Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Mikey. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Mikey, welcome back. Thank you, Uri. It's good to be back. Rivki wasn't able to make it again this week because she's preparing for her wedding. Mazel tov. Mazel tov. And so we are very excited to welcome back Mikey Friedman as a repeat guest host on Talking Talkless. I heard a couple of weeks ago a really good podcast you had where you had another guest host, and it made me itching for more. Yeah, well, I mean, it is a lot to live up to on your part because Dina really, first of all, did an amazing job, but also brought in...
a record number of downloads and listens for us. So we'll see what you can do for us this week. Okay. Wow. Well, so Mikey, you and I had been discussing for the last couple of days.
what to talk about. And so I understand that you had a pretty rigorous research regiment in preparation. You want to tell us about that? Yeah. Well, I kind of ended up going down the rabbit hole. I went back and re-listened, even though I've already listened once to every episode. I was listening at about three and a half X, a little bit faster and reviewed and wrote notes on over 13 and a half hours of you guys. That makes me really self-conscious because if you're taking this seriously, that means I have to take this seriously. And that makes...
that puts the pressure on me and it scares me, but I'm very flattered that you did that. And did you notice any, I'm very curious to ask, did you notice any trends? Did anything stand out in binging all the episodes back to back like that? Yeah. Well, first of all, you guys have been doing a great job. So if you've been able to do that without taking it seriously, all the power to you. Yeah, let's see. There were a few themes that I ended up, I started clustering different episodes into different themes. You guys have a lot of recurring themes. For most of them, I think I'll focus on you, Uri, since you're the one who's here. But one thing that comes up a lot is whether we hold Jews up to a higher standard than other people and whether we can get away with
either doing things to Jews or saying things about Jews that we couldn't necessarily get away with for other kinds of people and maybe why that is. Like, do we hold them or should we hold them? Or, like, both? Yeah, I think both. You guys try to, like, deal with that issue and figure it out. So the Jay-Z lyric, you know, where he talks about that Jews own all the real estate came up in a couple of podcasts or things like that. Uh-huh.
Something that I was wondering is, do you think our style and or opinions slash attitudes have evolved at all over the 31 episodes? I think you guys definitely have a little bit more rhythm down. You do a lot more tit for tat. And I found myself writing a lot more details in the last 10 episodes or so than I was at the beginning. In the beginning, I was just kind of writing down topic headers. And by the end, I found myself giving a whole small notebook page to an episode. Okay. Can I give you a couple of highlights? Please. Okay. So I think two of your zaniest podcasts were about religion. I'm curious if you could guess the two that I have in mind.
Not sure. I bet that our podcast listeners will at least get one of them. One of them was on what day of creation aliens were created. I remember that one. And another one was whether prophecy was this sort of drug-induced reality for people. That was one of my favorites also. They were pretty interesting. You also really, I think, like the Mike Pence Hamilton story that came up in a couple of episodes. For those who want to go back, it's episodes 10 and 26. And I have one more big topic that I want to get to, but I think that'll lead us into our next conversation. Okay, great. So why don't you start us off? What did you want to talk about?
Okay, so for our first topic, I want to talk about something that started happening on the podcast right after our episode. So listeners will remember that in episode 17, Uri and I talked about millennials and how they connect to Judaism, and we also talked about how women connect to Judaism at different times in their lives. So an issue that came up after that podcast that also I think you guys ended up discussing in the next one was that we were two men in a room talking about women's issue. Right. I found it curious that going back through all the episodes, in the first 17 podcasts, you guys made no mentions or call-outs about whether or not you were empowered to talk about some topic. But since that episode, in 18, you mentioned that we weren't women, which is true. And then after that, in 20, you mentioned you're both not Palestinian. In 23, you mentioned that you're a male about to talk about women's issues again. In 23, you both also mentioned you're not gay. In 26, you reminded us you're not journalists. Ola Rifki contested that. In 27, you mentioned you're not an immigration lawyer. In 28, that you again are not a woman. And in 29, you mentioned that you are empowered to talk about the conversation because you are both Jewish, both millennial, and both birthright staff.
Wow, Mikey, I'm blown away. So Uri, my question for you. So I'm not a lot of things. I don't really know what I am, but I know what I'm not. Yeah, and we all know what you're not too. But I guess that got me thinking in seeing it come up over and over again. I'm curious to hear from you what you think the value is in calling that out. And also I have, I've worked on here three points that I think are interesting about that topic. That is really interesting that you point out that we started doing that after it came up on an episode that you were on. To be really honest, I think the reason I do it, we do it, obviously it comes from a place of sensitivity. It also comes from a place of...
self-consciousness that like we're putting this out there and I don't want to say something that's going to offend people so if there are these qualifying statements I can make that will prevent or lessen the likelihood of like people being mad at me for something then why not just say it you know what I mean like what I understand the reason to say it which is it might upset people or I might just not be qualified to talk about something that I don't have in my lived experience and what would be the downside of saying it other than I guess sounding maybe unsure of myself yeah I think those are good points and I think I want to riff off of that a little bit later and kind of dig into why it might offend people or why it would help to not offend them if you called it out first. I kind of want to go through an evolution of some of my first thoughts that occurred to me afterwards. So my first realization, I guess, about this topic is that before I come on this podcast, both times, I get very nervous about representing something that I don't know a ton about, but like intellectually. So I'd be afraid to talk about some topic because I'm not an expert in that thing that I'm talking about. And so what makes me qualified to talk about it? But I noticed that I'm much less sensitive as I was on that podcast in talking about somebody else's experience that's not directly mine. And maybe I should. I mean, it sounds like I should. Right. Well, I mean, that's really interesting because I think it's...
very possible that that's like the opposite of the way most people approach these kinds of things. I guess because there isn't like some group of geniuses that are going to be offended when people talk about, you know, topics, but there are like, I guess, minority groups or oppressed groups of people who would be offended theoretically if somebody who's not in the group is talking about the group. But I mean, why is it that you don't feel as self-conscious about doing that, qualifying that? Yeah, it's a good question. I think, well, I'm not sure I have a good answer for why I haven't developed that sensitivity as much and maybe...
throughout my life I'll start to develop it more I think even going through these reflections I've started feeling a little bit more I would say maybe the group that this is going to sound pretentious but it is what it is the group that I associate with or the kinds of podcasts that I listen to are more intellectual in nature you said there wasn't necessarily a group of people but maybe the group of people that I'd be nervous about being called out by is people who are either intellectual or have certain expectations of the people who are consuming their podcast time Okay, so the second thing that I wanted to call out is that it seemed to me in thinking about this that there was a difference between the notion of somebody saying, you know, that conversation would have been enhanced if you had somebody in the room who was a little bit closer to the topic. That makes a lot of sense, and it's kind of in line with the more intellectual argument I was describing in the first part. But the notion that maybe we should have called out in our discussion that we weren't some minority group, that rubbed me a little bit more the wrong way.
Maybe it shouldn't have. I'm not saying that it should or shouldn't have. But it was interesting to me that the same notion, the same, we could all agree on the point that the conversation would be better or enhanced by having somebody closer to the topic. But the idea, I guess, of needing to ask permission or go through some ritual before I could endeavor in stating my opinion felt a little bit more aggressive than the flip side of it. Interesting. I mean, I guess the most aggressive thing that someone could say is not that you should qualify that that's not your experience, but rather you just can't talk about that. That would be the extreme. So like the way I see it is...
If you add that qualification, whether or not it's absolutely necessary, once you say it, you sort of like deflate that attack of like, you know, the only thing you can now say is you just can't talk about something, which I think is easy to give a counter argument to that, like, why I should be able to talk about it. And you can say, not only can I talk about it, I was even sensitive. I said, I'm not this, you know. Yeah. It's sort of playing it safe. Yeah. And I think that's an interesting point. And I think is in line with what you were saying at the top when you mentioned that you'll at least call it out so as not to offend anybody. Right. Like you said, it deflates. What's the downside is what I'm asking. Do you have an answer? What would be the downside?
I guess the downside to me is, and I'm not advocating this, but the downside of being required to say it is, why should I be required? Maybe it's nice, but it doesn't feel like I should need to put out all my qualifiers before I state my opinion. It's just my opinion. And I think this actually brings me into third, the last piece. Great, which is? Yeah, and the last piece is, let's take, for example, you did a podcast about the death tax, do you remember? Right, all the way in the beginning. All the way in the beginning, yeah. And so afterwards, I'm guessing, you can correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing that people didn't come over to you afterwards and say, hey, you didn't call out that you're not a policy wonk on taxes or whatever, right? Right, right. That's what happened. Right, because I think on the intellectual grounds, I think people know that
You know that you're not a policy wonk on death tax. But I think what makes this a sensitive issue is that when you don't call out that you don't have somebody's lived experience, the people who are listening are not necessarily confident that you know when you're speaking that you don't have the full context and that you're aware that there are other perspectives on the world and other experiences that are not your own. And I would guess that this comes from the fact that we're both white men and white men have historically not been as sensitive to every other minority group's way of viewing the world. And so it's just not automatic that people will give us that gracious assumption that we are aware that... We can't quite fully speak for everybody. And so I think that'd be the reason why people would not necessarily expect you to say, well, I'm not an immigration lawyer, but they do want you to call out just so that they know that you know that I've never lived this experience. Totally. And also, as I kind of was saying before, immigration lawyers don't have a history of being oppressed or being silenced in any kind of way. So I think that is a big part of it also. Yeah, I think that's true. You guys have talked about...
calling transgender people by their preferred pronouns, right? Like whether there should be a law that obligates you to, I think this was in the Jordan Peterson episode, or whether it's just a nice thing to do. And it is just a nice thing to do. And you should do nice things for people who want you to do something nice for them. So you're making a similar type of, that's what Jordan Peterson said. He said, I'm happy to call somebody by the pronoun that they prefer. But if you tell me I am obligated by law to do it, then I'm going to push back. So I'm not saying I'm going to push back. And also, I also feel the need to say that I...
This topic is not something that is close to my heart and my views. I know you're a very kind, sensitive person. So that's why people shouldn't say this too. But it was to the intellectual end of, I think, trying to represent what you're saying, which is it doesn't hurt you to do it. And if it makes other people not feel isolated or powerless or whatever negative feeling they might get from it, then why not?
I am a male. Neither of us is Palestinian. Neither of us are journalists. I'm not an immigration lawyer. I'm not an expert in either immigration law or law enforcement. This conversation that we've been having is a very heteronormative one. I'm not an expert on the history of feminism. So, I mean, I guess this is a good time for our weekly disclaimer. We are not feminists. I am not a woman.
Now that we've established the concept of what we can't talk about or who we aren't, what might be a topic that we would be squarely qualified to address? Yeah, so I thought it might be interesting to talk about a topic that you and Rifki have mentioned a couple of times in the past. Do you happen to know which episodes we spoke about this issue? Yeah, obviously. So in episodes five and six, you talk about this. I think in five, you were at an Intelligence Squared conference, and you were asking a question wearing a kippah, and you thought that affected the answer you got. You also went to an anti-Semitism in Israel conference, and you said that wearing a kippah there, you were curious to see what reactions it provoked. And I think in one other...
One, Rivki referenced that when she went to Poland, she was scared and she wasn't used to that in contrast to perhaps how men sometimes feel when they get stares for wearing a kippah. And I think you had one other story that was pretty funny. Right. This was from the Hadar panel where the topic was, what does feminist Torah look like? I'm Judith Blasco. I grew up in a classical reform congregation in which women were on the bima only to light candles Friday night. Men did not cover their heads in our temple and a man who came in with a kippah would have been asked to remove it. But the rabbi was opposed to the ordination of women because it was against tradition.
And I just thought that was so fascinating. I guess now I will have to qualify. I am not a reformed Jew, and I don't think you are either. So neither of us really have experience in that community. So I don't know the history of the policy of wearing a kippah and not wearing a kippah in reformed shuls. So I don't want to get into it. But I just thought that was really interesting. So it sounds like you want to talk about wearing a kippah. What about it specifically? One thing I was curious about is the extent to which I know that you wear a kippah most of the time outside. And I guess I'm curious to hear from you, how cognizant are you when you're outside that you're wearing a kippah? And does it affect your behavior and why?
I like that question. I happen to be a very self-conscious person in general, so I'm constantly conscious of many things about myself and my appearance. So one of them being the fact that I have a kippah on my head. It's probably in my head when I'm in public. I think it's on my mind constantly. I mean, you wear a kippah also. Is that your experience? Yeah, I'm not sure if we are representative or if we just both happen to be very self-conscious. But yeah, I do. Whenever I'm in public.
wearing a kippah, I'm very cognizant of it. You know, just on my way here, I was coming through Penn Station in rush hour. And as you just have to do, sometimes I would cut somebody off. And with every step, I was cognizant of the fact that somebody's going to see that somebody cut them off and that person is wearing a kippah. And even though that's the way that the world works in Penn Station at 5 p.m., I still, I guess, I'm nervous that I'm creating some negative bias in their head or perpetuating a negative bias. And it's something that I always feel like I have to be on alert for. Yeah. I mean, see, you were asking me earlier if I ever take off.
my keep off for any circumstances. So at first my thought was no, because like as a policy, I want to be proud of who I am. And so I'm not, I'm definitely not the kind of person that when I like go out with my friends, I'll take my keep off. Like I never really understood that practice and I don't like it. But then when I thought about it, I realized that I actually do occasionally take my keep off and in a very specific type of circumstance that relates to your Penn station example. And that is, so one scenario would be when I'm driving and
let's say I find myself that I need to cut in to some kind of line or any kind of questionable driving practice that I don't purposely put myself into that situation, but I find myself in that situation, I will instinctively take off my kippah so that if the person looks at me, they won't see a guy with a kippah cutting into the line or whatever. And then another time that I was just thinking about now, which is I think even funnier or more interesting, is anytime I'm... buying something and there is some degree of like haggling or bargaining involved, I will always, if I can, before entering into this situation, I'll take off my kippah because I don't want to be seen as like the cheap Jew haggling for a cheaper price. Yeah, that one in particular. Yeah, exactly. There's like a coin on the floor. Even if I'm about to like, in my head, I know I'm going to put it in charity or I'm going to give it to somebody. Even on my way here, there was a wallet on the floor that I returned to the station. And in doing so, I was aware that a lot of eyes are now seeing a Jew bending down and picking up a stranger's wallet. And I was nervous about it. But you didn't take off your kippah? I didn't take off my kippah. So do you ever take it off? I do sometimes take it off in situations.
that are similar to what you're saying, but also I'll say there are some times where I feel relief. For example, in the winter, I'll use another subway example just because, but in the winter I'll feel relief if I'm wearing a hat and it's winter and I can, it just frees me to hold the subway door for a second until I get myself on. You know, these aren't behaviors that are ideal, but they're by no means like social faux pas, but in having my kippah not exposed because I have a hat on my head, I feel just a little bit more freedom to be a regular person in society and not hold myself. to a higher standard. Right. I think it's interesting. I think the reason why we do things like that is because, especially in, like, the modern Orthodox community, we're, like, instilled with this concept of chil Hashem, like, desecrating God's name. And so, like, we are representing our community and our people by being visibly Jewish. And that was just, like, instilled in us, for better or for worse. I think for better. It happens to be, I think, in the last, you know, number of years, it's become very trendy to express one's...
ethnic identity. It's like an authentic expression. Yeah, meaning there was a time maybe earlier in the 20th century when the melting pot concept was pushed very strongly, especially with Jews, immigrants coming in. I actually recently was on a tour of the Lower East Side of the Jewish history there, which was fascinating. And they talked a lot about, let's say, the established Jews who were already there, who were taking care or helping out of the Eastern European Jews who were coming in in the early 20th century.
And there was a very big focus on Americanizing them and getting rid of their accent. In extreme cases, getting rid of any sign of Judaism in them and making them into real Americans. And that's not the approach nowadays for, you know, not just with Jews, with any kind of minority. And so like, honestly, when I walk down the street and I see a Sikh with like a beard and a turban on his head, my reaction is like, oh, good for you. Like, that's awesome. Like, I love that you're, you know, showing your identity. And then I think sometimes about...
being embarrassed that I'm wearing a kippah that I feel like I stand out where everyone's looking at me because I'm different. But then I remind myself, well, why am I proud of the Sikh but embarrassed about myself? It could be my personal neuroses. I don't know. Probably a combination. So what do you think, Ari? Is it a good thing that when we're wearing a kippah in public, we hold ourselves to this higher standard and we're almost nervous in trying to preempt somebody else from forming a bias about us? Or should we be more comfortable just being in the world like the Sikh that you described? I mean, I...
I don't think wearing a kippa makes somebody a better person, just if that wasn't clear, obviously. And it does make people look at you and maybe have certain expectations. For me, and this is something that I've thought about a lot in the past, I think there are costs and benefits, meaning I do feel a little bit more stress, a little bit more pressure in certain situations. But at the same time, first of all, a big part of me likes being held to a standard or to be reminded I should do the right thing. Maybe it's a superficial thing, but it...
just another reminder to like, think about what I'm doing, I think is a positive, you know, influence. And when I do something that I'm proud of, like, you know, I help somebody on the subway, or I help somebody carry a suitcase up the stairs, or whatever it is, and I'm wearing a kippah. So I mean, I'm It's something to be happy about whether or not you're visibly Jewish or whatever. But if I'm wearing the kippah, I think in my head like, oh, now they think Jews are good and kind and whatever. That's such a good call. I exactly get that same feeling of just like a thousand Jewish points for somebody to see me with a kippah doing something good. So those benefits to me outweigh whatever costs you might say are involved in the stress or the pressure and whatever. Yeah, interesting. So I think it's a net win. One extra thing I wanted to mention is that through all this, it's interesting, even the conversation that we've had about...
having our kippah on and taking our kippah off is an interesting, on the one hand, it's a burden sometimes for us to have a kippah on, but also of the different ways that people can be stereotyped, there's a luxury in at least having the option to take your kippah off and then blend into a crowd. Right. Some people can't, you're saying if somebody is black, they can't take off their blackness to go on the subway. Yeah. Well, one last thought about the kippah thing that I was kind of thinking about is that, yes, on the one hand, we are, I think, very qualified to talk about this because we are Jewish men and we wear kippahs, but we are men talking about this and there are Jewish women who also wear kippahs, maybe not Orthodox women, but in other denominations.
I was always very fascinated by that. Like, I think when you see something that you're not used to seeing, you automatically have a reaction to it. But that doesn't. And then so it feels negative. Like when I see a woman wearing a keep, I'm like, oh, whoa, that's weird. But then I say my head like, OK, it's only weird because I'm not used to that. And it's not what I'm how I grew up. But like, is it inherently weird or I don't, you know, so I don't really know again because not my how I grew up. I don't know the rationale or the history of that. I assume it's just some kind of like equality thing. Like men and women should be doing the same thing and practicing the same way. One observation that I've had, though, about that.
Which is very not PC, and this might upset people, so maybe not the best way to finish off. But I think it's kind of funny, and ironic mainly, which is that there's basically two main kinds of head coverings in Judaism. There's the kippah, and there is the practice for married women to cover their heads. And depending on the style and the type of head covering, those two head coverings could theoretically be very similar, you know, objectively to an outsider looking at it. But the women who cover their heads with a kippah, I'm willing to bet, are almost never the same women who would be covering their heads.
for being married. And for many of those women, huge assumption, but I'm assuming they would perceive one of those head coverings as being like empowering and a feminist statement, the kippah, and the other one as potentially, you know, like oppressive of women because it's for like modesty purposes. But to an outside observer, they could see the woman with the head covering and they wouldn't necessarily even know the difference of why they're doing it. And obviously I understand that these are two very different types of things coming from very different rationales. If a woman wants to wear a kippah because she feels it makes her feel closer to God or more spiritual, like...
I'm completely fine with that. And if she doesn't believe in a married woman covering her head for modesty, like I'm totally fine with that also. I just think it's ironic and interesting. And I guess it's kind of like an example of how the context of something can change its meaning so much, even when to an outsider looking in, it looks exactly the same. Fine. So let me tell, let me tell, keep a story on the other side of the spectrum. Great. So once when I was in elementary school, I was at Hershey Park on a Holomoe trip and I was at the kosher area.
for, I don't know, some meal, probably dinner. And they were davening mincha there. And so I was wearing a hat then and a kippah under my hat. And out of respect for prayers, I took my hat off. And there was somebody standing next to me in the same minyan who I would guess was a little bit more yeshivish than I was. And that community likes to double cover their head for davening. And so he asked me if he could take the hat that I had just taken off my head and put it on his head for davening. And I just thought it was a very funny, which is a very funny commentary, I guess, on the way that different people approach kippah. That is very funny. And I guess that also gets into letter of the law versus spirit of the law and the technicality versus like what it's supposed to represent or look like. But that is a really funny story. I love that story.
Well, Mikey, thank you so much for joining me today. I hope we didn't have too much toxic masculinity on that episode. I think there might have been a little bit. Do you know Noah Efron from the Promise podcast? Not personally, but from the podcast. I love him. I love that podcast. But I remember something that he once said, which is that he will not be on any kind of panel discussion that has more than one person if there's not a woman on the panel with him, which I thought was in some ways extreme. But I think it's also very interesting and obviously very thoughtful of him. And that made me think a lot about...
that concept, and I guess what we were talking about, and I guess we just violated his rule on this podcast. You said more than two, right? Well, so I said more than one, but I don't remember if it was two or more than two when he said it, but even just still, so if he had a third person here, that person, by his rule, would have to be a woman. Yeah, and I'm not sure that I describe, he's an activist in some way for this cause, and like you, I think that he's making a point, and there's value in being an activist for whatever cause you're being an activist for, but maybe not everybody needs to be held to those same activist standards. Right, so like I said, I think it's extreme, but I thought it was very interesting that he has that as a steadfast rule. Yeah.
Well, Uri, yet again, this was really a lot of fun. Thanks again for letting me on. Of course. So good to have you. You can be our official archivist, I think. I accept. Wow. I didn't know you would pay me for something I would already do. I did not say there was money involved. Of course, if anybody else wants to contribute, you can find us and keep the conversation going on our Facebook page. Obviously, subscribe on your podcast app. Give us a good rating. And you can also email us, TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions for sponsoring this week's episode. I guess we might have to give some of that money to you for your archival duties. A humble fee. And thanks so much to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless.
You know where I noticed on the podcast that Dina did that at the very end she had a little bye at the end. Yeah, I don't know if she does that naturally or if she was imitating me. Well, either way, I'd like to think that I started maybe a small tradition last time I was on the podcast. Okay, great. So I'll let you do it again. So we'll see you next time. Bye. Bye.