If you're a Disney Plus subscriber and you're watching The Mandalorian, Jack and I have a podcast for you. Every week, we'll discuss the latest episode of The Mandalorian and talk about other great content and maybe some not-so-great content on Disney Plus as well. As two lifelong Star Wars fans, we have a ton of fun geeking out over all the little details of the show, and we want you to join us every Monday. So search for Disney Plus Reviews. That's Disney, P-L-U-S, Reviews. Hey, Phil, how about that, Baby Yoda? Baby Yoda says, that's the podcast. Live from a bunker in the heart of the Ozarks, a podcast that's delivering on its part two before Dune, it's Sif Pop.
Welcome to Cif Pop Weekly Streaming Live. Most Saturday mornings are available to download later in your podcast feed. Unless, of course, you're a patron. Patrons get perks. Patrons get those perks. Got to. I'm your host, Aaron Dicer, and every performance is his best of the year. It's Andrew Ormsby, ladies and gentlemen. Ahoy. Each week we'll chat about movies, TV, and whatever else from the pop culture universe is on our minds. And please welcome our guest this week. He's still talking about Come On, Come On, Getting Robbed. It's Robert Bouffard. Hello.
And he's trying to remember why exactly he did like Reminiscence. It's Aaron Schweitzer. Guys, welcome to part two of the Sifties. Man, thanks for coming back a week later, guys. Man, it's been a long week. How's everybody been this week? None of us showered. We're filming back-to-back, unlike Dune. That's right, that's right. Yes, we were doing this the correct way.
We're excited to get into it. We have a lot to talk about because we're doing two full countdowns with all four of us. The categories for part two of the sifties are the big boys. You got the best performances of the year. As previously, the last several years, we do not distinguish for gender or amount of time or anything. These are just the best performances we saw on the screen in 2021. And then we'll have our best movies of the year as well. And again, I will mention that some of those you may think of as 2020 movies because of the way the awards calendar went last year. But there are plenty of movies that came out in January or...
February last year that even though they were up for awards of 2020 are technically 2021 movies that we didn't see until this year so just a heads up on that we will do between those two big categories we will do our favorite moments of the year favorite movie moments that will be nomination style we'll each have three nominations and pick a favorite of those we will also pick a favorite of the best performance and best movie between the four of us we will agree on one and then we will kick it off of course with the official sift pop top 31 movies this year, I think is what we're going to do. So basically, each year the top list is determined by how many movies get at least two votes. If a movie gets two votes, it gets on the list. So I think there were 31 movies that got at least two votes this year. We will talk more about that as we finish up with that later. So like I said, lots to do. So let's go ahead and get into it. We will kick it off with the top 10 performances of 2021.
I said a lot of different years. I don't know if I got them all right, but I think we're doing 2021. All right, we'll go for number 10, number one. That's what I did. We are doing BEC rules, so if you have something higher, feel free to trump it, and maybe we'll have some honorable mentions at the end. We will see. Let's kick it off with number 10. Aaron, you're going to start. What is your number 10 performance of 2021?
Yeah, this one has a lot of baggage attached to it. So Daniel Craig in 007. Interesting. Okay. It's maybe not quite to the caliber of an Oscar win, but I think he's done so much incredible stuff with the character, especially as simultaneously watching some of the old ones. Him in this movie as compared to something like Roger Moore in Live and Let Die is two different franchises. I think he's made quite a legacy for himself. Yeah. Good choice. Very close to putting him on my list. Very close. He's great. He's absolutely great in this. So yeah, I don't begrudge that choice at all. Robert, what do you got at number 10?
I'm going to redeem this movie. I'm going to keep doing it. I'm putting Joaquin Phoenix in. Come on, come on. Because Joaquin, I always think of as intense or there's something off about his character. But this one, he's very tender. And I don't often see that from him. And I really loved it. I felt so comforted by it. I was anxious when he was anxious. I loved when he loved. He drew me in completely. I loved that performance. One of my favorites of his.
Very nice. Joaquin Phoenix in a number 10. Andrew, what do you got for your number 10? You may hate the movie, but I hope you can at least appreciate the performance in this movie. I'm going Tahar Rahim in The Mauritanian. Okay. I think he is working on another level compared to some A-list actors. I mean, he's going up against Jodie Foster. Even though she's young, Shailene Woodley has definitely made a name for herself as an amazing actress.
And Benedict Cumberbatch, who I know you don't like, even though he's my number one on this list. But I think Tahar Rahim is killing it in this movie. Great performance. Yeah. Good choice. Good choice. They are great in the Mauritanian. My number 10 is Mike Feist from West Side Story. I really... Trump. Okie dokie. Trump. I was going to give you a little bit of a... I was going to see which one... Nope. All right. Does he play the main jet or... He is... I'm just trying to picture. He's the main jet. He's... Yes. Why is the character's name slipping my brain right now? I've seen West Side Story. Is it Benny? No. It's a...
not finn uh i was just trying to get a picture of who that was yeah no i i appreciate it it's just uh slipping my brain right now um there's a lot of people in west side story and only like three of them thank you yes yes um so there you go uh all right so we'll talk about that later but let's go to our number nines and erin what do you got at number nine yeah a movie i love i haven't got to talk about yet uh rebecca hall in the night house okay talk about it Yeah, maybe I'm confused about how I feel about this movie because I love it. To me, this is like in the style of The Invisible Man from last year. It feels a lot like Black Bear from last year as well. Two movies that I absolutely loved. I really loved The Night House. Rebecca Hall giving a really incredible standout performance and a lead. And it's a movie that I know Robert saw because I kept on hyping up the movie and her performance. He didn't really love it. I haven't seen it since theaters. I'm not sure how much that played into it, but lots to love about specifically Rebecca Hall's performance here. I have not seen this movie.
I missed this one this last year, so I'll have to put that on the watch list. I mean, I know horror is not really your thing. It's not really my thing either, but if this is more like along the lines of Invisible Man, you know. Honestly, the trailers got me intrigued. Like, I'm like, okay, so what's going on with, is this possible parallel universes colliding and stuff like that? I had a lot of questions and I did want to answer, so it's just one that I never got around to seeing, but I kind of do want to see it. Yeah, it's great. You should check it out. I will. Rebecca Hall, The Night House, in at number nine for Aaron Robert. What's your number nine?
Andrew Garfield, Tick, Tick, Boom. Trump? Trump. Andrew, what is your number nine? I'm going to go with Toby Huss in Cop Shop. That's a decent choice. I loved his character. Obviously, you're not supposed to love his character, but it's such a wild, eccentric, crazy character that brought a little bit of levity to an otherwise really tense, dark, surprisingly good movie.
Yeah, I think everybody's really good in that movie. He is the most showy of the performances, I think. And so that may be a love it or hate it kind of thing. But I think it works. Speaking of Halt and Catch Fire, it's just so different than that or other stuff that I've seen him in. I was really close to not having him on this list and having Alexis Lauder just because she was a nobody that I'd ever heard of. And I really loved her performance. But I think Toby Huss is so, I guess, like you said, colorful and charismatic as opposed to everybody else. He stands out.
Yeah, I would have gone with Alexis, but I don't begrudge you the Toby choice either. It's an incredible performance. My number nine is Will Smith in King Richard. All right. I'm not going to let you talk. Nope. I'll talk when it's my turn, apparently. We're on to our number eight. Aaron, what is your number eight? This is my King Richard acting pick. I have Anjanu Ellis, the wife. I think she's the stand-up. I wasn't expecting that. All right. Your number eight, Robert. Kristen Stewart and Spencer.
No trumps? No, no, no. I have my honorable mentions. I'm number one, man. I love this movie. No, yeah. I honestly haven't seen too much from Kristen Stewart, but I really, really loved her in this because I really love the movie. I don't think it really works if she's not selling everything that she's going through. I push back against Andrew's point from part one from last week, which is that I think things kind of build up for her. She has the same mindset the whole time, but she has conversation after conversation that kind of builds up and just kind of it all comes to a head at the end. And there's one scene that's kind of a fantasy scene in a house by herself that's just...
otherworldly um so she does like those big acting moments great and then she also does those small intimate moments well as well that scene you're talking about really made me think was this scene in particular directed by Guillermo del Toro because it felt like it it really did yeah uh since we're talking about uh Spencer I I will just say this movie has been one of the biggest growers for me uh on the year from when I first saw it uh to now I really want to see it again because I want to see if that growth is, you know, legit. But, man, it's such a mood. This movie is such a mood. And I don't know that I was ready for the type of mood it was when I watched it the first time. But I think it's really well done. All right. I think we're on, Andrew, your number eight. This is where I have Emma Stone and Cruella. Oh, nice. Nice. Yeah. Yeah, she made the character her own. Once I, you know.
reside in myself and thinking, okay, she's not doing the same Cruella that we've known from the 101 Dalmatians. She's not this psychotic animal killer. She's this vengeful artist who is slowly falling into this character that she's created. And you don't know when she's being the character and when she's being herself or if this character is becoming who she really is the whole time. Yeah, it was fascinating to see that character develop throughout the film. No, I think it's a good choice. I definitely think it's a good choice.
Let's see if I get to talk about one this time. My number eight is, and I'm going to mispronounce this and I apologize, but I'm going to go with Renate Rensiv for Worst Person in the World. This performance is astonishing to me. This movie is astonishing to me. It's really good work. It is a French film. If you haven't seen it, I just read an article recently about this movie that conjectured if this movie was in English, it would be competing in all categories. And I don't know that they're wrong. I understand that. I get that. But it is a pretty incredible film. And there are some segments in this that blew my mind.
I thought this was a Norwegian film. Did I get that wrong? I'm sorry. I think you're right. I think you're right. I think I said French, but I think you're right. I think it's Scandinavian. And I apologize for that. But yeah, anyways, if you haven't seen Worst Person in the World, I think it should be available on VOD soon, hopefully. I know it's expanding a little bit in theaters, so you might be able to check it out there. But she is absolutely astonishing and incredible in it. So that is my number eight. All right, on to number sevens. What do you got, Aaron?
Yeah, this is a movie I was surprised that you didn't have in overrated, or underrated, sorry. I have Zendaya in Malcolm & Marie. Yeah, that's a good choice. That's a good choice. They're both giving incredible performances, but Zendaya is the standout to me. The scene that I can't shake from my head is the one where she's threatening him with a knife. Yes. Oh, so good. I'm going to be honest. I totally spaced on this being available for this year because, again, it was in last year's awards season, and I should have... And it didn't get nominated for next... For hardly anything. I absolutely would have had Zendaya in my top ten performances. And yeah, so I'm glad you picked up my slack on that one.
I know Malcolm & Maria is a movie that people either love or hate. I loved it when I saw it, but I've kind of gone down on it a little bit because it's just really pretentious. Yeah, it is. Oh, it's definitely pretentious, for sure. I don't argue that at all. I just think it's incredibly well done. It almost earns its pretension at some points for me. So, yeah. Good choice. So, Robert, you're number seven. This is where I have Dev Patel and The Green Knight. Nice. I'm number seven? Yeah. Me too. Well, there you go. Let's talk about it now.
Yeah, he's just otherworldly great. Again, I was thinking about it the other day. I've seen the movie twice now, but I was thinking about it because I was taking a three-hour car drive. The difference between how he is in the beginning, how he is on his quest, and then how he is in that flash-forward sequence is stark. Those are three completely different performances, and he sells each one perfectly. I think that flash-forward sequence at the end is just absolutely astonishing. We'll talk about it later. His whole demeanor completely shifts in those three different...
segments of the movie. And on top of that, he's just insanely charismatic. Yeah, good choice. That would tell. Andrew and Roberts, number seven. Andrew, did you have more you wanted to say about? Yeah, it's interesting because Gawain, the...
The arrogance to humbleness, that story. It's like Robert said, it does take place in those three segments, but the segue, like the transition from each to the next step of that character development is so smooth. And I don't know if it's because you're so distracted by the vibrancy of the movie and like how visually stunning it is. But I do think that really his performance stands above in some of those like moments where you're like, oh, wow. So there's a giant, you know, bald person now walking across this tribe of giants walking across.
Oh, he's a little bit more humble now because he's seeing the world. He seems so, and I don't mean this, Aaron, I don't mean to take your pun, but he seems so green. He seems so green, you know, and, you know. I mean, that's part of the point of the title. I mean, it is the double meaning of the title. Yeah, for sure. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah, he's stellar. He is truly stellar. I love this movie a lot. Good choice. Good choice at your number sevens. My number seven, I think we're back to me getting trumped. Maybe not. My number seven is Ann Dowd in Mass. Yeah, all right.
You said mass and I'm like, oh, Aaron, Schweitzer, attack. All right, let's do our number sixes. Schweitzer, what do you got? Jessica Chastain in The Eye. Yes, I will trump that. So yeah, I'll trump you both. I'll trump you both. Robert, what is your number six? Rebecca Ferguson in Dune. I think she is the standout performance as much as I love Timothee Chalamet just overall, just as a performer and as an actor. Her performance is so good that every time I try to think of her name, all I can think of is Jessica because that's the character's name. And I always think it's Jessica Ferguson. I'm like, no, that's not right.
She has to play stoic in a way that's really impressive for me. It's different from what I've seen her do before, and I know she was in Reminiscence, but she's a different kind of stoic in this than Reminiscence. But at the same time, she has those moments where Paul's hand is in the box, and she's off in the corner just absolutely freaking out and worrying about what's about to happen in there. I think she has the most layered and nuanced performance out of all the performers in Dune. Everyone's great, and it was one of my favorite movies, as we'll see later, but I just had to pick someone, and she's easily the best.
Yep, I agree. I recently heard someone refer to Timothee Chalamet as a Spice Boy, and I now cannot get that out of my head. So yes, Rex Ferguson is a good choice. Number six. Andrew, your number six, I believe, has been trumped. So we're on to my number six. This is where I have Anjanew Ellis from King Richard. So my number six in was Aaron's number eight, I believe.
So, yeah, yeah. This is my favorite performance in that movie. Will is great. He was on my list. Ingenue is better. And I think she has the most powerful moments in the film. Some of her conversations with the Richard character, some of her conversations with her daughters. I think she's doing incredible, incredible work here. So, yeah, I wanted to recognize Ingenue Ellis. What else did you want to say, Aaron, about Ingenue?
No, just this could have easily been the performance that people forgot about where the you cast somebody that, you know, because the focus is on Richard and the daughters. But she she elevates this performance to actually mean something to the. Yes. Yeah. She has the most crucial work in the movie, in my opinion, because she is the one bringing King Richard down to earth. You know, she's the one trying to make this overbearing human likable. She's the one we're trying to see him through her eyes in many ways in the movie. Yeah, it's crucial.
There's two scenes I can think of in particular. One is when she goes, there's the obvious one, which is where she kind of has to put Richard in his place. In the kitchen. Yeah, the kitchen scene. And then the other one is just when she has to go confront the neighbors because they keep on calling the cops on them. She barely has to say anything, but she's got that thousand yard stare that's just like, yeah, I'll stop. Yeah, so good. So good. All right, on to our number fives. Aaron, what do you got at number five? Yeah, here's where I have Jodie Comer in The Last Duel. Nice. Oh, we got a Trump for Comer. All right, Robert, what do you got at number five? This is the less acclaimed.
female performance from Mass. And I think Martha Plimpton is the better of the two, even though all four are incredible. I was just grounded, taken aback watching that movie. Everything she does is internal. Ann Dowd is kind of like trying to be the peacemaker character, but Martha Plimpton, everything she does is internal. She's trying not to just absolutely lose it at every second. And then when she finally does, it's not in the way that you would really expect. Yeah, I love every single thing about this performance. Yeah, I don't begrudge any of these choices. You can pick any of those four in your best performances of the year, and I go, yep.
it works for me um no you're absolutely right with what you say about flimpton in this um she's doing incredible work so good choice at your number five uh my uh sorry andrew you're number five this is where i have will smith okay richard all right the further i get away from this movie the more i can appreciate the things that i was not able to because of how i personally felt about you know richard and uh so once i was able to kind of separate the real person from the performance in the movie itself that's when i'm really starting to realize like okay i think that will smith might be the front runner for uh best performance from a lead actor i think he is i think he is i think there's there's a feeling that it's his time it's his time exactly like he's waited long enough like he did pursuit of happiness he's done so many amazing things this is his moment now um and honestly I think that this is his best performance that he's ever given. Like he really transformed into this person. So he became Richard Williams. And it's, it's shocking to see that physical transformation really comes to life. You only see that from, you normally only see that from like method actors, like a Christian Bale or a, you know, Daniel Day-Lewis, you know, to physically transform into somebody. He does it here. And there's, there's a good portion of this movie where I'm not thinking that's Will Smith. And that's really hard to do when you're Will Smith to make me believe that you're somebody else because you are.
possibly one of the most recognizable faces on the planet yeah yeah good for him good for him you're number five my number nine um so and i would i would i don't have a lot to add to that other than to say i think it is his uh his most difficult performance um that that he's uh he's had to do although honestly i guess concussion was also a really interesting performance for him to try to do um but uh but yeah so i like the what he's doing here and i think the movie um pulls it off really good yep He was nominated for Ali in Pursuit of Happiness, right? Those are the two that he got nominated for, yeah. Honestly, I'm not getting pushback on this, but I think another insanely good performance of his is I Am Legend. The movie is all him. It's really him carrying the whole thing. Let's be honest. It's not like he's doing bad work in Independence Day. You know what I mean? The work he's doing even in the movies like Men in Black Independence Day, yes, it's more like this is Will Smith, but it's still incredible acting work. So yeah, I think he's great. I think he's absolutely great.
My number five is Denzel. Denzel Washington in The Tragedy of Macbeth. I didn't much care for the movie. Not because it's bad, just because it was hard for that movie to engage me. However, Denzel is absolutely astonishing in that movie. He is doing some great work. I wasn't as impressed with Frances McDormand. I think she's fine in the movie, but Denzel really, really blew me away. So recognize that here at number five. All right, on to our number fours. Getting to the nitty gritty now. Aaron, what do you got at number four? I have Kingsley Benadier from One Night in Miami. Nice.
That is clearly, in my mind, a 2020 movie. Did it not come out until January? It came out in January. Very early January. Okay, well, there you go. I don't mind this pick at all. To me, he's the standout performance from this movie. I know he was nominated for Best Actor, and he was never going to win, but I was kind of hoping he would. Yeah, me too. Me too. I love that movie. It's one of my favorite movies of all time. All right, Robert, what's your number four? Number four, this is where I have Jodie Comer. Cool. Yeah, I think everyone in this movie is great in The Last Duel. Wait, what movie did you get? The Last Duel. Oh, for One Night in Miami. That was 2020.
It was like early January. It might have a limited theatrical release. Yeah, yeah. But it was wide in 2020. I think technically, yes, it had a limited release in 2020, which makes it technically a 2020 movie. But I mean, if you saw it in 2021, no problem bringing it up here. Absolutely. I just considered because the way we've typically done, at least on the website, would have to be widely available. Okay. Well, then there would have been four different people in my list. I just want to get that, you know, out right now. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Jodie Comer, Last Duel. Go ahead, Robert. Yeah, like I said, I think everyone's great in this movie, but she bears the brunt of the themes and the message in the story. And she...
carries it all perfectly on her back. If you're not rooting for her, if you don't believe, well, the point is that you believe the character, but if you don't believe her as an actress, then the movie doesn't work. And I think she is just above and beyond with her performance. Yeah, I think she is absolutely great in this. My favorite performance, well, you know what, I won't say yet since it's in my honorable mentions and somebody else may have it later. So we'll just hold on that. But yeah, Jodi is asked to do some really interesting stuff here from the key perspective of the film. And when you're dealing with Rashomon-style type movie, that's heavy lifting that she's doing here and she does it really, really well. So yeah, I agree.
All right. I think, Andrew, we're ready for your number four. Yeah, this is where I have my performance on The Last Duel. And it's not the blonde person that Aaron is thinking about. Because I know that's who you would have if you were to nominate. I'm actually going with Harriet Walter, who played Matt Damon's mother in this. This is a woman, I think that she is, like, out of everybody in this movie, she is giving the most authentic performance. Because it feels like she is the one who has...
resigned herself to what it means to be a woman living in the Renaissance slash medieval times. Like I am a, I am not only a second class citizen, I'm a second class human, and I'm just going to hold my head high and live my life the best I can. And the whole thing with Jodie Comer is that she is trying to be like what a modern woman would react to certain situations. And she's like, what are you doing? This is life. This is how life is supposed to be for you. It's I'm not, I'm not being mean to you. I'm being honest. And honestly, if, if anybody from this movie gets nominated for
performance i have a feeling it will be jodie comber but i think harry williams is being just pure magic in this movie nice nice uh well that's interesting because my number four performance uh is ben affleck from the last duel no it's not i'm just kidding uh but it wasn't i knew that i knew that's who you were gonna have uh so no my number four performance uh this is where i have nicholas cage for pig i'll trump that all right i wondered if somebody might that's so good i love that uh all right let's get on to our number threes then um what do you got here it's all aboard the mass train let's go jason isaac this is where i have him also number three oh okay very nice Yeah, all four leads in this are incredible. They all get lots to do. They all have subtleties or not subtle moments. They're all terrific. They all deserve to be in awards contention. But yeah, Jason Isaacs was a real stand-up scene. I just love how he's known for being a villain. You know, Lucius Malfoy, the guy from The Patriot, that sort of stuff. And then here he channels some of that angry energy. But again, like his wife in the movie, it's very subdued and internal until it's not. And playing both of those feelings is just...
insanely great for him it's such a testament to this movie that people come away with different favorite performances of these four um and just how great they are because honestly reed bernie would probably be my number two performance in the movie i think he's the only one we haven't mentioned and i think he's astonishing as well so but yeah jason isaacs is doing some really really great work uh too what an incredible actor showcase that movie is um and to believe it was you know directed by you know the stoner from the cabin in the woods you know like just astonishing stuff from france uh france france Uh, all right. Uh, I think that brings us Robert. Oh no. You said, uh, Jason Isaacs was also your number three. So Andrew, I think we're at your number three. This is interesting because half of this movie, I don't know if it's a performance or if it's just really the person being themselves. I'm going to go with Bo Burnham's inside. Oh, okay. Interesting. Um, I, I don't regret his choice at all. Uh, tell us a little bit about, uh, about your thinking and putting a bow at your number three performance. It's the simple fact that I don't know when he's performing and when he's not. So I think that shows that.
for those moments that he is, there's an authenticity to this performance. I go, I get that it's a very personal movie. He's the only one we ever see. And it's really all about him. But at the same time, there are moments where there are moments like when he's, when he's faking doing the, the Twitch stream or he's faking doing the movie reaction or he's doing all these things. Like, is this Bo Burnham? Like, yeah, this is really me. Or is this like, okay, this is, this would be a funny bit. Like I could do. It's the simple fact that it's so pure that that's what made it so high for me.
I love it. I love it as a choice. Great job. Number three for me is an Academy of Winning performance. I have Anthony Hopkins in The Father. Oh, that was last year too? Yeah. Okay, so there are five. Yeah, I did the research. One Night Miami was in one theater in Miami on December 25th. It went white on January 8th. There you go. All right. I think like 70% of my choices have been trumped, but such is life. Aaron, what do you have at number two?
Yeah, here's where Andowd is for math. Oh, nice. Okay. Yeah. To me, her performance is the best because her role requires to be the most subtle. I mean, Robert, I know you mentioned the other female performer. I can't think of her name right now. Martha Plimpton, yeah. Yeah. Her role is designed to be on the edge of just about to flip out and hop the table any moment, whereas Andowd is the peacemaker, has made peace and is trying to absorb the anger in the room. She's doing really incredible work here because specifically...
She's given a lot to do, but it's not showy, kind of like the guy in Cop Shop that you mentioned, Andrew. Toby Huss. Toby Huss, yeah. He gets a lot to just play with and the restraint that all of these actors have to have specifically and out is, yeah, it's magic on screen. I agree. I had it at number seven. You had it at number two. I just think she is doing, for me, the most difficult of the performances and the balance she's trying to pull off in that character. To create the empathy she's creating with the situation that's going on in the movie is...
Just really astonishing work for me. By the way, I was just thinking, it took me way too long to understand the double meaning of this title. Like it was months after I had seen it before I was like, oh. So, you know, it's just, it's one of those things where this movie is doing so much and so much of it is on her shoulders. So yeah, And Out is my number seven and your number two. Paul, can you explain to me the double meaning of the title? Sure, I can. I don't want to really, I don't really want to give it away for those who haven't seen the movie because it is one of those movies where the less you know of going into it. I think I understand part of it, how it's the situational context of.
what they're talking about, what they're gathering about. Right, yes, yeah. I just don't think it's the other one that I understand. Oh, okay. Well, yeah, we can chat about that at some point. Aaron's like, oh, that's good for you, but we're not talking about it right now. Yeah, yeah. All right, Patreon exclusive. Robert, what is your number two? Here's where I have Nicolas Cage. I can't claim to have seen a lot of Nicolas Cage movies where he has a reputation of going over the top and all that. But here, just as an insular performance, it's just so personal, so intimate, so raw, and that's always what draws me to a performance.
I think the moment at the fancy restaurant with his old chef is one of the best moments of the year. Spoiler alert. And there's another one where he makes food for a couple people. Just those two moments, if those were the only acting that he did in the whole movie, I think I'd still have him at number two. But the way he has to play this grief, that's doubled after the opening sequence. It's just amazing. It's astonishing stuff. I do have him at number four. You have him at number two. Yeah, this movie blew me away. I was not ready for this Nicolas Cage performance.
People are quick to forget how incredible he is when he does the over-the-top stuff. And I love that he just keeps reminding people, oh, guess what? I'm actually one of the best actors to ever have lived. So here, let me show you that again. Oscar Wilde. Yeah, right? So bravo. Bravo to him and what he's doing in this movie. I think you said it very well. I don't need to add too much. But yeah, Nicolas Cage in Pig is my number four and Robert's number two. Andrew, what do you have at number two?
This is where I have Mike Feist for West Side Story. Nice. Yeah, for me, he was the standout performance in the whole movie. It was really close. If I was going to pick anybody from this movie, he was obviously going to be the first one. But another one that I really, really love was David Alvarez, who played Bernardo. Yeah, he was my favorite. I think that Feist, or Feist, however you say it, was a more well-rounded character. Maybe it's because we see a lot more of the Jets than we do with the Sharks, but it felt like a...
whenever he was like talking with Ansel Elgort and stuff like that, you could see like, he has a love for this character, but he is hating what Ansel Elgort is turning into because he's becoming everything that they'd stood against, you know, like, and honestly, the, the dancing that he does, the choreography on top of that is stellar. Yeah. Yep. You've got him at number two. I've got him at number 10. Yeah. I think he's a standout performance from the movie for me. My number two would probably be Ariana DeBose. I think she's incredible in this as well. Oh, her ending scene is just crazy. Yeah. It's, it's so good. I,
I think for me, what drives me to the riff performance is the energy. Um, and he just captures it so well. Um, and yeah, I was, I was really blown away by, by him in this movie. So yeah, my number 10, Andrew's number two. Uh, so, all right, let's, uh, let's, let's go to my number two, uh, which I trumped earlier. Uh, my number two is Jessica Chastain for eyes of Tammy Faye. Um, I think this is an absolutely astonishing performance. I, I am blown away by what Chastain does here in, uh, in absolutely.
it's not even an impression of Tammy Faye. She just kind of becomes Tammy Faye in this movie. And it not just becomes Tammy Faye at a certain point in her life, becomes Tammy Faye for Tammy Faye's entire life, you know, other than the childhood scenes, you know, which she can't un-age, you know, to do. I don't know. She did pretty good. That's right. Playing her as a college student. No, the college student stuff is great. I believe she's a college student. And when she's in her 60s, I believe she's in her 60s. Like, it's really incredible stuff that's going on here that she's doing. And I just...
It's not an easy performance either because Tammy Faye herself was just a scenery-chewing individual in the real world. For her to be able to find the balance of the authenticity of somebody whose whole life seemed inauthentic in many ways is really a beautiful, beautiful piece of work. So it's not just about incorporating who Tammy Faye is, but just the challenge of that individual person themselves is part of my love for this performance as well. So yeah, I had to give Chastain love for that performance. Who else had it on their list?
I had it at number six. Yeah, that's right. Andrew and Aaron both had it at number six. Aaron, what are some of your thoughts? I mean, we've been bagging on the movie a little bit during part one. I'm on the low side of like this movie, but both Jessica Chastain and Andrew Garfield are really incredible in it. They're for sure the reasons to watch it. And Chastain specifically is given a phenomenal performance. You're right. She doesn't feel like Jessica Chastain. She feels like Tammy Faye.
Yeah, really great work. I think she's the frontrunner for Best Actress for a reason. Andrew, what are your thoughts? She transforms. Like you said, it's not Jessica Chastain. Kind of like with Will Smith, I wouldn't put her in that category of that method actor who really does transform and become somebody else, but she does it. And it's not just the makeup. It's not just the prosthetics or anything like that. Her mannerisms, her demeanor is different. It's a completely different person. So yeah, insanely good. Like Schweitzer said, there's a reason she's a frontrunner. There's a reason.
My number two and both of your number sixes for Aaron and Andrew, Jessica Chastain, Eyes of Tammy Faye, and it is time for our number ones. No one can trump you now. Aaron, what do you have at number one? Yeah, a show of hands for Andrew Garfield and Tick, Tick, Boom. I have Andrew at number one as well. I know. Robert, you had him at ten, right? I had him at nine, yeah. Okay. Yeah.
So much of this movie relies on his performance, his ability to be kind of wacky and zany, kind of in that 3090 intro song, and his ability to be just really thought-provoking and deep in the Y song and just all of the in-betweens. He makes this movie something special. Yeah. Robert, why don't you... Actually, I had him at number one, so I'll go next. I did not know Garfield had this in him. I love him as an actor. I think he's an incredible performer.
I didn't realize he had this much range because not only is he doing a different kind of personality than I've ever seen him do before, which is this really, you know, all energy right at the front performance, you know, Broadway kid, you know, kind of performance. He's also singing these songs like like, you know, he's he's learning to play the piano and sing songs. And just like I just I'm blown away by the talent of this man. I think he is. He is clearly my 2021 MVP.
Uh, like, you know, I don't, I can't think of somebody who had a better year than Andrew Garfield had. Um, and, uh, I just, I think his performance is, is incredible. So yeah. Um, it is. He didn't even like, he didn't have the ability to sing until he was cast. Right. Like it's not something he'd ever really done. Yeah. This isn't like he grew up a theater kid and finally getting his chance. Yeah. He learned to be a theater kid. Like, how do you do that? Like, yeah, that's, that's wild stuff. Um, Robert, why don't you talk a little bit about it too, since you had him on your list? Yeah. I think I'm the number one Andrew Garfield scholar on this podcast right now. He's been my favorite actor for the last like six, seven years. Good. Yeah.
And so I wasn't surprised that he could do this. Right. And it's just a testament to the other eight performances on this list that he's only at number nine because, you know, Andrew Garfield is always up there for me. Yeah. But the fact, like you guys are saying, he's able to do the singing and the dancing to the charismatic theater kid stuff, as well as like the conversation with Michael on the street towards the end and the song where he plays the piano on the stage outside by himself on the end. He runs a whole gamut of like emotions and he just displays his incredible range in this. So, yeah. Yeah. Cool. All right. I think that means, Robert, we're ready for your number one. What do you got?
This is where I have Anthony Hopkins, the father. Unfortunately, I've had too many people in my life go through the same thing that Anthony Hopkins' character goes through in this. So just being able to see this stuff portrayed in this way, the way the father does, kind of getting inside the character's head is moving and creates empathy in a way that I don't think any other movie could for this kind of condition. And then the way Anthony Hopkins plays it, again, sadly, is just all too familiar to me. So I think that's just kind of what threw him over the top as easily the number one far and away best performance of the year that I saw.
You had him at number one. I had him at number three. I'm with you. This performance is so good that my brain was literally, while watching this movie, going, oh, no, Anthony Hopkins has Alzheimer's. No, I was literally feeling bad for the person Anthony Hopkins because it just felt like he was really there. It's an astonishing performance. I know lots has been made about the Academy's decision to do Best Actor Last, and it kills me that it overshadows.
you know, what was going on with Chadwick and, you know, in the stuff last year, because it is really one of those moments where it's like, can we please just let both things be true? Can we please just honor both things? Because at the end of the day, if you're putting it in front of me and going, you know, Chadwick Boseman's performance, Anthony Hopkins performance, I'm going, I think the Hopkins performance is better. But at the same time, if you're putting in front of me going, you know, who do you want to honor this year? I want to honor Chadwick and his life and his legacy in such a short time. Let's just let both things be true in our memory. And what really stinks is I think we could have done that.
pretty easily if they had just stuck to the regular script instead of trying to pull a fast one and go hey let's end it with this big moment um just a real bad decision by the producers of the show i think that really ruined something that could have still been beautiful i think um but yeah they'll also give chadwick a lifetime achievement award if not this year then maybe next um but yeah i'm with you what an incredible performance and and good stuff and andrew you even said like if you had considered it before this year it would be my number one yeah it would be my number one if i but it's it's the whole pandemic changing or not it's not the pandemics you know it was the weird reasoning behind changing it, you know, like the nomination period that threw me off. Cause yeah, I would have had a whole bunch of people from one night in Miami on this list and Anthony Hopkins would be my number one. Yeah. Aaron and Robert, I think people know how Andrew and I, because we've talked about it many times, feel about that decision to move the eligibility window. Where do you guys stand on that? Do you think that was a good decision, bad decision? Who cares? Like what's, did you have any specific thoughts on that? It doesn't bug me too much. It's just, this is the prime example of why it's really weird is that it throws off end of your list and all that kind of stuff. So that's, that's pretty much the extent of my thoughts. Yeah.
I mean, yeah, I like that they adapted. You know, I think when they made the change, they were hopeful that vaccines would be readily available by the start of 2021. That wasn't the case. So I think that they were hoping... I think we need to do away with limited releases on Christmas Day, counting. I think it needs to be wide release, and then that would just clear up so much confusion.
I don't think you're ever going to get, we're going to follow a little bit of a bunny trail here, but I don't think you're ever going to get rid of eligibility issues because people are always going to play the game, right? They're going to say, okay, what do we have to, because Netflix does this, right? The eligibility rules right now say that a movie has to be in actual theaters. That's the only reason Netflix puts their movies in theaters for a week is so that they can be eligible for awards. So everybody's always going to skirt eligibility stuff. It means the Netflix stuff, like if you say, you know, it has to be wide release. Well, the Netflix stuff, most of it never gets to wide release. So like, you know, when, what year do you consider that stuff for? So I just, for me, I just think we need to go calendar year.
Quit playing games with it. I would go more expansive rather than less. I would count One Night in Miami as a 2020 movie just because it had that one theater, one showing in 2020. Boom. It's a 2020 movie. Fine. I know a lot of people won't get around to it until January. That's okay. Count it in the 2020 because it did that. I would just say make it wide. I just don't like changing the actual dates of the calendar. It's like, well, if we're doing the best movie of the year, do the year. That kind of thing.
I'd also like to see additions for just the new kind of stuff that we're seeing, like Come From Away and Hamilton. I totally didn't realize at the start of the first show that the non-movie pop culture stuff, I would have picked in and of itself. Absolutely. I thought we were doing nominations at that point. So I'd love to see that get some Oscar attention, but it doesn't really qualify in anything. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I'm totally with you. I just think if they had stuck with the year, do you really think the father and Malcolm and Marie and those kind of things weren't ready to...
to show in December, they would have just shown them in December and they would have been a part of the 22nd. The only reason they waited until January and February was because of the window, right? In my opinion, I could be totally wrong on that. It's just a weird thing for me. Well, especially One Night in Miami being a prime, like Amazon bought the rights to release it. Like, there's no reason they couldn't have released it in December. Yeah, I'm with you. I think it should have, widely available. So even if that's just, you know, if it's on Netflix, you know, as opposed to since, it should be widely available January 1st to December 31st. All right, so...
I'm lost now. I think it's just Andrew's number one. Yeah, Andrew, what is your number one? It would be my number two. Just move everything down. Nancy Hopkins is number one. I'm going to go with Alana Haim in Licorice Pizza. Oh, nice. She blew me away. I had no idea who she was before this movie. I definitely will afterwards. I think she's a musician. Is that how a lot of people know her? Yeah, from the band Haim, right? Okay, yeah. I mean, what a performance. The whole movie, You Know Me, I Love PTA. And it's interesting how this movie...
more so than any other PTA movie I can think of, is all about the uncomfortableness in the relationship that this movie delves into. Yeah, she's a lot older than Cooper. I forget his first name. Is it Robert Cooper? Cooper Hoffman. Cooper Hoffman, yeah. Cooper Hoffman's performance. He's a young kid in this, and she's in her mid-20s. She even has that one line, like, do you think it's weird that I hang out with so-and-so and all of his 15-year-old friends? Because I think it's a little weird that I'm always hanging out. But her performance, she is technically older.
but on a maturity level, she's just as mature, if not less mature than Cooper Hoffman, you know, like he's seasoned and he's like knows the world because he's a child actor and that in and of itself makes him a little more versed. So seeing her reaction to like his stardom and his success and how that shapes her. Yeah. It's a stellar performance in a stellar movie. So yeah, I thought she was great.
Well, there you go. Number one for Andrew Alonheim, licorice pizza. Technically number two, which brings us to an interesting decision because we have Anthony Hopkins with Andrew's reintroduction with two number ones and a number three for me. Did all of us have Hopkins on our list? Aaron, did you have Hopkins on your list?
No, and this is, again, where it probably should have gone in my list. I just didn't for some reason. I totally agree with everything you guys are saying. It's a career best. And then we have Garfield with two number ones and a number... What did you have, Robert? Nine. And a number nine. So on numbers alone, it's Hopkins. Is there any... I think those are the two choices, right? I mean, those are the ones that clearly the most of us... And I haven't seen Tick, Tick, Boom. Oh, okay. Well, that's an element as well. So, yeah. What do you guys think? Just some thoughts between those two.
I would go Hopkins in a heartbeat. Yeah, just because it's a career best, and because of just how deep and layered it is. Career best from the guy who played Hiddleback. I'm so split, because as of now, both of these are career bests, and both of them make or break the movie. Oh, that scene with Anthony Hopkins at the end, like, I want my mommy scene, kills me. Look, my heart says Garfield, but I can't not just say Hopkins deserves it, right? Andrew?
Again, I have no way to compare. So obviously I'm going to go with Hopkins, but I want to see Tick, Tick, Boom. This is interesting for me. Because I think the only reason I would pick Garfield over Hopkins is because it is technically an awards season performance, where Hopkins isn't technically an awards season performance for this year. But that's not fair. That's not the way we're doing this. That's not the rules we have set up. And I think for that reason and that reason alone, the top performance, official 50 for 2021, is Anthony Hopkins in The Father. Can't be mad about it at all. No, can't be mad about it. In the same vein, I think Andrew Garfield is the best awards-eligible performance of 2021. I think we could say it that way. But yeah, congratulations to Anthony Hopkins for another award. That's a good question.
kind of modifier yeah yeah i mean again the field this really feels like will smith but i'm pulling so hard for yeah yeah me too me too uh all right let's do some nominations for best moment best movie moment of the year we each get three nominations we will go uh around for those uh we'll go in reverse order so i will kick us off on these I'm going to start the nomination. By the way, this is one of those things where if there are spoilers attached to it, sometimes you have to be creative with the way you say it. So it should be something that would make it clear to somebody who's seen it what you're talking about without giving it away to somebody else. With that in mind, I will nominate right off the bat the first Kitchen Portal appearance in Spider-Man Far From Home as a nominee for Best Movie Moment of the Year. I'll just say all the spiders is mine. Just the culmination.
Oh, so like the finale? More of the finale? Yeah, I guess. Which I'm kind of including. I guess I was less specific in this pic than what you were as opposed to a specific scene. I'm like, a specific element. Well, that's okay. No, I think the finale of... I could tell you...
So, for instance, how I would put that movie moment for me that you're talking about is Spider-Man web-slinging off of another Spider-Man. Like, there's, you know, there's, you know, there are just moments that happen in that finale that... Or the RUOK scene that made everybody cry. Right, yeah, yeah. So, are you officially nominating that, then, as your first nomination, or... Well, I was, that's what I was wanting to clarify, is, like, is that a different... Yes, that is a different movie moment, yes. Okay, then I didn't mean to jump in, I just wanted to clarify. No, you're up next, so, you know, feel free to nominate what you want.
Let's go with that then. All 12 of our nominations will be from Spider-Man Far From Home. No, that will not happen. All right. Yes, I will call that the group finale on Spider-Man No Way Home. I think I said Far From Home. No Way Home. Yeah. All right. Robert, what about you? The Funny Feeling song from Bo Burnham Inside. I tried to narrow it down to one moment, and I think that encapsulates the entire thing, and it's also a great song. Yeah. All right. Bo Burnham, Funny Feeling.
All right, Aaron, what's your first nomination? Yeah, I'll throw out my Spider-Man one. Peter Parker saves MJ from falling. Are you okay, Shane? Yeah, that's it. Are you okay from No Way Home? Ugh, tears. Spider-Man's gonna split the votes. That's the moment that just devastated me. All right, back to me then for my second nomination.
I'm going to go with Shifting the Fourth Diner Wall in Tick, Tick, Boom as my second nomination for movie moment of the year. I have seen that movie four times now, I think, maybe five, I think four. Is it on anything or is it in theater? Yeah, it's on Netflix. Tick, Tick, Boom is? Yeah, Tick, Tick, Tick, Boom is on Netflix. That moment in that song, which has become, I think, my favorite song from the film, which is saying something because there's so many great songs in that movie, is the most goosebumps I get every single time I watch it now is just the moment where...
The fourth wall literally comes down. And yeah, it's beautiful stuff. So that's my second nomination. Andrew, what is your second nomination? Well, it's also a song from a movie. I know which one. Yeah, go ahead and say it then. Seagull on a Tire. Edgar's Prayer from Barb and Star. Edgar's Prayer. I have it listed as Dornan Sings to a Bird on a Tire. Yeah, Edgar's Prayer is actually the name of the song. And it's movie magic, really.
No, it really is. I had it in my list of possible nominees as well. Well, here's why. And I think this is the main reason. Because everything I'd seen Jamie Dornan in, he was playing so serious his version of whatever character he was playing. Whether it be Fifty Shades or, you know, I forget what the Snow White and Huntsman. Yeah, those movies. Everything I'd seen him and he was like, oh, I'm serious. I'm trying to be, you know, very seductive. You know, everything like that. Here he just let that weirdness go and it was magic. I love it. I never expected him to do that. Robert, what's your second nominee?
This is tough. I have six listed, and I'm trying to choose only three. But I think I'm going to go with the line, this is only the beginning from Dune. Nice. It's just my favorite scene of the whole movie. It's a part that gave me chills. The music was swelling at that moment. Yeah, that's just what excited me about the movie in general. Also, this is only the beginning is the reason Andrew doesn't like the movie. I don't not like the movie. No, I know. Andrew and Aaron. I like the movie, but I was let down by the movie. I was overstating. All right, Aaron, what is your second nominee?
yeah look we've gone three hours without talking about coda so let's talk about the moment where the dad hears ruby yes yes by grabbing onto her yes holding the vocal cords i'll call it uh from coda yeah good choice good choice i'm glad that's getting a mention that's definitely one of the best movie moments of the year uh let's see for my final nominee um oh i don't like this i've got three left we're gonna do some honorable mentions on this one uh but my third official nominee I'm going to go for $96,000 in the Heights as my final nominee officially. You took them off my list. You're welcome. One of the most incredible goosebumpy moments, them walking to the pool, talking about the possibility of this money, that information, getting around to other people, people joining them in, several different areas doing their own thing, the big overhead shot of the pool.
There's so many moments in the 96,000 song that just blow me away. In the Heights very much could have been, in my opinion, in the most underrated, even though I know there are plenty of people that like it. It just doesn't feel like a lot of people are talking about it. Because in a year of many, many musicals, things can kind of get buried. And in a year of Lin-Manuel. I mean, if anybody's going to give Andrew Garfield a run for his MVP money, it's Lin-Manuel this year. Just so much stuff that he's doing. But yeah, this is really great work from him as a director for the first time. Just absolutely love that scene. So that's my... No, that was just in Lin-Manuel. Sorry, sorry. Yes, sorry. In the Heights was Lin-Manuel.
Not Justin Lin. No, not Justin Lin. Who did it? It wasn't Lin-Manuel. No, Lin-Manuel directed Tick, Tick, Boom as his first directorial, right? John M. Chu directed In the Heights. John M. Chu. This is how amazing a year Lin-Manuel is having. Well, and in Canto. You know, we haven't talked about it. Right. Yeah, no, I know. I know. And he wrote the songs for Vivo. Yes, he wrote all the music for Vivo as well. So, yeah, it's quite a year for Lin. But yes, anyhow, the pool scene in 96,000 In the Heights will be my official final nominee. Andrew, what's your final nominee in this category? I'm going to go with the ending sequence for The Green Knight, leading to...
The Green Knight actually saying, well done, boy. Now off with that head. And it's so good because you don't know in the moment whether this is a flash forward or if this is just how life was going to be for him and for it to come back to the Green Knight at the very end. And yeah, I love it. I love it. There were so many scenes I could have picked from this movie, but this is the best, I think. Nice. Robert, what's your final nominee? Well, I'm glad Andrew nominated that one because I can choose one of my others.
The one that I referenced earlier, the you don't get a lot of things to really care about scene from when he's talking to the chef that he was like a mentor of years prior. Yeah, that's just very emotional. And it's the whole movie's message just in one scene. Yep. Great, great pick. One of my favorites as well. Aaron, what is your final nominee? Last chance for an official nominee? In a movie full of sappy moments, I got to talk another one. In Coda, Ruby's final performance, singing both sides now for her audition. Ruby's final performance in Coda is the final nominee. All right.
Good choice. Here are the nominees. A couple from Coda, the Holding the Vocal Chords, and Ruby's final performance. Several from Spider-Man No Way Home. The first Kitchen Portal reveal. The R U OK? And the group finale are the No Way Home choices. Bo Burnham, Funny Feeling. This is only the beginning from Dune. The restaurant scene from Pig. Seagull on a Tire from Barb and Star. 96,000 from In the Heights. Shifting the Fourth Diner Wall from Tick, Tick, Boom. And the ending of The Green Knight. I don't think I missed any of the nominees.
Before we do our pick, are we going to do our own mentions now? Sure, sure. Yeah, let's go ahead and do that. I'll throw out Shang-Chi. The love fight is one of my favorite things that I saw in movies this year. I thought it was beautiful and just absolutely great stuff. So I loved that.
I'd like to throw out two real quick so then I can step away for a second. Ruby and Miles' duet from Coda is a moment where it just all sounds like... You just want to put Coda down as your... The whole movie of Coda. No, there's the duet where all of a sudden you see it from the parents' perspective who are deaf. And Bond's finale in 007. Okay, sure. That's actually a really good one and I'm surprised that it wasn't even on my list or anybody else's, but yeah. Any others, Andrew or Robert? Yeah, I got two. Go ahead. Okay. The duel in The Last Duel. And let's go with another scene in In the Heights. It's the building dance.
Yeah, no, that's a great choice. I thought there was just a magical moment in that movie that was already filled with magical moments. It's one of the moments in that I can remember actually saying out loud, oh, wow. As soon as it started happening, there was an audible reaction from me. Yeah, yeah. Robert, what are your honorable mentions of others you wanted to throw out there? Yeah, I had two more as well. And one is Superman rising, like when he comes back in Justice League with the black suit and then stopping the axe and all that. That and then one that everyone else is going to disagree with, but the White Rabbit song from The Matrix, where it's like...
the super medicine that you either love it or you absolutely despise it. And I really loved it. Nice. Nice. I'll mention a couple in the chat. The, let's see, Jay Bourgeois says, Jay Bourgeois says, when the audio cuts from Reagan's POV from Quiet Place 2, it's a good choice. And then Nick mentions another No Way Home, which let's just say a previous character mentions how good they are at lawyering. So, yeah. Yeah. Fun stuff. All right. I guess we'll go ahead and start this conversation. What do you think?
I mean, because we've mentioned No Way Home so much, does it have to be from that movie? I think it does. Is there a better moment from a different movie that's better than all of the... Because, you know, No Way Home had several good moments, but was it the best? I don't know. Aaron, what do you think? Where do you think we should start our conversation on this? Are you okay? From No Way Home? Okay. Robert, to me, it is the definitive moment. Robert, what about you? I assumed going in that the consensus was going to be something from Spider-Man, but my personal pick would be a funny feeling from inside.
I think that encapsulates the year and it encapsulates a lot. And it's great. Andrew, any other thoughts? Actually, Aaron, I think I'm leaning more towards your pick from No Way Home, the kitchen portal, because I think that's what everybody was like. Is it going to happen? Is it going to happen? And then it finally we finally get an answer. It does feel like I guess that's where I'm leaning to. And here's what I'll pitch. I will pitch the kitchen portal for the main reason that the other moments we've mentioned all rely on that moment to have their power. That's what I was thinking. Yeah. So it's, you know, it's a technicality, but I think it's one that.
that works for me. Can I make an argument for a different Spider-Man part? Sure. Yes. Why not? So not, not the, not the kitchen and not the, are you okay? But the third one, I think that's the, the best of the, the group finale. Yeah. Because to me, the kitchen, while it does, you know, do what we want it to do. One of them wasn't there. Yeah. That for one thing. And for another, it's a little silly in my mind. Some of, some of the dialogue and some of the interactions are just a little too silly for me. But the group finale is just great. Robert, I'm with you. I think, I think, I think we may go that way because.
it's kind of like the kitchen portal is Mjolnir, but the group finale is on your left. Like, you know what I mean? Like there's, there's a, one of them means a little bit more, you know what I mean? Like there's a, there's a little bit more meaning. And honestly, the third one we're talking about is kind of, you could even call it part of the idea of, you know, group finale and group finale means, you know, it's a wider way to talk about a movie moment, but it is a moment in, you know, it's a moment full of moments, including the, are you okay moment? And, you know, so it's a little bit of a cheat, but I think it's, it encapsulates why that, that movie has so many.
great moments, movie moments of the year and it's hard to pull off. So I think I'm going to throw my weight behind that idea of group finale Spider-Man as well. It's a little bit too much of a cheat for me to throw my weight behind. I get that. That's fine. It's your podcast. I just can't. I get it. Believe me, I totally understand. It incorporates a lot. If you're talking about the whole final act of a film, that's a bit too much. It's not the entire final act. It's more of like the culminate, like there's a culminating moment where like everything.
It's like, oh, we're officially going to start doing it. It's more of like how On Your Left is like the starting catalystic moment. Yeah, but On Your Left is a moment. On Your Left is a movie moment. What we're talking about is not a movie moment. Aaron is right.
I think Aaron's right. I think he's right. And look, again, mine doesn't quite get the heart of what you guys are talking about. Mine is, this is a specific moment for Spider-Man. How about this? This is a specific moment for Peter Parker. How about this? But it just means the world to me. Something that wasn't even mentioned. Well, that's not legal, but go ahead. With great power comes great responsibility.
No, I think that wasn't nominated. When I heard group finale, in my mind, it was Spider-Man swinging from strings. When I heard group finale, I thought hug. Those are definitely two different moments, which is probably, again, why group finale is not eligible in this category. I literally said the swinging. Then I say we go back to the kitchen rings. I literally said the swinging when we were talking about group finale. So I'm fine with that being the moment. But if that's the moment, I think I would lean, are you okay? I think I'm leaning that way. I think I'm with Aaron on are you okay now? Because that is a legitimate movie moment. It was the most powerful moment of that movie. It is one of the biggest movie moments of the year. If Andrew and Robert are good with that, I think that's where I'm leaning. No, I'm 100% behind that, yeah. Are you okay? Yeah, are you? Yeah.
i love that that moment as a fan of other movies um but my only thing with that is that it's for one character instead of collective but i'm still okay with it being a moment yeah no it is definitely i mean the moment is what the moment is and it means what it means to but as far as like an overall uh moment i think uh i think that's where we go uh boy i understand what robert's saying feels wrong not to include all of them right you know but uh well that's that is the discussion between i think the kitchen portal and the are you okay that is and i think i'm okay with going with Are You Okay? Because I do think it's a more, like that moment itself is more powerful and more meaningful than the other moment, even though the other moment I think best encapsulates what makes the movie more powerful. But I think as far as a specific movie moment of 2021, the sifty goes to Are You Okay? from No Way Home. And the performance just sells it too.
Yeah. So nicely done, guys. Love it. Love it. Love a little group work together. I think I changed my mind about 57 times. I like how we were teetering around spoilers like nobody has seen this movie. Right, right. I think everyone's seen it. I think everybody knows what we're talking about, but we try to be careful. You know, when George Clooney's Batman came back, it's like, man. Yeah. Nick Tokyo says the pose. I guess the pose is a better way to say. Yeah. Like the landing. The landing pose. Those kind of things, yeah. All right. Let's actually talk about the best movies. It is time. We will do our top 10. BEC rules apply. You can trump something if you have it higher.
Kick it off at number 10, and we will go to number one. Robert, you're going to start us off. What is your number 10 movie of 2021? Licorice Pizza. I'm a pretty big fan of PTA, and this immediately shot up to top three, maybe. I just love movies where people hang out, and that's what this is. But it's also more than that. It's episodic, and people are hanging out, and it's funny, and you love the characters. But there's a lot of darkness underneath, and there's a lot of depth to the characters. And like Andrew was talking about earlier, the age stuff gets out a lot of themes about maturity. Yeah, I love Licorice Pizza.
Very nice. This is my number 13 of the year, so I just missed my list. Aaron, what do you got at number 10? Yeah, The Suicide Squad. I really love this movie. I do agree with you, Aaron, though, that this would be a much better movie if it was PG-13 and kind of restricted to that. I think so. It has to be. Because you're right. They go for an easy joke a lot of the times. A person opens a window and is completely naked. Or like the Cleaver scene, which is a clever and funny joke. This film would be better with just a little bit of a reign. But just a little governor on it. Yeah, just a little. It's what makes The Guardians movies as good as they are. Because you have to work a little bit more for a creative joke.
Also talk about movie moments of the year. How about that's your mom? Yeah, sure. Yeah, like that kind of humor would be better. That's your mom. I still really like the movie, though, but it would be much better. And let me be clear, since I haven't said it on, but I think people know, but I don't begrudge anybody liking The Suicide Squad. I totally get why people love that movie. You know, the energy is really interesting there. And there's actually some decent thematic stuff going on there. It's not like it's an empty movie. I'd like to nominate Sylvester Stallone as a king shirt. All right, I'll go next. My number 10 will 100% get trumped, but I have mass at my number 10. So, yeah.
Andrew, what's your number 10? This is where I have The Harder They Fall. Okay, nice. You know me. I love Westerns, and this is not only a great Western, but it's a unique Western. It's a Western that's in and of itself. You know, it's in a world of its own, and I'm all for it. It's kind of a mix between Tarantino, Robert Rodriguez, and dare I say Sergio Leone. I mean, there's some...
definite elements of like, you know, a fistful of dollars or a few dollars more in this movie. It's, it's more vibrant and colorful and it plays with some really unique elements. Like when they go to the all white town and they make it very literal that it's an all white town, you know, I had a lot of fun. The characters are very well thought out. It's a good movie. Great performances.
Very nice. The harder they fall in at number 10 for Andrew. Robert, what do you got at number nine? The Matrix Resurrections. Nice. Just waiting to see if anyone wanted to trump that. No, yeah, I really loved it. I think I pretty much talked about it earlier, but even though it's very messy, I love what it's trying to do. And it doesn't do it perfectly, but I still think it does it very well. So, yeah.
There you go. Matrix Resurrections in someone's top 10. Imagine that. All right. Number nine for Aaron. Actually, let me just say this. Robert, I'm actually glad you're repping the pro Matrix movement because you're not alone there. I've certainly heard lots of very smart movie loving people who do really like that movie and appreciate what they're doing. So you are among them. It was kind of a backhanded compliment there, Aaron. No, there are smart people who like this movie. No, I said he's among them. I said he was among them. You gotta let me finish my sentence. Aaron, what is your number nine? Yeah, here's why I have no time to die. Nice.
Oh, all right. All right. I guess that brings it to me then. My number nine is Encanto, which we just mentioned for the first time just recently. But man, do I love this movie. I love the music in it. I love what it's saying about responsibility and parenting. And I love that it doesn't go for the easy protagonist resolution. I love that it sticks to its story and its theme. And it's just really great stuff. So Encanto is my number nine. Andrew, what about you? What's your number nine? Snyder Cut.
Nice. Okay. I don't know if I heard it. Okay. Not a chance. It's a combination of how much I loathed the original version of this movie and how I just think that this is just a really well...
you know, miniseries that somebody decided to make into a movie, you know? Yes, I 100% agree it would have been better if everybody had got their own original origin story film prior to this movie, but having that not be the case, this is great. There are so many elements of this movie and moments in this movie that made me go, how did this not make the final cut? Like, there's an entire sequence where we get cyborgs, not origin, but we get, like, the revelation of how powerful he is, like, where he sees this woman in poverty in a... actually brings a tear to your eye. And a moment that was this close to making my moments of the year is whenever Barry Allen's like, Dad, I just want you to know your son was one of the best of the best. And then he runs through time to save the world. It's such an amazing sequence that it just makes you go, how could you miss out on so many great moments? Oh, Joss Whedon, what's wrong with you? On top of the many other things that are wrong. I was going to say, the question Joss Whedon, what's wrong with you is being answered by a lot of people these days. But yeah, Snyder Cut, number nine.
All righty. I think that brings us to our number eight. Robert, kick us off. What's your number eight? Green Knight. Trump. All right. Aaron, what is your number eight? The Mitchells versus the Machines. That's a great choice. Number 11 on my list. Very good choice.
All right. Yeah, so the best animated movie of the year. Sony Animation is kind of really turning it around. Phil Door, Chris Miller, pretty great. The message of the movie is definitely ham-fisted and too much for me in most points. But the humor is on point and the animation is clever. I love this movie. Not as ham-fisted as Ron's Gone Wrong or whatever that movie was. That movie was fun at times, but it was so ham-fisted. Mitchells vs. the Machines is subtle in comparison. The only thing about Mitchells vs. the Machines is really the main...
the antagonist, right? The antagonist is way too far over the top. He's so paid by numbers, one-sided. Yeah, but everything else in this is really good. So yeah, I love this choice, Mitchell's versus the machines. Good call. It is the best animated movie of the year. Well, I had a content ahead of it, but yes, I understand what you're all saying. What's that, Robert? I like Luca. Yeah, nice. All right, yes, my number eight. Nine. Have you done your number nine?
Yeah, and Conto was my number now. We're on our eights, right? Yes. Yes, we're on our eights. I have the father at number eight. Trump. And it has been Trump. Can we do my list now, guys? What about you, Andrew? What is your number eight? Belfast. Oh, good choice.
We haven't talked about this movie. I was going to say what a weird thing when like one of the front runners for best picture of the year is something we've barely mentioned. I think that says something actually, but it's a good movie. Well, if we were to do honorable mentions for performances, I would have thrown it in Jimmy Dornan. I would have thrown it in Kieran Hines as the grandfather. I mean, it's Dornan's second best performance of the year, so. It is. You're joking, but I actually agree with you. I'm kind of not joking. I'm kind of not. It is actually. He's really good, but no, this movie is fascinating how it's, you know, it's his Roma. It's his version of his story, you know, growing up and.
unlike come on come on i think that you know the black and white actually serves a better purpose than pretentiousness i know robert i'm sorry i'm ragging on your movie but uh but uh it's i love this movie it's a happy movie with some actual emotional tense moments like the moments where he's being a kid are the best moments of this movie for me like whenever he's like really doing the best he can to uh get to the front row so he can sit next to the girl you know in class like it's just those heartwarming moments like oh yeah this is just a little kid who is trying to be happy you know yeah and then the world around him is falling apart I'm glad I got to mention Belfast in at number eight for Andrew. All right, let's move on to our number sevens. Robert, what do you got? I got Pig at number seven. Yeah, for all the reasons I've been mentioning throughout both parts, I think it's great. It's about grief. It's about caring. It's about love. It's about people. There's a lot of stuff that's so great about it. And I thought it was going to be Taken or John Wick, and it was absolutely not that at all. And that plays in hugely as to why I love it so much. Yeah.
Yeah, it is its own thing. I think I've described it as take and meet chef, but it's really neither of those things, and yet somehow it's kind of both of those things. It's lovely how it's its own thing. I will find you. Now we want to see Jon Favreau get his own Jon Favreau. There you go, yeah. He does have a particular set of skills in that movie, though. He does. All right, so Aaron, what is your number seven? Yeah, Cruella.
Again, just a big surprise for how much I love this. Yeah, Emma Stone's great. Emma Thompson's great. The fashion design is incredible. I love the soundtrack for this movie. You know, we haven't talked about the henchmen very much. They're great. And the Roger character is, from what we do in the shadows, who's the main vampire? Nandor. The guy who plays Nandor with a clean-shaven face looks unrecognizable. Kayvan Novak. Yeah.
So Cruella in at number seven. My number seven is West Side Story. Oh, Big Trump. Oh, wait, Big Trump. Big Trump. Andrew, what do you have at number seven? This is where I have no time to die. It's a very well thought out.
farewell for Daniel Craig. Like, you could tell that there was a lot of love, and I know that he's had, you know, moments where he's said some controversial things about the Bond franchise in the past, but for some reason when it came to this final one, I felt there was a profound love for this character. And, like, this was Daniel Craig's way of saying thank you. And just a great movie with a lot of tense moments. I forget, what did you guys think of Rami Malek as the villain?
Forgettable. Yeah, I wasn't a huge fan of Rami in this one. I'm more with Robert. I think he was a pretty solid villain. His performance is good, it's just that the motivations and intentions weren't as fleshed out as they could have been. It's not his performance that I didn't like. It's the little amount that he had to do. The villain was always secondary to the story. But what I loved about this movie was the competitive nature between the new 007 and him. It's a fun little element that you hadn't seen really in Bond since maybe Goldeneye. Another agent, another 00.
And how great is that on a Dharma scene? Like it's, it's the best. It's so great. Yeah. Yeah. She is the most unique bond girl we've ever had. Yeah. Uh, yeah. So this, uh, this is my number nine and it just goes to show that a testament is that like it's a two hour and 45 minute movie. And my end result was, I just wish there was more, I wanted more on a darkness, more Jeffrey, right? Um, more, uh, of the 007 and 007 thing. More of, uh, more, more runners. That one on the stairway is amazing. Um, yeah.
Good stuff. More him playing Home Alone in the Woods. Oh, that was such a good sequence. That was such a good, good sequence. I forgot that, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Andrew had it at number seven, and Aaron had it at number nine. That's No Time to Die. And we're on to our number sixes. Robert, what do you got? I'm sure this will be trumped, but this is where I have Tick, Tick, Boom. Yeah, yeah, there'll be a trump there. Aaron, what's your number six? All right, time for me to defend Last Night in Soho. Number six. Number six. Look, I'll admit, this movie falls apart in the last act for me, but there is something so special about this movie. The visual flair, I mean...
This is the definition of every frame of painting. Thomas and McKenzie and Anya Taylor-Joy are both just delightful in this film. Matt Smith is that perfect kind of grungy. I love the setting of 60s London with all this neon. There's some really great camera work in here. Lots and lots to love. There's little Edgar Wright flares every now and then, how there's a neon sign outside her window that will flash to the beat of the music. This is the best shot movie of the year. Yeah, it's best visual experience for me. That's what I voted for in the 50s.
Everything about this movie just falls apart in the end for me, but not enough to take me out of love, dude. Nice. Last night in Soho, in at number six. For me, my number six, Spider-Man No Way Home is my number six. I figured somebody might trump. That's on Andrew. What is your number six? In the Heights.
Oh, nice. Yeah, you know me. I'm not really a musical guy. So the fact that there are two musicals in my top 10 of the year should say something about the quality of musicals that came out this year. This, for me, was... You haven't even seen the best musical of the year, so... Right. Yeah, apparently. Yeah, apparently I haven't. Andrew, I'm starting to think you're a musical. Gosh. No, trust me, no. There's a grand history to prove otherwise. But I think this is Do the Right Thing, the musical. I love that this is a community. I mean, yeah, we have a main...
you know, two main characters to say, but for the most part, this is a film about a community as opposed to a person. And that's a really unique experience for somebody who lives in the Ozarks to try and understand this, this communal way of life in the city. I loved it. Music's great. As Aaron said, 96,000 is such an amazing song. And the building dance was just pure magic. So there you go.
What's interesting is, Aaron, you picked 96,000 as the best moment. I thought for sure you would have picked the Abuela song. No, I considered it. I wanted to pick one, and I just thought the moment of, like that overhead shot from the pool just sticks with me. Abuela is an incredible moment of the movie, but it only exists really in the context of everything else that's happening in some way. So I know these are minor distinctions. It's one of the reasons actually movie moments is one of my favorite categories of the year, just because you can kind of look at it in so many different ways. But yeah, no, that's fair. I certainly love that song. Abuela was my favorite character in the movie. Everybody needs that Abuela in their life.
I would have picked the fireworks during the blackout. I wouldn't blame you. In the Heights, in at number six, right? Isn't that where we're at for Andrew? So we're on to our number fives. Robert, what do you got at number five? This is one that I still have not seen hardly anyone other than Sif Pop writer Shane talk about, and that's Supernova, which is this movie where Colin Firth and Stanley Tucci play husbands, and Stanley Tucci is dying of dementia, and they're taking one last RV trip across the English countryside. And it is so moving and so touching and so thought-provoking in so many different ways.
It came out January 29th. I just looked it up, and it's stuck with me on my top five, literally almost for a complete calendar year at this point. I think this is one of the most special movies that came out the entire year, and I haven't seen hardly anyone say a single thing about it. Go ahead, Ian. Isn't it amazing that there are movies that can actually stick with you for an entire year? You're like, man, is it going to make it all the way to the end? And it's just like, yeah, there's something magical about this movie that can't be touched. Whenever I saw a new movie that was great, and I was adding it to my list that I keep track of through the year, I was like, nope, just doesn't beat it. I kept trying to...
beat it and it just wouldn't. I'm going to pull an errand here and read my Letterboxd review of this movie from earlier this year because it's one of those things I considered for award season last year and so it hasn't entered my mind considering stuff for this year. But it is great. But I said, you know those movies where people are like, this movie destroyed me. You need to watch it. And then you're like, I'm not fond of being destroyed. It's kind of unpleasant. And then they're like, but the unpleasantness of life is what makes the beauty so much more beautiful. And empathy only exists when we open ourselves to the pain of others. And then you're like, but do I have to experience it this deeply? It really hurts. And then you realize you're having that conversation with yourself. That is this movie. So yeah, this is one of those movies where it's just like...
it's going to open you up to all sorts of empathy and emotion and feelings. And it really is beautiful. I'm glad you mentioned it, Robert. That was exactly how I felt, except I was more welcoming of that feeling than what you described. Let's just copy and paste that from this. That's a fair point. That is a fair point. All right. So Supernova in at your number five is where we're at, I believe. So Aaron, what is your number five? Yeah, here's where I have The Night House. It just hit me in all the right ways. More horror films like this, please. Yeah. Again, this is one that we've talked about on these episodes that I haven't seen. I'll just have to get it on my watch list.
So The Night House Inn at number five. My number five is Malcolm and Marie, is where I have Malcolm and Marie for this year. I competed for awards last year, but definitely came out this year. And man, do I love this movie. And as I've already said, it is pretentious, but I think it earns its pretension. Some of the scenes are just incredible dialogue going on between these two. And any movie that's going to ask two people to hold a movie like this for this long is a high task. And I think Washington and Zendaya do it really, really well. So yeah, it is my number five of the year. Andrew, what's your number five?
Bo Burnham's inside. Trump. Nice. All right, on to our number fours. Robert, what do you got at number four? This is where I have the father. And yeah, I think I talked about it at length and everything I have to say earlier.
I knew people like this and it just hit all those torture buttons, but in a way that I wanted it to. Yeah. Yeah. Yep. You had it at number four. I had it at number eight. I would just add that this is another one, you know, considered for awards last year, but definitely came out this year and it is incredibly constructed. I don't, the level of difficulty in portraying Alzheimer's like this or dementia like this is, is just astonishing that it even makes any bit of sense. And I don't know that a movie has ever captured.
empathy for this condition in such a powerful way. Um, it, because it makes you experience what it must be like to experience this condition and, um, man, the father's good stuff. So I'm glad you had it that high on your list. Uh, in at number four for Robert, Aaron, what is your number four? Spider-Man. Trump. Trump and Spider-Man. So, my number four. Dune, I have at number four. Trump. Yeah, I figured that. So, Andrew, you're number four. What do you have? That's where I have the Green Knight. Nice. Because I have it at the highest. Yeah, a visual masterpiece with an amazing story of humility. I love it. Who else have? It's like cinematic visuals. It's not the best shot movie. I still think that's Last Night in Soho. But as far as the way that the color palette is used, I think that it's just the most gorgeous movie of the year. Robert, you had this one as well, right? Yeah, I had it at eight.
Yeah, for all the reasons I've been mentioning in both of these episodes is that, yeah, it's just so thematically resonant, visually stunning. Dev Patel is amazing. All of the supporting characters are amazing too. And I just get goosebumps and get giddy watching that, the moment that Andrew nominated for Best Moment. All right, so the Green Knight comes in at number four for Andrew and number, did you say eight? Number eight. Number eight for Robert. And so that brings us to our number threes. Robert, what do you got at number three? This is where I have Dune.
I'm 25 years old, so I've heard my whole life people talking about the amazing experience seeing Star Wars for the first time in theaters or seeing Lord of the Rings for the first time in theaters. And I never assumed that I would have that sort of experience, but I had it watching Dune. I was completely blown away, saw it opening weekend in IMAX. It was one of my best theater experiences in that no one was crinkling popcorn, coughing, talking or anything like that. It felt like something special was going on in the room just watching this movie. I really do think it's a full movie. I think Paul has a full arc and he's ready to go on another full arc in part two. But maybe I also know that because I read the book. But I think it's...
Again, visually amazing. The Hans Zimmer score is just one of his best ever, and I think the best of the year. I love all the performances. I love Denis Villeneuve even more than I did before because of this. The way they blended practical and special effects was just amazing. I could go on and on about how much I love this movie, but I'll stop there. No, I love it. It's so interesting because I had the exact same experience of you. You had this at number three. I had it at number four, in that it hasn't been since Lord of the Rings that I felt this way about a movie, where I went to it and was just like, oh, take me to this world over and over again. I want to live here. Show me all of the things.
This is so beautifully constructed. I want to know everything about this universe. Literally the only thing I didn't like about this movie was not the fact that it was a part one. Let me be clear about my opinion on this. It was the fact that it wasn't marketed as a part one. That's what I don't like. There's a negative part to my experience with this movie when at the very beginning it says part one and right off the bat I'm like, what? Nobody has been marketing it this way. And in a weird...
in a weird way where it's like they're almost holding part two over your head going, everybody better go see part one so we can make a part two. And it's just like, no, just you're making Dune part one and Dune part two and just market it that way. And if they do that, I have a perfect experience with this movie, even though it is only a part one, because it is just as much a full movie, in my opinion, as Fellowship of the Ring is, or, you know, any of these, you know, movies that, that, you know, going ahead of time are a part of a, you know, bigger whole. But yeah, I, I, so I, again, that's why I have it so high on my list because I absolutely loved this movie and I echo so much of, of why the things that you said. So there you go. That is Dune in it. Robert's number three and my number four. All right. I think that brings us to Aaron's number three. Now we'll have to wait a little bit because this is where I have mass drop. All right. Then my number three.
I did not include this on my official votes for the tally that we will be doing for the 50s overall movie of the year, but I do have it as my number three movie of the year. I do believe it is a movie. For me, it was a 2021 movie. I'm going with Derek DelGaudio's In and of Itself here. Aaron mentioned that. I know, Aaron, when you sent your picks, you also mentioned if In and of Itself counts, it would be way up there for you. And that is why I didn't count it in my official tally because, you know, as far as the rules of...
eligibility, those kind of things. But I love it enough that I did want to include it in my countdown at number three. This is astonishing, astonishing work that Derek DelGaudio is doing here. And it's not just the magician part of it or the, you know, the tricks that he's doing. I can identify some of the, you know, not necessarily sleight of hand, but even just like, you know, just knowing enough about having watched enough fool us and interpreted enough secret code words that Penn Jillette has said. I know some of the stuff that's going on here, but it is the story he's telling.
It is meta in a way that most things that are meta can only aspire to be. It is meta in a way that the very definition of the thing itself is what the thing itself is trying to define and at the same time not define. It is brilliant philosophical stuff that's going on in this from second one to second none. And I absolutely love it. So I had to mention it in my list. Aaron, I know since you love it so much, you'd probably like to talk about it too. So feel free to jump in. Look, I've talked this movie to death. This is that movie that I saw in late February and it went to the very tippy top of my list and it stayed there the entire year, not even flinching.
I'll say this. Of the type of things that we've seen like this, Hamilton, Come From Away, whatnot, this feels the most cinematic. Frank Oz directing this really makes this feel like a cinema experience, for better or for worse. And the other thing, too, is... Part of the reason why this works so well for me, I mean, the thematic stuff is really what works the best for me, but Derto Ogadio is a perfect leading man. We could even maybe mark him as one of the best performances of the year. He's so great. He's just a spectacular storyteller. Yeah, no, it's good stuff. Robert or Andrew, did you want to chime in about this one? I never even heard of it until you guys started talking about it, and then you mentioned that Frank Oz directed it. It's about magic. It's a documentary. I'm like, how have I not heard this? Well, documentary's a little weird. It's not really about magic. Magic is the avenue to convey the message, and it's also like... Well, I'm just going off what it says on Hulu. Sure, sure, yeah, yeah.
It fits more in a documentary than anything else, but it's not. It's a recording of stage performances. There's always going to be that twisted unexpectedness to it. Robert Dicer, you mentioned it whenever you first saw it on Twitter. And I think I watched it that night or the next day or something. And yeah, I was blown away also. But for whatever reason, it just hasn't stuck with me. So it's a bit further down my list. But yeah, I think it's great. That is my number three. Andrew, what is your number three? Spooderman, No Way Home. Is this the highest? All right. I had four. All right. So Andrew has it at number three. Aaron has it at number four. And I had it at number six. So yeah, Spider-Man, No Way Home.
Go for it, Andrew. It's one of those, like, you can't believe Marvel keeps making you go, I can't believe they did it. How many times is Marvel going to get away with that? Making me think, I can't believe they did it. They've done it so many times, and... Yeah, this is... Well, they made the Eternals, so... I can't believe... Oh, I can't believe they did that. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, everybody's great. Everybody who came back to do characters from the past nailed it.
uh maybe one didn't but uh yeah i'm i'm shocked that they pulled this off it makes me question the future of marvel like the ramifications of what happens in this movie what where does that lead uh not i'm not even talking about like the multiverse of madness stuff i'm talking more about like with peter parker there are a lot of questions like how how would this movie going forward what that means for him then i'm curious about yeah uh aaron you had it higher than i did what were some of your thoughts This is top tier MCU for me. I think I'm quite as high on it as just general people are. There are some moments that don't work for me. I don't think Benedict Cumberbatch is really invested. I agree with that. But I think that most of the cast is specifically two of the three spiders.
And the supporting cast as well, you know, Green Goblin, Doc Ock. Even Jamie Foxx looks happy to be there, which you wouldn't expect, but, you know, given Amazing Spider-Man 2. But it's... I think this is not going to hold up as well for me over time for two reasons. Number one, this is something that you remember the moments of, kind of like, you know, there's a big comparison, like, is Game of Thrones or Breaking Bad, the best show of all time? And it's like, well, Breaking Bad is, like, consistently really good throughout, but Game of Thrones is, like, you know, like, kind of middling, and then you get the Red Wedding, and then it's kind of, you know, like, I feel like maybe it's that. Like, we remember...
the moments we talked about so many moments and then also just however they choose to handle this going forward if they if they don't stick true to the ending that they made this movie I'm going to have a sour taste of this movie. I think Feige is really adamant about continuity and ramifications. There's a very interesting conversation to have about a movie that you ranked your fourth favorite movie of the year. That was almost like, it's my fourth favorite, but here's all the stuff I hate about it. Everybody's talked about all the things that work so well, and you gushed on it for most of the four hours. But there's a reason it's your number four, right? Yes, yes. But it's just interesting to see. As of this moment, I love it. But yeah, it's almost like a...
No, I have that tendency as well, too. I do the same thing. I will not do that here, though. I will just say the most incredible thing about No Way Home for me is that they were able to pull off meaningful cameos and like ultra meaningful cameos. So there I think I said this in the review. There was only one of the in movie cameos that I felt was cheap. And every other one felt to me to be like foundationally important to the film. So, yeah. And I would also mention.
Since we didn't do honorable mentions of performances, I had several. One of them was Willem Dafoe in Spider-Man No Way Home. He owns it. He just absolutely nails that character. Nick Tokyo in the chat. To quote a wise prophet, Marvel knows how to play with their toys. Hey, that was me. Yes, they do. Time after time, they know how to play with their toys. All right, let's move on then to our number twos. Robert, kick us off. What's your number two? Bo Burnham. Bo Burnham Inside. I also have that at number two, so we can talk about it now. Yeah, that was another one that...
It wasn't quite as long as Supernova or The Father, but the moment I saw it, it was going to be extremely difficult to have it trumped, and it will be, as we'll talk about. But there are infinite layers to why I love this, and the farther we get away from it, and the more I'm growing in my own life, and the more the world is changing, the more that my relationship to this piece is changing. I've talked about it multiple times in plenty of different platforms. I'm not going to go too deep into it, but I love the music on a lot of different levels, and I love what he's saying. But also, I think it's so interesting to figure out, like Andrew's talking about, whether it's a performance or whether it's real. That whole idea is just so interesting to me, so interesting to dissect and to dive into and to discuss. And I have discussed it a lot with certain people. Yeah, there are just so many different layers, so many different facets, so many different reasons why this is up here. And at this point, I think I have all the lyrics memorized because I've just been listening to it for the last eight months or whatever. So, yeah. Well, the crazy thing is, I think he is struggling with what's authentic and what's performance. And that's what makes it so incredible is, in many ways,
Because of the modern culture we live in, we're all struggling with what is authentically me and what is this performance thing I put on social media? Or even for us, like, you know, doing the show or, you know, whatever level. Everybody has a level of performance now to their life because they have a public persona on social media. And so it really is just such a crucial, crucial part of all of our exploration of our own psyches right now that he's talking about in such a powerful and intricate and... meaningful and hilarious way. It's just genius level work that he is doing in this. And man, I was blown away the first time I saw it, even more blown away the second time I watched it through. And it's just one of those pieces of art that I think is going to absolutely grow in estimation over time for what it meant to the moment, not just the pandemic moment, but certainly the pandemic moment as well, but also just the technological social media moment that we are struggling with as a society, as a culture, and as a world. So well done to Bo Burnham.
Is Bo Burnham this generation's Andy Kaufman? Yes. Hmm. I mean, I understand what you mean by that. Kaufman definitely had an unhinged layer that was part of his persona that I'm not sure Bo has. I say yes because I think there's an element of you never really know when Kaufman is playing the straight man when he's playing his own version of himself. And same with Bo. You never really know when he's being true and authentic and when he's not. So in that vein, I say yes. I really wanted him to win the variety special or whatever it was at the Emmys. He lost out to...
Hamilton but I for that very reason I wanted to see just like what his demeanor and how he was gonna act like up on stage accepting that award like what was he hasn't spoken about it there's no interviews there's there's nothing he just dropped it and then kind of disappeared again so that that's part of the mystique and part of what makes it so great yeah yeah uh it was my number two it was Robert's number two um I think Andrew you had it at number five uh so there you go Bo Burnham's inside doing very very well uh let's see so I think that means we're on to Aaron's number two Yeah, I'm going to trump that. My number two, already mentioned Bill Burnham's Inside. Andrew, what is your number two? This is where I have West Side Story. Nice. I've said it a trillion times. I'm not a fan of musicals. And this is a movie where I was like, Aaron, why is Steven Spielberg remaking West Side Story? And then you see it and you're like, oh, because he can make it look like this. There are so many sequences in this movie that are just like, this is Spielberg at his finest. And that's saying something, obviously. Whenever he can do things that made you go...
that's real cinematic magic. And you don't see it that often. You see it in like Jurassic Park. You see it in Schindler's List. You see it in, you know, these movies that you go, oh, so he is, there's a reason why he's considered the greatest of all time. And it's because he can make movies like this. And for me to say that a movie that's almost, what, three hours long, that's a musical.
is my second favorite movie of the year. It's insane. It's insane. This movie should not be this good. Yeah, I'm with you. I had it at number seven. You had it at number two. Yeah, I really wasn't expecting just the absolute splendor of this movie. And, you know...
And Spielberg is one of those directors who somehow we occasionally just take for granted. And then he pops back up and goes, hello, guys. Remember how I'm one of the greatest directors ever to have lived? And this is kind of one of those moments. I think his last couple of movies, he did like The Post or something. And then there was the Bridge of Spies. And I'm like, okay, he's putting out decent content. But every now and then he's like, no, no, I'm Steven Spielberg. And you're like, oh, yeah, you are. And this movie was one of those moments where I was reminded he is who he is. That's right. All right, it's time for our number ones. Robert, what's your number one movie of 2021?
At this point, it should come to no surprise that it's mass. This movie, again, I saw it, what, like a month ago? I didn't think it was going to be Inside, Dune, The Father Supernova, anything like that, but it did. It blew me away. I think this is a movie that everybody should see because it gets at the heart at understanding other people. It strips everything away and says, who are we at our core? Can we know who other people are at our core? And if so, how can we know that? There's a real center of earnestness and sincerity and just...
At the end, it's really just love and positivity, even though it's immensely difficult to watch, and I teared up multiple times throughout the movie, just at different lines of dialogue. I think it's super important. I think I'm going to watch it many, many times throughout the rest of my life, and show it to many, many people, because I think it's just an important movie to watch. And I was expecting it to be good, I was not expecting it to be something that could go on my favorite movies of all time list. Yeah. Three of us had it on our list, I think. Aaron, I think you were the next highest. You had it at three. Yeah, performances are incredible here. This could be titled Empathy the Movie or Listening the Movie, Understanding whatever. I'm with Robert. I think this should be required viewing by lots of people. Just put it in the curriculum somewhere, high school, college, whatever. And I hope this wins Best Picture this year. This is my hope.
Yeah, I don't see that happening. No, but it's my dream. If I could have one wish. It'll get nominated, but... I think it will. It should get nominated. I think it will. It might not, though, Aaron. It might not get nominated. It's kind of really... It has fallen under the radar in some ways, and I do have it at number 10. We've mentioned the incredible performances. We've mentioned... I think we've mentioned the incredible structure. It's very much a stage play in a film. When I say that, it almost sounds demeaning. I don't mean it that way. I just mean you could very much pop four people on a stage and do this.
But it certainly uses its film language well, and it's incredible stuff. So yeah, and just an incredible title with multiple meanings that I'll let Aaron know here later. So yeah, so Mass is a great choice. My number 10, Robert's number one, Aaron. Oh, okay. I thought you were starting over. I'm like, no. And Aaron's number four was Mass. Aaron, what's your number one? Yeah, if Mass is Empathy the movie, then Coda is Schmaltz the movie. I love Coda. This hits me on every emotional fiber I have in my body.
It makes me laugh a lot. It's a lot funnier than I think people remember. There's a lot of really funny moments in it, but it just hits me on all these just cheesy moments that everything about my heart loves this movie. I love it that it's a movie so good you're having trouble encapsulating how good it is. I love it when that happens, that it means so much to you in that way. I think it's beautiful. I think it's a beautiful film. I totally get why this would be at the top of your list. Number one. It's also just a feel-good movie. Sure. There are moments that can make you cry, but there's a lot of times it's tears of joy or it's...
Yeah, it counters an emotional moment with just, or a sad emotional moment with just something that's just going to light up the room. I love this movie. Very nice. Number one for Aaron is Coda. My number one, it should be no surprise, is Tick, Tick, Boom. I think it was the third viewing of this where I realized that it was impossible for any other movie to be my number one other than this one because every single moment in the movie, every single song, every single beat, just...
played perfectly to me on the third time through and I think it says something about a film for me when instead of getting tired of it once I know all the beats that I look forward to every beat as it happens and I just found myself every song being like oh I know what's coming next oh the next song's gonna be this one it's gonna be so amazing and it's just like you know every song is your favorite song until the next one comes and that's just how this movie is for me we've already mentioned the astonishing performance at the center of it I think Andrew Garfield is doing incredible work. And this is the movie that Lin-Manuel directed this year and just an incredible directorial debut. The choices he's making with how he is intercutting reality with the stage show is some of the most smart choices in storytelling that I've seen in a long, long time. There's the Marriage Argument song. Yeah, called Therapy.
it shouldn't work. It just shouldn't work. What he's doing in that song should not work because this is a song that depends on its quick rhythm and, you know, crazy actions. And he is cutting in real authentic emotion into this over the top. So like, it's just, it's mind blowing that he would even say, Hmm, I wonder if I could do this because my brain would be like, no, that's dumb. You can't like the tones will completely undercut each other and they somehow don't. And I like, it's just, it's, it's just some astonishing choices he's making here with the.
the real world stuff versus the stage show stuff. Tick, tick, boom. It's just every time I watch it, it gets better and better. So yeah, that's my number one. Who else had it on their list and wanted to talk about it? Aaron, you had it at number two. So why don't you go next?
Yeah, I have two things to add to that. It was during the song therapy that I realized that Andrew Garfield is giving the best performance of the year, or the awards season. He's so good. He's so good in this whole movie. He brings that kind of energy, like I mentioned, right at the beginning of the film. And you're with him the whole way. The other thing is, kind of like you mentioned earlier as well, the way that this movie kind of intercuts between the stage show and real life, it really cut one of my biggest problems with the movies, which is ever since, with musicals, ever since 2012's Les Miserables, I can't get over emotions not matching.
what the lyrics are saying. Like somebody's clearly not projecting as much as they are in the studio. But the fact that you're blurring the lines of reality, it just excuses it and it's okay. So it was really easy to get over that for me, which is a really hard thing to do. Robert, did you have it on your list as well? Yeah, I had a number six. It's a tough thing when you see a character that you realize is kind of unlikable for a bit and then start seeing yourself in the character. So that's kind of how it was with the andrographic character in here.
But also, it taught me a lot. It made me think about a lot of different things. And it's a lot of stuff that I've been thinking about just in general in my own life these last few months, few years. Yeah, there's just a lot of interesting stuff about pursuing your passion, but also realizing that other people don't have the same opportunity to do that. Some people aren't as good. Some people aren't in the right financial position. Some people have life-threatening illnesses, that sort of thing. There's just a lot of stuff that I really, really love thematically. On top of it, it's a lighthearted movie a lot of the times. It's really funny at some points.
No one mentioned Robin DeJesus, the Michael character. He is great. I really wish he would have been getting some awards consideration throughout the season. Oh, you're absolutely right. The reveal moment is he is so powerful in that scene. He's conveying like three or four different emotions at the same time and does it so well. Yeah. Yeah. That scene on the street and then the one up in the office. Those two are just knockout performance moments. But yeah, I love Tick, Tick, Boom. Nice.
Well, there you go. Tick, tick, boom is my number one. Uh, it is Aaron's number two and it is Robert's number seven. Is that what you said? Six, six, number six. Uh, so there you go. Andrew, we're down to your number one. Finish us off. The last duel, Ridley Scott. Nice.
Yeah, I was waiting for somebody to trumpet, and then I realized it's my number one. Nope, can't trumpet number one. It's my number one times two. No, it's so brilliant. I love this movie. As we said before, the Rashomon technique really is what sells this movie, because you're watching this movie in the beginning, and you're going everything through Matt Damon's point of view, and it's kind of like, not a palate cleanser, but it's like setting the table for like, okay, so...
Everything that we see from here on out is based on our interpretation of what is happening in this first rendition. And it's crazy to see it change so drastically from different perspectives, yet at the same time being so familiar. On top of that, you have an amazingly shot movie by Ridley Scott. In this entire movie, you're waiting to get to that last duel. And it delivers. It is terrifying, it's visceral, it's gory, and it's emotional. You're waiting for...
uh, this Adam driver character to, you know, like, is he like going to confess or whatever? Or is he going to stick to his guns? Like he didn't do it. And it makes you question at the very end, like, did he do it? Because he's adamant that he didn't do it yet. At the same time, we're like, is he just not interpreting what has happened as rape or is she lying? So you're like, what? I love a movie that leaves you. I know the movie wants you to believe that, uh, that, uh, Jodie Comer's character, uh, Marguerite is the one telling the truth. I think the movie is really, you know, trying to, you know,
send the message home that she's the one telling the truth. But honestly, at the very end, I was questioning, was she lying? And I've actually heard a lot of people, including my mom, who was like, I think she was lying. And I'm like, really? That's an interesting take that I was not expecting from this movie because it is so adamant to make you think that Jodie Comer's telling the truth. But the fact that this movie got people talking, and I really wish that a lot of more people had seen it. I love a movie that forces you to focus in and try and pick out all the different details. Yeah, it's my favorite.
Last duel. Good choice is Andrew's number one. All right. Well, that brings us to the official Sif Pop movie of the year. This is chosen not just by us four, but by all of the contributors and the guest gurus who guest on the podcast. Would you say that there's a plethora? I would say there's a plethora of contributors. So all those who contribute give their number five through number one. They are signed points based on.
those placements, and then they are ranked. If a movie only has one person who has it in their top five, that movie is not eligible. There were 31 movies that had at least two people mention them, and so we will do a top 31 countdown. We will go very quickly through the first several, and then we will slow down when we get to the top 10. I will throw just a couple shout-outs to a couple movies that only got one vote that are probably worth mentioning because they came late in the year. Swan Song is one of those. Tragedy of Macbeth is another one of those. The Lost Daughter.
is another one of those that came very, very late in the year. Olivia Colman, by the way, was one of my honorable mentions in performances. She's incredible in that movie. So some shout outs to those movies who may, after a little bit more time, get some votes. Being the Ricardos, also, we haven't really talked about that at all or very much. That only got one vote. So yes, those are some of the ones we're leaving off the list. So starting at number 30. Oh, and by the way, Tiebreakers. Yeah. Happened this way. Whoever had it the highest. Correct. So if there are two movies that say have eight points based on the point system, if somebody had one of those movies at number one and the other one nobody had it at number one.
then it goes by that. If those are the same, then it ends up going by how many people had it at that ranking. So there we go. 31 is a movie called... I have typed up my prediction for what number one is. I just want to say that. So I'm putting my phone right here. Good. Number 31 is Nine Days. I mentioned a couple times. A couple people had that on their list. Number 30 is Encanto. Three people had that on their list at number five. It comes in at number 30. Number 29 is Malignant, which we haven't talked about at all. But a couple people had Malignant on their list. So that's at 29. Ending up with a straight tie for number 27th is No Time to Die and Judas in the Black Messiah. Those two tied at 27. We haven't talked a lot about Judas in the Black Messiah. That's another one that was last awards season, but did come out this year.
Red Rocket comes in at number 26. Tied for number 24, Nightmare Alley and The Father. So The Father coming in at number 24 with Nightmare Alley. Number 23, Last Night in Soho comes in at number 23. Number 22, Licorice Pizza in at number 22. Tied for 20, Tatane and Worst Person in the World come in tied for number 20. Number 19 is The Harder They Fall. Tied for 17, Shang-Chi and Justice League. Zack Snyder's Justice League comes in at number 17 with Shang-Chi.
Number 16, no more ties from 16 on up. Number 16 is Don't Look Up. Number 15 is Pig. Number 14 is Mitchells vs. The Machines. Number 13 is The Suicide Squad. Number 12 is Power of the Dog. Number 11 is Mass. And now we get to the top 10. Mass just missing the top 10 in at number 11 with 17 points. Number 10.
Number 10 with 18 points. 8, 9, and 10 all had 18 points. They were separated by the tiebreakers. Number 10 with three number ones. No, I'm sorry. Yes, three number ones, a number four, and a number five is Belfast comes in at number 10. Nice. Number nine with six people voting for this one. So that's where it won the tiebreaker. I think I got those tiebreakers reversed when I said them earlier. It's actually if more people have it voted as the first tiebreaker. Second tiebreaker is the higher ranking.
So at number nine, with one number one, one number two, two number threes, a number four, and a number five, The Last Duel coming in at number nine. Number one was? I don't know. Number eight had a number one, two number twos, number three, and two number fives. Bo Burnham's Inside comes in at number eight on this official Sif Pop list. And at number seven, with 19 points, the only movie with 19 points, and on seven people's lists, The Green Knight comes in at number seven.
Number six, with 21 points on six people's lists, including two number ones, West Side Story in at number six. Number five, with 22 points on seven people's lists, including one number one, is Spencer in at number five. Good showing from Spencer. In at number four, with 22 points on seven people's lists, including a number one and two number twos, is Coda. Coda comes in at number four.
And on to the top three. Number three with 27 points on nine people's lists, including two number ones, Dune, in at number three of 2021. Number two with 41 points. Good number. 41 points. It was on 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 people's lists, including five number ones. In at number two is Tick.
tick boom uh in at number two and the number one movie the official sift pop sifty movie of the year with 56 points on 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 people's lists including 1 2 3 number ones it is spider-man No Way Home. I thought it was going to be. I got it. No, it was not. So there you go. The official movie of the year for Sif Pop is Spider-Man No Way Home. I am completely comfortable with that pick. I think it is one of the things I love about doing the Sif Pop is it is not about awards prestige. It really is about the best movies of the year. And in many ways, Spider-Man certainly fits that bill with what it did. So there you go. The official movie of the year for Sif Pop is Spider-Man No Way Home. And that'll do it for the Sifties this year. Congratulations on a four hour plus marathon in parts one.
and part two. Appreciate all those involved. Thanks so much for joining us today for Sif Pop. It is part of the Studio DNA Podcast Network. You can find out more about other shows on the network at studiodna.media or by searching Studio DNA in your podcast player. Huge thanks to Andrew for hanging out today. Feel like I've already done this today. Thank you, buddy. Big thanks to producer Phil for producing the audio and video show. Big thanks to Robert and Aaron for hanging out with us today. Tell us again about the other stuff you're doing. Aaron, tell us about the podcast.
Yeah, we'll just direct people to the Writer's Room. If you want to hear the Sif Pop writers that we have, mention their top five films of the year and why they are that. You can go to the Sif Pop Writer's Room podcast and listen to episode, I think, 83. It's our top five films of 2021. So if you want to hear some voices from some writers that specifically say they're five and why, that'd be a great place to start. And Robert, tell us about Robert's thoughts. Yeah, it's a YouTube channel slash blog dedicated to movies and TV. Do video essays. I'm working on one about Succession and another about Man of Steel right now. So got a lot of fun stuff coming up. A lot of stuff.
done already. So yeah. By the way, you now have 201 subscribers. Awesome. Thank you. Andrew, is it your news? No, I'm going to bring it back. I'm going to go unsubscribe. Just so it's a nice even number. No, thank you guys so much for your time. I know it's a big investment today and I really do appreciate it and appreciate the work you're doing at Sifpop.com and managing the website and all that. It's a big deal and thank you for doing that. Thank you to our Sifpop members as well for supporting what goes on here. $3 a month is where it starts. Different fun stuff at different levels including bonus episodes and ad-free podcasts, all that kind of fun stuff. You can find out more at patreon.com slash Sifpop. Lots of ways to connect with us. Feel free.
free to comment, rate, or leave a review at Apple Podcasts or email us at feedback at cifpop.com. And finally, if you're having a good time, your movie-loving friends will probably like it too, so make sure you let them know about the podcast and that listening is much easier than tiptoeing around Spidey spoilers. We will be back next week with probably Jackass and Moonfall. It is January. Yeah, it is. Let's go. So we will see you then. I like how we just talked about some of the most prestigious movies of like the past, possibly the past decade, and then we're going to follow it up, Jackass and Moonfall.