Skip to content
31. Kinder Guardians episode artwork

Jul 18, 2018 34 min

31. Kinder Guardians

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky recap last week's episode and special guest Deena Klein. They then discuss Sasha Baron Cohen's new show, " Who Is America?" and ask - is the show any good? Is it unfair to the guests? And, of course, is it good for the Jews? Next, they dive into Scarlett Johansson (another member of the tribe). Was it wrong for Johansson to be cast as a transgender man? And, what about Business Insider - were they correct in removing Greenbaum’s article from their website? What about Greenbaum’s very public decision to resign over this whole thing? Clip from SBC new show https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkXeMoBPSDk Joe Walsh explanation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9LjwRRO9fk&t=3s Guam capsize question https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cesSRfXqS1Q Scarlett Johansson https://www.cnn.com/2018/07/13/entertainment/scarlett-johansson-film-exit/index.html Daniella Greenbaum removed article https://www.weeklystandard.com/daniella-greenbaum/here-is-the-column-about-scarjo-that-business-insider-spiked-to-appease-a-social-justice-mob Greenbaum's response https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-social-media-mob-is-a-danger-to-society/2018/07/12/eef13834-860b-11e8-9e80-403a221946a7_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.eed3afdc6094 Ali G Animal Rights https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_la5XiQJdk

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky recap last week's episode and special guest Deena Klein. They then discuss Sasha Baron Cohen's new show, " Who Is America?" and ask - is the show any good? Is it unfair to the guests? And, of course, is it good for the Jews? Next, they dive into Scarlett Johansson (another member of the tribe). Was it wrong for Johansson to be cast as a transgender man? And, what about Business Insider - were they correct in removing Greenbaum’s article from their website? What about ...

Ready to play

31. Kinder Guardians

0:00 34:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Ari. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Welcome back, Rivki. Thank you so much. Sorry I missed a week, but I heard it was a pretty good week. Yeah, no need to apologize. It's great to have you back. But yeah, we had an amazing guest host last week, Dina Klein, our good friend. Dina did an amazing job. She was nervous beforehand, but she was so articulate. She did really well. Yeah, and I just want to clarify. I mean, not all of the feedback I got said that they agreed with everything that was said, obviously, but they all appreciated the conversation. And especially, I think it's scary to talk about yourself, talk about your identity in that way. And she was really brave. And I think she did a really amazing job. Yeah. And so if there are any new listeners that we have now, thanks to...

that episode, welcome. And we hope that you will stay with us and listen to us every week. I would also add that if you listened and you had something to say, either positive or negative, and you did not contact us, please send us an email. TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. We love hearing feedback.

So Rivki, I saw earlier this week on Facebook these mysterious posts from Sacha Baron Cohen. Apparently he had a new show coming out. Yeah, I mean, it's been a while and it was really exciting. He had this like cryptic video with Dick Cheney where he got Dick Cheney to sign his waterboarding kit. The hype wasn't just because people were talking about it. It's also because a lot of people who were sort of duped into being on the show. Started coming out of the woodwork. Yeah, immediate disclaimers that we were tricked and boycott Showtime. So I was never really a big Borat or Bruno or, you know, fan of any of these, the clips or the movies. It's not really my kind of humor. It's a little bit mean. It's a little bit, you know, harsh. You know, obviously I like to be mean.

mean, but in a different way. So I was never really a big fan of Sacha Baron Cohen or his style of humor, but I was a little bit intrigued, looking forward to seeing some of this new show. Yeah, I mean, I haven't loved everything he's done, but actually my favorite character who you didn't mention was Ali G. Are you familiar with that character? It's actually funny because I don't think he could do that character now for political correctness reasons. I mean, that's a separate discussion. I wonder if he could do the other ones. What, can he do Bruno now? Maybe not. I mean, my general rule is if something is funny enough, you get away with a lot more. And I think that rule probably still applies in some form. It also, I think, depends on, like, he clearly politically aligns with... Well, that's, yeah. So this shows my concern. My two main questions were how political

is this new show going to be? And also, I was really wondering, how did he get people to cooperate? Because everybody knows who he is. The answer ended up being, for each interview he did, he had an insane amount of prosthetics and makeup to play these different characters, which was really cool. So the show ended up debuting last night, as we record this, Sunday night it debuted. And there was one segment on the show with this 10-minute clip about gun control that probably stood out the most. You saw that clip, right? Yeah. It was pretty crazy. So let's play some clips from that, and then we can talk about it. So, Engineer Bobby, can you play the clip? My name, Colonel Eran Morad. I am the terrorist Terminator.

In America, there is big problem of shootings in schools. The NRA want to arm the teachers. This is crazy. They should be arming the children. Yalla, let's go. In America, there have been a lot of shootings in the school and in the university.

What do the liberals say is the reason for this and the solution? Well, they blame it on guns. Yeah, it's crazy because people... They blame it on the guns? Yes. It's no sugar. It is. We start a program in Israel for kindergartens. Okay. We train them from the age 16 down to the age 3. Yeah, well, I think it would be a good idea. We've been pushing something along this line for years, but really haven't gotten any traction with it. We were thinking 7th or 8th grade. You're talking much younger than that. My son was in the very first program. May he rest in peace.

He died doing what I love. Okay, and believe it or not, it actually just gets more and more outrageous from there. So this is the first guy, and he's actually, for the first good chunk of the clip, it's this Philip Van Cleave, who is president of Virginia Citizens Defense League, which is a gun rights group. So, I mean, is this guy a prominent figure? Not really. He has a Wikipedia page. Okay, but then the segment goes on to feature mostly Republican members of the House of Representatives. Bobby?

Now that I had this prat on board, I was welcomed into the halls of Congress, where I sat down with a house representative and outlined my common sense proposal. Oh, you want me to say on television that I support three and four-year-olds with firearms? Is that what you're asking me to do? Uh, yes. Typically, members of Congress don't just hear a story about a program and then indicate whether they support it or not. I support the kindergarten program. We in America would be wise to implement it, too. It's something that we should think about in America, about putting guns in the hands of law-abiding citizens, good guys, whether they be teachers or whether they actually be talented children or highly trained preschoolers. The intensive three-week kindergarten course introduces specially selected children from 12 to 4 years old to pistols, rifles, semi-automatics, and a rudimentary knowledge of mortars.

In less than a month, less than a month, a first grader can become a first Grenader. Okay, pretty crazy. I was shocked that these people, they were reading off a teleprompter that they were asked to read. Rivki, before I say the rest of my thoughts, what did you think about this whole thing? So there were definitely parts that were funny, but it was really sad. It was really sad to watch. It felt really painful. What was your main takeaway, would you say?

I get being tricked. I get someone shoving a camera in your face. Manipulated. Totally. Like, I can imagine that. And I can imagine it being really embarrassing. And these people really being forced into an uncomfortable situation. And maybe they didn't really believe anything they said. I understand that. But their reaction in the last week was not to say, oh, God, this is so embarrassing. I was manipulated. This guy's a huge jerk. And I don't believe the things that I was saying. I can't believe that I said that. I can't believe this happened. It was all a rush. Here's what I really believe. What they did was come out and say, this guy's evil. Boycott Showtime. He thinks this is funny. This isn't funny. This is ridiculous. This is absolutely ludicrous. I can't believe he would trick people that way. Right. I do think that's a really good point. But to be fair, before the show was actually...

released nobody wanted to admit to what they said because they don't know which clips are going to be used and which aren't so if their clip does not end up being used in the show they're not going to admit that they messed up if nobody's even going to know that they said something but once the show came out last night already this morning joe walsh was the last guy to speak in the clip that we played posted this on twitter i was reading from a teleprompter promoting various israel innovations i read a story about a child in israel who stopped a terrorist i then read about israel training children on firearms i thought it was extreme but often israel must be extreme the story was a lie I was reading about what Israel does. This was after being flown out to D.C. to get a Friend of Israel award, a 45-minute made-up interview about my support for Israel. Wedged in there was this sliver about kids and guns. And no, I don't believe we should train and arm kindergartners. I mean, I think part of it, to be honest, is also that this issue of gun control has become so divisive that the pro-gun people don't want to give an inch on anything. And so they don't even want to say that I was wrong about something because maybe they feel that that would be giving in too much to the other side, which I think is very immature and ridiculous. It's really problematic. I mean, as I was watching the clip, I was obviously cringing, but that's what his...

stuff always makes you do. I think the point that Sacha Baron Cohen was trying to make was that... a lot of the pro-gun people hold opinions that are ludicrous and insane. And it doesn't take much to get them with like some slight manipulation. You can get them to say really, really outrageous things on this issue because, and even though they were tricked and wouldn't normally say that, it's an underlying mentality. I actually think that's a really good point, Uri, that none of these people would unprompted, if someone, if I walked up to them and said, hey, what do you think about guns? They'd say, thank you for asking. I think we should train four-year-olds. But the issue has become so intense with them that they feel like it's my side or it's the other side. And the other side is complete control and my side has to be that complete extreme. So therefore, if you're trying to take an inch, I'm going to say, let's give four-year-olds guns.

point was not to embarrass these particular people I don't remember half of their names I think really the point is for people who are pro-gun to stop and say Wait, wait, wait, hold on. There has to be a more nuanced view if like this is the extreme that I'm going with. Right. So there's one big issue that we need to address, which is the Israeli thing in there. But before we get to that, I just want to say that I was a little bit disappointed in Sacha Baron Cohen for becoming so politicized when a lot of his old material was just about making famous people or prominent people look really dumb. And then the commentary was just on like America in general. Like, look, I can get people to say dumb things or whatever. It seems to have become about let's make Republicans look really dumb, which in this case, he has a point on this issue.

I happen to think, and I mean, do you disagree that? Like, let's say if he chose abortion or racism, he could get Democrats to say equally dumb sounding and insane things if he worked as hard at that as he did at this. Like, this doesn't detract from his point. And if you wanted to call out the gun lobby or the gun... supporters as being dangerous to the country and just insane people or whatever. I understand that. And I'm not saying that's wrong to do. I just think as a comedian, it would be funnier if he went after everybody. Yeah, for sure. I mean, look, let's talk about abortion, right? Maybe it's true. And I don't know, right? Because he doesn't have this clipper. Maybe it's later in the season. But maybe it would be true that if he interviewed people who were incredibly, incredibly pro-choice, you know, he could get them to say things as extreme as, you can kill toddlers, you know, it could be that you could create a system like that. You can imagine that. But A, we don't really know. Like, we actually don't know. And B, if that were the case, I would expect the same thing. I would expect anyone on the left, on the right, in any standard.

to be able to stand up and say, I can't believe I said that. Obviously, that was ludicrous. We shouldn't speculate about things that haven't happened. Also, my takeaway is, I already knew this, and not to sound like a jerk about it, but just because somebody's in Congress doesn't mean they're an intelligent person. I've heard a lot of really dumb things from U.S. Congress people just a couple months ago when Mark Zuckerberg was being questioned in front of Congress. I don't know if you saw that. People were asking him. Obviously, slightly older people usually just didn't understand how the Internet works. It's like neutrality. People ask crazy questions. Yeah, and I also remember seeing a clip from a Congress person who happened to be a Democrat who was talking to a general in front of the whole Congress and was talking about the island of Guam.

and how there's over 100,000 people living on this tiny island of Guam, and the congressman asked the general if he's worried that the island might actually tip over and capsize. That was the word he used, capsize, because there's too many people on the island. It's a sad thing that our elected officials are not that intelligent, but I don't think it goes down party lines, which is what you might take away from seeing this episode, but we'll see what the future episodes are about. We have to talk about the Israel part, though, because his character here is like this Israel anti-terrorist terminator, as he says. Is this good for the Jews or bad for the Jews? Is this going to make Israel look bad, or are you not worried about that? I mean, honestly, I think the reason that he chose something like this, he grew up in a very Jewish background. I have friends in L.A. who go to...

the same synagogue as him. My friend's in London who grew up going to the same synagogue as him. Like, he's very, very Jewish. And our friend Yak actually saw him in the hotel in Israel on Pesach a couple of years ago with his family. Yeah, that's awesome. Yeah, he's like very, very Jewish. And I think for him, this is what he's comfortable with. The question is whether it's good for the Jews or bad for the Jews. I don't know. I mean, in some ways it's good, right? Israelis kind of like this like macho commander right through the bad attitude. But also this hyper-militaristic thing obviously is not good. What if people don't understand, don't get the sarcasm and they're like, oh, Israelis are, you know, arming little kids. I mean, even the fact that it's just also interesting that...

Israel has become such a partisan issue that the way he tricked Joe Walsh was by luring him in with Israel. I mean, I kind of have to hope that people are not going to walk away thinking, wow, I can't believe Israel is really giving guns to kindergartners. It's so ridiculous. Maybe not literally, but subliminally, it'll be like, oh, it makes sense that Israel is going to be on the side of the lunatic gun people. I mean, in your experience with...

People who live in Israel? No, it's very far from the truth, which is why I'm a little bit concerned about it. Wait, what do you mean it's very far from the truth? Gun violence and school shootings and stuff, thank God, don't exist in Israel the way they do here. But I mean the attitude among people where they feel much more comfortable both with guns and with civilians carrying guns, I think that is true about Israeli culture. Yeah, it is. I think the whole reality about guns is totally different there. You don't have an NRA in Israel. You don't have people...

fetishizing guns in the way they do here. So I really just think it's completely different. Yeah, it's a very different world, but you're right that only people who have sort of an insider knowledge about Israel, people who have friends who are Israeli or, you know, grew up going there would really have knowledge about this. I also just want to say, and this is not really because of the political stuff. I watched the whole episode last night. I actually signed up for a free trial of Showtime just so I could watch the episode. I was not impressed. The hype was obviously through the roof and that's part of why I think it was disappointing. I just didn't think it was that funny compared to, you know, his older stuff and that happens a lot.

I mean, maybe also you've matured. It could be. Maybe, who knows? But this was the first of seven episodes, so, you know, I'm looking forward to seeing the rest, and maybe we'll talk about it in the future. And if any listeners want to sponsor a Talking Talks subscription, I think we would really appreciate the support. This is an island that edits...

The widest level is, what, 12 miles from shore to shore? Is that correct? I don't have the exact dimensions, but to your point, sir, I think Guam is a small island. Very small island and about 24 miles, if I recall, long. My fear is that the whole island will become so overly populated that it will tip over and capsize.

Well, there was another topic we wanted to discuss this week, and that is that our old friend, actress Scarlett Johansson, is in trouble again. Remember the tribe? Yes, she is a fellow Jew. You may remember her from her previous controversy, when she was criticized for being a spokesperson for SodaStream, an Israeli company that had a factory in the West Bank. The new controversy is about an upcoming movie entitled Rub and Tug, in which Johansson was supposed to play a transgender man. And just for those of you who may not be familiar, a transgender man refers to someone who their sex when they were born was a female sex, but their sense of personal identity and gender is a man, and therefore they identify as a man. Thank you for that clarification. So as soon as the news was announced, there was a tremendous backlash from the transgender community against Johansson and the producers of the film for hiring a cis woman to play the role of a trans man. When Johansson was initially asked to respond to the backlash, her representative said, quote,

Tell them that they can be directed to Jeffrey Tambor, Jared Leto, and Felicity Huffman's reps for comment. The representative was referring to three well-known actors who played critically acclaimed roles as transgender people, even though none of them are themselves transgender. However, soon after this first statement, Johansson issued a second statement, saying, quote, Our cultural understanding of transgender people continues to advance, and I've learned a lot from the community since making my first statement about my casting, and realized it was insensitive. I have great admiration and love for the trans community, and I'm grateful that the conversation regarding inclusivity in Hollywood continues. Soon after, Johansson announced that she was dropping out of the movie.

As soon as the casting decision was released, there were immediately people both attacking and defending the decision. Among the journalists who defended the casting was Daniela Greenbaum, who published an opinion piece in Business Insider. And disclaimer, while neither of us knows Daniela personally, both Rifki and I have a lot of mutual friends with her. So in the article, Greenbaum wrote, Scarlett Johansson is the latest target of the social justice warrior mob. The actress is being chastised for, well, acting. She has been cast in a movie in which she will play someone different than herself. For this great crime, which seems to essentially define the career path she has chosen, she is being castigated for being insufficiently sensitive to the transgender community.

So a few hours after Greenbaum's piece was published online, Business Insider removed the article from its website, stating that, quote, upon further review, we decided it did not meet our editorial standards. At the same time, Business Insider editor-in-chief Nicholas Carlson issued a lengthy internal memo outlining a new policy for opinion pieces covering, quote, culturally sensitive topics such as marginalized communities, race, or LGBTQ plus issues. Soon after the article was removed, Daniela Greenbaum wrote her letter of resignation from her job at Business Insider, and she posted the letter on Twitter. In explaining her reason for leaving the publication, Greenbaum wrote, Unfortunately, what happened with my piece, the tarring of a commonsensical view as somehow bigoted or not thought out, the capitulation on the part of those who are supposed to be the adults to the mob, is a pattern happening all over the country within institutions that pride themselves on open-mindedness and liberalism. So, Rivki, this is obviously a complex, multilayered story. But what do you think? First of all, was it wrong for Scarlett Johansson to be cast as a transgender man in the first place? And what about Business Insider? Were they correct in removing Greenbaum's article from their website? What about Greenbaum's very public decision to resign over this whole thing?

Wow, so this is obviously a very complicated issue, and there are a lot of different sort of layers to this piece. So I guess let's just go through them one by one, Uri, and I'm really curious to hear your thoughts about this. So I guess the first thing that I'm thinking about is the impulse of the trans community, of sort of saying like, hey, this isn't appropriate. There are a lot of trans actors who are not really being... given a fair shot. You know, you never see trans people being hired to play cisgendered characters. And just also, again, for those of you who don't know, cisgender means people whose gender matches their sex. Basically someone like me, right? I am female by sex and by gender. So I really understand, I think, the impulse for me to want someone of my own community to sort of represent me and represent our community on the screen, right? As I was reading about this, I was thinking, do you ever watch the HBO show High Maintenance?

I've seen one or two episodes. Okay, so there was, I also don't watch every episode, but I saw the episode that came out a few months ago where there was an ex-Hasidic Jew. Did you see this one? That was one or two that I saw. It was going around. It was really exciting because there was an ex-Hasidic Jew who was the main character of this episode, and he was played by an ex-Hasidic Jew. And that was really meaningful, I think, to people in that community. And I think, I'm not an ex-Hasidic Jew, but I definitely felt like there was something really exciting about watching someone really portray something about himself. There felt like a real life being given to that character. Well, so Rivki, let me ask you, just before we move on, I'm trying to understand what the fundamental problem is. Is it that...

it's wrong for someone who isn't transgender to portray a transgender person in a movie, that that is inherently wrong? Or is it more so that there are transgender actors and it's hard for them to get to find work, and here you have a role about a transgender person, which is the perfect casting for a transgender person. And to not give a transgender person that role is just insensitive and unfair. I think it's the second one. I think that's the general argument that I've been reading. So if transgender people were getting acting jobs left and right, it wouldn't be a big deal. And there are many quotes from transgender activists and other transgender actors making the same sort of claim. It's like, if I could get any role, then I wouldn't care about this particular role in the same way. Right, because you mentioned the ex-classic actor, which is cool. But I mean, like, in the movie Defiance, which is the first that comes to mind, Daniel Craig plays a Jewish Holocaust survivor. And he's obviously not Jewish. So, I mean, but there are also tons of Jews in Hollywood, if you haven't heard. So maybe, so meaning that's the difference. If it was the first issue that you can't have somebody portraying someone.

that they're not, that would be the problem. But if it's the second issue, then it's okay. Yeah, I think that's exactly it. I think that the real issue is that feeling like these people are not given opportunities and when something really would fit their wheelhouse, they still aren't given those opportunities. That hasn't been said. It's not just about having the opportunity to get jobs. There's also something about someone representing themselves, representing their own community that can really give voice or give expression to a certain thing. You know, imagine the best white actor in the world acting in blackface, okay? And like, it's totally good blackface. There's something about watching that that makes us really uncomfortable. Obviously, that's the way it used to be. So why are we not like that? Right, well, that's another extreme example. Yeah, of course. Because, right. Purposely setting up an extreme example. Right, because we could go down the line and in Greenbaum's article, she...

lists a whole bunch of types of, you know, roles where an actor is playing someone that they're not. And that is what acting is. She's right about that. But right. So blackface, I think, has so many terrible connotations historically and culturally. And that's why it's so unacceptable as opposed to other things like, you know, something in the middle that I actually recently saw the movie Born on the Fourth of July, which was made in 1989. It's a famous movie starring Tom Cruise as a disabled Vietnam War veteran. The movie was directed by Oliver Stone. It's basically an anti-war movie. Very powerful. But Tom Cruise is playing a disabled man in a wheelchair. So I think that's a fair middle.

ground case in kind of our landscape where I could see arguments on both sides there. So, I mean, and there aren't a lot of roles for disabled actors. Right. So there's, did you ever watch the TV show Glee? I've seen it. There was a character in a wheelchair who was able-bodied and there was a lot of criticism. Oh, he wasn't really? No, no, no. There's actually one episode that has, and now I'm admitting that I love the show. He's a good actor. I fell for it. Yeah, yeah. There was one episode where he has like a dream and there's like a dance sequence and he's actually a really good dancer. And have you seen criticism? There's a lot of criticism. Yeah, when it first came out of saying like, look, this guy might be great, but there are so many actors who are in wheelchairs who have no opportunity to play able-bodied people. So why are you giving this role to someone like him? Right. Okay. So I think

that that argument is a very valid argument to make. But then the question becomes, is the counter argument also valid? To say, yes, it's great when we can to give opportunities to, like, you know, marginalized people or people who don't get a lot of opportunities for acting jobs or other kinds of jobs. But in this case, when they gave the role to Scarlett Johansson, is that allowed? And if somebody tried to defend her, like Daniela Greenbaum, is that opinion acceptable? So before even going to Daniela Greenbaum, I also keep going back to thinking about, is there anything unique about the trans story? Meaning, is it the same as a black person, a disabled person, any sort of minority that would be representing their own community or maybe aren't representing other communities? And I think...

here's what I think is unique about trans, and tell me if you disagree with this, for a trans person to say, look, I would be okay with someone who isn't trans playing a trans person if you would let me play someone who is cisgendered, then I think a lot of people are kind of thinking in the back of their minds, yeah, but you couldn't play someone cisgender. But that's just reality. If an actor can pass for the person they're trying to play, then they could do the role. If not, not. That's what acting is. Yeah, understood. I'm not arguing about whether it's reality or not. I just think that that's a big part of the reaction of the trans community is because what they're thinking is you're never going to let us play these people because you're always going to see us as different. And that's part of, I think, the pain that they're expressing when they're upset about not getting the transgender roles either. Yeah, that's a really interesting point.

what you're saying is a transgender man just wants to be seen as a man. And therefore, a transgender man who's an actor would audition for roles for a man, but would very likely not get any of those roles because of what they would see as discrimination not being accepted as a man. So they're already being discriminated in that way, and now they're being discriminated against in this additional way by not even being cast to play transgender people. So now to get into the Daniella Greenbaum argument, Greenbaum made a very compelling case, I think, in the Washington Post when she was writing about her decision to resign. She wrote, the problem is not confined to the college campuses where conservative speakers are being shouted down or disinvited. It's not confined to the media where publications and television stations and their audiences seem increasingly comfortable.

in liberal or conservative silos where conflicting outlooks and even conflicting information are unwelcome. It's beginning to permeate every area where we use language, every area of life. The only way to fight it is head on. Defend the idea that more speech is always better. The best way to put bad arguments to bed is to air them out and highlight their weaknesses. Want to eliminate unsafe thoughts and unsafe as in quotes? Turn them loose in the marketplace of ideas and debate them. Don't try to silence them.

Uri, I completely agree with her argument. Did I love her piece? I don't know. I thought it was fine. She wasn't really writing anything particular. And she even says that, right? She wasn't writing anything that wasn't being said in a bunch of other places. It wasn't like what she said was particularly crazy. But whether you agree or disagree, I don't think sort of censoring things and being concerned that people might be offended is the answer. The answer should be a marketplace of ideas, right? Kind of like the ideal university, the ideal newspaper, right? The best ideas should win. To censor her argument, whether you agree with it or not, is something I'm very uncomfortable with. Okay. I mean, I think we're in agreement on that. To be real, I think the reason why Business Insider removed the article was because they were scared for their own reputation.

assuming that whoever's decision it was to take it down probably thought, we're going to get a lot of backlash for having this piece on our site. So the safe route is for us to just remove it. Let somebody else talk about why Scarlett Johansson should have been cast in that movie. What Greenbaum wrote was that people within the organization complained to the editor and then the editor made the decision. But I think you're right. I think it's both things. I think it's concerned about backlash. Whether that backlash is from outsiders or insiders, I think you're right. I actually connect this to the first topic of the Sacha Baron Cohen thing. I think it's very related because I think that in our current climate, our current culture, there are certain targets and groups that are okay to ridicule and make fun of and make look...

foolish. And there are other groups that are off limits, even if some of their arguments could potentially be taken apart just as easily. Meaning old white men are the ultimate soft target where you're not going to get criticism for making them look really, really bad, which is what Sacha Baron Cohen did. And with good reason for the things that they believe and said and whatever, according to him and a lot of people. So, for example, in Sacha Baron Cohen's show, in the remaining six episodes, I can pretty much promise you that he's not going to interview a transgender person and make them look stupid because that's too dangerous for him to do. His entire reputation will be destroyed. And I'm not saying I wish that he would do that, but I think it's just worth noting, and that's what I think Daniela Greenbaum is saying, that it's like certain things are just off limits and you're not allowed to talk about it, and the list of things that you can't talk about and you can't say seems to be growing. So, I mean, I understand the connection that you're making, and I think it's an interesting one. I would disagree that that's why. I don't think that he's scared to interview a transgender person. I think it makes complete sense.

but the people that you want to take down, so to speak, are the ones with the power. They're the ones who are controlling the conversation and are doing things that are harmful. So Democrats in Congress who hold certain opinions, like the island tipping over. I think there are plenty of ways in which they can. They make fun of Democrats and make it completely ludicrous and take it too far. And I think I can totally imagine that he's going to do that. I just don't think the transgender thing is particularly... Give me an example. What does he actually say related to transgender? Now that I think about it, on the Ali G show, his show from 10, 15 years ago, he does have at least a couple of segments where he interviews feminists. And I mean, he's really the one who ends up looking like an idiot, but it's very misogynistic and anti-feminist.

I mean, that's like the joke. I wonder if he would still do that kind of joke and that kind of humor. My gut is saying, I don't think so, because times have changed and times have become more sensitive. And you could say they've changed for the better, but I think it's important to note that things have changed so much. So, Ori, I also, I'm curious to hear sort of what you think. One of the things that she talks about in her article that we seem to be agreeing is that there should be this marketplace of ideas. And, you know, obviously, maybe you think there are limits. I'm not even sure if I think there are limits, but I'm curious to sort of hear where you think about Israel on this, because this is something that we discussed in the past. I think there should be. It always comes back to Israel. Exactly. Like, I don't think Israel should be off limits to sort of be able to debate. And the same thing in...

I don't disagree with that. I don't think people should be censored for being anti-Israel. I would just say, you know, relating to what we spoke about a couple weeks ago, I don't think children, young children in school should be exposed to some of those things because that gets into a separate issue. But in terms of just like newspapers and public forums and panel discussions, yeah, I mean, I'm personally curious to hear. whatever it is that people have to say about Israel, regardless of how negative it is. Yeah, I agree with you. Okay. Sounds like we're really on the same page about this one. Oh, no. What I would say for my concluding thoughts on this issue are that, again, to bring it back to the Sacha Baron Cohen thing, my concern, my fear is that it seems that the divisiveness that we find in our society is just growing and becoming worse and worse to the point where now you have, you could say it goes the other way also, but you have so many liberal people who look at Republicans, look at conservatives as lunatic, crazy, evil people. And so they'll watch the Sacha Baron Cohen thing and they won't even be surprised. They'll be like, oh, obviously they're insane because they're Republicans. And I think that's scary to me because I know...

that that's not all Republicans and not all conservatives. And I think that that type of mentality really degrades a lot of our public conversations. You know what I would love? I would love for sort of public intellectual conservatives and Republicans to tweet a link to that clip and say, wow, this is really embarrassing. Not all Republicans. This is not what I stand for. This is pretty ludicrous. I would love that. I don't see any of that. And maybe I think that I'm looking, but maybe I'm not looking enough. Okay, well, we'll look and we'll report back to you next week. Okay. Okay, is it wrong for people to do experiments on animals in their own home? It's wrong and unscientific.

Because we did a thing years ago with this mouse in this microwave to try about nuclear, to do a nuclear test to see if it could, you know, survive the nuclear thing. And it did survive. It came out, it was hot, whatever, but it was still alive. Is that wrong? Yes. That's pretty fiendish.

Well, as always, thank you all so much for listening. We love feedback. We really want to hear from you. So in addition to emailing us, as we mentioned before, talkingtalklesspodcast.gmail.com, you can also like our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. We'd also love to continue the discussion there. You can follow us on Instagram. And just in general, be in touch with us. We really, really, really love to talk to you. And make sure you subscribe to this podcast on iTunes or Stitcher or wherever you find your podcasts. And thank you, as always, to Drive-In Productions for sponsoring this week's episode. Thank you to our engineer, Bobby, for manning the controls. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 34 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on July 18, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.