*28.2 Makkos Daf 18 B (15 lines before spreads)*

*28.2 Makkos Daf 18 B (15 lines before spreads)*Rabbi Elazar quoting Rabbi Hoshaya: Placing the _bikkurim_ in the _beis hamikdash_ permits it for the kohen’s consumption, not reading the _parsha._*Summary**Rabbi Acha bar Yaakov* repeated the statement of “Rabbi Elazar quoting Rabbi Hoshaya” but he credited it to *“Rabbi Asi quoting Rabbi Yochanan”**Rabbi Acha bar Yaakov: Challenge:* This contradicts another statement by Rabbi Yochanan.*Rabbi Asi to Rabbi Yochanan:* When may _bikkurim_ be eaten by _kohanim?_*Rabbi Yochanan:* If it was separated before Sukkos, *from the reading.* After Sukkos; *from when it was placed* in the _beis hamikdash._Above he said, Reading is not what permits the _bikkurim,_ and yet here he says that it is. Above he said that Placing is what permits the _bikkurim,_ and yet here he says that it is not?*Resolution:* When Rabbi Yochanan says that it depends on the Reading, he is expounding *according to Rabbi Shimon* (26.3). When he says it does not depend on the Reading *he is following the Rabbanan* (26.3).When he says it does not depend on the Placing he is expounding *according to Rabbi Yehuda* _(in the following beraisa)._ When he says that it depends on the Placing, *he is following the Rabbanan.**Beraisa: Rabbi Yehuda: _“V’hinachto”_ refers to _tenufah,_* there is another possuk that states _“v’hinicho”_ which refers to Placing. _[If there were two pessukim that mentioned Placing, it would be a necessary part of the Bikkurim process.]_*Question: Who are the Rabbanan* who argue against this?*Answer: Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov:**Beraisa: Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov: _“V’lakach hakohen”_ refers to _tenufah_* _[not v’hinachto, thus it refers to Placing, and we have two pessukim that require Placing]._ See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate