*26.6 Makkos Daf 17 A (3 lines Up)*

*26.6 Makkos Daf 17 A (3 lines Up)*Rabbi Shimon is expounding on a _possuk_ , but he doesn’t go in the order of the _possuk_ , he skips around and rearranges the _possuk_ to best suit his exegeses. _[The possuk is a lav against eating a number of things “in your gates”, outside Yerushalayim.]_*Summary**Beraisa Continued:**Nedarecha refers to _olah_* [ _todah_ and _shelamim_ were already mentioned].It cannot mean that it may not be eaten outside of Yerushalayim, because *even the more lenient _maaser sheini_* may only be eaten inside Yerushalayim; we don’t need a possuk for that.It cannot mean that it may not be eaten before zerikas hadam because *even the more lenient _todah_ and _shelamim_* may only be eaten after _zerikas hadam;_ we don’t need a _possuk_ for that.It cannot mean that it may not be eaten after zerikas hadam by a Yisroel because *even the more lenient bechor* may only be eaten by a _kohen;_ we don’t need a _possuk_ for that.It cannot mean that it may not be eaten outside the _azarah_ because *even the more lenient _chatas_ and _asham_* may only be eaten by a _kohen;_ we don’t need a _possuk_ for that.It must teach that it cannot be eaten at all [even by a kohen, in the _azarah_ after _zerikah_ ]._(All the halachos mentioned in this beraisa were already known. Rabbi Shimon is providing a lav for all these prohibitions based on this possuk)_*Rava: Rabbi Shimon employs such remarkable methodology in this _beraisa_* that a woman who is having a child shouldn’t settle for less than Rabbi Shimon! _(In ancient times Jewish mothers would pray and make vows to merit a child who is among the Chachomim, we thus find that Shlomo’s mother referred to him as “child of my vows”)._ *Even though I can logically refute everything* that was said. See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate