*30.1 Makkos Daf 20A (5 lines Dn)*

*30.1 Makkos Daf 20A (5 lines Dn)*Rabbi Yochanan: One is only liable for eating unredeemed _maaser sheini_ if it was already brought up to Yerushalayim.This seems to be contradicted by a _beraisa_ delineating the liabilities for one who separates _terumah_ and then eats it in Yerushalayim (according to Rabbi Yosi). We understand that had it been eaten outside of Yerushalayim, there would be another liability - for eating _maaser,_ even though it had not yet been brought to Yerushalayim?The _gemara_ explains that the beraisa would only add a _malkos_ if the food had in fact been brought into Yerushalayim first.*Summary**Challenge: What then is the beraisa teaching?* [The laws of liability for _terumah_ themselves are very clear cut].*Resolution:* The _beraisa_ discusses a case where produce *was brought to Yerushalayim* [and taken out (Rashi)] *in a _tevel_ state.* [Thus when we infer that there would be liability for _maaser_ as well when eaten outside, we are learning that] *“Potential _matanos_ are considered separated”.* [So although it cannot be said that the _maaser_ was brought into Yerushalayim before being eaten outside, because it was not actually _maaser_ yet, one would still be liable].*Challenge: Rabbi Yosi disagrees* with the idea that “Potential _matanos_ are considered separated”.*Beraisa: Rabbi Shimon ben Yehuda quoting Rabbi Yosi: Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel agree regarding unprocessed produce* that passed through Yerushalayim, that its _maaser_ can still be redeemed.They disagree however regarding *processed _tevel:_**Beis Shammai:* It can no longer be redeemed [Potential _matanos_ are considered separated].*Beis Hillel:* It can still be redeemed *[Potential _matanos_ are not considered separated].* See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate