Skip to content
#32: Are You Ready for Some Radical Environmental Justice? episode artwork

Aug 28, 2018 1 hr 15 min

#32: Are You Ready for Some Radical Environmental Justice?

from The Most Important Question Hosted by Important, Not Important

Our guest is Shantha Ready Alonso, Executive Director of Creation Justice Ministries, whose mission is to “educate, equip, and mobilize Christian communities and individuals to protect, restore, and rightly share God's Creation,” focusing on providing ... Hosted on beehiiv. Read the full Privacy Policy at https://www.beehiiv.com/privacy.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

#32: Are You Ready for Some Radical Environmental Justice?

0:00 1:15:08
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called important, non-important, which is what you'll hear in the episode, and it's still the name of the company. But now the podcast is called, the most important question.

That is, what can I do? It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost 200 episodes now. So here we are, the most important question. Please enjoy this old conversation.

Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving us shit. Welcome to important number. Important, my name is Glenn. How's it starting?

I'm Brian Colbert Kennedy. Yeah, oh, they're so excited to be here. This is episode 32. Hey, Brian, today's topic.

It's time, Brian, for Radical Environmental Justice. It's been time. It's been time. A lot of people have been like, yeah, we've been here the whole time.

You're welcome. But it's time for us and our listeners to get the hell on board. Our guest today, pretty awesome. I liked her a lot.

She was fantastic. She put up a lot of people. So all the people, her name is Shantha Reddy Alonzo, and she's Executive Director of the Creation Justice Ministries, where, yeah, from what I understand, she's just, I think, in charge of all the religious people, right? Yeah, if you count yourself as a religious person.

In any way. She's now your boss. You have to do what she says. So, again, whatever she says, that seems to be cool.

Thankfully, she's wonderful, and seems like she wants to help the planet and all the people on it. So that's good. Right. She's a Notre Dame alum, Czech, by Nairish, and Creation Justice Ministries.

And this is important to why she's here today. Their missions to educate, equip, and mobilize Christian communions and denominations to protect, restore, and rightly share God's creation. And here's where it's important, because they focus on the vulnerable and marginalized. And those folks are our concern today, right?

We got into some Chicago stuff. We, yes, of course, because there are quite a few people in Chicago who could use some extra attention and love and support, just like there are all over the country. Yeah. Because some examples of the things she brought up that they work on and they fight against and they fight for, just it's just it's fucking ridiculous.

Yeah. She had mentioned, I mean, obviously, she mentioned that needing to be a much bigger conversation in the world, this topic we were talking about today. But I really liked it when she said that part of her job is going into local, going into communities and pointing out or highlighting what locally needs to be done. I feel like that is sort of the way to do it.

For those things, what those people are saying needs to be done and they can help educate them or assist them. Yeah. I don't know. I feel just like just a regular dude.

You know, shit's fucked up, but you're just watching CNN or whatever. Like, it's too broad. Like, I think you need to see what's going on. We have to stop climate change.

It's cool. Yeah, right. My sidewalk's been flooding for like 10 years. Like, what the fuck do I do about that?

Well, this is how you can educate yourself on why and how you talk to your local representatives about it and get them fired up. Yeah. A organization seems pretty important. Well, that's where people are going to give a shit the most and also where they can have the most impact.

Yeah. Right. Where they live. Right.

Yeah. Hey, you've got a laundry list of shit that's making your kids sick. Guess what? Now everything's on fire.

You're welcome. God, we fucked this. So Brian, we've been we've been we've been torched in this place for about 100 plus years, right? Yes.

Everyone's like, hey, you know what? I'd be great idea. Factories. Right.

I go ahead. No, please. I have a real quick thing. I read my buddy post.

I think it was our friend actually friend of the podcast, Mike Brilander posted this little newspaper clipping from I think it was 1906. OK. That I can't remember if it was a city that was saying I can remember what newspaper was or who was writing it. But they had said like we've recently discovered that all the coal that we're burning like out of our stoves and our houses are, you know, it's changed in the air a little bit.

And like that might have a profound effects in the next century. Good luck, everybody. Like we've known fucking known for a while. Nobody's done anything.

And this, so I want to talk a little bit about perspective. So we get so mad because we find all these papers were axed on in the 60s is like, oh, it's going to be real bad. Right. And then they cover it up.

We're like, but you shouldn't put it on paper. Because now, despite all the lawsuits getting tossed out, it's still like they knew. You've got a newspaper article from 1906. They're like, hey, maybe not great.

Look here. Not great. So 100ish years, right? Humans have been aroundish 200, 300,000.

This version of humans, almost sapiens 200, 300,000 years, right? OK. Prancing around. Sounds like we took actually there were a couple different groups the way they left Africa went different directions.

We found recently found some really early fossils in China. Couple different ways they spread across America. Just wasn't like one group, one family that went for a trip, someone went north, someone south, came back together a few times, kind of crazy. 203,000 years.

Talk about dinosaurs for a sec. So everybody's like dinosaurs are cute, right? They're so great. They're so great.

Soropods, which are like basically the biggest ones. Yeah. They were Soropods specifically. We're on the planet for 140 million years.

And it's insane. So 203,000 years. And I tried to do the math on this, not a math guy. But this is what the calculator told me on my Mac.

Oh my god, it's such a great shortcut. It's like one-tenth of 1% of how long those specific dinosaurs were on the answer. Or like, oh, dinosaurs are here, then the asteroid. No, no, no, no, no.

We are not even like a blink of the fucking eye. And that's how quick we fucked it up. Right, right. And that's impressive.

Everyone's like, oh, it's so important. We learned to cook and eat meat. And that's what made our brains bigger. Also, it made us fuck it up.

Yeah. It's the ultimate. It is the ultimate. Like, this is why we can't have nice things.

That's sad. And we always joke about how much we like that t-shirt of like, you know, dinosaurs didn't have a space program and didn't have science. And this is what happened. And yeah, they didn't do anything wrong either.

No, they were just hanging out. They were just hanging out. Fucking asteroids. It just comes along.

You got a nuclear winner everywhere. Everything's on fire and big waves. They didn't bring that on. They didn't do anything to stop it, which they could have worked a little harder at.

Yeah, sure. Come on, dinosaur. Right? We've seen that.

We can imagine. If they'd banded together, they could have built some sort of spaceship. But the point is, is like, boy, we really deserve this. We're getting that.

That is not a lot of time to impact everything that we have impacted. Right. So anyways, conversations most vital to the survival of the species, my last segue of this intro. This is a topic that we've come back to back and forth.

And I finally tied it to the survival of the species. OK. Are you ready for this? Yeah.

Headline. Science says was all the question of boxers versus briefs. Oh my god. You've got me on board with this.

They're very comfortable, right? So I told you I got this company on Amazon or on their website, Saks, X-X-X-X, the printer preposterous. They're ridiculous. But they're so comfortable.

Big fan. I went with the trunks and the briefs. OK. OK.

So here's the problem. What are trunks? Like small boxer briefs. OK.

OK. And then briefs. OK. Hold on.

Where's the line I want to talk about? Oh, no. This is going to be something bad. It's not great.

So a lot of our listeners haven't had kids yet, right? For one reason or another. Studies found that men who mostly war boxers, which is old me. Old Quinn.

Thanks, Brian. Had 17% more sperm and a 25% higher concentration of sperm than men who prefer tight underwear. So many studies. So many studies.

I'll tell you about them. For the latest study, which appeared in human reproduction, researchers who owned data collection from one to 650 men who sought treatment for infertility to massachusetts at the general hospital between 2000 and 2017, men who range from age 18 to 56 provided samples that were analyzed for sperm, count concentration, fertility and well-being. So what's the 17% less sperm and 25% less of a concentration of sperm? If you're wearing something that's why this sounds insane to me.

Briefs aren't too late. But here's the thing. You're not uncomfortable. But there's no other thing they're comparing.

So here's the thing. Ready? Here it is. The two things.

It's super annoying. How low are balls hanging? Right. Super not.

But it's got to be that way for a reason, right? So we decided, you know, it'd be comfy. It's like warm tight undies. Turns out they're probably hanging down for a reason.

So less sperm. But here's the deal. My wife has instructed me that we're done having children. Okay.

So it's actually this news is fine. It doesn't matter. You're done. I would say, yeah.

Every bad for me. Not great for you. This was the first thing I thought is you really love a baby. You don't have one.

I'm going to have babies. One of these days. The world of species, if everybody starts, we're in tight underwear. Everybody is 25%.

This smaller concentration for sperm. I think that's ball game. Literally right well, what? Nice.

Yeah, you're welcome. Anyways, they've had enough. Let's go, talk to Shanta, Randy Alonso. I'm a little pissed.

I told you days ago that I have to talk about our intro. I thought I was into two damn long. No, tell me because I thought it was a newspaper article that's why I thought I could start talking. Go.

What's your thing? No, what's your thing. We're doing it next week. No, I didn't know.

What's the whole thing. We're going to get up for a whole thing. Okay. You look good.

Oh, fuck you. Let's go talk to Shanta. Our guest today is Shanta Radio Lanzo and together we're going to talk about digging into a radical environmental justice and the steps you can take to get on board because it's time. Shanta, welcome.

Thanks for having me. For sure. Okay, so let's just start with who you are and what you do. Sure.

I lead an organization called Creation Justice Ministries. We bring together 38 Christian denominations, communions and fellowships from five church families. That includes Orthodox Christians like the Greek Orthodox, the Orthodox Church in America and the Armenian Orthodox. It includes many Baptist traditions, including the Alliance of Baptist, American Baptist, Progressive National Baptist Convention, National Baptist Convention USA, National Baptist Convention of America, so many Baptists.

Wow. The mainline Protestants, including the United Church of Christ, the Episcopal Church, the evangelical Lutheran Church in America. I feel like you're showing all of my choices. Peace traditions, including Medinites, Quakers, and Brethren and historically Black Church traditions, including African Methodist Episcopal, Christian Methodist Episcopal, and African Methodist Episcopal Zion.

You're like the person on LinkedIn where you're like, oh, all of the contacts. You're like the mom is right. You connected to everyone. Is there somebody there?

Well, so this organization was built through networks of the National Council of Churches USA and it's actually about as old as I am. It was born in 1983. And it started because of three things going on in the 80s. One was the rise of consumer culture.

And there was profound concern in religious communities about how consumerism was spiritually impacting our communities. And we saw that the rise in consumer culture was really something that was promoted intentionally through government and commercial sources and that there needed to be a loud voice about simple living and keeping focus on God and community and the things that matter. I'm looking around my office at all of the action figures I have from the 80s and I'm like, oh, that's me. Oh, I'm talking really good.

Gosh, she's talking about it. Really good. That's what we needed. So the second thing that was going on at the time was the acid rain crisis and religious leaders felt that there needed to be an organized faith-based presence speaking out against all of the precipitating factors.

We're talking about actual acid rain. Real acid rain. And the third thing that was going on at that time was actually the rise of the secular environmental movement and some astute voices in it that talked about how we are in the mess we're in because Christians had misread something called the Dominion Mandate in the Book of Genesis, which is a line in the Book of Genesis that is in the creation story. And God says that all humans should have dominion over the earth.

And that has been misread by many as domination. There's a lot of history to that and we can get into that later if you like. Yeah, this has been a topic of frequent. We are both, I'm not going to say pagans here.

Yes, they're different backgrounds, but we've talked to a couple of reverence and such and talked about the complications with that one specific reception. That's a very problematic. So they felt that there needed to be a much stronger and clearer Christian teaching available about what our faith says about our relationship to creation. And so from that point, a working group of faith leaders from the National Council of Churches got together and formed a working group.

And since then we have done things like put together the Green Bible, which highlights all of the texts in the Bible in green that relates to caring for creation. Just to make sure. We also started the tradition of honoring Earth Day Sunday. So congregations can take the Sunday closest to Earth Day and celebrate.

And then we've done quite a bit of advocacy over the years connecting educating religious communities about current issues and showing how they can plug in and make a difference. And we worked on climate, energy, environmental health and toxics, clean water, clean air, but to name a few endangered species, public lands. We really run the gamut. Are you showing up again?

Right. Yeah, she does everything. Well, faith communities are up to a lot and more than I can individually keep track of, but I try to serve everybody and connect them as best I can. And creation justice ministries was born as the environmental partner to the National Council of Churches in 2013.

And now the National Council of Churches sends all environmental issues our way. And we've retained basically the same membership as the National Council of Churches. That's incredible. So you've done a lot.

You do a lot. That's amazing. So Shantal, let's get into our conversation for today. We love asking questions like our thing, but not just any questions.

We want to ask action oriented questioners. Questions because our listeners are, you know, screwing around with their phones all day when they should be focusing on the road, which is actually real pain. And the answer to them because they're right in motorcycle. Or, you know, they're jogging or they're on their subway, you know, half a sleeper, drinking out some candy crush or whatever.

They're not sitting here doing research while we're talking. So we want to give them as much context as possible before we get nerdy about all this. Great. That sounds pretty good.

That sounds good. All right. So, Shantal, we start with one important question to really get the heart of why you're here with us today. So instead of saying, tell us your life story, we like to ask Shantal, why are you vital to the survival of the species?

And that is usually the first reaction from people's affairs. What? But listen, you're here for a reason both on the planet and on our podcast with all of our technical difficulties. So give it to us.

Tell people, tell us what are you here for? Sure. Well, I believe that the role of creation justice ministry is which I'm currently leading is really important in survival of the species because most people in the United States do identify with a faith community. And three of my members, we serve about 100,000 churches and 40 million people.

And that's a lot of people that need to be involved in our all hands on deck effort to protect the creation from climate devastation. How's that? That is perfect. Pretty much.

Pretty wonderful. I think we can wrap it up, right? That's been great. Yeah, that's been really great.

Thanks for coming. That's a lot of people. That's a lot of people. That's a lot of people that I think what she's saying is that she's in charge of all of those people.

I wish I wish they would all pay attention to climate change. We're working on it one by one. All right. Well, by the end of that.

Thank you. All right. So we're going to set up some context for today's question. And I do have to say this is one that fires me up a lot.

I'm from southeastern Virginia. My high school is 50% black and many of the kids, 70, 80% are on free lunch. There's an enormous amount of environmental injustice going on. And I appreciate so much of people like yourself and organizations like yours that are cranking on this thing.

So we're tinkering with our foreman a little bit. I'm going to take in some context. Brian usually gives a little silly book report as context. But he's got a lot silly.

Well, yes. He's going to take a little step back and try to come at this little more clean like our listeners again who can't just do research all time. He's kind of like a newborn child. The whole world is going to be open to him today.

So a lot of the questions will mostly be coming from him. And so he tries to stand in for listeners a little bit. So there's no question black and the Hispanic communities in America are overall poorer than the general population. So and we can get all in all the ways they're affected by the decisions we've made, specifically in this case for the past 100 years industrial area, the war on drugs, housing discrimination, et cetera, et cetera.

But today and always for us, we're focused on these relatively larger implications. And that's the environmental and health impacts of the past 100 years and going forward. So our poorest communities typically force the living areas where the rent is much cheaper. And why is it cheaper?

And by the way, jump in here at any time and tell me I'm wrong. Add something. Can I tell you, Aaron? No.

OK. No, that's why your mic doesn't work. I am. Yeah.

Well, a lot of the time it's because they're proximity to things like toxic waste, even if they don't know it. What kind of waste are we talking about? Lead, of course, ask Flint about that one. Past the sides, industrial chemicals, agricultural runoff, in the water, coal waste, fracking gases, nucuase, arsenic, septic waste.

And these communities, this is what that's what they're swimming in, right? Often literally. But they can't even say enough for themselves because they don't really have a lot of political power and why not? It's for a number of reasons.

We can start with the fact that the system isn't broken. It was designed this way. From the very beginning, from 16th time when we brought the first slaves over racism, is institutionalized and it covers a number of factors and it's being no doubt reinforced by our current administration. And I would argue before then.

Yeah. I mean, a solid colonization. Yeah, it absolutely didn't. Again, like I said, I'm from southeast and Virginia.

I live in next to Jamestown like that. Where it got started. And it has continued since. You know, we started poisoning the planet 110 years ago and these people are feeling at the worst.

And again, they can't stand up for themselves because we've made it so they can't. And if you read, there's a fantastic book by Professor Michelle Alexander called The New Jim Crow. And we talk about how we take that power away from them because of two things. One, many of the black males, young black males are in jail.

And two, we put most of our new prisons and many of the existing ones are in predominantly white areas. So why does that math matter? And that's because of a rule. And I think it's called usual residence, usual residency, which counts as incarcerated as residents of the district where they're being held, not where they're from.

So that means the right districts with prisons get more voting power as they seem larger than they are in more people and the poor black districts get less voting power. Oh my God. It seems like a popular sense decreased. And it has because of course we unjustly focus most of our law enforcement on young black males.

So they're just not there anymore. And if that sounds too, I held a lot like the three fifth clause. Again, Regime Crow. So I promise I'm getting somewhere here.

So that's a powerful read. I recommend it as well. It's even if you are inundated in the stuff and or if you're from one of these areas and understand it, it is so well researched and so comprehensive. If this doesn't get you in the streets, I don't know what to tell you.

Wow. So these, I mean, Brian, someone from Chicago, you have to read and understand this stuff to understand that Chicago is designed this way. Oh, yeah. You know, yeah, it's not a I love that say so much but holy power issues.

Yeah. So they've got less political power. Certainly less buying power. So these populations can't fend off the chemical plants, the bottoms, landfills, often mines, new power plants that we're still putting in from coming in the neighborhood.

And the government certainly doesn't give a shit what they say after cleaning up any of these existing issues. African American mothers are 100% more likely to live near a super fund cleanup site. And there's a 2011 paper said that proximity to a super fund site before cleanup is associated with a 20 to 25% increase in the risk of congenital anomalies. You're saying super fun?

Super fun cleanup sites. So that's the bad places, basically things have gone bad. We've got to clean them up. We just put some new jackass in charge.

It's not going to happen. Right. Basically. So we're giving these babies brain damage.

Good start. So what does that effect have? They've got lower test scores, ADD, higher crime rates, medical bills. There's a study of it in 2012.

It said the heavy metals, pesticides, et cetera. I've got 41 million IQ points off the American total. And you have to understand that it's not distributed equally. Right.

So it's not just the South, it's not just Michigan and Flint. We can talk about California's clean energy goals. We're Brian and I are, but we like to gloss over our raging inequality, which checks every box of the stuff I just talked about. On the EPA put a map in 2015, pinpointing 200,000 at risk communities for particular pollution, basically a lot of which is coming off tires off roads, trains, and Southern California's black and Latino communities not surprisingly.

It's the worst of it. Of course, there's no difference for them from Appalachia or Missouri or Mississippi. All this is reduced mobility. And if you want to argue with these health factors, I point you to all the research that's detailed on Americans brains have literally changed since we started cut out lead.

So to me, and we don't have to get into this part of it today, Shonta, but we hear a lot from some of these very rigid religious groups about pro-life and however life matters from conception, but we don't talk about the brain damage or giving black babies and the trains full of coal that Norfolk Southern runs through their communities, my old community throwing off particles so small that the mothers don't know their babies longs are damaged, except their babies are always sick. They're always sick. So we talk here about the conversations most vital to our survival of species, and it's a little ridiculous sounding, but we're facing the greatest threat our species has ever encountered, largely of our own making. And so no one's surprised at poor communities, often the community colors are taking the brunt of it.

We built the country on their backs and we continue to punish them. So to me, this couldn't be a more relevant and vital conversation to be having, because what's happening to them and has been happening to them is going to happen to the rest of us, unless we clean up our act and we've got a lot of work to do. So we appreciate what people like you are doing. Okay, that's enough, Bob, I'm sorry.

No, thank you very much for that. Yeah, well, forgive me. Very informative and very fucking sad. Yeah, but we can do it.

And people like Shampa and her community, it sounds like millions of people that she's in charge of again are changing everything. So let's talk about getting on board with environmental justice radical. A lot of folks have been fighting this fight for a long time. It's time to get our shit together.

So Shampa, your group, creation justice ministries, and I'm just stealing this right off your webpage. So it's based on the priorities of its members, with a particular concern for the vulnerable and marginalized creation justice ministries provides collaborative opportunities to build ecumenical community, guides people of faith and faith communities towards ecosystem justice transformations and raises a collective witness in the public arena echoing Christ's call for just relationships among all of creation. So how did you? You got that so inspiringly.

I feel like fired up and ready to change the world now. Yeah, that's the idea, man. Let's do this. How did you guys get on that path?

Again, we're not doing life story stuff, but what made you point that direction, working to raise a collective witness for those most affected? What does your work look like on a day to day basis? Tell me about you guys. Sure.

Well, I can give you a few examples of projects we're working on right now. Please. Two weeks from now, creation justice ministries, the NAACP interface power in light of Iowa and young evangelicals for climate action are getting together to do a series of workshops on energy equity. We're doing them in Sioux City, Des Moines, and Waterloo.

And we're bringing together faith leaders in those communities to talk about who's getting hurt first and worst because of our fossil fuel economy, who is paying the highest amounts for their energy bills disproportionate to their income. And the answer is communities of color. And so we're going to raise awareness about this from an inequy perspective and bring people on board with the idea of renewables as a solution going forward, not just for our climate, but also for equity. Is this happening only in Iowa or is it just like a one in a series?

It's a pilot project. So it's starting in Iowa and we're hoping to move it to more states soon. Why did you start with Iowa? But we found partners who are willing to work together in Iowa.

But Iowa is also a leader in wind power, which is really exciting. Sure. So it's a cool place to talk about renewables. Yeah, absolutely.

So what does your work besides something like that look like on a day to day basis? Is it constantly pursuing projects like that, finding partners to host a sort of thing? You know, is it lobbying to talk to me how it works? Yeah.

So we do a lot of event based work such as the workshops in Iowa. We also have done a few trainings in the Carolinas building a climate leadership bench of faith leaders from every congressional district in North and South Carolina who are ready to speak powerfully at rallies or to their members of Congress or through the written word about the moral imperative to act. And then we also have an annual Appalachia conference where we talk about just transition away from the fossil fuel economy and other extractives and towards more sustainable future. So those are a few examples of the event based things that we do.

Then we also do a lot of advocacy. So educating people about things like the weakening of our fuel economy standards or the weakening of our water rules or the pulling out of the Paris agreement, I mean, you name it in this administration we have been working on raising moral outcry about all the rollback. Wow. That's crazy.

So again, just thank you. I'm just going to keep saying that over and over again. Yeah, she keeps on that and just preparing it in. Right.

Just thank you. It sounds like it looks like when your focus includes reforming the coal industry. And by that, I mean, supporting those affected by this energy transition, which is underway, whether the administration likes it or not. And I feel like, and I think it's very true that these folks in that industry in those areas you talk about, the relationship consistently left behind often by stupid bullheaded progressives, like me or Brian, who want to clean break from our dirty past.

Coal was their livelihood and their grandparents and their parents. We've talked to some of those people, but now those people are sick. They're black lung, they're now out of a job and they're just trashed in the media as being for some terrible reason, the cause of our issues, which is ridiculous. And we wonder why they're voting for the bad guys.

Talk to me about your work there specifically and what we can all learn from that. Sure. So we've been partnering with councils of churches and non-profits in the Apple Atza region to build up a leadership group of people who will approach the transition from away from extractive economy, from a spiritual perspective. And the folks that were gathering intimately see this as connected to the life of the church, really, as the communities that they are serving are finding that jobs have gone away, that natural gas has taken over and the coal mining communities are left high and dry.

So where churches, the churches are shrinking and they're looking for ways to sustain more and more people who are looking for livelihood, looking for ways forward. And so we see the whole process of revitalizing the church in that region as being intimately connected to economic and ecological well-being of the region. And so what does that look like? We've been partnering on legislative advocacy, such as the Reclaim Act, to put people to work for claiming old minds in that region.

Actually, it's national. It would be all over the country, but it would especially help Apple Atza. There was a Reclaim Act legislation this year, but unfortunately it didn't go through. We also have supported Power Grants facilitated through the Appalachian Regional Committee Commission, which would empower certain areas in Appalachia to do economic revitalization projects to help them find the new economic sustenance in their communities.

Are you guys helping or would you be helping people find new jobs, like people out of work coal miners and stuff like that? So if the Reclaim Act had passed, it would have created thousands of jobs, but lots of people to work reclaiming minds, which is a first step towards the next sustainable economy is to heal the land. Can you just define for us exactly what reclaiming minds is and does? Yeah, so basically after mining activities have finished, the land is not very usable for other purposes.

It's been made toxic. And mining companies are responsible for paying into an abandoned mine land fund that is held by the federal government. And so money is already collected to reclaim these abandoned minds. It's got Pruitt spending it on a conference table?

No, not that part of money. Good. It's not a money that's just sitting there and the Congress has to release it. All they have to do is release it.

That's all they have to do. I don't know why you pretend like this is some sort of difficult thing, you know, as if they're not doing anything. So what are you doing to make them release it? So we had encouraged people to be contacting the members of Congress, having meetings about the moral imperative to heal creation and also heal our communities with new sustainable jobs.

And what we really liked about the Reclaim Act legislation that represented how Rogers put forward was that it included community development provisions along with the mine reclamation activities. So we had people talk about what they would do with our community if they were able to have some economic empowerment investment there. We also encouraged some religious leaders to get opinion pieces published in the media. And we did a call in day to Congress.

All of those efforts did not get Congress to pass the Reclaim Act. Is there any work being done on a new one, a modified new one that you would try to pass again? We might see one in the next Congress. We hope so.

Okay. Well, I mean, we might see a lot in the next Congress. Yeah. Or it's basically all over.

I think that's kind of it. It's just it's a big day. Hey guys, it's Quinn. If you're listening to this, you obviously like podcasts and you probably like music too.

On Spotify, you can listen to all of that in one place for free. You don't even need a premium account. On Spotify, you can follow your favorite podcasts. So you never miss an episode.

You can download episodes to listen to offline wherever you might be. And you can easily share what you're listening to with your friends via Spotify's integrations with social platforms like Instagram. Spotify has a huge catalog of podcasts on every topic, including the one you're listening to right now. You can just search for important, non-important on the Spotify app or browse podcasts in your library tab.

Very convenient. And of course, you can follow us. So you never miss an episode of important, not important. Spotify is the world's leading music streaming service.

And now it can be your go to for podcasts too. Are all these conversations that you're having with people or all this encouraging and everything that you're talking about? Is it happening in church ever? Like while the people are at mass?

Yeah, it depends on where. But certainly a lot of people are bringing these conversations to church. And one of the things that Creation Justice Ministries is doing to help facilitate that is encouraging certain times of year when you can have these conversations with people in the congregation. You know, a lot of our work does happen in conferences where people self-select and they're the people who are interested in these issues.

But it's also important to bring these issues to the quote unquote pews among people who might or might might not think about these things every day. And so good opportunities for that include Earth Day Sunday and every year we release a curriculum to equip religious leaders and congregational creation justice teams or green teams to lead conversations in their community. And then coming up very soon from September 1 through October 4 is the season of Creation, which is a set of weeks that are devoted for churches to celebrate God's creation. One way or another, it begins on September 1 with the World Day of Prayer for the Care of Creation, which is observed by the World Council of Churches.

It was started in the Orthodox Church. It involves the Pope Francis actually got on board with it two years ago. This guy, big fan. Yes, and now the Roman Catholic Church also celebrates it.

So it's gotten a lot of momentum in recent years. And then the other end of the season of Creation is October 4, which is St. Francis Day. And St.

Francis is known as many as the Patreon scientific ecology, St. Francis of Azizi. So just to pivot a little bit. So these are Appalachia and some of these areas are obviously much more, there's a greater awareness of what's happening there, obviously, because so much is transformed in those issues and they are being so left behind.

A lot of my concern is about these low-income communities where they are being poisoned. And oftentimes they don't know it. You hear about, I can come back to the String Company, Norfolk Southern, which runs through the South. They're these stories of how it blows through these communities in Virginia and how the Walter regulations basically say that I think it's like the only limit on how much coal dust they can emit is that it can't exceed the amount of coal that's passed through the terminal.

And so you have these entire communities where everybody is asthma. And these residents often don't realize it, or they try to bring, again, going back what we talked about earlier, they try to bring these companies to the table. And they just don't do it. And again, you want to talk about everything being connected, why our medical system is broken.

Is these people constantly going to the emergency room with asthma attacks? An entire community and babies. And I'm getting to the point where I want to know what groups like yourself can do to help those communities, whether it's specific going into black churches, whether it's activism, dropping leaflets, whether it's working with law firms, whatever it might be. And these people have a lower life expectancy because of these drinkers going through their towns.

And it's just completely insane to me. And it feels like, we talk about raising a collective witness. That to me has to be such a focus. So anyways, I'm just curious what your efforts are in rooms in areas like that, or if there are specific groups working towards those things, I'm sure they have been.

I'm sure they've been fighting for years. And it's just white people like us, they're just getting on board, which is infuriating for a number of reasons. But what can we do and how can we support those things? Well, there is a robust and under-resourced environmental justice movement that we partner with quite a bit that works at the local level.

So a lot of local community organizations are trying to tackle issues in their local communities, one in particular that we're working actively with in Florence, South Carolina is Kingdom Living Temple, which is run by, well, is passed by Leo Woodberry. Okay. And their community is bringing people together to raise awareness about climate changes impact on their community. They have experienced flooding in their area, they have experienced crazy rise in temperature, heat waves that put people in danger of heat stroke.

And so they have been working on particularly organizing their areas, South Carolina, for environmental justice issues, this frontline communities. Another group that we have visited and gotten to know a bit is the El Viho organization in Chicago. They have been doing a lot of really great work on getting truck depots out of their neighborhood, because those trucks just idle there in the middle of this residential area and give everybody exposure to air pollution and put them at risk for Amazon. Brian, you had a question about that?

What was the name of that one? Is Shanta, what was the name of that organization? Yeah, it's called El Viho. It's a little village environmental justice organization.

Is that Native American or is that Latin? Most of the leaders that are active in it are Latino. Gotcha. Interesting.

What part of Chicago is that? You're going to ask me that. I don't know Chicago that well. If you say something, Brian might have some sort of an idea.

Right. But we can look it up also. That's very interesting. There's just semi-idling in the next of homes.

That's infuriating. So let's talk about the, I guess, you guys are constantly trying to get anywhere from hyper local to district, to state, to federal government help in some way. We've got this new director of the EPA who's also a monster, but he said he's vowed to improve communication with low-income and communities of color. Again, disproportionately, I mean, that's a challenge by environmental issues.

But I obviously don't believe it for a second. He said we fell down on our responsibilities to Flint. Can you talk a little bit about if you have any sort of relationship with the EPA in the past or what it's like now, or what would be the most effective conversation with them going forward? Yeah.

So our organization has always maintained a commitment to building relationships with the Department of Interior and the Environmental Protection Agency and any agencies that deal with issues that our communities care about. And we have met with every EPA administrator since I can remember since the organization started to understand their priorities and how to go about working with them. I will say that there are parts of the Environmental Protection Agency that are still doing their job and are still able to partner with our communities. And it's important to maximize the partnership that we can find with anybody who's willing to do their job because people can't wait.

People can't wait for the next administration to pass. No, it's really easy for a lot of folks to say that to say like, oh, well, just you wait after November 6. But what about these folks with the sick kids who got the... I'm trying so hard not to curse because I know that's probably not your ball game.

I usually drop a lot of F bombs in these things. But again, like, semis idling in communities or, you know, we talk about climate change a lot. But you know, this conversation, it's like, oh, hey, you guys, you all got asthma. But also now it's flooding.

You're welcome. And it feels like I am glad there are so many people doing those jobs. And I have a friend in the office of Budget Management, which is our management budget. And the head of that place is literally the enabler of all of these draconian issues.

But he had to make a choice. Do I stay there and fight or do I leave and fight? And it's a damn hard choice that he wrestles with every day. He's still there.

No, he's still there. I mean, he's called while we've been recording. And every major regulation that we care about that relates to protecting creation, we have made sure we book a meeting with Office of Management and Budget to let them know our opposition to it being rolled back. If your folks are in the DC area or able to travel to DC and you can set up a meeting, that is an agency that is often really overlooked.

And they are the ultimately people are the only people. No idea how powerful they are. No idea how powerful they are. They're so boring.

Yeah. What they do, right? Which is run the game show. Right.

And that is what's super dangerous. Wow. Is we, you know, most people don't know what they do. We might have to think that we might have to get them on like, yeah, I style with them with a horseball, you know, put him in a silhouette.

I would screw that up somehow and just have like a spotlight on him. Here's his name and it's a scary number. Sorry. Yeah, I'm glad there's people fighting and I'm so glad you guys are able to find those folks and partner with them.

And obviously if they're out there listening, thank you for still doing your jobs and fighting until we can hopefully turn this thing around. But like you said, there's some people that can't wait. So that brings me to talking a little bit about this incredible woman, Rashida Tlaib, who's just super strangely elected technically, well, theoretically, I guess, not technically, yeah, elected to Congress in Michigan, and that she doesn't have a Republican challenger in the election. But she's going to represent Detroit.

Our first, I believe I might mangle this. She's definitely our first Muslim woman in Congress, or will be and I think also first Palestinian, but she's going to represent Detroit. Obviously, not just Detroit, Michigan's having the environmental justice issues all over the place. And Flynn is obviously a huge issue.

We're going to start a space force, but we can't get them fresh water. Kalamazoo has all kinds of shit in their water, sometimes literally Detroit, has water shut offs a few times a year, which is crazy. I cannot imagine what they're interested in. This city is fighting to get back off the ground and in some ways to succeed it.

But it's, there's a new law that let's put literally representatives polluting companies, Brian, sit on panels with a powerful right policy and pollution permitting decisions made by the state. So they have seats on that board, and that's just business as usual. So she's got a look it out for us. Is that okay?

So how? Right? Well, it's the people in charge and they capitulate to the money that's involved. But I want to again, it is what it is.

How do we support people like her? How do we get more folks like her in the office in these areas where even the smallest dent could make such a difference? Well, creation justice ministries is not in the business of campaigning. Sure.

No, of course. We do educate candidates. And I hope that Rashida Sleeve and any other incoming members of Congress really pay attention to the climate and also to water issues in how they're connected. And in Rashida Sleeve's case, she has plenty of stories to share from Detroit about the watershed offs and how they have affected the public health in the community.

And she's in a great position to advocate for water as a human right, which is something that creation justice ministries really supports. There is plenty of clean water and safe water advocacy to do. And I hope that she champions that when she comes in. It seems like she's making that a big, big focus, obviously.

I think if you went into coming from that situation, that area and you went into Congress with anything else but that, it would be a little weird. But she seems pretty hell bent on that. So again, talking about what will happen on November 6, getting people like her in there and more folks like her who it's great that you guys don't handle campaigning because we need to do other things and the education part is just as important. It's not more important in times because some of our first conversations were with folks who work on the Hill and do do lobbying a lot of times.

And they'll tell us how some of these representatives vote one way because they're just not educated on the specific topic, which that's a failure along with the chain of command. It's terrible because we have to educate these people so they can understand what's happening. It's kind of terrible to put it, but it's great. They're seeing fucking wildfires on their TV now.

This is what we got. You don't have an education. Everything is on fire. You can see this, right?

Yeah, you can. Right. Can't miss that. One thing that we do a lot of is we educate members of Congress about what their own religious traditions say about caring for creation.

And it's a great job. Yeah. So we work with a variety of denominations to say, listed them all off for you earlier. And then we also partner.

I believe it was just all of them, correct? We have a lot of religious diversity in the United States. And I do think that bringing different religious and moral perspectives to the table when understanding how the great traditions have talked about the earth and our relationship to creation and our responsibility to one another is a really important starting place for understanding what our collective values are. And those values, conversations need to reflect the diversity of our country.

So I think it's exciting that we finally would have Muslim women in Congress. So where do you see in bringing all those people together? It sounds wonderful and harmonious. I imagine a time it's not or it's difficult at least.

Where do you see most of your obstacles and complications on that front? Interestingly, on environmental issues, there's very little barrier to working together. The issues that come up are often logistical. Let's make sure we don't schedule things on anyone else's holiday.

Jesus, literally, if that's the issue, if that's your biggest issue, then that's great. You've the it's such broad and strong agreement about care, moral imperative to care for creation across religious traditions. It's pretty astounding. There are some issues that religious communities have a difficult time working together on, but environment is not one of them.

Well, and that's we try to reach out to folks that we probably disagree with on. Right. What would you say Brian? 99 out of 100 things.

Good news is this one. It seems like a lot of folks are on board and we've come back to this a million times. We think it's an important theme for us to remember. And also our listeners is that often the messenger is more important than the message and why someone like you or Reverend Hescox are better suited to talk to their communities than stupid Greenpeace or NPR shouting at them all the time.

That's not going to be really effective. Well, meeting people where they're at is a huge part of the way that we do our work, for sure. Well, we could all learn something from that. So I have one more sort of wonky question before we get into some specific steps.

So a lot of folks, and when we talk to people who work with folks who are already in Congress, who are either have either demonstrated that they want to take action or have told people behind the scenes that they'd be willing to under certain conditions, yada yada starts to feel like there's a there's a lot of momentum ish for a carbon tax or revenue neutral carbon fee is the way to get our shit together on climate and clean energy action. The issue, I guess, is getting it passed might require with doing away with a number, if not, most of the current regulations that are barely keeping our head above water as it is when it comes to clean water and clean air and such. So most of these communities already don't have a voice in how these big sweeping decisions are made. How what and feel free to just say, I have no idea, but what do you or I don't speak for them?

What do you think they would say if we actually did give a shit about what they said? Sorry, who is they? They is, you know, again, these these poorer communities or Appalachia or or the Latin communities or the folks in Chicago. Any idea on that front, because I'm just coming, you know, we try to get people to work most specifically with their voice and their phone and their dollar and that means talking to their local and state representatives and starting to build momentum for something like this, some big, big change.

And if it's going to be some sort of carbon neutral revenue fee, you know, I'm curious to hear what these communities have to say about that and have to what their fears might be about the fact that a lot of these regulations, the clean power plan, the clean water plan might go away in place of a fee like this. Yeah, I think it's incredibly important to listen to a variety of communities about how any kind of carbon pricing scheme could impact them. We have been getting feedback and one of the key concerns is the regulatory rollback that might accompany any viable carbon pricing legislation that we could see because the regulatory rollbacks would be the last best safeguards for environmental justice communities that they need to protect their basic clean air and clean water. And so we see regulatory rollback as a non-starter in terms of any carbon pricing scheme.

And we would like to see also that all communities that are low income will be benefiting from a carbon pricing legislation as well. So that means that, you know, if it's a revenue neutral carbon pricing package that, you know, there is a special effort to return a larger amount to lower income communities, either through a check to them individually or through remediation for pollution that has been in their communities for years or climate change, adaptation or mitigation. The bad word people throw out is reparations, but it's insane to me that that's not part of the discussion. Well, we need to make it part of the discussion.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Most Important Question?

This episode is 1 hour and 15 minutes long.

When was this The Most Important Question episode published?

This episode was published on August 28, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Most Important Question episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.