Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. How you doing, Uri? Pretty good. I saw that LeBron is going to the Lakers. Have you been following this intensely? No, not at all. So basically, he had the option to opt out of his last year of his contract. And I think a lot of people were suspecting after a few years of losing the finals that he was going to leave the Cavs and head to a new team. And he chose the Lakers, which is a pretty big deal because now the West Coast...
as it is, was kind of oversaturated with the good teams. And now the Lakers are just going to be thrown suddenly into the top tier. But maybe that means, you know, the East Coast, there's an opening. Maybe the Knicks are going to move up, you know? Maybe this is going to be our year. So LeBron's only motivation is he wants to go to the team where he has the highest chance of winning the championship? So I think there's a couple things. He wants to win the championship, but you can't just join an amazing team because then you look like a sellout, you know, like you're just joining. Like he also kind of has to prove himself. But there's also a lot of nice things about, you know, LA. Have you been to LA, Erie? I've been there, yeah. I mean, it's a beautiful city. It's nice all year round. So, you know, it's an exciting thing for him. Yeah, I was listening to an interesting podcast by Malcolm Gladwell
whole thing where he was talking about how his philosophy is that he roots for the front runner. He doesn't root for the underdog. And he gives a whole explanation of why that is. It was very interesting. Yeah. So you can refer to that podcast for his reasoning on it. But I found that he, I mean, it's classic Malcolm Gladwell to be counterintuitive, but I guess he might become like, I remember thinking about that when I was young. Like it was like something that people always sort of made fun of. And I'm always like,
I mean, I see the appeal, you know. Of what? Rooting for the best team, you know. Yeah, why not? One of the things I forgot to tell you, I think you'd like this. When LeBron was sort of making his decision, obviously people kept checking all of his social media, see if he's posting anything, any hints to anything. And the day that basically, or maybe it was the day before the decision was announced, he was like cliff diving, or I don't even know if it's called cliff diving, but he was jumping off like a, you know, a small thing into water, like on vacation maybe in the Caribbean with his family. And there's a video that he posted, like, oh, you guys didn't believe me that I really did it, but like, here it is. And in it, he's like pumping himself up to get ready to jump. He's clearly a little scared. Everyone's laughing. And right before he jumps, he screams, black excellence.
And then he jumps off and jumps into the water. And I just thought that was such a fascinating thing. It feels like a little bit like, you know, scoring a goal. And it's like, ah, I'm sorry. Like something like that. Like you're connecting this like tiny minuscule thing that you feel like a bravery or a pride in. That's what brings some strength. Yeah, there was something so interesting about that. I thought that was really cool. Yeah, that is pretty interesting. And I guess relates to the concept of tribalism and group identity, which definitely connects to today's topic. Yeah. All right. Let's get into it.
The group If Not Now describes itself as, quote, a movement led by young American Jews to end our community's support for the Israeli occupation. The name comes from the famous statement by Hillel the Elder, If I am not for myself, who is for me? And being for my own self, what am I? And if not now, when? On their website, they tell the story of the group's founding. During the violence of Operation Protective Edge in 2014, young Jews, angered by the overwhelmingly hawkish response of American Jewish institutions, came together under the banner of If Not Now to demonstrate their resistance through the beauty of Jewish ritual. Moved to act by moral anguish and inspired by Hillel's three questions, they organized mourners' kaddish actions in nearly a dozen cities across the country and lamented the loss of both Israeli and Palestinian life. They had three demands. Stop the war on Gaza, end the occupation, and freedom and dignity for all. In 2017, If Not Now organized a large protest outside the annual AIPAC conference in Washington, D.C.
This year, If Not Now focused first on Jewish summer camps, specifically Camp Ramah, with their Hashtag You Never Told Me campaign, in which former campers and staff members of Camp Ramah protested the fact that in all their years of Israel education at Camp Ramah, they were never told about Israel's occupation and oppression of the Palestinians. Their latest campaign is entitled Hashtag Not Just a Free Trip, so they're clearly good at social media and branding and hashtagging. This campaign is directed against Birthright. The tweet announcing the launching of the campaign stated, If Not Now launches Hashtag Not Just a Free Trip campaign pressuring Birthright to tell the truth about the Israeli occupation to its 40,000 young Jewish participants this summer. I just paused to say 40,000 Jewish kids in one summer. That's crazy. It's ridiculous. In the spirit of this campaign, If Not Now made headlines in Jewish media in the last couple of weeks. First, when they set up a table in JFK Airport to spread their message to young people about to embark on birthright trips. And then last week, when five women with ties to If Not Now publicly walked off a birthright trip in Israel in order to join the group Breaking the Silence with a tour of the Israeli occupation focusing on the city of Hebron. If Not Now is made up mostly of American Jewish millennials. And unlike other leftist groups like J Street, whose motto is pro-Israel, pro-peace, If Not Now does not take a stance on Zionism, Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state, or the BDS movement.
Although many If Not Now activists are also very involved with the BTS movement. So Rivki, what do you make of If Not Now? Do you think they're doing good work? So obviously, there's more nuance to any sort of answer. Besides for, they're doing great work, they're amazing. Overall positive or overall negative? Overall mixed, right? I mean, would I join If Not Now? No, I don't feel super comfortable with many of the things they espouse. But are they doing good work? Honestly, it's hard to say, right? They're radicals. They're purposely choosing to be completely confrontational and argumentative and espousing things that are way, way outside sort of like the normative view. But often...
radicals change the conversation. Even if I don't agree with their message, do I think that there's a value to radicals moving things slightly in one direction, even if I don't want it to move all the way to the extreme that they might want it? Yeah, I do think there is sort of value in that. I would say the biggest problem with If Not Now, even putting their ideology aside, is the fact that they don't have any sort of endgame. Like I said at the end of that introduction, unlike J Street, who calls to end occupation also, but then they call for a two-state solution, and that's the end.
what they see could be the end of the conflict, if not now, doesn't engage with that, doesn't get into that. They just say, and the occupation, that's all we care about. And almost like they don't care what happens afterwards or maybe they don't want to say what they want because they don't think it'll help their current, I don't know why. I don't think so. To me, it feels like when, if someone said to me sort of like, what is if not now's ultimate goal? It's really hard to say if not now. I would imagine there's two things. First of all, I think,
Education. I think there are a lot of American Jews, according to If Not Now, there are a lot of American Jews who kind of have this blind support for Israel, and If Not Now is trying to sort of shake them out of their stupor and say it is a bad thing morally for the entirety of American Jewry to just support Israel blindly. That, I think, is thing number one. And thing number two, which is, I think, a little bit simpler, is, yeah, they don't have maybe a 50-year strategy, but what they want is end the occupation. It's a moral travesty, and this is their sort of fundamental argument. No, of course they do not have sort of a 200-page memo to deliver to the prime minister. It's an advocacy group, right? The problem is if they want to be taken seriously by mainstream Jewish institutions like Camp Ramah, with which they've engaged directly, not having any sort of vision.
What's AIPAC's vision? Two-state solution. AIPAC doesn't have a vision of two-state solution. AIPAC's vision is to support the state of Israel. But at this year's conference, the president of AIPAC did speak positively of the two-state solution. But I'm saying AIPAC, in sort of a similar way to If Not Now, is sort of decentralized. And they say, look, we have these sort of general goals, but we don't have specific policy goals. No, I don't think it's the same thing. Of course not the same thing. So If Not Now's main focus, first of all, to answer my question, I think the answer is they don't have a unified vision. If you asked 10 different individuals, you might get 10 different answers. Like AIPAC.
Okay, fine. Or like the Israeli government. That in itself doesn't make them illegitimate. I agree. But I think their main focus is on education, right? They're focusing on camps where a lot of Jewish education happens, especially related to Israel and Zionism. And now they're also focusing on birthright, where also obviously a lot of education happens for many young Jews who have never been exposed to Israel. And even though birthright is obviously older kids, or not even kids, even though birthright is adults, it's their first exposure to, many of them, to Israel or Jewish education. So there's a sort of a similarity between kids in their first formative years as teenagers.
The first few years of education are critical no matter how old you are. So I guess we usually start our episodes with some kind of disclaimer. This one, I think, might be one that we don't have to disclaim as much because we are both Jewish. We are both millennials. And we've actually also both staffed birthright trips. So I think we're pretty qualified to talk about that topic. So I want to ask you, Rivki, because there was a video that was posted. I think it's been taken down because it wasn't working when I tried to watch it today. But these five women who walked off their birthright trip, one of them was filming the whole thing. It was like a half hour video. And so the kind of ringleader of the group got up on the bus.
and kind of announced to the whole group and to the tour guide why they were leaving and what their problem was. And among other things, her basic message seemed to be saying that they were not told about the occupation on the trip, and that the trip and the tour guide were biased and one-sided. So to say that Birthright is biased is obvious. Of course they're biased. It's a Jewish group, and their whole mission is to instill Jewish values and Zionism into these mostly unaffiliated young Jews. So to use...
That, as a criticism, makes the whole thing very confusing. And how do you understand that? How do you understand their goal? Do you think they think that birthright is a nice thing, but they should just talk a little bit more about the occupation? Or are they really saying this whole concept is wrong? So to me, that's not so confusing because, you know, similar to other conversations we've had in the past, I believe that the more education, the better. I don't believe that education gets in the place of love or that masking things or trying to whitewash things creates anything that's better or stronger, the outcome that they maybe would prefer. I think that, yes, birthright does give a positive spin on Israel, gives a positive spin on Judaism. And I understand what you're saying that, you know, to a certain extent.
have goals, they have values, and that's what they're trying to put across. But what I think, if not now, is saying pretty clearly, and I really agree with this point, is to give a fuller, more nuanced perspective doesn't mean that people are going to say, oh, wow, now that I realize this, Israel's a piece of crap, and Judaism's disgusting, and I want to get away from it. Okay, I mean, I think that's fair, but that brings me to another point of why I have very little respect for this group. I find them to be extremely disingenuous, because they claim that the right-wing groups are oversimplifying the situation. They are oversimplifying just as much, if not more. So I, myself, and you also, but I staffed three birthright trips.
On all three of the trips, the conflict was brought up, the occupation was brought up. And on one of the trips specifically, we discussed this in our episode on birthright, we actually went to the West Bank and we heard from this group that has Jewish settlers and Palestinians together in dialogue. And we heard from a Palestinian who gave us the Palestinian narrative. He was not a Zionist by any stretch of the imagination. And we engaged with him. We asked him questions. And it was extremely interesting to me to hear that. And I thought it was very impressive of birthright for bringing us there. And so now to hear these people saying that birthright as a rule does not...
tell you about anything about the Palestinians, nothing about the occupation. First of all, it's just a lie. I'm not saying every trip does that because I haven't been on every trip. I don't know. But to say across the board that that's what it is, black and white, is a lie. Sure. And so they're being dishonest about what birthright is and not to mention the fact that if not now says nothing about terrorism, nothing about Israel's security concerns, nothing about the oppression that the Palestinians are subjected to by their own leadership, and they don't even give lip service to Israel's right to exist. So if this group of young Jews can't even state that they're in favor of Israel's right to exist, why should they be given any say in influencing the way Jewish youth are educated about Israel? I don't disagree with you. I think obviously the world is more nuanced than left-wing groups or right-wing groups give to it. And I completely agree that they...
What they are doing is propaganda in another form. And I think that birthright trip that you went on is incredibly cool. But, I mean, I did two birthright trips. You did three birthright trips. So it sounds like one in five met with a Palestinian. Okay. Obviously, we can't, maybe every trip that besides for those four. Did your trips discuss the occupation? My trips did not discuss the occupation. Not once? Not once. They didn't use that word? I don't know what to tell you. I mean, I don't remember, obviously, and I couldn't play back the tapes, but I don't remember that being a discussion because I remember feeling a little bit uncomfortable about it. You didn't get a presentation of this is the conflict and here is what the Palestinians will tell you? My trips were not political. No, it wasn't even here's what they're going to tell you and here's why they're wrong. They weren't political because that's not what they were trying to do. But I would say even beyond that, I can
I had 12 years in Jewish day school, two years in Israel for the year. I did a JNF trip. I did Hasbroff fellowships, which is a trip run through Esha Torah, though it's totally not or superficially not meant to be religious at all, but also a trip that gives you sort of Israel advocacy skills. And I was involved in Hillel for four years in college. I would say that of all of those experiences, I learned very little Jewish education that did not feel like propaganda. Do you disagree? Do you think you had a different experience? Do you think you had a more nuanced experience in your Jewish education?
I know that sounded like I'm being sarcastic, but I'm genuinely asking. I think we probably had mostly similar experiences in our youth and growing up in education and stuff like that. I think the word propaganda is used as a harsh criticism. It's used so unfairly because what they're saying and their message and their website is just as much propaganda as anything else. Of course our education was propaganda. We were taught to love Judaism and to love Israel. If you want to call that propaganda, then fine. But I find it really sad and scary that so many young Jews now see the concept of Jewish institutions teaching Jewishly to be such a problem. To say it's propaganda and therefore it's bad, I think is a ridiculous argument.
Right. Just thinking about thinking about our childhood. Right. Forget about Israel for a second. I grew up, you know, in New Jersey. I went to school studying American history. OK. In my social studies class, my history classes, I learned an overall pretty positive view of America, but definitely with some nuance. Right. You learned about slavery. Right. You learned about Native Americans and obviously the painful history there. You got a portrait of America that showed a lot of the positive, but also showed the negative. And overall, you it didn't make us I don't think it made me less patriotic to learn a more nuanced view. As I grew older and as sort of teachers and schools are able to sort of give you a more and more nuanced view, I definitely think you got a more nuanced view in 10th grade than you did in fourth grade.
because I think that's pretty natural. It's just easier for older people to digest more and to see that nuance and to continue to love through that nuance. I do not think that it... made me more angry or, you know, maybe it didn't make me more angry, but I don't think that it made me hate America. I don't think it made me feel like, oh, I don't want this to be part of my identity because it's too confusing because there's too much negative and therefore I don't feel like I can affiliate with it. It seems to me that our Jewish education and birthright and Hasbara and all these organizations, there's a fear and maybe you disagree with this, but there's a fear that if we learn about these sort of unsavory things, then we'll just want to disassociate from it and we won't feel like connected to it. We won't feel like that's our family. We won't feel like that's our birthright in the same way. Okay, you know what? First of all, I think the American thing is its own topic and I agree that it's important to be exposed to those things, but there are many people, if you're not one of them, then fine, but there
America because of all of its past sins and actions. Even if that's true, to say that we shouldn't talk about it, which I'm not saying that's what you're saying. You know what, Rivki? Israel is the only sovereign nation in the entire world that has to continually make a case for its existence. And that makes Israel unique among a million other reasons why it's unique. And therefore, it doesn't really work to make comparisons to America or to any other country in the way that it is taught. For example, when we're taught about Israel, I'm pretty sure, I know I was, and I'm assuming you were also taught that there were actually Arabs in the land beforehand. And some of them fled, some of them maybe were kicked out. But we were told that that was all for a good purpose for us to have our homeland. So the facts are all there. What we weren't told is that in their perspective... I definitely was not told that Arabs were kicked out. I was definitely...
that Arabs chose to leave. Either Arab leadership told them to leave or Arabs themselves made the decision to flee because they were scared. I don't think, maybe until I was 22, 23, that there were Arabs were kicked out. We don't have to get into the specifics, but it's not so clear. There's no numbers. These are the numbers that were kicked out. These are the numbers that were fled. These numbers that were told to flee. Okay, fine. It's important, though, because that comes down to perspective and nuance. It's not about cold, hard facts that were just hidden from us. So what we weren't told was the attitude and the philosophy of the Palestinians, which is that Israel shouldn't exist and that the Jewish people have no right to Israel. I don't think that...
idea has to be instilled in Jewish youth who are so at risk, especially in America, of intermarriage and assimilation. I don't think Jewish institutions have an obligation to tell them, by the way, we might not be correct in our country of Israel. See, I don't think that's true, though. To me, that feels like we're scared of the truth. We're scared that if people knew the truth, they would marry non-Jews. Why is that the truth? It's not the truth that the Jewish people don't deserve Israel. But I'm not saying that what Frisch didn't teach me was that Jews don't deserve Israel and that Frisch erred in that. I'm saying Frisch oversimplified it, and yes, if not now, also oversimplifies things. I'm saying Frisch should have taught me nuance, and Frisch failed in educating me by assuming that...
I was too naive and I would be too easily swayed away from Judaism and from a love of Israel to tell me that the world is more complicated. Listen, Rifki, I personally don't have a problem with the Israel education that I received growing up. However, if you're going to criticize and say that it should have been more nuanced, we should have been exposed to a little bit more information, I totally accept that as a valid point and a valid argument. However, I think that the argument being made by If Not Now is completely disingenuous, and I just don't take it seriously. As opposed to, let's say, a group like J Street. They also made efforts, or maybe still are, I haven't really heard a lot about them recently, but made efforts to change the way that Israel is spoken about in the Jewish community, to change the educational system. But they were much more thought out. They said, we have to talk about the two-state solution. We have to look at the Palestinians as human beings. And they have a desire for a land and for a country.
and we should take that seriously. Those are all much more nuanced and legitimate arguments than to only say, and the occupation, that's all we care about, and that's all we're going to talk about. Yeah, I think that's actually a good contrast. One of the differences of many between J Street and If Not Now is also that J Street is very firmly pro-Israel. They are very firmly Zionist, and obviously different members would have different understandings of what that means, but they take a firm stance on some of these things. If Not Now does not take a stance on Zionism, which means that there are active members who do not consider themselves Zionists. And I think, very understandably, those of us who are Zionists and firmly believe that Israel should be a Jewish state are a little bit concerned about criticism that seemingly comes from within, except that it doesn't.
because these people actually don't believe that Israel is a Jewish state. So actually, If Not Now has specifically been in the news. You're right that they're really good at social media, Uri. They've been making the rounds in different conversations, especially because of the birthright thing, because they're a ma thing. It's actually funny. Recently this morning, Uri, I looked up J Street's Twitter and If Not Now's Twitter and If Not Now has more Twitter followers than J Street. And they've been around for just a few years. So yeah, it's pretty crazy. And recently they were on a podcast that I listened to called Judaism Unbound. Do you ever listen, Uri? Well, the first one I ever listened to was this episode that you told me about. I think it's pretty interesting. Sometimes I...
agree or disagree with the hosts or guests, but I always find it to be a pretty interesting conversation about an aspect of Jewish community and leadership that I often hadn't known about before. So Judaism on Band hosted Alana Levinson and Jill Rainey, two leaders in If Not Now. What's interesting about when I say leaders is that it doesn't have centralized leadership in a real way. So these are two members. Yeah, they're active and they really believe strongly in the cause, but they're not. They have no title in the group. Yes, exactly. That's a good way to put it. So I think what was kind of interesting, there are a lot of interesting things about this interview and I definitely urge people to take a listen to it.
These two women had sort of different perspectives that came from their two backgrounds. So Alana had grown up very much entrenched in the Jewish community. She had gone to Osama Czech their day school. She went to Jewish camp for many years. She actually did Hasbara Fellowships, which is the same trip I did, which I'd known her. And it's actually interesting because she talked about Hasbara Fellowships being a really strong turning point for her to when she started getting a little bit more suspicious because she felt like there had to be more to the story. And actually felt like for me also on Hasbara Fellowships. Yeah, I mean, it sucks for Hasbara. They think they're doing so well. It's turning people in the other direction. And that's when she really started questioning and started thinking there must be more to the story. And she went back to college and started taking, you know, different types of classes and visiting different places. She went to Jordan. She went on different trips. And Jill Rainey, who was the other...
if not now, leader. She had a very different experience. She always felt sort of outside the Jewish community. I think her mother wasn't Jewish. Her father was Jewish. She didn't grow up going to Jewish school, going to Jewish camp. She said she had serious relationships with non-Jews. So she had a totally different experience. But they both ended up in this same place of...
radical, left-wing, different perspectives on Israel. And Uri, I found myself actually, I felt a little bit more, like, maybe more connected to Alana's narrative. And maybe that was because, you know, I had a more similar upbringing to her. But I also felt like I understood her points a little bit more. Jill, I think she was a little bit rawer. Like, she's only really entered the Israel conversation. Well, she also said she didn't know what the Green Line was until 2016. Right. Which gives an idea of her background of knowledge and subject. Yeah, I mean, she kind of said that. She spoke very strongly. She said that not growing up with a Jewish education, going to Jewish camp, kind of freed her of the shackles of that kind of propaganda or that kind of sort of institutional pushing of knowledge.
Freedom of the shackles of knowledge. Well, specific kind of knowledge. But as I was listening to it, even though I felt like maybe there were some points that I agreed, but I think overall I didn't feel so comfortable the way they were presenting the situation. As we said, you know, there's a lack of nuance on both sides. Why don't we listen to a clip from the Judaism Unbound podcast? And I recommend anyone who wants to get a better idea of If Not Now and who they are and what they stand for should listen to this podcast. Again, this is not their official stance, but I assume that these two women are somewhat representative of the If Not Now philosophy. I believe that we can actually end this sense that...
the sense among the broader world that Jews are somehow scary or threatening or to blame for things or like embarrassing or like dangerous. You want to like keep them in a different place and get rid of them from time to time. We can end that sense so that we can live peacefully alongside non-Jews, including our non-Jewish family members, which thousands and millions of us have, by the way. Non-Jews are not an inherent threat. We can join with our Jewish people who have a wide variety of different backgrounds and non-Jews to actually end antisemitism in all of the countries and places where Jews happen to live or where Jews might want to move. And I think a country that prioritizes people of one ethnicity over all others is just not realistic to how human beings live. Like, we like our in-groups, but sometimes we make friends in other groups, and then a couple centuries later, we're all related to each other in one way or another. That's how humans live. And I think this idea that putting all Jews in one place with big walls and guns protecting us from non-Jews.
is both immiserating of those non-Jews, a moral disaster for those who are helming those guns, and also just not realistic to how people live. I think we can end anti-Semitism so that Jews and non-Jews can just live wherever we want to live. So when she said that, it really reminded me of the Michael Chavon speech. Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. It's a little bit less nihilistic because she's not saying everything is pointless and Judaism should just disappear, but she is saying a version of that. It definitely seems to be that she's saying Israel should not exist as a Jewish state. I mean, she said that in so many words, right? Well, I think she's talking about the idea of a state in general as being run by one ethnic group. She feels it's very progressive. It's very 21st century. There's no reason for any of us to sort of...
live in subgroups, right? Like Michael Chabon's walls, right? Universalists, yeah. So, I mean, I think I already know the answer, but let's just talk it out. She basically seems to think, or hope, but it sounds like she really thinks, that ending Zionism or ending a Jewish state could be the first step or the last step or the only step, I'm not even sure, to rid the world of anti-Semitism. Well, right. Is that what you heard? Well, to give a little bit more background, what she was saying before that was her understanding of Zionism. And this actually reminds me of what Linda Sarsour said at her panel discussion.
This woman on the podcast said that Israel and Zionism was created in order to stop anti-Semitism. So she didn't say because of the Holocaust, which is what Linda Sarsour said. But that already is so far from the full reality. Well, she also connected to the Holocaust because she says that part of the reason that we other Palestinians and that we other... non-Jewish groups generally is because we're scared of non-Jews, which we have a right to be, she says, after the Holocaust and after, you know, she's basically saying Israel was created as a solution to anti-Semitism, but the real solution to anti-Semitism is the opposite of Israel, which is assimilation and being friends and marrying, I guess, everybody else. Yeah. If we stop being afraid of non-Jews and we can sort of like embrace them, then we can end anti-Semitism. Right. So I guess along the lines of Michael Chabon, if Judaism disappears, then I guess anti-Semitism will also disappear. That is true. And I guess, and it sounds like that's kind of what she's saying, which I surprisingly would disagree with. I don't think she's saying that Judaism should disappear. She is.
She doesn't say as explicitly as Michael Chabon to promote assimilation, but she's saying... She basically does say that, though. But for her, if I could read between the lines here, she's saying that what's important about Judaism is the values, and it's not the ethnicity or nationalism, and the Jewish values should continue on, but this Jewish tribalism should not live on. The values as she sees them, and she sees the Jewish values as the values of progressivism and social justice. Yeah, I think that's true. Yeah, I think that's true. So I don't think there's, I think those might be nice values, but there's nothing Jewish about them. Right, it sounds like you're disagreeing about what the values of Judaism actually are. Right, which is a discussion we don't have to get into right now, but I don't think any of her values are uniquely Jewish. She's taking her progressive values, and whichever ones of those match up with traditional Jewish values, great, that's Judaism, and whichever ones don't,
That's not her Judaism. So to me, that's not Jewish. But again, to be fair, I just want to take a step back and say, she does not represent, if not now, in this way. This is not, if not now's position. Well, we know that we have two people on the podcast, and that was not the view that was being espoused by the other. Okay, but the other one didn't disagree on any points. No, it's the way all these panels work, right? Not necessarily. It's very rare, at least it's rare in my experience, for someone on a panel to say, I actually really don't feel comfortable with what you just said, and I want to just like voice that, that I do not agree. Especially two people who are from the same team, quote unquote. Right, well, I think that would make it a lot more honest and interesting. Completely agree.
I mean, maybe I'm wrong, but I would like to think that that is not the majority view of If Not Now. We got the perspective of two different people, one who really grew up well-versed in not only an education about Israel, you know, we could call it propaganda, but also in just general more steeped in Jewishness. And the other person really did not come from that background. And for her to have a really naive and maybe not the most thoughtful... perspective about what antisemitism really is, to me feels like I don't feel like we can paint the whole movement with that brush. Well, whether or not she's an official representative of the organization, I think it's very telling that she is speaking on their behalf. She's the product of intermarriage. She's self-described as having zero Jewish background or education. And she's self-described as not knowing anything about Israel until 2016. And now she's lecturing the Jewish establishment about all the things that they're getting wrong. And I find it very sad where our peers, our young millennial Jewish peers, seem to be increasingly of the opinion that...
there's something wrong with Jews or Jewish institutions promoting a pro-Jewish, pro-Israel stance, that that is somehow propaganda that's biased. And I just think that's so sad that they see it that way, as opposed to saying, let's be pro-Israel, let's be pro-Jewish, but let's just have a better understanding of the situation. If that's what they were calling for, I would have a lot more respect for that. Yeah, I hear that. And I understand that sort of hesitation. But I feel that hesitation also to sort of say, I don't feel comfortable partnering with someone if I feel like their starting point that they come with is not a starting point that is really someone who I feel like is my natural partner in a lot of these ways. I feel like there is an antagonism if they're not even comfortable saying, you know.
We... believe in israel's right to exist i would say though that i think that fundamentally a lot of the arguments that they're making that we are not given a nuanced portrait a lot of people are given this sort of propaganda on one side and we all need more nuanced conversations in our schools in our camps in our education big adult i think it's completely accurate and i think that again this is a really radical group and not the group that i think i would want to partner with and i understand why the ramah organization was not comfortable partnering with it but i think for ramah to take the ideas to heart for bertha to take the ideas to heart for frish i'm sorry i keep calling it frish it's a good school in some ways um but i think for all of these organizations to take this idea to heart that we need to give our education a little bit more nuance and that will not make kids turn away kids can take a lot more and think a lot more than we give them credit for. And this is, I think, a larger trend that we can maybe get into one day.
All right. Bye, everyone. Bye.