and immediately it was like when i looked at it was essentially it summed up to like you're not supposed to be here so that kind of attitude that i was getting from the world already just manifested in this old ugly painting on the wall so I'm Chris Chang and Phillips, Edmonton's historian laureate. Wait, nope, I'm not that anymore. But this is Let's Find Out, a monthly podcast about the history of Edmonton, Alberta, or A Mist Witchy with Skygon, on 3D6 territory. Let's Find Out is a proud member of the Alberta Podcast Network, powered by ATB. Check, check, check. Oh, that is still true. Each episode, we take questions from curious Edmontonians about local history, and then we find out the answers together. Wait, that's not what this episode is. What is happening? Is this still a podcast? Okay, yes.
Things will be back to normal next month, but I'm also in the middle of wrapping up my day job at the community radio station, CJSR, and with all the big, big changes happening in my life right now, I'm not putting together a full investigation this month. Instead, I'm reaching back to grab a handful of tape I recorded two years ago, when I first applied to become the historian laureate for the city. They told me to put together a presentation, and I thought, okay, I want to make a podcast. I better show them what I can do. Now, this story is pretty different from the final form that Let's Find Out ended up taking. It's just a straight-up story. And this is a story about First Nations people, settler people, Métis people, anger, and it's a story about art.
Now the interviews you're about to hear, I recorded them in 2016, so keep that in mind. It was almost like an emotional punch in the gut when I saw that, because I was just so unprepared for it. Well, I'm Kelsey Chief, and I'm a first-year Open Studies student. Well, I was raised in the Lackawish area, and of Plains Cree and Acadian-French descent. When Kelsey Chief was on her orientation tour at the University of Alberta in 2015, a librarian took her group to one of the most famous buildings on campus, the Rutherford Library. And they walked into a big, brightly lit room that's often called the Harry Potter Room, because all the bookshelves along the walls and the high ceiling have a very restricted section of the library at Hogwarts feel to them. And that's where she first saw two paintings, one of them set to become a big part of her life on campus.
And we went into that room, and they pointed out the mural. Like, first you see the Jean-Vier mural, and they pointed out that one. And then they turn around and point out the other one. And I thought the Jean-Vier mural was beautiful, it was great. It was kind of vastly overshadowed, though, by the... Normally that kind of thing, it didn't catch me off guard so much, but I was just so in, like, a childish awe of just kind of, like, wow, I'm at university, wow, I'm looking around, everything's new and great, and everything's going to be awesome. And it kind of just shattered that illusion.
So that second painting, the one that felt like a punch in the gut, is a mural called Alberta History. Henry George Glide was the artist. He was originally from England, studied art all around Europe. He started the U of A's art program, and he also helped the Banff Center get started. He painted Alberta History, this mural, as a gift in 1951, with help from some students. It's high above the entrance. It's like 20 feet long. You actually have to crane your neck and back up to get a good look. And it paints a picture, pun intended, of Alberta History dominated by two white Christian figures, the Catholic Father Lacombe and the Anglican Reverend McDougal. They're each standing around a cluster of indigenous people.
but the indigenous people mostly have their heads bowed, or they're facing away from the viewer. It's unclear whether they're Blackfoot or Cree or what, and Glide doesn't give them any visual clues. Fort Edmonton is in the background. Churches stand tall in the river valley, reaching up above a smattering of teepees. There's some big power relationships going on in this painting, and that's what Kelsey responded to most. The priest, or the pastor, or whatever, standing above the barely clothed, loincloth Indians whose faces you don't see at all.
whose humanity is obscured from you through both the stereotypical and inaccurate depiction of what they looked like and what they wore, and through not seeing their faces and them being crouched low below. Whereas you get a full view of the priest, I don't know, preaching to them, calming them, or soothing them. Every native person knows what it's like to be told down, to be calmed down, to not be so angry. Like, immediately it was like... When I looked at it, it was essentially, it summed up to like, you're not supposed to be here. So that kind of attitude that I was getting from the world already just manifested in this old, ugly painting on the wall. So like, cause that's the thing that like immediate, I had like.
I really studied for university, but I still had that kind of imposter syndrome. I didn't let it bother me too much. I just resolved, okay, well, that's one place I can't study here. Even though I knew there was like, there's hundreds of places. But part of me still felt angry that even if it's one out of a hundred places where I can go and study, one is too much. So Kelsey let that feeling stew. And then a writing assignment came up in her Aboriginal writing class that inspired her to do something about the anger she felt about that glad mural. She wrote a manifesto. And she got it posted in the library so students could see it when they came in and out of the room. I decided to write the...
The manifesto under the pseudonym The Angry Cree Indian, there's something close to that. I chose that because, I don't know, it was part of me just rebelling out against that idea that when you're angry, all of a sudden that you have nothing worth listening to. In the manifesto, she looks at not just the mural, but also what it represents, which to her is a failure of the U of A's attempts at reconciliation. And she asks other students to speak up about it. To actually acknowledge colonialism, to acknowledge it in a real way.
you know, mostly to talk about it, to actually, to let people know beyond our two-minute social studies lecture about colonialism in grade eight or nine, what it is to define it. If you're a settler, to be very considerate about the languages that you're, the language that you're using while discussing these issues. Someone is more likely to listen to you because they believe you to be the more impartial of the two, but to not take up too much of the space when it comes to discussions like these. What do you think should happen to the mural? I think it should be removed completely. Which is pretty persuasive, right? Persuasive enough that Kelsey got asked to be on a committee figuring out what to do next. But here's something that really fascinates me. One of the most compelling counter-perspectives comes from an essay written by a matey visual artist and professor. You could look at it on things. But I don't really quite see it that way. My name is David Garneau. I'm an associate prof at the University of Regina. I teach painting and drawing and some other courses. Born and raised in Edmonton. Moved to Calgary for about 20 years. Did a BFA and an English degree there.
maybe about five years ago, this teaching course. And when I brought primarily Indigenous students into the room, they didn't see it negative. And I was impressed that they didn't see it within the sort of knee-jerk colonial, anti-colonial frame. And they were focusing on the Native guy on the far right side. So, well, there's two groups of Indigenous people who look like they might be pacified by religion. A central figure, I mean, he's off to the side, but he's a dominant figure, facing the painting, facing, he's, you know, naked, like the other guys, except for a loincloth, but he's carrying a rifle. And to his right is a woman, and they seem to have some kind of agency in there, at least my Indigenous students.
The other readings that David Garneau sees in the painting are interesting. The settlers' attempts to pacify indigenous peoples around the time of the building of the railroad has parallels with the discovery of oil in Leduc in Glide's time. There's also a person in the middle of the mural that David says you can see as a way to start reading the painting, as a story about the birth of the Métis people as a political force, too. But beyond those specific things, what I think is interesting is that David says there are other legitimate ways of reading the mural, and it kind of doesn't matter what Glide intended. And he says Kelsey Chief's view that the painting should be seen as just what she calls a hanging message of hate in her manifesto.
David's not so hot on the Alex Jonker painting in the room as a solution either. It was put there as a response to Glide's mural.
To me, it just looks really awkward, though. It just seems like it has nothing to do with Glide's painting. I'd like to see... But for the student who wrote the manifesto, Kelsey Chief, that's not enough. I get... I truly understand that there is an underrepresentation of Métis history, misrepresentation. But I don't think you should be seeking it from a man like Glide. I feel like you don't have to keep something because it uplifts one people, but also is kind of putting down an entire other people.
It's been two years since I interviewed Kelsey and David, so I went back to Rutherford Library this week, up to the Harry Potter room, and Henry Glide's mural was still there, with no new signage explaining the context for the picture. And Alex Janvier's painting is still across the room, awkwardly facing the Glide piece. Anne Carr-Wiggin leads indigenous initiatives for the U of A libraries. Although the mural is in one of their libraries, it's technically managed by the U of A's museums and collections department. But she was the one who talked to the vice provost's learning services about Kelsey's manifesto, and that was what got the ball rolling with the group to review the issues around the mural. Anne said that although she would prefer that we're gone, since it's in a student space, there are quite complicated issues around it, like the fact that it's painted onto the wall itself. Also, the Glide family have rights to the work, and Anne said there are also issues around covering it or removing the wall with the work on it. She said the folks at the library use the mural and John Peer's painting as resources for teaching around representation of indigenous people and censorship.
I spoke to Kelsey Chief this week, and she verified that nothing really came out of all this after a few meetings with quote-unquote important university people. And she said she's become much more jaded about reconciliation since then. There isn't much of a middle ground. They can't be moved out of the room. In a way, it is the room. Which is the case with a lot of remnants of awkward people and ideas from our past. The name Oliver, that statue of the blanket swap behind the Stanley Milner Library, the neighborhoods built on Papa Chase land. I kind of appreciate that there is no easy answer with the mural.
partly because it shows that what the author meant isn't the last word. It shows that history belongs to us in the present, and it matters because it affects not only the way we see ourselves, but also what kind of communities we choose to create. So the question is still open. Who has the last word, if anyone? In a minute, I've got another free live history walking tour I want to let you know about, and I need questions from you folks again for this one. But first, Let's Find Out is a member of the Alberta Podcast Network, powered by ATB, host of wonderful Alberta-based shows, including That's a Thing, which is made by the founder of our network, Karen Unland, and her awesome daughter, Elizabeth. Elizabeth is kind of the young people correspondent on the show, explaining things like creepypasta and Tide Pods to her mom. If you, like me, feel frequently out of the loop, Elizabeth is an excellent guide to what the hell is going on with teens these days. That's a Thing is surprisingly easy to find on iTunes and on thatsthathing.libsyn.com.
What's Find Out is also brought to you by the Edmonton Community Foundation, funders of awesome things around town and makers of the Well Endowed Podcast, where you can hear the Chair of Canada's Task Force on Cannabis Legalization, Anne McClellan, explain why they are not calling it a pot task force or a marijuana task force. And also, you can hear her talk about how legalizing pot is going to change things, big time. You can find the Well Endowed Podcast in your favorite podcatcher or on their website, thewellendowedpodcast.com. All right, I promised I'd tell you about our next history walk. Back by popular demand, I'm really happy to announce I'll be doing another historical walking tour for the Let's Find Out podcast this June. It's another team up with the Ritchie Community League. Ritchie is a fascinating neighborhood, and last year we got to learn about when some of the street trees there were planted and whether some cows escaped from the meatpacking plant. If you have burning questions about this south side neighborhood, I want to help you find out the answers. And we'll be doing a walking tour to share what we found out on June 10th. So send me your questions. You can email me, chris at letsfindoutpodcast.com by Sunday, May 20th, or send a message to Let's Find Out on Facebook or Instagram. Send in anything you're curious about, like...
Maybe some questions about the Ayman Chow blacksmith shop? That's the building that's been in the news a bunch because the owners have applied for a demolition permit, and I would love to learn more about it. Drop me a line by May 20th, and join us on the walk, June 10th. Thanks for listening to Let's Find Out. This podcast is produced by Omar Salafu and me, Chris Jeng and Phillips. We want your questions about Edmonton history? Drop us a line at chris at letsfindoutpodcast.com. You can find all of our episodes on iTunes, Stitcher, Overcast, and letsfindoutpodcast.com. And you can find us on Facebook and Instagram under letsfindoutpodcast.
Also, every time I talk about the Glide Mural, people bring up the Grandin Mural in the LRT station underground, and Sarah Hoyles and Roshani Nair have done some excellent stories on the Grandin Mural, so I'm just going to link to those on the website. Okay, thank you time. Thank you to Kelsey Chief, David Garneau, and Ann Carr Wiggin. Thank you to Keevie Richards. Thanks to everyone who's been supporting this podcast, especially Finn. Original music for this podcast is by the monumentally lovely human being, Doug Hoyer. Artwork for our logo by Andrea Herji at Mount Pioneer Design. Alright, that's it for this month. Until next time, keep your questions coming.