Skip to content
331: Cyrano, Music Man (Broadway Show) episode artwork

Feb 28, 2022 1 hr 23 min

331: Cyrano, Music Man (Broadway Show)

from SiftPop Hosted by SiftPop | Aaron Dicer, Andrew Ormsby

Aaron and Andrew welcome Ian back to the show this week! They review "Cyrano" (14:34) and "The Music Man" on Broadway (26:03), rank Best Ever movies ending in "O" (47:56), then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:13:42).

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

331: Cyrano, Music Man (Broadway Show)

0:00 1:23:56
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

If you're a Disney Plus subscriber and you're watching The Mandalorian, Jack and I have a podcast for you. Every week, we'll discuss the latest episode of The Mandalorian and talk about other great content and maybe some not-so-great content on Disney Plus as well. As two lifelong Star Wars fans, we have a ton of fun geeking out over all the little details of the show, and we want you to join us every Monday. So search for Disney Plus Reviews. That's Disney, P-L-U-S, Reviews. Hey, Phil, how about that, Baby Yoda? Baby Yoda says, it's a podcast.

Live from a bunker in the heart of the Ozarks, a podcast that's not rude. We're just enigmatically distant and fashionably late. It's SIFPOP. Welcome to Cif Pop Weekly, streaming live most Saturday mornings or available to download later in your podcast feed. Unless, of course, you're a patron. Patrons get those perks. Patrons get those perks. I'm your host, Aaron Dicer, and each week we'll chat about movies, TV, and whatever else from the pop culture universe is on our minds. And please welcome our guest this week. He's Trouble with a capital T, and that rhymes with E, and that stands for Ian Whittington League? Yeah, sure, sure. Okay, hello. It's a little weird, but I'll allow it. Ian, thank you for joining us today. Thank you for having me. In America. Yeah, Ian has joined us in America. We're actually in the same room.

We're in the room where it's happening. We are. I wish it. And so it is. And so it is. So it's interesting to find ourselves sometimes in places with this podcast where it's like, OK, going away for a little bit, you know, going to take a little bit of a break. Do we just skip a week of the podcast or do we find a way to talk about something? I like the latter, you know, the latter thing. Like, let's find a way to talk about something. This is one of two podcasts, Ian, that I think you and I will be doing just as a pair over the next month. The other one is Awards Weekend. You're going to the awards show. Yeah. The Critics' Choice Awards with me. At least that's the plan. Unless they don't let me on the plane. How does this plan not happen? I don't know. Listen, you know what?

I just always want to put it out there that things can change. Things happen. You know, once I died. You know what? That's fair. That's absolutely fair. It's all about you. It is always all about me. And as long as we all remember that, we should be good. But yeah, so I'd like to, in those situations, go, okay, let's still try to put out some content this week. Do a good show. We're going to do a full show today. We've got two things to review, but it's a little bit, you know, interesting. I think it's the first time we're ever reviewing a Broadway show.

We both got a chance to see The Music Man with Hugh Jackman on Broadway. So we're going to talk about it on the show. We're also going to talk about Cyrano because it finally comes out into theaters this week. I feel like we saw this movie three months ago. We did see this movie three months ago. When I saw it on the email, I was like, well, that's weird. Why is he doing films that have been out for a long time? Is there really nothing out at the minute? It's a weird award scene where it's just like screeners come and then it's like, oh, we're not releasing this movie until the end of February. Okay. All right. Strange.

So anyhow, so that's going to be the show today. We've also got a best ever challenge in honor of Cyrano with best ever movies that end in the letter O. Well, this won't get me kicked off. Ian has already warned me that he is going to take liberties with this category. And look, I only get one veto, so I'm going to have to use it well. By the way, veto would be a great movie title that actually ends in the letter O. Is there a movie? I don't know. There should be. I do want to clarify the wording. The best ever challenge is films that end. Where is it?

I think it just films that end with an O. I don't think you say letter. Well, I did put the O in quotes. That was far more wiggle room than you ever should have allowed me. No, the quotes mean exact. The quotes are like, this is exact. It has to be O. Oh, no, I have the exact opposite meaning of that. That means that O, you know what I mean. O.

Oh, that's interesting. I do understand what you're saying because sometimes when people do like the quote sign, it's like, Oh, you're happy. Quote, unquote, happy. But in a journalistic sense, when you put quotes around something, it means this is exactly what that person said. Otherwise, it has to be paraphrased. Yeah. Okay. I forgot that I had a journalistic background. Thank you for reminding me. It doesn't matter. Part of the fun is stretching the categories and we'll see how all that goes. And then of course, we've got some buried treasure that we'll get to as well. But before, one more thing before we head in, just another reminder, you can make your Sposcars picks. There's been some news that's come out about the Oscars that we can talk about this a little bit, Ian, if you want to.

that they are shoving like eight categories off of the broadcast. And I just heard today they're going to tweet them out before the show starts. So what is this? Don't do it. What are you doing? Just mail the awards out. What is the point here, Oscar? I don't.

Look, I think the idea is normal people don't care about these categories, so why are we putting them in the show? And I'm like, who are you making the show for? Normal people don't care about the whole thing. Who is sitting on their couch? Who is sitting on their couch going, oh, I wasn't going to watch the Oscars, but now that they're not awarding sound design in the main show, I'm going to watch. I'm in. Let's do this. Who is sitting on their couch going, oh, you know what? If they could actually keep the show at just three hours, I'd watch. That person wants a 30-minute summary the next day on YouTube. They're not going to sit and watch the show. Make the show for the people who like movies. I don't understand these decisions. They're so dumb. Does the Super Bowl just cut away from the boring part?

to the game? But there wouldn't be much left. But that's what I'm saying. Do you know how many people who don't like football watch the Super Bowl because it's just what people go have a party and they watch it or whatever? Maybe they'll go play cards in the other room or have snacks or whatever and not really care about it. But it's on because it's football and somebody in their life loves football. And the actual broadcast itself knows that it's about a football game. That's the whole thing with the Oscars is just let it be about movies. Let it be for people who love movies. And the people who love people who love movies, they'll sit in the room occasionally too. But it's just like, oh, it just frustrates me so much. It's just the wrong direction. I think you've said everything I could possibly say about it. You're absolutely right. It's for the people who love movies.

The only way you're going to popularize it and get everyone in seats is if you nominate the Avengers movies and you do all of that kind of stuff in Fast and the Furious. And that's not what the Oscars is about. But see, that mindset, I don't mind as much as stuff like this. I don't mind there being a conversation about what makes a movie the best movie of the year. And if what makes the movie the best movie of the year is that it appeals to a broad audience, I think that's a legitimate argument to use. But let's have those conversations and not make the whole most popular Oscar or those kind of things. I didn't like that either because...

People are making movies and we're just, we want an award show to celebrate movies. And if Spider-Man No Way Home gets a nomination because enough people in the Academy think, no, that is a great movie because it was broadly popular and also because there are talented people at work. That's the other thing. I think it discounts the fact that a movie likes, you know, Spider-Man No Way Home or in other years, a big blockbuster or whatever. There are talented people that work on it and doing amazing work. Willem Dafoe's work in Spider-Man No Way Home is incredible. Like it's really good. So, so yeah, I don't mind that as much as this nonsense of let's make the award show.

you know, more for the common man. Well, they seem to be focusing on either A, dumbing it down, or B, simply the length. I was like, people don't mind sitting through long things. Like, we will sit in the cinema for three hours and watch something we enjoy. Focusing on the time just seems so, so silly. And you're just winding up the people that are loyal and are hanging around and don't want to see all of that stuff. Do you know how long the Super Bowl broadcast usually is? Oh, two and a half days. It's long. I know it's long. So, I mean, I don't know the exact answer. I haven't done the research. But generally, you know, the actual Super Bowl broadcast, and there's a bunch of pre-show and that kind of stuff, but the actual Super Bowl broadcast is like a four to five hour, you know, kind of thing.

How much conversation is there about, the Super Bowl is too long, we need to shorten the Super Bowl? None, because you're just celebrating this game or this sport or whatever. That's exactly the point I mean. It's celebrating the nation's probably most popular sport. We aren't celebrating the most popular films. You could argue that they're the best in quotation marks, but you're not talking about the films that have made the most money, which means not the most amount of people went to see them. So your audience is already small to begin with, and you're ostracizing even more of them by not having these categories. You need to add to the Oscars, not take away. That's it. Make a five or six hour show.

Make more categories. Stick the Marvel stuff in the middle so people have to sit through the other bits. Do more genre categories and be strict about what's included in them. Don't do category fraud so that we're voting for Cyrano in Best Comedy or whatever. And again, that's a funny movie, but that's not what the genre would be about. Free Guy would be nominated in Best Comedy and whatever. Stick Endgame in Best Adapted Screenplay.

But make it longer, add more categories, honor stunt performers, honor casting, honor voice work, honor digital performances, honor best first time movie, best debut from a director, honor MVP, who had the best year with the most projects. Andrew Garfield would be up for that this year. You know what I mean? That's what I'm saying. Make an MVP award.

Expand it out. Do all these things and just make it this big old Sunday celebration started at 2 p.m. or whatever Maybe you know, maybe you're dealing with having people in the room like to do a show in the room So maybe have the broadcast to be without you know Like a live audience there for a while as you're celebrating these things But I don't know that people wouldn't want to go hang out more fun Yeah, to make it a stuffy thing that lasts as long as it does. Anyhow, I get a little passionate about this They're killing view they're killing the Oscars and I think they're fishing it forward. Yeah, they really do They should hire us. As is the case with most things. Indeed. You should hire us. Anyhow, that was a nice little bonus topic. That was great. That would have been great for the pre-show. In the members-only pre-show, we did talk about our favorite musicals. We did. So if you do want to check that out, our SIPHOP members have access to that in your pocket. But I started all that to mention the Spotskers are coming. Yeah. If you are making your picks.

Uh, I am going to move the deadline up a little bit, uh, just because I don't know when they're going to announce those awards. And I want to make sure that people have their picks in before any of the awards are known. Um, so I am going to move the timing on that a little bit and just let you guys, uh, know what's going on there. So yes, go to sifpop.com. Just click on the Spockers and it will take you to the choices for all the different awards. Get your picks in. Um, and, uh, and we'll go about that. I am trying to think about like the, the live show that we do like.

if they do tweet those out, do we just mark those down? We start, you know, kind of knowing it kind of ruins a little bit of the fun of those beginning few awards, right? Yeah, no, you're right, because somebody could get a massive lead. Yeah, right off the bat, which is like, oh, they're eight for eight in the small categories. I think they might win. Like, it could really, you know, but we'll see. We'll see how it all works. We'll just, we'll play with what other rules they give us. I also really feel if we're ready for another rant, maybe it'll just be an all-awards rant show. I also feel like there is a place for these other award ceremonies, including my own beloved CCAs, and I really mean beloved. I love being in the Critics' Choice Association. I think they do really good work.

And more specifically, I think the people that I meet in CCA are all passionate film lovers who really watch everything, really try to make good decisions on this stuff. But these award shows, even the CCAs, could do a better job at not... Instead of trying to be the Oscars, trying to be better than the Oscars. And it's something I see that's kind of in this weird thing that's in the mindset of a lot of these award shows. We have to predict the Oscar awards. Like people will love us because we are the closest to the ones that they award. We're going to be a predictor or we're going to give a show that's similar to the Oscars. And I just think there's a real opportunity right now to show the Oscars how it's done and to produce an award show that is fun and joyful and celebrates the year. Add some of these cool new categories. That's the other thing. I think most of the categories should expand double the amount of nominees. Like there's no reason there shouldn't be 10 acting nominees.

so much especially as we get further and further away from gender mattering in these awards at some point it is just going to be best actor and it will include everybody you know it'll have to it will have to and at that point you better have 10 nominees like you know so it's it's it's interesting just to kind of think why don't we as these other award shows do these things before the Oscars instead of waiting for the Oscars to do it and then we'll follow suit it's just like no make the better show yeah I'm not saying you could ever be as popular as the Oscars or as important to the culture as the Oscars, but I am saying that you could have a lot of fun and people may find you and people who love movies may enjoy watching your show. I think CCI should haunt you. Wait, wait, wait. All right, let's get into the reviews for today. We're going to kick it off talking about Cyrano. My sole purpose on this earth is to love Roxanne. The world will never accept someone like me and a tall, beautiful woman. We have no money. A clever marriage is your only option. I won't be rescued. I'm not in distress. Love, does that mean nothing to you? Children need love. Adults need money.

I need something to die for. Cyrano de Bergerac dazzles everyone with his ferocious wordplay and brilliant swordplay. Oh, it's wordplay itself. Yeah, wordplay inside swordplay. However, he's convinced his appearance renders him unworthy of the affections of the luminous Roxanne, a devoted friend who's in love.

with someone else uh yeah Cyrano what did you think Ian did you like it love it dislike it hate it or it was just okay I liked it bam in the middle liked it all right straight liked it I think that's about where I am as well maybe slightly on the low side of liked it and the only reason I say that is I came away from it having enjoyed the experience there were certainly many many moments that I that I loved in it um but I didn't come away from it going man I can't wait to watch that again you know and there is something about that so I do think that puts it on the The lower side of musicals. Yes, right, yes. Because rewatchability factor on good musicals is high. And just the fact that I didn't feel that with this does mean something. So yeah, I'd probably go with low side of light. Why don't you kick us off? What are some of your thoughts on Cyrano? So we, well, I mean, we started watching this together a few months ago. Didn't realize that it was a musical until somebody ardently started singing. Oh, it's a musical. It's a musical. That's fun. And I've got to say, I perked up a bit. Because I was like, oh, this was around my tick-tick-boom-a-sance. And I was like, I'm going to give musicals a try.

and um you ought to give musicals a try i want to go i don't want to do this and i love love peter dinklage i think he can do no wrong in movies and i will watch pretty much anything he does um but i had no idea this was like based on anything else this was a film that had already been made that it was based on a film called roxanne totally ignorant of all of that um and where i come down is i really i like the performances i like the songs are enjoyable in the moment but i couldn't tell you that i was humming them afterwards peter dinklage for the first two thirds is fantastic and just witty and wordy and very um very, oh no, what's his name in Game of Thrones? Tyrion? Tyrion, thank you. It's always very Tyrion. Where is it? He's not Tywin, that's the opposite of what he'd want to be called. But how great he is with words and how articulate he is and usually the most intelligent person in the room. Really enjoyable to get a glimpse of that again. But the story itself just irritates me. It's such a bad story. It's so hard to get behind most of the people, most of the characters. You don't have to have somebody to root for, but who do I care about? Because even by the end of it, no one's really a winner.

I think Cyrano is supposed to be the driving force here. We're supposed to feel for Cyrano because of his self-immolation and the way he has tied his value to his appearance and those kind of things. I think we're supposed to root for him. But no, you're not wrong. There's a lot of pathos to go around here. And I think that's what the movie's driving force is supposed to be. It's just the emotion of poor decisions.

bad moments, all those kind of things. The love story doesn't work. That's what you're talking about, I think. Just the love story part of it is very icky, especially through modern eyes of stalking and those kind of things. And catfishing, essentially. Yeah, it's catfishing. Yes, exactly. I should have called that Cyranoing. I'm sure it would have caught on perfectly. It's just an easy thing to say. Yeah, no, I'm with you on all of that, including the fact that the Dinklage is...

astonishing in this movie. And I think most of what I really like about this movie is his performance. Absolutely. There is early on basically a rap battle. It's outstanding. It's like 8 Mile in Cyrano. It's so good. He eviscerates this guy. And it's really, really good. And the stuff like that is interesting to me and I enjoy. I just wonder if for me this would have been better if it was a little goofier maybe. I think there's because that rap battle has that. And then the rest of the movie is really self-serious. And that's okay. I'm not opposed to drama. I just...

I was kind of, I wanted more of kind of that fun that I had the first few minutes. Well, the last third is utterly miserable. Right. And compared to the opening quarter, that is goofy and funny. And even when he first meets Roxanne and they have that, the first kind of being reunited after all that time, that's kind of clumsy and goofy and fun. But pretty much from then onwards, it is just miserable. There's so little to grab onto that's enjoyable. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. What else do we want to talk about here? Were there any other performances other than Dinklage that you kind of wanted to bring out and talk about? Ben Mendelsohn? Yeah, Ben Mendelsohn's great. But again, I love him.

Regardless, he's always fantastic. I think Christian did a great job, but the character of Christian doesn't have a lot to... Kelvin Harrison. I love Kelvin Harrison Jr., by the way. He's been doing some really great stuff. But Christian just doesn't have a lot to do. I know he's supposed to be a puppet, but very, very much so in this. But he shouldn't feel so... Wooden. Empty. He's a papier-mâché character instead of... Yeah, there doesn't seem to be much agency there or anything that he's doing. I would say, by the way, since we're talking about Kelvin Harrison Jr., and I mentioned he's in some good stuff, let me just give you a couple of recommendations of Kelvin Harrison Jr. stuff that he's been in recently that you need to check out. He's Fred Hampton in Trial of the Chicago 7.

Oh, of course. I have seen that. He does great stuff there. He's in a movie called Waves that not a lot of people have seen. It's really, really good. Luce, another one, L-U-C-E, where he plays a kid at school who some people are suspecting is moving in a dangerous kind of realm of school shootery kind of mindset. And other people, he means straight A student, that kind of stuff. Some other people think he's, you know, and the movie is really great about.

not giving you all the answers and that you could believe both things. I like that. Luce is really great. I highly recommend Luce as well. So just recently, he's just kind of blasted onto the scene with that stuff. So good stuff. I wish he had more to do here. Absolutely. Is it Hayley or Hallie? Hallie Bennett? I'm not sure. Yeah, one of those. Yeah, great. I just don't like the character of Roxanne. And that probably means she did an absolutely fantastic job of it. But I just... There's a lack of agency in that character too that's really interesting because you would think the fact that she's making the choice is the agency, but the way the story paints her is...

She has no choice but to fall in love with his words and his body. Right. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah, I think I'm with you pretty much down the line. The music is fine. I will mention it's done by The National, which is a man you may know of and love. I think they have a scene where they actually sing one of the songs in this. And I think that does give the musical part of it this kind of thematic consistency. And it doesn't sound like every other musical. Right. So I think I put that in the positive camp. I remember thinking that.

Unlike Hamilton, there's not individual songs that you can grab onto. All of these songs are the narrative. They don't have the typical structure of the chorus verse. They don't have the payoff. It's just another way of pushing the story forward, which is a fine way to do a musical. But for me, as being musical adjacent doesn't give me a lot to grab onto. It's like, oh, you could have done this quicker if you were talking.

Well, it's almost more operatic, right? It's almost more like speak singing in many ways, like something like Les Mis would be or something like that. But yeah, I understand what you're saying. I still think the fact that it has that consistent tone to it is a good thing. Anything else about Cyrano that you wanted to mention?

no it didn't sell me on musicals it didn't make me it's one of the strange um examples where so for musicals in general my expectation will be very very low because i'm not a big musical lover but this started off actually quite high and then fell down so it may have killed my soul more than it intended to but it's fine i just i can't see myself ever wanting to reach for it again yeah uh joe wright directed it um i believe yes joe wright directed it you may uh You may know him from The Woman in the Window. Terrible movie. Which I liked. I liked that movie. Why is it? We're not talking about Women in the Window. Darkest Hour. I liked Darkest Hour. I liked Darkest Hour. I liked Darkest Hour. Atonement, Pride and Prejudice. Anna Karenina. Pan. The terrible Peter Pan movie. Oh, no. That was terrible. Oh. So, yeah. Joe Wright's a bit hitter. Interesting. It's from your neck of the woods.

I mean, it's why I follow him. It's why I'm so intimately familiar with him. No, I don't have a lot more to say either about Cyrano. It really is just all kind of right there. It's a musical. It's Peter Dinklage. Watch it because he's an incredible actor and he's going to be bringing something to the space in every single scene.

He delivers those intellectual characters so, so well. I don't think he'll be disappointed you watched it. I just don't know that it's going to rock your world. So that's where we'll leave that. There we go. That's Cyrano. It is in theaters. A very mild recommend from us. I wouldn't drive 60 miles to find a theater that's showing it. No, I wouldn't fly 5,000 miles to sit in Aaron's basement and watch it, but I do. I'd maybe spend, you know, $3.99 on a rental at some point. It'll probably be streaming somewhere, I would imagine. All right, let's move on to The Music Man. Certain words creeping into his conversation. Words like...

Well, and so's your old man. If so, my friends! Two-time Tony Award, Grammy Award, and Emmy Award winner Hugh Jackman will make his highly anticipated return to Broadway in what is widely agreed to be the greatest role ever created for an actor in the history of musical theater. You are taking the mic. I don't know. I have no context. I don't know if you're joking or not. I hope you're joking. Professor Harold Hill in Meredith Wilson's beloved classic, The Music Man. No, I think that is... I did not write that. I pulled that.

So it's a really prestigious role for an actor to have. It is a very big role. You know this because we went and saw it. It is absolutely... a bravura type of performance like you're in all the songs you're doing all the dancing you're you know like it is it is a big deal um so yeah we were in new york for the week and got a chance to see uh hugh jackman on broadway uh as a music man also caught hamilton while we were there as well which was amazing well spoilers on where we're going here did you like it love it dislike it hate it or it was just okay no i'll surprise you i was the high side of liked it oh nice i really really liked it it surprised me a little bit um man it is it is so hard in these situations for me to separate The analytical, how good was this from the experience? And I think that's part of it. That is part of the gig. That's part of the fun. So I'm going with loved it. I'm going to say low side of loved it just because because the actual material has flaws. Of course. But the Broadway part of it was astonishing. Yeah. So like that's the that's the balance, you know, the kind of that we're dealing with. You hit the nail on the head with why I'm in liked it and not just OK. If I watch this.

If you watched Robert Preston in the movie musical do this and just sat down in front of a TV and watched the movie musical, yeah, you'd be low side of okay. But the Broadway-ness of it and Sutton Foster and Hugh Jackman convinced me that I nearly loved this. But yeah, my logical brain was like, Ian, you know you didn't. Settle on liked it. I'll give you a high side. Yeah, that is the thing that happens. Let's start with Sutton Foster because she steals the show from Hugh Jackman. Yes, she does. How do you steal something from Hugh Jackman? But she does.

And we will get to Hugh, and he's great. That is not saying he is in any way bad, but she is phenomenal. She owns the stage. She brings a sense of humor to the role of Marion that I've never seen before. I've seen several versions of The Music Man from high schools to colleges to the musical, the movie musical. And I've never sensed Marion to have that kind of comedic.

Oh, interesting. Energy to her, and it's so good. It's so funny. It's very Mary Tyler Moore, like Dick Van Dyke era. There were times I swear she could have just gone, oh, Rob. She has a very Mary Tyler Moore energy to her, and it's so perfect. She gives that character even more gravitas and agency than I've ever seen that character portrayed with. As poorly aged as the plot is, as far as falling in love with a swindler and just letting them...

Although there is something almost modern about the way she's like, I accept you for who you are. The spin on it surprised me by the end of it. Oh, she knows all along and loves him regardless. It's still icky, but I'm glad it wasn't just... And that's not something they changed. That is in the original text. That's comforting to know. Yeah. So, yeah, there is something almost a little modern about that, but there still is like the, you know... The ickiness of chasing the woman and I will not be... Manipulation. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All that stuff. So, yeah, despite that, she absolutely makes it work and is so much fun. Everybody who is on stage with her is better.

When she's on stage with them, she just makes them better. And I just became a huge Sutton Foster fan. She feels like the lead. In every single scene, she feels like she's the lead more than Hugh Jackman, which is crazy. It's insane. And I wasn't too familiar with her, but she's a big deal, yeah? In Broadway, judging by the awards and whatnot. Yes, yes. But I will admit my own ignorance as well. I had heard the name, but not necessarily known where from. And I think that's because I'm almost sure I've seen her on TV or film before, but that's my world. But like...

I want Broadway to be my world now. So if this podcast in the next year or so transitions, beware people. I'm just, I just Broadway theater is just so much fun. It's so much to see. It's so hard to be disappointed, isn't it? When you see that spectacle. But yeah, I had no comparison because this was my first version of Music Man I'd ever seen. I knew it was based on a movie, but I hadn't seen it. So yeah, I didn't have multiple versions of the character to pull from, but I can't imagine any better than what, than what she does. She just, the cheer that she got when she came on stage was as big as when Hugh Jackman was revealed. We saw it on different nights, but.

It was huge. And yeah, she dominates every single part of the show. And even the character seems to be in control of it. It's an active choice to expose him and then defend him for the reasons that she gives. The creepiest part is the main character is chasing a woman and not taking no for an answer. Because yeah, that's just what women do. You're supposed to ignore the first 10 no's. There's an entire song called The Sadder But Wiser Girl. Oh my goodness.

That was the one part I was like, I can't like this. Yeah, yeah. It's not okay for me to be enjoying this. Right, yes, yeah, exactly. So... You can't redeem him quick enough for this to be okay. There's not enough of the show left. There's not enough time left, actually. Unless you do a 20-year time jump. Yeah, this is not okay. We will talk about Hugh Jackman's performance. I'm sure people are curious. I thought he was great. I thought he was kind of an astonishing look at what was going on there. I really felt like that performance was interesting and fun. I do feel like there...

there's almost a disconnect between his general, uh, ambiance and this character. I don't know if that makes sense, but it was, the one thing it was like, And maybe that's not fair to him, but I was just like, man, I don't know that you fit this character exactly. But he makes it his own. He has fun with it. Almost not slimy enough? Yeah. Too wholesome? Too much of it? You're rooting for him straight away. And this is probably partially the unfair curse of being so, so famous and then going on Broadway. I was watching Hugh Jackman more than the character, and it's so fun to watch him dance and sing and be...

almost Hugh Jackman playing in a sandbox in a playground just having a great time but it's quite tricky to critique the performance itself yeah yeah totally agree um so tell me how you felt about the the songs like aside from the message of the songs like the actual just like the the dancing the choreography like just the presentation of because this is a big musical like there are there are numbers in this where they sing the song and then they dance for 10 minutes yes you know I prefer the dancing to the singing but again that's the musical thing something about Wells Fargo So there are some really fun songs that I remember, but I'm so bad for latching onto songs and remembering them after the fact. Which is why Hamilton was so rare for me, because immediately there's like four or five songs that you're humming when you come out of there. But I could, I had Denae next to me, and she recognised a lot of the songs without realising that she recognised a lot of the songs. So it's obviously, it's a big deal. I think I'll have to watch it a couple more times. But the choreography was astounding. The way they used the entire stage, how Hugh Jackman leads every single...

dance. I came out of it wondering why the con wasn't teaching people to dance instead of calling them into buying musical instruments. Because he has that skill. He could give dance lessons without being a con man. But yeah, it's fantastic. Yeah. Which songs do you remember and jump out for you? Well, the big one, the big showstopper is usually Trouble in River City, you know, about the pool table and how he gathers the town around. That's great. The very first one. Yeah, that's awesome. That's the showstopper. But then you've got like Shapoopy and... That was just a bit dumb. It is. But I do like the... What's the really...

emotional one that she sings about the mountains and love was there all along that he doesn't return to later. I enjoyed that. I just can't remember what it is. And there's that moment where they're singing lines from two different songs and then they switch. Oh man, she starts singing about the trombones. I don't know if it's a fourth wall break, but it feels like it. I don't know if you're talking about Goodnight My Someone. Yes, I think that's it. Yeah, put the ickiness on one side. It's good. Well, there's also this thing in a song like that where it's like, and I get the romanticization of this, but there's that element of

that someone is out there for me, even if I don't have a name for it. It's like this thing that pop culture has put on this idea of coupling up and this idea of- There's lots of someone. It's not just one of them you're hoping to stumble across. And God forbid you be single, maybe for your entire life. You could just be a happy librarian. Right. Yeah. So there's that element of it too, where it's just like, oh, okay. Yeah. But I mean, I also get that that is something that certainly dominated the idea of what it means to be human for a long, long time.

Any other thoughts on the Broadway musical version of Music Man? There's lots to say, but... Yeah, let's talk about You Crushing My Dreams. Oh, yes, let's talk about that. This is an interesting experience. Why don't you kind of set the stage for what's happening here? So, we watched it on different nights because of just some important family thing happened to Aaron. For a wedding or something. Yeah, it meant he'd rather do that than spend time with us, right or wrongly. Fair. So we watched it the night before, and there was a, by far and away, the funniest, biggest laugh, biggest round of applause that there was the entire night was towards that kind of the...

opening of the second part after the intermission Sutton Foster pushes Hugh Jackman away and it is so such a hard push he nearly hits the deck he recovers and then does this kind of dance and wiggle thing and kind of shimmies back over to her and midline she stops and just breaks down and she covers her face and they stop for like three minutes and they can't continue and eventually they stumble through the rest of the lines and Hugh Jackman's like you okay and they deliver these really sincere lines but through laughter and they're just completely broken. And we all looked at each other and were like, oh, that was great. They messed it up. And only after the fact did we think, maybe, was it staged? No, you don't staged something like that. No, because it was genuine. It seemed so great. There's no way they could be acting. Until Aaron. So we asked Aaron ahead of time. We didn't preload it. We just said, when do you let us know if you had the same character break? And, of course.

yeah i bore the bad news that is absolutely planned that is the that is a planned break uh i don't know what they i don't know if there's a technical term for this on broadway or on stage disappointing i think there's a beautiful philosophical conversation to have here but before before we get there um this is something that that is done occasionally is the idea of and of course the psychology of it is you give your audience something they feel is their own and so they're so they're invested in it in an even deeper way like it becomes like what it becomes funnier it becomes more amazing and then the one-two punch of that especially in the scene where they do this here is it leads into a serious moment in between them where a real fulcrum of the plot is happening as he is understanding he may actually love her and that's right after this and so what it does is it takes that oh we're all family now we're all laughing together now this is our experience and then straight into something serious it makes that serious turn even more like chill bumps you know kind of thing because it's like oh yeah i'm with you and it's it's perfectly executed it's perfectly planned and it happened the exact same way in my show two nights later unbelievable it's just and it it works because statistically what happened to us isn't going to happen like you

the majority of the audience will be one and done and not see it again. I would love to interview them about this to kind of see how this came about. My guess is it may have happened naturally the first time and they liked how it felt. It may have been planned from the beginning because of how much it makes sense with that scene. I wouldn't be surprised about that either. I can see Hugh Jackman suggesting it and saying I would like to do this to make my own. During previews or whatever. Yes, absolutely. And my guess is in that moment, however it happened, the moment now is you try to push me down as hard as you can. Let's see if you can get me. So there is a little bit element of there that it might be a little different. You know, maybe in one night she actually knocks him to the ground or whatever, you know. That's my guess is that that's the fun for them in that moment is.

he has told her, you try to knock me to the ground and I'll do my best to stay up and then I'll goof around a little bit and we'll break. It's so well done because he's almost like, are you okay? Can we carry on? Because she is so, so professional and is just Broadway and he's Hugh Jackman. You kind of believe that this is, it's almost a relief for her to do something less serious. But yeah, I mean, they fooled me.

fine, whatever. I told you this when we started talking about it. It is weird for me because I totally understand the human psychology of you're feeling disappointed, of you feeling like something was taken away from me. I don't have that feeling. Maybe it's because I'm on the other side of it and I was kind of looking for something you guys had said, so they broke or something. Maybe that's it, but I also have had to deliver speeches or presentations or whatever to different groups and have landed things that felt improvisational or in the moment and done it time after time and had to do it in a way that it felt.

in the moment and improvisational each time. And that's just, you know, I mean, it's just good storytelling. It's just good performance. Immensely satisfying for them because it's like you, you mugs, you will think that this is, this is fake. They're giving you a great time. And I think what I compared it to was, it's not an exact analogy, but a fantastic one shot that you find out has cuts in it that are so well done. You can enjoy it as a one shot, but a little bit of the technical magic is gone. And this is probably the reverse because technically it's a bad thing, but it made it better.

yeah well technically it's even more challenging to pull that off than it would be just let the scene play on exactly yeah yeah Well, it was well done. And I do think he has several of those moments where he lets his personality shine through. None in that same way as far as having a break. But yeah, he does make the performance his own. His dancing is astonishing. He's such a song and dance man. And I think if you just know him from Wolverine, it's just so weird to know that. Now, of course, he had the greatest showman on the big screen where he was able to show his song and dance capabilities. But yeah, I'm a big Jackman fan. I think he does great work. He's great.

being that close and kind of seeing the work that he's doing, especially in the dancing. You were super close. Yeah. I was third row center and, um, you know, they're pros and cons, mostly pros with being up that close. But, um, but yeah you get spat on quite a bit especially by winthrop yeah yes uh as did the cast um but that's intentional uh anything else you want to say about the broadway show music man um no i i just man broadway special we're not gonna be the first people to say that but i i'm i would almost love to talk to somebody that has a bad time watching a broadway show because there is just the location the event of it the the atmosphere of all of it you can't switch that for anything else. I watched Aladdin a few years ago and it wasn't great because I was comparing it to Lion King, which is just on another level. But I still had a great time with it. It's still a spectacle. I think we should talk about Broadway more and plays in general. That'd be nice. We'd have to go to Broadway more. We would. Let's just move to New York. I hear it's affordable. No, cost of living is a little bit different than Southern Missouri. Eating in New York is so difficult. So expensive. Oh, man. Yeah, I cannot imagine finding like a little tiny 200 square foot closet that you live in for $1,000 a month or whatever.

No, no. Wild. Wild stuff. All right. There you go. That is the Music Man on Broadway. Before we head on to the Best Ever Challenge, just a reminder that you can be a member of Sift Pop at Patreon. Patreon.com slash Sift Pop if you want to do that. And members get all sorts of fun stuff. You can check out the different perks at the different levels. And there are ad-free podcast feed that's your own. You also get the bonus podcasts in that podcast feed at a certain level.

So yeah, go check that out. It's at patreon.com slash siftpop. Thank you so much to our current siftpop members who make this possible. We'll let you know also there's some siftpop.com web stuff happening this year that's going to, I think, be really fun. So we'll keep you up to date with that as that stuff happens. But yeah, go to patreon.com slash siftpop to check all that stuff out. All right, let's move into the best ever challenge. And Ian and I are now joined by Andrew Orbsby, who's joining us.

Here's my quick two-minute review of Cyrano. I didn't like it. It wasn't for me. The first time we see Cyrano where he's like accosting the play guy, that was my favorite part of the movie, and it just kind of went downhill from there. That's almost exactly what we said. Really? I think we liked it a little bit more. Yeah. Like what we've said before, it's a movie that's not for me. Yeah, totally. I don't know if you said at the beginning of the show why I wasn't here. There was a construction crew clearing some trees and stuff out of people's yards.

We had a nice storm here not too long ago. So there were chainsaws and whatnot going on. But they left early. So I'm here now. And I haven't seen Music Man, the movie, or the Broadway show. Well, there you go. Don't bother with the movie. Watch it on Broadway. It's our review. Okay. All right. Let's move into the best ever challenge. We're going to do in honor of Cyrano, best ever movies that end in the letter O. So let's go from number five to number one. And feel free to trump anything that someone has higher. Ian has already indicated that he is stretching this category beyond belief. Especially with my honorable mentions. Which I don't understand because there are so many good choices. There are so many good choices in this category. That I haven't seen.

realized all right fair enough fair enough uh ian you get to start us off what is your number five um number five uh it was one hour photo um and just a movie that i really really enjoyed now there's loads of these films that end you know that i hadn't seen so this probably wouldn't make most people's lists but this is the first time i watched robin williams be not robin williams and just creep the socks off of me um what a great great performance um great little thriller as well just love this movie yeah one hour photo is good i haven't watched it in a long time um but yeah that's definitely a good choice uh andrew what do you got number five At number five, I have American Psycho. Nice. Good choice. Christian Bale doing some creepiness here. Every single time I see this movie, which it's not one that obviously I put in all the time because it's not a type of movie. This is not a movie you watch on repeat. No, no, no. Exactly. And if you do, well, let's not be friends. Exactly. But every time I have seen it, I come away with a lot of questions like, what is this movie trying to be? And I say that in a good way because...

it works on many levels. It works on a metaphorical level. Like, is he the representation of the upper class, you know, you know, and is it like a metaphor for like, you know, you know, the upper classes attack on lower, lower incoming. Is it just literally about a psycho? Is it about so many things? And I think that a movie like this, which is still captivating on its own yet has possibly so many things to say is really, really well done. I should read the book because apparently people say the book is a lot different than the movie. Yeah.

You know, people won't be surprised to know that I haven't read the book, but I have, Aaron doesn't know how to read. We've just, I have seen the movie and it's, it's beautiful satire. It's really dark. It's really terrifying. Yeah. And it's even more terrifying that there are people out there that don't take this as satire and that see this character as some sort of hero. But, but yeah, I've never met a single person who walks away going, you know, I think Patrick Bateman is a really stand up fellow, you know, never met one of those people. Don't wish to. My number five is that thing you do.

comes in at my number five. It is the only entry into my top five that isn't one of two themes. So I won't give those away yet. I think I can guess what the themes are. There are two themes to my list today. And this is the only movie that doesn't fit those two themes. So yeah, The Thing You Do is great. Tom Hanks is so fun. This has one of the best ever fake songs within a movie that feels like an absolute real song.

So yeah, I love, love, love this movie. Lots of fun. Pretty sure it's a real song after the movie. Well, after the movie, yes. It became a real song once they wrote the song. My brain hurts. But it feels like there are plenty of movies, TV shows, whatever, that are like, this is a hit song. You're like, that would never be a hit song. You listen to this song, you're like, oh yeah, that would be a hit song. And then strangely enough, it became an actual hit song. It's weird how that works. But yeah, I really like that thing you do. So I definitely wanted to check it out. Good pick. That's number five. Number four is Ian. What do you got? I have Encanto, which is a nice recent pick to slip in. Yeah, I didn't like it the first time I watched it.

re-watched it a few times, and I really, really like it now. The story that I thought was a bit too basic is kind of perfect for the message that they want to send out. I got really hooked up on the fact that Mirabelle doesn't have a power at the end, and I know I shouldn't. That's kind of one of the beautiful things about the movie, though, I think. No, I totally agree, and it is. And the songs have grown on me. Now, this is a musical. This is a musical. It's where the songs have just absolutely grown on me. The Louisa song is so... Yeah, the one that's really strong. Yeah, so powerful. So powerful. It has such a message to everybody that's under that kind of pressure.

it's that's the tick tick tick yeah yeah yeah yeah so so good trip trip yeah um and the fact that she's the only one actually doing any legwork for the entire village everyone else is just popping out plants and shape-shifting but um it's just a really it's really fun and i would recommend giving it every watch if you like me and did not like it in general if you're popping out plants probably should get that checked out you should yeah that's one especially cactus yes especially you'll know about it uh let's see andrew what's your number four number four this is apocalypto yeah i have my honorable mentions i'm here what a crazy movie oh my goodness it's yeah it's unique and would you consider this a foreign language film even though it was pretty much made like here in the US yeah it's a foreign language film I mean if you're going just by the definition of you know it's in a foreign language directed by Mel Gibson and if there's one thing that Mel Gibson for all of his faults I guess you could say the man has a visual eye and whenever it comes to violence he can do it in a way to where it is still you know

atrocious and horrifying to look at, but it's not gratuitous and unnecessary. All of the violence in his movies, I feel, serves a purpose to, you know, hit home a sense of reality. Like, if you look at, like, the second half of Hacksaw Ridge, you know, that's when, like, you realize, oh, oh yeah, I forgot we were in a Mel Gibson movie for a second because everything was happy-go-lucky with Andrew Garfield in boot camp. And then, of course, Braveheart. I think this movie is so fascinating because it's such an...

intimate story in a completely foreign environment. Normally, whenever you have a movie like this, where it's like, where the majority of your audience is totally unfamiliar with, uh, like the area or the culture or anything like that, filmmakers have a tendency to, you know, try and world build, you know, to like, you know, expand everything. But I think that Apocalypto is just very intimate and confined. Like, you see the Mayan, it was Mayan, it wasn't Aztecian, I can't remember. I think it was Mayan. But you see these, uh...

you see like the temples and the pyramids and everything that they've built but they don't spend a lot of time like it's just there it's all about I forget his name I think it was the panther was his name or something like that the main character but everybody in this movie I can't believe none of these people went on to star in like major major motion pictures because everybody was stellar in this movie yeah yeah absolutely stellar no I really like apocalypto I think it says some really important things about humanity I think you're right about the violence thing I think what it is is there's a real intent to show violence for how visceral it really is literally viscera you know literally visceral and it doesn't, it doesn't do it to be, in my opinion, maybe some would disagree. I don't think it does it to be titillating. I don't think it does it, you know, for some sort of, you know, shock reaction. It does it because that's what that would actually look like. This is a real world. And I think it grounds the movie in some, some interesting ways. I just think it's an incredible story too. Yeah. So yeah, it's, it's, it's a, it's a rare bird for sure. Yeah. It's, it's crazy that a movie like this can have the same amount of like violence. And like you said, viscera as a movie like hostile, but hostile is torture porn. Whereas this is,

a historical look on what might have actually gone down. All right, so my number four begins the thematic category of Hitchcock movies with Psycho in it, my number four. The thing about Psycho that a lot of people forget, because it's certainly looked at as a classic and people kind of know what it is, is that when this movie came out, it absolutely changed movies because Hitchcock did a thing with, you know, casting a star that is killed off, like, within the first 20 minutes of the movie that blew people's minds. The way he used... sound in this movie is so different because he doesn't score it as much as use like sound effects as a score. We all know like the, you know, the eek eek.

in the you know like that kind of stuff but it's it's just it's really interesting the way he has chosen to do that the black and white thing is purposeful here which you know it didn't it didn't have to be black and white but he wanted to be able to show some things he knew he couldn't show in color and so he uses black and white chocolate milk yeah he used chocolate syrup for blood the first is this right I could be wrong about this I think it's the first movie to actually show a toilet in the movie that's funny that would not surprise me so yeah just it's just it's interesting how uh you know how how culture has changed but um but just really astonishing horror work suspense work here um absolutely speaking of broadway you know um anthony perkins was a big broadway star doing all sorts of stuff slays this role literally uh and ends up typecast and can never you know get movie roles again and it's just like that's how good his performance is in this um but yeah psycho is is absolutely one of my list of shame it's a bizarre one i've just never never got around to watching all right so we know what we're doing after the podcast but

Do I need to drive on over? We're going to have a watch party. Yeah, exactly. All right. On our number threes. Yes. Ian, what do you got? I have Fargo. Yeah, good choice. I love this movie. It's so, so much fun. Speaking of violence. Speaking of violence and quirkiness and bizarre things. And woodchippers. And woodchippers, yeah. It is. It's just one of those movies where minute to minute, you don't know where you're going and you don't know what's going to happen next. You don't know where it's taking you. By the end of it, you don't really know what story it's told. It's just so original. So, so much fun. Cohen's just.

blowing my mind with just original storytelling and yeah absolutely love it it's probably my favourite Steve Buscemi performance as well it's the right amount of Buscemi but yeah absolutely love it and I could have just as easily if I'd been allowed recommended the TV show as well because it somehow is the first season absolutely follows the theme so truly and so such a good sequel Good choice. Very good choice. I think the Coens are another set of directors who really have an interesting way they use violence and they do it purposefully and it has a comedic tone to it. So, yeah, that's interesting stuff. You're being really good so far, Ian. These are all legitimate in letter O. No, no, they are. It's my honorable mentions. Oh, honorable mentions. Listen, you can stretch as much as you want in honorable mentions. Oh, okay. You can mention Saving Private Ryan. Yeah, we only veto stuff that's in the top five. You'll be fine with my... I wish I'd really put all my honorable mentions in there. Andrew, what's your number three?

Just real quick on Fargo, that scene with William H. Macy being interrogated by Francis McDormand is like one of my favorites. My number three, this is where I'm going to tell you guys to get off my lawn with Gran Torino. I hate to be that... I'm going to say it and I know it's none of my business nor do I have any say in this, but I think this is the film that Clint Eastwood should have hung his hat on acting-wise for the end of his career because it's just...

It was the perfect time to say, you know what, I'm going to hang it up. I can still direct movies, but I think acting's done for me. It's just not good anymore for as much as I love Clint Eastwood. This movie's crazy. This movie's racist. This movie is all the things that you would have content warnings about, but I still love it to death because it is all of those things intentionally. There's a purpose to it. It's just a man from a bygone era trying to survive in a new world that's been thrust upon him. Great story. Great acting from Clint Eastwood. Not so much everybody else, but good movie. What's the other?

get off my lawn film that he did where he's he's not he hasn't got superpowers he's just a What was it? I don't think Clint Eastwood has ever been a superhero. No, but in Gran Torino, he's basically way more. He gets away with a lot more than he should. There's another one. Oh, well, in Cry Macho, he beats the crap out of some gangsters. And I'm like, yeah, you're 95 years old. How are you taking on some 20-year-olds? Are you talking about his threesome and the mule? No. That was some superpower. Two! He had two threesomes. Let me direct myself into two threesomes as a 90-year-old. No, there's one where he's just a resident somewhere and some kids are pushing him around.

And he's trying to defend the neighborhood. Are you sure you're not thinking of Gran Torino? I might just be thinking of Gran Torino. I'm sorry. Yeah. And they will be. Yeah. I like that movie. Yeah. Yeah. That's fun. Yeah. All right. That's my number three. My number three is the other theme for me this week. And that is Coco in the Pixar theme. Coco is one of those Pixar movies that I think when all is said and done will be looked at as top tier Pixar. I think it came out at a time when people were ready to kind of be done with Pixar and just kind of like on a public consciousness level of, you know, oh, okay, the good days are gone, you know, kind of thing. I guess I'll just be making movies.

But this is so solid. The emotion is so incredible. Remember You is one of the most powerful moments I've ever seen in a movie theater when he sings to his grandma. So, yeah, this is just a powerful, powerful movie, and I really enjoy it. It's also gorgeous and beautiful and funny and amazing. Yeah. And another one I have not seen. There you go. I think we're going to have an afternoon, aren't we? Wow. Yep. Could happen. Could happen. All right. Number twos. Number twos. Yeah, what do you got, Ian? Me. I have got, this is where I'll just sit down and find me.

I might try that. On to you. On to you, Andrew. Yeah, Andrew, what's your number two? Well, I think we know what Aaron and I's number one is now. My number two is Memento. Drop! Oh, cool. Nice, nice, nice. Very cool. Aaron, what you got? My Hitchcock theme comes in at number two. Vertigo is my number two. I think I just need to watch. Not by Northwesto. I should finally do that Hitchcock marathon. I'm going to have to. I'm wondering if I've seen any Hitchcock films.

We'll find out. Yeah, the one with Clint Eastwood where the kids are pushing for a run. Just an incredible, incredible look at paranoia, at the idea of denial. And there's so much going on thematically here that it's easy to forget how gorgeous this movie is and how incredible the performances are. Jimmy Stewart's probably, in my opinion, his most nuanced role in his widest role that he ever played.

He's playing outside of type here. This is not somebody at the end of the day that you're going to come away from this movie thinking, oh, I like that guy. Let's hang out with that guy. So, yeah, this is also Hitchcock dealing with a lot of his own demons, too, because there's meta-contextually a lot of stuff here about this character dressing up women to look like his ideal that Hitchcock himself has admitted and many historians have dug into how that's what it was like for him with actresses, that he was always... you know, trying to dress them up to look like his ideal and, you know, uh, and was not, um, very nice to them at all. Uh, and so it's, it's interesting that I wonder how much of that was textual for Hitchcock in this movie and how much was subconscious. Um, but, um, but there's definitely some meta textual stuff in here as well. It's, it's really, really interesting. Um, the soundtrack is one of the greatest ever, uh, just absolutely genius level stuff all around in, in vertigo. So, uh, that is my number two. Uh,

Number one. Number one. No surprises. This is where I'll have Memento. Oh, nice. Yeah. Yeah, I love this movie. I only watched it for the first time early last year. Yeah, I was watching through everything Nolan did, including following. It's weird. But yeah, Memento is so good. Probably, man, one of the most unique ways to tell a story I've ever seen. Until the next Nolan movie. Until the next Nolan movie comes out. And then until the next Nolan movie comes out. Yeah, absolutely almost impossible to follow the first time around. And Nolan doesn't really apologise for that.

And that is also the next movie. But it's great. It's so, so clever. It's beautifully put together. It is understandable. We just may take a couple of runs through. Not Guy Ritchie. No, it's Guy Pearce. Absolutely brilliant. It'd be interesting to see a Guy Ritchie. Yeah, I think he'd probably not pull it off. Possibly. Possibly. You know, he kind of has the...

if just a lack of British, like super thick, you know, British accents, you know, it's the perfect average movie. Yeah, I'll do it. No, I'm right there with you. I love Memento. It's such a great movie. This was actually the first Nolan movie I think I ever saw. I think it was. I may have seen Insomnia before, but I don't think so. I think I saw this one first. Insomnia's a weird one. It's a very weird one. Speaking of another Robin Williams serious role. But yeah, I'm right there with you. I love, I love.

Love, love, love Memento. Aaron, you and I, we have the same number one. We do. It is Finding Nemo. I've talked about this movie many, many times. It is one of my favorite movies of all time. One of my favorite Pixar movies. Yeah, and I think rightfully so. It's just so full of joy and amazing characters. The story is so propulsive and full and adventurous and somehow manages to keep its B-plot up front and also interesting and fun and has its own set of amazing characters. Yeah, this is...

this is just great storytelling just pure and simple just incredible storytelling and um and then you've got like all-time performances from like ellen degeneres uh and albert brooks although it's calling it albert brooks is all time i know he's had some spectacular performances but it's just he's so perfect for this character um so you think you can do these things but you just can't yeah i've recently i make same face in every single time i've i've uh i've recently started saying that to one of my children but reversing it and just saying you think you can't do these things but you can oh that's great so um I like that you took that as sweet and that I was encouraging them as opposed to just wanting them to do their laundry. Oh, yeah. No, I thought it was a motivational thing. Like, particularly difficult poop in the morning. I appreciate that view, but no, it's more... Yeah, pick up your clothes. Stop being a terrible person. You think you can't do it, but you can. That's right. Be the little engine that could. Yeah. Any thoughts from you two on Finding Nemo? Yeah, it's great. I think we've talked about it a million times. Yeah, it's fantastic. All right, let's get into our fun honorable mentions. I'm starting with Ian because I want to know how you stretch the category. Let's go. Okay, so...

Now, your wording, Mr. Dicer, was movies that end with an O. It wasn't the letter O. So I have the ring. What? Before you die, you see an O.

That is beyond a stretch. 300. 300. 300. 300. That's definitely. Maybe if there was like a 90210 movie where they actually say, oh, but that's the 300. 300. It's how it was released in England. It was actually 30. Looper. Looper? What are you talking about? The loop ends. It ends with an O because you close the loop. Now you're just being silly. My personal favorite was any Bond film. They usually end with an O.

Fair enough. Fair enough. That's been the comedy stylings of Ian Whittington. The Ring was pretty good. Sure, sure. Andrew, what are some more legitimate honorable mentions for this category? Because there are a few. Honestly, I can't even right now. It's like my brain just shut off. I did have some. Sicario is the first one. I love both Sicario movies. They're great.

I cannot thank you. There's some I really love. Hugo is one. Really, really like Hugo. That's a lot of fun. Argo, also a really fun one. Oh, Argo is so good. Casino, probably worth mentioning in this category. Towering Inferno. Oh, that is good. Yeah. It's worth a mention as well. Serpico, probably also worth a mention, which I just recently saw for the first time. And Rango. I really enjoyed the movie Rango, too. Johnny Depp is a lizard CG movie. Nice.

I'm sorry for breaking you. Was it the bomb thing that did it? It was a culmination of shattering. Yeah, that was a straw that broke the camel's back. There you go.

now is it is the movie Kubo or is it Kubo in the two strings yeah oh come on you're gonna push the definition play the game properly Andrew no like because you look it up in some places it just says Kubo oh interesting but in other places it says Kubo in the two strings but you could do Cujo you know what I could do Cujo the movie made me afraid of St. Bernard's yeah that's what that movie does alright let's move into our buried treasure what is that one thing in any area of pop culture that you want to make sure people know about Andrew kick us off hi I'm going to go with a new show on Amazon. It just finished its first season, The Legend of Vox Machina. Oh, nice. You've seen it all. Yep, seen it all. I'm a huge fan of Critical Role. As you guys know, I play a lot of D&D, and people at Critical Role finally were able to animate their stories from playing D&D into an actual show, and it's amazing. It is so funny. These characters that you've heard just the voice acting for for years and years, finally seeing them animated and stuff just brings a whole new...

excuse me, a whole new level of, like, excitement and just fun. The show's hilarious. The stories are stellar as ever. I absolutely love it. It's definitely, definitely for adults. So just because this movie is based around D&D, do not get confused to think that your kids should be able to watch it. Therefore, it is adult. Yes, it is exactly right. Yeah, so, yep, it's great. Very nice. Legend of Vox Machina on Amazon Prime. A little bit of a weird recommendation for me for my buried treasure. I'm going to go with a place. And pop culture is...

Maybe stretching the definition of pop culture, but I think at one point almost everything in here was popular culture. I'm going to talk about going to the Met in New York City. And the reason I want to talk about it is because I knew it was a museum. I knew it was a great museum. I didn't realize how big of a museum it is. And it is literally a place you could spend three days at and not see everything. And it is astonishing some of the history that is in that building. It is astonishing some of the beauty that is in that building. So big, big recommendation for the Met in New York City.

Ian, you were there. Did you get all dressed up when you went? No. Just for kicks and giggles? No, the gala wasn't on at that point. No, they weren't doing the Met Gala. Yeah, it's stunning. And I really enjoyed the layout. The layout of it felt really organic because it took you through time and the themes within each period of history as well. We had a very hearty discussion about modern art, which is probably for another podcast, but Aaron is wrong. But it's great. It's so, so good. There's a million things to do and see in New York, but of the museums, I would put that top of my list. Yeah, it was incredible. Yeah, Ian's wrong about the modern art thing, but...

But other than that, just so you know which side we're on, Ian is angered by modern art because he doesn't believe it is art. Certain examples of modern art. Certain examples of triangles. Triangles, my goodness. Three upside down triangles is not art. Well, I've seen some amazing pieces of modern art. I saw a guy duct tape a banana to a wall. Not art.

And I keep telling him the fact that it is bringing up that emotion in him makes it art. Not good enough. Not good enough. Really enjoyed the Met. If you're ever in New York City, I think it's like a $25 donation per person to get in. And it is well worth it. Some of my favorite experiences were seeing sketch artists who just go there to sketch sculptures and stuff. And I found that really beautiful. So yeah, some really good stuff. I think there's only two pieces in the Met that I actually would pay to see. And that's Washington crossing the Delaware and then the self-portrait to Van Gogh. Yeah.

There's a great Dutch Masters thing that they've got going on right now that had some Vermeers and some different things that I was really excited about. But yeah, it's good stuff. Nice. Ian, what do you got? I had the opportunity to watch some films on the flight over here, and I watched Godzilla, King of the Monsters, and The Father. And I'm going to talk about the more exciting of the two, The Father. Yeah, The Father, really, really... I wanted to watch this when it came out. It's right up my alley. I am a sucker for films about mental health and Alzheimer's and dementia and that end of the spectrum, because I know they'll kill me, and I know that they will make me feel things, but in a almost... Man, I don't know why heartwarming is coming to mind. I think it's the care. I think it's the...

you have to have such grace and forgiveness for what they're going through and just the toll that it takes on the whole family and how the person that doesn't recognize you anymore and is just falling apart, you still have to be there for them even if they say the most hideous, disgusting things to you. And it's finding that balance of entertaining them when you want to snap them back into reality and convince them that everything is in their head and somehow you feel like you can convince them into returning to normal in quotation marks yeah the movie does it beautifully um just yeah it did such a great great job um not something to watch on a plane filled with people i was about to say are you okay okay yeah brilliantly done anthony hopkins is just an all-timer yeah he's just fantastic and as much as we all love chadwick boseman one of you know the the whole shenanigans the oscars did last year with trying to put that award last and everything i really think took away from just the achievement of hopkins performance there it's you know it's fantastic um olivia coleman is is unsurprisingly fantastic because she's just she's great

Huh? She's good? She's good? What a surprise. Huh? What? Who is this lady? But yeah, he just stole it from me. I couldn't stop watching him. And that final scene in the car home, my goodness. I don't know how he got through it. Yeah. Yeah. It's a great film. Not for the faint of heart. Great choice. What a brutal movie to watch on a plane. Well, honestly, after King of the Monsters, it was a relief. Hey. It's like you want to fight or something. You're in my town now, son. I'll find you. I'll find you.

Well, there you go. That's The Father. It is streaming on Starz. You can also rent or buy it in most digital platforms. The Met is a museum in New York City and The Legend of... New York City is a city in America. The Legend of Vox Machina is available on Amazon Prime. How much did you say a ticket to Met is? About 25 bucks. For a day pass? Yeah, about 25 bucks. 50 if you buy tickets on the wrong day and have to buy it twice. Yeah. Yes. That is correct. That is correct. All right. Well, we did it, guys. We managed to do a podcast. Congratulations to everybody involved. We didn't even have to sing too much, Ian.

for you. I can't think of any songs. One day. Very nice. Very nice. Thank you so much for joining. Wait, were you just singing Modest Yahoo? I don't know. I think I was doing Les Mis. Is it One Day? Or is it Someday? Someday, yeah. Someday. I think One Day is the Modest Yahoo and Akon song. Okay, nope. That's not what I was going for. Either way, congratulations on this being a musical episode.

Thank you so much for joining us today. For us, it's part of the Studio DNA Podcast Network. You can find out more about other shows on the network at studiodna.media or by searching Studio DNA in your podcast player. Huge thanks to Andrew for hanging out with us today. Partly, but thank you, buddy. You're welcome. Big thanks to producer Phil for producing the audio and video show. Thanks, Phil. And thank you to Ian Whittington for being present, traveling thousands and thousands of kilometers just for this show.

Anything you want to let people know about? Where do you want to send people? I forget this every time. I don't know. So, yeah, an Englishman and an Irishman is on hiatus at the minute, but there is a 90-episode back catalogue that you can listen to if you would like to hear me talk about Captain's... Gosh, dang it! If you would like to hear me talk about Star Trek with Danae Hughes, we have a podcast called Captain's Pod that is also on hiatus, but coming back in a few weeks. So, yeah, there's lots of places you can hear me talk about things. So, basically, Ian has destroyed and killed all of his podcasts. Yeah, anything vaguely successful I'm just not doing anymore.

Appreciate you being on. It is always good to have you on. If you want to support what goes on here, you can do that at the Patreon. Become a member of Sif Pop at patreon.com slash Sif Pop. Starts at three bucks a month. You can check out all the perks, including bonus episodes, add free episodes, monthly video hangouts, all sorts of fun stuff. Find out all the info at patreon.com slash Sif Pop. Really appreciate those who have become members. That's really awesome. Thank you for doing that. Lots of ways to connect with us. Feel free to comment or rate or leave a review at Apple Podcasts, or you can email us feedback.

at sifpop.com. And finally, if you're having a good time, your movie-loving friends will probably like the show too, so make sure you let them know about it and that listening is much easier than not getting spat on while Winthrop sings. We'll be back next week with The Batman. Yeah. And some more stuff, so we'll see you then. The Batman. Why did you say that name?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of SiftPop?

This episode is 1 hour and 23 minutes long.

When was this SiftPop episode published?

This episode was published on February 28, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this SiftPop episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.