EPISODE · Nov 28, 2022 · 38 MIN
284: Should we redraw state lines?
from Beer and Conversation with Pigweed and Crowhill · host Pigweed and Crowhill
The boys drink and review a 2-year-old bottle of Raison D'Extra, then discuss proposals to redraw state boundaries. They start off with a review of federalism, and the idea that the country is a collection of states, not simply a mass of people, which is why tiny Rhode Island and sparsely populated Montana get as many senators as California. What happens when residents of a state feel they don't fit in that state? The idea is being tested in Oregon, where the conservative, agricultural residents of the majority of the state differ drastically from the urban liberals in Portland. They'd rather join up with Idaho. A similar thing is going on in Maryland, where the conservative eastern and western ends of the state don't feel represented by the liberals in Annapolis. But where does this end? Do county lines need to be redrawn? City lines? Neighborhoods? The solution is not to keep redrawing lines, but to respect minority rights and making most political issues as local as possible.
What this episode covers
The boys drink and review a 2-year-old bottle of Raison D'Extra, then discuss proposals to redraw state boundaries. They start off with a review of federalism, and the idea that the country is a collection of states, not simply a mass of people, which is why tiny Rhode Island and sparsely populated Montana get as many senators as California. What happens when residents of a state feel they don't fit in that state? The idea is being tested in Oregon, where the conservative, agricultural residents of the majority of the state differ drastically from the urban liberals in Portland. They'd rather join up with Idaho. A similar thing is going on in Maryland, where the conservative eastern and western ends of the state don't feel represented by the liberals in Annapolis. But where does this end? Do county lines need to be redrawn? City lines? Neighborhoods? The solution is not to keep redrawing lines, but to respect minority rights and making most political issues as local as possible.
NOW PLAYING
284: Should we redraw state lines?
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Mar 19, 2026 ·34m
Feb 18, 2026 ·11m
Feb 11, 2026 ·45m