Hi and welcome to classical stuff you should know a podcast about the classical world classical education put on by three guys who are Classestists in a classical school who know stuff that they are transmitting to news that you should know Bite-sized classical tidbits for the fast-paced modern world Wow, but these podcasts are like an hour. Yeah Well regardless of how we introduce We thank you for listening and tuning in today. We're gonna take you on a journey One may even say an Odyssey And Hanoverg is not responding is our fearless captain. He has tied himself to a pole in the middle of the classroom With and he's plugged his ears.
I'm not quite sure why that is, but maybe he's going to tell us my problem with these pun intro Is to tell our audience about the Odyssey and they only get it if they already know the Odyssey It is like a little Easter egg or like a little tidbit of the already initiated so that they can get it They have to listen to our podcast and then go back and listen to your introduction If you read a book once you've never read it. It's right So I'll listen to a podcast once you've never listened to it But to really plumb the depths of the podcast it requires multiple listens. How many times have you listened to each episode? Listen at all speaking of listening.
I've been listening to our podcast a little bit I know Graham listens for quality and I know you also listen for quality at least on the most part And you know we get some things wrong and we address that at the end of the podcast But Graham and I were talking and both of us feel inadequate to this task that we're doing at least to a certain extent Right I listen back and I think oh, there's a thing I should have known that I don't know that's kind of on the edges of my topic and or I don't know it quite as thoroughly as I Need to and I know Graham has the same experience every once in a while We ask a question and he just doesn't know it happened in the House of Atrios episodes to me It happens in a lot of the episodes that I'm in charge of and it's it's a little embarrassing But I don't know that avoiding That there's a good way to avoid it right part of jumping into the classical world is being comfortable with not knowing absolutely everything Exactly as a classical scholar you are at least a little bit a generalist right you want to know about these things But knowing absolutely everything about the early on the Odyssey is possible Yeah, it's well, it's probably possible, but only if I had a PhD and You'd only know the Odyssey right right and that's not the point of jumping into classical education It's knowing it's knowing these stories enough to bring all of the ideas together right and so yes We are amateurs at least to it at least you know to an extent and I hope you as an audience aren't disappointed with when we say We just don't know we are trying to bring you into the classical world in the same way that we jump into the classical world And that is with a little bit of Failure and a little bit of being okay with not knowing everything and not understanding it to you know 100% degree that you would get from say a PhD in in the classics But then you miss all of the breadth of the knowledge that you could have right most classic classics Oh, it's word generalists. They knew a little bit of math. They knew a little bit of art They knew a little bit of music they knew a little bit of gymnastics They knew a little bit of everything and that's what we're trying to help you do when you come into the world That's what we're trying to do ourselves So I'm sorry audience if we ever you know bump up against the edges of our knowledge But that's just part of trying to do so many disparate topics is think of our failures as an ability as inspiration for you to Dive in and not have to feel like you have everything but that under your belt Yeah, I don't know if all of this podcast is to so we could get here We could get on the podcast we could read Wikipedia article to you all day and provide you more information But I don't think that's what I don't think that would be a good use of anyone's time like I think part of what we provide here is that we love these things that we're talking about and so I don't know I'd rather that catch on than you learn 87 facts about the Odyssey. Why click on that?
You would you read that? It's some crazy things man. I love those excuse me. I love those deeply articles.
I just it's almost all Facebook has for ads for me now It's just like 20 crazy things celebrity tweeted and I'm like oh, yes celeb tweets It's just what I give me that sweet sweet trash. Yeah, it's great It's just a way to rot my brain and I love it. Did someone read out about that or is that just something you all been? Oh, you just heard how to thought we were talking about it and we didn't want You know, it's kind of embarrassing to run a podcast where you're like, I don't know when you ask questions I don't know if it is like again You all enjoy these things and you teach these things to the students like I don't know I think there's value in the passion You all have for it and what you all know I don't know you don't have to know everything about these topics for them to be useful or interesting Yeah, anyway, just as an audience.
So we're sorry that we don't know everything I guess that's what I'm apologizing for Yeah, maybe it's a little bit of hubris. I'm sorry. I don't know everything. Yeah, okay anyway today I wanted to talk about the Odyssey we talked at last You know recording session we had Dante and then a while before that I didn't intro to the epics and I wanted to jump a little bit further into the Odyssey because it's one of those foundational books that It's just sort of generally important to know and understand what's going on there and how it has affected other literature coming from it So I'm gonna give a quick summary and then I'm gonna talk about Campbell's heroes journey which has been translated into Star Wars and a few other things I think it's Joseph Campbell and then I'm gonna talk about the Golden Bowl theory which sounds funny and it is a little funny But we'll get there so the basic summary of the Odyssey what what you probably are familiar with is only four chapters of the Odyssey Right as sort of a lay person we all get the travels of Odysseus, but that's only four chapters of the book It's a small portion and it's where it's kind of the good part all the action happens Yeah, there's a couple other good spots where lots of people die and get murdered and that's fun But really the journey only takes about four of the 24 chapters of the entire Odyssey So where the book begins is not with Odysseus at all we don't meet him until chapter five the book begins at home where His son to Lemicus that he left at home when he journeyed off to war He hasn't seen telemicus and telemicus was but a babe right he was a tiny child and so he went off to war and when he left He took his wife Penelope and he said listen once my son grows a beard if I'm not home You marry another man, right?
Which could happen around what 1516s or I don't understand this is another one of those things that I don't Really sure depends on the kid. Yeah, I think some some start going full beard about a brave freshman Yeah, who are like I'm a stick for janitors And we don't have janitors Yeah, I still can't grow a beard. It's embarrassing. I get patchy.
That's all the gross I really like if you don't shave it just I haven't shaved what you are seeing is non-shaved a patch here and a patch here And they're lopsided on my face. It's fast. It's not a good look Anyway, so we start with telemicus And he it kind of opens with him daydreaming in his house about his dad and just sort of sitting there and what we find out Is that in Odysseus absence because he's been ten years at war and that's what sort of the iliad is about is that war and then he We find out later. He's been about ten years coming home So he's been gone for 20 years But now he probably knows that the war has ended and he is still gone because other heroes have probably trickled home Yeah, other heroes have returned Nestor an old fella has returned and he's kind of nearby Menelius one of the great kings has returned here He's kind of nearby and then egg a memo return and got murdered by his wife Which we talked about in the house at atreus all of that's happened and most most of the Greeks have know that it has happened and Odysseus Is nowhere to be found he is yet gone So she is beset with a hundred and fourteen suitors who are in her house vying for her hand in marriage And I know a lot of my ninth-grade girls are like oh if only right they are they're thinking oh that would not be fantastic having a 114 guys vying for my hand like wrecking the house aren't they eating all the food and that's the problem we these are 114 guys Who have not been able to get married yet?
So probably not the cream of the crop Well some of them are young and you have to you have to think that they aren't the guys that went to war with Odysseus So they probably weren't the able-bodied men that were in Ithaca at the time Ithaca is the island that Odysseus rules as king And they're nearby lords and they all come and divide for her hand and she has delayed marriage by telling them all I will marry somebody after I finish a funeral shroud for Odysseus father laterties Who is old and he's sleeping in the vineyard and he's being real Moby and so he's probably gonna die soon Because he's really sad that Odysseus is gone. He's kind of treating himself like a homeless person and Not like the king that he is or at least the father of the king and she says once I'm done with it I'll marry somebody but every night she unweaves her progress and takes all the threads out so that the guys are like man you are the slowest Weaver ever I swear it was right there yesterday and she's like it just takes time you guys and The problem with having 114 suitors in your house is you got to feed all those guys They have been drinking Odysseus wine eating Odysseus cattle using all of his resources They've been abusing the waitstaff or sleeping with the waitstaff even as they vie for her hand and then and she knows this She knows that they're just sort of abusing her hospitality. She can't kick him out and Tilemicus who should be the man you know wearing the pants in this situation. He should be in charge of his house Isn't he sort of moping around he's a easy young child.
We get the impression He's probably like 21 by now He's supposed to be around 20 or 21 But it feels when we when it opens like he's like 14 or 15 So he's not really acting the age that he is and at least he's not taking control of his house and while we have wealth laid up in bank Accounts their wealth was almost entirely in flocks so the longer those men are there the poorer Penelope gets right every her house is being Decimated the phrase they use is bleeding my house white and these the first four books is known among scholars as the telemic It's like a mini epic for telemicus because in the first couple of books Athena shows up pretending to be somebody else and says I know About your dad. He's coming home. What you need to do is try to kick these suitors out go find out some news about your dad so he Calls a council says all you suitors should get out of my house and even some of the neighbors are like yeah You suitors are being pretty shameful about this and the suitors stand up and they pretty much say what are you gonna do about it? Like you have the force to kick us out No, until your mom chooses somebody we're gonna stay here and eat all your food And there's nothing you can do about it.
So it's like his burst into tears and the council everyone throws the talking stick on the ground It's not again. Not a good look just like my beard. It's not good Doesn't look good on him Yeah, and so he sneakily gets a crew together and then goes to visit nester and medallias to find out news about his dad And so he takes a little journey and for him It's a journey of growth what he sees when he's at these other two kingdoms is with nest or it's a king with his sons And the sons respect their father his armies are all well-arrayed and they are giving sacrifices to the gods So he sees a well-run pious kingdom which he's never seen before and then at medallias his house He sees a wealthy king who has gotten his goods by war and a good marriage strangely enough because Helen has returned and is not with medallias And she's like huh I was such a I'm sorry for this She's like I was such a whore back then I was yeah, she's like what a silly girl I was and she they start telling stories about who Odysseus was so as he travels he sees a well-run kingdom a good marriage with and Material rewards gained by glory and also gets stories about his dad and everyone recognizes and they'll you look just like him It's the spitting image and so inspires him with stories about his father that will hopefully mean that he returns home and takes control of his house So he hears and sees life as an ought to have been like life as it should be with an ordered house an ordered kingdom Yeah, he has never a good life that he's never seen he's never had a good male authority figure His grandpa's sleep in the fields all the dudes bleeding his housewives sleeping with the wait staff No one is a good example for telemicus and so he doesn't know what it means to be a king So his travels are to establish him as As the king and so what he undergoes is something called pidea and it pretty much means coming of age with divine help Right Athena is kind of guiding him through this in fact she joins him on the travels under the guise of someone named mentor Is that where we get the word from? Yes, actually when we say he is my mentor We are actually making a reference to the Odyssey right we're saying that he is my divine Athena that is bringing me towards adulthood so he goes off and he's traveling and then we sort of leave him And we know that he is going to return and the suitors have planned an assassination They think because he's right and he's like get out of my house and they don't want him around anymore They want to be able to get free stuff and just sort of poop around and not have to pay for anything And so they say when he comes back we are gonna lay it lay and wait and kill him And so that's kind of setup and then we get book five.
I'm sorry. This is gonna So they don't resolve it by book four so I don't think they do I think that it gets resolved near the end of the book I think it's a little bit too but it's just because it's just and Odysseus is at the end of his journey Right it kind of jumps in the middle of the action and so we see him at his lowest point He comes off Calypso's island. He sails for a little while he gets some help from a nymph that gives him a magical sea scarf It's really unclear what the scarf does my impression are always really confused by it Like he's in this storm Poseidon is still really angry at him and we kind of learn a little bit more about why later It's it's said early in the book, but we sort of don't know the whole story Poseidon hates him He sends a storm and he's just on a raft clinging to it his raft is destroyed and then it pops up and she's like here take this scarf It will help you he ties around his waist and we still have no idea what it does I think maybe she just wanted to flirt right and then she says when you hit land you must avert your eyes and throw it back into the sea So it's like it's magical sea scarf grenade that he has to chuck into the sea Maybe it's like a flotation device like it's like a water. Yeah, maybe I mean he still is like almost drowned naked He shreds his hands on some coral which is horrible He's just having a bad time and then he chucks the scarf into the sea and we don't hear anything more about it That's all we learn and then he takes refuge under this really weird olive bush Now Graham you talk about one of the things we do in classical literature is when something seems odd or weird or impossible Or the author spends a lot of time on it inexplicably for seemingly no reason like he spends four pages talking about You know a sea crab There might be something going on there that we need to investigate the things that are strange or the things that we have to investigate more And he takes refuge under this impossible physiologically impossible olive bush And he he's kind of at the end of everything.
He's tired. He's naked He's at the end of his travels and he piles up some leaves crawls underneath and sleeps And the reason it's an impossible bush is because one side is domestic Right, it's a cultivated olive bush that would be found on a farm the other side of it It's like trimmed and pruned and Beautiful and you know selected for its genetic properties the other is wild It's a wild bush but they grow from the same root Which unless you have grafted a branch on which no one would do on a random beach somewhere This this plant cannot exist so something weird is going on there And they don't we don't really understand it until later But Odysseus or Homer gives us this beautiful picture as he falls asleep. So he wakes up meets a nice princess Who's like oh you cute? It's really awkward.
They're like playing on the beach and he walks out naked and he's like hello Please help me And we find out that he's you know Athena kind of makes him good looking She's still protecting Odysseus and the the princess is like hey Oh, this is this is a man She can recognize that he is quite manly And then she says we can't go back to town together because me showing up with a strange man coming back from time probably isn't a good thing So she sneaks a man naked one right right and then there's like some songs and contests and they welcome Odysseus And he spends some time crying when one of the bards sings a song about the great war It's actually really funny. Homer tends to write himself into the novels somewhere So he's just like incredible so he makes him tell incredible in his story Yeah, once in a while like a bard shows up and like there's this little musical interlude and all the heroes are like Bards are awesome. You are the real hero of the story. And that's what happens the bards Yeah, the bards sings it and then Odysseus the master craftsman who invented the Trojan horse who is maybe one of the greatest military minds ever walks up and says I respect no man on earth more than you like I respect you more than he has been with Achilles and he's telling this random bard like I respect you More than anyone else and so it's this great little interlude And then they ask Odysseus to tell his story right so he's in this strange kingdom the fations and they say hey Where where are you from what's your story?
I know disias is greatest sort of weaving tales and he needs these people to help him He has nothing and so he has to paint himself well So he tells the story of his journey from the the end of the Trojan war to where he is now And that's this is where the big story begins it only takes four books and I'll try to hustle through it But yeah, this is what we're familiar with right so as he leaves Troy the first thing he does is raid another island He doesn't go straight home. He just stops and he's like how about we kill some more people and get some more stuff But he didn't need the stuff he just wanted to oh absolutely not great. He is rife with treasure He's got like 12 ships. He has the arms of Achilles that are beautiful.
There's no reason he needs to stop But hey, why not we're making some war great so they stop they raid a town and then they do the dumbest possible thing And that's they don't leave they're staying the town and then they hang out on the beach nearby Kind of eating and feasting and then the guys from the town go to other towns nearby Raise an army and then attack back and he has to flee and they lose you know They lose a bunch of people yeah, the next place is the the land of the lotus ears This is one of the more famous scenes if you read Percy Jackson and I have it no I've had a recommended that is your reference like this is the most famous thing perhaps if you have read the Percy Jackson Yeah, it's a popular kids book. Yeah, and so this is where he he also like Famous poems called the anyway, whatever. Yeah eating the lotus has become since now since then synonymous with sort of oblivion and the temptation of drugs and their returning and sort of Leaving the things you care about behind so he's men walk in and they find a bunch of people who are just eating these lotus flowers And they're sort of spaced out and we find out that when you eat the flower You forget about home and you lose all desire to do anything Well, so he realizes the danger here that we could lose desire for anything takes his men and even as they are crying He likes chains them to the rowing benches and forces them to row which is a little bit of a better outcome than they just had Yeah, the other place. Yeah, yeah Then he shows up on the Cyclopsus Island and this is the most the single most famous scene in the in the Odyssey and He's curious.
He goes into this cave He wants to hang out and wait for a guest gift which is traditional custom Right I show up you give me a gift and the next time when you go to my house I give you a gift what comes in instead is a Cyclops who is lawless and says you guys have been eating my food and now I'm gonna eat you Roll's a big boulder in the way eats a couple of guys wakes up the next morning eats the more people goes out to you know And then eventually they feed him some wine make him fall asleep and Odysseus tells the Cyclops that his name is nobody He's like what's your name is nobody and then so in the night after he's drunk they stab stab the Cyclops in the eye The Cyclops gets up rolls the stone away and then calls for help from his brothers, but he what he knows nobody has blinded me Nobody is hurting me and they're like why are you talking and then they all ignore him and Odysseus You know they he tapes all his guys under sheep and then the sheep run out And so the Cyclops is feeling the sheep and all he feels is his flocks And so he doesn't catch any of the men as they run out of the cave Oh, and then as they're sailing away as the Cyclops is mourning on the shore and this is I spend more detail here because it's pivotal he Odysseus turns around and says you know who blinded you? Oh Odysseus Odysseus of Ithaca that's the guy who blinded you if anyone asks it was me and your own crimes come down on your head for eating his Guess which is not okay. That's like a bad idea to give the name Yeah, and his men also said it was a bad idea especially cuz like arrogant yeah What happens is the Cyclops takes big boulders and chucks him at the ship and almost hits him and it one lands like just off the bow And then I'm like dude shut up and then he yells again And he's like oh you missed you nerd and then they throw more rocks and that moment of hubris of folly of saying wanting to be well known wanting to be Story Well, it allows the Cyclops to get on his knees and pray to Poseidon and say I have been blinded And because the Cyclops is one of Poseidon's sons He says I've been blinded by Odysseus Ithaca please punish him for this and that is what causes the remainder of Odysseus troubles He would have just sailed home if he would have kept his big mouth shut Yeah, but because of this moment of hubris and pride he brought it on himself He brings it on himself well so after that they sail to aolia which is the island of the god of winds And he gives he begs up all of the three winds except one so he leaves one wind and that's the wind that's gonna blow them all home Odysseus has this bag full of three of the four winds and he doesn't tell his men what's in it They're like dude what do you got there? And he's like you'll find out when we get home and he's really cagey about it and eventually he falls asleep and the men are They think he's hiding treasure from them so they open it and it blows them right Like they were in view of home they can see smoke from the chimneys They open the bag and it blows them all the way back to the island of the wind god And he says yeah get off my porch clearly the gods hate you I don't want to help you anymore get out of here And so his troubles continue to compound he stops at the land of the Leastregonians And they turn out to be giants and cannibals and they sink all of his ships but one Then he goes to the island of Cersei And this this is where he meets another he meets a goddess She turns all of his men into pigs and then he's as he is trying to rescue them He meets Hermes Hermes gives him a plant that makes him immune to her magic And then he says after you you know avoid her magic Draw your sword and frighten her a little and then she'll offer to go to bed with you and you have to say yes Does it hurt me saying this yeah?
Hermes tells him you have to say yes to a goddess. I feel like Hermes is like a bored aristocrat It's like you know what else you can do for fun Well, you know in mythical history, it's always a really bad idea to refuse a goddess She's like hey, we should get together if you say no she'll like turn you into a crab with broken claws It never turns out well when you don't do what the gods want. Yeah, so he scares her she says hey I worry attracted to you. Yeah, he puts the men back together and they spend a full year in Cersei's house A year just like a long time.
They don't need to spend a year. Yeah, Odysseus has a family to get home to yet He stays and I think this is where we kind of learned that we realize that Odysseus doesn't know what's happening at home When he left 20 years ago, he said you need to get a new man when my kid gets a beard and it's been a long time It's very likely that Penelope has remarried His kid has never seen his face since he's been a baby. Can you imagine returning not knowing what's going on? So there's just big like family drama waiting for him at home and he's he like dallying and he's just yeah He's just trying other.
He's just avoiding the the hard conversations. Yeah, I mean even Even now it's awkward to meet an ex that you may be still love and she's got a new guy And you have to make her choose between like it's just really complicated He goes home and finds that there's a king in his place He faces mortal danger that he might want to kill him and he faces a wife who he's now putting in a really difficult position He's got a kid that might be like you're not my real dad And I mean that's not something you really want to go home to and he's hanging out with a cute goddess She's got lots of resources. She's feasting them every day and I can see why he wouldn't want to leave It's frustrating that he chooses to stay there instead of trying to get home like he doesn't want to own up or um face all this problems You're talking about like yeah, I don't know he's comfortable going in slaughtering villages and taking these treasures and stabbing slack Clops in the eye, but he doesn't want to face his family like I don't know I think it's a very charitable reading to say that like he's worried about going home But he's also is cowardly. I don't know if he's cowardly so much as glory hungry.
He's causing a politics He wants to be known throughout the world. He wants to have seen the world. He's interested in all these things and Sleeping with a goddess for a year is a good story to tell I guess yeah, but I can see I can see where he's coming from Do I ruin the punchline if we talk go back to the olive branches? Uh, we'll return in a little bit.
All right, so he hangs out with Cersei and eventually it's his men that say dude We want to go home we have families too and you are hanging out and eventually is like all right I have to leave in the morning that they're gonna leave they've of course gotten drunk the night before and one of them is sleeping on the roof And he wakes up and he's like oh I gotta get out of here and he forgets to take the ladder back down off the roof and just runs off the roof And dies. Oh no, and what does he's leaves him without burying him and we'll meet him in a second So obviously he's leaves him and they go now to the underworld, which is where she said you have to go She's like to get home. You're gonna have to visit hell Essentially she give a reason for that because I mean they were almost home before with the winds why she like yeah, no the real way You know this time you go down. She says you have to go visit Tyreseus who is a famous Greek seer He's supposed to be one of the wisest men on earth because he spent time as both a man and a woman Hmm, really?
Yeah, yeah He witnessed the gods mating and as a punishment The gods turned him into woman and then he would come back into a man and he'd be so he would sort of frequently through his life Flip back and forth between male and female and give him really I thought it was just the one time thing my understanding was that The gods came down because he was wise they asked him who has I'm sorry There are kids with kids you might want to skip for 20 seconds But it was a bet between Hera and Zeus about who had more fun in the sack and he said I think he said men or Something one of the he offended one of the gods was answer and they so they changed into the other yeah And then later he saw two snakes making love and hit the snakes with a stick and the snake actually gods Oh was it yeah, okay, that was where he witnessed the gods mating It was like real shiny and it's like trying snakes No, he came into the sacred grove where the gods made love and he wasn't supposed to be there and he saw what he describes two snakes and And then he then I think the gods were really offended and then turned him back There's a couple of stories where he goes back and forth between the gods between being male and female and female And yeah, he shows up a lot in He's kind of all over in the Greek world So they need to go and visit him to get wisdom about how to get home He's dead and he's an ill so he goes Odysseus and his crew travels to the underworld and how they get there I think now would be really vague We would expect him to like jump in a hole in the ground right is our understanding is that hell is down for the Greeks Their cosmos was a big flat disk with the ocean river around the outside like a big Hamburger wrapped in bacon, right the bacon is the ocean river so they sail across the ocean river and they get outside Basically the known realm where the the Sun every morning would plunk jump out of the ocean river travel its course and then jump back into the ocean river At night so they're past that they are in a land of always twilight the Sun does not reach them So that's where he goes to the underworld He is past the known universe or at least where mortals usually go and he's in the realm of the immortals and he talks to Tyreseus the Seer who gives him a little news of home and says you have to do a few things you can't eat the cattle the Sun You're not gonna die till you're really old and he gives him some signals about knowing his death is coming It's like sort of reassures Odysseus that the rest of the journey is not gonna be dangerous and he talks about You know it says you need to curb your wild desire and the wild desires of your men basically you're being rowdy Just go home. You don't he also meets Elton or the guy who fell off the roof and the guy who fell off the roofs asks for a couple Things he says please bury me because if you don't I have to suffer for the rest of you turn They go back they have to go back to Cersei's island and also tell my story So in my head Elton or is like the greatest frat boy of all time who's like I died doing what I loved I party Make sure everybody knows that I was the hardest partier there ever was Because if it was me and I died I'd be like you wrap that up Because in the book of acts there is somebody who is I don't know if this is similar or if this is a An illusion, but there's somebody who's sitting on a window so listening to Paul preachers sermon and he falls out of the window and dies and then Paul prays over him and he comes back to any comes back from the dead I know that there is That in the Luke acts narrative there are Some classical scholars out there that think that there that the author of Luke acts has the Odyssey also in mind a little bit I wonder if there's more to that story. Well, there are I think it's it's not the telegram It's the the name of a dissius also gets used. I think it's in Luke the man of twists and turns Yeah, the word that they use in Greek to describe Odysseus is poly tropos and twists in terms Yeah as either the man of twists and turns or the man of many faces, but that's not a complete translation Polly is many what's tropos?
I think Phase ways that's what many ways and a better translation would be a man of many many's he's so multifaceted his facets have facets Yeah, that's kind of the way to think of him He is he's not just a jack of all trades even in the trades He is twisty internian knows what to do, but it's a word that only gets used in the Odyssey to describe it Is it's like they made up a word for a dizzy in this and when when the I think it was Luke right he uses that word to describe Jesus Yeah, he's not beating around the bush any Greek listener any Greek listener that would have read that book immediately would have made the comparison Between Jesus and Odysseus and he was intentionally making that comparison saying you guys have this myth that you hold to be the greatest man ever Buckle up It would be interesting to go through Paul's travels that have lots of shipwrecks and islands and these kinds of things and see if there are direct parallels Between how the author of Luke acts is talking about the gospel in Luke and then the journey of Paul in acts and see if there are Odyssey crossovers. I've never done it. I just know that that Another comparison with Jesus was intentional. Anyway, sorry, right?
So he also talks to his mom because she died. You know how she died? Just sad she was sad. Oh, she missed him.
She's like I died from grief and your father Layers he's is about to meet the same fate. He will also die of grief. Also your wife still single Or still married to you. Yeah, still married to you.
She had nobody has married her also No one has usurped your place as king basically he learns from his mother that there is still a place for him Yeah, there's something about telemicus being like an English fatherless sad. No, but he does meet Achilles in the underworld kid And this is in his basement for his 20s And this moment this meeting with Achilles is a pretty big turning point for Odysseus because he goes up to Achilles and he says dude Achilles You are the greatest you're my hero. You know everybody thinks you're the best like you must be killing it with a ladies down here Like ruling all over all the breathless dead and Achilles says are you kidding me? It sucks down here I would rather be a dirt poor farmer slave alive than rule down here over all the breathless dead Which is what I'm doing and that flips Odysseus ideas on his head because he has always imagined that glory was the most important thing Like getting glory even if it meant death But now he talks to the most glorious man that has ever lived and he says man It is not worth it Cherish your life cherish the things that you have even being a farmer is better than this and that would have been a paradigm shift Odysseus that was unexpected and the next thing Achilles does is ask about his son He says do you know about my son is he okay?
And that I mean if you were a father you would immediately think of your own and then there's some he meets motherfokes Ajax is still mad because Ajax killed himself over something Odysseus did so he's like hey Jax what's going on Ajax just doesn't talk to him He's not the cold shoulder and wanders off then he sees Hercules and he sees some other folks And then he sees a big parade of women that would remind him like it's some of them are virtuous some of some not but it would remind him of his own Home so the journey to the underworld is basically a realignment of Odysseus perspectives up till now He's been seeking adventure, but he knows now there's a place for him at home He will safely arrive that seeking glory is not all it's cracked up to be so it just sort of he didn't get any super great information Aside from eating don't eat this certain set of cattle, but it would realign the his values So when he leaves he does revisit Cersei's island in the Rekind of world is there a split between like the good people and the bad people or is there like a or does everyone go to this Same place it doesn't really go over that the only thing that we see is that some people are tortured right Tantalus is tortured sisific is tortured the guy who pushes the rock up the hill Tantalus is the guy who can't eat You know drink the water or eat the fruit that's over his head he's being tantalized and then we talked to Hercules weirdly who's there he's like you're here to her please like me I mean I think he's got like to explain it in a really weird way But he returns to Cersei and only spends a day she gives him a little more advice He buries up and or like he should and then he goes and then I'll try to hit the rest of this really fast The speed of which I'm going kind of means that I might not get to some of the other theories I was gonna talk about today. We need a part to yeah, but then he talks to he goes past the sirens This is another famous episode where we always hear that I think when they're depicted in popular culture The sirens are always hot ladies and they're always tempting him with sex. That's not a classical version of the siren The sirens were bird ladies They had the bodies of birds and the heads of women and they would get you to the shore and they would either eat you or you died Of starvation It's not a good thing for you and the thing that attracted you was their song and she she Cersei says no one should hear this You should all plug your ears and sail as fast as you can by plug your ears up with earwax do not listen But I know you and you're curious so if you have to listen make sure that you your men restrain you you tie yourself to the mast So it is as they're sailing by tells his men he lies and he says Cersei said I was the only one who's here So he stops up all their ears and then ties himself to the mast So he is one of the only people ever to have lived to hear the sirens song and live so they sail past the sirens They go through skillet and cribbed is are you not frustrated by this guy like that's dumb for him to do that right? He's curious the way that I view Odysseus even now is he's kind of like that eighth-grader that gets himself into trouble all the time He's curious and he's rambunctious and he wants adventure, but he's really good at talking his way out of it Yeah, he's like yeah, I burned down the bookshelf I was curious about what would happen yeah, and he got it's all he kind of talks his way out of it He's that and he's kind of lovable in that way, okay.
It's frustrating like cuz I guess he has I sure the safety of his crew by plugging up their ears But like isn't he yelling at them to avert course while the sirens on is going on? Oh, yeah, he is trying furiously to free himself from the mastings We've been crying and saying free me and freaking out and trying to get to the sirens But he said whatever I say ignore me and luckily they have their ears stop the point So they can really hear me anyway alright pop quiz maybe where does that pop up in Narnia? You know this is Quisho come back to you and it's either I guess myself feel you know the Lusus is a solution no, I don't sorry so in silver chair. There's the snake lady who has gotten the prince Hypnotized by her by the by the song and by like and everything's when the moon comes out He has to be tied to a silver chair because he says he goes crazy But actually what happens is he gets his he gets his his his reason back Oh, he's always crazy, but when he's tied to the chair he gets his reason back anyway it's another little bit of that illusion to the seductive song and losing your mind and you know How the things you can expose yourself to can can divert your passion so much that that you do things that a rational normal person should be doing so it is yeah, so it is bad you're agreeing I You got so I mean he's an archetype right like all these characters are showing these types of people like Achilles the wrathful glory hungry Quarterback of the football team who gets it and then looks back at his like state championship ring when he's 50 And he's like was it was all worth it And then you've got sort of a nius in the aniad who's pious and good and always does the right thing But at least bodies in his wake and everyone but you look at him You're like wow that's such a pious good guy But then you go and you look at a story and you realize like everyone he sort of used people and he's And there's a trail of sadness and yes, he's completed his mission, but it's kind of this he the thing that he creates is kind of this intense Juggernaut of Rome that yes is glorious, but also was a machine that chews through people and it is kind like that and then sorry And he is kind of like that and then it is he's like this the tricks the trickster talks his way out of things You love him you're frustrated by him.
You want him to change you wanted to grow up But he he sort of feels like at some points he gets it and then other points You're pretty convinced that he's just gonna get back in the boat and go off again and and you can never like Yes, he's trustworthy, but he's also his own man He's gonna do whatever he wants and he doesn't like he's wrestling with this being Domesticated and being wild and he can kind of do both at the same time. Yeah, we'll get we'll get there Yeah, cuz this yeah, we're not there yet. So a few more things he goes past skill and crib this so quiz show what dang what is Skilla the whirlpool and crib this the something else. I think maybe it's the whirlpool and skill is like the snake monster Yeah, so it's a pair of cliffs and this is killer is the snake monster Yeah, she has six heads that pluck dudes off boats and just chop them and eat them And then caribdiss is a whirlpool monster whirlpool And so they can either he has not and you can try to try to go past because it only goes every once in a while But you never really know when or you can just lose six guys and sale sale pass killer So it's either like six mouths.
Oh, does he choose the six-man either like all or nothing with It's like it's all the dice and if you're wrong you lose the whole boat or no for sure You're gonna lose six dudes, but you make it through. I don't want to make that choice So it's really says you have to do skill it's better to just lose six guys than lose the whole boat Do they know do the six guys know he does not tell his crew? Actually, it's really funny because she tells him don't try to fight just sale as fast as you can you cannot fight this It's a dragon monster You have no chance just sail through but it is he's kind he kind of takes her advice because he when he when they're coming up on it He goes below decks puts on his armor and then comes back above decks and his men are like hey, man What's going on what's what's happening? I imagine he was just like oh just trying to get You know just on the trial the old armor and then all of a sudden six of them gets snatched off the boat And they get chewed and he tails fast and he says it's one of the saddest sites He ever had to see because he had to make that choice But I mean in the ancient sacrifice six of his people I don't know in the ancient world that becomes synonymous with like a rock and hard place So if you ever hear he had to choose between the skill of blank and the karibis of blank It's it's basically basically two bad choices right neither yeah, neither of them are good and he sails through and Makes it to the cattle of the Sun which they were told not to eat They were told not to eat but they hit some doldrums.
They're running out of food his men mutiny cause him to land They eat the cattle and it's a weird moment because the skins that they've taken off and the the meat the meat begins to moo at them Oh, and the skins begin to crawl around on the ground It's very creepy and he's like that's a bad sign and then the god that owns the cattle's like hey Zeus kill these guys and he loses a whole boat and later has to go back to Karibdis and he's it's like this action scene where he's hanging on the branch over the giant world pool and he's lost everything That's where his last boat goes and then eventually with nothing he has lost all the wealth from Troy He has lost every single man that he left with means if you lived in Ithaca You might be a little grubby because he killed all the men right from the island and eventually he makes it to the island of Calypso who is this beautiful goddess? She's one of the most tragic figures in all of antiquity She sided with or she's the daughter of a Titan and when the gods beat the Titans I think she sided with the gods which is why they gave her mercy and kill her But they stranded her on an island and said you can never leave and your further cursed is that heroes will land on your island You will fall in love with her, but they will never love you back and they always have to leave So she is just consistently getting a heartbroken That's the saddest thing and Odysseus ends up spending seven years on Calypso's island Come on and she is always wanting to sleep with him and if he doesn't live for a little while and then eventually she offers him Immortality she says why are you wanting to go home to your wife look how beautiful I am and she does have lovely braids That's why I always describes her. She's got some hot braids and I can offer you immortality and I can offer you myself What are you lacking for and he says I don't know I still just like my wife We finally he like weeps every day he becomes a real big bummer and eventually she gives him the raft and then sends him off after the gods say Hey, you have to let him go and that is where he or Poseidon takes his final revenge breaks his raft and sends him with nothing To the island of the Asian so now we're back to where he landed and met the nice Tell story. Yeah So now he is finishing his story with the fascians and remember that is where he sleeps under the olive bush So that olive bush if we can return we didn't we didn't understand what it was in book five But now that we're through his journey We see that Odysseus has a conflict between his wild side his desire for adventure and glory and story and everything and His domestic side his cultivated side which is his desire to go home and be with his wife and his son now He can't completely abandon his adventuring ways because he's gonna need them to return home.
He's got a 114 suitors He has to face but he has been favoring one side for sure He's been adventuring and as he sleeps under this olive bush what we see is the marriage of his two sides There's a lot of language that makes it seem as though he is dying and being reborn again the next morning He emerges naked right he buries himself with a litter of dead leaves and then sleeps in this small tomb underneath these branches And the olive tree is also associated with Athena It's her tree so it symbolizes her protection and his marriage right these two sides that grow from the same root finally being so entangled together And then he emerges as like the complete hero right he's ready to return home He has learned his lesson adventuring is not worth it, but you can't leave that but it shouldn't dominate you So then he tells a story He just wants to go home even Nausica says hey you wanna get you feel like Mary in a princess and he's like No, I have a wife I have to go home So he's facing temptation all over the place goddesses princesses finally he returns home because I can get to take his revenge on the Theations he's like what hurts somebody and Zeus says I just hurt them And so he hurts the theations they kind of deserve it because they'll help anyone even if even if the gods hate them What you're not supposed to do so they're kind of being impious in helping Odysseus and helping anyone that happens across their doorstep They get punished and he returns home and over the course of the next few books. He pretends to be a beggar He goes in disguise. He has to lie to his wife people start to recognize him He cleanses his house in after this big contest to show that he is still the hero we once thought he was Yeah, he locks everybody in the in the hall and then just kills all of them Then he makes all of the serving women that were sleeping around clean up their dead boyfriends and then he kills all of them Wait really? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, let's get that part when we come in sorry.
He has telemicas do yeah. Yeah, he says telemicas go take care of these For serving women to take them all it does telemicas have any qualms like oh, yeah, they abuse telemicus They abuse Odysseus in his own house. They abuse Penelope They are not good people right they should and it goes out of their way to show that the suitors have had warnings Yeah, right they are warned They're omens that say like you guys better get out of here the gods are not pleased with you and yet they stay yeah The Odyssey is very clear that what they're doing is sinful Okay, and lawless and that the serving women have been raised and nurtured and cared for by the house of Odysseus and they still sleep around and they Still abuse Odysseus. They still abuse Penelope.
They are ungrateful and so they deserve what's coming So he cleans he cleans hot shop uses his wild side and then there's only a couple more things I promise I'm almost done we have The final meeting between Odysseus and Penelope. She doesn't know it's him She kills everybody and then she's like sleeping upstairs Finally the servant one of the faithful women goes out and says Odysseus is home You have to go downstairs and she's like off only that we're true She comes down and she can't know whether this is Odysseus or a god in disguise because the gods play tricks often right? So she says I don't know if it's you she's playing real cagey and it's this like Odysseus is leaning on column He's like oh girl, he's so cold and And tell him the kiss. He's like mom.
Why don't you welcome dad? He's here finally and and Penelope says I you know I'm glad you're home and has She says if you want to sleep I will have our servant pull our bed from our bedroom and put it in the hall and you can sleep there and this is a test because Only Odysseus would know that their bed is rooted to the floor one of the posts of their bed is actually an olive tree that has grown into the ground Yeah, and isn't it like not just growing to the ground But there's this if I remember it the images like that the the the roots of the tree are in the actual just roots of the island of Ithaca it's almost like this tree is The island itself like if the island could grow something alive It would be this tree that their bed is rooted I'm not sure about that But I do know that when it describes the bed it says that he built his bed first when he was building his palace He built his bed has a tree root the tree root He built his bed attached to that and then built the room around it and like the palace around that and I don't know about you guys But when I'm gonna build a house, I don't build bed first. You spend so much time in bed. It's an important thing You try to invest in a mattress my face this is our first They're really comfortable back revolutionary technology If you're listening call us I hear that if you're not satisfied in 30 days Anyway, they have a 90% satisfaction rate Good enough for a disneyas.
Yeah for me anyway She tests him and he says unless someone has changed my bed There's no way you could do that and she you know is overjoyed she realizes it's actually Odysseus and she jumps on them And they tell stories and they spend and I think he probably doesn't tell her about sirsia Oh, yeah, he keeps that under right hat, but not in your club so thing But there's this parallel between the rooted bed Which I mean it's the marriage bed It's symbolic of their marriage and those roots go down to the go down in Ithaca And their palace is built around it and the island around that so it it symbolizes their marriage as the center of all of life and Ithaca The wholeness of this relationship no Odysseus is a pretty He has broken the wholeness many times throughout the book, but he's gonna come back and he's I mean It's not I don't think it's a satisfying repentance But it's like a in some ways it is and he's come back and then they're their marriage of king and queen husband and wife The whole marriage bed brings health and peace back to the land That had been gone when he wasn't there tolemachus to his kingdom to his servants to his poor dog Yeah, or goes to dog. I really want to talk about our ghost. I'm not sure we have enough time So I'm anticipating sorry. I'm anticipating a part two.
We'll do that next week if I actually sequence these episodes correct So he that that olive bush that his bed is made out of harkens back to the two-sided olive bush He slept under right that was the union of his two sides and if there has ever been a domesticated olive bush This is the most domesticated olive tree ever right it is literally part of a marriage bed It is the most domestic there is so once again we have it is the dollar style like it is the house And it is symbolizes, you know, Athena's involvement and protection of their marriage his ultimate coming back to domesticity and taking his home Back from where it was and what we see through these few chapters is Odysseus coming into his own and Like finally kind of growing up and realizing what's important and at the same time his son is going through the same experience right at Chronologically telemachus and Odysseus have been experiencing their coming of age stories at the same time right Odysseus is realizing what's really important not adventure home Son family wife that is what really matters and telemachus is finally growing up and taking control We actually see him correct his mother and say mama got this I'm in charge now and she is you know now when that happened Oh mom will be like oh no, you don't I'm a charge Yeah, but back then you would want your son to grow and now do his father and be strong and take control of his house And that's what telemachus starts to do he starts to insult the suitors and tell them to get out of the house and say that he's in control And he's got clear sense and he's just he's really turning into the man he's supposed to be so they grow up together Right and at the end of the book they have to deal with This unfortunate war that's gonna happen because they just killed 114 people whoops and those people have families And all of those families get together and say pretty much we've got to kill Odysseus a couple of them say hey What our kids were doing is not okay. They deserved what was coming but if you said we got a you know We are bound by law to avenge them so at the very end Odysseus is prepared to fight off all these suitors And it's him and his son and his dad later He's not out sort of revived and a farmer and they're all ready to fight and then Athena comes down and says hey stop it Oh peace now everything is done. I will not allow anymore fighting and so at the very end of the book the 24th book We have peace and if we take the ilea and the Odyssey together We've had 47 books of war and one of peace And so this is the primary example of deus ex machina where a god comes down and solves all of the Major conflicts this is like the archetype of that right where the gods come down and say finally there is an end to all this strife And usually that's kind of a bad thing to do for a writer But in Greece like that was how to end this problem there was no other way to stop a few like this besides having a whole bunch of people die So she just says you got to stop there's peace now and the problems are solved That's probably true of like blood feuds today The only way that yeah like a few that's been going on for generations is some kind of like divine intervention saying stop it both of you Yeah, okay, yeah, yeah So that's that's the Odyssey and I will next week walk through a couple of the theories about the Odyssey We'll talk about just a Campbell we'll talk about the Golden Bowl We'll talk a little bit about our ghost the dog and give you a lot more insight here But now you have kind of an idea of what the Odyssey is all about it's if you get the Robert Faggles translation It's kind of an easy read and it's a it's easier entry into classes and then the ilea the ilea adds a little more inaccessible This is easier. It's a fun adventure story You don't have to have read the ilea to get the Odyssey No, if you know a little bit of the background just that he's returning from war you can get the whole story And you also get some I got one of my favorite things about all these stories is the great kid names Like I'm gonna name one of my daughter's Penelope after Odysseus's wife because she's so smart Yeah, and she's so clever and she tricked people all the time and she turns out to be this virtuous wonderful clever woman Yeah, and you're gonna name your dog Argos.
I wanted to believe that naming her Eliza and said after Elizabeth in it But I had wanted to know your dog Argos. I mean you'll probably have a very dog eventually no start to live forever I don't understand what you wait what? Maybe you've never been told about death what you never been introduced this concept to death what okay Do we I always want to name dogs after famous theologians but change their last names to prefer dog noises So one dog would be Hans Ores of Phon bark. Sorry.
Oh Oh, so good. Oh my word. That's what I want. I'm trying to think about any others like Kierkebark.
Yeah Kierkegaard dog For some reason what this makes me think of is our Twitter account where in Graham You've been the main instigator on that one and like all the people were following are those hip hop slash the allosians Do you're mixed up? Oh, yeah, so we talk about that. We talk about it. It's like the only people were following our bat Okay, do we have any things we got wrong for previous episodes?
We've never made mistakes. I don't understand the implication None that have been pointed out reason when recent memory which is good which means that Catherine stopped listening I I've listened to previous episodes and especially in this last bunch I was tired and I lapsed into a lot of verbal fillers and I didn't unsee it Well, and some and I feel like I sound kind of drunk most of the time So if I put all of my words together and sort of slur them I'm sorry audience I'm trying to enunciate better and make it more understandable. We're learning. We're all growing as podcasters Well, I think I told you all that I listen to all podcast at two times speed and with a feature that reduces the silence and podcasts also So I never know if there are awkward pauses.
I never know if we sound like we're drunk or whatever because it just sounds like we're Chipmunks the entire time so try give that a try if you want to fix for that All right good times well, yeah, this has been classical stuff Hamburg part one of the Odyssey next week we'll come back for part two where we talk a little bit more about the analytical side of this and some of the theories of The hero's journey and all this other stuff that we've got cooked up We'll talk about Star Wars and Lord of the Rings how it relates to modern time So thank you for listening if you have any questions comments feedback Funny dog names out of theologians, please email us at classical stuff at veritasacademy.net good memes or Capp videos or dipli articles those 15 15 tweets from people who didn't know what they were doing That's right. I'll see you visit us at classical stuff.net for to see the podcast and to see shining glory's pictures of us And then you can follow us on the Twitter at cool school stuff And it's the same logo so you'll notice us. Thank you for listening and he will catch you listening next time No, we won't we won't know if you're listening, but we thank you that you are bye bye