*24.1 Makkos Daf 15 B (3 lines Dn)*

*24.1 Makkos Daf 15 B (3 lines Dn)**Summary**A learner* in the presence *of Rabbi Yochanan:* In the case of a _lav hanitak l’eseh,_ if he fulfilled the _eseh_ as soon as he was warned by _beis din *(kiymo)*,_ *he is absolved* from _malkos._ If however he ruined the opportunity to do the _eseh *(bitlo)*,_ *he receives _malkos._**Rabbi Yochanan: What are you saying?* (He saw that he was mixing together two extremes).*Learn: _“Bitlo_* receives malkos, *_lo bitlo_* is absolved from _malkos.”_*Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish:_Kiymo,_* if he fulfilled the _eseh_ as soon as he was warned by _beis din,_ he is absolved from _malkos._ However in a case of *_lo kiymo,_* he would receive _malkos._*Question:* What is this argument based on?*Answer:* It depends on the question of _hasra’as safek [a doubtful hasra’ah, that is when the eidim giving the hasra’ah cannot know whether a transgression will indeed take place]._*Rabbi Yochanan: It is considered a valid hasra’ah.* _[One can therefore be warned upon transgressing the lav and receive malkos a long time later upon ruining the opportunity to do the eseh]._*Reish Lakish: It is not a valid hasra’ah.* _[One can receive malkos for a lav hanitak l’eseh because the malkos is not dependent on the eseh*]._____________________* _Listen to the recording with Tosfos for more clarity on this point._ See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate