What's next? This is a question we're all having to ask and answer more frequently. I'm Jenny Blake, your host of the Pivot podcast and author of Pivot. The only move that matters is your next one.
For show notes from this episode, visit pivotmethod.com slash podcast. If change is the only constant, then let's get better at it. Here we go. Welcome back, everybody.
I am super excited and thrilled to be here today with one of my dearest friends, Bob Gower. Bob is a returning Pivot podcast guest. He was previously on the show with his wife, Alex, about their new book, Radical Alignment, how to have game-changing conversations that will transform your business and your life. That was episode 204, if you want to go peruse the archives.
My fun backdrop story to Bob and how I met Bob was that we were attending— I didn't live in New York City yet. I think this was 2010. And one of my internet friends, which was somewhat radical at that time that you would just have an internet friend that you've never met, was throwing a party in Manhattan. I went to this party, and being the introvert that I am, I just kind of zoomed in on one person who was interesting enough.
I'm not the type to circulate a room. And that ended up being the one and only Bob Gower. And I think we just geeked out about I don't even know what for three hours of, to me, riveting conversation. And we've been friends ever since.
So with that friendiversary story, because it's our 10-year friendiversary, Bob, welcome back to the show. Isn't our 10-year friendiversary, really? Yes, I think so. That party could have even been in 2009, in which case it's our 11-year friendiversary.
Isn't that wild, how time flies? That's insane. That's insane. And now we have so many friends in common.
You know, it's funny. You tell this story from time to time, and I'm like, that was where we met. But now it feels like we have so many different kinds of points of contact that I forget that it was so random, our initial point of contact. I do too.
And that our circles were not really overlapping at that time, but that now they completely do across all things, you know. Books, podcasts. I adore Alex. So Alexandra Jameson is Bob's wife.
I attended their wedding. I mean, there's just so many friendsgivings, so many brunches. A lot of these have been friendship. Oh, that's next week.
That should be next week. You should be coming over next week. Oh my gosh. I miss it so much.
I miss it so much. Me too. Me too. Well, at least we're here doing this podcast.
Right. Right. This is my social life now. Yeah, mine too.
Hey, I got to admit, I mean, for a long time, my social life is just hosting a podcast. That's my... See, that's another introvert strategy. If you're, you know...
I saw it through Rebecca's Instagram, which you linked to in one of your articles that we're going to talk about today. The most hilarious quote that empaths get confused because, I mean, that empaths get confused because they love and adore and care so deeply about people, and yet they don't ever want to be around them. But I don't think you have that problem because you're very social. Oh, I can be, but I also can be extremely shy.
And, you know, one of my strategies has always been to get a job at a party, you know? So to be the bartender, to be the welcomer, to have something to give me some reason to talk to people. Once I have a reason to talk to people, I'm fine, but I can be a complete wallflower. And I do the same strategy you do.
I zoom into one person and hopefully they're fascinating. And even if they're not fascinating, I usually try to find something that's fascinating about that person and kind of get to know them and broaden my horizons a little bit. Well, that's the real art of conversation is my dad told me when he was 16, he got a job bagging groceries and he was very shy. So in order to overcome his shyness at that time in his life, he would pretend he was Johnny Carson and interview, not interview, but ask questions of every single person that came through.
And he said that at the start, they would look at him like he was crazy. Why is this guy trying to talk to me? And that by the time he was carrying their groceries to their car, they didn't want to stop talking. And he's still like that today.
I don't know if you've met my dad. I have actually. I met him at your book launch party. I met your dad.
So then I think he circulated the room the whole time. Like he probably had more deep conversations than I was able to at the list. That's classic Dale Carnegie too, right? Is to, you know, if you want to be interesting, ask interesting questions.
You know, like if you want to be a good conversationalist, talk to people. And it's a strategy I've used, you know, throughout my life. Yeah, because, you know, and I also don't want to share too much about myself often. So it's also a good way.
A deflection strategy. I know that one well. Yeah. I feel, I feel a little, I'm a little shy in the beginning about sharing too much about myself, which is kind of funny once you get to know me, because my, my life has been so weird and, and I can be so open to people that I'm comfortable with.
Yeah. And you are very transparent and you're willing to take risks as well in terms of putting yourself out there, which I really admire. And on the topic of conversation, part of what sparked us having this one today was that you sent me a link to your fantastic article, rules of engagement, five steps to better arguments. And you had sent this to me pre-election and outlined the difference between discourse and debate.
And I thought to myself, because you and I love going on walk and talks as well. That's one of our many activities when I'm not brunching with you and Alex. And we talk about a lot of hot topics, a lot of things that are quite controversial. We talk about the different media that maybe we've listened to or articles that we've read.
And it always strikes me that you and I are able to reach. And I want us to actually define for listeners the difference between discourse and debate, but that so many of us have probably had quite fraught conversations this year during a stressful time, a lot going on politically, economically, socially, justice, you know, there's a lot going on. And I think it can get quite heated and it can be quite stressful when there's these obvious differences that we have across the political aisles. But what if there's tough conversations happening in your own home or your own friendship circles or your family or approaching holidays coming up?
I just thought you've outlined such a beautiful way to think about this. And that's really what I'm excited to dialogue with you today. Like no agenda, just to dig into some of this. Cool.
Well, I'm really glad the article spoke to you. It was an article actually written for myself in many ways, really trying to capture the way I was beginning to think about discourse or the way I was beginning to think about conversation. And it was really driven by an experience I had a couple of years ago where I read a book, which is now super hot. I think it's still probably one of the bestsellers and still quite controversial, which is Robin DiAngelo's White Fragility.
And when I read White Fragility, you know, my experience of it was as a middle-aged white male, which I guess we always have to qualify things these days, but it all made perfect sense to me. You know, like I read it and I was like, oh yeah, this, I agree with the points she's making. It aligns with my worldview rather comfortably. It's something I'm always trying to do better on my own sort of internalized sense of my own internalized racism or my own attempt to be a good actor in the world.
And then I posted something on my Facebook about it. And it wasn't anything really about white fragility. It was just a list of bullet points that she has in the book, which is sort of like, you know, this is what the power structure looks like. This is the racial makeup of the people who make laws in this country, the racial and gender makeup of the people who decide what gets on TV, who decide what gets on the radio, who again, decide what laws get made.
And it was just a very interesting and very stark list because of course, it comes out, you know, very heavily white and very heavily male. And as I looked at that, I was like, oh my gosh, if you think this is the result of a meritocracy, then that's kind of a white supremacist stance. I don't mean it in the inflammatory way. I just mean that you're saying that if, if this power structure is the way it is because these people earned it and nobody else did, then you're saying that these people are better at earning that than other people are.
And if those people are all white, then essentially we're saying that white people are better at earning these things than people of other races or people of other genders, the white males are kind of better at, better at leading, better at deciding what gets on TV, better at making laws. And to me, like that, that seemed like a fairly, almost benign argument, even though I know it's inflammatory and maybe it even sounds inflammatory to you, I'm not really sure, but it was just sort of like, You're now more intentional. What I see you post on LinkedIn, you know, the article we're talking about, Rules of Engagement, and of course, I'll link to it in the show notes, is posted on LinkedIn. It's very deep and thoughtful.
So therefore, there again, you're trying to invite discourse, whereas why I think this is so important, it's like you said, debate almost puts the other person on the defensive. And it doesn't build bridges. I mean, and this is something that I have been kind of concerned about in the last few years as well, that I think for so many people, there's a desire to create change, but how we go about that change is important. Otherwise, it just won't work.
And when we're just like conversational rams, totally butting heads and trying to be right, it doesn't do anything. You're just then talking into an echo chamber. And, and so I just love you starting out by defining discourse is actually an effort to kind of end up, at least having an open mind and trying to learn from the other person. Whereas debate is, I'm going to keep pressing my arguments until I prove that I'm right, as if there is a right or wrong.
Yeah, it's really interesting because I think what, what I was also became really aware of my own, let's call it potential hypocrisy with it because a lot of what I'm arguing for, you know, and the work that I do, you know, I care really a lot about, let's call it diversifying the power structure of society, you know, like that. And I, and I care about it for a couple of reasons. One is, I think, you know, it's the right thing to do. You know, I do think that, you know, equal access to power, equal access to media, you know, maybe even a small example.
I was watching a movie last night, this documentary about artists, and there was a young woman who's an actress and she's black and she's queer. And she talks about how, you know, like she, when she was a young girl, she just didn't see her stories represented in the media. You know, she was still entertained by the other stories, but maybe on the Cosby show, maybe here and there, she would see little glimpses of her experience, but she really wouldn't see her experience. So I think, okay, that's just important.
That's just sort of being fair and being nice. But further than that, you know, I also work with teams that are focused on innovation, focused on problem solving. And I know that when you have more different kinds of thinking at the table, you tend to make better decisions. You tend to make better stuff.
You tend to solve problems in more interesting ways and in ways that are more useful to more people. And so this idea of sort of equity, inclusion, sustainability, access, all of these things really matter to me. And it's really what I've spent my life working on. But then when I got into this debate, I found myself wanting to just shut down contrary ideas rather than really engage with them, you know.
And, you know, I make this point often to the teams that I work with that just diversifying teams isn't enough because most teams operate in ways that assume homogeneity in terms of background, in terms of thought, in terms of, you know, ways of discourse. And we have a homogeneous group of people. They tend to have less conflict just because they're like, oh yeah, of course, we see, you know, we see the world the same way. So we have less conflict.
And so when you introduce diversity and whether that's, you know, cognitive diversity in the sense of having somebody who's an artist and somebody who's a scientist at the table or whether it's, you know, background or identity diversity in terms of like where someone comes from or the life experience that they've had based on, you know, their gender, based on their race, based on their religion, based on where they grew up, their class, that you, by definition, are introducing conflict into the conversation. And so I do really, really believe that we do need to come up with a better way to talk to each other. And and I don't and I have to be, I have to be honest, I think I'm part of the problem, like a lot of the time and I'm really trying not to be. Yeah.
Well, I think you said something in the, in the article that I wanted to bring up, which is that there are cases. You said there are there are times when calling out, you said, I believe it is our duty to aggressively at times counter speech that is causing harm. And so I think especially this year, there's been such a call for people to use their voice in any manner of ways. Where I've seen this get problematic is that some people feel so strongly about an issue.
And there's a lot of them that were on election ballots, not not just the president, but all manner of things. And that when people get very entrenched in their views, they believe that they're right without a shadow of a doubt and that the other side is causing harm. And that, in fact, the notion of harm is some is subjective sometimes in that you and I, you and me, Bob, we might agree on what's harmful any manner of of aggressions, microaggressions anywhere along a certain spectrum. But not everybody agrees.
And so then I see that this creates some of the combative tension because people are wondering, when do I speak up? When do I speak up more aggressively than not? You know, just recently I shared in a Pivit list newsletter, just my two cents at the election result. I thought this can't be so controversial.
I don't want to I don't want to, you know, we talk, you talk about right speech in the action and that's important to me, too. Like I really try not to spend my energy disparaging. That's doesn't fit my ethos. But yeah, it was so controversial.
There were a reply came in saying, kind of, how dare you? This election hasn't been called yet. Well, to me, it has. You know what I mean?
But that's somehow in today's day and age, I don't know what to say. It's not a fact, although the facts seem clear to me and so this duty, this duty to counter speech is causing harm, I think sometimes creates a, a lot of the arguments because people think that they're doing right by their, their community or their causes that they care about. Yeah, I'm really reminded of, there's a philosopher who weirdly, I don't agree with a lot of things, but whose work I really respect named Brian. I think it's Brian Singer, an advisor on The Good Place.
And even actually Michael Schur, who is the creator of The Good Place, like wrote the introduction to his last book. So I heard him interviewed. I heard Singer interviewed. What he talks about is that being a good person is actually not very easy.
So he like posits his sort of classic thought experiment. This is a little bit of a diversion, but I think it's going to be back someplace interesting. But his thought experiment is that if you're like see somebody drowning, you're walking past a pond and you see somebody drowning and you're the only person who can save them, but you're wearing your really nice shoes and you don't jump in because you don't want to mess up your shoes. You know, clearly that's an immoral act.
But when you also like go shopping for really nice shoes that essentially you're making the same choice because that money literally could save somebody's life in the third world by buying them a seat on that or by buying the vaccine or by buying, you know, like there are very clear ways that that money could actually save lives that would otherwise be lost. And so when we decide to buy a luxury good, we are in a sense deciding that that luxury good is more valuable than somebody else's life. And I think, you know, what we're looking at the world, obviously through a, through a capitalist lens here in some ways, but, but yeah, I mean, the point that Singer, I think was trying to make is that being a good person is really hard. And and I think it's kind of to your point, there's another meme.
We'll just speak in memes briefly, but that, uh, I saw this meme yesterday. Somebody said just because someone gets angry when you say no, doesn't mean you should have said yes. Right. Um, Right.
You know, which is uninternally, right. But we're not responsible for other people's reactions to our actions. And so then the question is like when it comes to, and this is where I think that it gets really kind of difficult to tease apart sometimes, but when it comes to your newsletter or when it comes to my work, you know, I think about this when I write pieces or when I, I'm kind of, you know trying to figure out what my next book is going to be right now. Uh, or when I'm, you know, I'm giving a talk in a few.
Weeks to some people in Brazil, some HR people at a big corporation and I'm trying to think what I really want to say, but when I'm thinking about those sorts of things, it's the question is, is sort of like, well, what's true? That's one thing. And the other question is, is what's helpful, which doesn't always, which aren't always the same things. Like just because something is true doesn't mean it's helpful.
Just because something expresses like my authentic, you know, like let's say I am happy over the results of the election, which by the way, I am, that, and I do believe it's decisive at this stage, that that that it may not be really useful for me to go around and tell everybody that I'm happy, depending upon who my, you know, who I want to connect with and what kind of And throughout the course of this, the pandemic, he and I started meeting really regularly and really trying to work on something together. And we operated in very, very different domains. And so what we were going to try to build together. And he's quite a contrarian too.
Like, he's somebody who really, he's a scientist. And he really sometimes just likes to throw out, you know, radical ideas that are completely the opposite of what you're saying. You know, I'm saying. So anyway, through the course that we were meeting, we started meeting weekly, which was much more often than we'd ever met.
And then during, throughout this, through the Black Lives Matter, you know, the George Floyd protests started coming up as well as the pandemic was more and more in the news. And he started expressing some ideas, just in this very offhand way that I found very, you know, kind of off-putting, let's just say, you know, they were really kind of contrary. But he's also not white. He also comes from a country where he, you know, he's experienced a lot of, you know, racism aimed at him in his life.
And so I tried to approach it with a lot of humility. And then it just, I found it very, very difficult, frankly. Because, you know, we kept coming back and kept talking more and more. But at the end of the day, I was like, these topics really probably just aren't good for us to talk about.
And as a matter of fact, what I realized recently was that the, like, had we just remained sort of like drinking friends, like, if someone throws out an idea, like, I'll counter the idea, we can talk, we can banter around, but nothing's really on the line. But the fact that we were talking about working together and that we were going to be in the front of the room together, kind of, and we need, you know, in that case, I feel like we sort of need to align or at least, you know, have some sense of alignment. I'm going to cut this story short, but the, it's been somewhat painful for me. We haven't actually spoken recently.
We sort of just hit pause on the project and then we haven't come back together again. But there's a part of me which feels like, I don't know that we should have gone that deeply into the project together. Because I don't want to have to resolve every difference of opinion with every person in my life. I just don't think that that's constructive or, you know, but there are people, like if I'm building something with them, it's not that we have to agree on everything.
As a matter of fact, we should probably disagree on some things. But we do need to have some sense of alignment. Am I making any sense at all? Like, I feel like I'm actually still a little bit fuzzy about this.
And so it's probably coming across as I'm talking. That's why we're having this discourse, this kind of discourse, or is it just a one big ramble? That's for the listener to decide. Yes, listeners, you can decide for yourself.
What I love what you said, there's something really crucial, which is that I don't want to resolve every ideological issue with every person in my life. And what you're describing is a friendship that was potentially tipping into some kind of business partnership, in which case your reputation is more intertwined. I still think it can be challenging. This idea of resolution, I'm pretty sure it was the Gottmans.
I know you cite the four horsemen. We should talk about those if you want. But I think it was the Gottmans who said, in all relationships, let's look at intimate relationships. There may be 30% that you will never agree on, whether it's the lifestyle or an issue, who knows what.
But there's this common core of disagreement. And the research said that the couples that are the most successful learn what that is early on and they learn when they're in one of those argument pitfalls. Why am I trying to say potholes? Pitfalls.
They're in one of those argument potholes, and they stop. They don't even try to resolve that piece of it. They just say, oh, here we are again. We're in that familiar trap.
And I will say that probably similar to you, I love some of the many of the contrarians in my life. I love the rebels, the contrarians, the questioners. I love people that are not always just willing to accept the status quo. It is important to me that I have these types of people in my life.
I'm curious about them. I love hearing what they were exploring. And I have, there's so much I respect. And what that inherently will come with is some percentage that's totally out there as far as I'm concerned, which, which is their prerogative.
You know what I mean? So I think sometimes it's interesting to note that we find these contrarians exciting. You know, they're kind of exciting to talk with and think about what are you thinking? How do you think about this?
What have you discovered? And yet it's just inherently going to come with stuff that's going to make the listener uncomfortable as well, because they're saying what goes against the mainstream, basically again, not, not the acceptingness at the point of causing harm. I'm saying it's probably different than your example that you're giving, but there's certainly going to be more room for landmines with those types of people or thinkers and just your intention to not necessarily feel responsible to resolve it every time. I have to remind myself the same thing.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, my, you know, my specific concern with this guy was that he was going to say something in the room that, you know, might damage my reputation, but also might damage the level of discourse that I was trying to generate in the room if we were leading, if we're leading a workshop together. And I felt like there was a degree of unconsciousness to some of the biases.
I mean, we all have unconscious bias, which is, I think, which is why we need other people, because we need other people to kind of show us where those things are. And I'll also say that this this guy also like recommended a book to me, which I'm reading right now and kind of deeply involved in and, and it's really opening my eyes to some of the way that he sees the world that was being, you know, the way he was expressing it. Because I think sometimes when we're close to people also that we tend to, and especially online, right, that we were expressing things. You used the word nuance a while ago.
We're expressing things in this shorthand that almost has no nuance to it. You know, as soon as, and as you say, like if people don't agree with the statement that we, a statement that we make, like, you know, I think a controversial one that I'm still, you know, questioning and have, you know, interesting thoughts about, right, is defund the police. Right. So that was a big thing that came out recently.
And if you were like, wait a minute, shouldn't we have some police, you know, and are we talking about defunding all the way, you know, and police reform, I believe in, I probably believe that they need less money, especially in, I think the New York city, like the police in New York city is the, I just Chris Voss and his book said it's the seventh largest standing army in the world. You know, we might be able to have, we might be able to get by with a little less funding and direct some of that funding towards mental health care and all of these things. But all of that nuance gets lost in the, you know, completely abolish the police department as we know it, which I also think, yeah, the tagline. Yeah.
Yeah. But on the other side, you know, like I have some friends who are activists who are like, can make a pretty cogent argument for, you know, completely abolishing the police force and building a new thing from the ground up, you know, and completely rethinking the way, you know, and I'm like, oh, that's really interesting. I don't know anything about that kind of policy. I don't, I don't think about it.
And I think maybe we're getting on something else here, but, but one of the, the, the things that I've learned the hard way or that I've learned now that I'm off social media is I really don't need to have an opinion about a lot of different things, you know, there's so much. Yeah. Let's just stay in our lanes, you know? And, and at the same time, I think there is also this other thing, which I find somewhat problematic, which is you know, my, my training, you know, my, my degree is in, is in business as a sort of a social force, right?
So, so we called it sustainable business or sustainable systems, you know, 15 years ago when I got the MBA, but the idea is, is that, you know, that business can be a source of creating a better, a better world, which I think, I still think it's a valid idea. And so, but, but one of the things that you get at really quickly when you start thinking about these things is that everything really is connected to everything else, you know, like who we are privately really is who we are publicly, you know, like, and that the political stance of the owners of businesses does matter to me sometimes. And I guess what I'm, what I'm trying to address is that the idea that, oh, it's just business. And I see, I've seen this happen a little bit in the wellness space, which I think is really, really interesting kind of what's been happening there recently in terms of, you know, the and realizing how sort of difficult it can be to have those blinders sort of taken away.
But then what you're talking about, I think, in some ways is the other side of that, which is, we're going to ideologically retrain people to think the way, to have the experience that I'm describing that I have for myself. So I hope I'm being clear here, because what I'm saying is that I believe that this inquiry, I'm calling it awakening. I know I'm not comfortable with that word, but I'm going to stick with it for now, where I suddenly started seeing things that I had previously been unable to see, the deep inequities in our society, my complacency, even my participation in those inequities at times. And that's a painful, it's a painful experience.
James Baldwin talks about how it, you know, it attacks, you know, your sense of who you are, you know, your sense of the world. And it's really, really painful. In the recent article, I wrote about this exactly. But at the same time, I can't give that experience to somebody else.
If I start trying to go around saying, well, you need to have this experience now, to another person, that seems, you know, problematic, right? And I think that way does lie some of the things that the right wing is maybe concerned about when they raise the specter of communism and they start talking about, you know, the reeducation camps in the communist block countries and that kind of thing. I think it does come out of that impulse. I hope I'm not getting myself into too much trouble here.
Yeah, but who knows? Who can know? Well, like you said, we can't necessarily see. What I find so interesting is that every statement, maybe this is the postmodern era, every statement has its alternative.
Like when we went, when I was in orientation at Union, they said, intent is irrelevant. It's the impact that your actions have that matters and as might matter in terms of have you caused harm or not, which was counter to anything I had ever previously kind of thought around, well, my intention does matter, because if I'm intending to hurt you, that's very different than my best intention was to be kind and I still did the wrong thing. OK. And you talk about in your article the difference between calling out and calling in.
So there's a school of thought that intention is irrelevant. It's just the impact. And then there's another school of thought that's like the golden rule, treat people as you'd want to be treated and and that your intention does factor into the outcome. It may not be everything.
As we talked about, we can't be responsible for how people respond to every single thing we write and say and do. Otherwise, I would never create anything again because the effect that that has on me, I find it quite paralyzing to try to empathize and anticipate every single kind of possible way that I could create harm in all the unexpected ways. And obviously, I think we all want to do our best. That's why you and I are even here having this conversation.
That's why you wrote your article. But at a certain point, we've got to hit publish. We've got to keep moving. We've got to lean on that our intention is good, our intention is to build bridges while having all the self-awareness and deep digging.
And as you said, the awakening, like being willing to have the painful experience of seeing things differently. And also, I really resist. No, it's okay. I was just going to say I really resist thought control.
I don't care who it's coming from, but when someone tells me how I need to think and speak, I'm immediately going to resist that. That's just not going to work for me. And so sometimes I think people have the best intentions and they'll say, well, this is what you need to do now or how you need to speak or how you need to be. And I just don't think that that's going to work.
Like even if they, whoever saying that is with the best intention or thinks that that's correct, it's not, at least from my personal experience, that's not going to motivate me. I'm just going to stop. It's not going to work. I'll just say that.
Yeah, yeah. No, I completely understand that. Yeah. I mean, I think the way I'm thinking about all of this now is really kind of twofold, because I think you bring up some interesting things.
Like on the one hand, the way people speak to me or have asked me to speak or the way that I'll sometimes see people speak online about the way people who wear my identity, what we should do, you know, and how we should behave and how we should feel about ourselves and those kinds of things. There are times when I'll read some of those things and they really, it really hurts. You know, like it really like takes me back a step. And there are times where I'll, where I will tune people out.
I'll be like, okay, this is not the person who's speaking to the way I listen, but here's somebody else who's operating in the same space who does speak in a way that, that maybe I can hear. And sometimes you'll hear the same thing said in two or three different ways. And all of a sudden you're like, oh, wait a minute. Now I get what that guy was saying or that person was saying.
But there are also times where there are people who I know and love who are speaking in ways that I, and asking me to speak in ways or that, you know, there's a lot of anger. Let's just say there's a lot of anger being expressed and a lot of like shoulds coming from that person. And then I think about that person's life experience and how also how little I know what it was like, what it's like to be them. And I try to give them a lot of generosity and leeway because having both, you know, grown up with a, with a bit of childhood trauma myself and also in a discussion for another day, but, you know, I'm pretty open about it.
I was part of a high, what's called a high demand group, what you would sort of commonly call a cult for two years. And, you know, there was a fair bit of abuse and sort of trauma there and on the other side of it and recovery for myself. I know that there have been times in my life where if people are judging me based on my behavior and the way I used words in those moments and these sort of less than calm moments for me where I'm speaking out of my trauma that I don't want them, you know, I want them to hear my words in a different way. And so I try to extend that sense of generosity to as many people as I can.
Obviously I have limits, you know, but there are, you know, I try to extend that sense of generosity. And then on the other side of it, I really do my best to be somewhat ruthless with myself. I have a morning journaling practice where I write, I got it from, you know, The Artist's Way, from Julia Cameron's work, where, you know, you write 750 words in the morning and the goal really is to just be as really brutally honest about what you feel, what you know, what you understand, what's going, you know, what is up for you at that moment. And I really do my best to try to be as intellectually honest and as intellectually humble as I can myself.
So it's sort of an interesting combo of extending generosity to other people that I don't necessarily extend towards myself. Where I've seen others get tripped up or where I think others get tripped up sometimes, and I've seen this happen in, there are a couple of people I could name who are very big profile people. I feel like Sam Harris does this sometimes. I feel like Jonathan Haidt does this sometimes, is they are almost like lecturing other people about the way they should discourse all the time rather than looking at their own kinds of discourse.
Does that make sense? You know, like, and I think it's, so I think it's important to be sort of like harder on ourselves than we are on others, because I think that's, I think, because, you know, at the end of the day, it's a rather stoic way of looking at the world, I guess, but it's like at the end of the day, only, you know, we're the only people who we can really alter whose behavior we can really alter. And if we're really just trying to alter other people's behaviors or alter the discourse landscape by arguing and by tweeting, I don't know that we're doing a lot of good. I think maybe we're, we're creating friction where it's not really helpful and not really necessary.
Yeah. And thank you for sharing your experience and kind of your history a little bit too, because I also think that if you, if you've ever been in a relationship, as I have, where you've been gaslit or manipulated or a really a skew power dynamic. I can say in my case, I didn't have a well-enough developed muscle of discernment or boundaries of not being thought controlled. And in fact, this notion of being harder on myself, I was so hard on myself.
I didn't just exit the relationship. Like I actually think some of the a lot of the spiritual reading and practices I had done had me going, it's on me. What can I do? How can I see this differently?
How can I be more compassionate? And it kind of kept me stuck in situations and relationships that weren't good for me because I wasn't questioning. I was taking someone else's truth as my own. And that's why I think I get so sensitive around this.
And this actually brings us, zooms us all the way back out. Is this discourse or debate as how you've defined it, which is why it's so brilliant. That in discourse, we can have a sense that with the other person, I'm just engaging in that thing I hate, even the thing I don't want, which is righteousness, and this is the only way. Now, I may still end up there in my own heart, but at the very least, isn't every person entitled to their own sort of like journey?
Again, not creating harm in the world, ideally speaking, but that I think we can't allow. There are going to be boundaries that we draw, but I find it interesting to listen and think, what is it about their experience? And I don't similar to you, but I've uncovered parts of people's stories where I think, OK, it makes complete sense that this conspiracy theory or this part of the universe is resonating with you given your history that I can't possibly understand from my place of privilege or my position from being born in America. You know, it doesn't matter, whatever my worldview.
And so I do find it so interesting about how do we discourse across the, not just the aisles, such a cheesy phrase, but like, how do we listen generously and with curiosity and not enter that debate from that triggered place with the people who they think their worldview is, you know, is correct. And it's yet so fundamentally different from the one you and I have, I know, for sure, that you and I share in our line on many aspects of it. And this is what creates those, you talked about it, the liberal bubble or these bubbles that we have where it can be so fascinating when the bubble gets popped. And you're like, I thought everybody felt like me.
Well, no, they don't. Yeah. Yeah. I really think at the end of the day, I remember thinking this back, I think it was either in the 2000 or 2004 election when I first became aware of, you know, kind of polarization in this country and kind of where it was going.
I was like, I don't think we need further polarization. I think what we actually, you know, I was, you know, I didn't, I did not walk my talk. I moved to New York city and not out. But I was thinking like, we really need to move to like red counties and then and make friends, you know, like hang out with people and barbecue or something that I do think at the end of the day, that there's so much more that aligns us than doesn't align us.
There's so much more that unites us than doesn't, but it can be so, we can get so wrapped up in, especially because we live in a winner's take all political system and also this increasingly insular and weird, you know, sort of social media environment, which, which really amplifies polarization. Yeah. Not to mention increasing income inequality and the myth of meritocracy that we have in our capitalist, hyper-capitalist culture, at least here in the States. Right.
Late stage capitalism is a brutal place to live. Have you seen the Reddit? There's a late stage capitalism series of memes on Reddit. If not, but I will, I will look it up this minute.
I love those sort of channels. But yeah, but I, I, you know, and also I think something that's very comforting for me, which is maybe oddly comforting in a way, but is that, you know, this world was a pretty messed up place before I got here. And I'm, you know, entirely sure it will be a messed up place after I leave, you know, like, you know, and at the end of the day, it's not up to me to fix everything or to control everybody around me or to control the world, but it is up to me to be the best person that I can be and to do the best with what I have in order to leave the world a better place. Or at least not even, you know, not even think about the future, just to be a decent person to the people around me today.
You know, the people who are in front of me today, the people who, you know, I, I don't want to get too religious here, but who God brings in front of me today, right. To be with those people in a way that I can respect myself, you know, tomorrow. And if I get too, if I get too focused on outcome, if I get too focused on making things right, I think I'm really missing the point. I love that.
That's so, so beautifully said. And thank you for bringing us back to that place of sanity. You know, we can't save the world. We can't fix everything.
We can't turn every conversation from a debate into a discourse. We can focus on, and I just love your mission to just show up. And you so do live this way to be the best version of yourself, to learn and grow, to be kind to the people that God puts in front of you. I mean, wow, just what a beautiful place to end it.
Thank you so, so much, Bob. This is, as always, a delight to bat ideas around with you. And if you're still here listening and you survived all of our radical, thank you for being here. I mean, you can see that this is not about having any answers.
It's, and I think that's, hopefully we've lived some percentage of your message, Bob, of exploring, exploring ideas. I hope we've been interesting to at least one or two people and they've stuck around. So thank you so much, Jay. This has been wonderful.
Thanks again, Bob. And thanks everyone for listening. Thanks so much for listening to this episode of the Pivot Podcast. Make sure you don't miss an episode or my insider tips and templates by signing up for Pivot List, a curated twice monthly newsletter where I share the inside scoop on what I'm reading, watching, listening to, and the latest tools I'm geeking out on.
Sign up at pivotmethod.com slash pivotlist. Get show notes from this episode at pivotmethod.com slash podcast and connect with me on Twitter at Jenny underscore Blake. Remember, build first, then your courage will follow. Haven't it always?