Skip to content
278: Marcus Aurelius's "Meditations" episode artwork

Apr 22, 2025 1 hr 6 min

278: Marcus Aurelius's "Meditations"

from Classical Stuff You Should Know Hosted by A.J. Hanenburg

Ever feel like reading the diary of a Roman emperor? Boy have I got the book for you.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

278: Marcus Aurelius's "Meditations"

0:00 1:06:52
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi welcome to class with stuff you should know Podcast we're trying to be professional. No, we are so a podcast put on by three highly sophisticated and educated No, we're just managers who love books love learning and this podcast is about old books philosophy education specifically classical education sometimes talk about art and Most of the time we talk about literature. My name is Graham Donaldson, and I'm joined with by joined by Thomas Fletcher Maggie hi and Arthur yon Hanenburg, I'm Lord of sea land you have a longer title like Oh, there's more to see my just Lord you can pay for a fun fact. Did see land get tariff?

Did you get a terra fun? Oh, look into that. Oh, we don't we don't have a lot of industrial reports. Yeah, turns out But I mean how awesome was there was like a terra fun radio.

I was about to say if there was a terra fun So I'm a friend anyway, we are we are coming in on the like we're on the cutting edge of of the zeit guys of the internet Yeah, because we are gonna be talking about the hottest of all topics the the broiest of all silicon valley bro topics And the best part is that AJ has no idea I don't even know the thing we're talking about Marcus Aurelius's meditations today ladies and gentlemen And I was teasing AJ beforehand because like Marcus Aurelius and stoicism I've kind of had a moment of the internet where like the meditations has been become sort of a best-seller again largely in part of like Ryan holiday and his work and just sort of like the growth of of Sort of yeah a recollection or a re-re-discovery of Marcus Aurelius and stoicism and Cicero and Seneca Having its kind of moment again in the Sun of which AJ is delightfully oblivious of because AJ Like I am with most things apparently which is why you know you are like you would just appear as departed people It's like you ever seen that movie. Oh, what's it called? Oh, I heart-huckabees? I've never seen this moment.

Oh, wait, what's that again? Is that like a little girl wants to go dancing? No, it's about it's got a marky mark in it and it's got it's about You're a wall bird. Yeah, it's got Mark wall bird and it's a philosophical comedy I can't I can't really like we just gotta be like a rock or dish a mold all day and they bash themselves in it like in the face With a beach ball that's me bro AJ All day well-ran Hymn educated person but does not know I get involved in the world with I love you for you Just like this is what I want to talk about.

Yeah, you have no idea that like like stoicism is like the you know There's like a New York Times article that Ryan Holiday wrote today. I'm serious. Yeah I don't know about that great. I would probably wouldn't have done it if there was competition I was in competition shows and something else before this is who cares what I've done the tarot Gram a couple months, right?

Yeah, I thought you go through this bike accident like you know You get this bruise and now you're gonna learn about how to tough it out. No, AJ got a bike accident got a really big bruise And then thought I need a short book I was planning on this weeks ago before I got the so to fill the audience in I got it in one last thing before you get on your Sorry AJ is also like like I work so I don't AJ is someone who is who is well read in the Stoics And he's not doing this just because he's a bandwidth and waggoner So I put that out there like no yeah, you have read this not because like you read some tweet where people were like bro Meditations. No, I've read Seneca. I've read the Enchiridian I've read like me and the Stoics are good friends.

Okay cool Just want to put that out there that you're no geistoics. That's one of these like hip Stoics I thought my high school was last year like I am deep into so yeah, but I mean so since I was moment for like fast For a while yeah the past two thousand years well for sure. Yeah, but those are like modern Stoics movement thing has been about since like It's gonna be a decade right 2016 really? Yeah, how did I know about this?

Okay? Sorry, we're not the wrong with that. Sorry. Yeah, do your thing.

It's like And bike and you know, let's do DJs. Sorry. We love you. All right.

Well, that's what I'm doing. So today we are talking about Marcus Aurelius So we're gonna start with a quick history I'll tell you a little bit about stoicism not a whole lot because we do have podcasts on it that you can go listen to and then There's a part that's at the beginning of his meditations. I'm gonna say for the end, but before that we're gonna have sort of quiz show So it'll be history and then stoicism and then fun quiz show Okay, and then maybe a sort of a last a last word and I'll probably ask one big question here at the beginning So that's kind of where we're headed. Let's do it.

Okay, so Marcus Aurelius was born in AD 121 He was not the son of an emperor. He was not in line for the throne at all He was likely schooled by slaves as many wealthy people were back then You know, you have a Greek slave you pay him in nothing because he's a slave and he would educate your kids and you know That's that's kind of how it was done. There's some of the slaves actually they did the educated the ones that were schooling They did earn wages and you actually also earn their freedom. Yeah, which was cool Okay, so when he was 16 the emperor Hadrian was childless.

He had been adopted by the guy before him so So he adopted himself as well like he had an adopted heir But his heir died and so he selected a new one to adopt a guy named Antoninus with the proviso that that guy had to adopt Marcus along with his like previous dead heirs kid who was seven years old at the time So in 161 Antoninus died and Marcus carried out Hadrian's intention and pushed his younger adopted brother Lucius Verus Into co-regions as he took a power himself. So this he was 16 when I think he was adopted and then eventually took power Okay, so at this point the Senate didn't have a whole lot of power It was mostly fully an empire and the emperor pretty much had it all But he did a good job of giving the Senate as much dignity as he possibly could he pretty much let them rule and make decisions He sat in the Senate house and when they they would like so yes This is approved and then look at him and if he nodded his head like yeah, it's a proof They're like great. It's approved so we kind of let that go on for a long time eventually That would be abandoned by subsequent emperors and they the Senate wouldn't be able to save face in that way But he did a really good job sort of bringing everybody in and making feel like that job He died at 58 which is yeah, which is relatively young But it means he ruled for a good long time his wife had died a little bit before that on a journey to retake control a portion of the Empire that had Recognized a governor of Vidius Cassius as emperor which promised a civil war except Cassius was assassinated by a subordinate so So he had to go show himself around but on that trip his wife died she had had 13 children Yowser what only one son had survived and he'd been trained the whole time for the eventual emperor ship He was consul at 15 so eventually his son succeeded him as emperors That's a quick background lots of stuff happened during the time he was an emperor There were little skirmishes on the edge of the Empire just like usual right like there's little times that the barbarians push And you got a push him back and then you got a little bit of civil war threat and you gotta go solve that so there's a Year in there so he was born in 121 and then in 161 is when he took power and then he died so when he was 40 He's a power pre-Christian empire. Yeah, so he ruled he ruled for 18 years He didn't know about the Christians because he doesn't mention them in the meditations But at this time it was not a Christian Empire it was before that okay So he was a stoic and stoicism had been the philosophy of the day for a while you have Seneca's letters I mean Rome pretty much took it up wholesale Lots of stoicism sort of flying around and Marcus himself had no pretense of being a philosopher I think at some point he kind of wanted to imagine he was but he knew that he was in a bird Hins and his job was to rule and he had been building his life towards that for a very long time And so the meditations aren't like yeah, I'm an emperor, but I'm really a philosopher.

That's not really what's happening When you read the text it's weird because some of it seems like a good philosophy to hand down to you and then some of it is like weird editorial notes referencing things You don't get and there's it's clearly a one-sided conversation Most folks are pretty sure that the meditations are just Marcus releases notes to himself It's not like he made this to be read or he intended it to be some great philosophical treatise It's not even a big philosophical logical construct. He's not trying to prove anything to you It seems like you are reading the diary of an emperor that really wants to do Emperor ring good He wants to do a good job and he wants to not fall to the many pitfalls that are available to an emperor And he wants to remind himself of these things repeatedly and that you see throughout the thing because it's a lot of the same stuff Right? I mean you could put it under some headings, but it's really just the same kind of stuff over and over again where he's reminding himself Not to fear death and he's reminding himself of a variety of things in a number of ways And it seems like yeah, man You just said this like three pages ago But if you know you're growing and every couple of years you write something in your diary it feels like that's what you're reading is just You know at the time maybe he was fearing his death and his legacy and so he had to put it down a reminder for himself in his diary And that's what he thought about that day That's kind of what you're reading and so if you come across entries that are like Remember the line from X that's it. He doesn't even tell you what the line is well That's because he's he's just reminding himself of something So this is like daily discipline or maybe not daily But this is a discipline he's done in order to keep his ego his emotions and check to be sort of like it's sort of his Just sort of remind himself to do good Yeah, and to do a good job and to not yet to not fall to the psychological and philosophical pitfalls that come with being an emperor Which is swept away from the tyranny of the immediate or whatever Yeah, which is great because we have seen some pretty bad emperors And so he has to keep himself in line and check there is one section at the beginning where he sort of says a thanks to my predecessors And the people I have learned great things from that reads different than the rest of the meditations So he thinks like his teachers.

Yeah, he thinks his teachers. He thinks his dad. He thinks his great thing to think your teachers there He thinks the gods he thinks his mom He thinks everyone that has had a great influence on it even says what they did for him And I think that section that's a section I might read at the end or at least a section of it Just because I think it's really beneficial. It's a good outline for hey if you want to live a good solid public life Here's kind of the way to do it much of this is actually would actually be really beneficial for anyone looking to take public office or really Just live Simply and honestly wasn't this yes, Lewis didn't he say that he wasn't a Christian he'd be a stoic.

Yeah, and Lewis I think at some point sort of says that still this doesn't gets quite close to the Christian ethic But you know, Mrs. Mrs. Key things. Yeah, it gets a lot right I mean as you read this you like wow there really isn't much to argue with here and I kind of agree There's there are definitely lessons to take from this book There isn't it's not like I can read this and go ha ha what an idiot no most of it's just really good solid advice to both Himself and to us.

Okay, so can one of you guys summarize? What is stoicism? Can you give me like a quick elevator speech? What's your gram?

Yeah, I see you doing the nose goes, but this is an audio podcast So I think I win by speed is I mean essentially Like you want the like the critical version or you want the like really? Just give the short of it an attempt to or philosophy that's that is trying to like Radically remember that there that you should not be worried about the things that are beyond your control I think it's probably a big part of it. Yeah, there's like an acceptance of the goodness and the badness of the universe or another way of phrasing it is like Things own anything that bothers you you have let bother you like like You are it's almost like a radical willpower like yeah, you've let if anything bothers you You have allowed it to bother you and you should just sort of accept the things that you can't control and then control the things that you can control That's pretty damn close. Yeah, you you are trying to live in tune with nature Yes, and to let go.

Yeah, let go the things that can't really hurt you and perception has a big So I'll give a little bit more of a throw thing But that's pretty much the gist of it right let go the things you can't really control Does he talk about like the types of things that we also associate with classical world like the four virtues wisdom just spruits temperates I don't feel like he ever really gets into that kind of they pop up But there's no systematic codification of these things and he doesn't bring up those four virtues very often He talks about justice and he talks about courage as good things, but he's not like here are the four This is the four right again. They're just reminders to himself. Here's how you be a just man. Okay So one thing we have to we have to know before we jump into stoicism is the logos we talked about the logos a lot on this podcast Since Graham just went Thomas.

I'm just not gonna be me Give me what logos is logos would be I mean I literally mean word right word speech, but it's like this underlying logic It's this underlying kind of like meaning or understanding to how the world works to I guess it'll depend on the context We're saying but yeah So to sort of give you a basic in logos and I'm taking some of this from the introduction to my version of Marcus Really is new translation with introduction by Gregory Hayes if you're looking for it. So and it's a great the introduction is awesome So I do recommend this one But the logos means essentially rational connected thought but it is a rational connected thought that pervades all things So in man it is the faculty of reason in the cosmos It is the rational principle that governs the organization of the universe right sort of animates everything the universe is rational It definitely makes sense that appears in man as as reason and it's also I think for the stoic almost like an animating fire Like there is sort of a force that is the logos like as modern people we talk about the laws of nature Yeah, and that's one way to talk about it But the laws of nature we talk about like gravity and like you know I don't know like a gestation of new life But the logos in the in the world of antiquity means that but then there's also it almost has like a metaphysical or supernatural element to it of like there is a there is a pervading logic of the natural way the laws of nature capital and like You know you should not be surprised if a wronged person feels like they have been wrong Right like you know that sort of idea of that is that would be like the natural the natural thing Yeah, and I think it involves when way back when they were sort of establishing this as a concept I think it also involves math, you know they were learning math They're like ah we're discovering the mind of God and the rational principles at the base of everything And so I got tied up into the logos to it Just think of it as like it is that unifying principle that runs and animates the universe And so it when it says you know in the beginning was the word in the word was God the word was with God I don't think they were talking about scriptures. They were talking about like Jesus is the rational principle that animates the universe That's what John is doing in the gospel He's saying that like hey classical world that idea that concept that you have of this of this logos that pervades all of the known universe isn't just an Isn't just like a Force or an energy. It's a person with a personality and it is a it is a knowable relational thing And it is that's who came down and dwelt with us.

Yeah So don't believe that that's not right you're not saying that Jesus is the logos No, they don't the logos is its own thing. So the introduction breaks it up into three basics three kind of basic attitudes And it's a pretty good like basic viewpoint of to use though system There are three things that you have to master your perception your action and your will your perception You must see things for exactly what they are and no more you don't want to attach a whole bunch of extra things to something If it doesn't need to be there Don't like yourself and and you can see something for what it is like your house may have burned down But what have you as a person actually lost house a house and nothing more right? Okay, your action you're gonna participate in the logos in nature and so accommodate yourself to its demands and requirements Which seems like according to Marcus Aurelius is to be unselfish and to act as part of a unified whole we'll get to that Sort of how he views things So with Marcus I was gonna read something about the logos, but I don't know well here I'll read this so all events are determined by the logos and follow an unbreaking chain of cause and effect Stoicism is thus from the outset a deterministic system that appears to leave no room for human free will or moral responsibility in reality The stories were reluctant to accept such an agreement and attempted to get around the difficulty by defining free will as a voluntary accommodation to what is in any case Inevitable according to this theory men is like a dog tied to a moving wagon if the dog refuses to run along with the wagon He will be dragged by it yet the choice remains is his the choice remains his to run or be dragged in the same way Humans are responsible for their choices and actions even though these have been anticipated by the logos and form part of its plan Even actions which appear to be and indeed are immoral or unjust advance the overall design which taken as a whole is harmonious and good They too are governed by the logos. Okay, we've more I want to run or be dragged.

That sounds terrible Well, the thing is I'm not even sure Marcus himself would kind of adhere to that it seems like throughout the entire thing He has this dichotomy between the divine spark that is in man Which is your humanity like your soul is not a material thing right? It sort of directs the body But it is not the body and it's its own thing. I think if you asked about human nature He would say that is the nature of your soul the body is largely a distraction to that right? It has wants it has needs you often get tied up in pleasures These things are a attraction from what your real humanity is doing and I think for Marcus to align yourself with nature is to align Yourself as much as possible with soul rather than body right?

There is that divine spark and that divine spark is part of the logos just as much as your body is I think tied up in the pleasure of this the realm of this coffee. Yeah, I leave it behind buddy I can't it's your your your marring your human nature. I what's can I just like give into the bodily pleasure? Just this one.

Okay, so I'm not sure he would have said like we have no choice But we might as well I think for Marcus like if we are going to adhere to nature then yeah We have to try to yearn as much for our natural human nature as we can which is spirit But again none of this is that specific He's actually sort of against what he holds logic dropping and he doesn't really dive into it that much These are just reminders to him about how to govern well and as far as I can tell he never sat down like codified this into a like Alright, let's write out every precept of this philosophy. No, not even close in fact He reiterated several things a bunch of times and as far as I can tell I've written down six things that I sort of see his themes These are not exhaustive. This is not official. I haven't you know gone back through and check these It's just like kind of the feeling I get as I would come out of stoic Rose So number one he's trying to remind himself not to fear death It is natural and not threatening and he says and when we die and it seems like Marcus is always has a little seed of doubt about The gods and what happens after he dies so he says either we're gonna go to the gods or we're gonna dissolve into nothing And if we're nothing that we don't feel bad if we're going to the gods and it's a good thing So there's nothing to fear and that like hey, don't fear death.

It's okay. It's okay. It's like almost that's a credit Yes, it is and one of them is the future in the past don't exist all you have is this one fleeting moment And when you die that's really all you lose is the one fleeting moment that you're in and that's not much Not a big deal and he's like he constantly reminds himself to think about the old dead emperors and they're legacy and the people who mourn them They're gone too. So why worry about my legacy and why if you're deaf like it's just constant number two I kind of like the fleeting moment me too.

Yeah, yeah number two people are the worst But they hurt themselves and not you so don't be mad It seems like he is constantly having to remind himself that yes They're all turds, but I can I can suffer a turd here and there and what I should do is teach them how they are going wrong without getting myself in a TIFF he's constantly having to remind himself. That means he's getting annoyed by people. Oh sure. Yeah, it seems like life at court often vexed him Number three Orient oneself away from concern other people think about you and instead do your civic duty with unselfish action So he's like don't get concerned about legacy or fame or what everyone else thinks or don't worry about all of that You have a job to do and it's to be unselfish and to work for the unity of the whole because that's what nature is That's logos So don't get wrapped up in everybody else and in legacy and in fame and all that praise and nonsense You don't want to know that even if I talk about you, it's not your concern So he's just reminding himself say separate from the will of the multitudes number four The universe is a flow of time all of which has been the same like it's just the same dang cycle over and over again Things change and then drop and die all we have is the present all we can lose is the present So don't stress it doesn't do anybody any good and don't yearn for temporal things So he just constantly reminding himself like this is all temporary.

We will all die It's not a big deal and it's the same thing over and over again. Nothing is new. So don't stress Do you think you just said you know don't stress and there's never done anybody any good? But don't you think a little bit of stress does you good?

Probably it doesn't be good sometimes any even under the like the definition like a baby who wants to develop and grow like if a baby Didn't stress out about life a baby would never strive to speak or to walk. I don't know I'm just saying there's something about like desire which is always been a little stuck in my crawl about about stoicism is that it casts a like a It looks at desire a scance and doesn't and thinks that does human desire is a is a bad thing But I often wonder if like if we really could cut out desire the way that they talk about Would that not we not have sort of these knock-on effects that would be good? Don't we want a little stress to grow our bodies need stress in order to get stronger I don't think Marcus would agree with you in that stoicism says no stress or no desire because he says clearly there are things I'm here to do I'm here to be unselfish to serve my fellow man to decouple myself from pleasures and to be good And so if you don't desire to be good, you're doing it wrong There's a couple quotes I will read today that are like well if you're having trouble like getting out of bed. Here's what you do So do you couple from all pleasure?

We'll get there. I love sauces. But the pleasure the pleasure you should get is from like I'm like food doing good for being a good person Okay, if those things are motivate you then you're doing something wrong And so I think he's saying move from stress to unstressed serene right action I know what I have to do. I know how to do it There's nothing that should perturb me while I do it if it goes wrong like it's probably something I can't control or it's something I can't I can get better right there's no reason to stress about it But there is reason to act and I think that that that's what he would say okay number five fine serenity And simplicity and according oneself with nature and with virtue number six only the soul can be good or bad and all is it Accordance with nature so things can happen to you But they're only good or bad if you feel that they are like anything outside of you is just Calamity it's just circumstance is how you react to it that makes it good or bad okay, so those are the six Don't be your death people are the worst orient yourself away from what other people think Universities of flow of time so freak out fine surrendering simplicity according yourself with nature and only the soul can be good But that's kind of what I see reiterated again and again and again Okay, you guys ready for quiz show do it because this is just sort of a collection of sayings and I desire to win quiz show It will give me pleasure so negative pointed off the bat.

Oh, it's a yeah, so it's So it's a question of phrases So I figure that the best way to do it is to read some of them and have these guys try to fill it in You're probably gonna get it wrong So I'm just gonna point to whoever I think got closest okay, right cuz getting it right is kind of tough. Yeah, okay So let me flip to my are you looking for a copy of a painting? I'm looking for some buzzer. Oh here before we get there I had a few things I could read that are sort of like a good summary of the things that he tells himself again again And involves that wake up in the morning one that I was talking about so when you wake up in the morning tell yourself The people I deal with today will be meddling ungrateful Arrogant dishonest jealous and surly and this is what follows right after he thanks everyone for making up who he was That's great They're like this because they can't tell good from evil But I have seen the beauty of good and the ugliness of evil and have recognized that the wrongdoer has a nature related to my own Not of the same blood or birth But of the same mind and possessing a share of the divine and so none of them can hurt me no one can implement Implicate me in ugliness nor can I feel angry at my relative or hate him We were born to work together like feet hands and eyes like the two rows of teeth upper and lower to obstruct each other is unnatural to feel Angry at someone to turn your back on him these are obstructions Whatever this is that I am it is flesh and a little spirit and intelligence throw away your books stop letting yourself be distracted That is not allowed instead if you were dying right now despise your flesh a mess of blood pieces of bone a woven tangle of nerves Vames and arteries consider what the spirit is air and never the same air But vomit it out and gulped in again every instant finally the intelligence think of it this way You're an old man stop allowing your mind to be a slave to be jerked about by selfish impulses to kick against fate and the present and to Mistrust the future Number three what is divine is full of providence even chance is not divorced from nature from the in weaving and Folding of things governed by providence everything proceeds from it and then there is necessity in the needs of the whole world of which You are apart whatever the nature of the whole does and whatever serves to maintain it is good for every part of nature The world is maintained by change and the elements and the things they compose that should be good enough for you To do an axiom discard your thirst for books so that you don't won't die in bitterness But in cheerfulness and truth grateful to the gods from the bottom of your heart.

Okay, that's a good like base Start yeah, I think okay Let's see I think I may have lost my first little Quote. Oh, there we go. Okay, so I'm gonna though you have to fill in the blank If you seek tranquility do blank Your duty do what is right do what is good both failures if you seek tranquility do less or accurately do what's essential So wait, what do you say what is natural? I said what is good?

I said your duty feels pretty close to essential. All right, I think point goes to grandma What the logos of a social being requires in the requisite way which brings a double satisfaction to do less better Because most of what they say and do is not essential if you can eliminate it You'll have more time and more tranquility ask yourself at every moment is this necessary? But we need to eliminate unnecessary assumptions as well to eliminate the unnecessary actions that follow Okay, well like go on a date do less those necessary dates. No, yes, of course or like I know like telling your kids you love them.

I guess that's necessary Yeah, and it's part of like unselfish action and it's helpful you know the whole he would say that absolutely do It would be like a necessary action Getting up and like farting around your phone. Yeah, yeah, probably it doesn't help anything doesn't help unify It doesn't help it's not unselfish. I think like he says pretty much we are put here for unselfish action That's what humans are made for So you're the rest of it. I did want to read an extra side one So in between little quizzes will have some others that I want to read this one just says there's nothing else than this number 28 character dark Womenish obstinate period wolf sheep child fool cheat buffoon salesman tyrant.

That's it. That's the whole entry I don't know what that means. It's a bad day. Yeah, he's just You may have had a little to drink that night.

You never know What's the stoic answer to someone that's like screw it. I'm gonna do bad things cuz I like it. I want to be bad He's saying you're denying you in nature, but I would what if I say like but it got me all this cash He'd say you are confused about what is good. I am sitting on a mountain of cocaine and I say little to my little friend like why you would say you're hurting yourself.

I'm not though You are that was cocaine. Yes, you are. I've seen that movie I guess so what we're gonna put the person what about what does this do? Exha to the person's like you and I both end up in the same place You can like deny yourself and do your own selfish action and I'm gonna like party you will have lived a less happy life And that's just like you will not be in accordance with nature and you'll be hurting yourself all time And then what if I was okay like then Then you would say you know what then there's that then let them go like they're confused Let him go do that and that is not out of sync with most of the old That meme of like the guy that's the corner and everyone's dancing around and having the party Yeah, like it feels like the guy the corner say like they're not active good at coordinates with nature And everyone's like me, it's so awesome, but I think again You're still like you're oversimplifying his position would mark us a really is celebrate if there was cause for celebration I think absolutely yeah, yeah Like what do you party if there was reason the party if there was a festival?

I don't know if you would I don't know if you would I feel like it's unnecessary. Yeah, I don't think that might be a no I think you guys are being a little too hard on here saying like I'm not saying that negatively It's just I think if you want to be ready by tickets to like, you know SEL like what he just want to go let me like let's just let's just go hard this weekend and go to Yeah Because he was he was devout and I think it would depend if it was like a festival to the gods who probably Yeah, I think I might take the no one but okay, number two second quiz if you have trouble getting out of bed tell yourself Oh, what is this is the part where you said don't go back to sleep, right? Like you take the first off of you and you get out of bed like If you don't want to get out of bed tell yourself You're gonna die one day. I think point goes to Thomas And done when you have trouble getting out of bed tell yourself I have to go to work as a human being What do I have to complain of if I'm going to do what I was born for the things I was brought into the world to do Or is this what I was created for to huddle into blankets and stay warm and then he argues himself here But it's nicer here So you were born to feel nice instead of doing things and experiencing them Do you see the plants the birds the ants and spiders and bees going about their individual tasks putting the world in order as best They can and you're not willing to do your job as a human being Why aren't you running to do what you're an a man's but we have to sleep sometime Agreed but nature set a limit on that as it did eating and drinking and you're over the limit You've had more than enough of that, but not of working you are still below your quota You don't love yourself enough or you love your nature to and what it demands of you people who love what they do Wear themselves down doing it or even forget to wash or eat Do you have a less respect for your own nature than the engraver does for engraving or the dancer for the dancer for money or the social Climate for status when they're really possessed by what they do They'd rather stop eating and sleeping than give up practicing their arts is helping others less valuable to you not worth your effort Look at one got a bed There's one right here that says no one could ever accuse you of being quick with it Well, right, but there are plenty of other things you can't claim you haven't got in you So he's just kind of encouraging himself because I think people call them dumb sometimes Okay quiz number one one one one one two one all Oh By the way, the answer you know that the obstacle is the way poster you have I think it's from our Really oh, I'm just having this relation you already knew this you just had the realization Yeah, I got my class.

It's What is in the way becomes the way something that which is yeah, it's an meditation. Yeah, so here's the quote I think it comes from but when they in a sense people are our proper occupation our job is to do them good and put up with them Right, yes, but when they obstruct our proper tasks They become irrelevant to us like son when the animals our actions may be imputed by them But there can be no impeding our intentions or disposition because we can accommodate and adapt the mind adapts and converts its own purposes Converts to its own purposes the obstacle to our acting the impediment to action advances action what stands in the way becomes the way Yes, yeah, it's where it comes from. Yeah, okay. Oh Where'd quiz three go?

I think some of my bookmarks have like slipped down. Oh here. We go. Okay.

Got it Don't be irritated at people's blank natures Attitudes I think Graham gets this one. Don't be irritated at people's smell or bad breath What's the point with that mouth with those armpits they're going to produce that odor argument? They have a brain can't they figure it out? Can't they recognize the problem?

So you have a brain as well good for you then use your logic to awaken his show him make him a realize it if you listen Then you've solved the problem without anger you stink like buddy. He's not bad. Oh, I find that entertaining. That's pretty funny Okay, the number four the best revenge is to not care succeed I Think point Graham the best revenge is to not be like that.

I'm on our own. I'll be like that Alright, hi guys. What's up? Great three three one.

I mean three one grams up. Okay, if you had a stepmother and a real mother You would pay your respects to your self Real mother I think I've got to tell us this one. It's a stepmother you pay your respects to your stepmother Yes, but it's your real mother you'd come home to theirness The court and philosophy keep returning to it to rest in its embrace It's all that makes the court and you Indurable so to him the court the court is like the stepmom yeah, and so philosophy is a real mother So pay your respects to court but keep on coming back to philosophy because it's the only thing that keeps the same Poor guy stuff. Sounds like life at court was not not his favorite not awesome.

I mean people got assassinated all the time Right, I think spend a bunch of time at war right during his life. That's I don't know how often he was at court Yeah, okay, this one's a triple three points available not not with one question Okay, okay, and you to write it is three to favorite gram. All right ambition means what? Suffering here.

I'll give you a little more of it And vision means time your blank to blank fate to the wind okay your heart to nature I Think Thomas cool for two points or just one ambition means time your well-being to what other people say or do Okay self-indulgence three-year self-indulgence means tying it to So I'm sorry the first one ambition It means time your well-being to what other people say or do and self-indulgence means tying it to Beast within Dying it to my desires. Yeah, oh Thomas Self-indulgence means tying it to the things that happen to you Say it means tying it to the logos Nature Thomas again, so it means tying it to your own actions. I think virtue makes more sense there than logos I'm supposed to have for three. Yes.

He does he is ahead now. Oh, no five three. I'm saying more than that Yeah, because there were multiple points back my friend Right, you know the ambitious Winning the game that we're all investing this time play We saw like eight more things about the bookmarks in there. Oh, yeah, we're on number seven of fifteen Oh, we got plenty of time.

I think this was the easiest way to like read a bunch of the more I wonder how to like do this book as an episode because you can't really summarize it like you group them into topics But it is literally just like thought thought thought yeah, and they're all disparate and all kind of disconnects There's no real thread through the mall. This is the second time we've done the meditations as an episode Did you do the meditation? No, it is not a meditation. No, I haven't read this before no, I think it was I've done the uncaring enough done so is something I don't know Yeah, this is the first time I was gonna share so I think this was the easiest and I tried to pick ones that were like funny and stood out Rather than him saying like time is a river like Over and over again.

I thought the one about bad smelling people especially funny So I picked out those ones are a little bit unique as best I can so you say it's five to three. Yeah, I am Okay, this one is seems to be a definition of kingship and I think he's quoting somebody because it's in quotes I'm not sure cool, but kingship colon is what? King ship is what it's a clever. It's a clever aphroism.

So you have to come up. I'll give you a second Kingship is kinship. Oh, I like that. That's so nice Okay, I don't have anything witty kingship is Something about the sort of damn it leaves like kingship is the threat over the over one's head I think I gotta give Graham this one.

Oh kingship to earn a bad reputation by good deeds Okay, I think this is We can do two on this one. I'm gonna throw in an extra one. Okay, five four I'm trying to figure out how to do this one in just a Yeah, I'll just read this one. It's hard to have a blank and have it make sense It was just think of yourself as blank and I was like oh, I'll think of yourself as dead You have lived your life.

I don't like it take what's left of the possible really properly day. I still point for me I'm sorry. I keep doing that. Okay.

This one. I think is him just reminding himself that demeanor. He should have not a dancer, but a Stick in the mud You do not like the stoics what is your deal? You try to party with snow before is that your issue?

Who the like a Sick of fan Manages the temple DJ Sticking the mud. No, I don't want to flick words in your mouth. I'm just you were saying a priest. Yeah, like more religious Roll all right.

We're gonna crowd sort like what do you guys think the answer is not a dancer but a wrestler? Not close to priest not close to stick in the mud. Yeah, no, I think we let's just Watch so not answer but a wrestler waited waiting poised and dug in for sudden assaults Like that Dog in waiting for some assaults. Yes, so is it good Graham?

I just need to by the end of this episode. I want to do except they're good things and so I actually like it No, no, so in my defense, I'm it's one of those things where it's like I'm being cranky because I respect it a lot Okay, I really like stoicism But the people who are bad not but the like the deficiencies Like it is way better than like living a life of sort of hedonistic pleasure for sure Yeah, but it is missing it feels like it is missing a little like Jwadaviv like it feels like it is missing a little bit of Like I like Chesterton more than I like Marcus really sure because Chesterton. There's a little like you know, I don't know Like okay, we We're too early for this Too early to get this conversation. Let's say for the end of the episode.

We can have maybe between We can have the conversations. Okay, well, I want to get through the quiz first I don't even mean that doesn't mean anything to win and I shouldn't I don't know what this course is right now. What where did I ever say anything about not enjoying? No, you not you.

I should still okay. Yeah, that's fair. I should only control the answers I gave I shouldn't care about what I'm right Okay, there are three points of yellow for this one great. It is not a three question thing But there are three things that he lists so you can't give your list and I'll give the program.

Why thank you Perfection of character is that you use a little colon perspective character colon to live your last day every day without These three things It's a list of three things. Mm-hmm. That's perfection of character Concerned for the opinions of others without Malice without election without vice I was gonna say Complaining Like trumpeting your your virtues like like self self Marketing yourself and Profession of character not complaining not not pumping your own tires and not Worrying about outcomes. It's a great a gram, right?

I think so they're so similar. They're so close. Okay. What were you three again?

I don't remember you don't read the game. Okay, so I gave you one point Thomas because you're like concerned What other people think about you? I think I close to one so the three things are frenzy sloth and pretense So consider people think of you. I think that's a point Thomas.

Yeah I'm from Graham you also had that right not pumping your own tires. That would be pretense that's easy win for you I think you also said sloth which is really close to what you said which was complaining. Yeah, I'll give you that point there I'm doing lots of things and then frenzy. What was your third thing?

It was like self-marketing or complaining and Carrying about outcomes. So not caring about outcomes was kind of a lot. I like it's close to frenzy I feel like that's worth a point. I feel like that's close enough.

So sweeping the gram gram gets all three for that one to climb ahead by One point. He's one neck and neck and neck and two three four five six seven. Let's see one two three four five six seven for Graham And then six for Thomas. Okay, so far so good gents Okay, you can hold your breath until you turn blue but Don't you can't change the mind of others Tom Thomas gets that one mom you can hold your breath into turn blue But they'll still go on doing it.

That's right. Yep. That's a very easy one for Thomas. I did up Okay Number 11 he says we have three relationships.

What are those relationships each person has three relationships He just goes three relationships colon. I want to see that's another three pointer So what are the three relationships that man has to act in accordance with nature? It's three relationships. Mm-hmm.

You're three relationships Is it I was thinking the target of those relationships interesting. No, I'm here here's I say your relationships are acting in accordance of nature to Not complain about people came before you Am I I way off? I'm even no clues Or you because my three relationships are like with myself with other men with the gods, right? Those are Thomas's my relationships are the relationship to act in accordance with nature What do they say to not care about those who came before you and to Not lie to yourself those are my reality.

Okay, so relationship with self honesty to self Duty to nature and not caring about other people. Okay, so honestly self-duty nature and not caring with other people About other people Thomas very clearly gets all three points You'll have to help me whether you get them. So he says the three relationships number one with the body you inhabit Yeah, so to not does that does not do not lie to yourself does that count for granted zero points? With the divine the cause and all things Everything and all things and number three with the people around you So your body the divine and people and Thomas listed I think all three other men and the gods So he had all three of those pretty solid as a tech bro.

I was prepared for this episode. I don't care He swept the last three pointers. This is all good Okay, I like this one You want praise from people who blank themselves every 50 every 15 minutes the approval of people who despise themselves is a sign of Self-respect to regret nearly everything you do so you want praise from people who blank themselves every 15 minutes The approval of people who despise themselves is a sign of self-respect to regret nearly everything you do Contradict doubt themselves Kick neither get the point people who kick themselves every 15 minutes. That's a very strange tick for someone to have I want to know more about these people you talking about.

I mean like you know you say something like ah yeah crap So dumb thing yeah, okay We are coming up on the end here In case in case for less than 30 people 10 to 7 okay in favor of Thomas rock and roll. Let's go luckily Graham I think I think you've got you got three points here you can get it and there's one that has a two part of it Okay, I gotta run the board though number 13 nothing you care okay Today I escaped from blank or no I discarded it because it was within me in my own perception not outside care Laziness point Graham That's good. Let's go the answer is anxiety anxiety today. I escaped my anxiety or no I discarded because it was within me in my own perception not outside so when he's just like you know what I'm done stop it Yeah, I'm stopping anxious.

It's not it's not a real thing okay, two left eight to ten favor of Thomas. He's gonna get this I Believe stop whatever you're doing for a moment and ask yourself am I afraid of death because I won't be able to do blank anymore Can you read the first part stop whatever you're doing for a moment and ask yourself am I afraid of death because I won't be able to do blank anymore? It's not just this like because it starts with he's doing something and you stop so I can't do this anymore Yeah, that was also me. I'm sorry the present thing word for word nice job gentlemen point point for each the answer is this okay cool Well, so stop what are you doing for a moment ask yourself am I afraid of death because I won't be able to do this anymore?

I have that when I'm grading papers what I'm sort of longing for death Am I scared because I won't be able to grade papers anymore, okay, this is just a No, I mean I was a thing that we were all right. There was a I mean right now. It's 11 to 9 in favor at Thomas Yeah, there's one more but it has two points You could tie it or Thomas could win there are a few but I'm gonna keep the suspense high because if you already I'm okay, this one I have I've titled death of a school teacher 36 it doesn't matter how good a life you've led there's there'll still be people standing around the bed who will welcome the sad event I'm glad you're dead even with the intelligent and good won't there be someone thinking finally to be through a Fattled school teacher even though he never said anything you could always feel him judging you and I imagine this is how our students will stand around our And that's for a good man How many traits do you have that would make a lot of people glad to be rid of you remember that when the time comes You'll be less reluctant to leave if you can tell yourself This is the sort of life I'm leaving even the people around me the ones I spent so much time fighting for praying over caring about even they want me gone In hopes that will make their own lives easier How could anyone stand stand a longer stay here and yet don't leave angry with them be true to who you are caring sympathetic and kind But not as if you were being torn away from life But the way it is when someone dies peacefully how the soul is released from the body That's how you should leave them it was nature that bound you to them that tie the knot and nature now unties you I'm released from those around me not dragged against my will but unresisting there are things that nature demands and this is one of them So it's kind of a nice little thing, but I read the school teacher bit and I was like oop that sounds like my death Okay, this one's called someone despises me The pages cut in a weird way or have you folded either dog earring like a thousand things Yeah, well I dog eard anyone that seemed interesting and then before the podcast I ran back through it found the one Sort of stood out from the rest of the crowd. Yeah, okay someone despises me.

That's their problem Mine not to do or say anything despicable someone hates me their problem mine to be patient and cheerful with everyone Including them ready to show them their mistake not spitefully or to show off my own self-control But in an honest upright way like focion if he wasn't just pretending That's what we should be like inside and never let the gods catch us feeling anger or resentment as long as you do It's proper to your nature and accept that the world's name Except what the world's nature has in store as long as you work for others is good by any and all means What is there that can harm you? It's kind of nice. Okay, this one I really like the despicable phoniness of people who say listen I'm gonna level with you here. What does that mean?

It shouldn't even be need to be said it should be obvious written block letters on your Forehead it should be audible in your voice visible in your eyes like a lover who looks in your face and takes in the whole story at a Glance a straightforward honest person should be like someone who stinks when you're in the same room with them You know it, but false straightforwardness is like a knife in the back false friendship is the whoa and then I Yeah false friendship is the worst of what it at all costs if you're honest and straightforward and meanwhile it'll show in your eyes It should be unmistakable. So the whole I just really liked the listen on a level with you here What does that mean? I love that bit. Okay, and then I had one more Okay, here's an entry.

I don't fully understand because that's the question one or is not not quiz show one Yeah, one more before we show okay, the town mouse and the country mouse dress and agitation of the town mouse It's a self-fable right? I think it's is it yeah the one about there's the there's a mouth that lives in the big city in the Mouse that lives in the country the town mouse goes out to the country and you know the pleasures are simple But it's still an enjoyable time. There's no stress or anxiety You think you know it's a pleasant trip It's not fancy country mouse goes to the town and it's like they eat really well But they're they could died any minute because if they get caught they're gonna get killed by the by the house that they're in And so I think the lesson is supposed to it's like you know They're different types of wealth and it's better to be the country mouse than the town mouse Yeah, and the town mouse has the stress and agitation. It's like what's the country mouse does not oh?

It's one of the eight-suff labels. Oh, that's great. Yeah, that's great. Yeah, that's right up Yeah, okay last question one with a possible tiebreaker if Graham gets both of these wins I think we would tie it at that point right you would which is why I would bring a title Oh, okay stupidity is expecting blank in winter or blank in old age those are two different words Stupidity is expecting blank in winter or blank in old age fruit in winter and like Love making an old age Winter and I don't even vigor in old age.

I'll give me a little more a little more graphic with mine I think both go to great Stupidity is expecting figs in winter or children This is the world big random page and let's figure it out Okay, man, all right, maybe this one if you if I don't do you can actually get who this quote is from because he's quoting someone else Yeah, no thefts of free will reported by blank he has recorded that as like a little quote He needs to remember and then he's put the author right next to it So number 36 or like a book 11 36 no thefts of free will reported basically no one can feel your free will I am I was trying to think of what play right? Who's the guy did last time he did disclose is that my nander who was it the answer is epic teetis I always think it's after Marcus really is okay. Let's see if I find another one that we can throw in here There's a lot that's repetitive here. Um, we could just talk We're all winners, you know, we're all losers.

Oh, okay We're all losers read and cared about the game. No, I mean I'm trying to like put towards my like allergic reaction to it Okay, yeah, we can call that quiz show done. Yeah, I we can carry the quiz show into other elements areas of our life We're gonna compete another Okay, I will say that the very first section book one where he thanks everyone If if you're looking to like bring up a kid on how to act well, it's a pretty good codification of hey This is just good behavior So I'll read just the first few so from my grandfather various character and self-control from my father integrity and manliness from my mother Her reverence for the divine her generosity her inability not only to do wrong But even to conceive of doing it and the simple way she lived not the least like the rich My great granddad to avoid the public schools to hire good private teachers and to accept the resulting costs as money well spent My first teacher not to support this side or that and cheer you're racing this fighter or that in the games To put up with discomfort and not make demands through my own work on my own business and have no time for slanders From diognitis diognitis not to waste time on nonsense Not to be taken in by conjurers and who do artists and they're talking about incantations and exorcism and all the rest of it Not to be obsessed with quail fighting or other crazes like that to hear unwelcome truths quail fighting I'm awesome. I'm getting obsessed with quail fighting.

Oh, can you imagine having like your quail? To practice philosophy and to study with back yes and then with Tandyus and Marcinus to write dialogues as a student to choose the Greek lifestyle The camp bed and the cloak from rusticus the recognition that I needed to train my character and discipline not to be sidetracked by my interest in rhetoric Not to write treatises and abstract questions to deliver moralizing little sermons or compose imaginary descriptions of the simple life for the man who lives only for others It's dear clear of oratory poetry and Bell's letters So it's just like kind of how what made him himself Which I appreciate it's a good little sort of here's here's the makeup of a good man and here's how I was put together Interesting. Yeah, so is it a good read? Yes despite my like talking cheek nature The markets really is a book is very good the and all those like the virtues of stoicism are good like not letting other people Control you in terms of your emotions.

Yeah, that phrase of like you can hold your breath into your balloon of faith But they will people still keep on doing it. They'll keep on doing it caring about duty and responsibility and The steadiness of mine and whatever he called his grant the virtues he talked about his grandfather work I can't remember what you said, but as you read it. I was like, yes, these are good things the maybe the quib the thing that I often wonder about stoics is By can you get to the place where you have so? Disregarded how other people can affect you that it actually limits your ability to like really enter into the human Congress the real Radical like or the the real love that is required in like in family life So for example, like you know, this is where this is coming from the Roman Empire This is coming from a a Roman family structure that does not but it looks quite different than what we modern people look at as families like like the The the relationship between husband and wife and even fathers and children are not the kinds of relationships that we would recognize as sort of like the modern Western nuclear family, so I often wonder if the Stoics are if one of their sort of blind spots is like Almost treating everybody like enjoy the good when you if you can get it But in reality like you're kind of on your own kid and deal with and sort of accept that and deal with it I think there's a lot of really goodness a lot of good to that But I often get the sense that the true stoic is often like has a hard time or it doesn't believe that like authentic or isn't Italian friendship can exist or that like the real joining of two people in in self-sacrificing love can ever exist or even Should be something that you work towards because you're only just gonna be disappointed in the end like I'm with you I'm with you.

I've stopped where over time, but There is even a spot where he remembers somebody else saying that when you kiss your son good night You should say he may die tomorrow, right? Which is probably not a healthy way to say good night to your kid What if he hears that that's not great. You're reminding yourself to not get too attached. That seems busted So how should you read this?

I think it's great stuff to contemplate and you shouldn't just read it straight through like I did Or read three a day and sort of contemplate those things see where they fit in your life It's a great little sort of morning tradition because a lot of it is just urging you towards good works kindness openness not getting angry Taking things as they come a lot of it is really really good And I do think I'm with Graham and that I think they're pitfall stoicism But a lot of it's pretty solid And so if you read like if you want to read this as sort of a daily reminder to be good and not get frustrated with people into Taking things as they come. I think that's great. Anyway, I liked it It was fun read there's a few of those I would probably commit to memory smelly one is probably my favorite But yeah, there you go. That's Marcus really awesome.

Well, this has been classical stuff You should know with Graham Thomas and AJ and we are not going to let anything you email us disrupt our Zen No, not as in our chill or stoic or so and no are already now are duty to know to Logos and nature, but you can email us at the guys at classical stuff net you can patronize us on patreon We're in we have monthly amaze and a chat that we chat in yeah And after the summer AJ and I will have posted a bunch of stuff from a trip that we're taking together to England Yep, and you know we sort of have big plans for the more content in the patreon And you can find us on Twitter where I will sometimes like things you tweet Reel active and besides that but thank you for listening and we will catch you next week. Bye. She's bye

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Classical Stuff You Should Know?

This episode is 1 hour and 6 minutes long.

When was this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode published?

This episode was published on April 22, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Classical Stuff You Should Know episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.