Hey everybody, welcome. This is Classical Stuff You Should Know. This is a podcast about the classical world, old literature, that sort of thing. We talk about philosophy, sometimes art, sometimes the economy, surprisingly enough.
We talk about a lot of things. My name is A.J. Hanenberg. I'm joined by Thomas Magby and Graham Donaldson.
We're back, and I have only two questions for the both of you. Question number one is, am I the only one who doesn't always shower before coming to record? Do you really want us to talk about this? I mean, so here's what, like, I know how far I'm going to sit from you guys.
I know you probably won't smell me. I know you're jumping together in an episode, don't have time. I'm just wondering if that's just me or if that's... I think none of us have showered today, actually.
That's probably what's true. I'm not showered. Yeah, I have not showered today either. So, cool.
Clear that up. Question number two is, you know, right before we come into an intro, we always ask what the episode's going to be about so you can say something clever. Thomas asked Graham, and then Graham said a lot of words. And my question is, what was all of that about?
You said a lot of words that all seemed to mush together. I don't... We're talking about classical stuff. Classical stuff.
You should know. Yeah. Okay, cool. Question number two is, you know, right before we come into an intro, we always ask what the episode's going to be about so you can say something clever.
Thomas asked Graham, and then Graham said a lot of words. And my question is, what was all of that about? You said a lot of words that all seemed to mush together. I don't...
We're talking about classical stuff. Classical stuff. You should know. Yeah.
Okay, cool. Wow. I was reflecting on the fact that our name is pretty, like, classical stuff you should know. It's, like, pretty forceful.
Pretty direct. Like, you should know this. You should know this. It's kind of embarrassing you don't know this.
Yeah. So, really, instead of our goofy intros that we still haven't nailed, we should open up, like, what up, idiots? Here's the stuff that you should already know. Cool.
So what are we talking about today? I don't know. Can you give the same summary you gave me and maybe the audience will understand? We're talking about...
Well, I don't want to give away. Okay. So. We haven't recorded in a while.
One of the reasons we haven't recorded was I went on a vacation. That's the only reason. That's the only reason. That's right.
A.J. That's right. And I went to Rome. I've never been to Rome before.
And we did the tour of the Vatican. We paid the, like, extra money to be there before everybody else shows up and have the breakfast in the Vatican, which is really fun. And when we were going to go on the tour, the little tour guide said, oh, we're, you know, here's what we're going to be doing on the tour. And he didn't mention the Raphael rooms.
And we were kind of bummed. And so I was like, all right, well, that's kind of too bad. Maybe because Rome's going under, they're doing all the, like, they're cleaning it for the Jubilee next year. Anyway, my wife raises her hand and says, will we see the Raphael rooms?
And our tour guide says, no, we're not going to see them. I'll show you where they are at the end of the Sistine Chapel if you want to circle back and go yourself. And we're like, okay, that's fine. Anyway, we go to breakfast, we come back.
Hold on, I just realized something. So last night we were talking about your trip and you guys talked about how the Pieta was all like, it's just been cleaned. I said, well, that's really smart of you to go right after the Olympics because I know that in Paris they cleaned everything in that city. And for me, I guess my whole Europe trip blended together.
And for some reason I thought the Pieta was in Paris. So I said something really dumb to you. And Amanda and I realized it but didn't call you out on it. I really appreciate that.
Amanda, I love you. I'm sorry. I'm done. Yeah, I was like, Roman Olympics.
I just realized that. So anyway, we come back from breakfast and the tour guide's like, hey, would you guys be cool if we extended the tour by half an hour and go to the Raphael rooms? And we're like, yes. Anyway, so we got to go to the Raphael rooms.
And I got to see the School of Athens. Now, and this is what spawned this idea for the podcast. So in the School of Athens, for those of you... Which is the main thing you can see on our website, right?
Which is the main thing you can see on the website, which is something you can Google right now if you're driving, you can imagine it. Okay. Or if you're driving a Tesla, you can Google it because your car's driving for you. Terrifying.
Yeah, it is terrifying. In it, so the School of Athens, that famous picture of Raphael in the Vatican of all of the famous sort of ancient pagan philosophers and mathematicians, like, doing their thing. You got one dude chilling on the steps. You've got math going on.
You've got... If you look at the far right corner, there's this dude looking at you, and that's Raphael. But right in the middle of it, you've got Plato and Aristotle. And Plato is the older guy on the left, and Aristotle is in his famous blue robe on the right.
And if you look at that, are you looking at it right now? And so if you pull it up, so they're both gesturing. And so, Magby, what is it? Can you describe the gestures?
Plato points up and Aristotle points down. Plato is pointing up to the sky, and Aristotle is almost, like, pointing down, but it's almost like Aristotle is giving a, like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, buddy. He's, like, kind of, like... Looks like he's dribbling a basketball.
Exactly. Looks like he's dribbling a basketball. And this is sort of visually symbolic of their methodology. And we're going to talk today about sort of the Platonic idea of how you understand something and why Plato was pointing up, and the Aristotelian idea of how you know something and why Aristotle was pointing down.
Now, they're not opposites, nor are they in conflict. And in a weird way, like, often Plato and Aristotle come to the same conclusions about topics, but they're using very different methodology. And I kind of want to... Like me and you.
Like me and you. I'm right, and you have to be convinced. And I want to talk about that methodology and, like, maybe some of the ways that if you just use one or over the other, how it can go wrong. And just sort of, like, how you think about these two different ways of knowing something.
So, let's talk a little bit about Plato. So, if I was going to give, like, a little summary statement of the Platonic view and the Aristotelian view. Plato is somebody who is all about, like, the theoretical ideas, the world of ideas, up in the sky, he's pointing upwards. He wants to know the essence of things.
He wants to know the essence of things. If you've listened to our episodes that we've ever done on Plato, A.J. is going to do another one after this. It is done in dialogues, these Socratic dialogues where Socrates is asking, basically, strip away questions.
He's asking questions to try to get to the essence of something. And we're going to look at the Plato analogy of Plato's, the allegory of Plato's cave today to sort of give the example of, like, this is what the philosopher man should do. So, Aristotle's, sorry, Plato's all about the world of the ideas up in the heavens. He's pointing up.
Aristotle is all about, his methodology is more about coming to conclusions based on the world of observable experience. So, he is from the, he's pointing down and he's talking about experience, and he's talking about that which can be observed. So, it's like inductive reasoning versus deductive reasoning. It's, it's theory versus experience.
And so, these are the two sort of methodologies. And, anyway, so let's look at Plato first. So, I'm going to read a little bit of Plato's cave. And you'll get a sort of sense as to what Plato thinks, how we sort of, like, how we understand something.
So, for you keeping score at home, we're reading a little bit of Plato's, Allegory of Plato's cave, which is found in Republic Book 7. And we're also going to be looking at the first chapter of Aristotle's metaphysics. And the reason why we're sort of reading this is I kind of want to show the, less the conclusions and more the method. Because the method is interesting.
And, and, yeah, so let's look at it. All right, so let me read some Republic Book 7. So, the Republic is a dialogue between Socrates and a bunch of people, and they're trying to understand what justice is. And the way to understand justice is they build a theoretical city.
They don't, they just sort of, like, build it already. There's that idea that they are, oh, to understand the nature of something, let's imagine an ideal. They're literally just sitting around in the living room using their imagination to come Come then, share with me this thought also. It isn't surprising that the ones who get to this point are unwilling to occupy themselves with human affairs and that their souls are always pressing upwards, eager to spend their time above, for, after all, this is surely what we'd expect, if indeed things fit the image I described before.
So Plato gives a sort of idea that the world that we live in is the shadow world and that there are people who are pressing upwards into the study of like the divine things or the realm of ideas. And this is why Plato is pointing up, because he says it's kind of obvious that for him that he lionizes this idea. This is the goal of the good enlightened man is to try to like almost disembody, well, if you sort of take it at his word, almost disembody himself from the shadow world and try to dwell in the real world or the world of the good, the world of the beautiful. It's all, I mean, there's no, there's a reason why Platonism as it went on almost took on like a quasi-mystical religious enlightenment bent that like, have we ever talked about Gnostics in the podcast?
How would you like to describe Gnosticism? It's like this belief that there's like secret knowledge that certain people get access to and that whatever group is offering it is like, they are the one source of truth, right? So that's kind of like more broad. And typically body evil, spirit good.
Yes, body, yeah. So that secret knowledge was usually that. Was usually that, that like there's like a realm above and beyond the physical realm that is good and the body is bad. And so we see this even play out today with any kind of like sort of new agey stuff or even like startup bros that are taking mushrooms in the Amazon to try to, what's that like famous drug that people are taking?
Ayahuasca. Yeah, because there's that idea that like, oh, if we can sort of ascend to some sort of higher plane. We'll please our investors. Yes, the investing gods will be pleased.
And we will sort of attribute some sort of secret knowledge and then we can like, I don't know, like crush our KPIs or something. It sounds like a religion, though, Platonism stuff you're talking about. Yeah. And what's a KPI?
I already know, obviously. Key Performance Indicator. It's like business speak. Yeah, business speak.
I mean, I knew. I just wanted to make sure that you told the audience. That's very comical. Sorry.
OK. So Plato's got this idea that like human life and philosophical inquiry is to be done in the realm of the idea. It is to be sort of done above the common bound. And yeah, it almost takes on this quasi sort of like enlightenment spiritual aspect to it, that the physical world.
He doesn't go so far as to say that the physical world is evil. But even in the analogy, there's sort of disdain for the people, almost mockery for the people who are staying in the cave. And like the real ones are the ones that can kind of escape it. Now, this is the passage that launched a thousand insufferable like philosophy undergrads.
That's what I'm saying. Don't you hate this person? Like as it's like, no, I mean, Nietzsche smacked me. The funny thing is how much this is playing in my next episode.
Oh, so much. Yeah. So, yes. So, I mean, yeah, it is kind of this insufferable thing because you have lots of people that are like, I've reached, you know, I live in the world of ideas.
I don't live in the common realm. I knew a philosophy major like that in college. Oh, for sure. They're all like that.
Nietzsche stuff. I could have thought of all that. But you didn't. That's right.
But so there there I think it's right to say that there is a certain kind of arrogance with this. And but this is the realm of this sort of. Like I tell you it's deserved. Like, no, no.
But I think there's where I'm going with this podcast. We'll look at metaphysics in a second is I'm trying to figure out, like, when is that kind of mode of thinking necessary in human affairs, having a philosophy about something, having an idea about saying there's trying to find the ideal of something versus its opposite, which is going to be what Aristotle talks about, which is coming to conclusions based on experience. And so this looks like metaphysics. So we've kind of covered Plato.
Plato is the things that you can experience in this life are derivative, derivative at best, you know, maybe even manipulative at worst, that by looking at them, you're not getting the real thing. And if you turn into somebody that really pats yourself on the back for like categorizing the shadows, that's almost a laughable thing. That passage where he says, and if there had been any honors, praises or prizes among them for the ones who was the sharpest at identifying the shadows as they pass by and who best remembered what usually came earlier, which later and which simultaneously. So it's like, oh, this person predicted that the dog shadow preceded the cat shadow on the little like carousel of whatever.
And Plato is sort of making fun of him. Okay, so keep that sort of I'm also not doing a good enough job being neutral. Like I'm sort of making fun of it a little bit. I do think being a first principles kind of person is important.
Like not having to experience something, but thinking through it. Anyway, I'm putting the cart before the horse. I'm probably thinking like break out of like, there's a way things are in your current city, whatever, and like trying to find true things beyond that. That's right.
So you don't need to be completely relied on just your own personal experience that you can sit in a room and build a city in your mind and come to real conclusions about the world and learn things. You can. And that's a really important thing. Okay, so that's why Plato is pointing up.
Here's why Aristotle is pointing down. So we're looking at the metaphysics. Now, if you I have this complete, this is this giant book I'm holding is the basic works of Aristotle. Just the basic works.
Just the basic works. What Aristotle tries to do. You know what? I want a bust of Aristotle.
I've decided that this is probably not a surprise, but I'm a huge Aristotle fanboy that if you just look at the are you looking up how much it costs? You just find your Christmas gift, obviously. If you kind of look at the books that Aristotle writes, Aristotle is trying to create the basically the category of everything that can be known and observed. So Aristotle comes up with conclusions about the universe through observing the particular and coming to the generalization.
Whereas Plato kind of wants to leapfrog the particular and just go to the generalization in his mind. If you just, yeah, anyway. Yeah. Let me just read.
I was thinking of maybe reading the entire table of contents. Just you can get a sense of what Aristotle's books are. It's well, here we go. So he talks about like what actually is a category.
How can you interpret something? The prior analytics, the posterior analytics. What are the topics? What are how do you refute?
Then he has a book on physics, a book on the heavens, a book on generation and corruption, a book on the soul, a book on memory, a book on dreams, a book on prophesying, which is interesting. A book on animals, on parts of animals, the generation of animals, the metaphysics, the ethics, the politics, the rhetoric, the poetics. So Aristotle is trying to, he's writing basically notes on everything that you can observe in the world. And this is why Aristotle is somebody who is depicted pointing down.
He is, Plato can be perfectly happy sitting alone in a room thinking about things, whereas Aristotle is the one that like wants to explore the entirety of the world. So let me just read to you a little bit of chapter one of the metaphysics. You can get a sense of his methodology. All men by nature desire to know.
Great first sentence. And, you know, how would Aristotle have come to this conclusion? He's a man. He's a man's man.
He sees it. An indication of this is the delight we take in our senses, for even apart from their usefulness, they are loved for themselves. And above all others, the sense of sight. For not only with a view to action, but even when we are not going to do anything, we prefer seeing, one might say, to everything else.
The reason is that this, most of all the senses, makes us know and brings to light many differences between things. So already at the beginning of Aristotle's book about knowing, he praises eyes. Like our eye. He's like, isn't it a great thing to be able to see?
So Aristotle, the observer. I'm not saying that Plato could be blind, but Plato does, when Plato writes about how we come to know, he starts off by having men in a dark cave not seeing properly. And Aristotle talks about how we innately love our eyes, and we almost see viewing as a good in and of itself, even though it is in the service of a greater good, which is knowing. So I'm not trying to spoil next week's episode, but that is literally the opposite of what Plato says.
He has Socrates saying he is desirous of death, and one of the things he says is, like, our senses lead us astray. We are never seeing what's actually real, and so trying to get away from our senses into the essence of things and not trust the silly things our senses are telling us, that's the real way towards wisdom, which is literally the opposite of like... So Aristotle is saying our Now, okay, but he's going to come down a little bit on the pure theoretical person. And the theoretical person is like the Plato person.
With a view to action, experience seems in no respect inferior to art, and men of experience succeed even better than those who have theory without experience. The reason is that experience is knowledge of individuals, art of universals, and actions and productions are all connected with the individual. Four, the physician does not cure man except in an incidental way, but Callius, or Socrates, or some other called by some such individual name who happens to be a man. If, then, a man has the theory without the experience and recognizes the universal, but does not know the individual included in this, he will often fail to cure, for it is the individual that has to be cured.
So Aristotle seems to be saying, if you could jump to the holy realm, the spiritual realm and get out of the cave and learn medicine, you could have the form of medicine and you came back, you probably wouldn't be all that good at curing men because you would have lacked the experience and you wouldn't have sort of the art that presumably gets built up over time. Does that make sense? Am I reading that right? I'm not sure I agree with it because I'm trying to think of like, who do I want to be my doctor?
Like, do I want Plato or Aristotle? And I think I want Plato, right? If you get to the theoretical realm and you find the cure to whatever disease I have, I'd rather that than like Aristotle goes, your example of the dirt, I think, is like spot on, right? Like he knows a guy who got cured by dirt, so he's going to like try and apply that again.
But would you want the surgeon that right before you're going under says, I've never done this before, but I've read a lot of books. I think I do, the one who's read books instead of like, I don't know, man. Because even Aristotle hasn't probably gone to school. I don't know.
Like there's going to be a problem after we get to extremes on either one of them. But the person who has studied this and knows, like, this is in general where, like how this works, as opposed to I did this a couple of times and now I hope you're similar to the people I've known. I think we're underselling what art is like a guy who's done it a couple of times. Like, for example, if I'm going to send my kid into a classroom and there's two different teachers and one has just come out of college, they've just did extensive studying.
They have a PhD in like teaching sciences. They know all of the theory. And then there's a guy who's been teaching for 20 years. I'm going to send my kid to the one who's been teaching for 20 years because he actually knows how to control a classroom because all of the theory, like I can read a whole bunch of theory about how to control a classroom, but I know, like, personally, like when I, like my, my experience in controlling kids and developing relationships with them is invaluable.
Like over the 15 years, I figured out how to do that right. But walking in, even if I had like studied it, I wouldn't know what I was doing. And so maybe we're talking about your example, though, is taking like one is much less, um, has spent much less time on it than the other, right? One has spent a couple of years learning and the other has spent 20 years in experience.
So like you need a more comparable comparison between those two of one who has thought about and gotten to, you know, the person who is well-read in the classical works that they are teaching as opposed to the one who has taught a few classes like that. We need to get more on more similar comparisons between the two. I hear you. I think what Aristotle is saying about the art is that you have to have a massive breadth of experience to develop the art.
And so it wouldn't be just like a doctor who's done it a couple of times. It's a guy who's been in the field for 20 years and has seen the dirt applied a thousand times and some other guy's like, ah, that's not the essence of tea. He goes like, yes, but this is the thing that works. He does say in later, Aristotle says that men of experience can't teach.
He says only the artist can teach. So I think Plato, when he describes the person who's broken into the realm of ideas and Aristotle, when he describes the artist, I think they're talking about the same thing. That the artist is the person that knows the idea of the essence of something. And Plato was talking about the person who knows the essence of something.
But Plato seems to denigrate the experience and Aristotle seems to say that the experience is the necessary function that you need to do in order to get to become the artist. I don't think you become an artist. I think Aristotle said, I don't think you become an artist any other way. You can't just leap to the essence like Plato wants you to.
Aristotle says you have to get there through experience. And yes, now, the thing is, I think Plato does believe that you can leap and get to the essence. And that's what he's and that's what Socrates, that's what he has Socrates doing. The dialectic, the asking of questions.
And we've had this debate on the podcast before of can you come to anything true by talking about what everything isn't? If you can strip away what something isn't, can you get to what is? Aristotle, my understanding of Aristotle is that Aristotle says, no, you can't. You actually have to go and do a bunch of experience and then come up with those general categories and become the artist.
So I want to see if there's anything else I wanted to read here. But yet we think that knowledge and understanding belong to art rather than to experience. And we suppose artists to be wiser than men of experience. It is a sign of the man who knows and of the man who does not know that the former can teach and therefore we think art more truly knowledge and experiences for the artist can teach and men of mere experience cannot.
They can know that fire is hot, but not why fire is hot. So the way I think about it is that I'm trying to think of like maybe examples that drive this home. And if this is too repetitive for people who've listened to this podcast for a long time, I apologize. There's a scene in Romeo and Juliet where Friar Lawrence and Romeo are arguing and Romeo is lamenting his the fact that he's been banished from Verona and he's going to leave because he's killed Tybalt and he's been banished and he's not going to see Juliet anymore.
And Friar Lawrence is trying to reason with him. And Friar Lawrence is clearly correct in reasoning with him. They're like, dude, it's OK. Go to Mantua.
Hang out there for a little bit. And Romeo says to Friar Lawrence, you basically says you can't you can't speak about what you've never felt. He says, if you were like me, an hour but married, Tybalt murdered, you yourself being banished, then you can give me advice. Then you could tell me about this.
But because you've never done any of these things, you don't know what it's like, Friar Lawrence. And Friar Lawrence is like, I do know what it's like. You know, Friar Lawrence can be like, I may not have experienced this, but I like I'm a man. I'm a human being.
We, you know, I also have emotions and I can tell you that you're being an idiot. And Romeo says, but you haven't experienced this so precisely and acutely that you actually don't know what it's like to have this, the feelings that I have, which is a very like 19 year old person person thing to say. I feel it stronger than you ever have. But the thing is, OK, maybe that's a comical.
And in that sense, like Friar Lawrence is clearly in the right on this. But that is kind of illustrating a little bit of this problem, which is there are benefits and limitations from being purely a first principles thinker. Friar Lawrence, who lives alone in a cell, but has a lot of knowledge about things. And there are benefits and limitations of being somebody who experiences a lot and sort of goes off into the world.
And my question is, like, how can I phrase this? Some there are times when you need to be one and there's times when you need to be the other. And it's hard to know when those times are. So without driving too much of a wedge between Plato and Aristotle, one way you can think of Aristotle is that Aristotle is the kind of thinking that would put a lot of sort of weight behind statistics, a bell curve, because that is the bell curve is like the experience of the world.
So here are all here's all of these scenarios that play out and here's the distribution of the outcomes. And because the distribution of the outcomes, we can look at the fat middle of that bell curve and we can make sort of predictive results about the world. That is the Aristotelian kind of ethos. That is the hand pointing down.
And there's a lot of times when that is really, really, really helpful. And that kind of thinking is great and carries a lot of water. You can be very successful in the world doing that. But then there are other times where you need to sort of like have an idea and try to have like and then work to have, you know, the context conform to that idea.
All right, there's a big football game today. UT is playing Georgia, right? Let's use the sports analogy. There's two ways to build a team to succeed in a game, right?
One is you're like Plato and you have a philosophy, an idea about how the way the game is to be played when everybody else is playing bell curves and you swing more to be bell curves when everybody else is being an idealist. Like someone comes in with this new way of playing the game that is based on a philosophy that he's concocted in his mind, and then he tries to conform reality to his idea, and he's successful. But then when everybody starts doing that, everybody sort of has analytics teams that are putting together to try to play the game in a different way. You're gonna have somebody that's gonna have to innovate.
And does it swing over to the other side? Do you innovate back to, you know, going back to basics or going back to pragmatism or are you sort of swing back to this more aristotelian way of thinking about solutions? I think maybe we are underselling what Aristotle is actually trying to do. I think we're trying to say like, he's like, just be practical, figure out the knowledge that way.
But I think what Aristotle is saying is the opposite of what Plato said. Plato said, can't trust your eyeballs, right? They're never gonna tell you the truth. You have to do it just with pure mind.
And what Aristotle is saying is like, no, your eyeballs are telling you real information. And the way you get to the essence is by bringing together a whole bunch of memories and a whole lot of experience and then putting an idea together. And so going back to the moneyball analogy, the guy who concocted this plan, ran across a statistician and said, like, I like what you were saying in there. And from experience, he recognized, now this is a guy that knows what he's talking about.
Teams when they get on base. And he knew that because of years and years and years of experience and an aggregate of memories that he had had with different baseball teams. And so I think it's unfair to say it's just lock in, do the bell curve. That guy knew the essence.
He did, right? Plato knows the essence because he wants to skip the eyeball part. Aristotle says, no, you still need to know the essence. That is the art.
You both get to the same principle, but you're only gonna do it by trusting your eyeballs. I think it's more an epistemological position. Like this is how we earn knowledge than a statement about pragmatism versus theory. Aristotle, I think when he gives that analogy about doctors have to cure individual men, they don't cure man, really gets to it.
Because when you come to the reality, when you come to being an artist, when you get to the actual, when you get to the idea of something through experience, there's all these other factors at play, like muscle memory, the fact that you are, you even, if you do something with experience, you also develop an intuition for something that you sometimes can't quite put your fingers on. And you kind of have that like embodied experience that comes to a knowledge. And then when you have theoretical knowledge mixed with embodied experience, you're probably better than just the theoretical knowledge, pardon me, than just the theoretical knowledge, which is what he got at. One of my favorite like teacher theoretical like experience things that I've put into place is you need your kids to believe that you've got eyes in the back of your head.
So the way that I do this is I have a rule for no gum in my classroom. So if I see a kid is chewing gum, I don't call them out yet. I wait, wait for a few minutes. And when I'm turned around, writing notes on the board and I'm like two sentences in and I haven't looked at them in 20 minutes, I say, Jeff, go spit out your gum.
And they're like, how do you even see me? And so then they believe that I see all. It's a noble lie. Yeah, exactly.
So that's that's like one of those things that they don't really teach you in the theory. But so another way that we can sort of think about this, and this is going to continue on with the sports analogy, is there is a ethos of playing soccer in South America that is different than how you play it in Europe. In Europe, they are much more, they have this idea of a philosophy. You have the manager and the manager has an idea of how the game is going to be played and he is going to conform his team into playing according to his ideals.
That's a very European way of doing it. The best coach in the world, Pep Guardiola, like has an idea of how the game is played in his mind and he has his players conform to that idea. Players and coaches in South America, one of the most, sort of a very influential coach in South America, he was a coach of the Brazilian national team for a while and he coaches a team named Fluminense in Brazil, Fernando Diniz. He's got this way of coaching where it's like, I don't tell the players how to play.
I have the players sort of figure out, they need to be in a relationship with each other as players and solve the problems of the game through their sort of intuition of where each other are on the pitch. The European model is, maybe I'm going to tell you that if AJ does this with the ball, you're going to do this and you memorize that. And every time he does that, we're going to drill it. You're going to move here when AJ does this.
And when the game, when it happens, we're a machine. Whereas in the South American version, it's like, I need you and AJ to become buddies, have some beers together, get each other's sort of vibes and kind of know each other so that when you're on the field, you kind of like intuit what's going to happen and you play it in this relational way as opposed into this prescribed way. I think Aristotle is more, lends itself to that second way, which is through lots and lots of repetitive experience of the world. You not only get an intellectual theory of how things work, but you also get a like, I don't want to say vibe, but I'm going to, you get like sort of a vibe of how nature works, about how things work.
Like you can get a feel that when this person is sick in this way, like maybe my theory isn't going to be perfect because there's all these other variables that I've experienced before. And I know that, well, in this case, actually, I think my, my rubbing the dirt technique isn't going to be as effective because of all, because of all these other variables that aren't necessarily part of the theory, but they are part of the experience. And so you, you can sort of then like come to the solution. You can be successful in whatever realm you're doing because you've sort of built up that, that experience of doing something.
Yeah. You know that rubbing the dirt might not fix his runny nose, but it sure will make it beautiful. Yes. I mean, his skin is going to be exfoliated.
Yeah. So, I mean, there's, there's no lie. I am much more of a fan of Aristotle than I am of Plato. I think Plato is a little naive in saying the world is a lie and you have to jump over it to get to truth.
And I think Aristotle is much more correct when he says he's much more forgiving where he's like, we can come to statements about what is, but he's also says, we're gonna leave room for mistakes. Like you need to cure Calias. You need to cure Socrates. You can't cure mankind.
There's always going to be all of you. We can't control all of the variables. Plato wants to know the form and control. Aristotle gives room for, you know, not pure pragmatism, but he gives more room for like, he sort of gives intellectual wiggle room.
So for example, Plato, when in his Republic gives the form of the perfect city. And so Aristotle would go in and say, well, sure, that's all great in theory, but what if these people are like a seafaring people and they live on the seashore? That's gonna be a little bit different. What if their warfare isn't necessarily on the ground, but really all about sailing?
That's gonna look different. And what if there are people of letters or people of philosophy versus mostly a farming people? Right. What, like different kinds of nations do different kinds of things.
A mountain people's gonna look different, right? So maybe just, but if you have experience of all those, if you know what a seafaring people looks like in a mountain people and you've lived in all these places and then you have to go start a city in the desert. Well, you've got the art. You know how to deal with different kinds of people.
You still know the principle. What a perfect place is supposed to look like, but really you're concerned with this individual city. The one built near a desert oasis and you're not gonna be sailing. It'd be more like a mountain, more like a plains type of people.
And so you have all that art. You still know the principle, but you don't just try to skip the experience, which is governing in all of those different places. In his politics, Aristotle says, here's how monarchy works. Here's how monarchy falls apart.
Here's how Republic works. Here's how the Republic falls apart. Whereas Plato in his version of the politics, which is Republic says, here's how a city, the best city should function. And we're all gonna be married.
And we've done a whole episode, 10 episodes on it. It was like we're gonna marry each other and like we're in a lot of the other people. So they have no kids and we have a weird sex lottery and tell the army that they have golden blood. And I think Aristotle is like, you know none of this works, right?
Yeah, but that's sort of indicative of the problem is that like the, the, the more Platonist thinker can get so married to the theory that We got a whole bunch of other extra words that didn't necessarily make it onto the main episode. So if you're looking for the side stuff, you can go support us on Patreon, which is patreon.com/classicalstuff. Is that right? Yep.
So you find us there, and here are in-between banter where we talk between the episodes. You can also hear our monthly AMAs. You can also find us online at classicalstuff.net. That's our website.
And you can email us at [email protected]. And we're also on Twitter with CLSSCalStuff. And I think that's it. We're not on anything else.
Not on like Blue Sky or... Mastodon, is that still a thing? Or like TikTok. Yep.
Mastodon? What's Mastodon? Another Twitter clone, right? I'm on TikTok.
I do a lot of dancing. You TikTok it? Search for a Grammarly investor on that TikTok. Thanks.
Anyway, we, you know, we're doing stuff, so thanks for listening. All right, ciao.