253 – Moby Dick (with Emily St. James!)

What this episode covers

We’re going back further than ever before this episode and we’ve got writer/critic/author Emily St. James along for the ride! After a consecutive run as an Oscar favorite in the late 1940s to early 1950s, director John Huston gave us 1956’s Moby Dick, an adaptation of perhaps the greatest novel of all time and often seen as unadaptable. With Gregory Peck as Captain Ahab and a cameo performance by Orson Welles, the film earned Huston favor at the DGA Awards, but even with its (then) technical feats, the film did not continue Huston’s Oscar streak. This episode, we talk about the impossible task of bringing Herman Melville’s novel to the screen and the perception of Peck as miscast. We also discuss the 1956 Oscars, Peck’s run as Academy president, and outrage over Home Alone‘s underwhelming Oscar nomination tally. Topics also include the Grumpy Old Men blooper reel, Reba McEntire as Trish, and we also announce the return of Vulture’s Movies Fantasy League! Join the rest of the Garys with league name AllOfUsGarys! And don’t forget to sign up for our Patreon, This Had Oscar Buzz: Turbulent Brilliance over at patreon.com/thishadoscarbuzz !! Follow Us on Twitter! @Had_Oscar_Buzz Joe: @joereid Chris: @chrisvfeil Emily: @emilystjams

Distinct summary based on available episode metadata or transcript content.