Skip to content
27. Looking for America episode artwork

Jun 20, 2018 39 min

27. Looking for America

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky dive into the issue on everyone's minds: the OU honoring Jeff Sessions at their annual policy conference, after the emergence of reports of children being forcibly separated from their parents by immigration authorities. They ask, what is really going on? What are these policies, really? How are the policies under Trump different than Obama, or Bush-era policies? And what about the OU - did the OU make a mistake? What should they have done? Is the anger against the OU deserved? Catch up on everything below: The Trump policy: https://www.vox.com/2018/6/11/17443198/children-immigrant-families-separated-parents https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/16/opinion/sunday/family-separation-immigration-trump.html Jewish groups letter: https://www.ou.org/community/notices/jewish-communal-letter-condemning-family-separation-policy/ Orthodox Union Event: https://www.c-span.org/video/?446982-1/attorney-general-sessions-backs-supreme-court-decision-colorado-baker-case Orthodox Union Letter: https://www.ou.org/blog/news/update-ou-takes-a-stand-on-zero-tolerance-immigration-policy/ OU's decision: http://jewishweek.timesofisrael.com/justice-justice-you-shall-pursue-on-the-ou-honoring-jeff-sessions/ Related podcasts: NY Times, The Daily, "How Separating Migrant Families Became U.S. Policy": https://www.nytimes.com/podcasts/the-daily NPR, Up First: https://www.npr.org/2018/06/19/621277687/tuesday-june-19th-2018 Vox, Today Explained, "2,000": https://www.vox.com/pages/podcasts Where are the kids being held: https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/inside-casa-padre-the-converted-walmart-where-the-us-is-holding-nearly-1500-immigrant-children/2018/06/14/0cd65ce4-6eba-11e8-bd50-b80389a4e569_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.8022bed9754f Conservative perspective: https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/05/illegal-immigration-enforcement-separating-kids-at-border/ https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/06/ice-loses-1500-children-myth-shows-media-bias/ Music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eo2ZsAOlvEM

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky dive into the issue on everyone's minds: the OU honoring Jeff Sessions at their annual policy conference, after the emergence of reports of children being forcibly separated from their parents by immigration authorities. They ask, what is really going on? What are these policies, really? How are the policies under Trump different than Obama, or Bush-era policies? And what about the OU - did the OU make a mistake? What should they have done? Is the anger against the OU...

Ready to play

27. Looking for America

0:00 39:17
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rizki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Uri, are you watching the World Cup? I am. Yesterday, I watched the Mexico-Germany game, which ended up being a big upset. That's the game to watch. You got lucky. I actually heard that in Mexico City, the uproar and the excitement was so strong that it actually measured as a tiny earthquake. Isn't that amazing? Yeah, that's pretty crazy. It was also funny because, I mean, this is going to get into the topic we're going to talk about later. As an American, since America's not in the World Cup, who should Americans root for? And so there is an argument made. And one of the commentators was even talking about, like, maybe it should be Mexico. Because, like, first of all, they're our neighbors.

Second of all, maybe because Trump is giving Mexico such a hard time, we have to show solidarity with them and we should stick up for them. Yeah, I mean, I guess I was happy for them also because they're the underdog in that game. So it was cool that also Germany, obviously, you know, there's always something weird about Germany. So right. So Germany won last. We didn't actually say Mexico won one nothing. Right. Germany won nothing, which was a huge, huge upset.

So Germany won this. Yes, right. So they're the reigning champions. Good job, Mexico. Yeah, good for them. Also going on right now, the Maharat graduation is actually tonight. We're recording this right now, Monday, 645. And the Maharat graduation actually just started. Oh, well, do you want to tell our listeners what Maharat is? Yes. Maharat is the first female Orthodox ordination program in the country. It only started a few years ago. I think they probably at this point have five years of graduates, which is pretty small. Let's say on average they graduate three to four students, something like that. I actually have a few friends. I think you do also already who are graduates of the program. Acquaintances, yeah, friends.

I hope no listeners. And I've gone to graduation before and I found it to be a really, really incredible experience because you're not just celebrating the women who are up there receiving their smithel, even though, of course, that's part of it as well. But you're also you're celebrating how far we've come. You look around the audience and there are female scholars and male scholars who really hadn't seen this in their lifetime and now seeing sort of the young future leadership of the Orthodox people. The future is female, as they say. And it's a really inspiring thing for many people. A lot of people bring their kids, their grandkids. Right. I guess we have come far whether people agree with it or not. I don't mean to be like, you know, diminishing or like off color about it, but they're.

One sign of how far we have come is that there's like a famous joke that no longer works. The punchline doesn't work anymore. This is a friend of mine points this out. But basically, there used to be a joke. What's the difference between reform, conservative and orthodox? At the orthodox wedding, the bride's mother is pregnant. At the conservative wedding, the bride is pregnant. And at the reform wedding, the rabbi is pregnant. But now the rabbi could be pregnant at an orthodox wedding. So the joke is out the window. You know what? I think we take progress over a joke, especially not my kind of joke in the first place. But yeah, I don't know. I think it's pretty exciting. It's weird to not be there. So I just want to give a shout out and congratulations to the graduates who are becoming rabbis, rabbis, maharats, whatever they choose today. It's a really big opportunity.

honor for all of us to have you as our leaders of the Jewish people. Yeah, Rifki, thanks for that. Mazel tov to all the graduates. And moving on to the main topic we want to talk about today, getting back to Mexico in the World Cup, is the topic of immigration. Specifically, the issue that seems to be everywhere now. Everywhere you look, people are talking about this policy of separating children from their parents. People who cross the border illegally are being separated from their parents. And I think anybody would say that that is not a good thing for children to be separated from their parents. I think that...

The specifics of it and the level of outrage varies. But even more specifically than that was an event that happened a few days ago where the Orthodox Union had a ceremony in Washington for its political advocacy wing. They had Jeff Sessions, the attorney general, speak at the event. And they gave him, it wasn't exactly an award, but basically a plaque that said, which is from the Torah. It's about pursuing justice. And I'm actually going to play a clip, the audio from the event. This is actually, Jeff Sessions spoke for about 20 minutes. It was long. And he spoke about religious liberty and freedom in America and the history of it and why it's so important.

he spoke, Sessions was presented with this plaque by the OU's public policy director. Thank you, Attorney General Sessions, for your important comments this afternoon. And thank you for your essential work at the Department of Justice that has ensured the security of our community and institutions, and for the work you and the Department of Justice have done, and now will expand to protect and advance religious liberty in the United States. As a token of our appreciation, I wish to present to you, on behalf of the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations, this artistic rendering of the biblical verse from Deuteronomy, Tzedek Tzedek Tirdof, which translates, Justice, Justice, You Shall Pursue. Over the centuries, rabbis and teachers have offered many commentaries on the verse. Why does it repeat justice twice? Rabbi Simcha Bunim of Piszczyska, who lived in the Poland in the 18th century, offered the following comment. The Bible repeats the word justice twice to teach us that, of course, we must pursue justice. But not only must we pursue justice to its end, we must pursue it through a just means. The means has to also be just. And therefore, thank you, Attorney General, and our prayer to you is that God will bless you and your colleagues at the department with the wisdom to serve America by the pursuit of justice and through the means of justice. Thank you, sir.

So almost immediately after this ceremony took place, there was a huge backlash, I guess mostly in the Orthodox community or people who are aware of the Orthodox Union. And they were very upset because Jeff Sessions is the attorney general of the United States. And he's basically the one in charge of this immigration policy and this new semi-new policy of separating kids from their parents. And so people were really, really upset that the OU invited him in the first place and had him speak and gave him this. People were calling it an award. It wasn't exactly an award, but gave him something and acknowledged him and didn't even mention the immigration stuff. So the OU the next day released the whole statement saying that they actually did talk to him about the policy and that they were against the policy, but they spoke to him in private about that.

But then, either the same day or the day after, the OU also signed on to a letter that was signed by many Jewish organizations speaking out against this policy in pretty strong terms, that they don't agree with it, they think it's really wrong, it needs to be changed. But... People are still very upset. I think you were telling me before that there's now this weekly protest, Mincha Minyan, outside the OU. Yeah, there's something called Moral Mincha, which I think is going to be Monday at 6 or 6.15 in front of the OU. It's almost like a prayer protest. It's not a regular sort of rally. It's meant to show its religious underpinnings. In some ways, it feels like it's a bit of an empty gesture because it is after hours. The OU is basically going to be closed. It's also down on Wall Street, so it's basically going to be closed, but it's trying to make it accommodating. Only an empty gesture, but an ineffective gesture. Right.

So, I mean, I think the main question or questions that we want to discuss and talk about are, first of all, we have to talk about the policy itself a little bit and how we understand it and how it's being spoken about. But speaking about the OU in particular, did they do something wrong? And if so, what is wrong about what they did and how should that have been done differently? What do they need to do differently in the future, et cetera? So Rivki, what are your thoughts on this immigration policy?

All right, thank you for asking. I want to start off by just saying, you know, I'm not an immigration lawyer. I'm not an expert in either immigration law or law enforcement. These disclaimers are really coming in handy. It happens to me that my sister is an immigration lawyer and is not only intimately versed in this, but also really emotionally connected to this. And the truth is that I think a lot of us feel pretty emotionally connected to this in ways that, you know, we didn't think we would be. I do not have any children. I have nieces and nephews. And I remember reading about this and sort of imagining the scene of parents and children being separated at the border. And I started imagining my own nieces and nephews, if God forbid something would happen, and they were separated from their own parents and imagining their fear. And it's hard to have.

a conversation about it when those emotions, which are really real, sort of get in the way. But as much as possible, I think we do want to try to sort of understand the policy without getting too overwhelmed by emotions. But basically, immigration has been a problem for a very long time. I don't think anyone really has a solution. I don't think Democrats have a solution. Obama has notoriously been pretty difficult on migrants or illegal immigrants as well. This has been a problem. Obviously, Europe is trying to figure out what to do. America has been tough. And obviously, Trump is still dealing with the same difficulties. And they've all dealt with it sort of in different ways. But to overgeneralize and give a very broad understanding,

So separating parents and children is something that Bush and Obama's administrations both kind of considered. They both quickly sort of said to themselves, A, that's not who we want to be, and B, consider the optics. Even if we do think it might deter immigrants, the images of parents being taken away from their children is just not something that we can live with as an administration, as people who are trying to govern this country. So we can't actually do it. John Kelly, the chief of staff, he announced, I think it was maybe a year ago or something like that, that they were going to start separating parents and children.

Quickly, major backlash from both parties, from the Democrats and Republicans, and immediately sort of walked that back. About a month ago, after a steep incline in illegal border crossing, Trump ordered a new effort to start prosecuting anyone who crossed the border unlawfully. including tearing parents and children away from each other. They're calling it the zero tolerance policy. Yes, exactly. And this is something that, again, is not something that they invented out of thin air. This has been considered by past administrations, but it's the first group that is really going all in on it. Right. Well, just to clarify a little bit, it's not that the policy is to go find families that cross the border and make sure that the children get taken away from their parents. If someone is caught crossing the border illegally, they're brought before a judge, and if they plead guilty, they're almost always sentenced to time served and then sent back over to the other side of the border. So in those cases, if there is family separation, it isn't for more than a few days. However, if the parent wants to apply for asylum in the United States, the U.S. is required to let them stay in the country until their case is decided. So instead of letting them go free...

So all that isn't to say that it's fine what's happening, but I think it's important to have at least some idea of what's actually being done instead of just saying, oh, Trump just wants to separate all kids from their parents. So the difficult thing about this policy is that it's very difficult to have the conversation without talking about... the humanity of the entire thing, right? Like what even the leaders in the administration are saying is, look, this is incredibly painful and incredibly difficult, but we still have to do it. They are acknowledging how emotionally tearing this can be for these families and to see these pictures and what these children must be going through. But they're saying that ultimately it's the best choice for legal immigration for deterrence. But what the other side is saying is it doesn't work like that. At the end of the day, you have to make a choice about what your values are. And if you're valuing borders and if you're valuing...

what you deem an immigration threat more than you're valuing not traumatizing these children and these parents, of course, then you're making bad choices and your values are wrong. And I think, to me, it feels like a pretty simple calculus there. Right, okay, so here's my problem. My problem is with these mobs of virtue signalers online. Okay, virtue signaling, for those that aren't familiar with that term, I learned it recently. Virtue signaling is basically, when you make a statement, usually on social media, showing how good of a person you are by how outraged you are by this policy or that policy or this politician or that person, but you're not actually doing anything.

tangible for it. You're just trying to show, look, I'm a good person. I'm virtuous because I think this is horrible. And like, you know, a very, a tweet and a very concise, simple black and white statement. And then you move on with your day. It's very much trend related where it's like, oh, a lot of people are posting about Syria now. I need to talk about Syria or people aren't going to think I'm a good person. So the separating parents from the children, I think that's terrible. And I think any thoughtful, good person will say that is terrible. Even if they say it needs to happen, they're going to say it's terrible. Well, that's what Trump is saying. Trump is saying it's terrible, but it needs to happen. But I also think it's only one small, tiny part of the immigration question that is a much, much bigger question that most people,

don't want to be bothered with. That doesn't, because I don't see anybody saying anything else about that. Meaning like when I was doing research on this topic and I really just wanted to understand what is actually happening. What are the, what are the actual laws? How has, what's different now than two months ago or two years ago? It was really hard to find basic information and facts about this seemingly super important issue because that's not what people are talking about. They're talking about like the most superficial level thing. And yes, I agree. It's a horrible and very important thing to talk about that kids are being separated from their parents. But like, for example, okay, on average, how long are they being separated for? Are they keeping track of whose kids or whose parents? Like,

Is there a plan to reunite them? Where are these people coming from? Things must be really bad if these people are willing to risk their lives and risk their children's lives to bring them to America. So is anything being done about the situations in their home countries? Are people even talking about what's happening in the home countries and what can be done? All of these kinds of questions were very, very hard to get.

answers to. And I took that as a sign as really on both sides of the issue, but mostly on the people who are outraged by it. They're not really interested in those questions. And that to me shows an insincerity, whether they realize it or not, that if you really cared about this issue, you would be looking into those things instead of just demonizing Trump, demonizing Jeff Sessions. So that's like one thing that I want to say, which makes me a little bit cynical about the whole thing. I also just think that we talked about last week about the failures of journalism, that a lot of journalistic resources are missing context. It's so frustrating. Like the New York Times that I, the New York Times is so good in so many ways and reading about this.

felt like I was banging my head against the wall. And I'm like, give me more. Give me cross links. Give me context. Tell me more of the story. Literally, there's I just want to read from one line from this article, which was published two days ago about the family separation and obviously blaming Trump for it. Among those who have professed objections to the policy is the president himself, who, despite his tough rhetoric on immigration and his clear directive to show no mercy in enforcing the law, has searched publicly for someone else to blame for dividing families. He has falsely claimed that the Democrats are responsible for the practice. But the kind of picture is so feared by Mr. Trump's predecessors could end up defining a major domestic policy issue of his term.

That's it. That's the only thing. It says Trump claims this. It's not true. And then it just keeps going. And I'm like, there has to be more than that, right? If you do all the research, and I think people like my sister have done all the research and can tell you why he's claiming this, what flimsy excuse he's using for why he's claiming it and why it's not true. And I expect the New York Times to do that research and tell me. I'm sorry about that mini rant, but it's just so frustrating. Anyway, please continue. So basically the floor's consent decree, it says that the kids under 18 can't be detained for more than 20 days. So when Trump blames the Democrats, what he's trying to say is, listen, I don't want to separate families, but we have to detain the parents while we're deciding whether or not to grant them asylum. And we're not legally allowed to detain the children for more than 20 days.

Therefore, we have to separate them and take care of the children in a different way. So he's implying that if only the Democrats would agree to change the law and allow children to be detained for more than 20 days, then we could keep families together. but his hands aren't actually tied because he could also just decide to not enforce the law and just let people go instead of detaining anybody. We're going to include a bunch of links so you can read it for yourself. Suffice it to say that the issue is significantly more complicated than most people are making it out to be. I think that is what we can both agree on. I would agree with that. So I think one of my big questions is, and I see a lot of people asking this, you know, people are coming more from the conservative end are, okay, so what should we do? Should we just, if a person that's outraged by this policy is advocating for open borders, then while I might think that that's a little bit of an insane idea, at least that's consistent and they know what they're saying. If they say outright, I think border

are immoral and whoever wants to come in should be able to come in and we should take care of them and make them citizens and whatever like If that's what you're saying, then fine. But if that's not what you're saying, then maybe what you're saying is we should just be taking in a lot more immigrants. So 500,000, a million, whatever number you put it at, there's going to be more than that number who are trying to come in. And therefore, you're going to have to turn people away and you're going to have to have some policy of dealing with the people who are crossing illegally. So do you believe in open borders? Of course not. Why? Of course not. You're right. I shouldn't say of course not. I definitely have considered it. And there are definitely times where I kind of do consider it. But I don't want that to be the focus of our conversation because I think at this point we should transition a little bit to the OU conversation. I just wanted to put that out there. You're right. Neither of us are experts. The point I wanted to make was that things are more complicated and that what bothers me about the current conversation happening on

Facebook feed and on Twitter and whatever is that it's so superficial and it's so black and white in terms of the villains and the heroes. But you know, that's what happens when there are children involved, especially, right? When you have kids, when you have, what I think they're going to reverse this policy just because of the pressure. Absolutely. And so they reverse the policy and then, and then what? Then, then people are going to move on to the next topic and they're going to be outraged about something else and they're going to forget about immigration for a while and it'll probably come up at a later point or whatever. Like it just bothers me because I don't think that's how political action and advocacy should work. I agree with you that virtue signaling is a little bit empty and a little bit silly. But I also don't think that it's the biggest problem here. Like the biggest problem here is what is actually.

what is actually being experienced by these children and these parents. The biggest problem is not the religious thing. And I think an even bigger problem than that is just the immigration issue in general, which is a lot more difficult to address than just saying, we're not going to separate parents from children. Okay, great, what are you going to do? Sure. Fine, but let's get to the OU piece of it. I guess I'll start by saying that the whole thing is just, I mean, it's embarrassing in a bunch of ways, like as an Orthodox Jew, to see the OU so quickly caving to the pressure and signing this letter, criticizing Sessions, and...

criticizing the policy. Like, yeah, I mean, I think that is the right thing to do, to say that as a religious group, we believe in, you know, because they said something about, like, families. If they're always talking about the value of the family, then you should not want families to be separated if you're going to be consistent. Yes, I understand that. But just to see how, they didn't sign that letter when the letter was first put out. They only signed it after the pressure. Why do you think they didn't sign that letter in the first place?

It's a good question. It could be that they would have a few days later, regardless. Who knows? I would want to give them a better figure. Organizations have not been joining on. They released this letter with a bunch of organizations. Probably because they, if they didn't, it would probably, I'm assuming because they don't want to be associated with the other groups, the non-Orthodox, progressive groups on that letter. It is not an Orthodox letter. It is just from Jewish organizations and they didn't want to be associated with that. I think that's pretty disappointing. That's a separate discussion. I think that's actually a critical part of the conversation because it's about the OU making choices about their priorities. But we're assuming their intentions. We don't know. Okay, let's come up with some other theories. Well, let's talk about what actually happened. So I think there's a big distinction in what you were getting at before. Big distinction with the fact that

Jeff Sessions was invited to speak at this event months ago, okay? So in order to not have him there, they would have had to have disinvited him. And I think that would have been a huge slap in the face to the administration. And I think as a group representing a religious minority, I don't think they can afford to alienate the administration even if they disagree. And I think if you really want to give them the benefit of the doubt, when they gave him that award, that clip that we played before, I think they were very subtly, very subtly saying, we hope that you do the right thing. And obviously separating kids from parents is very obviously the wrong thing. And we hope that you can fix that. But they didn't want to publicly...

call him out on it, but to say, pursue justice, and not just justice, but the means in which you pursue justice has to be with justice. I don't think that you can say that was a bad thing to say to the Attorney General of the United States. So I think there actually is something to that, and I remember I was having this discussion with a few friends the day that the video came out, the day that he received this honor, and thinking maybe it is this sort of exhortation of, you know, you shall pursue, right? It's a commandment. It's not acknowledging his past justice. It's saying, pursue justice. You need to pursue justice. But when you watch the video or when you read the speech, how many times do they say thank you? They're smiling, they're shaking hands. They immediately tweeted out this picture, right? There's this really sort of like, what they're trying to create is this relationship in which it's like, okay, Jeff Sessions, like, we honored you, we showed you this covered. Now, when we want additional school security funding, you got our back also. I think that's like...

pretty clear. And you're right, it's a political calculus. It's not that they're saying we love Jeff Sessions and the policy that he's promoting of separating parents and children. We want to give him this award for that. That's not what it is. He's the Attorney General and we want to be in good relations with the people in power. Yeah, and they're making a choice about their priorities when they do that. See, but I think it's also unfair to say that if the OU's main advocacy in recent years has been education related, I mean, that's true. I mean, that's just the fact. Education related in terms of like making Jewish education more affordable or getting access to public funds whenever possible.

But I think being on good terms and having relationships with the people in power with the administration is not just about pushing that agenda. It's also about pushing future agendas that will arise in circumstances that we can't predict and that we don't know what they are going to be. But we want to be on good terms for that eventuality. God forbid if something bad happens or something arises, they don't want to alienate themselves because they can't afford to do that. All of that is true. All of that is true. The OU has goals. The OU has objectives that they're trying to accomplish. Would they meet with...

David Duke to accomplish that agenda? No, of course they would not. David Duke is not the attorney general. Agreed. If David Duke were the attorney general, would they meet with him? Yes. I mean, I don't know. Whatever. No. Okay. I'm going to say they probably wouldn't. Okay. You know what? Let's make it ridiculously extreme. Okay. Obviously, I'm setting up a Stroman. Don't get upset. If Adolf Hitler were the attorney general, would they meet with him? Of course not. Why not? Because there are limits. You don't just meet with anyone because you're like, look, we're trying to accomplish. We're trying to get more funding for buses. So we got to meet with Hitler. What are you going to do? Of course, they wouldn't meet with Hitler. Right? I think you're actually getting directly at the point that is bothering me, which is that for so many people in this country, Donald Trump is Adolf Hitler. Oh my gosh. You don't agree with that?

Do you disagree with that? Is he a cartoon villain? Sure. But I don't think that's why people are upset with the OU meeting with Jeff Sessions. Have you seen SNL? The Jeff Sessions portrayal on SNL? I saw that clip where he was in the sewer. It's a recurring character. If anything, he's even worse than Trump in the minds of that. He's a cartoon villain. I think that it's a very scary thing about our current culture that the socially acceptable way of disagreeing with our democratically elected officials is by caricaturing them as heartless, horrible, evil, barely human beings. Instead of at least acknowledging where they're coming from, what their arguments are based on, and then disagreeing in our

arguing on those points. Because if you just paint the picture as good versus evil, then you don't have to talk about the points because you've oversimplified it to the extent where there's nothing even left to say. Therefore, we should not acknowledge him. We should not have anything acknowledging his position. And I don't think that's what people are saying either. There are limits to who you sit down with in the attempt to create your goals because at a certain point you lose sight of the bigger picture. I'm not saying they should boycott the Attorney General. I think there are a couple things that they could have done differently. They had already invited him. That's true. Which maybe I don't think they should invite him in the first place, but okay, fine. They're saying he's the Attorney General. We're inviting all the leaders in the Republican Party.

in the Democratic Party, but I think they need to be much, first of all, much less fawning, right? You saw this video, right? You heard this speech. Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you. Here's a black thank you, thank you, thank you. And when the OU and other organizations treated Obama with the same type of thank you, thank you fawning, so many people in the Orthodox community were extremely upset in the same kind of way that the progressives are now upset. Yeah, that's definitely true. The OU is very often not reflexively on either side and gets beat down a lot. But they did it in both cases. Whoever's in power, they're going to do what they need to do to keep good relations with them. What people are arguing is that Jeff Sessions is not a normal politician that people disagree with. Separating parents and children, which unfortunately for the OU happened the exact same week as he was, this Bruhobz.

coming out the exact same week that he was speaking. It's bad for the OU. It sucks for them. But also, one of the big things, and this is, I think, a bigger picture. Hold on a second. I think it's a bigger picture problem. One of the things the OU is trying to do, the OU as an organization also represents a lot of very good things that are much more explicitly and intimately involved in promoting Torah and mitzvot. The OU runs NCSY, it's a Kira program. The OU runs JLIC, which sends Torah educators to different college campuses. The OU is involved in Yachat, right, which is an incredible organization doing amazing chesed. That work becomes much more...

problematic or muddled when people have an association between that and diving into politics with Jeff Sessions. And when you're intimately connected with Jeff Sessions, which a lot of people are very upset about, that's going to hurt the other Torah work that you're doing. I don't think they were diving into politics with Jeff Sessions. They had an event. Sessions agreed to speak at the event. He spoke about religious liberty and freedom, and they gave him a thing telling him to pursue justice. He speaks about religious liberty and freedom, and the next day he says the reason you shouldn't be upset with the law is because of the Bible. You can say he's a terrible person, but I don't think it's at the level where you need to shun him and shut down your

entire agenda when it comes to lobbying Washington because the current administration, especially, it's not just him, it's the whole administration that a lot of people would say is beyond the pale and should not be engaged with on any level. And I actually, and I don't think as representing a minority religious community, I don't think they can afford to alienate themselves from this entire administration. I think you're right. And I think the whole reason that the OU is making this calculus is because they think we need the United States government to make our day schools affordable. And that's why we have to do things. That's not the only thing they're doing. The guy actually right before sessions at that event, I watched the video of the guy right before him, it was a congressman, Chris Smith, who pushed a bill that was...

pushed, helped with by the OU or whatever, where basically the policy had been. that when it comes to natural disasters, FEMA, which is the government organization that helps after natural disasters, would not give assistance to religious institutions, which included schools and houses of worship. And there had been incidents, I think the first one was in Seattle in 2000. There was a Jewish school that was flooded in some storm and they weren't given help by FEMA. And George Bush changed the law that religious schools were given help. But it still applied that houses of worship were not given help. And now with the help of this guy, Chris Smith, they got a bill through with bipartisan support through Senate and Congress. Obviously, my first instinct is why should schools be helped if there's a strong separation of church and state, but okay. Because they help everybody, whatever. But the point is that this bill wasn't just for...

synagogues it was for all houses of worship it was for churches mosques whatever and so this thing that the OU pushed for and it is now you know giving acknowledgement to the congress people that helped with that initiative is something that helped all religious communities and now in a natural disaster houses of worship are given assistance by FEMA and that's just like an example just from that same ceremony where it's not just about Jewish schools getting as much money as they can for their kids and their students agreed I'm not saying it is and to a certain I think what the OU does for schools is incredible obviously I mean I want to actually just say disclaimer a good friend of mine and a listener of the podcast also works for the OU in advocacy and I think the OU does incredible work and I also agree with you that The OU is not reflexively on the left side of an issue, on the right side of the issue. I personally am not anti-OU. I worked for the OU for several years. I have a lot of Hikartos, the OU. I think the OU does a lot of incredibly meaningful work. But I think it is true that when the OU gets into politics because there are specific things that they want to accomplish, it muddies them and they have to get dirty. Politics is a messy business no matter what you say or do. Agreed. And when you're representing a religious community, a community that is based on Torah, a community that is based on Torah values, on mitzvot, on a relationship with God, you are hurting that cause when you do things like this. Like what?

Like honoring Jeff Sessions. They didn't honor him. It's a couple. They didn't get him an award, but they obviously didn't have a couple. Should they have disinvited him? Should they just not have shaken his hand? What if they just said something acknowledging the policy? I'll tell you what I think they should have done. It's June 2018. This guy is leading the charge of a very, very painful policy and many other painful policies. And we didn't even get into that. And we also didn't get into all the other things that have been sort of controversial in the past few years, especially on the left side of the equation about the OU. But we could save that for a different time. I would say either disinvite him completely and say, look, here is a really bad time. We want to keep working with you on all these other issues, but we have a lot of pressure from our constituents. We cannot do something that our constituents do not believe in.

constituents right now are saying that they are they're revolting which they didn't they didn't do or they invite him they do not have some sort of like private thing in a secret meeting that the next day they tell us about and say oh no no we told him that we didn't like it they sign on to the letter they publicly say we think that there are a lot of important things that you've done for religious liberty there are other things that we're concerned about but we know tzedek tzedek you know if you're going to be doing these things this is important blah blah blah maybe not 15 thank yous maybe don't take all these cozy pictures and then blast them on all the social media showing To the rest of the world, hey, everything's going great. Look at Jeff Sessions. Look at this plaque we handed him. There are many things that I would have done differently. Okay, so I don't have, I don't really strongly disagree with what you just said. I think if they would have done something like that, I definitely don't think they should have disinvited him. But to acknowledge, let's say, in their speech that, like, we do have a problem with this current thing, and I hope you can find a solution where you can, let's say, uphold the law, but also not separate families, something like that, where it's said in a respectful way, I think that I probably agree that they should have done something like that. But I guess the reason why I'm reacting the way I am is because I'm reacting against the intense, simplistic backlash against the OU.

often coming from people that are not really constituents of the OU, that are not really having anything to do with the OU in any other situation, but are using this as an opportunity to attack them, which I think you would agree is not who the OU is representing or is meant to represent, and therefore their criticism should not be taken with the same weight as people who are genuinely members of the Orthodox community and feel a part of that community. But do you think that's the case? I mean, just based on my own social media and my own conversation with friends. I think it was mixed. Yeah, I think much more so than other...

that other sort of mini controversies that the OU has had, in which case it was non-Orthodox people or people who used to be Orthodox and left the Orthodox community who were pretty upset about things within the OU. And maybe, you know, obviously a lot of people have an axe to grind in general with the OU. And this is just another opportunity to grind that axe. I think there are a lot more people who are angry about this. And maybe, again, it relates to virtue signaling and relates to also once you get a mob started, it just keeps growing and there's an escalation there. But I think that I know many people who don't normally get involved in this sort of like Orthodox political infighting, discussions on Facebook, things like that, who have come out very strongly saying that the OU came out on the wrong side of this and the OU made a very bad mistake by not making a much stronger statement. Right. And maybe...

Listen, I'm open to the possibility or the argument that they did make a mistake. Even though I'm arguing this side, it doesn't mean that I'm 100% confident. I think it's not too late. I think people still generally trust the OU. I still generally trust the OU. I think if the OU came out with a statement right now and said, we screwed up. We should have signed up to that letter in the first day. I think they basically did say that. No, they didn't. They said, we had a private meeting. You don't know what happened at that private meeting. There was no, I apologize. There's no, we should have done things differently. I mean, they didn't just sign the letter. They wrote their own statement. And I'm looking at their website. And the headline of the statement is, update, OU acts to reverse zero tolerance immigration policy. And they're explicitly directing this to Jeff Sessions.

through the administration and saying that they have a big problem with the policy. I think it's hollow because this came after a huge backlash. So very likely they're doing it because of the backlash. Whatever they say now is going to be hollow because it's coming after this mob. Maybe, but there's authentic apologizing. If they said, we were working on the wording, we should have rushed this out, it's something that we really care about and we will keep you updated about this because this is something that we really are passionate about. We messed up and not communicating that. That would mean a lot more to me than a letter a week after every other Jewish organization. People who feel strongly orthodox but also really care about things like this, they feel less and less connected with the orthodox part of their identity when the OU, which is representing them, doesn't do things like this.

guess my main point is that I totally get what you're saying and I totally am open to the possibility that the OU messed up in some way, but it bothers me that a lot of this outrage that we're seeing against the OU is not taking into consideration the complicated position that they're in and really their obligation to be on good terms with all administrations, whether they agree with them or not, because as an organization that is representing a religious minority that... has a very long history of vulnerability. They just can't afford to be burning any bridges. And even if they did mess up in this situation, I think that has to at least be appreciated and taken into account. And just to be clear, I totally think that the OU and all Jewish organizations can look out for the interests and well-being of the Jewish community and also care about other groups and other minorities and do what they can.

to help those groups and to express their support for other vulnerable people. I hear what you're saying, but I also think that it really makes people feel disinclined to think of the OU as representing, even though I agree with you that it's wrong because the OU does so, so much that people don't even realize or recognize that people are involved and they don't even know about. Yachat is an incredible, incredible organization, what they have done. So many people have been touched in some way by one of their other programs. OU does a lot of amazing things, obviously not even to mention the Khashr, but the OU is an incredible organization, but I also think that when they mess up, and I think this is a serious mess up, they need to be called to task because the more things like this happen and other things, obviously, in a much smaller scale.

like this have happened and I think though you need to recognize that people are slipping away from them well it's a complicated issue and then if people are interested if people are interested in finding out more information about it we're going to include as many links as we can kind of just giving the best picture possible of what's happening with all this All right. Thanks everyone so much for listening. As always, please make sure if you like what you're hearing, subscribe to the podcast, use Stitcher, SoundCloud, iTunes, whatever you use. And that way you will never miss an episode. And of course, please rate us five stars and that way other people will be able to find us. And thanks so much to Drive-In Productions for sponsoring this episode and for giving us their beautiful studio to record in, even though it is a little bit warm today. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Regate. They are the official band of Talking Talkless and they give us our theme song. Thanks everyone. Bye. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on June 20, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.