Hello and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a podcast about classical education Lectures and Christian civilization. My name is Thomas Magby. I'm joined as always by mr.
Graham Donaldson hello and mr. A. J. Hanenburg that's me and today, you know We only we only ever cover works that are over a hundred years old.
We're very very consistent with that We only think of authors who are long since past. Yeah, of course, and so that's why Graham is gonna be telling us about a lecture from 2024 It's true. I did I was talking to my wife last night about this because we rewatched a lecture for dinner And she's like how can you justify this for your podcast? And I was like you don't even listen so that's true.
She listens when she needs to go to sleep cool. Yeah, if she can't sleep She'll listen to what she was supposed to know but then she couldn't fall asleep last night And so she listened to the like Senate I don't think that put her to sleep she woke up angry. No, we're gonna be looking at the recent Erasmus lecture at first things So first things every year has a lecture that they put on I actually realize I don't know what the purpose of the Erasmus lecture is but based on the fact that it's named after Erasmus You can assume that it's about sort of like man like you know sort of like those talks that are in after Ted exactly Ted's talks. Yeah, Ted Mosby from from what's called My mature mother.
Oh, okay those are Ted talks. No, um, so the Erasmus lectures from first things they have is sort of the their keynote lecture And this year's lecture or 2024's lecture was done by a guy named Paul Kings North We probably talked about him on the park before yeah, not a theologian He's an author that he's listed on their mast head here first things as a novelist essayist and poet living in Ireland His background is really interesting. Oh, and then the talk that he gave is called against Christian civilization And so we did an episode last episode We talked about Sir Thomas Moore and the the move from kin based relationships till institution based early relationships And we also there was one episode a camera Which one it was but in our in between we I we sort of were asking the question and the question that one of you guys said or that came up somehow and has stayed with me was did Christianity perfect Rome or did Christianity destroy Rome and that's sort of been a question That's a not a new question about in the Christian history But that is anyway so Paul Kings North is giving this lecture against Christian civilization and he is he's essentially saying that like any idea of trying to Kind of like re-inflate a lost Christianity in the West to save the West is a fool's game That's his sort of his thesis. So we'll get that in a second Paul Kings North.
He's an interesting guy He wrote his almost like his sort of testimony or conversion story on first things His background was that he was a pretty hardcore left-wing Environmentalist like the chaining himself to trees kind of guy of the 90s like green piece and religiously He was full into like ancient English British or Irish Is Irish or English actually don't know but he was full into like sort of the ancient traditions of like the English Isles paganism Right, so there's still pagans that like do Stonehenge and all that kind of stuff Although they've kind of got a I feel like Stonehenge has friends around it as fence like they probably don't get to use actual Stone they do they do yeah, I seriously do for yes, they get to do they get to do they On the solstice like the Macke Pagans will be a show of his own Stonehenge I'm going this. I mean what was 2006? Your last pagan sir? Anyway, so he sort of grew he Sort of your typical kind of like modern atheists and then kind of like dabbled into like woo-woo stuff and like Zen Buddhism and you know Pick any kind of like environmentalist cliche religious sect He probably dabbled in it and then really got into sort of you know His that sort of paganism of the of the the druids and that kind of stuff And then the way that he tells it there was one ceremony that he was going to go to at night And he just physically couldn't do it and he had been having dreams about Christ and and almost like physically couldn't go There are photos of the pagan ceremonies.
Thank you. It looks like a music festival, but you're interested in that happening right now It's playing So and he sort of like physically couldn't go to stuff and sort of felt himself being drawn to Christianity and he couldn't really explain What I was a wonderful article where he where he talks about his conversion I think the name of the article is the cross and the machine which is like awesome anyway I listen to them in the 90s. Yeah, so And so he's really interested in yeah, so that's where he's come from And so he does this harassment structure called against Christian civilization because his big If you had to sort of pin him on something that he believes in regards to the modern world He thinks and I think a lot of editors at first things agree with him that in our cultural moment something is ending Culturally and something is coming culturally that we are in some sort of between we're some sort of like transition period between Maybe the end of what we would call modernity to To some sort of new thing whether that's like the nation states of the 19th century or or whatever it is that like you know The excesses of the modern world with its technology and its the financialization of everything and Paul Kings North looks at this and says like this is this is a civilization that doesn't have staying power and is kind of falling apart now already like we can Agree I mean I want to give his sort of argument and we can talk about it so don't miss it I know you think I'm grouchy, but I don't necessarily agree I do I do I do I'm not pausing this because I think Kings North is right on everything But it was an harassment structure and well he basically is like well let's keep going You'll be able to make sense um so he has this thing let's read his sort of his article Graham actually printed out this this as this lecture. Yeah, we have it in front of you But you also did it landscape I did for my mistake.
Oh, I was wondering if that was in no no, okay, um so um So so he's talking about his sort of viewpoint on this on our sort of modern time So let me read these two paragraphs here a few decades later the British historian Arnold Toynbee echoed Spangler's prediction Collapse in his own painstakingly developed cynical mode of the rise and falls of cultures his vast multi-volume work of study of history examined 21 civilizations Across the span of human time seeking common reasons for their rise and fall of those 21 civilizations he uh 20b concluded collapsed when they reached the moral state The United States is in now note that this now was quite some time ago. 20b died in 1975 I have taken to call on the strange dissolving increasingly nihilistic moment We are living through a quote culture of inversion We can best understand the process I think by simply observing that our elites today are focused overwhelmingly on inverting the culture that we took for granted When I was growing up the inversion takes many forms and can be found in almost every crevice of society now From the curriculum in schools to the output of the Disney corporation turning everything on its head is the work of the west today um I kind of think I know what he's getting at there But he doesn't like go off and explain what he means by this culture of inversion But I think what he kind of means is that a culture whose Foreign momentum is based on the like destruction and criticizing of things that have come before it That it is not a culture that is like producing a positive vision of life but is sort of like Devouring through the past positive vision of life and that's kind of its essence. Is it fair? What he's getting at?
Do I think it's a fair summary? Do you think that's what he means by culture inversion? I think that's what he means by that's what he means by that. Yeah, I think Yeah, you probably agree with that 100 percent.
I don't know. I mean I think there's definitely elements to it But is the battle lost and that's another question so um and then he says okay This is what's happening to western civilization and the definition that he gives of western civilization is one that he takes from a medieval historian that says There has never been a unitary organization of western culture apart from that of the Christian church Which provided an effective principle of social unity behind the ever-changing pattern of western culture There was a living faith with which gave you up a certain sense of spiritual community in spite of all the conflicts and divisions and social Schism that marked his history So the western this is a historian named Dawson the west was a religious construction It was the creation of Roman Catholicism because to delineate between the western church and eastern church after this after various schisms So then his big question he's asking is I know i'm reading a lot from this essay, but I kind of want to read his thesis He says if the Christian faith is the basis of western culture What happens when that faith retreats or rejected and he makes reference to another Christian historian named tom holland who wrote a book called dominion Which is probably another episode we should do at some point He says another historian tom holland demonstrated in his book dominion It was Christianity that formed the western mind when such a sacred order dies There will be upheaval at every level of society from politics right down to the level of the soul This I think is where we are and i'm hardly the only one to have noticed In fact almost everyone who is paying attention has now by has by now noticed some of those people in response have come to a conclusion Since Christianity was the basis of the western culture of ours and since this culture is now sick or even dying The way to revive it must be to revive Christianity not so much as a religion But rather as a social blue or even as a weapon what we need we increasingly hear from many different quarters is a return to something called Christian civilization regardless of whether the Christian faith is in fact true at a certain level This may appear to be attractive narrative, but I believe it to be a deadly mistake So that's sort of his thesis is that if you if we look at sort of the culture around us and say there's something about this idea There's something sick and dying in western civilization And western civilization is built on christ on the christian on christianity if we revive christianity We save the west and he says that doing that is the wrong game But if you do that that is he says that is a what's he call it deadly mistake deadly mistake All right, do we have any initial thoughts so far? I feel like I need to hear more not sure I have the Full argument at this point. He's doing his he's minute 15 into 40 minutes of silence.
Yeah. Yeah, I think my My initial issue is that any organization that thinks the way to health is to revert to a previous state rather than like Push forward to something new like the people who are like I got a recapture the magic of yesteryear are are the ones who never quite get it Yeah, that makes sense. I like you're saying I don't think is it like it would take a deep systemic crisis to even get close to reviving A christian state he's saying that ultimately when you hear people say we need to sort of revive christian civilization Basically what he's saying is what they really mean is we need to sort of double down on modernity and fight the modernities fight to the death And what he means by modernity is he means A growth economy, uh technological progress, um and those are sort of what we want those things we don't want those things I he says we don't want those things he actually thinks that um modern life and christian values are Incompatible, which is maybe even more of the fiery the fiery point that he's getting at So he kind of has two arguments he's going through one. He says if you have public intellectuals who say who cares if christianity is true or false We need its ethic to fight against the he he quotes.
Um, uh, what's her name? Um, uh, shoot Um, the the wife of nyle Ferguson's her name, um, uh, iin her siali that's right So he quotes so iin her siali she's a public intellectual Um, and she sort of in the early 2000s became kind of famous for her anti fundamentalist islamic take Journey the war on terror and everyone kind of labeled her as as islamophobic And um, she wrote an article saying like why i'm now a christian and her reasons why she was now a christian had nothing to do with Oh, it didn't really, they didn't really talk if it did her main point was that we need to sort of establish The judao christian ethic to fight against the rise of like communist china global islam and woke ideology Like that and therefore christian faith is going to be this bulwark that fights against the sort of three prong thing And that was the reason why she was sort of advocating for it So she was a christian ideologically, but yeah, and also he also uh kings north even quotes talking about jordan peterson who makes a lot of the same argument Saying like who cares if it's true or false It's like a good thing for young men to believe to get them like to establish in this grand tragedy that is life And kings north i think rightly says christians cannot uh you can we should not um put up with that But the faith is not weak we people can't just say i want the fruits of christianity, but i don't i don't want the belief Christianity i don't want to practice this or maybe you don't want the practices you can't have the fruit without The reality of it so jordan peterson, you know, whether or not he believes in god He says well christianity is kind of like get some nice outputs and kings north is saying If we are going to adopt we're going to sort of like adopt some kind of civilizational christianity in hopes of getting the outputs He thinks that that's going to be a wrong the wrong game before the wrong sort of war to fight that um allie and um peterson are only putting on The mythos of christianity for the coming war and he thinks that that's that's not right He thinks of that sort of actually against christian general so he's got that one argument and on that argument i kind of I believe with that i agree with that that christianity is not sort of a um Sort of a competing a mythos that is in that that only exists in competition against communism Some sort of like social Marxism or or is not like that's not what christianity is It's not just god didn't just give an identity for us to continue to combat other identities Um, so I agree with him on that but then he even gets into and fundamentally says that um christianity seriously considered cannot um coexist with our modern world with our modern way of life um and um He says well even so he goes to the bible and he says when man when god made man he put man in a garden And had man tend to the earth commune with man and and sort of live this agrarian not even agrarian because we're even farmers Live this sort of like almost um hunter gatherer Not even hunter a gatherer lifestyle humans it turns out we're created as vegetarian partners Yes, so that's that's what he says. Yeah, and when the fall this is a vegetarian thing I have Come to find out is maybe foisted upon it. It says I have given these all the green things You know for food it never says don't eat animals sure just just a thing to think about is like I can't find out of the text anyway Here's where I think maybe we can start getting into uh some disagreement maybe my disagreements But the whole point of this episode is not to like say what dulson thinks about this It's just sort of point this out and talk about like this is a tension that exists and why does this exist on classical stuff?
Well, um a lot of classical christian schools have this kind of Id in the back of them that we are we are educating students either to go off and fight in the culture wars or to quote regain or save western civilization and um He wants to make the argument of like how do western civilization come about and that may actually be the way to save it And it's not the way that peterson and all we were talking about and it may not be the way that our schools are setting it up to be Anyway, what's I talking about how to say well? We'll get to that. Okay. Um it comes It comes to a reading of what happened at the end of the roman empire with with the monastics and the mystics But we'll get to that in a second.
Um So this is reading of god's relationship with human institutions and civilization Um when we disobeyed what happened farming happened work happened hunting happened metal work happened murder happened cities happened civilization happened It was all a deadly result of our fall So already there's a theological point that he is saying that like civilization and cities and government are a result of the fall And there is a um there is a theological position that says that government institutions are necessary because of sin I can't remember what it's called And that's contrasted to someone like Thomas Aquinas that says there would have been a there would have been government If the fall hadn't happened there was government and there was government before the fall happened so kings north doesn't Apparently agree with that he thinks that um Civilization is a result of that cities and work and farming and and metal work is a result of the fall Um and that is an interpretation of the Old Testament for sure and that is a theological position that some people in christian history have held Um, but it's not like that's not not subtle science It's not that that is a an open theological question because you could just as clearly you could just as easily say well God actually comes and establishes a way of life for the israelites god actually wants a temple bill for him God establishes a city that comes down at the end of history Um god praises middle workers and has them adorn his house of worship in in the Old Testament Um God creates and says you will be my nation you will be my people and seems to establish his realize as a nation Um, but kings north sort of glosses over that and jumps to the book of samuel Where people say we want a king and samuel says you don't know what you're asking for if you don't have you want god You're like no, we want a king and he says well the king's gonna take your boys and fight him in wars He's gonna take your crops gonna take your money and people like we want a king anyway and He concludes his reading of the Old Testament is at this is kings north at the very least I think we can say that this god of ours has an ambivalent relationship to humanities earthly power structures um And then he uh towards the end of the essay he goes on and says what if um does um Um, um, yeah does what is when we talk about trying to save western culture and civilization um And therefore to do that we need to sort of emphasize christian practices and christian religion in culture Um, he then asked the question is the modern way of life that we have Um compatible with christianity And he says this to find out we might hold up the stated values of our own civilization against the famous list of the seven deadly sins The list was compiled in the sixth century by pope gregory the first Um, how is western civilization doing today at fitting off these sins? And we've definitely had a um an episode on this um And I realize that part of this is kind of actually this kind of can you read it? Yeah, can we start with pride is celebrated everywhere? Pride is celebrated everywhere pride in nation status wealth ethnic groups identity religion We have a month long festival name for it greed is the basis of our economy along with in viet is the cornerstone of the idol of our time The universally worshiped god known as economic growth if we were neither greedy nor envious the economy would collapse in five minutes Wrath is the fuel beneath the culture wars and all of our political factions As for lust find me a billboard or a film or a song or a brand of shoes that doesn't piggyback on this most primal human passion It was perhaps behind only gluttony in its ubiquity even sloth has been monetized How else could something as oxamoronic as a leisure industry even exist?
Thanks and then he says our entire civilization then not only fails to resist these deadly sins but actively encourages them They are the very basis of its existence. This um surely is what oh he is somebody that he used as an example early in his speech And many other critics like him many of them christian have been able to see our christianity and modern civilization oppose and irreconcilable On this basis, I think we can say unequivocally yes So this is his argument is that sort of the modern growth economy and the way that we have society set up Culturally That seemed to be encouraged to seven deadly sins. He says if we actually created a christian civilization That fought against that like took those deadly sins seriously and tried to create an environment or a culture or social practices That removed those seven deadly sins from people's lives We would actually be at war with the current culture that we have because we would be choking off the its oxygen or whatever um, and then um and then he continues to go on and mention that the teachings of jesus himself are no basis for building a civilization when um jesus says to um abandon your dead father and let the dead bury the dead and follow me Um to not store up your grain in barns to not carry about tomorrow to give away all that you had to the poor To and he says if you sort of take those commands of jesus seriously Um, you know that's sort of that's no way to run a city Right. Um and so in that sense he's sort of saying that like a lot of the commands of jesus um are anti-civilized or uncivilized because if you did if everybody did them you would not have uh, a functioning city and in many ways this was reminded me of um of the granny quisitor When um the granny quisitor so and also the temptation of jesus in the desert so which he makes reference to in his speech He doesn't make reference to the granny quisitor, but he does make reference to um to the temptation of the desert The devil shows jesus all the kingdoms of the earth and says quite provocatively This has been given to me.
I have authority over all of this Which is already kind of a wild thing for the devil to say if it's true He says I have authority over all the kingdoms of the earth Worship me and they're yours and jesus says no Um and in the granny quisitor narrative uh aj you're the expert on this Why does the granny quisitor take issue with jesus saying no to the devil's offer of getting authority overall that do you remember? Because he's gonna fit everyone. Yeah, he's gonna fit everybody That like if if jesus agreed you've done so much better if you take a deal just use the ring for good Yeah, yes, um And so jesus of course says no, but the granny quisitor in docios story has is mad at jesus because he's like listen You could have ended suffering you could have an emissory you could have jesus you could have set up christian civilization if you had said Yes, and jesus says no and so kinsner holds it up and says if jesus says no to all the powers of the earth Then what are what are christians doing saying that they need to have earthly power? That's good.
It's good. I think he's conflating a lot of things. I think he is conflating a lot of things And then to answer it so let's sort of see what he goes with this of a jay's last question, which was okay So then what do you do um he says um Um, I believe there was wisdom to be found for us in this disintegrating age not in crusading nights or christian nationalists Not in emperors or soldiers, but in the mystics the ascetics the hermits of the caves and the wild saints of the forest in the desert These were the people who built a real christian culture So did simple everyday lovers of god in the world who tended to the poor and the sick for no reward as the gates of rom were breached by goths As ireland and england were invaded by vikings as the ottomans overcame constant Concentiable as a communist dynamite a cathedral some crucified monks they kept on Um, and then um, yeah, they did their work They did not fight for civilization They fought for christ and they fought not with swords but with prayer and with active love for their neighbors and enemies without that love the devil wins He goes on to say so his reading of why the church grew in the first century at all Was that it was the christians who stayed behind in the plague riddin cities to take care of the dead It was the christians who took care of the discarded babies of the roman elites who didn't want to they gave birth to a daughter They're like one another one of those and they left them exposed the christians took them in and raised them Um, and the christians obviously were willing to die during midst of the persecutions um, and then he says Culture I sometimes thinks are built by accident If at the heart of all cultures is a sacred jewel a revealed truth if all cultures have a spiritual essence well then it comes from spiritual work The monks built the west just as surely as the soldiers did and they built the more enduring part christian civilization wrote the liturgical artist Tillery white recently is the secondary fruit of christian mysticism and then he quotes a quote by cs Louis where cs Louis says revision religions devised for a social purpose like roman emperor worship or modern attempts to sell christian He has a means of saving civilization do not come to much the little knots of friends who turn their back on the world are those who really Transfortunate and so his conclusion is that the way to sort of if we really do want to save the west or not even save the west if we really do want to have um have Sort of if we really do want to have anything what do we do in this time of decline and confusion? um And his argument is that there's there's prayer love service and sort of a return to christian mysticism a turning one's back on the world Um and then from that turning one's back on the world He says when that happened the first time it did happen after the when Rome fell and all of it sort of like Magisterium of the roman empire being this christian thing that was going off to perfect the world it fell apart um What created the next what created the next christian age was this thing that nobody could have guessed and it was this society This of the middle ages built out of the mysticism of the desert fathers and the monastics And then that middle age society existed until it got co-opted and decadent and sort of turned into You know the renaissance which turned into the industrialism which turned into modernity And so his view is that like what we're looking at now what modernity is right now is this like motion he doesn't put this this is more my theory is that what modern world is this amalgamation of like christianity of europe and you know technol i believe in sort of technology in the classical world of the renaissance and all this thing and um all of this stuff sort of pushed together into institutions of Sort of the english legal world and uh and he says it's falling apart and the way and the way to revive it is not to Sort of fight for some sort of idea of christian civilization But it's almost like to turn one's back and retreat and just sort of like embrace the coming dark ages and be christian mystics in hopes that Something can come out of that and he said who would have guessed of the revival of the russian church in the midst of communism like for the christians When the communists were blowing up all the cathedrals and crucifying all the monks they would have thought this is the end of history But 70 years later kind of communism is gone or is at least not what it was and christianity remains and is and that and eastern Eastern orthodoxy is sort of on the ascendancy And so he's like that is the way to do it and they didn't do it because they doubled down and fought for christian civilization They kind of retreated to almost these like mystical lives of just like white knuckling keeping the faith going in the midst of of destruction Anyway, so that's his argument is that any kinds of attempts to Save the west through like a recapturing of christianity and maybe even if we're gonna be a little self-critical the classical education world he is skeptical of and and thinks that that is What a deadly error and that what we should be doing is Presumably retreating from the world and focusing on lives of prayer and contemplation It hopes that from that a new vision of the feat of the christian future can take shape All right, that's I think it is my best attempt to kind of give justice to his position Do you want to you want to start with your response or do you want a dated for 40 minutes?
Let's go for it a to let's see. Well, okay. Let's some criticisms one By saying that that civilization and government and farming and cities was the result of the fall I think it's too easy reading of the Old Testament I think I agree sort of with Aquinas that there would have been a structure of government that was pre-lapsarian I know that that you know and so this idea of yes, so Natural government is not just to mitigate sin natural government to some of that exists in the positive not just in the negative sense Yes, so the natural family so in that sense like if Adam and Eve did not sin and they reproduced and you had a nation of sinless beings on earth creating the garden You would have had Organizational structures and God would not have been ambivalent Let me talk about like Adam naming the animals and ruling over them and being astute like there's all of these things like clearly there was government before the lapse Yeah, so he kind of falls into that more like Hobbes or Locke enlightenment idea that civilization or even Russo that civilization is a Or that government structures is a necessary evil terrain in man's excesses and I don't think that there was a positive government in the Old Testament Yes, I agree other criticisms you're walking away like you're done. No, I was gonna get that hot sauce I was well-tasting wait what?
That's all it's just a little table tempting me. I just want to try that I want to say I was wondering if there were more you said there were some criticisms is that the only Oh, there's that one the idea that like our entire basis in motive life is incompatible with Christianity because of the seven deadly sins I don't think when he says that our entire economic system is based on greed and envy. I don't think it's also I don't think it's fair I think it's based on debt, but I think I think you can have a I think you can have a positive vision of economic activity that isn't just based that doesn't just fan the flames of sinful desire I think it's hard. I think fan the flames of sinful desire is gonna come a lot, but um But just to say because because the system has created excesses People creating something and selling it so they can continue to create something that mechanism in and of itself is not simple It's like saying alcohol is not molecularly sinful.
It's just the misuses of it art Christ turned water into wine It's a good one. So it's like the actual buying and selling of goods at its core I don't think it is but he sort of he seems to conflate the two and say that it is and so I wonder if we went through all of those Things like is is wrath really the basis of our government structures? No, it's not at least it shouldn't be our government structures is based on like the dudes were working on the roads aren't exactly doing that because of Wrath Even when well, let me just read this little section that I've been teaching in my government class from Madison's federalist papers number 10 when he talks About so let's see if we can find it See what he talks about Sorry, I realized I didn't have this right ready to go. Oh, yeah, it's just about like he says what we need to do is We need to be electing people.
Oh here we go We should be electing people in passing laws passing through the medium of a chosen body of citizens whose wisdom may best to Surin the true intent of their country and whose patriotism and love of justice will be least likely to sacrifice it to temporary or partial Consideration right this sort of like at its founding at least in the early days of the American experiment in the American Republic There was a belief that we are going to establish a country wherein People who love justice are going to be put in positions of making of passing laws and to say that because that may have degraded over 200 years and we now have really embarrassing like screaming matches of these like Senate hearing committees It's again that same argument like is civilization as an idea inherently sinful or is it just that like we employing it have done poor Jobs of maintaining it and my position is we have done poor jobs of maintaining it and it sounds like King North King's North is saying at its very Conceptual level God is against it and I don't think that's true. I don't think that's true. He says his thing is that Best in bivalent Like them the monarchy right opposition to the being a king. That's right.
Yeah, I was thinking about this This is one of my so I was you were talking I was writing down my beefs for the 40-minute mark So one of them is that since have always infected culture because since I've always infected man our culture is not unique in that there is Sin right if you look back at almost any of the cultures you could level the same You know the seven deadly sins are part of what we do criticism like look at the Vikings was greed not a part of their world Lust for things right greed was the very foundational their culture right they rated other civilizations as of yet We haven't invaded Canada as of yet So there's and the Vikings did yeah And so if we're if we're talking about that like the seven deadly sins being an integral piece of our culture I think that they have really ugly had an every culture because they've either had also his point is that they've really had No every culture and he's saying can there be can there be a distinctly Christian civilization or is because Culture is going because sins are going to shoot themselves through culture like Christians Shouldn't play the game of trying to create civilization his recommendation is to create smaller Christian civilizations almost by accident Yes, he wants us. Yeah, if he wants us to create, you know Monasteries where monks can flourish there are no more regulated places than that that is civility of its eyes Yeah, right that is civilization and if that's his solution I mean I am sympathetic with his notion that we cannot take this whole nation and make it once again a Christian community Yes, I'm sorry to that too I don't think I think he is right and saying that that is a fool's errand to try to make this a Christian centered Christian based nation But I do think it's a little bit silly to say that civilization is bad as a solution is to create civilizations on a smaller scale like that seems a little silly to me I think he's I think you're right in saying that like what he is describing for is a Like a massive de-stealing down to smaller Christian communities and I bet if we actually pushed if you were able to push things Or he would probably agree with that. I don't think he would say people need to be isolated or like the nasticks also didn't have families and children I don't think he would go that far So I do think if you sort of like asked him real practically how this works out He would give you some kind of vision of like the small localized Christian parish working together I was gonna say so what he wants is the church and you have that yeah But it's almost like he wants that and nothing more or anything more than we have is going to is is like the church should not be Backstopping its failings the church should almost be like Working in the margins or in the half spaces of those of civilization to sort of right the wrongs at the civilization does wrong Which is civilization is always going to exploit the church is supposed to be there to to to mitigate the exploitation as opposed to the church should be coming in and helping crop up the exploiting civilization yeah I mean sounds like what he wants is the church are we not doing that like our church is not having food drives and Helping the poor and making disciples which is the great commission It just seems like he wants the church to be better than it is that that seems like his call is like Christians do this And or maybe just to prevent the church from saying we need to overhaul this whole government of the entire nation and make it a Christian nation once again I'm sympathetic to that, but I don't know that we need to do much different than we are already doing which is no The thing is what he wants to fight against is is us saying like we are going to adopt or hold up or or encourage Christian activities and Christian principles because they're the most effective tool to push back against the present enemies of communism or woke ideologies or oh so basically don't have Christianity stay out of that tussle like that ideological Fight that's happening in the media and everywhere else he says he wants Christianity to not be part of that That's something yeah, he wants that I'm talking about that or if they are part of that tussle They're not part of that tussle of like align themselves with modern civilization They're part of that tussle by removing themselves from civilization to pray and be mystic and contemplate And I think that rubs a lot of people the wrong way like if that's if you know I don't know that like mysticism and contemplation I think as long as you couple those with real activity in your community like these ideological battles happen every you know in the Media but what's actually happening in the nation is individual activity within a community and as long as we are as a church focused on Those things like I'm happy. I'm happy not to submit talking heads to the news Yeah, so I'm sympathetic with some of this stuff I just think he he ends at that place In a I don't know it seems it seems more inflammatory than it has to be and also like he says we want to preserve the West We like this culture our current culture is the logical conclusion of the West like it's sorry if we're talking about Western culture We are Western culture right now, and so what exactly are we preserving?
What generation does he like I mean what is he trying to harken back to That that would be my question because if we're talking about say Britain during the plantagenets I wouldn't exactly call that the culture that we want where everyone is after power and killing each other and it's tribal and I don't think we want that We also want the Vikings or maybe the culture of the 1300s So it seems like he wants a very specific notion of culture and what he wants is virtue, and I think that's found in the church Well, I think it's fine I think when he I think it is helpful that when people say oh man we need to have a Return to Christian values or even classical schools because like this this a lot There are classical Christian conferences that have like the tagline saving the West as its tagline and that is very much in sort of the a lot of the I'm sure there's headmasters of schools that are like I am creating students who can go off and can recapture this kind of lost glory days of the Western civilization that we've lost now because look at all the excesses and look at the fighting and look at all the pornography and look at all the violence and whatnot and and and tech running away with our children's lives like we need to go back and return to something to a glorious classical past and His point is not his point is You're not going to be able to go back and retain a glorious past if you actually want to build a Christian future you almost need to reject This dying animal that we have right here Get out of its way as it's dying Retain Christian practices in the small scale and then and then know or have faith that a new sort of Christian vision of society is going to come out of it some sort of Christian society that is you know That is compatible with modern technology and the world that we're going to have on the other side of whatever is coming I mean you can also just not agree with Kings North and think that we're at the end of some great thing, but I mean I Yeah, I mean I think that's a bit of a disruption is what he's talking Yeah, and it's what I try to do every day with my students like if preserving the West and his Idea is to teach our students the great ideas and then also try to hand them virtue I'm on board with that I do wish the tag lines of some of those AC you know the like Conferences you have of classical school schools was instead of saving the West it would be Teaching our children virtue and handing out handing down the great idea So do you think AJ then we should have or in Thomas D going on this do you think that we should have we should want our students to Then go off and try to reform institutions. I'm thinking again I'm thinking of this in regards to the Thomas more episode We did before like do we want to go off and can we reform if the if the institutions of the West are degrading Which is Kings North position should we be going back and trying to trying to? You know like you know like we were talking about in the in between episode like should can can the institutions repent and buy another lease on life? It sounds like King's North says no, but what do you think Thomas?
Like should we be encouraging students to like try to go off and bring back our public and private institutions from the brink? I don't know if I buy them. I don't buy the premise off the bat. Yeah, let me this is King's North I think did you read the part where he uses the phrase defend the West?
I think he picked up the paragraph after so I just wanted to read this our work is not to defend the West this is what he says That's idol worship our work is repentance, which means transformation We have to be prepared to die and thus reborn I'm speaking as someone who is most of the time afraid even to contemplate what this might demand of me which is very good Yeah, I think he I hear all the points that you all are making I do think that we need to We should be on watch for the deadly sins And I think that there are unique temptations to living in 2025 that didn't exist in 2005 or 95 or pick whatever decade or pick up a few Hundred years ago, there are five. Yeah, pick up five. There's a there are unique temptations to a given time and I just had this in my mind of a long time ago. I when I first came across Thomas Martin was really fascinated with this idea of Monasteries and monks and Really like love that idea and so spend a lot of time thinking about what it would look like to be a monk and like go into that life But that's not what I'm called to I'm a husband I'm a father and I'm not ever going to be a monk in a monastery And so it's fine to like think about what it would look like if things were better But I think ages points are kind of around the like what do I do tomorrow?
And if I believe in this argument I kind of give up, right? Yeah, I don't think that is right and I don't think that's what people should do Yeah, I was gonna say I think we are call the Christians to do a couple of things make disciples and if and to be virtuous and follow Christ that if those Things are Reformative to answer Donaldson's question like should we go into these places and reform them? I think you know being a person who's making disciples who's being virtuous you may get promoted and then those things will suffuse themselves into the Institution and Like that that is our call and to quote sign back is one of my favorite quotes He says evil must constantly respond while good while virtue is immortal vice has always a new fresh young face while virtue is venerable as nothing else in the world is like no, it's not a Flashi solution to say go and keep on doing like keep on making disciples and being virtuous It sounds like Kingsworth ends in this place, but I don't think it should be one of resignation I think it should be continuing to do the call that Christians have been called to forever Yeah, when it comes to the monastic thing I think this is answered with the idea that the body is one with many parts like are there people who should turn their backs on society turn their backs on Marriage turn their backs on family formation and be people who go off and in their lives kind of live a like screw you guys I'm going to the woods No, and like some sort of idea of prayer and contemplation as a model of Resi of like turning away from the eels of the world I definitely think that there should be that people for who they should live their lives that way And I think that that ends up being but not not everybody and the benefit of that is that their lives are almost being lived as sacrifices of Examples to the rest of us and that's how the man has to the mystics were is that everyone came to visit him and said things like holy crap You're living this crazy aesthetic life in the woods What can you tell me about God and he'll say you know and you would he would give some an answer that could be taken back to the Community and would strengthen the faith of the community. I think that's an important thing But equally as important as I think like does he has the idea that That extreme people are either gonna be criminals or monks Right if you are like Raskal and Koff if you are such an extreme person that you are gonna live completely out of your convictions Well when your convictions are I want to get what's mine You're gonna go off and murder somebody and when your conviction is God is God and I am not well, then you're gonna go off and live out that conviction by being Rejecting everything and living in the woods, but not everybody's an extreme person Razumikin is not an extreme person in crime punishment and Raskalnikov sister Dune is not an extreme person They go off and get married and live you know they're they're sort of They're their their life together and Raskalnikov doesn't so I think there's I think King's North is right in saying that if we are living through a degraded time morally that the church should be looking for people who are going off and Trying to keep the you know making sure that the faith doesn't get caught up and swept up in the passions of its time And if that means that there are people that need to remove themselves from The streams and flows of those passionate times, and that's a good thing Right, that's not everybody can't do that nor should everybody do that and if you had a family you don't abandon them right?
Like Thomas you should not go and do that great. Um, but also but it's good But just even that list of like these are how the deadly sends infiltrate into our modern age He's not wrong. He's not wrong like can wrath be the motivation for political fights Yeah, 100% but then so there are things we need to deny ourselves that maybe but so could high-minded justice That's right, but there's probably TV you shouldn't watch this probably you shouldn't listen to you probably should pray more And watch let's watch fewer movies like those are things that are true And so yeah, I think ages right to frame this is like it's not no civilization. It's smaller civilization And so people should you should if for Christian listeners you should have a church that is close to where you live that you're like really involved in Right, so these aren't like radical things, but they're necessary things if you're gonna like maintain sanity, right?
Yep, anyway, that is the the episode so it is a Either reason I put it out there is because yeah, it's pertinent to our ideas of school. I think he is highlighting a coming a growing Movement that exists in Christian circles that I think is worth highlighting as a potential blind spot in contentious times so like you know if he lists All these concerns about sort of the the great forces the great forces are fighting against the west of like the rose rise of global Islam totalitarian communist China and kind of like cultural Marxism as these great things whether or not you think that those are dangers or that those are You know sort of yeah enemies or whatever you want to call it I think he's right in pointing out that the argument is not in militarized or a Sort of a crusading Christian faith that's fighting back against that even despite all the memes you see online but it is that sort of yeah a distilling down into into into deep and robust Christian communities which is scary because there's not a lot of them and What are the questions that we had in our on our ama's was a question about? Sort of the movement of young people in regards to denominations and being born out of maybe the weakness of of modern churches Not really sort of being sufficient in giving people a vision of the Christian life that can fight against the seven deadly sins of the modern age But maybe even sort of like either poo-poo them or even worse lean into them. So anyway, so I think Kings of North is Yes, I don't agree with everything that he says you know He's a very challenged I would encourage everybody to go and listen to the lecture He's really gave a little bit of it, but I think I think a J is his pronouncement is right is that yeah?
It's that yeah, it's a smaller civilization And yeah, those are the that's the episode any final thoughts you got any any little zingers going in there? No, I like a walk a walk a walk a I don't think so I you know I hate to do that thing where I'm like well God's just asking us to keep on being faithful and like you know, I feel like my answer is never Revolutionary here, but you know it does You always have a question you face and there's something to the you all work at a private Christian school like you all are a part of a Smaller community that is like intentionally You know, there's a school part, but there's the discipleship component like you all are doing something more than just like get Come to your class and you teach them for a few hours a week So I think you all live out in a way that's much closer to what King's North is arguing for maybe I want to talk about that more in Between but I don't know if that's what you have in mind when you say there aren't a lot of places like this Like when you say there aren't a lot of Christian communities that yeah, well, I was just thinking of or churches or yeah It's a lot of modern churches people are like I just get the sermon online. That's right. Yeah, so yeah, anyway All right, this has been classical stuff You should know you can find us online at classical stuff net you can find us on x.com at fiscal stuff CLS CAL Stuff you can find us on patreon patreon.com slash classical stuff where we record in between episodes after each of our main episodes We're gonna record one right now to continue the conversation.
We also have monthly AMAs We just recorded one of those today and you can find some of our old episodes that we've deleted from our main stream like some of the stuff I've done that I'm embarrassed of leave up for the patrons You actually deleted stuff. Oh, yeah I think I have one that I recorded during covid that we deleted from the main feed also It's one of my Dante episodes. Yeah, I think it's one of ours some stuff from Poe Yeah, there's definitely a Squarespace has a limit on the number of episodes we have so I think it's really yeah I think it's either three or five hundred yeah, it's all cramps episodes weirdly enough So we might have to have to it's a point the other great thing is that patreon now has an option to go to like post for a podcast So we might already have hosting a patreon to do I think they also let us I think we can sell individual posts I wonder if we should do that for AMAs so people can like try them out Oh, we can we can talk about that anyway, we put all this up on patreon You can support us there and get access to a ton of content everything AJ just said plus we have some recordings of conference talks Or training the veritas just like things that we've done outside of the podcast that are posted you know So chat with us there. So it's such a good deal.
It's a good deal. It's all about sign up Okay, even if even the $2 one gets you all that it means but most of the stuff you get access to the chat Just two bucks a month. So check it out. It's great.
You can email us the guys at classical stuff that net will read your email We'll try and reply. I don't know we do it. But what we read it. So there's that so thank you all so much for listening And we will talk to you all again soon.
Bye