot of guys used tomato paste. Tomato paste, water, and sugar. You need a kicker, which is like a, what they call a mash.

You would call it a mash. They called it a kicker. Get a plastic bag. You put it in a plastic bag.

You let it blow up. It goes through the process. The carbon dioxide process. I did the whole paper on ethanol when I was in Cornell.

So that I could learn how the process was. And it's pretty good stuff, especially if you distill it. But it's bad for you because it has a component in it called methane. And it goes straight to your brain.

But like, you know, in the streets when distillation places or facilities, they distill it, they removed that part of the alcohol. The methane, but in prison guys just drink it. It's just like, you know, give a fuck. Or you make the fruit juice.

Same thing, plastic bag, sugar, kicker mash. What is the kicker? The kicker is to accelerate the process. I know, but what is it consistent?

Usually like spoiled fruit, some spoiled bread with mold on it because it begins the process of fermentation. It's like a mash. So this is gonna be super toxic for you. Oh, super fucking.

Juicier's dropping like flies. Like flies. Here's the, when you hear like going forward, what? How Sheldon changes life and not just the correspondence courses.

But all of these various counseling programs, outreach programs, his connections to the outside world. What you'll talk about is that the impossibly sick fucking twisted, horrifically sad irony to all of this is that it took prison to save him. And why couldn't he be saved as a kid? That's what what I am really trying to sort of put energy towards now.

When you asked him earlier, wasn't their counseling in the group home. And you know, if you see what this counseling is like, obviously I can't cast aspersions on every counselor in a group home across America, but you know, I've had people on, you know, the podcast with me and I'm listening to their anger management classes, right? I won't mention who it is. But I'm listening to like the anger management class that they take.

And it's fucking, it's on zoom. It's run by a guy that can't fucking turn his camera on. And it's like, it is, it's, it's bedlam. There's just people screaming.

Hey man, I can't, I can't hear you. What the fuck did you just say? What are you here? Not just the anger and the frustration, but the guy's inability to control the situation, to control the technology, let alone giving out, you know, real advice and constructive feedback on how different people are.

He's checking a box this guy to do a job. Is that happening with everyone? It's not happening with everyone. But again, the, the, just the paradox here is that this, this insane, inhumane sentence actually saved Sheldon.

But why aren't there those programs that thought that implementation in his community to save him as a kid, right? And I don't just take cases. You know, the Perlmutter Center, we're on the executive director of the Perlmutter Center for Legal Justice at Cardozo Law School. We get a massive amount of mail and we get a lot of people calling us to help out on cases.

I want to help as many people as we can, but people that I think can succeed, or that we can help succeed when they get out. And, you know, on paper, you can see pretty quickly what somebody has done with their time. You know, I've sat with people in institutions all over the country where I said, what programs are you in? And I feel like an idiot asking because I'd be a fucking puddle on the floor.

I asked him many times, how often did you cry? How did you extract yourself from the gang? How did you sleep at night with the noise? Sheldon told me about this thing called a human harpoon that people make at magazines and a sharp toothbrush.

I mean, can you fucking, the mind fuck on this? They stiffen the pages of a magazine with toothpaste, soap, water, let it dry, let it dry so that they could basically work it into a rod. You keep on working the paper between your hands and then you attach with soap, newspaper, a sharpened toothbrush handle at the end of it. Or what?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Joe Rogan Experience?

This episode is 2 hours and 40 minutes long.

When was this The Joe Rogan Experience episode published?

This episode was published on February 1, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Joe Rogan Experience episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.