#26: Is Atheism Really Rational? | Prof. Kelly James Clark episode artwork

EPISODE · Mar 30, 2026 · 54 MIN

#26: Is Atheism Really Rational? | Prof. Kelly James Clark

from Let’s Discuss · host The Prometheans

Is atheism the rational default — or is that claim itself irrational?In this episode of The Prometheans, Ali Zaka (AZD) sits down with Prof. Kelly James Clark — Distinguished Professor of Philosophy at Ibn Haldun University, former student of Alvin Plantinga at Notre Dame, and author of God and the Brain: The Rationality of Belief — to dismantle one of the central assumptions of the New Atheist movement.Prof. Clark argues that humans are natural-born believers, and that religious belief doesn't require formal evidence to be perfectly rational. Drawing on Reformed Epistemology, the Cognitive Science of Religion, and Plantinga's landmark Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism, this conversation challenges the idea that analytical thinking leads to truth — and asks whether the "rational atheist" narrative is itself built on shaky ground.What we cover:→ Why belief in God is the cognitive default, not atheism→ The "innocent until proven guilty" model of rational belief→ What the Cognitive Science of Religion actually says about faith and delusion→ The psychology of atheism — including Theory of Mind and autism research→ Plantinga's Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism, explained clearly→ Why your grandmother doesn't need philosophy to rationally believe in God→ Why disagreement makes us dehumanize the other sideThis is essential viewing for anyone serious about philosophy of religion, religious epistemology, or the ongoing debate between faith and reason.📚 Books recommended by Prof. Clark in this episode available on request in the comments.🔔 Subscribe to The Prometheans for rigorous conversations at the intersection of philosophy, theology, and interfaith dialogue.The Prometheans | Hosted by Ali Zaka Philosophy | Theology | Interfaith DialogueSubscribe to our YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/@prometheans789?si=dxtl-3Yikz7uD4Se

Is atheism the rational default — or is that claim itself irrational?In this episode of The Prometheans, Ali Zaka (AZD) sits down with Prof. Kelly James Clark — Distinguished Professor of Philosophy at Ibn Haldun University, former student of Alvin Plantinga at Notre Dame, and author of God and the Brain: The Rationality of Belief — to dismantle one of the central assumptions of the New Atheist movement.Prof. Clark argues that humans are natural-born believers, and that religious belief doesn't require formal evidence to be perfectly rational. Drawing on Reformed Epistemology, the Cognitive Science of Religion, and Plantinga's landmark Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism, this conversation challenges the idea that analytical thinking leads to truth — and asks whether the "rational atheist" narrative is itself built on shaky ground.What we cover:→ Why belief in God is the cognitive default, not atheism→ The "innocent until proven guilty" model of rational belief→ What the Cognitive Science of Religion actually says about faith and delusion→ The psychology of atheism — including Theory of Mind and autism research→ Plantinga's Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism, explained clearly→ Why your grandmother doesn't need philosophy to rationally believe in God→ Why disagreement makes us dehumanize the other sideThis is essential viewing for anyone serious about philosophy of religion, religious epistemology, or the ongoing debate between faith and reason.📚 Books recommended by Prof. Clark in this episode available on request in the comments.🔔 Subscribe to The Prometheans for rigorous conversations at the intersection of philosophy, theology, and interfaith dialogue.The Prometheans | Hosted by Ali Zaka Philosophy | Theology | Interfaith DialogueSubscribe to our YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/@prometheans789?si=dxtl-3Yikz7uD4Se

NOW PLAYING

#26: Is Atheism Really Rational? | Prof. Kelly James Clark

0:00 54:13

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Northern Sass and Southern Class Tay and Ani Come sit in on girl talk with Tay and Ani as we discuss life in Texas, girl math, food, wine and roasting each other. Explicit Bitcoin Gateway Lea meakin Welcome to Bitcoin Gateway, the podcast where we dive deep into the world of Bitcoin, hosted by Lea Meakin. This show is for anyone who’s ever felt overwhelmed by the complex world of cryptocurrencies and wants a simple, straightforward explanation. Each episode, we’ll break down the basics of Bitcoin, explore its history, and discuss its potential impact on the future of finance. Whether you’re a complete beginner or just looking to expand your knowledge, Bitcoin Gateway is here to help you understand Bitcoin, one episode at a time. Explicit Southern Senpais Nicholas Killian and Derek Johnson II Far from the far East, two American Southerners explore Japanese culture in Southern Senpais! Hosted by Derek Johnson (@derek.johnsonii) and Nicholas Killian (@nicholaskilliann), they discuss popular Japanese anime, manga, and video games from a Southern eye. Tune in as they navigate the culture from the perspective of two guys that grew up in small rural towns! Explicit The Pod and the Pendulum Mike Snoonian The Pod and The Pendulum is a new horror movie podcast covering every movie in every franchise. From heavy hitters like Friday the 13th, to the direct-to-video titles like Subspecies, we’ve got you covered. We feature guests on every show in order to discuss their love of movies like The Blair Witch Project, Scream, Alien, A Nightmare on Elm Street, Jaws, Halloween, The Conjuring, and many more. Support the show and become a patron today at www.patreon.com/podandthependulum and get access to exclusive bonus content. Tweet us at @podandpendulumEmail us at [email protected] a patron and receive bonus shows for as little as $2 a month at https://www.patreon.com/podandthependulum Explicit

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Let’s Discuss?

This episode is 54 minutes long.

When was this Let’s Discuss episode published?

This episode was published on March 30, 2026.

What is this episode about?

Is atheism the rational default — or is that claim itself irrational?In this episode of The Prometheans, Ali Zaka (AZD) sits down with Prof. Kelly James Clark — Distinguished Professor of Philosophy at Ibn Haldun University, former student of Alvin...

Can I download this Let’s Discuss episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!